![]() |
|
|
#11 |
|
Overlord
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,096
|
Ok, I think I can finally go into detail about how I feel about the concept art. I don't like it.
The lack of defined muscle on the turtles just seems wrong to me. I'm assuming idea of this being more action than comedy is just completely thrown out the window here, because the designs remind me more of the Rugrats art direction than any previous animated incarnation of the turtles. Pretending the general direction of these designs are good, which I don't think they are, I like that they don't go overboard with trying to make them look different and trying to make them look different in more subtle ways is the right idea if you want to do that... But I don't understand why Donnie needs to have a tooth sticking out or Leo the point of Leo's braces? Is there going to be a lot of close up shots of their mouths open? While I doubt the pizza cutting scenario here is meant to be an actual scene, more just to get the vibe of the movie across, I'm not sure what to make of it. I seriously can't tell if it's meant to be the present with some futuristic elements or the future with some lingering elements of the present. It's very jumbled and I would have preferred it if the artwork had depicted something that would actually have been a particular scene. If it is meant to be an actual scene, then this movie is just going to be a jumbled mess with no rhyme or reason. As for the individual elements depicted here, I've already talked a bit about Wingnut but only because someone else brought him up. To clarify, it means nothing to me, the character is and has always been an uninteresting nothing-burger meant to fill out a toyline. In many ways it just feels like he's thrown in there so there is technically something recognisable in this but I doubt that many people actually care about Wingnut in the first place for him to even be recognisable. If he ends up in the final movie, I'm willing to bet it's like Rhino in TASM2, he'll be there but practically irrelevant. As for his design, I honestly assumed he was a generic gargoyle until it was pointed out that the yellow smudge was Screwloose, that's how unrecognisable he is. Similar to Wingnut, we also get the Technodrome just sitting there. Now unlike Wingnut, I do assume the Technodrome will play a major role in the movie, which just makes me cringe a bit. The Technodrome sucks and we all know it, you can use it like one story and trying it again will just look embarrassing, because it can literally never be allowed to destroy the world. It should just be left in the Fred Wolf show where it belongs and be forgotten (and honestly, the Fred Wolf show might have been slightly stronger without it). As for the design, I can't believe they somehow ended up making something that looks even uglier than the Fred Wolf design, it looks like a total piece of junk, even if that is a perfect description of this thing in general. Then there is the statue of what I assume is Shredder. It is standing on top of a water tower, which is really weird. That is part of the reason I suspect this isn't meant to represent any particular scene and is just a bunch of things that may or may not be in the movie. If it is meant to convey some actual plot point, this statue could be placed in a more logical place and I'm guessing that in this movie, Shredder has conquered New York? Doesn't really matter, none of this implies anything about the plot really. Assuming that is indeed the Shredder and it is indeed his final design, I do not like it. It basically looks like it took the worst design elements of the 2012 Shredder and the Cyber Shredder (two of the worst Shredder designs) smashed them together and gave him horns for some reason. He basically looks less like the Shredder and more like Emperor Zurg from the Toy Story movies, and that character design was meant to make fun of ugly looking action figures. I also see the Turtle Blimp, which... Ugh... Look, at least the Technodrome makes some sense even if it's a lot more lame than a most fans like to admit. But the Blimp, Van and most Turtle vehicles don't really have a place in this franchise. Let it go. There is also the thing with a tail shooting a laser gun. Maybe that is Newtralizer, so at least there is some things here not just lifted from the Fred Wolf era, even I don't think taking the 2012's random ideas is much better. Not sure what to say about the design. Then there's the whale which I assume is original. I don't have any memory of that from anything else, so at least there is something I can call original about this. If I'm wrong and this thing is from something, by all means, point that out to me. Assuming this is indeed something that ends up in the final movie, it's probably a major plot point because it's kind of hard to ignore. Final thoughts here... No, very little of this looks right to me. It feels like whoever made this watched the Fred Wolf cartoon and assumed nothing about TMNT came out before or after it. It is essentially what I assume Andrew's nightmares look like. To me it's just cringe though, albeit a very disappointing type of cringe. I mean seriously, don't just emulate the Fred Wolf cartoon and make the character design ugly. If you can't try to adapt the Mirage comics, at least pick a wider range of things to draw inspiration from and failing that, just make up something new (preferably something that ain't hideous). |
|
|
|
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|