|
Originally Posted by Peter Laird
You have some completely valid points. Let me see if I can give you a bit of perspective from my side of things.
When I began TMNT Volume 4, I had been with the Turtles as co-creator and co-owner for about fifteen years. By that time, the whole "ninja hiding in the darkness" thing had kind of lost its appeal, at least for me. It's not that it's a bad concept, I was simply tired of it. I wanted to set up a situation where the Turtles could begin to interact with the larger world in ways they had not been able to previously. Having aliens land on Earth and establish a public presence seemed to be a good way to accomplish this -- giving the Turtles the ability to "hide in plain sight", as it were.
I know this took away a lot of the "secret ninja" aspect of the Turtles. However, to my way of thinking, having the ability to walk around in public didn't remove the ability of the Turtles to do the whole ninja thing -- I mean, they can still hide in shadows, scale buildings at night with their climbing claws, and fight with their ninja skills -- they just don't HAVE to all the time. They have more options now.
I'm not going to say that one approach is better than the other -- I can only say that for ME, the approach I took was the one which made doing Volume 4 interesting enough to me that I was willing to take the time and effort and money required to produce it.
As for my writing/plotting style -- you are correct in saying that it meanders. The way I am writing Volume 4 is quite possibly -- maybe even quite likely -- not what people expect from most comics, or most popular entertainment, which has exactly the "conflict-building tension-climax-resolution" formula that you describe. It may have a lot to do with why Volume 4 doesn't sell all that well. But the fact of the matter is that this is the way I want to tell this ongoing story. I am not interested in writing comics the way Kevin and I used to write the Turtle series. Those were fun stories, and some of them even hold up, I think, as good comics. But I am simply not interested in that approach for Volume 4. I fully understand that this approach is not to everyone's taste, and that I have lost readers who want what the old books were like. I regret that I can't provide that for them. Basically, it comes down to this -- if people want me to write a TMNT comic, Volume 4 is what they are going to get. I'm not going to do a series like Kevin and I used to. I don't want to. I have no interest in doing that. This is the form which currently pleases me.
This is why I have said, a number of times, that if you haven't realized after reading, say, a dozen issues or so of Volume 4, that it is not and very likely never will be like a traditional comic or like the comics that Kevin and I used to do together, I don't know how to help you. It's why I have said several times in the letters column of Volume 4 that if you don't like the way Volume 4 is going, STOP READING IT!!! They say that madness can be defined as doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. I have tried to make clear that this is the way I want to do Volume 4. If you like this approach, I am happy to have you as a reader. If you don't, I regret to lose you as a reader, but that's life.
I have tried to satisfy the types of readers who aren't interested in my Volume 4 approach by reviving the "Tales of the Turtles" series. I think a lot of very good work has been done in that series, with most of the issues being stand-alone stories. It's possible in the future that Mirage might publish a new, Volume 5 if you will, Turtle series which might be more like the old Volume 1 -- an ongoing continuity, but told with stories that run in short arcs, ranging from one to four issues. There are no plans to do so, but it's a possibility. But I can pretty much guarantee that it will never happen with Volume 4, and I am prepared to accept the consequences.
I hope this has been helpful. -- PL
|