The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Comic Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 07-19-2022, 12:00 PM   #81
Cowabung-Gal
The Party Dudette
 
Cowabung-Gal's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: U-S-A!!
Posts: 2,606
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cipher View Post

Okay, so, more questions:

1) Is the current TMNT comic 60 percent LGBT? If not, then is it fine?

2) If the story is about a gay community, can it have a 60 percent+ LGBT cast? Or is that topic inherently woke and bad? Can a story be inherently woke and disingenuous just by being about a particular group?

3) What's the difference between pandering and sincerity if the author cares about the topic they're tackling? Does the distinction matter?

Related and to keep this focused, were Mirage or Archie TMNT ever pandering? (I would argue yes, in the non-Murphy Archie specials, but outside of those.)
I actually stopped reading the comic after issue #113, so I’m not sure how many LGBT characters are in there now, but last time I checked, it was about, what, 20%, maybe less? But I also remember it having crappy fanfiction-esque writing as well as some unnecessary political analogies (for example the MAGA people protesting the idea of letting mutants back into society in the “Jennika” series) and Jennika becoming a Mary-Sue that now dates chicks because she got dumped/betrayed by her two previous boyfriends (because men suck, right?). I left because I saw how unbearably woke it was becoming.

I loved the TV show “The Proud Family”, even though I’m not black. Why? Because all of the main characters were funny, well-written, and more importantly, relatable, and the show didn’t portray all white people as uncaring insensitive monsters; sure there were a couple, but the rest were pretty decent characters. That show was not “woke” despite it being a “black” show. The same applies to “The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air”. Everyone of all races could enjoy those shows, not just black people. Did those shows tackle the topics of racism and prejudice? Yes, but it wasn’t done in a way that made you feel bad about being born white like how a lot of woke shows/comics do.
__________________
Cowabunga
Cowabung-Gal is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:07 PM   #82
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,634
"When activism/diversity for the sake of diversity/virtue signaling for this cause or that cause or this group becomes the driving force of a creative work, overshadowing everything or almost everything else going on in it" is the answer I think Cipher is digging for. But I think he already knew that.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cowabung-Gal View Post
I loved the TV show “The Proud Family”, even though I’m not black. Why? Because all of the main characters were funny, well-written, and more importantly, relatable, and the show didn’t portray all white people as uncaring insensitive monsters; sure there were a couple, but the rest were pretty decent characters. That show was not “woke” despite it being a “black” show.
Is that what that is? I thought "The Proud Family" was a big LGBTQ thing.
Andrew NDB is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:10 PM   #83
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Okay, see, now we're at least getting into nitty gritty about what may or may not feel sincere about how it tackles issues, which is at least something I can engage with. On bits of execution like that, I can't comment without having read it.

Quote:
Yes, but it wasn’t done in a way that made you feel bad about being born white like how a lot of woke shows/comics do.
Does TMNT make you feel bad about being straight or something? Guess I'll find out.

Certainly seemed like the older TMNT comics could occasionally make people feel about about being of certain political views (immigration, anything anti-environmentalism, Murphy letting intolerant Christian parents quietly dunk on themselves in letter columns, Laird taking potshots at essentially MAGA rhetoric two three decades removed, etc.), but they weren't hurting anyone and that kind of comes with the territory of touching on something sincere. You run the risk of putting off those who don't identify with it.

Now, how adeptly or how sincerely it seems like recent TMNT is doing all of that, again, I can't say. But the opening quip of this thread was to get at: Unless it's handled in the clumsiest way imaginable, it isn't new territory for even widely celebrated TMNT comics. Just new territory for IDW (the outlier), and maybe new issues.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
"When activism/diversity for the sake of diversity/virtue signaling for this cause or that cause or this group becomes the driving force of a creative work, overshadowing everything or almost everything else going on in it" is the answer I think Cipher is digging for. But I think he already knew that.
I don't now that I would have put it that way--I think activism in a certain respect being the driving work of a piece can still lend toward quality work, especially with pulp comics when tend to not be all that subtle in the first place. I especially think that's true of Adventures, where a lot of time the topic leads the plot, but Murphy still turns in a fun, engaging series around it, and engenders even more good will since I like that he's trying to not waste his opportunity on a kids' book with that reach. Even at its least subtle, my overwhelming sense is "This is the only way this man could sleep at night" rather than "He's trying to score brownie points." There's a bit of that energy, and not just from him, in portions of Mirage as well. Again, not always directly political, but you got the sense that multiple writers really were working through things that felt close to them. I like that.

But "virtue signaling"? Sure, if we take that to mean the empty gesturing toward something the author doesn't care about either, or can't mesh germanely with their storytelling, and that lack of caring generally leads to poor storytelling results on a number of fronts not just related to what it tackles.

Is Campbell making empty gestures? I wouldn't have thought so (frankly I still kind of doubt the gestures are being made so heavily period in a book where major beats(?) are still based around "This thing is back!" that I found so exhausting under Waltz--who, full apologies if you're reading this), but heck, maybe it's clunky.

But yeah, obviously a lot of my rhetoric here is leading. But other spots are genuinely my wondering where people are drawing lines and how they're viewing things.

Last edited by Cipher; 07-19-2022 at 12:28 PM.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:31 PM   #84
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cowabung-Gal View Post
I actually stopped reading the comic after issue #113, so I’m not sure how many LGBT characters are in there now, but last time I checked, it was about, what, 20%, maybe less?
There have been 3 confirmed LGBTQ+ characters: Jennika, Sheena and Lindsay Baker; about 3% out of a cast of maybe 100 or so that's about right for a group of that size: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.e...y-people-lgbt/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cowabung-Gal View Post
I left because I saw how unbearably woke it was becoming.
And you've proven my point that most people don't actually know what woke means > 'aware of and actively attentive to important facts and issues (especially issues of racial and social justice)' as per the dictionary definition I posted

Last edited by hypered1; 07-19-2022 at 07:38 PM.
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:32 PM   #85
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
Something, something in the dungeon.
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:33 PM   #86
Cowabung-Gal
The Party Dudette
 
Cowabung-Gal's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: U-S-A!!
Posts: 2,606
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cipher View Post
Does TMNT make you feel bad about being straight or something? Guess I'll find out.
Well, you explain why Jennika started dating Sheena. Was it because they have real chemistry (which I don’t see and it feels weird and forced to me), or is it because Jennika got screwed over by men her entire life and thought that women would treat her better? If Jennika was a lesbian from the beginning but started dating Casey and became bisexual like she is now, you think the SJWs would handle that change well? Heck no. They’d scream “homophobia” until their faces turned blue, even though bisexuality is part of the LGBTQ+ category. I know someone who got crap for making the “Hazbin Hotel” character Angel Dust bisexual in her fan art, even though he is portrayed as gay in the show. And given that both of Jenny’s boyfriends were straight white males, it wouldn’t be a stretch to assume that Sophie made her date Sheena because she, herself, has a personal vendetta against straight white men.
__________________
Cowabunga
Cowabung-Gal is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:33 PM   #87
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,634
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cipher View Post
Does TMNT make you feel bad about being straight or something? Guess I'll find out.
The right question to ask here is, "Does it try to?"

And I don't know the answer. All I've known about IDW TMNT for a long time now is that it isn't for me, and that has nothing to do with wokeness or anything.

Quote:
Certainly seemed like the older TMNT comics could occasionally make people feel about about being of certain political views (immigration, anything anti-environmentalism, Murphy letting intolerant Christian parents quietly dunk on themselves in letter columns, Laird taking potshots at essentially MAGA rhetoric two three decades removed, etc.), but they weren't hurting anyone and that kind of comes with the territory of touching on something sincere. You run the risk of putting off those who don't identify with it.
Occasionally. And I would leave the letter column out of the equation because it's the letter column.

Maybe the difference is that what little of this there was in Mirage and Archie, it was because the main plot of a given issue did not grind to a halt to dwell on whatever the issue at hand was (pollution, global warming, etc.). I suppose you could point to fleeting spots in Vol. 4, but while I dig it there was hardly a lot of momentum in the overall narrative to begin with for it not to grind to a halt here and there.

And then -- it appears -- that there is large pockets of IDW TMNT material where it's like the author reaching through the comic book, waving an arm at the reader, "Look? See? Fat is beautiful. And look over here, healthy lesbian relationship. See over there? Another one. Oh, wait! Right! Coming out stories, got it covered! Over here and here and here. Elections are a big deal right now, I got that covered next issue, too!" And so on.

But I don't know.

Quote:
I don't now that I would have put it that way--I think activism in a certain respect being the driving work of a piece can still lend toward quality work, especially with pulp comics when tend to not be all that subtle in the first place. I especially think that's true of Adventures, where a lot of time the topic leads the plot
Hm... what would be examples of TMNTA issues where it led the plot?

Quote:
But "virtue signaling"? Sure, if we take that to mean the empty gesturing toward something the author doesn't care about either,
It can be something they care about. But mostly it is the looking for the likes and the high fives from "the community" and/or their echo chamber of like-minded people that is the motivating factor at play. The search for validation and affirmation that they're doing good fighting the good fight, on the right side of history, etc.
Andrew NDB is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:36 PM   #88
Cowabung-Gal
The Party Dudette
 
Cowabung-Gal's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: U-S-A!!
Posts: 2,606
Quote:
Originally Posted by hypered1 View Post
There have been 3 confirmed LGBTQ+ characters: Jennika, Sheila and Lindsay Baker; about 3% out of a cast of maybe 100 or so that's about right for a group of that size: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.e...y-people-lgbt/
You forgot the raccoon and his platypus boyfriend, as well as the blue poison dart frog Jay.
__________________
Cowabunga
Cowabung-Gal is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 12:42 PM   #89
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cowabung-Gal View Post
You forgot the raccoon and his platypus boyfriend, as well as the blue poison dart frog Jay.
Still doesn't make up an excessive amount of characters and those three, Bandit, Puggle and Jay are all minor recurring characters at best.
__________________
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 07:15 PM   #90
CyberCubed
Overlord
 
CyberCubed's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 43,917
Cipher if you saw this out of context would you assume this belonged in TMNT:



For reference, this is Jennika (a female mutant turtle), and Sheena, a female pig mutant who was a human rockstar. Keep in note when Jennika was human, she had a crush on Casey Jones and they apparently briefly became a couple off-screen and broke up.

Now that Jennika is a mutant Turtle, she suddenly went full lesbo with a female pig mutant. Now we have two lesbian mutants in TMNT instead of an action franchise about the Turtles fighting ninjas and battling aliens or mutants.
CyberCubed is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 07:21 PM   #91
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Lmao, you guys.

So, I read the second volume of the Campbell run, #106-110, since it was free with Kindle Unlimited. As prep, I also read through about half of the IDW Collection #12, since it was also included, just so I had a little chunk of the later Waltz era for comparison.

Quick praise for the the 12th collection: I was pleasantly surprised by and really enjoyed Ian Flynn's Michelangelo one-shot and Ryan Ferrier's Mutagen Man-Mondo two-parter in Universe. The main book issues included let me kind of cold, but I didn't have any context and they were plot-heavy, so I don't think I can respond fairly to them. (Feeling extremely plot heavy with scant character moments was one of the things that got me to eventually drop the book, but things may have changed and this was just the wrong spot to drop in. Or not, and anyway, to each their own.)

For the Campbell issues ... this was what the fuss was about?

I enjoyed them a lot more than I had most of IDW when I was reading it, but I'm still not sure it's my thing. I do like that we have more downtime, and the interesting roles it's put characters like the Turtles Hob into though (the issue with him where the weasels sneak in really piqued my interest, and the weasels themselves are also great, even though I have no idea what's up with them). I also got a chuckle here and there, out of bits like the Koya-Karai-Bludgeon scene, the weasels and Hob, and a few other sections. It feels like it's really doing something new, even though the "remember X?" reliance in certain spots still got me. It's IDW.

Anyway, here's the tally on what people told me was too woke about it, or too different from whatever previous Turtles books have done:

--------------

Touching on real-world issues: Five pages.
  • Alopex and Mona discuss how the government isn't looking out for them, which could be read as an allusion to governments failing marginalized communities in general. One page. Ripe for commentary, but in this case it's also an immediate setup for discussing more Mutant Town government establishment talk, which is a natural avenue for storytelling and I'm guessing something for future plot points?
  • Michelangelo watches talking heads inaccurately discuss mutants on the news, and then a reporter asks him weird mating questions before even getting his name. Two pages. Yeah, that's probably a trans allegory, huh? But it's a good one and germane to the characters and setting. If you don't want to read it as one, incidentally, you don't have to, as it fits right into the plot without being overt or didactic at all, which was a mode Mirage and Archie hardly ever turned to for their real-world topics, much as I love them and their bluntness. If you want to just read it as a beat for Michelangelo's motivation you can, but if you want to put two and two together on discussing groups in media without their representation or immediately asking about people's junk not being great, that's there too. I was told this was the unsubtle one. What about this is less subtle than Laird plucking far-right-wing rhetoric for villains, greenhouse-gas futures, Radical waxing about industrialization next to neon buffalo signs, or Jagwar taking a moment to shout about deforestation mid-action, I'm not sure.
  • Mona fails to earn her parents' sympathies over a video call. Two pages. Yeah, that's a trans allegory. See above.

    Also, Michelangelo being inspired by that encounter to start his own radio show is interesting and just a decent, human story angle. I like that. It's not really a political allegory at all, unless championing the power of humanistic journalism and storytelling counts as one. Makes good use of his character.

LGBT characters: Two.
  • The only characters' whose sexuality I know isn't straight in this five-issue volume are Jennika and her girlfriend. Are we at 60 percent yet?

Girls being invincible and guys sucking: Zero.
  • Jennika does exactly the same things in the action scenes as the other Turtles, winning or losing when the group does.
  • Raph beats a female biker in a race.
  • Later, the Turtles beat a female lemur who invades their house.
  • All other female characters: April, Mona, Alopex, Sally, Sheena, Karai, Koya ... am I missing anyone? ... don't get any action this volume.
  • So that's actually ... one instance of a girl doing the same things the rest of her all-guy group is, and two of girls losing to guys.

    Not that it would be a problem if the ratio skewed the other way, but this was the unnatural, distracting girl-power that was putting people off the book? Feminists need a better rep.

Gender/race/sexualitybending: Zero.
  • Race isn't much of a factor when the bulk of the book has become mutant animals, but all the human characters who showed up had the same skin tones as their initial appearances.
    • There've been a grand total of 2.5 instances of that in TMNT history ever, right? Two of which, Baxter in the original cartoon, and Eric Saks only very narrowly not replacing Oroku Saki in the first Bay movie, where moving non-white characters to white ones, with only Rise's April being the opposite?
  • There were no genderbent characters in these issues. I'm aware of two in the IDW book that came up during the Waltz era though, in Null and Jagwar?
  • No sexuality switches with existing characters that I saw here. At least two of the Turtles were shown/implied to be straight, and I know this April is, etc. The only two explicitly non-straight characters were new ones, which I thought was the right way to do it.

Sh*itting on the American flag and holding up a Marxist one: Zero. Y'all had me excited.

"Remember X?": Two.
  • Road Hogs
  • Tokka and Rahzar (the volume cliffhanger)

This was something I was curious about on my own, since I found so distracting in previous IDW material, where I was constantly wishing it would have the confidence to do its own thing. That feels like pandering to me, and always took/takes me out of the book, since it leads to cliffhangers and plot beats that feel like they hinge solely on recognition. I can't say if the rate of that coming up has gotten any better or worse. Two per volume feels maybe on the low side compared to the past, but still pretty high. Anyway, it's still IDW Turtles-ing.

--------------

It's ... IDW, with a little more space for unexplored character territory (the Hob direction is so good; that I'm genuinely curious about, and he was one of the best parts of the book back when I was reading it, as one of its original ones) and some touching on real-world personal/social issues at a rate of five pages per volume. Which I'd absolutely rather have than not, and which puts it more in company of previous Turtle books, but this isn't exactly dominating the content I read. Mirage circa Tales Vol. 2 and Archie would have gotten up to things far less subtle at a higher rate on that front. Again, for better or for worse.

What was there definitely did not feel like pandering; I'm sure that's stuff that's actually on Campbell's mind and that she's been through, just as Laird, Murphy and co. were getting at things near to them. And again: Five pages. One of them's hardly even an allegory.

If you don't enjoy the story direction, then obviously feel free to not enjoy it--and I can see why people who were super gung-ho on the Waltz era over any other Turtles books might not be having a great time. But the talk about this feeling more politically pandering or issue-heavy than any pre-Waltz TMNT comics is so disingenuous. I say having read all that pre-Waltz stuff up and down, and now having read this for comparison.

Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?

EDIT -- Other note: I also liked the page of Sheena, Mona and Jennika sitting around drinking beer and discussing bands. That feels believable for a group of recently mutated girls, and it's the kind of moment I don't remember getting much space anywhere in at least the first 30 or so issues under Waltz + the spin-offs. I remember wanting moments like that, since it felt very all-plot all-the-time--even during the "downtime" Northampton arc.

Last edited by Cipher; 07-19-2022 at 08:31 PM.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 07:41 PM   #92
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cipher View Post
Lmao, you guys.

So, I read the second volume of the Campbell run, #106-110, since it was free with Kindle Unlimited. As prep, I also read through about half of the IDW Collection #12, since it was also included, just so I had a little chunk of the later Waltz era for comparison.

Quick praise for the the 12th collection: I was pleasantly surprised by and really enjoyed Ian Flynn's Michelangelo one-shot and Ryan Ferrier's Mutagen Man-Mondo two-parter in Universe. The main book issues included let me kind of cold, but I didn't have any context and they were plot-heavy, so I don't think I can respond fairly to them. (Feeling extremely plot heavy with scant character moments was one of the things that got me to eventually drop the book, but things may have changed and this was just the wrong spot to drop in. Or not, and anyway, to each their own.)

For the Campbell issues ... this was what the fuss was about?

I enjoyed them a lot more than I had most of IDW when I was reading it, but I'm still not sure it's my thing. I do like that we have more downtime, and the interesting roles it's put characters like the Turtles Hob into though (the issue with him where the weasels sneak in really piqued my interest, and the weasels themselves are also great, even though I have no idea what's up with them). I also got a chuckle here and there, out of bits like the Koya-Karai-Bludgeon scene, the weasels and Hob, and a few other sections. It feels like it's really doing something new, even though the "remember X?" reliance in certain spots still got me. It's IDW.

Anyway, here's the tally on what people told me was too woke about it, or too different from whatever previous Turtles books have done:

--------------

Touching on real-world issues: Five pages.
  • Alopex and Mona discuss how the government isn't looking out for them, which could be read as an allusion to governments failing marginalized communities in general. One page. Ripe for commentary, but in this case it's also an immediate setup for discussing more Mutant Town government establishment talk, which is a natural avenue for storytelling and I'm guessing something for future plot points?
  • Michelangelo watches talking heads inaccurately discuss mutants on the news, and then a reporter asks him weird mating questions before even getting his name. Two pages. Yeah, that's probably a trans allegory, huh? But it's a good one and germane to the characters and setting. If you don't want to read it as one, incidentally, you don't have to, as it fits right into the plot without being overt or didactic at all, which was a mode Mirage and Archie hardly ever turned to for their real-world topics, much as I love them and their bluntness. If you want to just read it as a beat for Michelangelo's motivation you can, but if you want to put two and two together on discussing groups in media without their representation or immediately asking about people's junk not being great, that's there too. I was told this was the unsubtle one. What about this is less subtle than Laird plucking far-right-wing rhetoric for villains, greenhouse-gas futures, Radical waxing about industrialization next to neon buffalo signs, or Jagwar taking a moment to shout about deforestation mid-action, I'm not sure.
  • Mona fails to earn her parents' sympathies over a video call. Two pages. Yeah, that's a trans allegory. See above.

    Also, Michelangelo being inspired by that encounter to start his own radio show is interesting and just a decent, human story angle. I like that. It's not really a political allegory at all, unless championing the power of humanistic journalism and storytelling counts as one. Makes good use of his character.

LGBT characters: Two.
  • The only characters' whose sexuality I know isn't straight in this five-issue volume are Jennika and her girlfriend's. Are we at 60 percent yet?

Girls being invincible and guys sucking: 0.
  • Jennika does exactly the same things in the action scenes as the other Turtles, winning or losing when the group does.
  • Raph beats a female biker in a race.
  • Later, the Turtles beat a female lemur who invades their house.
  • All other female characters: April, Mona, Alopex, Sally, Sheena, Karai, Koya ... am I missing anyone? ... don't get any action this volume. So that's actually ... one instance of a girl doing the same things the rest of her all-guy group is, and two of girls losing to guys.

Not that it would be a problem if the ratio skewed the other way, but this was the unnatural, distracting girl-power that was putting people off the book?

Remember X?: Two.
  • Road Hogs
  • Tokka and Rahzar (the volume cliffhanger)

This was something I was curious about on my own, since I found so distracting in previous IDW material, where I was constantly wishing it would have the confidence to do its own thing. That feels like pandering to me, and always takes me out of the book. I can't say if the rate of that coming up has gotten any better or worse. Two per volume feels maybe on the low side compared to the past, but still pretty high. Anyway, it's still IDW Turtles-ing.

--------------

It's ... IDW, with a little more space for unexplored character territory (the Hob direction is so good; that I'm genuinely curious about, and he was one of the best parts of the book back when I was reading it, as one of its original ones) and some touching on real-world personal/social issues at a rate of five pages per volume. Which I'd absolutely rather have than not, and which puts it more in company of previous Turtle books, but this isn't exactly dominating the content I read. Mirage circa Tales Vol. 2 and Archie would have gotten up to things far less subtle at a higher rate on that front. Again, for better or for worse.

What was there definitely did not feel like pandering; I'm sure that's stuff that's actually on Campbell's mind and that she's been through, just as Laird, Murphy and co. were getting at things near to them. And again: Five pages. One of them's hardly even an allegory.

If you don't enjoy the story direction, then feel free to not enjoy it, and I can see why people who were super gung-ho on the Waltz era over any other Turtles books might not be having a great time. But the talk about this feeling more politically pandering or issue-heavy than any pre-Waltz TMNT comics is so disingenuous.

Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?
And finally after many issues, Raph and Alopex are officially a couple, Raph's relationship with Ninjara in the archie comic didn't last forever since it was near the end of the comic's run when it abruptly got canceled.

But I could see this pairing lasting for way much longer.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 07:45 PM   #93
neatoman
Overlord
 
neatoman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,097
I've said this before but the problem with the Campbell run isn't "politics", it's that it's incredibly boring and poorly written. None of the new characters are compelling or even does anything noteworthy, important details to understand what's even going on are missing, there is plenty of false conflict/resolutions to make it seem like something is going on (which it fails at) and there just isn't much going on.

I'm sorry but the problem isn't so much what the writer wanted to make, it's just that in a purely structural sense, this run is utterly broken. It doesn't qualify as a functional story.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH View Post
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.
Hahahaha!
neatoman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 07:56 PM   #94
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cipher View Post
Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?
In the IDW series human-born mutants just kinda become random animals unless it's done in a controlled environment like Bebop and Rocksteady. Animal-borns stay the same.

I'll also save you some trouble; a good chunk of the bashing done to the current run is purely because Sophie Campbell is trans to the point that people have directly attacked her, including dead-naming her, with little-to-no connection with the comics themselves.
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 07:57 PM   #95
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
I've said this before but the problem with the Campbell run isn't "politics", it's that it's incredibly boring and poorly written. None of the new characters are compelling or even does anything noteworthy, important details to understand what's even going on are missing, there is plenty of false conflict/resolutions to make it seem like something is going on (which it fails at) and there just isn't much going on.
I can see why people would feel that way if they were into the Waltz material, which was always very much a plot-first serial. I enjoyed what I peaked into here more, but sure, I can see why current readers may not like the mode/pacing switch. I suspect the readers who were super into the Waltz material were also ones not super hep on what Mirage became, whereas, as a fan of that material, I feel like I'd be most at home in IDW post-100.

Anyway, that's totally fair! But others have assured me, including in this thread, that something was somehow different/worse about its commentary specifically, and ... I just don't see that.

I have to bite my tongue on the conflict resolution comment and how I felt about the earlier IDW material. I suspect that if that's still an issue, it would be more in a "So what's changed?" vein.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 08:17 PM   #96
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Quote:
Originally Posted by hypered1 View Post
I'll also save you some trouble; a good chunk of the bashing done to the current run is purely because Sophie Campbell is trans to the point that people have directly attacked her, including dead-naming her, with little-to-no connection with the comics themselves.
Nah. That's projection. Typical "What you REALLY mean is THIS..." stuff.

I mean, I am quite sure a couple of people here are mad at that - and you can tell Who those people are in just about every case - but that's assuredly not the case for every single person who hates the run or even the majority. It's a convenient bogeyman to point at - "Those awful transphobes!" - but I remain unconvinced.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 08:37 PM   #97
mrmaczaps
Banned
 
mrmaczaps's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Maine
Posts: 2,619
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
I've said this before but the problem with the Campbell run isn't "politics", it's that it's incredibly boring and poorly written. None of the new characters are compelling or even does anything noteworthy, important details to understand what's even going on are missing, there is plenty of false conflict/resolutions to make it seem like something is going on (which it fails at) and there just isn't much going on.

I'm sorry but the problem isn't so much what the writer wanted to make, it's just that in a purely structural sense, this run is utterly broken. It doesn't qualify as a functional story.
All that and the highlights of new characters being introduced are like fireworks, all light show & no dead terrorists. Lol or foot clan...

The jennika minis both sucked less than the ongoing and yet none of those two stories tied back into the main much at all... and mostly could have been told in the ongoing.
mrmaczaps is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-19-2022, 09:02 PM   #98
neatoman
Overlord
 
neatoman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,097
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cipher View Post

I have to bite my tongue on the conflict resolution comment and how I felt about the earlier IDW material. I suspect that if that's still an issue, it would be more in a "So what's changed?" vein.
A fundamental difference between Waltz and Campbell is that Waltz has a much better understanding of cause and effect. So let's take Bebop and Rocksteady as an example, since that might be the most obvious thing.

Right, so even though I'm not convinced Waltz really cares that much about Bebop and Rocksteady, given how little he used them and how much they come across like outsiders to the character drama, he still writes them fairly consistently. In issue 42, Shredder assigns them to guard Donatello in case he attempts to betray Shredder during the invasion plan, when Shredder believes he has he orders them to kill him which they attempt to do, even if they are almost distracted by Metalhead. They then leave because Karai orders them to return to HQ and don't make sure Don is dead as a result, this allows Don to temporarily use the Metalhead body while he is getting surgery. Later on during the gauntlet, their tendency to get distracted and carelessness is used to defeat them. When Splinter takes control of the Foot, they let go because of their violent nature and loyalty to the Shredder.

As for Campbell's attempt to write them, it's seriously confusing. They're sent into Mutant Town to look for Karai who is missing but seemingly just forget their mission and goes into the nightclub to kick the band off the stage and start playing their own music. Then they are willing to follow orders again after a little while and when they come across Tokka and Rahzar, they start fighting them. During this fight, they attempt to kill Tokka and Rahzar, at which point they are stopped by being offered a battle of the bands, at which point they once again start ignoring orders and completely stop trying to fight Tokka and Rahzar. When the battle of the bands eventually comes, they don't even play because they think the other band is too good and just leave peacefully.

The way Waltz writes them follow a clear line of events that make sense with what we know about them and they always act in character, which in this case means obedient, dumb and violent, which each new action being influenced by the previous ones. While Campbell tries to write them in character to some extent, Campbell also keeps having them act out of character in case it suits the story and the conflict keeps ending abruptly with no clear cause and effect in place.

In short, Campbell's writing is far less coherent, and don't even get me started on the whole "It looked like Venus abducted herself" gibberish in the most recent issue.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH View Post
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.
Hahahaha!

Last edited by neatoman; 07-20-2022 at 07:38 AM.
neatoman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-20-2022, 05:50 AM   #99
Topsu
Hench Mutant
 
Topsu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Finland
Posts: 400
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
In short, Campbell's writing is far less coherent, and I don't even get me started on the whole "It looked like Venus abducted herself" gibberish in the most recent issue.
At some points I really felt punk frogs story could've been good, but then it had some of the worst art in series, and then that "abduction" that made really no sense at all.

I don't really hate Campbell run, it has it's good points, but it's been a slow burner. Can't remember anything as stupidly written as Venus abduction tho.
Topsu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-21-2022, 09:01 AM   #100
CyberCubed
Overlord
 
CyberCubed's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 43,917
Did anyone else think April and Oyuki were having lesbian sex behind the scenes in the Archie series? I always got that vibe from them since they were living together. I wish we could have known.
CyberCubed is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:33 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.