The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-27-2008, 01:45 AM   #61
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Heya, Krang.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Krang View Post
Even if a serious, Mirage-based TMNT movie were made, the majority would most likely make a joke out of it rather than taking it seriously.
Who, the critics? They've never made any difference on these kind of films... look at TMNT 1.

Anybody else? Well, again I agree it's a bit of a prickly pear. On the one hand, it's literally about four mutant Turtles to be sold in a serious manner... something that hasn't been done on the big screen since, well, Hellboy, and maybe the Toxic Avenger before him. It's a tough sell, I won't deny. We're talking about savvy, perhaps viral marketing, slick teaser trailers... this sort of thing. And we'd still need a good 10 years of sitting on our hands to wash the taste out of society's collective mouths of "TMNT is For Kids" after the TMNT Part 4 backwash.

Quote:
How is that any more "unhealthy" than Mirage purists who want to see the TMNT origin story over and over again?
Who's talking about the TMNT origin over again? Well, now that you mention it I guess it'd be a necessity to some degree in any reboot en masse, but we're talking about potentially a -- at worst -- 3-5 minute flashback or such in the course of a 90+ minute feature. Would that be so terrible? And though it may not seem like it to you and I (and damned if those years aren't just a flyin' by lately) it has been 18 years since there was any TMNT origin on the big screen.

Quote:
There is no "wrong" or "right" interpretation of the TMNT. People are entitled to their opinion as to which interpretation they like the best.
Of course they are... but we're talking about a TMNT comic book movie here -- we've never seen that before. TMNT is quintessentially a comic book property -- you follow the roots, you end up at a mature comic book. You follow your nostalgia... you end up in children's cartoon spinoffs, which, while have their own devout little followings (and that's cool), isn't indicative or the fault of the source material, which shouldn't perpetually be the whipping boy of Eastman and Laird sitting down sometime around 1986 saying, "OK, Fred Wolf Productions, you guys can do a cartoon loosely based on our comics."

Quote:
And making "Mirage Volumes 1 and 2: The Motion Picture" is preaching to a far, far smaller one.
I'd like to see where you see anyone here advocating a literal "Mirage Vol. 1 & 2 Motion Picture" (I'd be far more interested in seeing someone in a Guilmero Del Toro vein taking the source material, piecing together what worked and what didn't, and bringing forth a creative/directive vision that will just blow comic fans and non-comic fans alike away) but you're not really seeing the bigger picture here. You can't count on the Mirage fans, same as you can't count on the Old Cartoon fans either... a proper TMNT movie absolutely needs to sell itself on itself and nothing else. A bit of name recognition from folks who read the comics, watched the cartoons, watched the old movies has to be the cherry on the top, not the cake itself.

But once more, it's just pie in the sky. There was a chance in the air but it's gone for a good while now. In ten years we can wet our finger and stick it up, see how the wind's blowing, but the pooch has already been effed for the here and now.

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-27-2008 at 02:49 AM.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 02:27 AM   #62
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jo Dawn View Post
Yeah, but what about real people that actually went to see the movie? All that I heard was that they wanted away from kiddie and more adult. And I heard that with my own ears. People can type what they want, but I'll let what I know for a fact by experiencing, and the obvious drop in the box office at week 2, after people actually saw it.

Yes I heard people say it wasn't the fun loving turtles they remember, too "dour", too "dark", "a byproduct of a post 911 world", I heard all this nonsense at the movie theaters.

It dropped the second week like most front loaded movies, add to the fact it wasn't promoted very well and opened up in a crowed market.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
I'm not entirely convinced those people don't represent maybe, at best, 5-10% (and I think I'm being extremely optomistic, even assuming the active membership of this board only represents 5% of the fans out there) of the overall box office take. The other 90-95%? Young teens oblivious to Transformers that saw transforming robot action, the guy from Even Stevens, and slick trailers and went, "Whoa, awesome!"

And yeah, anytime you put the names "Spielburg" and "Bay" on the table at the same time, you're not exactly examining your garden variety movie.
True, Transformers didn't make 300 million on the strength of G1 Transformer fans out of pocket money, but their constant and dogmatic
following certainly didn't hurt the hype machine for the movie.



Quote:
OK, but can you quantify that dollar amount into how much longtime TMNT fans like you and I actually brought to the table in that? I suspect only a fraction. A small fraction.
The 5-6 billion figure covers the time it was introduced back in the 80's, a few years ago 4kids announced that the 2K3 turtles had collected over a billion dollars, I would say a good chunk of that money came from older fans, back when the turtles were a merchandising juggernaut in the 80's and 90's.

Quote:
You're absolutely right, but in the case of this movie, you might have seen a significant boost in the opening weekend before word-of-mouth spread around about, "You guys fooled me! It was just a toddler affair!" (by this, I mean the regular movie-going public, not toddlers, tweens, or existing TMNT fans)... but that's about it.
Most front loaded fanboyish movies make most of their cash during opening weekend, and then drop like stones in week two, and if you were to add amazing PG-13 action it wouldn't be a "toddler affair" would it?


Quote:
I wasn't talking about adults.
But they do make up the mainstream public, it's ok, kind of an old point, forget it.

Quote:
Thus the need for an ice age. Well, a second ice age... the first one just ended up producing kiddy crap again.
How long would this ice age be? Looking at the reviews for TMNT, for good and for bad, 14 years was not enough too fade the memories of the "cowabunga" era, and putting it in a closet and hoping it will go away will never work, because there will always be a kids line. TMNT has proven itself a successful evergreen property, if you can dust off something every 10 years and make a billion dollars, Peter Laird or anyone else with an ounce of sense will never kill off the golden goose. And whenever dealing with movie execs who will be backing the movie financially, do you believe they will back the obscure black and white comic or the 800 pound gorilla that is a proven money maker.


If you really want to see the line mature then you deal with it in the here and now, TMNT may not be as serious as some people would have liked, but it is step in the right direction from the previous movies, and would be a nice building block for more mature stories, just like the Harry Potter books.

I also don't believe the existence of a kid friendly TMNT line spells the end for for a more adult version of TMNT or vise versus. The media world is big enough for both.


Quote:
I don't think I would be -- the ones I think we're talking about already are more than willing to settle for so little.

Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.
Seeing how Transformer fans flip over small things like hearing a specific sound effect, theme song, or VA, it wouldn't take much to satisfy those fans, and it would be a classy tip of the hat to the fans that made Laird and Eastman rich, and helped to keep the turtles alive after all these years. After that move on.

Last edited by Dragon Turtle; 02-27-2008 at 07:42 AM.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 03:47 AM   #63
Krang
Admin and Sega Guru
 
Krang's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Dimension X
Posts: 3,755
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Who, the critics? They've never made any difference on these kind of films... look at TMNT 1.

Anybody else? Well, again I agree it's a bit of a prickly pear. On the one hand, it's literally about four mutant Turtles to be sold in a serious manner... something that hasn't been done on the big screen since, well, Hellboy, and maybe the Toxic Avenger before him. It's a tough sell, I won't deny. We're talking about savvy, perhaps viral marketing, slick teaser trailers... this sort of thing. And we'd still need a good 10 years of sitting on our hands to wash the taste out of society's collective mouths of "TMNT is For Kids" after the TMNT Part 4 backwash.
Yeah, I meant the general public (I agree about the critics). Even if there never were any TMNT cartoons or TMNT 4 or anything else TMNT-related aimed at kids, I still doubt that even the most serious TMNT movie wouldn't end up being laughed at, considering the fact that most teens and young adults can't seem to take anything at all seriously. I'm not saying I'm against a mature TMNT movie, just that it is not likely to be successful. It would be interesting to see an attempt at one and the marketing behind it, though.

Quote:
Who's talking about the TMNT origin over again? Well, now that you mention it I guess it'd be a necessity to some degree in any reboot en masse, but we're talking about potentially a -- at worst -- 3-5 minute flashback or such in the course of a 90+ minute feature. Would that be so terrible? And though it may not seem like it to you and I (and damned if those years aren't just a flyin' by lately) it has been 18 years since there was any TMNT origin on the big screen.
That was just an example to show that wanting to see a reboot with a Mirage-based story would involve retreading just like wanting to see a movie with concepts from the original cartoon in it would. Personally, I don't have a problem with either one.

Quote:
Of course they are... but we're talking about a TMNT comic book movie here -- we've never seen that before. TMNT is quintessentially a comic book property -- you follow the roots, you end up at a mature comic book. You follow your nostalgia... you end up in children's cartoon spinoffs, which, while have their own devout little followings (and that's cool), isn't indicative or the fault of the source material, which shouldn't be perpetually be the whipping boy of Eastman and Laird sitting down sometime around 1986 saying, "OK, Fred Wolf, you guys can do a cartoon loosely based on our comics."
While TMNT did start out as a comic book, the success of the original cartoon is the reason why TMNT is still around today, so I don't think it's fair to try to sweep the OT under the carpet and forget it ever existed. It would be fine with me if there were a comic-based movie that made no reference to the OT whatsoever, but since the OT was an important part of TMNT's history, I don't think it should be considered out of the question to make references to it in the less serious interpretations of TMNT.

Quote:
I'd like to see where you see anyone here advocating a literal "Mirage Vol. 1 & 2 Motion Picture" (I'd be far more interested in seeing someone in a Guilmero Del Toro vein taking the source material, piecing together what worked and what didn't, and bringing forth a creative/directive vision that will just blow comic fans and non-comic fans alike away) but you're not really seeing the bigger picture here.
It's true that nobody said anything about a movie that follows the comic page by page, but nobody said anything like that about the original cartoon either, which is what my comment was in response to. Incorporating characters or other elements from the original cartoon in a new TMNT movie wouldn't necessarily turn it into a revival of the OT.

Quote:
You can't count on the Mirage fans, same as you can't count on the Old Cartoon fans either... a proper TMNT movie absolutely needs to sell itself on itself and nothing else. A bit of name recognition from folks who read the comics, watched the cartoons, watched the old movies has to be the cherry on the top, not the cake itself.
Good point, I agree.
__________________

"My motherboard's microchips are chomping at the... 'bit'. A little computer humor." --Krang, Welcome Back, Polarisoids
Krang is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 09:27 AM   #64
raphdude
Thug
 
raphdude's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 90
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krang View Post
Yeah, I meant the general public (I agree about the critics).

While TMNT did start out as a comic book, the success of the original cartoon is the reason why TMNT is still around today, so I don't think it's fair to try to sweep the OT under the carpet and forget it ever existed. It would be fine with me if there were a comic-based movie that made no reference to the OT whatsoever, but since the OT was an important part of TMNT's history, I don't think it should be considered out of the question to make references to it in the less serious interpretations of TMNT.
Krang,
I couldn 't agree with you more. The OT existed for almost 10 years. Honestly, I have grown to actually enjoy all of the interpretations of the turtles. They all have their place and time. Back in 1990, I went and saw the first live action film (it's still my favorite) repeatedly. I refused to watch the OT because at the time I thought it was stupid and silly. It wasn't until I started buying the Lionsgate dvd's that I got totally hooked on the OT. Back in 1990, I didn't appreciate the subtle adult humor in that show and how funny and almost lovable Shredder, Krang and his two buffoons were. Some of Krang's lines (i.e. "Cry me a river") and Raph's lines have had me laughing outloud! I have since bought all of the Lionsgate dvd's and have throughly enjoyed them.

In terms of another TMNT movie, I'm sure one will come down the road and
I'll go and see it. But I'm not really in a hurry. Until then, I have more than enough dvd's of the turtles to watch.

BTW Krang, Thanks for the warning on the Stephanie PM. I thought that message was odd and my gut feelings told me not to open the link included with it. I'm glad I didn't!
__________________
A Jose Canseco Bat?! Tell me, you didn't pay money for this!!
raphdude is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 09:40 AM   #65
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krang View Post
Well said. What Mirage purists fail to realize is that the very concept of the Ninja Turtles is ridiculous. Eastman and Laird knew that, considering the concept of the TMNT was a joke, and the first issue of the comics was a parody. To quote the cartoon that throws Mirage purists into fits of rage, they're "big, green, talking turtles." One of the key reasons behind the original cartoon's success is that they took that concept and ran with it by making it into a comedy that didn't take itself seriously. Even if a serious, Mirage-based TMNT movie were made, the majority would most likely make a joke out of it rather than taking it seriously.


How is that any more "unhealthy" than Mirage purists who want to see the TMNT origin story over and over again? There is no "wrong" or "right" interpretation of the TMNT. People are entitled to their opinion as to which interpretation they like the best.


So you're saying you don't want a Mirage-based movie after all?


And making "Mirage Volumes 1 and 2: The Motion Picture" is preaching to a far, far smaller one.
Hey, now! I'm (nearly) a Mirage Purist myself! Just wanting to throw out that: Krang, you're generalizing!

I know the Turtles are a parody! That's why, in most instances when talk of a movie comes up, I always speak of wanting to see more subtle humor. My favorite kind of Turtle humor is the subtle parody stuff that comes from the concept of turtles being ninjas set in a world full of 1980s martial arts movie drama and overused comic book cliches. My second favorite type would be subtle social commentary sprinkled throughout a TMNT story.

I don't think I'm the only one who understands this, either. I just feel like I'm being treated like an idiot when given cringe-worthy humor in lieu of something a little more... "No More Heroes" in terms of being funny.
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 11:42 AM   #66
Drtooth
Foot Elite
 
Drtooth's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 4,439
Well, I say this all the time, and I bang my head against the computer popping this respeonse out all the time. I agree...there is no wrong way to do the Turtle franchise (though adding a girl Turtle was pretty close).

When I expected to see TMNT, I expected something similar to the live action films, based only slightly off Mirage (the first one still had April as a news caster, and Don and Casey were friends instead of Raph and Casey, etc. Etc.).

Does this mean I want to see a real Mirage version of the film? Yes, eventually. Somehow. Does it mean I would like to see one based off the old series? Yes! Eventually. But I tended to think of TMNT as the same universe as the first 3 movies. Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady weren't there. Shredder was his own man, like in the comics. But then he had mutant henchmen in the second film. I find the films a good mix between the cartoons and Mirage, almost holding closer to Archie.

Before this gets into a critical about the movie thread (which it isn't), we need to get back on track. From what I've read, a lot of responses were "I didn't like the movie, and I don't want to see a sequal." not "does this film financially warrent a sequal" which is the real question here. A film need not be good or enjoyable in any aspect to get a sequal. Who clammored for Daddy Day Camp? In most cases, sequals are either franchise films (Saw, Shrek, etc) or contractual obligations (also like Saw from what I've heard).

As I said earlier, the merchandising alone warrents a sequal, be it DTV or theatrical. We know that all sides want to do one, but what we don't know is what they want to do for the next one.
__________________
[Insert mildly amusing banner here]
Drtooth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 11:46 AM   #67
silentrob
Mouser
 
silentrob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Cincinnati
Posts: 14
I'm jumping in here late, but I just watched the movie again last night. It was the first time since I saw it opening weekend. I have to say, I really loved it.

I'm a Mirage fan from the very beginning, my favorite TMNT tales are the early stuff and my favorite movie was the first live-action one. With that being said I think the movie was the perfect mix for me. I love the heavy stuff between Leo and Raph, I love the brotherhood and team themes and I thought Don and Mike were handled well too.

I dont think us hardcore Mirage guys will ever get the original comic inspired turtle movie we've dreamt about. There just isnt the market for it and I've come to terms with that... so in my opinion the movie was great. As great as a modern CGI TMNT movie could be.

So I say bring on the sequel! And if/when they do I'll be first in line.
silentrob is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 11:50 AM   #68
The Shelf
Mad Scientist
 
The Shelf's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,031
Let me just say that I am very impressed with how well this thread has held up. It's refreshing to see a good internet debate with no flaming, so I commend all who have participated.

On topic, I have had the privilege to talk both online and off with many different types of Turtles fans, and I think it's safe to say that there are as many fans of one Turtles incarnation as there are of another (with a handful of exceptions). Personally, I have enjoyed nearly every incarnation, and I find myself torn because I am a big fan of both the campy turtles and the serious turtles.

TMNT (part 4) appealed to both sides which is why I loved that movie so much when it came out. I think that one of its greatest strengths was that it tried to appeal to both types of fans. Unfortunately, that is perhaps its greatest weakness as well. It tried to be something for everyone and ended up being everything for no one, which is just a clever way of saying that it flopped in the long run.

There are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't like the old cartoon, and there are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't serious enough like the old comics. I think if a TMNT movie is going to be successful it needs to cater to one or the other. Ideally, Mirage should make direct-to-dvd animated movies that resembles the old cartoon and live-action theatrical movies that resembles the comics. Sure, that would require making twice as many movies, but we'd be making twice as many movies that are both more successful than the last movie was.

Making a movie to please everyone at the same time is just too risky as we've seen. I am finally convinced that splitting the serious and goofy TMNT aspects once and for all is the only way to give everyone what they want, and I think it would be very well accepted.
The Shelf is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 01:41 PM   #69
Tinuvielsdreams
Nothing without passion
 
Tinuvielsdreams's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 1,722
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Shelf View Post
Let me just say that I am very impressed with how well this thread has held up. It's refreshing to see a good internet debate with no flaming, so I commend all who have participated.

On topic, I have had the privilege to talk both online and off with many different types of Turtles fans, and I think it's safe to say that there are as many fans of one Turtles incarnation as there are of another (with a handful of exceptions). Personally, I have enjoyed nearly every incarnation, and I find myself torn because I am a big fan of both the campy turtles and the serious turtles.
TMNT (part 4) appealed to both sides which is why I loved that movie so much when it came out. I think that one of its greatest strengths was that it tried to appeal to both types of fans. Unfortunately, that is perhaps its greatest weakness as well. It tried to be something for everyone and ended up being everything for no one, which is just a clever way of saying that it flopped in the long run.

There are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't like the old cartoon, and there are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't serious enough like the old comics. I think if a TMNT movie is going to be successful it needs to cater to one or the other. Ideally, Mirage should make direct-to-dvd animated movies that resembles the old cartoon and live-action theatrical movies that resembles the comics. Sure, that would require making twice as many movies, but we'd be making twice as many movies that are both more successful than the last movie was.

Making a movie to please everyone at the same time is just too risky as we've seen. I am finally convinced that splitting the serious and goofy TMNT aspects once and for all is the only way to give everyone what they want, and I think it would be very well accepted.
I decided to pull the newest movie last night and watch it again. What is funny is after reading this I realized I had that exact same conversation with the person I was watching it with, but the outcome was opposite...
I think the happy medium is what will survive a theater debut, and I do agree with the idea that if little kids can be flocked to the theater to see Spiderman, and X-men PG-13 rated flicks then why not turtles?
I think for a turtles movie to be successful it needs to have a very balanced mix of what everyone wants to see...Light and dark. I think they went as far as they felt safe going with 4.

I do know our love of the franchise make us all very critical and that's okay conversation like this thread are great...

I would also say the more movies the merrier and I would really love to see darker straight to DVD turtles movies. I know a lot of people here would agree with me when I say I have a BFA in animation (or some other art and writing skill) I'd make them without needing to be paid a ridiculous amount of money if some studio decided to produce them but I just don't see it happening. This entertainment industry in to eager to dismiss and start over if they don't see a quick $$$ result.

I do however really think we haven't seen the last of turtles on the big screen...
Tinuvielsdreams is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 02:13 PM   #70
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
So, I just got done talking to Dan at Mirage about it all based off one of my later messages in this thread.

Seems to be that while the heart was there with Kevin Munroe and Peter Laird (Kevin and Peter? hah!) to make a TMNT movie that everyone could enjoy, it's the people who make the products based on the movie and such who had a lot of pull in why there's such a limitation put on it. Of course, this is due to TMNT's reputation as being purely Season 5 OT TMNT, but it was still marketing pull.

I mentioned earlier a DTV release based off the comic storylines. Seems Mirage has really considered it! However, how much it would cost to do such a thing is just way too much for them right now.

So, in the end, if they were to use some of the money they get from stuff produced for mainstram appeal into a project for Mirage purists and Mirage fans in general, I could handle them putting out something that's more comedic than serious... as long as they do it with dignity and it's used as a means to the end I want to see (more Mirage stuff).
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 02:38 PM   #71
The Shelf
Mad Scientist
 
The Shelf's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,031
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinuvielsdreams View Post
I think the happy medium is what will survive a theater debut, and I do agree with the idea that if little kids can be flocked to the theater to see Spiderman, and X-men PG-13 rated flicks then why not turtles?
But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13. Those films are geared toward teenagers and adults, not the kiddies. Sure, kids go to watch them, but they're not the target audience. There are animated cartoons and movies geared toward them. The theatrical movies are geared to a more mature audience. That's exactly what I want for the Turtles. Two separate lines for two separate audiences. TMNT (part 4) was a happy medium, and I just don't think it was as successful as it could have been if two separate movies lines were being made. The only thing is that one line needs to be theatrical while the other is direct to video. It doesn't matter to me which one goes where so long as it eventually happens, but I would prefer to see a PG-13 TMNT movie on the big screen just because it would be totally epic and the potential viral campaign could be amazing.
The Shelf is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 02:46 PM   #72
Kendamu
Sewerhead
 
Kendamu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canada
Posts: 2,890
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Shelf View Post
But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13. Those films are geared toward teenagers and adults, not the kiddies. Sure, kids go to watch them, but they're not the target audience. There are animated cartoons and movies geared toward them. The theatrical movies are geared to a more mature audience. That's exactly what I want for the Turtles. Two separate lines for two separate audiences. TMNT (part 4) was a happy medium, and I just don't think it was as successful as it could have been if two separate movies lines were being made. The only thing is that one line needs to be theatrical while the other is direct to video. It doesn't matter to me which one goes where so long as it eventually happens, but I would prefer to see a PG-13 TMNT movie on the big screen just because it would be totally epic and the potential viral campaign could be amazing.
It could be done kinda Harry Potter style...

Y'know, start off aiming the movies as a specific target age group of kids and as they grow older make movies grow with that audience until they're adults. That's kinda how I felt going off the OT to the Image comics. They really tried playing off that whole "no moar kiddie turdlez thees r grownup turdlez rawr!!!111" thing.

Last edited by Kendamu; 02-27-2008 at 02:47 PM. Reason: Added "thing."
Kendamu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 03:16 PM   #73
Tinuvielsdreams
Nothing without passion
 
Tinuvielsdreams's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 1,722
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Shelf View Post
But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13. Those films are geared toward teenagers and adults, not the kiddies. Sure, kids go to watch them, but they're not the target audience. There are animated cartoons and movies geared toward them. The theatrical movies are geared to a more mature audience. That's exactly what I want for the Turtles. Two separate lines for two separate audiences. TMNT (part 4) was a happy medium, and I just don't think it was as successful as it could have been if two separate movies lines were being made. The only thing is that one line needs to be theatrical while the other is direct to video. It doesn't matter to me which one goes where so long as it eventually happens, but I would prefer to see a PG-13 TMNT movie on the big screen just because it would be totally epic and the potential viral campaign could be amazing.
I get what you mean, I guess I just think of PG-13 more the norm lately for hero movies. PG is the new G because you barely ever see G rated movies anymore. I also know kids love to see PG-13 rated films..lol

I do love your idea, I have always wanted to see straight to DVDs happen. It's really nice to hear it has at least been considered from what Goongasnootch said earlier. I could see them putting the kiddier films in theater and doing the grittier version on DVD. We just may never get that.
I guess I thinkn back to Movie 1 and I just feel like they did something really right there with the balance of what fans were getting. Maybe I am just hoping too much for another TMNT 1
Tinuvielsdreams is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 04:30 PM   #74
GreasyBoi
Foot Soldier
 
GreasyBoi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Indiana
Posts: 238
I don't think there is any chance on having a rated R TMNT movie. If it is rated R, the kids will be dissapointed and not be able to watch. That means low budget on a rated R movie. Although, a PG-13 would still be great. But I'm hoping for a live action movie.
__________________
Prayers for Paul George
GreasyBoi is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 07:13 PM   #75
Masked Ninja
Doodles TMNT for fun
 
Masked Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: sploshin' through some sewer...
Posts: 2,137
Interesting, the too funny/not funny enough split reaction over TMNT.

My observation: There's quite a lot of attempted humor, but about 85% of it falls flat. So you really only laugh a few times, though they're constantly trying. It is surprisingly dark when compared to the OT, mainly because you have Raph and Leo seriously fight each other. And that family tension, while really the only "dark" thing happening, does pervade the whole tone even while Mike is ridiculous all over the place. That's where the OT fans get that "dour" complaint, I bet. The Turtles aren't mindless cartoons that are ready to group hug at any given moment - they have some problems they're working through and Leo returning isn't going to hunky-dorify everything.

Andrew's earlier assessment of TMNT is one I actually agree with on all points... I think the reason I'm still able to have fun watching it is I shrug off the bits I don't like and immerse myself in the parts I do. But the thing that still kills me every time I watch are those flopped one-liners. A few are chuckle-worthy, but most... blech.

That's what we need for any sequel... if there are gonna be jokes (and even in a Mirage-loyal film there should be a decent amount), they have to be good.
Masked Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-27-2008, 08:49 PM   #76
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Goongasnootch View Post
So, I just got done talking to Dan at Mirage about it all based off one of my later messages in this thread.

Seems to be that while the heart was there with Kevin Munroe and Peter Laird (Kevin and Peter? hah!) to make a TMNT movie that everyone could enjoy, it's the people who make the products based on the movie and such who had a lot of pull in why there's such a limitation put on it. Of course, this is due to TMNT's reputation as being purely Season 5 OT TMNT, but it was still marketing pull.
Got to get those Happy Meal toys out to the young'uns.


Quote:
I mentioned earlier a DTV release based off the comic storylines. Seems Mirage has really considered it! However, how much it would cost to do such a thing is just way too much for them right now.
Since Warner bros. has been on a direct to video kick as of late, it would be nice if they could kick in a few mil for a direct-to-video TMNT flick, you know do something to promote the product for a change.


Quote:
Originally Posted by The Shelf View Post
But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13.
I don't believe OT turtle fans would object to a PG-13 movie, especially considering many OT fans consider the first live action movie to be the gold standard of TMNT films, and that movie would definately be rated PG-13 today.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja;5
92876
Interesting, the too funny/not funny enough split reaction over TMNT.

My observation: There's quite a lot of attempted humor, but about 85% of it falls flat. So you really only laugh a few times, though they're constantly trying.

I'll be honest, I just don't see where TMNT is constantly attempting to be funny, yes the Mikey parts more often then not fall flat, but most people would agree he and Don got the shaft when it came to screen time, so what else is there? Don's IT job, some one liners during the monster fight scene (most likely ablibbed by the voice actors), Raph's scuffle with the Jersy Devil? Meh. Maybe it's the shortness of the movie that gives the impression that TMNT was wall to wall gags.

Last edited by Dragon Turtle; 02-27-2008 at 09:08 PM.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-28-2008, 02:35 AM   #77
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
When I have 40 minutes to set aside to respond to a lot of the very articulately brought up points here, I'll do so. In the mean time, let me add...

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Shelf View Post
Let me just say that I am very impressed with how well this thread has held up. It's refreshing to see a good internet debate with no flaming, so I commend all who have participated.
I couldn't agree more, and I was thinking the same thing. When I was voicing pretty much my same opinions a little under a year ago, maybe TMNT Part 4 was a little too fresh on the brain for the fans around these parts to properly digest it and set aside that kind of "zomg, new Turtlez movie, someone dares bash it?" blind sentiment (aside from one or two folks, posting my thoughts about the film was seemingly like throwing out a pinata for flamers), but it seems like -- maybe -- finally we can have an intelligent conversation about that in retrospect now, and for things moving forward.

This is a good thing, it's cool, and just about everyone here has brought up valid points. It's all remained respectful, no name-calling has been hurled even as personal convictions all seem to be laid plainly on the table.

Before I sign off, one post just begs a rebuttal...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Batista13 View Post
I don't think there is any chance on having a rated R TMNT movie. If it is rated R, the kids will be dissapointed and not be able to watch. That means low budget on a rated R movie. Although, a PG-13 would still be great. But I'm hoping for a live action movie.
No one of sound mind is asking or expecting (or at least, asking that honestly expects) an R-rated TMNT movie... and you won't find any posts in this entire thread advocating an R-rated TMNT movie. It's quite possible to translate a proper Mirage-oriented comic book movie into PG-13... and quite impossible to do it as PG.

Is there any R-rated material in the comic books? Not a whole lot that it's just inherently a part of it, but sure. The way the R rating is, any kicks to the head is an automatic R (by this latest stigma, even the original TMNT movie would be rated R). Actual panels showing free-flowing blood and dismemberment would have to go, or be left tactfully implied (hopefully saved for a later unrated DVD director's cut, but whatever), and probably the TMNT doing any underage drinking of alcohol is probably a no-no... but I'm pretty sure even the most jaded Mirage fan can live with these concessions.

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-28-2008 at 02:40 AM.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-28-2008, 02:45 AM   #78
Krang
Admin and Sega Guru
 
Krang's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Dimension X
Posts: 3,755
Quote:
Originally Posted by Goongasnootch View Post
Hey, now! I'm (nearly) a Mirage Purist myself! Just wanting to throw out that: Krang, you're generalizing!

I know the Turtles are a parody! That's why, in most instances when talk of a movie comes up, I always speak of wanting to see more subtle humor.
My mistake, I didn't mean to imply that all Mirage purists were like that. I was only referring to the really gung-ho ones that get furious at anything TMNT-related that isn't "dark and gritty" and are too closed-minded to acknowledge the humorous origins of the TMNT.

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Shelf View Post
Ideally, Mirage should make direct-to-dvd animated movies that resembles the old cartoon and live-action theatrical movies that resembles the comics. Sure, that would require making twice as many movies, but we'd be making twice as many movies that are both more successful than the last movie was.

Making a movie to please everyone at the same time is just too risky as we've seen. I am finally convinced that splitting the serious and goofy TMNT aspects once and for all is the only way to give everyone what they want, and I think it would be very well accepted.
Good idea, I agree. If there were to be a new movie based on the original cartoon, though, I hope they would hire the original voice actors and one or more of the original writers. Without them, I doubt they would be able to capture the unique humor of the OT.
__________________

"My motherboard's microchips are chomping at the... 'bit'. A little computer humor." --Krang, Welcome Back, Polarisoids
Krang is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-28-2008, 09:11 AM   #79
JetsAndHeels
Stone Warrior
 
JetsAndHeels's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: NC
Posts: 596
Quote:
Originally Posted by silentrob View Post
I'm jumping in here late, but I just watched the movie again last night. It was the first time since I saw it opening weekend. I have to say, I really loved it.


So I say bring on the sequel! And if/when they do I'll be first in line.

I agree with all of this. I thought the movie was great, and I look forward to hopefully seeing a sequel in the future.

It was a fun movie to watch...I enjoyed all the action and the plot. I thought the characters were well developed (although don and mike were not in it as much) and the animation was very well done. ONe of my favorite movies.
__________________
JetsAndHeels is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-28-2008, 10:09 AM   #80
Drtooth
Foot Elite
 
Drtooth's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 4,439
Because it has no direct linking, and you'd have to go and look for it anyway:

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

Scroll down to see the Wednsay, Febuary 27th post. It has a notice saying "Imagi is hiring" and it features an Uncle Sam-esque poster of one of the Turtles. Clearly they want one to happen.

And off topic, there' apparently an Astroboy version of this poster. I'm too lazy to look for it, though.
__________________
[Insert mildly amusing banner here]
Drtooth is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:06 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.