The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > 4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-23-2004, 06:08 PM   #21
Buslady
WingsOfDarkness! Perkele!
 
Buslady's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: In 7803...
Posts: 4,366
Good stuff Heretic, I learned a bit from all that!
__________________
Buslady is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-25-2004, 01:44 PM   #22
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Thank you.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-29-2004, 02:52 PM   #23
Ronin_of_Kirai
Thug
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: I'm not to sure myself
Posts: 74
Re: wee

Quote:
Originally Posted by heretic888
Ok, here we go...

Quote:
I forget the episode but it's the second one with Zog. In one sence where Leonardo and Rapheal boarded the Foot ship a Foot is potroling the area while his back is turned Rapheal walks up behind him with sai drawn then quickly put his hand over the foot ninjas mouth and pulls him off camera......IT"S ABOUT TIME!!! I've been waiting for the TMNT to do some truly in the way of Ninjutsu. Who else enjoyed seeing this landmark for Ninjutsu.
Ummmm... that's nice and all, but just because they did something "sneaky" doesn't mean its ninjutsu. A lot of people have done "sneaky" things throughout history --- doesn't make them ninja.

Quote:
I know what you mean but asuming that a ninja is defined as one who sneaks around committing silent murder and the like, isn't what Ninjutsu is all about.
Technically, "ninjutsu" refers to the collective arts of 'stealing-in' or 'invisibility' --- which sometimes included skills that could be used for assassination. Regardless, the historical shinobi no mono were not primarily known for assassinations (contrary to popular belief) --- their main during the Sengoku Jidai was siege warfare (primarily guerilla tactics) and reconaissance (that's scouting, stoopid).

Now, Ninpo, however... that's another story.

Quote:
That's just an aspect of Ninjutsu that Hollywood blew out of proportion in the 80's. Now almost everybody stereo-types ninja as assasins.
Uhhh... actually, that "stereotype" comes from the dramatic literature of Tokugawa and Meiji Japan. The West just carried it over.

Quote:
Ninja are much more on the level of the "freedom-fighter" who would fight in open war to defend there people, villages and maintain cosmic balance in the Universe.
Sorry, but that "freedom fighter" angle is a historical revisionism developed by Hayes. It is about as historically accurate as the "heartless assassin" angle. It should be noted that Hayes has, to a degree, since retracted a lot of his earlier claims concerning the ninja.

The "cosmic balance in the Universe" does have some historical precedence, though, but that's mostly from the shinobi's association with Mikkyo and Buddhism in general.

Quote:
Around the last chapter of the feudal era, Ninja took on a more espionage aprouch to maintain universal balance.
Actually, as far as I can tell, the ninja did not get involved heavily with Japan's wars until really late in the game --- no earlier than the mid-1400's. And, even then, their primary contribution was siege warfare and reconaissance. I believe the espionage angle was primarily accomplished during the Edo Period, when the shinobi formed a sort of secret police for the Tokugawa Shogunate.

Quote:
Those who train in the art of Ninjutsu today are still trying to combat the stereo-typing of the "silent killer".
Actually, most people that train in Ninpo today just try and stay away from the whole "ninja" image completely. That was the major reason why Hatsumi-soke changed the name of his art from Ninpo Taijutsu to Budo Taijutsu.

Quote:
The reality is that ninja are the unsung heroes of a time and place when they where simply outcasted as devious warlocks by the Samurai (and Samurai pretty much ran the country and influenced everybody's way of living and thinking).
Ummm... not really.

They weren't really outcasts or persecuted against, although records indicate they were constantly misunderstood and distrusted. However, records also indicate the shinobi were very respected for their skills.

Also, as a matter of history, most shinobi did happen to be samurai themselves. As in, most were landowners, which made them samurai.

Quote:
Even as it comes to the TMNT fighting its just not ninjutsu
Well, definately not on the cartoons.

Quote:
On a last note. Dont diss the Samurai if you had guys killing your samurai without honor youd be pretty pissed too
I know this is going to upset a lot of people's images about the samurai, but the 'bushido' code of honor you are citing is primarily a product of the Edo Period. It wasn't actually formalized in writing until the 1700's --- long after the samurai had been in active use as warriors.

Just take a look at some historical records from the Sengoku Jidai or any of the surviving koryu traditions --- they use "sneaky" and "underhanded" tactics all the time. By no means were these unique to the ninja.

Quote:
Just don't think that reading that one book makes you an expert.
Just don't think that reading any number of books makes you an expert, either. I used to think that --- until I actually had conversations with guys that had done a bit of research firsthand in Japan. I was promptly put in my place, and had many of my previous preconceptions of 'ninja' corrected. Now, I try to go to primary sources as often as possible.

Quote:
As much as I love seeing "real" ninjutsu, without mixing in a little fantasy and kick-butt action, I don't think it would appeal to as many people.
Depends on the audience, I suppose.

I have found that my attempts to use "authentic ninja" ideas among roleplaying circles (primarily D&D and Ninjas and Superspies), for example, have been generally well-received.

I doubt most children (the target audience of the cartoon shows) would either appreciate or understand a lot of the concepts in Ninpo, though.

Quote:
But I do grin over the little touches, like the breathing exercises they used when they were trapped on the Triceraton ship.
Technically, they were using Chi Kung -- not Ninpo.

Quote:
Oh heavens no. Heh want wanna know something pretty cool. I was gonna take a ninjutsu....but my poppy said no.... O well I think im going to take Kendo or Shotokan.
Heh. You should just tell him you're taking Budo Taijutsu or Ninpo.

Or, failing that, just call it 'jujutsu'. Hah!

Seriously, though, your father's reaction was one of the primary reasons modern practitioners try and steer away from the "ninja" image of the art. It dissuades too many good people that would actually benefit from the art, while attracting unsavory individuals that one doesn't necessarily want to be teaching martial arts to in the first place.

Quote:
My friends in Japan who've been ordering the new series off of Amazon said something similar...they were excited when the TMNT infiltrated the TCRI building in vol. 8 and said, "They're finally sneaking around like real ninjas for once!" (Even the Japanese have the same stereotypes about shinobi people abroad do )
Not surprising, considering the 'stereotypes' originated in Japan.

Quote:
Ronin of Kirai, I am certainly not dissing the Samurai. They helped unify Japan. If not for the Samurai, it would be almost imposible for Ninja to maintain balance on the land. Samurai's strict code of ethics is what kept Japan from going to oblivion! I'm just saying that the Samurai misunderstood the Ninja and his/her actions.
Technically, the 'ninja' were samurai. It is true, however, that their methods and motivations were often misunderstood --- or evenly actively distrusted -- by the samurai of other regions (but they always seemed to have been highly respected and admired for their skills). They did arise in promincence during the Tokugawa shogunate, however.

Quote:
Dr. Masaaki Hatsumi (34th grand master of Ninjutsu / Budo Ninpo Taijutsu)
Actually, he's 34th soke of Togakure ryu Ninjutsu. All the other ryuha have a different number of generations behind them.

Quote:
Oh, and a note to kitsunepixie; don't expect Japanese to have acurate knowledge on Ninja. Well, not most of them, anyway. Ninja wasn't a big aspect in Japanese history, and what little information on Ninja that you would find in a typical Japan history book tend to favour Samurai, making Ninja look like the sneaky villians of Japan. It's like asuming that Americans know there country's history inside and out acuratly, even the little details that would normaly be over looked.
Again, while there is some truth to this, the fact remains that the ninja were, for the most part, samurai themselves.

Quote:
"Hell, if you want to get REALLY technical about ninjas, then the whole "honor" thing is a joke. Ninjas were assassins, they killed people by any means nessassary, even by using small bombs.
The "honor" thing is, for the most part, ignored in Ninpo. Survival is seen as having much greater precedence. Of course, the "ninjas were just assassins" is also an inaccurate (and overexaggerated) angle, as well --- shinobi were primarily commandos and scouts (not to be too simplistic).

Laterz.
1.Im well aware of that Herectic but in this case where the characters are trained in ninjutsu........there being ninjas (Excuse me but I have a hard time explaining myself at times)

2. Oh no, My Poppy didnt want me taking ninjutsu because of the spiritual part of it. In fact hes suggested that whatever art I may take to include ninpo techniqes if I reallly wanted to.
__________________
Oro?
I love Rikku!
Ronin_of_Kirai is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-29-2004, 07:56 PM   #24
Ryona
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Well, you certainly are very knowledgable, Heretic888, But I can't agree with you one hundred percent, though most of it I agree with.

One of the things I had difficulty accepting was your claim that almost all Ninja were Samurai. I know you explained the whole "owning ones land makes one Samurai because Samurai own there own land" but Samurai may be the wrong term to use since "Samurai" is a title for the officers of Lords. The meaning of Samurai is "to serve", and Ninja didn't really serve any Lords. They only assisted them. Now I can see some Ronin Being Ninja, and some Ninja having Side Identities as Samurai (among others), so in that sense I can agree with some Ninja being Samurai.

As for the role that the Ninja played, I'm not quite sure why you don't accept the role of the "Freedom Fighter". I mean, Ninja played many roles through out history; The Freedom Fighter, the Assasin, The Yamabushi, and a host of others. You know, there is a lot of truth to Steven K. Hayes words, even though most people may not accept do to ignorance or what ever else. The term "Assasin" has become a desease that Ninpoka are trying to rid them selves of. Hatsumi-sensei has even commented many times of the Ninja historicly fighting for peace and protecting those who can not protect them selves. Now I do know that not all Ninja had good intentions and some were down right miscreant, after all, Ninja are human like any body else.
Lets try to aknowledge and appreciate the other roles of the Ninja rather than be infixiated with the briefe "darker" role of the Ninja.

Also, as for the "Breathing exercise", while it is practiced in Chi Gung, it is also practiced in Budo Ninpo Taijutsu aswell. Everthing done in the art of Ninjutsu is acompanied with proper breathing for maximum efficiancy.
Ninpoka are infact incouraged to use the "Art of breathing" in everything they do through out there daily life.

As for my little discription on Dr. Hatsumi Masaaki, I was keeping it simple so it wouldn't go over anybody's head (much like most everything else I posted).
  Reply With Quote
Old 06-03-2004, 09:27 AM   #25
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
In response to Ronin:

Oh no, My Poppy didnt want me taking ninjutsu because of the spiritual part of it.

I feel that the "spiritual" part of Ninpo is over-exaggerated, in no small part due to Hayes' implanting of Tendai Buddhism into his books.

The simple truth is that individuals of all nationalities and religions practice Ninpo across the world. Its no biggie. There is a philosophy underlying a lot of the concepts, but it isn't pushed on anyone.

Actually, practices like "sitting" meditation are typically discouraged by Hatsumi-soke, as are Buddhist mudra practice. Its all in the taijutsu --- taijutsu, taijutsu, taijutsu. Everything else is secondary.

If you want a little more information on this particular subject (of taijutsu superseding "meditation"), here is an article written by Ben Cole:

ON MEDITATION

Some teachers teach meditation to their students, but this is usually something they acquired from elsewhere. Soke does not teach meditation nor encourage it. "Just do Budo," he says, "and it will all come together."

Budo is moving meditation. In time, you gain the state of "no-mind," which is what people are sitting on their butts trying to achieve. In time, you also gain "ki" (for those of you who believe in it), which allows you to use "kiai" (true kiai, not the grunting of a base Karateka) and "kihaku." Both kiai and kihaku are part of Soke's teachings, but you still don't see people running around in class kiai-ing all the time. Why? Because that is a crass way to learn this stuff. If you just do Budo, everything else will come....

A true kiai should feel natural. It just kinda comes out. People may feel uncomfortable when it happens (thinking others might believe they are trying to make Taijutsu into Karate), but a truly skilled teacher will recognize the kiai (if it is natural) for what it is. I personally think it is a step in one's evolution as a martial artist.

Having kiai just naturally come out can be a dangerous thing though. So over time, you need to learn to control them. You don't want to risk having them come out at the wrong time. This is no different than learning to turn your "shinkengata" on and off. One second you are standing there talking with a friend, the next second you are in a fight. And then, as soon as the fight is over, you need to be able to "turn it off."

This type of training is very important. That is why I think it is important to NOT train an entire session "turned on." You cannot live life being "on" the entire time. You will frighten people around you. Instead, you need to be "invisible"--only "turning on" when you need to make a point (frighten away an attacker, reach a large audience during a speech, etc.)

During training, you need to train intensely during the time with your partner, then turn immediately carefree when your teacher is showing a technique or speaking. In fact, I think it is important for a teacher to break the intensity of the paired students by talking, telling stories, explaining things, telling jokes, whatever. People tend to get too "wound up" thinking, "If I don't train intensely, I will never get good." In fact, if you always train intensely, you will NEVER get good in my opinion.

A teacher who interrupts class, just when you are "getting into the technique" is not a bad teacher. In fact, it is a sign of a very good teacher who is trying to teach you a skill set without you knowing it.

If you train properly, these skills of kiai and shinkengata will begin to manifest. No need to do anything more than that.


Or, you can view the whole link here: http://www.kutaki.org/modules/newbb/...86&forum=2

Hope this helps. Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-03-2004, 09:46 AM   #26
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
In response to Ryo:

One of the things I had difficulty accepting was your claim that almost all Ninja were Samurai. I know you explained the whole "owning ones land makes one Samurai because Samurai own there own land" but Samurai may be the wrong term to use since "Samurai" is a title for the officers of Lords.

Uhhh... sorry, but no.

'Samurai' was a social class during the Kamakura Period (1200) on. There was really nothing else to it than that, despite a lot of the romanticizing historical revisionism that has been bandied about.

'Samurai' were the military class in feudal Japan, and included individuals ranging from jizamurai (rural samurai), samurai officers (urban samurai), daimyo (regional lords), and the shogun (military ruler of Japan). There were many ranks within the class itself. And, it was this social class that "owned" all the land in Japan --- only members of the samurai class were land-owners, even merchants could not own land.

Records of individuals in Iga and Koga indicate that they were a class of weapon-carrying land-owners. Thus, samurai --- although, technically speaking, most were probably jizamurai. During the Edo Period, the ninja especially rose in prestige serving under the Tokugawa Shogunate.

The meaning of Samurai is "to serve", and Ninja didn't really serve any Lords.

Uhhhh... yeah, they did. Or, what do you think guys like Momochi Sandayu and Hattori Hanzo were??

Although, to be fair, most of the "lords" the ninja served were heads of Iga and Koga families. In addition, the Iga and Koga ninja groups sold their skills to many lords from other regions on a case-by-case basis (i.e., mercenary-style like the Swiss pikemen), but retained no permanent fealty.

Now I can see some Ronin Being Ninja

A Roning wouldn't make a very good "Ninja", as the entire point of Ninpo was to protect one's family and community --- a Ronin was a "wave man", and had neither.

and some Ninja having Side Identities as Samurai (among others), so in that sense I can agree with some Ninja being Samurai.

Sorry, but records show that most were samurai --- at least the ones from Iga and Koga. Although, no doubt, ninja serving in an espionage capacity also had alternate "identities" that may or may not have been samurai.

As for the role that the Ninja played, I'm not quite sure why you don't accept the role of the "Freedom Fighter". I mean, Ninja played many roles through out history; The Freedom Fighter, the Assasin, The Yamabushi, and a host of others.

Because, contrary to what Hayes has written in the past, the ninja were not some minority of "persecuted" underdogs. Particularly on the basis of religious persecution, which is one of the most ridiculous claims of all, when historical evidence is taken into account.

With the exception of Oda Nobunaga's invasion of Iga and Koga, the ninja seemed to have been pretty much left alone for most of Japanese history.

You know, there is a lot of truth to Steven K. Hayes words, even though most people may not accept do to ignorance or what ever else.

I'm sorry this might be upsetting your preconceptions about history, but Hayes has retracted a lot of the claims in his earlier books --- including the "persecuted peasant underdog" angle. The simple truth is that it just doesn't align with actual history --- there are no records of any of this.

The term "Assasin" has become a desease that Ninpoka are trying to rid them selves of.

Well, that's another problem as well. The simple truth is, as Stephen Turnbull has pointed out, that there just isn't much evidence of many "ninja assassinations" in Japanese history. It just really didn't seem to be their forte --- as opposed to siege warfare, espionage, and reconaissance.

Hatsumi-sensei has even commented many times of the Ninja historicly fighting for peace and protecting those who can not protect them selves.

I would ask you to put the words of Soke into context (i.e., citation) before claiming them as your own to back up your position.

Also, as for the "Breathing exercise", while it is practiced in Chi Gung, it is also practiced in Budo Ninpo Taijutsu aswell. Everthing done in the art of Ninjutsu is acompanied with proper breathing for maximum efficiancy.
Ninpoka are infact incouraged to use the "Art of breathing" in everything they do through out there daily life.


Ummm.... sorry, but Chi Gung is a Chinese art. Ninpo is not. Just because proper breathing is emphasized in Budo Taijutsu, doesn't mean Chi Gung is being taught. Proper breathing is emphasized in many martial traditions.

I also refer you to the article by Ben Cole that I posted above.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-03-2004, 07:20 PM   #27
kitsunepixie
Foot Soldier
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Hoosierland
Posts: 125
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryo
Oh, and a note to kitsunepixie; don't expect Japanese to have acurate knowledge on Ninja. Well, not most of them, anyway. Ninja wasn't a big aspect in Japanese history, and what little information on Ninja that you would find in a typical Japan history book tend to favour Samurai, making Ninja look like the sneaky villians of Japan. It's like asuming that Americans know there country's history inside and out acuratly, even the little details that would normaly be over looked.

You probably know this already, though.
Yeah, I was just mentioning it as a quirk to put things into perspective. I've been studying Japanese for most of my life have lived over there quite some time, so I consider myself relatively informed about many things Japanese.

Ninja are looked at over there just as they are here: mysterious and intriguing, and I've heard people you wouldn't expect (such as professors at conservative universities) say things like, "I wish I were Ninja so I could hide in trees and spy on my students!" Maybe like the people nowadays who say, "I wish I were a pirate so I could dress all sexy, steal ships, and get booty!" after watching Johnny Depp swagger around with eyeliner on (not that I'm complaining, mind you ). And we know that misconceptions abound about them as well.
__________________
"Are you for good, or for awesome?" - Strong Bad
"Do you deny me fresh-maker!?" - Happy Noodle Boy
Vote Leonardo for President 2004
kitsunepixie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-09-2004, 09:33 AM   #28
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Ninja are looked at over there just as they are here: mysterious and intriguing, and I've heard people you wouldn't expect (such as professors at conservative universities) say things like, "I wish I were Ninja so I could hide in trees and spy on my students!"

Yup.

The simple truth is that all these "stereotypes" and "false images" people have concerning ninja originated in Japan itself (somewhat similar to the conceptions Americans have concerning "cowboys"). A lot of dramatic fiction and literature was made in the Edo Period (1603 - 1867) revolving around ninja characters, and this was intensified during the Meiji Period.

By no means is it just a "Western" thing.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-15-2004, 12:38 PM   #29
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
hrmm

A good article about ninja history:

http://www.bujinkanwakodojo.com/bwd_...u_history.html

Enjoy.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:30 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.