Marvel Noir - Page 2

*Spitfire* · 10-26-2010, 08:40 PM

I read them all collected. I have all of them but Luke Cage. The Punisher one is neat. It has villains from the MAX series and his normal series. The Wolverine one was okay. Wolverine being a down and out detective who has to watch over his seemingly retarded brother wasn't exactly that engaging. It was a story about betrayal and his problems with "Sabertooth". Honestly wasn't different enough for me. The X-men one would have been better if it was less convoluted. By the end I was left with a sorta "Eh" feeling about it. I need to re-read it because I didn't understand a lot of it and the artwork made it hard to tell who was who sometimes.

Both Spider-man books are great and I look forward to a 3rd one, which they set up for. Daredevil was surprisingly good too. I didn't know what to expect because I normally hate that artist but it fit this story perfectly. I also like how it's told in a non-linear fashion.

If they do more I'll probably look into them. Not sure how I feel about Deadpool Pulp but I was never a big fan of his character anyway.

*Powder* · 11-23-2010, 08:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brodie

I know this is a bit old, but I know Spitfire and Powder were gonna look into these. Did you guys?

Thoughts?

Also, did you guys get single issues or the collected volumes?

I noticed the Hardcovers were normal format, but the book I picked up for X-Men is just a bit bigger than digest size, in terms of height/width.

I actually totally forgot all about it, this thread included. After reading over everyone's opinions, I really wanna check out the Spiderman books & will do so soon. Spit posted his feelings just above me.

10-26-2010, 08:40 PM	#21
Spitfire Writer • Director Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Los Angeles Posts: 12,035	I read them all collected. I have all of them but Luke Cage. The Punisher one is neat. It has villains from the MAX series and his normal series. The Wolverine one was okay. Wolverine being a down and out detective who has to watch over his seemingly retarded brother wasn't exactly that engaging. It was a story about betrayal and his problems with "Sabertooth". Honestly wasn't different enough for me. The X-men one would have been better if it was less convoluted. By the end I was left with a sorta "Eh" feeling about it. I need to re-read it because I didn't understand a lot of it and the artwork made it hard to tell who was who sometimes. Both Spider-man books are great and I look forward to a 3rd one, which they set up for. Daredevil was surprisingly good too. I didn't know what to expect because I normally hate that artist but it fit this story perfectly. I also like how it's told in a non-linear fashion. If they do more I'll probably look into them. Not sure how I feel about Deadpool Pulp but I was never a big fan of his character anyway. __________________ Check out my online portfolio http://www.christopherpelletier.com/