|
The "Lost" 11th Commandment doth dictate: "Thou Shalt Not Cover GNR."
Some bands/singers, it's okay to cover. Sometimes the covers are better, like AFI's "Head Like A Hole" or Johnny Cash's "Hurt" both being better than the NiN originals. I've heard a few decent Bowie covers. I love Kiss but I can admit that most other bands play Kiss songs better than Kiss does, since Kiss aren't actually objectively great musicians. And so on.
Some stuff, though - GNR, Metallica, Queen, etc. - you just can't do it. I mean, you can in theory but it's just not gonna come off right no matter who it is or what they do. It's not even just the sound of it, there's a certain intangible that just doesn't translate when performed by others.
|