Quote:
Originally Posted by staypuftweepel
Interesting, so it sounds like a case of too much editorial haha. As a fan you never really know what’s going on inside the company. You can only speculate. I would imagine it’d be tough as writer, because if editorial was making decisions that fans disliked pretty much all of the criticism lands on the you. Also, I read your comments above. It would have been neat to see Armaggon show up here. Was your plan for TMNT post 100 very different from how things have become?
|
No way, it's just the right amount of editorial! Bobby is great. He lets me do a lot of what I want and helps finesse it, other times I'm not sure of something and he helps hash it out, other times I come to him with a bananas idea (like turning April into a mutant fly for example) and he'll have me sell him on it and then I realize yeah it's a stupid idea.
My original pitch for post-100 had similar beats to what we're ending up with, but it was way more frenzied with more "big" things happening I guess you could put it, it involved Terrorpin (which I don't recall if we even have the rights to) and would have ended with a Mutant Town guerrilla warfare thing which I think was a good call to remove because it felt too similar to City at War. It also had things that were too much, like Raph gouging out Hob's other eye and Terrorpin eating Hob, and even MORE characters were involved like Shadow Jones (SOMEDAY I'll get her into the comic! lol). My initial pitch was definitely too much, I tried to cram way too much in.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman
So yes, technically a series like Dragon Ball is creator driven, Jump doesn't own the copyright as far as I can tell, they just publish it. That doesn't mean editors don't have any power, they still approve of ideas and it is their call to cancel the series if it performs poorly.
|
Yeah of course, I didn't mean editors don't do anything (except at Image or Iron Circus for example which don't employ editors), they're a big factor of the American book market comics I've been talking about since it operates more like traditional prose publishing. I mean creator-driven as in it's typically the creator who brings the story to the editor, the editor helps them shape it, and the creator is often the focus from a marketing standpoint.