|
I prefer to read them as originally published, be it in B&W as per volume 1 or color as per volume 2.
Whilst the coloring of some of the B&W can be interesting, it often masks what I enjoy so much about the original series i.e the grit and the depth that the duo-board work manifested. I was glad that IDW republished the B&W originals in the Ultimate Collection, although I wish they had done a 'complete' collection which included all TMNT comic material from Mirage - from the short stories through the the 'guest' issues - regardless of story/art quality. But that's the completist in me.
Some of the (re-)coloring has some strange choices, too - IDW's coloring of The Shredder was not clever and a bit shoddy, though they did some lovely work elsewhere.
I have to say that, as a general rule, the re-coloring of books originally published in color leaves a lot to be desired: the way DC and Marvel approached their classic ranges tended to be really quite garish and unsympathetic and in those cases I might just prefer to see the black and white line art alone.
|