The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-25-2008, 09:46 AM   #1
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja View Post
And that's the reason why they're horrid, probably. The better animated movies take roughly four years to go from concept to finished film. It's because they spend time getting the kinks out of the story and plussing the animation.

Not like I can hope for that with a Turtles movie, because nobody seems to take it seriously enough. The last one was a decent effort, but not quite there yet. Y'know?
Ending "Tales" is epic fail when it comes to my wallet's relationship with Mirage.

As for a movie sequel, as fun as it would be to see it happen, I'd rather have the most fun by seeing it done right. None of this "We have to limit it to PG" crap. If that means direct-to-DVD, fine. If that means I have to order it directly from Mirage to get it, fine. I'm just tired of hearing "4 t3h childrenz" as an excuse for PG when properties like Transformers, Batman, and Spider-Man can get PG-13 movies as still be enjoyed by the "they better fscking get this right" older crowd and the "BUY ME THAT USELESS PIECE OF PLASTIC!" younger crowd.

So, if they do it right, I'd like to see it. However, I can wait awhile and put it in the back of my mind if that's what it takes to get it right. I think the animators and such doing the dirty work last time had their hearts in the right place. They just didn't have the creative freedom to get it done right.

I had one other point, but I'm multitasking and forgot what I was gonna say.
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 10:51 AM   #2
Drtooth
Foot Elite
 
Drtooth's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 4,439
Quote:
Originally Posted by Goongasnootch View Post
As for a movie sequel, as fun as it would be to see it happen, I'd rather have the most fun by seeing it done right. None of this "We have to limit it to PG" crap. If that means direct-to-DVD, fine. If that means I have to order it directly from Mirage to get it, fine. I'm just tired of hearing "4 t3h childrenz" as an excuse for PG when properties like Transformers, Batman, and Spider-Man can get PG-13 movies as still be enjoyed by the "they better fscking get this right" older crowd and the "BUY ME THAT USELESS PIECE OF PLASTIC!" younger crowd.
Been saying that since last year. If we can have Baby Spiderman products (he's on ^%$# diapers now!) while a PG13 movie is out, they can sure as shell make the next one PG 13. Or at least make a PG a PG, not a souped up G. No kid's gonna go on a shooting rampage if Raphael says "Damn" more than once.

And think this way. There are movies that do terribly and have sequals. Not even justi DTV sequals. Actual, theatrical sequals. Was their any call for Daddy Day Camp? Even if they decide on a DTV release there WILL be a second film made. It's not an issue of of the distribution company (which would be the biggest stumbling block). it's an issue of Imagi and Mirage working over the plot line.

So even if it's just DTV, we will get a sequal IF Mirage and Imagi work it out. While TMNT didn't perform amazingly at the BO (due in part it was released a week before a Disney film and a pointless Will Ferrel comedy), it did generate enough merchandising interrest.
__________________
[Insert mildly amusing banner here]
Drtooth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 01:04 PM   #3
Tinuvielsdreams
Nothing without passion
 
Tinuvielsdreams's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 1,722
I am going to say that I think there is still a shot. Remember if Imagi is the studio that will continue to do TMNT in the future there are busy right now. They have projects lined up...Gatchaman, and astroboy just for example

It can take 2-3 years usually to put together an animated film especially when you are talking about the caliber of CGI they are going for. 2009 and 2010 are very reasonable time periods. Look how long we had to wait for this one, if the franchise keeps going (which I know is a big debate) I know we will see another film
Tinuvielsdreams is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 01:48 PM   #4
Jester
Rat-faced Dude-guy
 
Jester's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Arkansas
Posts: 26,301
I'm gonna remain optimistic and say 2009 to go with the 25th Anniversary and have it based on the City at War comic arc!
__________________

"Clearly, you're Ninja Turtling incorrectly." - Leo656

Last edited by Jester; 02-26-2008 at 07:11 PM.
Jester is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 03:31 PM   #5
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jester View Post
I'm gonna remain obtimistic and say 2009 to go with the 25th Aniversary and have it based on the City at War comic arc!
It's conceivable a TMNT sequel could make it out for 2009, the development time for TMNT was 18 months, but I would much rather have them take their time and release it later in 2010, TMNT's story definately would have benefited from more development time.


Considering the 25th Anniversary is something that will only appeal to older fans, I would like to see a direct-to-dvd animated (2-D) feature, maybe using CaW as a basis, or a directors cut of TMNT based on the original script.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 04:23 PM   #6
OA
Scatter the nuns!!
 
OA's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 3,981
If there is a sequel, I'm betting it will go straight to video...
__________________
OA is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 04:44 PM   #7
Aztec General
Mad Scientist
 
Aztec General's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 1,437
Quote:
Originally Posted by Goongasnootch View Post
As for a movie sequel, as fun as it would be to see it happen, I'd rather have the most fun by seeing it done right. None of this "We have to limit it to PG" crap. If that means direct-to-DVD, fine. If that means I have to order it directly from Mirage to get it, fine. I'm just tired of hearing "4 t3h childrenz" as an excuse for PG when properties like Transformers, Batman, and Spider-Man can get PG-13 movies as still be enjoyed by the "they better fscking get this right" older crowd and the "BUY ME THAT USELESS PIECE OF PLASTIC!" younger crowd.

So, if they do it right, I'd like to see it.
I agree 10,000%!!!!!!!!!!!

As for TMNT 4, it was really such a dual movie. There were parts of it that reminded me of the Mirage comics and the first film. The parts where Leo & Raph fight, where Leo goes off on his own to train, where Raph becomes a vigilante, where Casey ponders growing up, where Splinter talks to his children, where Karai tries to lead the Foot after the death of the Shredder. These parts felt right. They felt like TMNT to me, they felt mature, and they felt like the direction where the TMNT should be heading.

Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.

Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.

In short TMNT was a mixed bag. Half of it was a true sequel to the first, and only great, TMNT film and the other half was Saturday morning cheese. In short: wasted potential.

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.
__________________
Aztec General is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 04:51 PM   #8
GreasyBoi
Foot Soldier
 
GreasyBoi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Indiana
Posts: 238
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aztec General View Post

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.
How do you know there won't be one?
__________________
Prayers for Paul George
GreasyBoi is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 05:06 PM   #9
OA
Scatter the nuns!!
 
OA's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 3,981
Quote:
Originally Posted by Batista13 View Post
How do you know there won't be one?
I pretty sure he's making an "educational guess"...
__________________
OA is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 05:12 PM   #10
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aztec General View Post
I agree 10,000%!!!!!!!!!!!

As for TMNT 4, it was really such a dual movie. There were parts of it that reminded me of the Mirage comics and the first film. The parts where Leo & Raph fight, where Leo goes off on his own to train, where Raph becomes a vigilante, where Casey ponders growing up, where Splinter talks to his children, where Karai tries to lead the Foot after the death of the Shredder. These parts felt right. They felt like TMNT to me, they felt mature, and they felt like the direction where the TMNT should be heading.

Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.

Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.

In short TMNT was a mixed bag. Half of it was a true sequel to the first, and only great, TMNT film and the other half was Saturday morning cheese. In short: wasted potential.

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.
Thanks for backing me up. Looking at your point of view about TMNT 4, I waswondering: did you read the novelization? I read it before I saw the movie and I think that the novelization, as it leaves a lot of the imagination, makes a great story that was kind of "true to Mirage tone" while having elements of "true to Archie tone" in there as well.
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 07:02 PM   #11
sdp
Detoxed Member
 
sdp's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Tokio, Italy
Posts: 11,234
I didn't think the first one was going to do that good, so I thought at best it was a miracle to have this one new movie. The fact that we are still getting new toys based off the movie and that the series was renewed mostly because of the movie I do think a sequel could happen. I always knew the movie wouldn't come out for quite a while anyway 2010 earliest. Imagi has a lot of projects right now. TMNT hasn't really gotten that big since its "come back" so I don't really see people losing interest in fact we now have many movies that come out every 3 years that are aimed at children like Spider Man, Harry Potter etc.
sdp is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 07:28 PM   #12
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,620
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aztec General View Post
I agree 10,000%!!!!!!!!!!!

As for TMNT 4, it was really such a dual movie. There were parts of it that reminded me of the Mirage comics and the first film. The parts where Leo & Raph fight, where Leo goes off on his own to train, where Raph becomes a vigilante, where Casey ponders growing up, where Splinter talks to his children, where Karai tries to lead the Foot after the death of the Shredder. These parts felt right. They felt like TMNT to me, they felt mature, and they felt like the direction where the TMNT should be heading.

Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.

Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.

In short TMNT was a mixed bag. Half of it was a true sequel to the first, and only great, TMNT film and the other half was Saturday morning cheese. In short: wasted potential.

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.
Correct. On every point.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 08:25 PM   #13
xmen510
Foot Soldier
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: London Ontario Canada
Posts: 105
The last movie has made a fair amount of money from Box Office and DVD. I would bet we will see one at some point.
xmen510 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-25-2008, 08:28 PM   #14
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aztec General View Post
Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.
The only thing wrong with the monsters/Winters plot was that it was underdeveloped, and knowing how much was cut out of the movie, that may be more by design then poor writing.

Really, the plot of the movie was more representative of the types of plots you got in the original Mirage comics, If anything, the movie plot is far less silly and outlandish then many of the stories in the first two volumes of the Mirage comics.



Quote:
Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.
There is no reason why TMNT can't be taken serious, but I wouldn't compare TMNT with Batman or Spider-Man, those franchises have far more mainstream credibility then TMNT. Transformers (a movie more immature then TMNT), was backed by Spielberg, and Dreamworks and Paramount were desperate for a hit franchise, and were willing to gamble on what many people viewed as just an 80's toy fad.


TMNT was greenlighted based on the popularity of the new cartoon and the toy sales based on the cartoon, hence a movie aimed more at little kids.

Considering other nostalgia properties (G.I. Joe, Robotech, He-Man, ect.) will likely head down the PG-13 road after the success of Transformers, Warner Bros would be fools not to jump on the bandwagon.


Quote:
As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.
Unless you have any solid arguments to support this claim, I'll just take it as wishful thinking on your part.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 02:02 AM   #15
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,620
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
The only thing wrong with the monsters/Winters plot was that it was underdeveloped, and knowing how much was cut out of the movie, that may be more by design then poor writing.
I won't deny that another 20 minutes or so of material making us swallow the monster/wacky bonanza thrust upon us would have been beneficial to the film... but it's still back asswards.

It's like... let's make Batman Begins Part 7. But let's make it with Guidomaxius, who needs to trap 20 demon bats in order to stop a global apocalypse. Between Robin burping and Batman jumping in Robin's arms when a particularly scary bat demon surprises them, they save the day.

No, it was just a flat-out wrong approach to the source material. Is it better than TMNT 2 and 3? Yes. Is it kind of approaching TMNT 1, even in a sideways, diluted kind of way? Mm, I can see that to some degree in the side-stories of TMNT Part 4, sure (the family story bits).

But it's a far effing cry from anything resembling a proper comic book adaptation of the source material.

Quote:
Really, the plot of the movie was more representative of the types of plots you got in the original Mirage comics, If anything, the movie plot is far less silly and outlandish then many of the stories in the first two volumes of the Mirage comics.
Oh? Which ones, pray tell?

Let's break it down.

The first issue, we learn the Turtles have been raised since birth to one day grow up and assassinate Oroku Saki. They do so, Leonardo impaling Saki through the chest with both katana, then Donatello throwing him over the side of a skyscraper, Saki's own grenade blowing up next to him turning him into giblets.

The second issue deals with mousers, mostly the Turtles' introduction to April. Not a story arc in itself.

We move on a bit, the Turtles investigate TCRI and end up -- long story short here -- on the Triceraton homeworlds. It's a bit of a brutal mortal combat here, the Turtles fending for their lives. The Turtles kill their adversaries and we even see Don jamming his broken staff into the neck of a Triceraton for the win. They escape; the Utroms teleport them back.

We arrive at the Leo special (following the Raph special, an excellent and gritty intro to Casey), where Leonardo is beaten to a bloody pulp by a resurrected Saki/Shredder after killing a number of Foot himself. Moving on, the Turtles escape after April's Second Time Around Store is torched.

They make it to Northampton, where we see a touching story with the Turtles coping and reaffirming themselves in the countryside. At one point saving April from dying/freezing in the ice.

Next issue some NRA crazies are big-game hunting. They're dealt with.

Some random one-shots follow, but the issue with April and the Turtles at the farm (#11) marks the last Eastman & Laird collaboration until #19-21... "Return to New York." Teaming with Zog for a while, they kill truckloads of Foot, take out Saki's other worm clones, and then Leo cuts off Saki's head and his brothers burn the pieces over the Hudson.

That's it from Eastman/Laird until #50 (the issues in between just a musical chairs with different teams, hit or miss), which begins with the Shredder Elite Foot asserting themselves, beheading the old Foot to usurp command themselves. After a very, very bloody ordeal (the brutal gunning down of Karai's daughter, countless Foot slain, and other deaths), finally the last Shredder Elite is killed.

Shall we go to Volume 2?

All right, cards on the table. I don't like it. It's boring. But to actually examine it?

First we get Baxter. He's back. He carves his own head open and inserts his brain into a cyborg and eventually has a rematch with the Turtles that ends in him getting exploded into giblets. Some Triceraton throwbacks attempt to launch a final attack on Earth to a nuclear end... and granted it gets a little fuzzy with Louis (did it happen? was it a dream? did he warp reality, and if so, how?), but pretty much all the Turtles and their enemies in DARPA get atomized -- and viscerally.

So yeah... about the "weirdest" storyline out of all of the Eastman & Laird TMNT comics was the TCRI storyline which segwayed into the Triceraton encounter/arena/escape. Which for how off-the-wall it may sound, was played pretty straight... a hybrid of a gritty ninja movie, a late night sci-fi movie, and Gladiator... it worked, it was cool and it had balls.

TMNT Part 4? 13 wacky monsters in a Pokemon-esque "Gotta Catch'em All" plot, Mikey doing a 5 second burp for toddler giggles, Turtles literally leaping into each other's arms screaming in terror like something out of Looney Tunes, bloodless, toothless combat, Mikey not even being able to use his weapons... yeah, not feeling so much Eastman & Laird in that.

Quote:
There is no reason why TMNT can't be taken serious
There's every reason. It's not fair, it's not right, and it's a shame that the beancounters can't see the forest for the trees (meaning, can't see the Mirage source material in spite of the made-for-children rubbish it spawned).

Quote:
but I wouldn't compare TMNT with Batman or Spider-Man, those franchises have far more mainstream credibility then TMNT.
They do now. But at some point they still had to go from Point A to Point B. At some point Spider-Man crossed over from old children's cartoons with a campy theme song to a relatively mature movie... what are the real differences here?

A guy of Sam Raimi's caliber. Marvel behind him. People with clout, people able to do exactly the movie they wanted to do, with a keen understanding and respect of the source material.

Quote:
Transformers (a movie more immature then TMNT), was backed by Spielberg
Well there you have your answer. Spielburg is a skeleton key for any movie.

A proper TMNT movie doesn't need a Spielburg, per se... but it does need someone with a little more Hollywood clout than a former video game director.

It's unfair, I know. And again, I know that had Kevin Munroe been given carte blanche to do exactly the most badass TMNT movie he could imagine and conjure up, we would have gotten something very, very different than what we saw in TMNT Part 4... but we still have what we have, at the end of the day and have to judge it as such.

Quote:
TMNT was greenlighted based on the popularity of the new cartoon and the toy sales based on the cartoon, hence a movie aimed more at little kids.
You're probably right... and that's unfortunate. Shooting oneself in the foot usually is.

Quote:
Considering other nostalgia properties (G.I. Joe, Robotech, He-Man, ect.) will likely head down the PG-13 road after the success of Transformers, Warner Bros would be fools not to jump on the bandwagon.
See, this is where I can't agree. A proper TMNT movie should have little to do with nostalgia -- not apart from some kind of vague name-recognition of "TMNT" or "Ninja Turtles." It should sell itself.

Akin to movies like Hellboy and Spider-Man, with a minimal amount of concessions it should burden itself with nothing more or less than being a true and proper comic book adaptation (or amalgamation) of the comic books.

If watchers of the children's cartoons want to jump aboard, great. If not, it should totally be able to stay afloat on its own laurels... and if it doesn't, it'll have failed totally of its own right. I don't know about you, but I can live with that.

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-26-2008 at 03:10 PM.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 12:24 PM   #16
Drtooth
Foot Elite
 
Drtooth's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 4,439
I still think the option to have it theatrically released is 50/50 at this point. It could go either way. It's not like TMNT was a huge budget film anyway. And I've seen a lot more films that didn't do that well at the BO get theatrical releases. Hell, there's gonna be a "Hoodwinked 2" at some point, and I'll be damned that doesn't get a theatrical release.
__________________
[Insert mildly amusing banner here]
Drtooth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 01:06 PM   #17
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
The more I think about it, the less I have to give up on. We'd probably know more if Murph hadn't been silenced under threat of 'cement shoes' from 4Kids and Imagi.
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 01:04 PM   #18
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
I won't deny that another 20 minutes or so of material making us swallow the monster/wacky bonanza thrust upon us would have been beneficial to the film... but it's still back asswards.

It's like... let's make Batman Begins Part 7. But let's make it with Guidomaxius, who needs to trap 20 demon bats in order to stop a global apocalypse. Between Robin burping and Batman jumping in Robin's arms when a particularly scary bat demon surprises them, they save the day.

No, it was just a flat-out wrong approach to the source material. Is it better than TMNT 2 and 3? Yes. Is it kind of approaching TMNT 1, even in a sideways, diluted kind of way? Mm, I can see that to some degree in the side-stories of TMNT Part 4, sure (the family story bits).

But it's a far effing cry from anything resembling a proper comic book adaptation of the source material.
Why? If you are strictly basing your argument on story content, then the storyline for TMNT, which at its heart is nothing more then your standard villain-gathers-objects-to-obtain-power comic storyline, easily fits into the world created in the original Mirage comics.

Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.


As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued, mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.




Quote:
There's every reason. It's not fair, it's not right, and it's a shame that the beancounters can't see the forest for the trees (meaning, can't see the Mirage source material in spite of the made-for-children rubbish it spawned).
I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon, which leads us into the next point...



Quote:
They do now. But at some point they still had to go from Point A to Point B. At some point Spider-Man crossed over from old children's cartoons with a campy theme song to a relatively mature movie... what are the real differences here?

A guy of Sam Raimi's caliber. Marvel behind him. People with clout, people able to do exactly the movie they wanted to do, with a keen understanding and respect of the source material.
Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT, those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned. And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics. Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.

Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon), it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?), it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.

Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.


If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 07:31 PM   #19
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,620
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.
Actually no... Peter Laird has pretty much un-canonized every story that didn't involve... Peter Laird.

In any case I see the point you're trying to make (and there's been awesome stories with "oddities" like time travel and magic and such)... but the forest you're not seeing for the trees is that these stories were told straight out. No gimmicks, no Turtles jumping into each others' arms, no blatant kid/toy-pandering moments or cringe-worthy dialogue.

Quote:
As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued,
Yeah, you and I pretty much didn't watch the same movie. No offense.

Quote:
mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.
Meh, I had no problem with Dancing Evil Parker in the context of the films, but whatever. I'm not a Spider-Man fan so I don't judge.

Quote:
I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon,
That's... crazy. First of all, the "mainstream public" has no idea the TMNT comics even exist for it to have somehow been imaginarily "replaced" by the cartoons. Second... why should they? Until there is a mainstream, proper comic book adaptation of the source material, the Mirage comics will never have any mainstream public appeal.

Quote:
Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT,
This is much ado about nothing. The credibility was earned.

Quote:
those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned.
Do they? You go up to most kids and go "Superman!" and they're probably thinking about that boring movie with the guy doing the Hackman impression, or Smallville, not comic books.

But you're kind of going on a tangent here.

Quote:
And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics.
Much ado about nothing. Just because the last and most prevalent thing in the media has been one thing (kid fluff) doesn't mean TMNT as a franchise needs to be a slave to it indefinitely. Did anyone know who the eff the Crow was before the Brandon Lee movie? Hellboy, before... Hellboy? Did it matter who or what they were before?

A proper TMNT movie shouldn't concern itself with any existing vestige of the fandom apart from the comic fans themselves , and even then they shouldn't go out of their way to give those comic fans a handjob... just concern themselves with doing a proper movie -- reboot, total clean page -- in the same spirit and grit of those original TMNT comics with whatever artistic flair (such as directors with a vision do when they're allowed to go balls-out) they want to add to the mix.

Better to do this than continue TPTB's never-ending perpetual cycle of putting TMNT crap on the screen that kids keep outgrowing. And it's not hard... they just need to look to the comics, or attempt something in that vein.

It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.

Quote:
Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.
Well that's a pretty broad statement... I'm pretty sure the millions and millions of readers of Spider-Man over the past some-odd decades would probably beg the differ. I'm certain the movie did kick Spider-Man "awareness" up to the Nth degree, sure. But Hellboy? It was a niche comic with a niche following that spawned a movie with a modest success... seemed about relative to me.

Quote:
Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon),
F***'em. Let them sate their nostalgia for the children's cartoons on DVD.

Quote:
it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?),
F***'em, too. It's not the TMNT's fault said people are uneducated about the Turtles' creation as a mature enough comic book.

Quote:
it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.
Eh, what? I don't think we're talking apples to apples anymore.

Quote:
Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.
*cough**box office**cough*

Quote:
If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.
Isn't that kind of like sitting someone in a chair, spinning them around until they're so dizzy they can't see, then expecting them to walk a straight line?

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-26-2008 at 08:03 PM.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:26 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.