Originally Posted by Metropoliskid41
TotheNines and I have started to have a discussion on this a bit over at the IDW Boards as well. So I'll kinda repost my thoughts here on that.
What is QNA indeed, is that some sort of brain sample that they either take a physcial brain matter sample of or some sort of brainwave scan?
So are you saying that Krang essentially "grew" or reproduced their consciousness artficially and then found a way to inject those into the Turtles?
If so, I see some holes in that as being a way to generate the Turtles personalities.
1) During the attack on the lab and escape of Splinter and the Turtles, Splinter has a real urgency about him to rescue the Turtles. I guess if the Hamato Yoshi persona was injected into him, instead of a purely spiritual manifestation via re-incarnation, how is he aware that the 4 turtles likewise possess the injected personalities and memories? If it's some sort of spiritual, astral awareness that gives Splinter the personality of Hamato Yoshi via re-incarnation, then I see that awareness that those turtles are also his reincarnated sons, but I guess I don't buy that test tube baby splinter would know the test tube baby turtles were his sons, if that makes sense.
2) The Brain matter aspect still points to something physical and genetic based. They are taking a physical sample, use that essentially to clone or create an artificial personality, and then physically implant that into the turtles and splinter. Again you could use the "advanced utrom science" plot device, but that kind of falls apart when you look at Donnie's Essence/Soul being transfered between his Turtle body and Metalhead. There is no physical exchange there. They are not pulling out Donnie's brain matter or any genetic material when he hops between Turtle Donnie and Metalhead Donnie.
One might say that the process that is used by Honeycutt and Donnie to transfer Donnie's consciousness to and from his Turtle body, could have been what was employed by Krang, and he somehow had those consciousnesses then stored all these years. I don't like that for 2 reasons:
a) that undermines the Donnie coping with the re-incarnation and spiritual side of the Turtles development that we had early on in the series. That was a big part of Donnie's character arc, and a major source of conflict between the brothers. That kind of reverses all of that and peddles backwards a bit on some of the early themes they drove home.
b) that means that Krang could have done it on their dead bodies. Meaning the urgency to get Donnie's consciousness transferred to Metalhead ASAP before his body died, really wasn't urgent at all. It eliminates any actual fraility or mortality to any of the characters. Oh, Shredder's dead, no biggie, let's just do a brain scan on his decapitated corpse and inject it into a new body. He's back. That means none of the Turtles or any of the other characters are truly in any real danger, and it makes their re-incarnation less special.
Not trying to start an argument at all, I find all of this really fascinating and I think it's neat that the last page triggered such different thoughts and theories among fans. I'd like to get more of your thoughts on it.
If it was in fact IDW's intention to get us all speculating and scratching our heads with that page, and it was supposed to raise way more questions than it answered, then they pulled it off perfectly.
So I guess that begs the question that I hope Bobby will be able to answer, is Krang's remark on the last page about using samples from the Hamato Clan to his advantage against these "sword swinging barbarians" refering to something that has already happened in the series or a hint at what is yet to come?
|