The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Comic Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-27-2020, 10:41 AM   #1
Ninjinister
無問題
 
Ninjinister's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Moesko Island, WA
Posts: 14,348
Quote:
Originally Posted by puirnaut View Post
I do not know why many of you are fixated only on the scientific experience of Mona. It’s sad when you label people like that. This, I think, is really an insult to the character and its discrimination. Too bad Sophie did the same. And does not want to see otherwise. I will never believe that when watching the only episode with her appearance, you fans from the 90s thought that she was a smart college student. Please do not tell. This is really not funny. Everyone looked at her and saw what she was like now, how much fire was in this character, watched how she made decisions, what she was real. But apparently in our time, no one wants to see in her a strong passionate character rushing forward. Of course, it’s easier to make her a wise guy, reduce her to a wise guy, and ignore everything else. It is a pity that the character is drowning under such stereotypes. This is really sad. Again, I apologize to the users of the forum.
What the eff word are you even talking about? None of these are conclusions that a logical human would make.
__________________
Ninjinister is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-27-2020, 01:35 PM   #2
puirnaut
Random Punk
 
puirnaut's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninjinister View Post
What the eff word are you even talking about? None of these are conclusions that a logical human would make.
I see that we don’t understand each other anyway. It does not matter. There is no sense in this argument anyway. Nothing depends on us
puirnaut is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-27-2020, 11:50 PM   #3
Ninjinister
無問題
 
Ninjinister's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Moesko Island, WA
Posts: 14,348
Quote:
Originally Posted by puirnaut View Post
I see that we don’t understand each other anyway. It does not matter. There is no sense in this argument anyway. Nothing depends on us
You need to make some points to argue for there to be an argument. You're just coughing up a salad of nonsense.
__________________
Ninjinister is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-28-2020, 08:16 AM   #4
puirnaut
Random Punk
 
puirnaut's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninjinister View Post
You need to make some points to argue for there to be an argument. You're just coughing up a salad of nonsense.
Our whole conversation goes in a different direction. Well, I'll start again. I don’t quite understand what exactly do you want to hear from me? But...
Firstly, I wrote that I am extremely dissatisfied with the fact that in this version Mona will not be Raphael's love interest, as it was in her two previous interpretations. Since I am a fan of the Raph/Mona couple, I am not very pleased to see that Sophie brings Mona to another character, and in a similar way. As I wrote earlier, I have nothing against Alopex. And I perfectly understand the fact that she, as she appeared in this series of comics, was considered by the creators as a couple to Raphael. Pay attention, I didn’t write about breaking everything between them all at once and switching Raphael to Mona. You thought it up yourself. The relationship of Raphael and Alopex lined up for a long time. And no one will destroy them, and this is understandable. I am enraged by the fact that a new character is introduced into the series, which before that was Raphael's love interest and do so by crossing out what was in previous interpretations of their relationship. Sophie, knowing what introduces such a character, did it as insulting as possible to the fans of this couple and Mona. As I already wrote in this series, they did not even get to know each other and there was not a single phrase addressed to each other. Sophie crossed out Everything about Rafael and Mona before. She left only that Mona is fond of science, because it is so convenient for her, and she intentionally crossed out everything else. What do you want from a fan of this couple? So that we swallow it so simply and all? This is a spit in our direction and extreme disrespect for what was before and for us. This decision Sophie comes from her personal preference, because she once said herself that she was a fan of Raph and Alopex. Therefore, to bring Mona with someone else is a personal whim of Sophie, and not a plot need.
The second insult is how Sophie brings Donatello and Mona together. If to speak, then in general in any way. Just introduced, and already on the last page of the issue she goes with Donatello together. That is, there are no prerequisites, nothing for this to happen. Everything is too swift, disgusting. Again, this is just Sophie's whim. She so wanted and that's it. Most likely, Sophie herself is a fan of the Don / Mona couple, so she did as she wanted, based on her ego, especially now she just can do it. It was more expedient to introduce a love triangle between Rafael Mona and Alopex, as a result of which (unfortunately) Raph will prefer Alopex, as their relationship has been building for a long time. Mona plotly admired Raphael, a warrior who protects the inhabitants of Mutant Town, so it would be more logical if she had feelings for him than those invented for Donatello. In this way, her feelings for Raphael could have arisen, which would eventually reject her. At least that way Sophie could somehow console the fans of the Raph/Mona couple, but she decided to just neglect us.
The third thing that infuriates is that it brings two science lovers together as a shortcut. We already have Harry and Libby, now she is trying to sell the same in a new wrapper. If Harry and Libby have their own background, leading to their relationship, then Don and Mona have none and never have. Only fanfiction. I am based on what would really be. The relationship between Raphael and Mona was in the 2012 version, and in the first Mona appeared in a series dedicated to Raphael. I had no idea and these are facts. Donatello And Mona can work as colleagues, but there’s nothing more, of course. Their relationship is just fanfiction. Remember yourself what characters the girls of this type choose. Obviously not like Donatello, but rather like Raphael. And if you try to say that this is an insult to women or something similar, then in this case, most films, TV shows and cartoons will also be an insult to women according to this logic. This is stupid and no one offends anyone in them, and now I am not offending anyone. Therefore, this is only your cover to prove your case. Here is a simple example for you. Watch the movie "A Walk to Remember" is a great moving film in which a smart girl falls in love with a bully with a good heart. And there are many such good films! Therefore, to say "they are a great couple, only because someone has similar hobbies," is an insult. Thus, you yourself label and stick into the framework of such characters, which is their insult. Just now, Sophie is doing this with Donatello and Mona. Thus, you do not allow such characters to reveal themselves in the present, but only fetter them for their interests. It's horrible. I do not say that everything should always follow a similar scenario, but the romance of relations is based on such differences that over time lead to real feelings.
For some part, I regret that I started this conversation, but without it, the authors will allow myself anything, crossing out what is not convenient for them, and they will hide behind the fact that "this is a new version, a new universe." And again I’ll say I don’t say that they don’t have the right to do this, I say what to do like that, only taking into account the feelings of the fans. Indeed, first of all, the authors create this for us - fans, and not for their whims. Of course, they present their originality, but you need to do this carefully so as not to hurt the feelings of fans.
Dear forum users, I apologize again if someone offended or insulted my words. There is nothing in them that could offend anyone. If someone touched these words, it’s all not on purpose, I didn’t want this. I apologize to all of you, I did not want to offend or offend anyone.
puirnaut is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-28-2020, 09:48 AM   #5
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
I have no desire to feed this pointless argument, so I'll just say this: you never write for the fans; you write to service the story and the characters. If you write well, and your story is good, then the fans will come. Everything else will end up becoming a disaster.

It's impossible to please everyone so there's no point in even trying.
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-28-2020, 10:43 AM   #6
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChosenOne View Post
I have no desire to feed this pointless argument, so I'll just say this: you never write for the fans; you write to service the story and the characters. If you write well, and your story is good, then the fans will come. Everything else will end up becoming a disaster.

It's impossible to please everyone so there's no point in even trying.
Its why I'm open to the idea of Donnie and Mona Lisa becoming a thing. Given how far Raph and Alopex's relationship has come. Having Mona Lisa paired with another Turtle would be a good opportunity for these characters to grow. Donnie and Mona Lisa makes sense because they both have the same interest in science. If you take a look at Raph and Alopex. These are characters whose been fighting there inner demons and they relate to one another because of that.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-28-2020, 11:15 AM   #7
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
Quote:
Originally Posted by TigerClaw View Post
Its why I'm open to the idea of Donnie and Mona Lisa becoming a thing. Given how far Raph and Alopex's relationship has come. Having Mona Lisa paired with another Turtle would be a good opportunity for these characters to grow. Donnie and Mona Lisa makes sense because they both have the same interest in science. If you take a look at Raph and Alopex. These are characters whose been fighting there inner demons and they relate to one another because of that.
I'll admit, if it were me writing, I don't think I could resist the meta appeal of pairing up Leonardo and Mona Lisa...
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-28-2020, 03:58 PM   #8
Sophie Campbell
Official TMNT Staff/Cast
 
Sophie Campbell's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Rochester, NY
Posts: 498
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChosenOne View Post
I have no desire to feed this pointless argument, so I'll just say this: you never write for the fans; you write to service the story and the characters. If you write well, and your story is good, then the fans will come. Everything else will end up becoming a disaster.

It's impossible to please everyone so there's no point in even trying.
My approach is sort of somewhere in between, I do try to write to service the story and characters, but I also write in service to myself and what I personally think is fun or interesting or what I'd like to see. I pander to myself, haha.

Obviously I can't (and wouldn't) do any old thing or follow every whim I have particularly on something like TMNT that I don't personally own and involves many other people, but for me part of doing comics long-term is finding ways to stay excited about what I'm doing and when I'm the artist, focusing on what's most fun and engaging to draw. Otherwise the work suffers. I don't usually think in terms of whether what I'm doing is good or bad/well-done or badly-done, the most important thing to me is whether I'm having fun with it or not, and if I'm having fun then other people will too (not EVERYONE will but you get the idea). Yeah, you can't please everyone, but I can at least try to please myself. I've done enough comics at this point to have stuff I'm not proud of or be disappointed in the end result, so if I can just have fun with what I'm doing and be happy with how it turned out even if people don't like it, then that's the ideal result.

About the Mona Lisa stuff, if Alopex wasn't on the table I probably would have gone the usual Raph/Mona route, but when it comes to romantic relationships I really follow my gut and my heart and whether the dynamic is fun to write. It has to have some spark on the page when I'm writing, and sometimes two characters that I initially set out to pair up simply don't end up having a spark so I move away from that even if I love the pairing. I can't force a relationship if I'm not feeling that spark.

I actually never even thought about anything between Mona and Donatello before working on issue 104, it was never part of my plan or anything, but I noticed that when I was writing scripts and drawing scenes, moments between the two of them kept popping up. It felt like something was there, meanwhile nothing between Mona and Raph ever worked its way in, Alopex being present notwithstanding, like my gut never led me down that route. I don't have anything against Raph/Mona, I think the original Fred Wolf cartoon episode is great and they're fun together, but I think a bigger issue is that IDW Raph is different than 1987 Raph and 2012 Raph. Every incarnation of the Turtles has them written a bit (or a lot) differently, and while 1987 Raph definitely has that spark with Mona, I just didn't feel it with IDW Raph. He's a different person than those other versions. I just don't feel anything drawing him toward Mona when I'm writing, and when I do start outlining a scene between the two of them, it always ends up on the cutting room floor, and to me that sends a message that it isn't "right," whether it's not right for the characters or it's not the right time for that to happen, or both.

And obviously Mona doesn't HAVE to be with anyone, she isn't just a love interest whose only purpose is to hook up with another character, from her first issue she's got her own goals and things she's interested in. Regardless, we'll see where things go.
Sophie Campbell is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-28-2020, 05:15 PM   #9
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell View Post
My approach is sort of somewhere in between, I do try to write to service the story and characters, but I also write in service to myself and what I personally think is fun or interesting or what I'd like to see. I pander to myself, haha.

Obviously I can't (and wouldn't) do any old thing or follow every whim I have particularly on something like TMNT that I don't personally own and involves many other people, but for me part of doing comics long-term is finding ways to stay excited about what I'm doing and when I'm the artist, focusing on what's most fun and engaging to draw. Otherwise the work suffers. I don't usually think in terms of whether what I'm doing is good or bad/well-done or badly-done, the most important thing to me is whether I'm having fun with it or not, and if I'm having fun then other people will too (not EVERYONE will but you get the idea). Yeah, you can't please everyone, but I can at least try to please myself. I've done enough comics at this point to have stuff I'm not proud of or be disappointed in the end result, so if I can just have fun with what I'm doing and be happy with how it turned out even if people don't like it, then that's the ideal result.

About the Mona Lisa stuff, if Alopex wasn't on the table I probably would have gone the usual Raph/Mona route, but when it comes to romantic relationships I really follow my gut and my heart and whether the dynamic is fun to write. It has to have some spark on the page when I'm writing, and sometimes two characters that I initially set out to pair up simply don't end up having a spark so I move away from that even if I love the pairing. I can't force a relationship if I'm not feeling that spark.

I actually never even thought about anything between Mona and Donatello before working on issue 104, it was never part of my plan or anything, but I noticed that when I was writing scripts and drawing scenes, moments between the two of them kept popping up. It felt like something was there, meanwhile nothing between Mona and Raph ever worked its way in, Alopex being present notwithstanding, like my gut never led me down that route. I don't have anything against Raph/Mona, I think the original Fred Wolf cartoon episode is great and they're fun together, but I think a bigger issue is that IDW Raph is different than 1987 Raph and 2012 Raph. Every incarnation of the Turtles has them written a bit (or a lot) differently, and while 1987 Raph definitely has that spark with Mona, I just didn't feel it with IDW Raph. He's a different person than those other versions. I just don't feel anything drawing him toward Mona when I'm writing, and when I do start outlining a scene between the two of them, it always ends up on the cutting room floor, and to me that sends a message that it isn't "right," whether it's not right for the characters or it's not the right time for that to happen, or both.

And obviously Mona doesn't HAVE to be with anyone, she isn't just a love interest whose only purpose is to hook up with another character, from her first issue she's got her own goals and things she's interested in. Regardless, we'll see where things go.
It will take a couple of issues to see what Mona will be doing. After all since her debut in this comic. Her goal was to help bring food for the shelter for other mutants. So we'll see her helping other mutants who are in need. She even helped with saving those mutant children from being taken away from Old Hobbs.

So her heart is in the right place. She'll be working along side Alopex and Donatello in the shelter. So it will be interesting how they all get along in there in the coming issues.

Also IDW Raph is indeed a different Raph then what people are used to. I liken the whole Raph and Alopex dynamic to the Raph and Ninjara dynamic from the Archie comics.

One other thing. When you drew that panel. Did you do it knowing the kind of reactions it would get? Even if it was just to tease those fans? Because some people tend to jump into conclusion way to early if you know what I mean.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305

Last edited by TigerClaw; 03-28-2020 at 05:34 PM.
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-29-2020, 01:59 PM   #10
puirnaut
Random Punk
 
puirnaut's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell View Post

About the Mona Lisa stuff, if Alopex wasn't on the table I probably would have gone the usual Raph/Mona route, but when it comes to romantic relationships I really follow my gut and my heart and whether the dynamic is fun to write. It has to have some spark on the page when I'm writing, and sometimes two characters that I initially set out to pair up simply don't end up having a spark so I move away from that even if I love the pairing. I can't force a relationship if I'm not feeling that spark.

I actually never even thought about anything between Mona and Donatello before working on issue 104, it was never part of my plan or anything, but I noticed that when I was writing scripts and drawing scenes, moments between the two of them kept popping up. It felt like something was there, meanwhile nothing between Mona and Raph ever worked its way in, Alopex being present notwithstanding, like my gut never led me down that route. I don't have anything against Raph/Mona, I think the original Fred Wolf cartoon episode is great and they're fun together, but I think a bigger issue is that IDW Raph is different than 1987 Raph and 2012 Raph. Every incarnation of the Turtles has them written a bit (or a lot) differently, and while 1987 Raph definitely has that spark with Mona, I just didn't feel it with IDW Raph. He's a different person than those other versions. I just don't feel anything drawing him toward Mona when I'm writing, and when I do start outlining a scene between the two of them, it always ends up on the cutting room floor, and to me that sends a message that it isn't "right," whether it's not right for the characters or it's not the right time for that to happen, or both.

And obviously Mona doesn't HAVE to be with anyone, she isn't just a love interest whose only purpose is to hook up with another character, from her first issue she's got her own goals and things she's interested in. Regardless, we'll see where things go.

Thank you for your answer Sophie. Perhaps what you don't see now will become relevant over time. Yes, see where things go.

Thank you all for an interesting discussion.
puirnaut is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:16 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.