The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-26-2008, 01:04 PM   #41
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
I won't deny that another 20 minutes or so of material making us swallow the monster/wacky bonanza thrust upon us would have been beneficial to the film... but it's still back asswards.

It's like... let's make Batman Begins Part 7. But let's make it with Guidomaxius, who needs to trap 20 demon bats in order to stop a global apocalypse. Between Robin burping and Batman jumping in Robin's arms when a particularly scary bat demon surprises them, they save the day.

No, it was just a flat-out wrong approach to the source material. Is it better than TMNT 2 and 3? Yes. Is it kind of approaching TMNT 1, even in a sideways, diluted kind of way? Mm, I can see that to some degree in the side-stories of TMNT Part 4, sure (the family story bits).

But it's a far effing cry from anything resembling a proper comic book adaptation of the source material.
Why? If you are strictly basing your argument on story content, then the storyline for TMNT, which at its heart is nothing more then your standard villain-gathers-objects-to-obtain-power comic storyline, easily fits into the world created in the original Mirage comics.

Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.


As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued, mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.




Quote:
There's every reason. It's not fair, it's not right, and it's a shame that the beancounters can't see the forest for the trees (meaning, can't see the Mirage source material in spite of the made-for-children rubbish it spawned).
I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon, which leads us into the next point...



Quote:
They do now. But at some point they still had to go from Point A to Point B. At some point Spider-Man crossed over from old children's cartoons with a campy theme song to a relatively mature movie... what are the real differences here?

A guy of Sam Raimi's caliber. Marvel behind him. People with clout, people able to do exactly the movie they wanted to do, with a keen understanding and respect of the source material.
Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT, those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned. And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics. Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.

Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon), it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?), it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.

Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.


If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 01:06 PM   #42
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
The more I think about it, the less I have to give up on. We'd probably know more if Murph hadn't been silenced under threat of 'cement shoes' from 4Kids and Imagi.
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 02:14 PM   #43
Noah'Dib
Mouser
 
Noah'Dib's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: San Antonio, TX
Posts: 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr._Mutant_Man View Post
I'm mostly concerned with the comic book continuing. I heard they thought of ending Tales of the TMNT, just when I started to read it.

As long as the comics and hopefully the trades keep coming, I think I'd be pretty much content.
Agreed. I'm first and foremost for the comics. As for the movie and the dung I'm apparantly wading through, I have to say they WILL make one. It may not be anytime soon, but if hollywood could bring Rocky & Indiana Jones out of retirement, they could (and will) make another TMNT. It just might be some time. Hey, it only took 2 1/2 decades for Indy to come back.
Noah'Dib is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 05:40 PM   #44
Dr. Doom
Allons-y!
 
Dr. Doom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Castle Doom
Posts: 4,535
I really think everyone here overestimates just how many dedicated adult TMNT fans there are out there. Let's be honest, a large portion of our population here on the Technodrome has the maturity level, people skills, and grip on reality of a 5 year old as it is. TMNT thrives on the younder audience, and that's why we get what we do. I don't understand why people can't comprehend the fact that they need to market this stuff to kids in order to have any sort of success at all. There's no way TMNT could be at the same level as Spider-Man or Batman, because when it comes down to it, things like that are just frankly more grounded in reality and easier to take seriously than a property about 4 giant turtles who practice a somewhat bastardized form of martial arts.

Don't get me wrong, I love TMNT just as much as the next sane person here, and just like many others here, I'd love the makers of a film to take the source material just as seriosuly as I do and give me something that I can appreciate above anything else as an adult, but I know what TMNT is, and I know what we are. We're not the juggernaut of untapped financial output that people here seem to think we are. We're a cult following. You can throw Transformers at me if you want, and yes, that's coming from a similar place, but it's got a completely different angle, and one that's a lot easier for studios and producers to market towards people today in order to make it a bazillion dollar franchise, especially when you can get car companies involved. Audiences love cool cars and **** blowing up and giant robots who act like ****ing retards, so there you have it's success. TMNT is not the kind of property that can get the same reaction, and frankly I don't want TMNT to get taken in the direction that Transformers did, because that movie ****ing sucked. We'd end up with a movie about teenagers who discover the Turtles in a crashed meteorite and we'd then proceed to be regaled with humans talking to each other for 90 minutes while the 4 guys danced around in the background like assholes and advertised soft drinks while simultaneously offending any intelligent people who happened to be watching such a monstrosity.

I for one thought TMNT was a great film, despite its shortcomings, because it gave us a taste of the franchise on the big screen and in a large, epic scale once again. That really made me happy, I think Kevin did a great job. But it got there because the new cartoon was something that 4Kids and playmates realized they could direct at kids once again and make money that way. If the franchise didn't have that appeal, we would have never gotten the 2K3 cartoon in the first place and the last taste of TMNT media outside of volume 4 we would have had would be The Next Mutation, and everyone would still be stuck on how awful that was with the exception of a few lunatics who touch themselves to Venus' hawt plastron bumps.

In short, don't hold your breath for the franchise to be taken as seriously as we all want it to be, because while we're certainly a part of why any of this is possible, we're not the bulk of it. That's the parents who bring their kids to the movie and go buy them the action figures and happy meal toys and party favors and fruit snacks afterwards. They're the bread and butter. I'd love to see another movie in theaters, and I guess it's not impossible, but they don't stand to make like OMGWTF summer blockbuster money from it even as a kids' film, much less as a nod to the dedicated cult following who severely overestimate their significance to the people who see TMNT only as something to make money off of.
__________________

Last edited by Dr. Doom; 02-29-2008 at 01:08 PM.
Dr. Doom is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 07:05 PM   #45
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
I'm not exactly sure. When I saw TMNT there weren't any children in the theater. The theater consisted of adult fans, teenage fans, and young teens who are riding the "oldschool stuff is cool" fad that's still going on right now who wanted to see what exactly they were wearing on their t-shirts at school the other day.

I know plenty of children saw the movie. I'm glad they did! However, I think being limited to PG (rather than allowing themselves to slip into a low PG-13) and having runtime restraints that caused some neat things to be cut for time really killed some of the things that would've kept the older fans more interested so they would walk out of the theater saying "Okay, so it wasn't like the OT but it was still pretty cool" rather than going "gawd t3h sux no beebop nad roxteddy!!!11" and "ware iz buhnilla ice?!?!!!1"

Though a lot of people are looking for TMNT 1990 to happen all over again, I can't speak for all of them. I just think that a little more creative freedom would make it more interesting for older viewers while not having to abandon the kiddie aspect of the franchise. While I know Kevin and crew tried their hardest to give both crowds what they wanted, they didn't get enough creative freedom MPAA-wise and runtime-wise to allow that to happen and, in the end, a lot of the older viewers felt abandoned.

Personally speaking, though, I wouldn't mind seeing TMNT movies that had stylistic similarities to Issue 18 or Issue 41 (both Vol. 1) or Archie TMNT 42 through 44. Maybe a mixture of those writing styles, even! The Vol. 1 stuff could easily be tweaked in tiny places to fit PG by MPAA standards and TMNT Adventures was written toward children in the first place!

Don't get confused, though. I'm not asking for a direct rip of those stories. I'm just talking about the general writing style and how everything was depicted. I think those are good examples of stories that TMNT fans of different ages can more easily enjoy without having to give up any creative freedoms. Maybe if those and others like them were used as general examples, a movie that can be enjoyed equally by people of all ages can enjoy could more easily be created while keeping WB and the MPAA happy.

Last edited by Kendamu; 02-26-2008 at 07:06 PM. Reason: in ur post, fixin some codes
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 07:31 PM   #46
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.
Actually no... Peter Laird has pretty much un-canonized every story that didn't involve... Peter Laird.

In any case I see the point you're trying to make (and there's been awesome stories with "oddities" like time travel and magic and such)... but the forest you're not seeing for the trees is that these stories were told straight out. No gimmicks, no Turtles jumping into each others' arms, no blatant kid/toy-pandering moments or cringe-worthy dialogue.

Quote:
As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued,
Yeah, you and I pretty much didn't watch the same movie. No offense.

Quote:
mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.
Meh, I had no problem with Dancing Evil Parker in the context of the films, but whatever. I'm not a Spider-Man fan so I don't judge.

Quote:
I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon,
That's... crazy. First of all, the "mainstream public" has no idea the TMNT comics even exist for it to have somehow been imaginarily "replaced" by the cartoons. Second... why should they? Until there is a mainstream, proper comic book adaptation of the source material, the Mirage comics will never have any mainstream public appeal.

Quote:
Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT,
This is much ado about nothing. The credibility was earned.

Quote:
those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned.
Do they? You go up to most kids and go "Superman!" and they're probably thinking about that boring movie with the guy doing the Hackman impression, or Smallville, not comic books.

But you're kind of going on a tangent here.

Quote:
And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics.
Much ado about nothing. Just because the last and most prevalent thing in the media has been one thing (kid fluff) doesn't mean TMNT as a franchise needs to be a slave to it indefinitely. Did anyone know who the eff the Crow was before the Brandon Lee movie? Hellboy, before... Hellboy? Did it matter who or what they were before?

A proper TMNT movie shouldn't concern itself with any existing vestige of the fandom apart from the comic fans themselves , and even then they shouldn't go out of their way to give those comic fans a handjob... just concern themselves with doing a proper movie -- reboot, total clean page -- in the same spirit and grit of those original TMNT comics with whatever artistic flair (such as directors with a vision do when they're allowed to go balls-out) they want to add to the mix.

Better to do this than continue TPTB's never-ending perpetual cycle of putting TMNT crap on the screen that kids keep outgrowing. And it's not hard... they just need to look to the comics, or attempt something in that vein.

It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.

Quote:
Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.
Well that's a pretty broad statement... I'm pretty sure the millions and millions of readers of Spider-Man over the past some-odd decades would probably beg the differ. I'm certain the movie did kick Spider-Man "awareness" up to the Nth degree, sure. But Hellboy? It was a niche comic with a niche following that spawned a movie with a modest success... seemed about relative to me.

Quote:
Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon),
F***'em. Let them sate their nostalgia for the children's cartoons on DVD.

Quote:
it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?),
F***'em, too. It's not the TMNT's fault said people are uneducated about the Turtles' creation as a mature enough comic book.

Quote:
it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.
Eh, what? I don't think we're talking apples to apples anymore.

Quote:
Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.
*cough**box office**cough*

Quote:
If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.
Isn't that kind of like sitting someone in a chair, spinning them around until they're so dizzy they can't see, then expecting them to walk a straight line?

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-26-2008 at 08:03 PM.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 07:42 PM   #47
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr. Doom View Post
I really think everyone here overestimates just how many dedicated adult TMNT fans there are out there.
A proper comic book TMNT adapation on the big screen would make adult TMNT fans.

But TMNT Part 4 set any hope of that motion back another 10 years, at least.

Quote:
Let's be honest, a large portion of our population here on the Technodrome has the maturity level, people skills, and grip on reality of a 5 year old as it is.
How true. Which is why they really shouldn't bother themselves with any of the existing fandom -- 99% of TMNT fans will see any TMNT movie that they put out there anyway... so why not finally make one that's true to the source material?
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 08:06 PM   #48
Dr. Doom
Allons-y!
 
Dr. Doom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Castle Doom
Posts: 4,535
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
A proper comic book TMNT adapation on the big screen would make adult TMNT fans.
Who's to say they'd go see it in the first place if they weren't already fans? Marketing can only do so much, and I'm not confident that TMNT could be marketed well to adults who aren't already interested in it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
How true. Which is why they really shouldn't bother themselves with any of the existing fandom -- 99% of TMNT fans will see any TMNT movie that they put out there anyway... so why not finally make one that's true to the source material?
Why would they have to if the fans will just go see whatever anyways?
__________________
Dr. Doom is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 08:14 PM   #49
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr. Doom View Post
Who's to say they'd go see it in the first place if they weren't already fans? Marketing can only do so much,
Marketing can do plenty. The campaigns for 300 and Cloverfield made people go crazy for those movies without knowing much about them at all.

A broad example, I know.

Quote:
and I'm not confident that TMNT could be marketed well to adults who aren't already interested in it.
It's a bit of a challenge, granted, and it's moot anyway... if the first TMNT trilogy (moreso the latter two movies), NT:TNM, and the first cartoon and general "Turtlemania!" craze of the late 80s and early 90s kind of hammered into pop culture this nail of "TMNT is for Kids"... in the 10 years or so between then and TMNT Part 4, that nail got loosened a little bit. New generations of kids had come and gone, with only old-timers like you and I really having any memory of those days (and we're barely even in the target demographic of films at large anymore). So what do they do? Rather than seize the opportunity to let the nail finally fall out and start fresh or pull it out, they grab a hammer and nail it back down with TMNT Part 4... so we're back to the mass media idea of "TMNT is for Kids" for another decade or so.

And before anyone cites the 4Kids cartoon (which is good, and gets about as much mileage out of comic book stories as you can in, well, a children's cartoon... but let's not fool ourselves into thinking it's anything but)... look at the brand label itself. 4Kids. Need I say more?

Quote:
Why would they have to if the fans will just go see whatever anyways?
Well, to touch on only one thing, because one would hope they'd learn from history. They've tried to dumb down the Turtles for toddlers and tweens, and offer it up as such... yet kids keep outgrowing it, forcing them to perpetuate this never-ending, self-destructive cycle of cashing in on one generation of kiddies and tykes, then putting it on ice after it fails, then going after another generation of kiddies and tykes... who all end up inevitably outgrowing it. Why do this over and over again, when they can attempt to do something that folks don't need to outgrow? Something that is... actually somewhat mature? I'd agree it's a stretch, except for the simple fact that the TMNT were created as a mature comic book, day one.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 09:28 PM   #50
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr. Doom View Post

Don't get me wrong, I love TMNT just as much as the next sane person here, and just like many others here, I'd love the makers of a film to take the source material just as seriosuly as I do and give me something that I can appreciate above anything else as an adult, but I know what TMNT is, and I know what we are. We're not the juggernaut of untapped financial output that people here seem to think we are. We're a cult following. You can throw Transformers at me if you want, and yes, that's coming from a similar place, but it's got a completely different angle, and one that's a lot easier for studios and producers to market towards people today in order to make it a bazillion dollar franchise, especially when you can get car companies involved. Audiences love cool cars and **** blowing up and giant robots who act like ****ing retards, so there you have it's success. TMNT is not the kind of property that can get the same reaction, and frankly I don't want TMNT to get taken in the direction that Transformers did, because that movie ****ing sucked. We'd end up with a movie about teenagers who discover the Turtles in a crashed meteorite and be we'd then proceed to be regailed with humans talking to each other for 90 minutes while the 4 guys danced around in the background like assholes and advtertised soft drinks while simultaniously offending any intelligent people who happened to be watching such a monstrosity.
There is no shame in cashing in on nostalgia, all those kids that grew up on the old cartoon are anywhere between their late teens to early thirties, a prime target audience, it was those same nostalgic Transformer fans that went to go watch that movie 5-6 times, there are plenty of old ninja turtle fans to take advantage of (we are talking about 5-6 billion dollar franchise). As for the casual fan who could care less about the ninja turtles, you need hype and spectacle to get those people to even remotely care about a TMNT based movie, and the current movie had neither of these.



Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post

Yeah, you and I pretty much didn't watch the same movie. No offense.
I guess not, no offense taken.

Quote:
Meh, I had no problem with Dancing Evil Parker in the context of the films, but whatever. I'm not a Spider-Man fan so I don't judge.
I guess it makes perfect sense that evil impulses would cause one to have the urge to boogie down.


Quote:
That's... crazy. First of all, the "mainstream public" has no idea the TMNT comics even exist for it to have somehow been imaginarily "replaced" by the cartoons. Second... why should they? Until there is a mainstream, proper comic book adaptation of the source material, the Mirage comics will never have any mainstream public appeal.
You're right, the Mirage comics never had mainstream appeal, only the cartoon.




Quote:
Do they? You go up to most kids and go "Superman!" and they're probably thinking about that boring movie with the guy doing the Hackman impression, or Smallville, not comic books.
So you are saying kids don't know that Superman is based on a comicbook character, un-huh, well try asking any adult on the street who characthers like Spider-Man, Batman, Superman are, I qurantee you they will tell you they are comicbook characters, ask the average adult on the street who the ninja turtles are they will tell you they are cartoon/videogame characters.




Quote:
But you're kind of going on a tangent here.

You asked what the difference was between Spider-Man making the jump from campy cartoons to relatively mature movies, asked and answered.


Quote:
Much ado about nothing. Just because the last and most prevalent thing in the media has been one thing (kid fluff) doesn't mean TMNT as a franchise needs to be a slave to it indefinitely. Did anyone know who the eff the Crow was before the Brandon Lee movie? Hellboy, before... Hellboy?
It's not about awareness, comics like the Crow and Hellboy have it easy, since they are not competing against more popular alternate versions of themselves, they just had the comics.




Quote:
It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.
I have no problem with seeing a more faithful adaption of the old comics brought to big screen, and I would hope it would succeed, but just don't act surprise if gets ripped apart by the older cartoon fans and flops because it's not what most people are accustomed to when comes to the ninja turtles.



Quote:
Well that's a pretty broad statement... I'm pretty sure the millions and millions of readers of Spider-Man over the past some-odd decades would probably beg the differ. I'm certain the movie did kick Spider-Man "awareness" up to the Nth degree, sure. But Hellboy? It was a niche comic with a niche following that spawned a movie with a modest success... seemed about relative to me.

umm, I believe you misread me, I said "never".


Quote:
F***'em. Let them sate their nostalgia for the children's cartoons on DVD.
Heh, I'm pretty sure there are old cartoon fans saying the same thing about comic readers, "F***'em, let them reread their old comics, the 80's cartoon is the only version that matters".

Quote:
Eh, what? I don't think we're talking apples to apples anymore.
Just using HP to illustrate the difference between the more kid friendly first book with the last one where everyone is getting killed off, as the books progressively got darker, imagine if they went from one extreme to another.


Quote:
*cough**box office**cough*
Yes, there are those within Imagi/Warner Bros who believe TMNT was too dark and serious and it had a negative effect on the boxoffice, and that the sequel should be more lighter and silly, I'm glad we can agree on this.




Quote:
Isn't that kind of like sitting someone in a chair, spinning them around until they're so dizzy they can't see, then expecting them to walk a straight line?
You would be surprise how little it would take to please fans of the old cartoon, I don't see the harm in acknowledging the fans who, like it or not, help to keep the ninja turtles alive today.


Quote:

It's a bit of a challenge, granted, and it's moot anyway... if the first TMNT trilogy (moreso the latter two movies), NT:TNM, and the first cartoon and general "Turtlemania!" craze of the late 80s and early 90s kind of hammered into pop culture this nail of "TMNT is for Kids"... in the 10 years or so between then and TMNT Part 4, that nail got loosened a little bit.
Loosened? how, because they were off the radar? I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!". And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.

Last edited by Dragon Turtle; 02-26-2008 at 09:54 PM.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 09:57 PM   #51
Coola Yagami
Overlord
 
Coola Yagami's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 15,742
Yo Andrew, you kinda forgot all the weird 'what were they smokin' stories Eastman and Laird did. I know that after Return to New York, the series went to 'guest-writers' hell before the comic got more serious with City at War, but you forgot the stories that took place in between the Turtles facing Shredder and Return to New York.

All the stories about Nobody, Leatherhead, Rennet, the Passing, the Kirby cyrstal Don Special, Justice Force and such were all extremely weird and wacky, especially yhe Rennet ones. And c'mon... in Return to New York did you ever expect the TMNT to side with a Triceraton to take down the Foot.. and to run into 3 weird-as-all-hell Shredder clones?

I agree that the 13 monsters story was out of left field, and in my opnion didn't really have any business in the movies, but yeah... the turtles in the comics was full of crazy stuff too. We've seen the TMNT in New York as is, maybe in a new movie we should see some Triceraton invasion stuff...
Coola Yagami is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 11:23 PM   #52
Jo Dawn
Inactive Moderator
 
Jo Dawn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Authority On All Things Don
Posts: 5,190
Quote:
It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.
Totally. Agreed.

Please!! It DOES deserve it. I wish the actual TMNT would have a chance to shine. In the right hands, and done in the right way, it would be HUGE. TMNT doesn't have to be silly. It can be a cool movie. TMNT isn't for kids. Heck, not all kids NOW like the old toon. A 6 year old told me last Sunday that he hates the old toon because it's too silly. He likes the new toon (not much better) or the comics or first movie.

And not all people in that age range for the old toon WANT to see it ever again.

My plea to those that are in charge... Just give the REAL TMNT a chance.
__________________
Jo Dawn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 11:28 PM   #53
Jo Dawn
Inactive Moderator
 
Jo Dawn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Authority On All Things Don
Posts: 5,190
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
Loosened? how, because they were off the radar? I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!". And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.
Uh, not really. Not around here, at least. People were kinda hoping for more. Like, going away from old toon tendencies.

...though I guess that explains why they can't sell an old toon DVD for anything here, either.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post


There is no reason why TMNT can't be taken serious, but I wouldn't compare TMNT with Batman or Spider-Man, those franchises have far more mainstream credibility then TMNT.
Well, we have the old toon to blame for that, don't we? It's kinda like they sold their soul for the one big hit and it's gonna haunt them forever by ruining any chance they had to BE credible. Why do we think TMNT isn't credible? I'd say if we got rid of the kiddie stigma, it'd be quite easy.

Quote:
I disagree, while TMNT was not on the same level of maturity as the old Mirage comics it was hardly a throwback to the old cartoons or movies, in terms of tone it was more serious then the previous movies (too serious according to some), only the lack of violence and action is what kept TMNT a kid friendly PG movie.
It was in no way too serious. When I went to see it people were disappointed with how silly it was and wanted a more serious tone. No one laughed. They left and I heard whispers about how it had 'regressed'.
__________________
Jo Dawn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 11:44 PM   #54
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jo Dawn View Post
Uh, not really. Not around here, at least. People were kinda hoping for more. Like, going away from old toon tendencies.
Mostly on sites dedicated to following movies.

Quote:
It was in no way too serious. When I went to see it people were disappointed with how silly it was and wanted a more serious tone. No one laughed. They left and I heard whispers about how it had 'regressed'.
And I've read and heard opinions to the contrary,"not enough pizza and cowabunga" and "it lacks the goofy charm of the originals", that pretty much balances it out.

Last edited by Dragon Turtle; 02-26-2008 at 11:52 PM.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-26-2008, 11:52 PM   #55
Jo Dawn
Inactive Moderator
 
Jo Dawn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Authority On All Things Don
Posts: 5,190
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
Mostly on sites dedicated to following movies.
Yeah, but what about real people that actually went to see the movie? All that I heard was that they wanted away from kiddie and more adult. And I heard that with my own ears. People can type what they want, but I'll let what I know for a fact by experiencing, and the obvious drop in the box office at week 2, after people actually saw it.

They really need to give the real TMNT a chance now. Though I think it's too late to salvage, they have nothing to lose. And it would be admirable if they made the movie that they really wanted to make. Make the movie for them, and if it bombs, then at least they had the balls to try it.
__________________
Jo Dawn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 12:00 AM   #56
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
There is no shame in cashing in on nostalgia, all those kids that grew up on the old cartoon are anywhere between their late teens to early thirties, a prime target audience, it was those same nostalgic Transformer fans that went to go watch that movie 5-6 times,
I'm not entirely convinced those people don't represent maybe, at best, 5-10% (and I think I'm being extremely optomistic, even assuming the active membership of this board only represents 5% of the fans out there) of the overall box office take. The other 90-95%? Young teens oblivious to Transformers that saw transforming robot action, the guy from Even Stevens, and slick trailers and went, "Whoa, awesome!" Hell, if I was like 15ish, I might just go see it because of Megan Fox's ass in the trailers.

But yeah, anytime you put the names "Spielburg" and "Bay" on the table at the same time, you're not exactly examining your garden variety movie.

Quote:
there are plenty of old ninja turtle fans to take advantage of (we are talking about 5-6 billion dollar franchise).
OK, but can you quantify that dollar amount into how much longtime TMNT fans like you and I actually brought to the table in that? I suspect only a fraction. A small fraction.

Quote:
As for the casual fan who could care less about the ninja turtles, you need hype and spectacle to get those people to even remotely care about a TMNT based movie, and the current movie had neither of these.
You're absolutely right, but in the case of this movie, you might have seen a significant boost in the opening weekend before word-of-mouth spread around about, "You guys fooled me! It was just a toddler affair!" (by this, I mean the regular movie-going public, not toddlers, tweens, or existing TMNT fans)... but that's about it.

Quote:
I guess it makes perfect sense that evil impulses would cause one to have the urge to boogie down.
No strong feelings on the Spidey dance either way. It could go or it could stay, but it seemed somewhat in line with Spidey II's "Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head." But whatever.

Quote:
You're right, the Mirage comics never had mainstream appeal, only the cartoon.
Won't argue that. But neither did material like the Sin City comics, the 300 comics, Hellboy comics, Crow comics, etc., etc..

Quote:
So you are saying kids don't know that Superman is based on a comicbook character,
Kids about 10-15ish, sure.

Quote:
un-huh, well try asking any adult on the street who characthers like Spider-Man, Batman, Superman are, I qurantee you they will tell you they are comicbook characters,
I wasn't talking about adults.

Quote:
ask the average adult on the street who the ninja turtles are they will tell you they are cartoon/videogame characters.
Probably right. The name of the game is opening eyes... but again, TMNT Part 4 set the clock back on that one a good long while, so forget about it.

Quote:
You asked what the difference was between Spider-Man making the jump from campy cartoons to relatively mature movies, asked and answered.
Oh, you're right. Sorry.

Quote:
It's not about awareness, comics like the Crow and Hellboy have it easy, since they are not competing against more popular alternate versions of themselves, they just had the comics.
True.

Quote:
I have no problem with seeing a more faithful adaption of the old comics brought to big screen, and I would hope it would succeed, but just don't act surprise if gets ripped apart by the older cartoon fans
All 30 of the fanatical ones that congregate here? I can live with that. I think you can, too.

Quote:
and flops because it's not what most people are accustomed to when comes to the ninja turtles.
I think we're doing a bit of a dance here. When I'm envisioning a successful TMNT comic book adaptation of the comics on the big screen... I'm not factoring in any of the people that are "accustomed" to one mass media kid-fluff incarnation or another -- it will live or die by the hype it generates in being entirely its own beast.

And again (and again), this can only happen in a vacuum. TMNT -- at least in the mass media -- needs to go into a kind of ice age for a while, let memories of "Cowabungas" and camp and all that fade into a generation that isn't going to be filling the majority of seats anyway. TMNT Part 4 retarded that back a bit... but we can always hope for another 10, 12 years down the road again.

*sigh*

Quote:
umm, I believe you misread me, I said "never".
Then I apologize again. Just running down the line here.

Quote:
Heh, I'm pretty sure there are old cartoon fans saying the same thing about comic readers, "F***'em, let them reread their old comics, the 80's cartoon is the only version that matters".
Oh, those 30 again? They ought to sit down.

Quote:
Just using HP to illustrate the difference between the more kid friendly first book with the last one where everyone is getting killed off, as the books progressively got darker, imagine if they went from one extreme to another.
Thus the need for an ice age. Well, a second ice age... the first one just ended up producing kiddy crap again.

Quote:
Yes, there are those within Imagi/Warner Bros who believe TMNT was too dark and serious and it had a negative effect on the boxoffice, and that the sequel should be more lighter and silly, I'm glad we can agree on this.
When you phrase it like that, yes. The box office numbers came in weekend #2, I absolutely believe they played a bit of "OK, whodunnit?!?" before committees start piping, "It wasn't comedic enough. Look at Ratatouie and Over the Hedge... why can't TMNT be more like that?"

Quote:
You would be surprise how little it would take to please fans of the old cartoon
I don't think I would be -- the ones I think we're talking about already are more than willing to settle for so little.

Though I lump myself in as a fan of the old cartoon. I'm just able to seperate my nostalgia from it enough to go, "That was fun when I was a kid, it's fun now in small doses as nostalgia and when I want to pop a DVD in and go, 'Haha, I remember that episode! That was the sh*t when I was 9 years old!'" but when it comes to actual material that does anything for me on an adult level... yeah, we're really just talking about the comics here.

A bit of a love-hate affair at the moment with the current state of Vol. 4 and Tales Vol. 2, but what can you do. Post-Eastman & Laird breakup things are a bit topsy-turvy.

Quote:
I don't see the harm in acknowledging the fans who, like it or not, help to keep the ninja turtles alive today.
Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.

Quote:
Loosened? how, because they were off the radar?
Exactly! That's what it takes, the extent of which the "TMNT is for Kids" motif has permeated things.

Quote:
I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!"
There's no accounting for the truly rabid fans of something. I don't think the answer is to cater to them.

Quote:
And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.
Yeah, pretty much. It did a little bit of damage control on the material vs. the Fred Wolf stuff... but essentially yeah, just, "Oh, look. A new TMNT children's cartoon."

Quote:
Originally Posted by Coola Yagami View Post
Yo Andrew, you kinda forgot all the weird 'what were they smokin' stories Eastman and Laird did.
Like what?

Quote:
All the stories about Nobody, Leatherhead, Rennet, the Passing, the Kirby cyrstal Don Special, Justice Force and such were all extremely weird and wacky, especially yhe Rennet ones. And c'mon... in Return to New York did you ever expect the TMNT to side with a Triceraton to take down the Foot.. and to run into 3 weird-as-all-hell Shredder clones?
Nevertheless, all of the stories you mention were handled in a straight enough manner with real, tangible consequences, TMNT that don't jump into each other's arms and scream in fright, spend and focus time on slapstick, goofball dialogue.

It's all in the "take." Right now, I can write a story about a clown on a space station with a talking cow... but I can write it to drum up the laughs, goof-factor, aim it to toddlers, or I can play it straight, keep it within a serious, Twilight Zone/Outer Limits feel.

I know you can appreciate the difference.

Quote:
I agree that the 13 monsters story was out of left field, and in my opnion didn't really have any business in the movies, but yeah... the turtles in the comics was full of crazy stuff too. We've seen the TMNT in New York as is, maybe in a new movie we should see some Triceraton invasion stuff...
Crazy stuff in the comics isn't the issue. The goof, Looney Tunes crap... yeah, that's the stuff that wasn't there.

Unless you count those rubbish Hedden-McWeeny stuff... but even when it was published it bore no bones about it being Elseworlds.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jo Dawn View Post
I wish the actual TMNT would have a chance to shine. In the right hands, and done in the right way, it would be HUGE. TMNT doesn't have to be silly. It can be a cool movie.
That it can. Of its own right.

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-27-2008 at 12:44 AM.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 12:20 AM   #57
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
I wish Bruce Timm would work on the Turtles for a direct-to-DVD animated movie, but everyone would probably be wondering where Batman was during "that new Justice League ripoff with the Ninja Turtles."
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 12:51 AM   #58
Coola Yagami
Overlord
 
Coola Yagami's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 15,742
The saddest part is.... if the movie sequel had Shredder return with Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady and the Technodrome... and the kiddy comedy aspect was played up further..... the movie would have been three times the hit a more dark and serious TMNT would have been....
Coola Yagami is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 12:56 AM   #59
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by Coola Yagami View Post
The saddest part is.... if the movie sequel had Shredder return with Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady and the Technodrome... and the kiddy comedy aspect was played up further..... the movie would have been three times the hit a more dark and serious TMNT would have been....
You can't know that for certain. A "dark and serious TMNT" movie has never been tried before (not that I'm saying there should ever be no humor in a TMNT movie)... and making "TMNT The Old Cartoon: The Motion Picture" is just preaching to a very small choir.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 01:28 AM   #60
Krang
Admin and Sega Guru
 
Krang's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Dimension X
Posts: 3,755
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr. Doom View Post
TMNT thrives on the younder audience, and that's why we get what we do. I don't understand why people can't comprehend the fact that they need to market this stuff to kids in order to have any sort of success at all. There's no way TMNT could be at the same level as Spider-Man or Batman, because when it comes down to it, things like that are just frankly more grounded in reality and easier to take seriously than a property about 4 giant turtles who practice a somewhat bastardized form of martial arts.
Well said. What Mirage purists fail to realize is that the very concept of the Ninja Turtles is ridiculous. Eastman and Laird knew that, considering the concept of the TMNT was a joke, and the first issue of the comics was a parody. To quote the cartoon that throws Mirage purists into fits of rage, they're "big, green, talking turtles." One of the key reasons behind the original cartoon's success is that they took that concept and ran with it by making it into a comedy that didn't take itself seriously. Even if a serious, Mirage-based TMNT movie were made, the majority would most likely make a joke out of it rather than taking it seriously.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.
How is that any more "unhealthy" than Mirage purists who want to see the TMNT origin story over and over again? There is no "wrong" or "right" interpretation of the TMNT. People are entitled to their opinion as to which interpretation they like the best.

Quote:
There's no accounting for the truly rabid fans of something. I don't think the answer is to cater to them.
So you're saying you don't want a Mirage-based movie after all?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
You can't know that for certain. A "dark and serious TMNT" movie has never been tried before (not that I'm saying there should ever be no humor in a TMNT movie)... and making "TMNT The Old Cartoon: The Motion Picture" is just preaching to a very small choir.
And making "Mirage Volumes 1 and 2: The Motion Picture" is preaching to a far, far smaller one.
__________________

"My motherboard's microchips are chomping at the... 'bit'. A little computer humor." --Krang, Welcome Back, Polarisoids
Krang is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:44 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.