![]() |
|
|
#1 |
|
Foot Elite
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
|
Integrity vs. Completion: Mirage and creator-owned rights
Eastman and Laird have always been fierce supporters of creator-owned character rights in the comics industry. In the editorials of the old Volume 1 series, they never seemed to miss a chance to condemn Stan Lee and support Jack Kirby (dedicating an issue to him while the man was still alive, even), who were both on different ends of the creator ownership issue.
The support of this notion went so far as to allow guest creators on TMNT Volume 1 the priviledge of keeping the rights to any characters they created. This, of course, has led to some troubles with reprinting and "canonicity" in recent years, as these rights issues (particularly with Rick Veitch and "The River") have kept certain material from being reprinted or included in "canon" (obviously we're all capable of making our own "canon", but I'm talking in terms of official/legal status). Though I also have to wonder how much of that is the creators being unwilling to "play ball" or how much is Laird simply being uncooperative/non-communicative? We all recall the hullabaloo with TMNT (Vol. 1) #8, where Laird swore up and down that it could never be reprinted due to the presence of Cerebus, going so far as to commission Jim Lawson to write and draw a Cerebus-free alternate version (which, to date, has only seen print in Spanish language TMNT trades). This was brought to the attention of Dave Sim who basically came out and said, "Dude, why didn't you just ASK!?" Sim vocally gave Laird permission to reprint the issue, free of freakin' charge, so long as he made sure to include a proper ownership credit. Laird, in all his panic, simply never bothered to ask. And so it was reprinted without incident in 2009. On the flipside of the coin, we have the work-for-hire heavy Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 2). Lots of creators who were not Mirage staffers, mostly newcomers to the industry, contributed to that book, but unlike during the "guest era" of TMNT Volume 1, none of these non-staff creators got to keep any of their creations. While this creates a greater ease for reprints, as Laird wouldn't have to worry about picking up a phone and asking someone for permission, it has the opposite effect of turning Mirage into exactly the thing it railed against back in the 80s: Marvel/DC. While no doubt all the freelancers who contributed to Tales Vol. 2 were aware of what they were signing away when they worked on the book and were cool with it, it still comes across as a breach of Mirage's company standard and integrity; by taking the work contributed by others because they want them for their own convenience. So the question I want to ask you is, what matters more to you: "integrity" or "completion"? We may never get to see much of Volume 1 reprinted (if Viacom ever sees it fit to do reprints) and much of it had to be "de-canonized" (not that it really matters) because of the creator-ownership issues. However, the attitude maintained Mirage's integrity as a publisher that supported creator ownership and didn't "swindle" creators out of their creatons. Then there's Tales Vol. 2, which had the creators from outside Mirage sign away their creations if they wanted to contribute and get paid, but at the same time, we will never have to worry about any of those stories being unavailable for reprint or stricken from continuity due to legal matters. Which is more important to you? Are you willing to forgo creator-ownership rights if it means having complete collections in the future (at the same time, everyone who signs a contract should know what they're signing away, so they aren't "victims")? Or are you willing to forgo ever seeing a story reprinted again or willing to see it overwritten in continuity due to ownership rights, so long as the person who created it gets to keep their creation? |
|
|
|
|
|