The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > General TMNT Discussion

Notices

View Poll Results: Who's the best fighter of the TMNT?
Michelangelo 12 17.14%
Donatello 6 8.57%
Leonardo 41 58.57%
Raphael 11 15.71%
Voters: 70. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 12-01-2005, 10:37 AM   #121
Ryona
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Oy... *shakes her head* You just had to bring fifth turtles into this, didn't you?
  Reply With Quote
Old 12-01-2005, 10:45 AM   #122
Anarky
Outlaw Hero
 
Anarky's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tannhauser Gate
Posts: 4,867
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Oy... *shakes her head* You just had to bring fifth turtles into this, didn't you?
I second that. And seeing that I'm having major issues about fifth turtles, I have the following statement to make:

ARGH!!! Why you...? Urge to kill... ARHHH!!!

Thank you.
Anarky is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-01-2005, 11:02 AM   #123
Sewer Bull
Devil's Advocate
 
Sewer Bull's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 4,768
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Oy... *shakes her head* You just had to bring fifth turtles into this, didn't you?
Yes. Since yesterday, I'm widely known as the Tsar of Turpitude.

Frankly speaking, I think this thread should have already been locked, as the further discussion seems to be rather pointless, because all the sides of this conflict have ran out of the reasonable arguments (and they repeat what they had stated before). Otherwise someone will post something in here in 2007 for sure, stating that "Rrraphie is the best".

Thus spake Sewerbulla.
__________________

Soooo... THIS is how you spend your free time now?!
Sewer Bull is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-01-2005, 11:39 AM   #124
XERO
Hybrid Theorist
 
XERO's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Alamo City
Posts: 8,185
Sorry, Sewer Bull, but this was one issue I chose to stay out of.

Thanks, though. I feel honored to be mentioned here.

Besides, I'm not even the second best fighter, and definitely not the last.

Sorry, Ryona and Anarky. I had nothing to do with that one.

If you guys want, I could make a thread about MY fighting skills.
__________________

"Travel at the speed of light... then hit the nitro!"
XERO is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-01-2005, 05:18 PM   #125
GK Punk
I'm your Devil
 
GK Punk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 12,439
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anarky
I dunno... to me, the TMNT or the way the stories are told, always seemed different. Like, there's no main character, no main Turtle so to say. I admit that the new toon could be renamed "Leonardo feat. the TMNT" at the moment, but I believe that it will change again. Personally, I wouldn't be against a couple of "Donatello feat. the TMNT" episodes...
Go back and read my post again, I highlighted a certain part of her post
GK Punk is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 06:38 AM   #126
trexmaster
Thug
 
trexmaster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 55
Quote:
I am sick to death of people making Raphael out to be some stupid mindless cave man. Yes the turtle has anger issues but he isn't some dumb drooling beast. I can't speak for Mirage Raphael, I really believe that New toon Raphael deseves better respect than this assumption.
I'm sorry, I was too hard on him. I sometimes am infuriated when some people here bash Mikey, sometimes to the point where I think very ugly thoughts, and yet I was bashing Raph, and therefore I did the same thing to many of his fans. My apologies for my unfair words.

Last edited by trexmaster; 12-02-2005 at 06:53 AM.
trexmaster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 10:18 AM   #127
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
It's true that Mikey is the most agile, but Leo is right behind Mikey in that category
Actually, according to the Palladium TMNT RPG, Leo is not "right behind" Mikey in that category. There is twice the difference between Mike and Leo as there is between Leo and Raph. Look it up.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Leo is also very cunning, an excellent strategist and tacticion, and has a natural affinity for warfare and such.
I will admit Leonardo is a great natural leader, but nothing I have seen him do in either the new show nor the Mirage series has led me to believe he has a greater understanding of tactics or strategy than any of the others (with the possible exception of Raphael). In fact, I would pick Donatello as the one to excel in that category.

Not that things like "strategy" have anything to do with real martial arts or real fights. In a real life-or-death situation, you don't have time to think. You can't think.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 10:22 AM   #128
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Now, I love Mikey, and no offense to Mikey fans, but I just don't get why he got any votes. Yes, he's the most agile, but it takes a Hell of alot more than being quick on your feet to be a superb fighter. Leo is superb in all aspects of fighting. He's a natural fighter where as Mikey is simply a natural athlete.
I voted for Michelangelo on the basis of what I have seen him do in the Mirage series and new show, outside information like the FoxBox website and Palladium RPG, and my own understanding of budo (as partial as it may be).

From what I have seen, Leonardo makes for a good "robot" martial artist that most people expect of budoka, but does not genuinely understand or express the budo spirit. Personally, I don't think ninpo is the ideal art for him, as it is very much at odds with his personality and training approach.

Additionally, Michelangelo has been described as the "natural fighter" of the bunch --- meaning, he has the greatest intrinsic talen in the martial arts --- whereas Leonardo is the most well-trained.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 10:52 AM   #129
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
I've noticed that things like this always look more clear when you work it out mathematicly.

We can work out a fighter's statistics through some basic categories...
  • Physical strength and endurance.
  • Agility, speed, and reflexes.
  • Resourceful thinking, scanning, and calculating.
  • Spirit, focus, and drive.
I personally don't agree with the aforementioned list at all, nor is it the approach to combat taken in ninpo.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Setting the scoring system as 1 - 5 (1 being the lowest and 5 being the highest), here's the rating for each TMNT...
Many of these statistics have already been laid out in the Palladium TMNT RPG, which Eastman & Laird worked closely on in the early days of the license and which Dan Berger told me is a more or less agreed upon interpretation of their characters.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Physical strength and endurance

Leo - 4
Don - 3
Raph - 5
Mikey - 3
This is completely wrong.

In terms of Physical Strength (P.S.), their actual scores are:
- Raphael: 20
- Michelangelo: 16
- Leonardo: 15
- Donatello: 13

In terms of Physical Endurance (P.E.)., their actual scores are:
- Raphael: 20
- Leonardo: 18
- Michelangelo: 17
- Donatello: 13

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Agility, speed, and reflexes

Leo - 4
Don - 3
Raph - 3
Mikey - 5
Close, but somewhat off the mark.

In terms of Physical Prowess (P.P.), the actual scores are:
- Michelangelo: 24
- Leonardo: 20
- Raphael: 18
- Donatello: 17

In terms of Speed (Spd.), the actual scores are:
- Raphael: 15
- Michelangelo: 14
- Leonardo: 11
- Donatello: 10


Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Resourceful thinking, scanning, and calculating

Leo - 4
Don - 5
Raph - 3
Mikey - 3
The closest equivalent to this in the RPG is Intelligence Quotient (I.Q.), which doesn't directly have anything to do with combat:
- Donatello: 19
- Leonardo: 16
- Raphael: 12
- Michelangelo: 11

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Spirit, focus, and drive

Leo - 5
Don - 3
Raph - 3
Mikey - 3
Difficult to evaluate this, but the closest things are Mental Endurance (M.E.) and Mental Affinity (M.A.).

Mental Endurance (M.E.):
- Leonardo: 16
- Donatello: 15
- Michelangelo: 14
- Raphael: 13

Mental Affinity (M.A.):
- Michelangelo: 19
- Leonardo: 17
- Donatello: 13
- Raphael: 11

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Total Fighter rank...

Leo - 17
Don - 14
Raph - 14
Mikey -14
Well, ignoring Physical Beauty (P.B.) here, the total rank of the TMNT's actual Palladium attributes are:
- Raphael: 109
- Leonardo: 113
- Donatello: 99
- Michelangelo: 115

So --- going by Intelligence Quotient, Mental Endurance, Mental Affinity, Physical Strength, Physical Endurance, Physical Prowess, and Speed alone --- Michelangelo just edges out Leonardo, barely.

Of course, some of these attributes don't directly affect combat (such as I.Q.) but I would be willing to accept alternative uses of the relative ability scores outside of the mechanics of the Palladium combat system. Additionally, there are other things to take into consideration in the game (Leonardo, for example, is one experience level higher than Michelangelo which means he has one more attack per melee round and a slightly higher Weapon Proficiency bonus). But, all in all, they're pretty evenly matched.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
I really think that the official site should have a ranking chart like this posted up. It's clear, honest, true, and fair.
There is already an "official ranking chart" like this in the Palladium TMNT RPG. Look it up.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 11:20 AM   #130
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
As for the TMNT's official combat skills in the TMNT RPG....

Raphael
- Attacks Per Melee: 6
- Unarmed: +5 to Strike, +7 to Parry/Dodge, +5 to Damage, +8 to Roll With Punch or Fall, +3 to Pull Punch
- Sai: +8 to Strike, +9 to Parry, +6 to Throw, +9 to Entangle

Leonardo
- Attacks Per Melee: 6
- Unarmed: +6 to Strike, +8 to Parry/Dodge, +2 to Damage, +7 to Roll With Punch or Fall, +3 to Pull Punch
- Katana: +9 to Strike, +11 to Parry, +7 to Throw
- Wakizashi: +9 to Strike, +10 to Parry, +8 to Throw

Donatello
- Attacks Per Melee: 5
- Unarmed: +3 to Strike, +3 to Parry/Dodge, +2 to Damage, +3 to Roll With Punch or Fall, +3 to Pull Punch
- Bo: +6 to Strike, +4 to Parry, +4 to Throw

Michelangelo
- Attacks Per Melee: 5
- Unarmed: +7 to Strike, +9 to Parry/Dodge, +3 to Damage, +5 to Roll With Punch or Fall, +3 to Pull Punch
- Nunchaku: +10 to Strike, +10 to Parry, +7 to Throw, +10 to Entangle

Weapons
- Sai: Forked Weapon, 1D6 Damage, can entangle one-handed
- Katana: Large Sword, 2D6 Damage
- Wakizashi: Small Sword, 1D8 Damage
- Bo: Staff Weapon, 1D8 Damage
- Nunchaku: Chained Weapon, 1D8 Damage, can entangle two-handed

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 12:35 PM   #131
Ryona
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Oh, come on, Heretic... You follow those Palladium rules so seriously as if they were the ten commandments.

First, those character statistics where writin in 1985. That's only one year after the release of the first TMNT comic book. I would certainly believe that Eastman & Laird where still developing the TMNT during that time and nothing was writin in stone yet.

Second, Palladium isn't really a great system. There's other ones out there that are better, like White Wolf for example.
I mean, come on! You really think the stats in the Palladium book are so flawless? Have you not noticed the mathematical errors in that book? Lol!

Third, since you are following the Palladium books so rigidly, you'll notice that you really haven't been telling it like it is when you base it on their writen profiles.


Further more, how can you say that my writen stats are ****ing wrong? My calculations are based on near 20 years of observation where as those Palladium stats (some which are mathematicly incorrect) were based on a single year of TMNT when the boys where still going through developement.


A final note... You're quite knowledgable in ninpo and the martial arts in general, but it really isn't right to warp facts so that your favorite shines brightly beyond the rest. You give Mikey way too much credit and the others (especially Leo) way too little. I would seriously respect your opinion if it wasn't so biased.

And just so you know... Peter Laird himself said that Leo is the most excellent fighter of the four. You can't argue with that.


Ciao.
  Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 02:29 PM   #132
Rhane
Random Punk
 
Rhane's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: New York
Posts: 43
This has gotten so outa control. You all got your answer on the best fighter and now all points have been exausted. Can't ya'll call it a day or have fun with it? It's not life or death. I know i'm not a patron here but the 'drome is know as being a fun and friendly place to talk tmnt, and i think we left friendly a while ago.
Rhane is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 02:32 PM   #133
DSWBandit
Random Punk
 
DSWBandit's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: East Bound and Down
Posts: 35
As much as I can like him, cold hard facts just state Donatello sucks. XD I still agree on the "TURTLE POWER!" teamwork theory though. They won't get far without each other, but one to get the farthest on his own would have to be Leo. That's why i voted for me.
*slowly slips out hoping no one will notice his post and won't get caught up in the heated "serious" discussion*
__________________
The Lost Woods Forum <-- Dare to Enter?

The Lost Village Animal Crossing Forum

(Another link coming soon, I hope)

The DSW <-- Explains the "DSW" part of my name.

"If you shoot wolves to save moose and then you shoot the moose you're either out of your mind or in Alaska"
DSWBandit is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 02:55 PM   #134
Ryona
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
You guys are over-reacting a little bit. It's just a heated debate (which should be over by now with Peter Laird's authoritive word). When it comes to polls like this, opinions are going to clash. There's going to be those who are right and those who are baised. That's how it usually is.


And I just want to say that Donnie kicks alot of ass. If your opinion on Donnie was based on those ridiculous stats Heretic posted, I say to just ignore them. Those stats are just from a flimsy RPG system that some guy wrote after hearing a breif and loose discription of the boys back in 1985 when the TMNT were only in one year of their existence.
  Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 04:38 PM   #135
Jester
Rat-faced Dude-guy
 
Jester's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Arkansas
Posts: 26,301
So....his facts are biased, though from knowledge, but yours weren't? I think we all have our biases....there's no escaping it. I think that the guide book, though it is only a year into the TMNT's existance may hold water. It was thought out, even if the TMNTs characters weren't yet.
__________________

"Clearly, you're Ninja Turtling incorrectly." - Leo656
Jester is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-02-2005, 06:31 PM   #136
trexmaster
Thug
 
trexmaster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 55
Quote:
And just so you know... Peter Laird himself said that Leo is the most excellent fighter of the four. You can't argue with that.
First, Laird is only one of the TMNT's creators. Second, from what I know, his response was very vague and tongue-in-cheek, making its reliability questionable.
trexmaster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-03-2005, 02:02 PM   #137
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Oh, come on, Heretic...
Oh, come on, Ryona...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
You follow those Palladium rules so seriously as if they were the ten commandments.
First off, I take all moral religious prescripts --- including the Ten Commandments --- with a rather hefty grain of salt.

Secondly, I was just putting the information out there for what it is. You wanted an "official" ruling on the TMNT's various attributes and abilities, well the TMNT & Other Strangeness RPG is the closest thing we have to that. It certainly beats your self-selected system --- in which many of the scores you gave (such as the Strength and Endurance rankings) were intentionally designed to favor Leonardo --- by a considerable degree.

Thirdly, I actually emailed Dan Berger about the Palladium attribute scores some time back. He flat-out told me that Eastman and Laird agreed with Palladium's interpretation of their characters. End of story.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
First, those character statistics where writin in 1985.
Sure, but the revised edition was published in 1993. None of the attribute scores had changed (although other parts of the TMNT's profiles had, such as their particular Secondary Skills).

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
That's only one year after the release of the first TMNT comic book. I would certainly believe that Eastman & Laird where still developing the TMNT during that time and nothing was writin in stone yet.
This is indeed a possibility.

However, it is a logical fallacy to assume that because things may not have been "writin in stone" at this point in time that the aforementioned attribute scores would be different if written today. In fact, given FoxBox's original online profiles of the characters and their portrayal in issue 10 of the new Mirage TMNT series, that does not seem to be the case at all.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Second, Palladium isn't really a great system. There's other ones out there that are better, like White Wolf for example.
I mean, come on! You really think the stats in the Palladium book are so flawless? Have you not noticed the mathematical errors in that book? Lol!
This is just a Red Herring on your part. The "greatness" of Palladium as an RPG system has nothing to do with the discussion at hand.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Third, since you are following the Palladium books so rigidly, you'll notice that you really haven't been telling it like it is when you base it on their writen profiles.
So, I take the exact numbers directly taken from the book, but I'm not "telling it like it is", huh?

Two words: Prove. It.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Further more, how can you say that my writen stats are ****ing wrong?
Because some of them --- such as Leonardo having a higher Strength and Endurance rating than Michelangelo or Donatello --- are just stuff you made up to support your argument. In social psychology, we call these self-confirming biases.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
My calculations are based on near 20 years of observation
In other words, you're making a fallacious Appeal To Authority, based on the fact that you've been a fan for close to 20 years. You aren't actually providing support for your position, just requiring others to trust your judgment because you've put in some down-time.

I've been "observing" the TMNT since 1988, so what does that make me??

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
where as those Palladium stats (some which are mathematicly incorrect) were based on a single year of TMNT when the boys where still going through developement.
Those Palladium stats were also endorsed by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird, a fact which was confirmed to me by Dan Berger. Your stats are just your own opinions, some of which are unsupported by any external evidence.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
A final note... You're quite knowledgable in ninpo and the martial arts in general, but it really isn't right to warp facts so that your favorite shines brightly beyond the rest.
Kettle, pot, black??

I suggest you actually re-read my posts, as I don't claim Mike "shines brightly beyond the rest". The same, however, cannot be said for you.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
You give Mikey way too much credit and the others (especially Leo) way too little. I would seriously respect your opinion if it wasn't so biased.
Again: kettle, pot, black??

Actually, if you'll look at my previous posts, you'll see that I only claim that Mike edges out on Leo by a slight margin. A 115 compared to a 113 is hardly more than a 1.5% differential, hardly anything to get worked up about.

Even when we compare the TMNT's combat bonuses, the only one of them who performs decidedly lower than the others is Donatello. If it came down to Raph, Mike, or Leo, my money would be on the luck of the draw.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
And just so you know... Peter Laird himself said that Leo is the most excellent fighter of the four. You can't argue with that.
I can by putting it in context, something you are reluctant to do.

For example, I'm the one that wrote the letter to Peter Laird so it was based on a question that I specifically asked. His answer was vague, tongue-in-cheek, and hardly conclusive. Any casual observer could easily make note of that.

Plus, as a psychology student, I am well aware of the fact that creative productions can have a mind and life of their own well beyond the conscious decisions and opinions of their creators.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Ciao.
Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-03-2005, 02:09 PM   #138
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
And I just want to say that Donnie kicks alot of ass. If your opinion on Donnie was based on those ridiculous stats Heretic posted, I say to just ignore them. Those stats are just from a flimsy RPG system that some guy wrote after hearing a breif and loose discription of the boys back in 1985 when the TMNT were only in one year of their existence.
You, of course, have no evidence to support this conjecture. It is nothing more than wild, baseless speculation on your part.

I emailed Dan Berger about the Palladium attribute scores. He confirmed that Eastman and Laird agreed with their interpretations of their characters. That similar descriptions were given on the original FoxBox website (such as Michelangelo being a "natural athlete", a fact that is only corroborated by the Palladium RPG) and allusions to these qualities were demonstrated in issue 10 of the new Mirage TMNT comic (where Raph was lifting weights, Mike was practicing with an 'agility machine', and Leo was practicing kata with a bokken), only further supports this supposition.

Before you start screaming about everyone else's "bias", you should perhaps take a look in the mirror.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-03-2005, 02:19 PM   #139
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
In case anyone is intersted, this is exactly what Dan Berger said to me via email over a year ago....

DB: "[The Palladium RPG stats] are as official as it gets."

DB: "Kevin and Pete worked very closely with Palladium during the early years, as there wasn't really any other TMNT licensing going on at the time."

H888: "Did Kev and Pete agree with Palladium's basic interpretation and presentation of the characters??"
DB: "Yes."

H888: "Did they 'approve' everything?"
DB: "Yes."

I think his answers are pretty straightforward.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-03-2005, 02:26 PM   #140
Sewer Bull
Devil's Advocate
 
Sewer Bull's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 4,768
Hmm... heretic, how about editing your initial post instead of writing new ones after a few minutes?
__________________

Soooo... THIS is how you spend your free time now?!
Sewer Bull is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:14 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.