The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 02-26-2008, 01:04 PM   #24
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
I won't deny that another 20 minutes or so of material making us swallow the monster/wacky bonanza thrust upon us would have been beneficial to the film... but it's still back asswards.

It's like... let's make Batman Begins Part 7. But let's make it with Guidomaxius, who needs to trap 20 demon bats in order to stop a global apocalypse. Between Robin burping and Batman jumping in Robin's arms when a particularly scary bat demon surprises them, they save the day.

No, it was just a flat-out wrong approach to the source material. Is it better than TMNT 2 and 3? Yes. Is it kind of approaching TMNT 1, even in a sideways, diluted kind of way? Mm, I can see that to some degree in the side-stories of TMNT Part 4, sure (the family story bits).

But it's a far effing cry from anything resembling a proper comic book adaptation of the source material.
Why? If you are strictly basing your argument on story content, then the storyline for TMNT, which at its heart is nothing more then your standard villain-gathers-objects-to-obtain-power comic storyline, easily fits into the world created in the original Mirage comics.

Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.


As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued, mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.




Quote:
There's every reason. It's not fair, it's not right, and it's a shame that the beancounters can't see the forest for the trees (meaning, can't see the Mirage source material in spite of the made-for-children rubbish it spawned).
I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon, which leads us into the next point...



Quote:
They do now. But at some point they still had to go from Point A to Point B. At some point Spider-Man crossed over from old children's cartoons with a campy theme song to a relatively mature movie... what are the real differences here?

A guy of Sam Raimi's caliber. Marvel behind him. People with clout, people able to do exactly the movie they wanted to do, with a keen understanding and respect of the source material.
Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT, those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned. And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics. Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.

Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon), it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?), it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.

Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.


If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
 


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:57 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.