I'm sure there are people who want to talk about other things in the main film thread, so let's bring the argument here.
Quote:
The "PG-13 or don't bother crowd" (which I actually coined four pages back) aren't saying it just because we think a PG movie would be poor entertainment.
We're saying it because it would be poor entertainment and strike another nail into the franchise's coffin. The franchise will never maintain a presence unless the public can get it into their heads that it isn't just a renewable cartoon and toyline.
You know how Batman can have action figures and cartoons, and people are still aware that there's an adult-oriented comic book being printed? You know how Batman, as a franchise, can pretty much do whatever it wants? If you want that to happen to the TMNT, we need a PG-13 movie to redefine them. Because the greater public simply will not see a PG movie.
|
Quote:
There's no argument (that it could be good or bad, regardless of rating). Now try getting people in the seats with a PG rating. Try having people take notice of the comics or larger franchise with a PG rating. People liked their light-hearted Turtles in 1989. Now they either want only old toon, or you have to give them something completely different. TMNT (2007) was a mess of conflicted tones with no clear target audience outside of the toy-buying, kiddie crowd. A memorable movie that does not make.
It's not about what we personally want to see in a movie (although I do think it needs the liberty of a higher rating). It's about what's best for TMNT. We want people to see the real, Mirage TMNT, with the humor and the darkness. We want people to be able to accept all aspects of the Turtles so it can support itself without whatever gimmicky toyline is running that year. This is a chance for that to come true. Accept no substitutions.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by CyberCubed
I get the feeling the first movie is probably the darkest a TMNT theatrical movie will ever get.
|
So you want to see a perpetual cycle of the TMNT cracking pizza jokes and fighting ninjas with cymbals and comedy props?
Talk about setting your standards low.
Quote:
|
I'm with the rest of you on this, NC-17 or no sale.
|
I don't know why I bother. This is not about making the movie as dark and violent as possible. It's about appealing to the widest audience. Kids and teens/adults will see a PG-13 movie. Only kids will see a PG movie.
|
Taken from other thread. Discuss. Argue. Try to be mature.