The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > 4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion

Notices

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 06-27-2004, 01:03 AM   #1
Jarrah White
Banned
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 2,394
Secret Origins review by the Australians.

It's been a long wait, but the Secret Origins episodes have finally been aired on Australian soils. Just a reminder to you all, I chose to wait till this show aired, then say what I thought of it, and to prove it click HERE. It is now 109 days since I posted that, and now that I've seen the episode I will review it. My fellow Australians can feel free to follow suit posting up their reviews. For now, here's mine, it is below in blue.

Where to begin... Where to begin...

(sigh) Alas, I had hoped it wouldn't have to be this way, I really did. But no matter how open-minded I was, for me this three-part episode provided me with little enjoyment. I will say it explains alittle, just alittle, like why Hamato Yoshi was targeted by The Shredder. But Alas, Yoshi just being a Guardian has stripped him of that heroism he had in the comics, defending the honour of the woman he loved from the hands of Oruko Nagi. Also, a few things are yet to be explained, mainly how did the Utroms get from Japan to America? What are these Shredder clones really? I remember Laird quoting on the DVD that 'In the second season we'll learn the secret origin of the sword of tengu, and it's a cool secret origin'. This is just me speeking my mind but I found the sword's origin quite dull actually, I was hoping the sword began as, I don't know, a weapon of peace created by the Utroms. A weapon used to bring justice in the universe, maybe used in a fight against the Tricerations, but only to fall into Shredder's evil hands and become a weapon of mass destruction. Instead, all we learn is it was created using metal from the Utrom crashsite, that's about it. Finally, it is time to talk about The Shredder himself, or should I say Krang dressed as The Shredder himself. I didn't find his origin interesting. The Mirage comics featured a small boy called Oruko Saki, overcome with grief from the loss of his older brother. The Foot Clan took him under their wing and trained him how to become a warrior. He rose in the ranks quickly and Saki, now called The Shredder, slaughtered the killer of his brother along with his wife. Like Yoshi, Shredder has been stripped of who the comics made him to be. And here they've just made Shredder another Krang, a deranged war criminal. He even has the same image, which I find (And this is my verdict from watching the episode) downright pathectic. Not only have they taken away what made Saki become The Shredder, they have taken away what made Shredder a warrior. He doesn't fight in his true form, he fights from the controls of an exo suit. Of sure he can do plenty of damage with this suit, but outside it he is a threat to no one (Except maybe other Utroms). It's alot like a tank driver, behind the wheel of this heavily armoured vehicle he can crush everything in his way. But outside this assault vehicle he's vulerable to lethal gun shot wounds, aircraft missiles, etc, etc. It's the same case with Shredder, in his true form he is at the mercy of creatures larger than he is. He isn't a warrior, he's just a little blob living inside a body, a body that he relies on to fight with. Loose his body and what is he? Exactly. And the concept of seeing this alien stick to Raphael's face took the biscuit, a classic example of his weakness. Not only do I find the idea of Shredder turning out to be a Utrom moronic, but I also find it highly unnessacary. There was nothing to convince us that Shredder was tied to the Utroms in Season 1, in fact the evidence presented in that season suggested the opposite; that Shredder was the least likely person to turn out to be an alien, when you look at everything that points against it, Shredder being able to drink, the appearence of his clones, the Guardians believing he died. The only thing that was concrete was the fact that he was the Utroms arch enemy. And for all we knew he could have been a man trying to rid the world of these aliens, aliens who were accidentally/deliberately responsible for the death of his brother. As for him getting up and picking up his head, would there not have been a possibility that his soul lived on through the armour? Laird told me two reasons why they made Shredder a Utrom was to tie him to the turtles' origin and so they could do the decapitation scene on Saturday morning TV. Sorry, but I am not convinced: The old toon perfectly tied Shredder to the turtles' origin, for it was he who dropped that ooze on them, and the old toon was able to keep him in the human race. And as for not being able to do the decapitation scene, I don't no about you Americans, but the Australian network shows graphic violence on the television all the time. Sometimes fictional, like cartoon violence, othertimes it's often reality violence, but most of the time it is potentually lethal. Just weeks ago I saw some poor fellow being brutally decapitated with a Machete. Why is it right to show reality beheadings but wrong to show cartoon beheadings? Finally, I see Shredder's red and black skin colour a poor excuse to colour Krang as Darth Maul. The new Shredder may have the superior armour, but the Mirage Shredder has the superior origin.

Sad to say, I have begun to like this series, the series that made me a turtle fan in the first place, less. Sad really. What next? What other Mirage characters are gonna be miss-used and miss-potrailed and stripped of what the comics what them? Is April O’Neil going to turn out to be a shape-shifting blob of slime that ‘resembles’ Lurch from the image comics? Maybe there are no mutant turtles, maybe each of them is an Utrom and we don’t know it. I know alot of you are fine with the idea of Shredder being an alien, I have no problem with you liking it. But as you can clearly see in my review, I don't like the idea. To me the idea of making Shredder’s character turning out to be a Utrom is a pathetic as say, the idea of changing James Bond’s gender to female. As such, I don't want to see the Red Utrom anywhere outside the new toon, much like Peter Laird not wanting to see Venus anywhere outside the Next Mutation series. I won’t go on, but here’s what I will say, if you want a Utrom samurai in a TV show based on a comic book, I strongly suggest invent one.


Just so I'm not being byassed, the Secret Origins episodes did have a few nice touches, like Krang's return and April's news reporters disguise. Spider Baxter rocks!


(Pants) Glad I got that off my chest, anyone else from downunder wanna contribute?
Jarrah White is offline  
 


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:55 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.