Which version of shredder was/is your favorite?

[LittleBlueHero]

IDW Shredder
Movie Shredder
Original Toon Shredder
Nick Toon Shredder
Mirage Shredder
4Kids Toon Shredder

I think thats the way I would have to rank them. In regards to the original toon shredder being the deepest of the characters... Duh he had the most time to develop. Mirage Shredder was offed before he had a chance to develop more character 4Kids version seemed very one dimensional, Movies had to focus on the Turtles obviously.

IDW so far has spent a significant amount of time exploring the Shredder, how he got where he is and why his ambitions are what they are. He is also that physically imposing monster we saw in 4kids. Anyone is lucky to scratch him in combat let alone best him. So far he is definitely my favorite iteration.

[Gabriel GP]

Easily the IDW version. He seems to be the strongest of all the incarnations. He also has the best background history for me.

In second place would be the Nick version, even not doing many things for his own, when he does, it does well. Just lost some points after taking a beating from Splinter.

[turtlefanforever]

Originally Posted by LittleBlueHero

IDW Shredder
Movie Shredder
Original Toon Shredder
Mirage Shredder
4Kids Toon Shredder

4Kids version seemed very one dimensional, .

If by one dimensional you mean he's gonna find you kill you and move on then yes.