The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

View Poll Results: Did you enjoy TMNT?
A+ this was an awesome movie 87 41.63%
A It was really good 64 30.62%
B pretty good movie 43 20.57%
C eh it is ok but I like the older ones better 8 3.83%
D Disapointing I didn't really think it was all good 3 1.44%
E Terrible. Disgusting. worst movie of 2007 3 1.44%
I am not going to see this movie. Don't like CGI or ninja turtles. 1 0.48%
Voters: 209. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 04-14-2007, 12:13 PM   #1
Masked Ninja
Doodles TMNT for fun
 
Masked Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: sploshin' through some sewer...
Posts: 2,137
Quote:
Originally Posted by Warhorse View Post
I love the cgi in this movie. It is really top notch in my opinion. Blows anything Pixar has done right out of the water.
I'd have to disagree with you on that one.

In all seriousness, though. I think the look is competitive. The textures and lighting were awesome and definitely different from anything Pixar does. (I will say that yeah, the textures were better, because Pixar tends to keep theirs simple. Though there is some freaking good stuff showing up in the Ratatouille trailers...) The effects animation was also competitive.

I'll even say that the "family tension" side of the story was deeper than most Pixar stuff, except for maybe The Incredibles. Though the monster story gets owned.

But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.

Though I do love to see an animated movie with a darker feel, both visually and story-wise. Certainly fresh and different... but I wouldn't say "better." But that's just me being an animation nerd.
Masked Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2007, 08:14 PM   #2
Warhorse
Emperor
 
Warhorse's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Florida
Posts: 5,544
Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja View Post
I'd have to disagree with you on that one.

In all seriousness, though. I think the look is competitive. The textures and lighting were awesome and definitely different from anything Pixar does. (I will say that yeah, the textures were better, because Pixar tends to keep theirs simple. Though there is some freaking good stuff showing up in the Ratatouille trailers...) The effects animation was also competitive.

I'll even say that the "family tension" side of the story was deeper than most Pixar stuff, except for maybe The Incredibles. Though the monster story gets owned.

But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.

Though I do love to see an animated movie with a darker feel, both visually and story-wise. Certainly fresh and different... but I wouldn't say "better." But that's just me being an animation nerd.
We all have our differences and opinions. I jsut think the fact that detail to the breathing of the Turtles alone, was ages away from Pixar.

As for the lip sync, i found no problem with this movie. Did you see the same movie I did? Did you see the reaction and tension built during the Raph vs Leo part? When they were arguing, with Raph shouting out that he is calling his own shots, and Leo blasting on him for what was he thinking, endangering the lives of the family. What about Leo spitting like a real fighter would when getting the wind knocked out of him by Raph. I have seen nothing from Pixar that comes even close to this.
Warhorse is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-15-2007, 06:48 PM   #3
Masked Ninja
Doodles TMNT for fun
 
Masked Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: sploshin' through some sewer...
Posts: 2,137
Quote:
Originally Posted by Warhorse View Post
We all have our differences and opinions. I jsut think the fact that detail to the breathing of the Turtles alone, was ages away from Pixar.

As for the lip sync, i found no problem with this movie. Did you see the same movie I did? Did you see the reaction and tension built during the Raph vs Leo part? When they were arguing, with Raph shouting out that he is calling his own shots, and Leo blasting on him for what was he thinking, endangering the lives of the family. What about Leo spitting like a real fighter would when getting the wind knocked out of him by Raph. I have seen nothing from Pixar that comes even close to this.
Well, the Leo vs. Raph sequence was nearly perfect. And yes, I like that scene more than most of what Pixar has done, I will admit... they don't tend to go for the raw arguments (and when they do something close, you still never really get the sense that the two characters may never make up, much less one might come within a hair of killing the other). Plus most of the acting in that part was great. THAT part was top notch.

But I stand by my assertion that while it was acceptable most of the time, there were parts where I cringed at the awful lipsync. There are a few moments like that in the Leo/April talk inthe beginning. One of the worst cases is when Mikey say "Oho! Someone's cranky!" that makes me wonder if they changed the voice clip at the last minute and left the animation as it was.

I'm not bashing TMNT as a whole; it will go down in history as being severely underrated. It did quite a few things Pixar hasn't touched (I'll have to watch again for the breathing - of course Pixar characters will do it when called for, but having it go on all the time? Maybe a rewatch of both TMNT and my favorite Pixars will be in order. ), but Pixar's still got it beat in some ways.

Ahh, and enter the Fled. You know, I do agree that CG animation can't be treated quite the same as 2D, especially since some of the zanier stuff looks way better as a collection of lines than a solid virtual shape. (That was part of my beef with Madagascar, along with many other things... while I appreciated the use of intense squash and stretch, it was overdone and the 'tooniness got annoying after a while) And yeah, overacting is not necessarily the best way. Why I like how Pixar does their stuff are the little acting subtlties that a lot of other companies don't take to that level. There's some overacting, sure, but it reads a lot better in animation than live action.

The acting issues I have in TMNT are the occasional overdone bits. There's a bit between Raph and Don where Raph goes "Yeah... you got me all figured out!" and he moves way more than I would think Raph would, tilts his head, and even points for effect. Though there are some times where the animation acting is understated and it does read better.

Again, I'm not trying to say that Pixar is still leagues ahead. TMNT is dang close. I'm just noting that there was still room for improvement, which could probably have been aided by a bigger budget and more time to check over animation in some scenes. (the lipsync issues are the most annoying - acting problems are only here and there)

This topic makes me feel like a pessimist who hates the movie. I don't... in fact, I loved it a lot. There are plenty of subtle things that just make it work. But I'm also an animation major and one of the best ways I can learn is by picking apart what others have done.
Masked Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-15-2007, 10:44 PM   #4
Fledermaus
Mad Scientist
 
Fledermaus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: SoCal
Posts: 1,115
They call me -- LONG POST.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja View Post
The acting issues I have in TMNT are the occasional overdone bits. There's a bit between Raph and Don where Raph goes "Yeah... you got me all figured out!" and he moves way more than I would think Raph would, tilts his head, and even points for effect. Though there are some times where the animation acting is understated and it does read better.
Hm.... Hm.... I'll have to watch that particular Raph-Don scene again. (The head tilting I agree with, but I attribute that more to the fact that the animators are Chinese people trying to make their characters seem American. Overall... I really think it lacked time. See, if there had been a Pixar-level investment in polishing, someone could have pointed out some of the more awkward bits. I keep thinking again of the budget and the time and the experience of those in charge... eh. Remember, I ranted about how crappy the movie looked when I saw the first trailer. I ranted about how it looked like a video game (which it certainly does in some sequences). I believed that there was little to no hope for this movie and that I could only be utterly disappointed. If I remember correctly, you were a lot more hopeful despite the fact that TMNT had a supa low budget with a first-time film director whose only background has been in... just look up Kevin on IMDB ... compared to Pixar. (correct me if I'm wrong, I apologize).

You know what? I'm done comparing TMNT to Pixar. TMNT's always been this underground thing to begin with whereas Pixar is more about creating art and great cinema. Just compare TMNT to itself. We know sure as hell what could have been improved.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja
This topic makes me feel like a pessimist who hates the movie. I don't... in fact, I loved it a lot. There are plenty of subtle things that just make it work. But I'm also an animation major and one of the best ways I can learn is by picking apart what others have done.
You don't need a degree to be an animator or to study animation compulsively. Some people just take the side-entrance.

But I don't think you look like a pessimist. Just look at all those people in the several "things I found annoying about the movie" thread. They're picking TMNT apart despite the fact (perhaps because of the fact) that they loved it.

My frustration as far as looks go had to do, I think, with the budget of this film; I got the impression that there wasn't enough experienced, professional direction (for movies, that is; I realize that a lot of these guys were professionals, but I remember reading that their backgrounds were mostly in TV and video game animation), not to mention any cultural barriers despite best attempts at communication. Those are much bigger roadblocks than I think most people realize.

So you see, that is why I get so bent out of shape about how much money there is for a sequel. I'll be genuinely pissed if they are unable to improve on the "cleanup" or spotting repetitiveness and awkward moments in the animation. It would be a major shame if money or the need to cater to a rating or time limit got in the way of things.

I think that, with the current leadership and the animation staff, it is unrealistic to expect that the animators will settle for anything better than generic acting. It only got awkward when the generic acting (like Raph's wild head tilting, the excessive pointing -- which I thin only worked really well in the rain scene -- or Mikey's exuberant expressions in front of the TV... ) lost sight of staying understated.

The same principle applies in real-life acting. Damn how do i say this?... I remember how my director would get on our case about being over the top when our main idea wasn't that special or creative. That's when generic acting crosses the line from looking natural (not very theatrical, but at least dignified) to looking forced (trying to hard to be bigger than it is).

BTW, another instance of repetitive animation...

A lot of people praised the "subtle" action of Don holding Mikey back so that Raph and Leo could have some down time at the battle. I thought it was appropriate. Maybe it was. However, when Splinter does the exact same thing to Raph only five minutes later, I started wondering. Did Raph have some special bond with Max? Did he have some particular tendency that needed to be addressed by this action?... My guess is probably no and that that was thrown that in for the hell of it. Though stuff like this did not outweigh the many strong scenes, thank God. But it was still noticeable *grimaces* ... The look and animation in TMNT felt like, at worst, an unfinished project, overall well done, but certainly not lacking in its sloppy moments.

Now over the hedge did not have standout sloppy moments. But ultimately, I care more about whether the CG movie has ANYthing that makes me go -- woooooww.... TMNT had this. Over the Hedge, for all its cleverness and professional finished quality, did not.

Sorry for the long Fledermaus post.
__________________
We're calling it a freeway. Eight lanes of shimmering cement running from here to Pasadena. Smooth, safe, fast. Traffic jams will be a thing of the past. I see a place where people get on and off the freeway. On and off, off and on all day, all night! Soon there will be a string of gas stations, inexpensive motels, restaurants that serve rapidly prepared food! Tire salons, automobile dealerships and wonderful, wonderful billboards reaching as far as the eye can see! My God... It'll be beautiful.

Last edited by Fledermaus; 04-16-2007 at 01:48 AM.
Fledermaus is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-16-2007, 01:28 AM   #5
Masked Ninja
Doodles TMNT for fun
 
Masked Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: sploshin' through some sewer...
Posts: 2,137
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fledermaus View Post
You know what? I'm done comparing TMNT to Pixar. TMNT's always been this underground thing to begin with whereas Pixar is more about creating art and great cinema. Just compare TMNT to itself. We know sure as hell what could have been improved.
Haha. I try not to all that much. And it does stand quite nicely on its own two legs.

And the lipsync is a big improvement from the live-action movies, to be sure. Love the suits and all - they were awesome. That was just a limitation they had.

I enjoy reading your long posts, no worries. And there's a lot in there I do agree with. I think it's a little interesting too how you went in thinking it'd be crap and came out loving it. I went in with certain expectations and came out thrilled, if a little disappointed. Must be the Leo in me... my eye tends to zoom in on the flaws even in films I enjoy.

The fact that I've only seen the movie once is probably another factor. Now that I've analyzed the heck out of things on the first shot, I need to go back, see it again, and look for the awesome details I missed or overlooked the first time.

Maybe after finals.
Masked Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2007, 08:30 PM   #6
Fledermaus
Mad Scientist
 
Fledermaus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: SoCal
Posts: 1,115
Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja View Post
But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.
Budget and time. To me the animation in TMNT is so mixed. If you looked at several scenes in this movie, the animation (not just the texturing) looked like the 3/4 stage of animation in a Pixar movie. It looked mostly done, but not completely. As far as lip-sync goes, all they needed was a few more weeks to tweak it AGAIN. That's part of why Pixar movies are so... practically perfect. They go over things so many times until voila -- you have a great movie with NO rough spots.

TMNT had a lot of rough spots. It was still, overall, very enjoyable, however we are talking about the technical quality.

Now, where I think you and I may disagree is on what principles CG animation should be based. I'm definitely more of a follower of Chris Landreth (director of Ryan) when it comes to character animation in CG movies.

Call me nuts, but I think another reason why I liked quite a bit of the animation in TMNT was because it didn't look very disney/pixar at its roots, nor did it have that pixie-stix bounce of Dreamworks cartoony cartoons...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elen Besen
The standard wisdom in commercial and educational circles, these days, is that the strongest foundation for creating believable characters in CG is still the 12 principles of 2D classical animation. These groundbreaking fundamentals, which include such concepts as stretch and squash, anticipation and the use of arcs, were developed by Disney animators in the 1930s to give their drawn animated characters more life. But is this really the best and only approach for CG?

Landreth, who came into animation through a side door instead of through the usual animation schools and studio apprenticeships, certainly challenges this idea and has been adamant about exploring other paths � ones that don�t follow the old rules to the letter. Up for re-examination are the use of gesture and exaggeration and the whole pose-to-pose approach.

Take, for example, the idea of ambiguity. Landreth explains that 2D classical technique is based on clarity of gesture and emotion from one pose to the next. So if a character is supposed to be sad, the face and body posture should convey a united front of sadness. But though emotionally clear, the end result of this approach is stagy and the lack of ambiguity actually gets in the way of creating realistic, original CG performance.

Are the principles the only problem here or do technical limitations also get in the way of creating subtle performance with CG characters?

�Look at a film like Final Fantasy,� Landreth says, �The problem there is not a lack of controls, in, say, the face. I�ve seen the rigs for a lot of these characters and they are immensely complex. It�s a relatively straightforward thing to add tons of controls, which can make anything happen to the face. If anything, a 3D animator has way more controls than he needs, rather than not enough.�

Where the 2D mentality sets in, then, is in how the animator chooses to use those controls and how he/she approaches them technically. For example, a lot of the animators on Ryan liked using dope sheets because they make it very easy to break down the individual motions in a character. But that is part of the posy approach, which Landreth was trying to get away from.

Ultimately, Landreth succeeded in weaning his animators off the dope sheets. Instead he encouraged them to use the graph editor � a more left-brain way to look at the animation � and from that to gain a better understanding of waveform. �People don�t move in curves,� says Landreth, �Their nerves impulsively fire off a muscle contraction and that means that motions begin with an abrupt twitch and then trail off. The pattern looks like a shark fin instead of a smooth arc.� And then, because there is also muscle, there is momentum, follow through, mass etc. to be accounted for.

He also encouraged his animators into giving individual characteristics to different parts of the body. And into working with straight ahead animation, rather than laying out timed poses and then defining where the inbetweens are, which tends to create a very cartoony acting style � one gesture per accent of dialogue, no ambiguity allowed.

The results of these changes were spectacular, exceeding even Landreth�s own expectations. But the roots of this success go back a few years, to the late `90s when Landreth immersed himself in a study of the human body: how it was structured, how it moved, how it expressed emotion. The key to this was the detail that Landreth went into. Interestingly, this was exactly the kind of detail that classical animators learned to leave out in order to make actions and emotions read more clearly in 2D.

So Landreth studied finger movements and noticed the shark fin patterns they created. And he studied the performances of great film actors to understand the role that tiny facial muscles play in expressing the subtleties of emotion. I�ll never forget the time he came out to a class I was teaching at Sheridan, in the midst of this study and had us all staring intently at Dustin Hoffman�s chin, watching how an almost invisible muscle would begin to pull downward as Hoffman�s tension increased.
Not that TMNT approached even what Ryan had... but I like that it seemed to rely more on subtlety and ambiguity than supa-creative-drama-in-yo-face stuff that I remember from such performances as Marlin's in Finding Nemo...

Read the rest here.

Can we have an thread just for discussing the character animation in TMNT?? I wonder how many people would be interested. I want to butt heads with the other animators at the Drome. CG animation is a slightly different medium than traditional animation, in my opinion. "Sfumato" -- not only in the face but in overall bodily movements -- becomes much more important because you're animating at a full 24 fps -- not to mention the 3d quality. Pixar may know how to polish like there's no tomorrow, but the hallowed Way-of-Disney is not the be-all-end-all to CG animation. Especially CG animation.

But I have to go back to work now...
__________________
We're calling it a freeway. Eight lanes of shimmering cement running from here to Pasadena. Smooth, safe, fast. Traffic jams will be a thing of the past. I see a place where people get on and off the freeway. On and off, off and on all day, all night! Soon there will be a string of gas stations, inexpensive motels, restaurants that serve rapidly prepared food! Tire salons, automobile dealerships and wonderful, wonderful billboards reaching as far as the eye can see! My God... It'll be beautiful.

Last edited by Fledermaus; 04-14-2007 at 09:03 PM.
Fledermaus is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:15 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.