PDA

View Full Version : Thoughts on the new movie!


Pages : 1 [2] 3

VaughnMichael
03-24-2007, 11:44 PM
they can ban me for that all I care. As far as I'm concerned double posting = the same post twice. I don't care how far apart a person's two posts are.
I just know I hate it when I've read a post once and then someone edits something in and I miss it because I THOUGHT I had read the post already. I don't think it's fair to myself to write something long and thought provoking and then have everyone miss it just because they had already read the previous unrelated post and i had to edit it into that one.
ok blue dude I think you just need to step back for a moment man.

Peanut
03-24-2007, 11:48 PM
they can ban me for that all I care.

I don't think that's what you want. So maybe you should just step back for a minute and breathe a bit. You don't really want to get yourself thrown out, do you?

If you're really that adamant about arguing your point about the movie, then make your own thread and post all your related thoughts there. In a civil matter, might I add. There's no need to go around and turn every thread into a flame war, alright?

You might also want to remove the text from your signature. It's not necessary, it makes you look silly, and it's only going to get you in more hot water.

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-24-2007, 11:50 PM
I don't think that's what you want. So maybe you should just step back for a minute and breathe a bit. You don't really want to get yourself thrown out, do you?

If you're really that adamant about arguing your point about the movie, then make your own thread and post all your related thoughts there. In a civil matter, might I add. There's no need to go around and turn every thread into a flame war, alright?

You might also want to remove the text from your signature. It's not necessary, it makes you look silly, and it's only going to get you in more hot water.

Agreed, although I will say he tried to have his own thread, but Anarky locked it (started getting ugly). And he's slowly poisoning this one, come to think of it...:ohwell:

blueoakleyz
03-24-2007, 11:51 PM
I don't think that's what you want. So maybe you should just step back for a minute and breathe a bit. You don't really want to get yourself thrown out, do you?

If you're really that adamant about arguing your point about the movie, then make your own thread and post all your related thoughts there. In a civil matter, might I add. There's no need to go around and turn every thread into a flame war, alright?

You might also want to remove the text from your signature. It's not necessary, it makes you look silly, and it's only going to get you in more hot water.


I'm just saying if they WANT to ban me for what the dark side of the internet has deemed double posting (Posting two completely unrelated posts back to back. Personally I don't care HOW many other posts separate someone's posts, if I read something and someone edits something new into it it pisses me off) then so be it..

I think you people have a different interpretation of the internet than I do.. the whole point of it to me is that I can never BE in a hot water or look silly

Zachatello00
03-24-2007, 11:52 PM
Not that all of this isn't fun, but back to thoughts on the new movie:

I think Mikey said it best: The Turtles are back. Definatly looking forward to the sequel. Hopefully Donnie will have a bigger role this time around.

Masked Ninja
03-24-2007, 11:53 PM
Listen, in the old movies, there are REAL people doing REAL martial arts/stunts/action. They aren't usually hurting each other but they make the illusion they are. Of course that's what a movie is about, making an illusion. You can SEE with your own eyes people doing the moves, so in your imagination you have no reason to believe it isn't actually happening. In a cartoon, where no one is actually doing anything, it works if you need to move the story along but to showcase martial arts or skateboarding skill, it makes no sense. It's like "Why am I supposed to be impressed by some guys skills with a mouse and a computer??"I can understand this sentiment, however much I disagree with it.

Though the fact that you imply computer animation is somehow easy, like a few clicks of the mouse = bam! movie! grates me a little. I would argue that it's almost as hard to get a certain action to look right (especially in three dimensions!) as it is to learn that action. And the skateboard scene was one of the better animated scenes of the movie. Mikey had weight, and you could feel it by watching it. It wasn't real, but it felt real enough. To me, at least.

Heh, I wish I wasn't an animation major sometimes, though. The quality of the animation itself was up and down throughout the movie, especially weak in lipsync. And that, I think, has prevented me from enjoying it as much as I could have... especially since I knew the monster story was going to be cheesy, but I had really high hopes for the animation. Luckily everything was firing on all cylinders for the Leo/Raph fight, which was my favorite scene anyway (everything was good for that part).

I've been digesting the movie all day today (kinda had to, with that crazy pace) and I really do want to see it again... I didn't all that much when I left the theater last night. And I must have watched the "Who said I wanted to be led?!" clip on IGN about 5 times this morning. Awesome stuff. The DVD will be worth it just for that scene alone. Probably my favorite in Turtle history so far. Bonus features will, of course, sweeten the deal.

Raven
03-24-2007, 11:54 PM
I never did read the comics.
The cartoons were good to me because of the characters. I can't explain it. When they fought you'd get into it. I think fighting was more of an expression of the story in the cartoon. It just doesn't work for me in the 2K3 series.

Here's the general thought/notion that goes through my mind: In real life when you watch martial arts you enjoy it because it takes actual skill, it's something not everyone can do. Then there are cartoons or movies such as this one that might take a skill based thing like skateboarding, and try to impress the audience, but it just comes off as silly since it's just really some guy at a computer drawing it. Take video games for example. Some like Tekken or Mortal Kombat show the characters doing katas. How is this supposed to impress me?


Can some give me his internet provider so I can do us all a favor and cut this guy off from saying any more stupid things?

I know you mean well but your insulting alot of artists with this one comment, please rethink what you just said because thats a very ignorant view sir.

ZariusTwo
03-24-2007, 11:54 PM
Guys, ignore him, you're falling right into his trap and dragging the topic off of the movie, which is what this idiot wants. Ban him, and move forward

Peanut
03-24-2007, 11:56 PM
Agreed, although I will say he tried to have his own thread, but Anarky locked it (started getting ugly).

Which is why I said he should go about it in a civil matter. ;)

I'm just saying if they WANT to ban me for what the dark side of the internet has deemed double posting (Posting two completely unrelated posts back to back. Personally I don't care HOW many other posts separate someone's posts, if I read something and someone edits something new into it it pisses me off) then so be it..

I think you people have a different interpretation of the internet than I do.. the whole point of it to me is that I can never BE in a hot water or look silly

You won't get banned for double posting, dude. That's just crazy talk. Anyways, I'm only trying to help you out here. You don't need to get so hostile all over the place. And maybe your view of the internet is what's making you a not-so-liked character around here? You can indeed be both in trouble and look silly on the internet, in fact, it's not very difficult at all.

If you're willing to be warned, or what have you, go ahead and keep doing what you're doing. You won't make friends that way, and what's the point in hanging around if you can't enjoy yourself?

Now if we could, everyone, back onto the topic of the movie!

Zachatello00
03-25-2007, 12:02 AM
Zarius is right, and in that spirit, I'm gonna try again.

So, here's somethin' we can talk about. Casey and April were living together. Discuss.

Splinter's Iroonna
03-25-2007, 12:04 AM
My god sometimes it really grates at me when people can't understand what I'm talking about just because they are a tad bit complex.

Listen, in the old movies, there are REAL people doing REAL martial arts/stunts/action. They aren't usually hurting each other but they make the illusion they are. Of course that's what a movie is about, making an illusion. You can SEE with your own eyes people doing the moves, so in your imagination you have no reason to believe it isn't actually happening. In a cartoon, where no one is actually doing anything, it works if you need to move the story along but to showcase martial arts or skateboarding skill, it makes no sense. It's like "Why am I supposed to be impressed by some guys skills with a mouse and a computer??"

Maybe because, in the time-honored tradition of ANIMATION, regardless of whether it's pen and paper or click the mouse-- the animators not only studied art, they studied LIFE!

Your argument is similar to those who blow off voice actors as not being "real" actors-- and that is forgetting that radio was the first really mass medium around.

And why am I wasting time with you? You remind me of a certain Australian that I became rather fond of in a weird way-- and at that I will end this post.

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-25-2007, 12:04 AM
Zarius is right, and in that spirit, I'm gonna try again.

So, here's somethin' we can talk about. Casey and April were living together. Discuss.

Natural progression in their relationship. I liked it, even though Casey appeared to be worried about "settling down".

Zachatello00
03-25-2007, 12:05 AM
And I definatly pointed out where the "family friendly" are concerned, that Casey was definatly sleeping on the couch, and was obviously not around when April got dressed in her Ninja outfit.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:07 AM
Natural progression in their relationship. I liked it, even though Casey appeared to be worried about "settling down".
yeah it was even worse in the paper back novel I'm glad it didn't show how mean april was to him in the movie because the story in the book really ticked me off over Aprils actions towards Casey.:ohwell:
And I definatly pointed out where the "family friendly" are concerned, that Casey was definatly sleeping on the couch, and was obviously not around when April got dressed in her Ninja outfit.
very true I told my grandmother today it's safe to take the kids to see my uncle and his wife are very strict chrisitians and and keep their children away from allot of things.
But I told them the movie teaches very good moral values as well as family ones about being a good family and obeying your father.

ZariusTwo
03-25-2007, 12:09 AM
Natural progression in their relationship. I liked it, even though Casey appeared to be worried about "settling down".

Agreed. April acted as the professional when it came to buisness, but that excellent line when Casey joins Raph on the rooftop shows he really still has her on edge. She seems more concerned with living up to HIS specialty of street vigilantism, to be his equal.

Splinter's Iroonna
03-25-2007, 12:09 AM
Actually, I really think that they ALL felt "comfortable"-- you could tell that they'd been friends/family for a long time, not just April and Casey in their "settling down" situation, but the Turtles with them-- though Mike seemed rather "surprised" by the apt.-- but that may have been the fact that they'd not been around much due to all their new ventures.

Still-- turtles and humans (meaning Casey and April) definitely felt as if they were truly OLD friends/family.

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-25-2007, 12:10 AM
yeah it was even worse in the paper back novel I'm glad it didn't show how mean april was to him in the movie because the story in the book really ticked me off over Aprils actions towards Casey.

Yeah I'm glad they toned it down there, too. She came off as a real, well, witch with a capital 'B' in the book--And I like April too much to watch her acting like that. Oh but did you catch the pout she made while talking to Casey on the phone?! It was...wierd to me. I can't explain it.

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 12:11 AM
Maybe because, in the time-honored tradition of ANIMATION, regardless of whether it's pen and paper or click the mouse-- the animators not only studied art, they studied LIFE!

Your argument is similar to those who blow off voice actors as not being "real" actors-- and that is forgetting that radio was the first really mass medium around.

And why am I wasting time with you? You remind me of a certain Australian that I became rather fond of in a weird way-- and at that I will end this post.

Your argument is like one of those people who like to compare one argument with a completely unrelated argument so as to make that person look like he's one of those people too. Yah? hahaa
I never said anything about voice actors not being real actors, so that has nothing to do with this.

Zachatello00
03-25-2007, 12:12 AM
Stow it dude, we're all over it.


I think that what Splinter's Iroonna's said was probably spot on. I mean, even though Mike did seem a little suprised by the apt, April's talk with Leo in the jungle certainly alluded to the fact that they were all still hanging out.

iris
03-25-2007, 12:12 AM
Here's the general thought/notion that goes through my mind: In real life when you watch martial arts you enjoy it because it takes actual skill, it's something not everyone can do. Then there are cartoons or movies such as this one that might take a skill based thing like skateboarding, and try to impress the audience, but it just comes off as silly since it's just really some guy at a computer drawing it.

That's the first thing you've said that's made any sense to me. Consider, if you will, that the intent of the skateboarding scene was to do several things, only a minor part of which was "impress the audience."

1. Say hello to Mikey being... er... Mikey. Keep up! He's doing pointless tricks and making wisecracks with no audience except himself... this is typical of Mikey, and it's not an unrealistic character trait. What a happy-go-lucky guy, right?

2. Welcome to Turtletown, with your host, Michelangelo! We follow Mikey from his job, down the streets, down a neglected alley, into a camoflaged garage, down a manhole, down a ladder, down... and down... and down... and we get a feel for how far deep into hiding the turtles are. And that is, really far! The route is impossibly labyrinthine. The front door is hidden. Mikey's home is literally a deep, dark secret.

3. Honey, we're home! Eh... honey? Anyone? Bueller? Oops... Mikey's manic rush has come to a dead end in disappointment. And that's the point: we've witnessed Mikey descend into a lonely place. It's practially a visual metaphor for a spiral into depression, and Mike's the perfect guide. Mr. Party Dude ends up watching a business report.

Oh wait, I didn't include the part where they're trying to impress the audience with Mikey's skateboard tricks. That's because I couldn't figure out how it fits. It was kinda incidental to the main point.

And even if you disagree, this post was still fun to write. I loved the skateboard scene!

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 12:12 AM
Yeah I'm glad they toned it down there, too. She came off as a real, well, witch with a capital 'B' in the book--And I like April too much to watch her acting like that. Oh but did you catch the pout she made while talking to Casey on the phone?! It was...wierd to me. I can't explain it.

I certainly did not like how they made it seem like Casey was a slave to April. Or like one of those guys that's so in love with a woman they'll do anything for them even if they treat them like a dog. Certainly not the same relationship as in TMNT1

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:13 AM
Yeah I'm glad they toned it down there, too. She came off as a real, well, witch with a capital 'B' in the book--And I like April too much to watch her acting like that. Oh but did you catch the pout she made while talking to Casey on the phone?! It was...wierd to me. I can't explain it.
lordy me also I'm glad I wasn't the only one to notice that in the book..I worried about it the whole time till I saw the movie. I'm sooo glad it didn't go that way.
And I believe it was odd because we hardly ever see April acting typical "Girly" in anything and that for sure was a ugh my man drives me crazy moment lol.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:14 AM
I think that what Splinter's Iroonna's said was probably spot on. I mean, even though Mike did seem a little suprised by the apt, April's talk with Leo in the jungle certainly alluded to the fact that they were all still hanging out.
don't be to sure of that she had no idea Leonardo was there she just happend to be there collecting the statues for Max.

Zachatello00
03-25-2007, 12:17 AM
I'm just talking about the fireside chat that they had. In which she said "our little group hasn't been the same without you." Then went on to describe what everyone was up to.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:20 AM
And even if you disagree, this post was still fun to write. I loved the skateboard scene!
whats this could it be we dissagree for the first time ever...that scene is everything I've really ever hated about computer animated movies that makes them seen like cartoons from the 1920's where they dance around and act all show offish looky here by golly we made us a movin' picture movie!
The Garefield movie really does this to me as well as the one coming out the bee movie...they really need to stop with this and just get back to making movies. TMNT was a good example of what to do correctly.
I'm just talking about the fireside chat that they had. In which she said "our little group hasn't been the same without you." Then went on to describe what everyone was up to.
Yes but that could elude that Leo has been gone a very long time.
I'm sure we will see just exactly how long he's been away with the prequel comics...and as you can see in the movie alone they hadn;t been around april or casey at all for some time excluding Aprils contact with Leo in the jungle.

Raven
03-25-2007, 12:20 AM
I loved the short little scenes bewteen April and Casey, plus it was nice to finally see some progression in there relation ship like Kunoichi_Haruko had said.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:22 AM
I certainly did not like how they made it seem like Casey was a slave to April. Or like one of those guys that's so in love with a woman they'll do anything for them even if they treat them like a dog. Certainly not the same relationship as in TMNT1
They didn't have much of a relationship in the first movie though..and it's been years since that anything could have happend between them.
I just wonder what exactly is being used from the past and whats not exactly a list of things on the official site or in the comic book from peter laird would be nice.

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-25-2007, 12:23 AM
lordy me also I'm glad I wasn't the only one to notice that in the book..I worried about it the whole time till I saw the movie. I'm sooo glad it didn't go that way.
And I believe it was odd because we hardly ever see April acting typical "Girly" in anything and that for sure was a ugh my man drives me crazy moment lol.


Aha! That's exactly it! She went, like, Snotty Valley Girl on us in .2 seconds right there! Rolling her eyes and shaking her head, I expected. The pout? A little OOC, but that's just my opinion. Lucky for me, that was the only one she had.
And speaking of April...SMG did very well with her delivery on most of her lines. At first I thought she'd be pausing like crazy, but she didn't. Yay SMG! :)

Ecto Jedi
03-25-2007, 12:24 AM
They didn't have much of a relationship in the first movie though..and it's been years since that anything could have happend between them.
I just wonder what exactly is being used from the past and whats not exactly a list of things on the official site or in the comic book from peter laird would be nice.

I'm intrigued as to how many "official" years have past since TMNT 3 (or the original film, depending on this film's continuity.) Everyone has definitely drifted apart, so I'm assuming a good chunk of time has gone by...But the Turtles are still Teenaged, so who knows?

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:25 AM
Aha! That's exactly it! She went, like, Snotty Valley Girl on us in .2 seconds right there! Rolling her eyes and shaking her head, I expected. The pout? A little OOC, but that's just my opinion. Lucky for me, that was the only one she had.
And speaking of April...SMG did very well with her delivery on most of her lines. At first I thought she'd be pausing like crazy, but she didn't. Yay SMG! :)
I agree she was great as April especially as some one I didn't think could ever pull it off.
I'm intrigued as to how many "official" years have past since TMNT 3 (or the original film, depending on this film's continuity.) Everyone has definitely drifted apart, so I'm assuming a good chunk of time has gone by...But the Turtles are still Teenaged, so who knows?
yeah really some one should write in to mirage and ask.

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 12:30 AM
To me this movie was a loose sequel to the movies. It's kinda nice to think that the connection is there, but also see they just don't have EXACTLY the same characterizations. For me it's hard to tie these guys in directly with TMNT3.

Although I just assumed it was two years. One year for training, one year to stay extra in south america

Raven
03-25-2007, 12:30 AM
Aha! That's exactly it! She went, like, Snotty Valley Girl on us in .2 seconds right there! Rolling her eyes and shaking her head, I expected. The pout? A little OOC, but that's just my opinion. Lucky for me, that was the only one she had.
And speaking of April...SMG did very well with her delivery on most of her lines. At first I thought she'd be pausing like crazy, but she didn't. Yay SMG! :)


Yeah SMG did a fantastic job, I didnt think she would be very good for the part but heh while watching the movie I forgot it was her.

Evans was pretty good, but the turtles voice actors were very impressive.

iris
03-25-2007, 12:31 AM
whats this could it be we dissagree for the first time ever...that scene is everything I've really ever hated about computer animated movies that makes them seen like cartoons from the 1920's where they dance around and act all show offish looky here by golly we made us a movin' picture movie!
The Garefield movie really does this to me as well as the one coming out the bee movie...they really need to stop with this and just get back to making movies. TMNT was a good example of what to do correctly.
Oh no... you did NOT just compare TMNT to Garfield. :cry: Brother, you wound me. *sniffle*

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-25-2007, 12:34 AM
Evans was pretty good, but the turtles voice actors were very impressive.

Well that goes without saying. :P Nolan North was so incredibly...awesome. They all were, of course, but he impressed me so very much. He's as good as Josh Pais, IMO.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 12:35 AM
Oh no... you did NOT just compare TMNT to Garfield. :cry: Brother, you wound me. *sniffle*
hahah no you miss understand It was a bad example but ok seriously I hate those garfield movies he's a fat lazy cat that does next to nothing and what does he do runs around and dances more than anything...the skateboarding scene to me in this new movie was the worst point it was boring and very show offish something that bothers me allot with cgi animation...it's like saying hey look i'm flashy and fun look at me!!! It just doesn't roll well with me when they do things like that. I mean sure it would be fun to do that in a video game trying to get mike through all those sewer tunels and all.
But it just sort of comes up as a waste of time to me.:ohwell:

iris
03-25-2007, 12:49 AM
hahah no you miss understand It was a bad example but ok seriously I hate those garfield movies he's a fat lazy cat that does next to nothing and what does he do runs around and dances more than anything...the skateboarding scene to me in this new movie was the worst point it was boring and very show offish something that bothers me allot with cgi animation...it's like saying hey look i'm flashy and fun look at me!!! It just doesn't roll well with me when they do things like that. I mean sure it would be fun to do that in a video game trying to get mike through all those sewer tunels and all.
But it just sort of comes up as a waste of time to me.:ohwell:

lol... yeah, I got you. I guess I look at story really broadly, so I saw the point to the scene and it had nothing to do with skateboarding. I mean, they coulda had Mike just groove his way down to the lair door boppin' to his iPod... but instead they rushed him down on a skateboard. *shrug* I thought it worked.

I love skateboarding stunts. My cousin and my older brothers are all sk8rbois. Maybe that's why I didn't even consider being impressed with Mikey's tricks... to me it was more of a mode of transportation!

Dude, now you've got me wanting to play a skating video game. :lol: I'm going to bed!

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:01 AM
What?

the CGI was awful. The turtles looked good of course, but everything else looked awful. It was just an awful awful medium for a martial arts action movie. I hated when George Lucas did CGI in a live action movie, doing CGI the entire movie was disappointing.
The scene at the end with them fighting the foot with Splinter/April/Casey was awesome but short.


The CGI was awful?!? Dude, if you think it's awful then I would like to see you do better

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 01:02 AM
The CGI was awful?!? Dude, if you think it's awful then I would like to see you do better

So would I! Unfortunately I have not devoted my life to a medium which I feel will take years and years and years to ever look realistic.

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:12 AM
And the people that do are ****IN GREAT at it... not to mention are making a hell of a lot more money then you doin such a "unreleastic" form of story telling laughing at you as they read this(I'm sure if Kevin reads this topic he may relay it to the others) and will have a good laugh at your stupidity

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 01:14 AM
And the people that do are ****IN GREAT at it... not to mention are making a hell of a lot more money then you doin such a "unreleastic" form of story telling laughing at you as they read this(I'm sure if Kevin reads this topic he may relay it to the others) and will have a good laugh at your stupidity

not sure where you conclude they make more money than me..

I don't think they're doing a great job at it. To be honest it's weird but the first time I really saw it used a lot was in Jurassic Park and that somehow looked ultra realistic. Ever since, in Star Wars etc it's always looked bad.. noticeable and out of place.

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:28 AM
How do I conclude they make more money then you? They are working a major motion picture here... they are going to get paid a big chunk of change.

And right I feel that little Susie has more intelligence ... and I would love to hear your views on cartoons for not being realistic and made with a click of a mouse...

Masked Ninja
03-25-2007, 01:29 AM
Am I the only one that doesn't mind CGI not looking realistic? It's like in 2D animation - sometimes it's broad and cartoony, sometimes it's semi-realistic, and sometimes they go as close to full realism as they can. You know, style. As in, not a reflection of capability. Dreamworks' humans are pretty realistic, but they have a deadness to them (esp. the eyes) that I'm really glad TMNT didn't have. Even Advent Children, while looking quite nice and realistic, still looked dead to me... again, it was the eyes.

If they were trying to be realistic in this movie... then they failed. But amazingly enough, that was not their intent! How crazy!

I agree with iris in that my main appreciation for the skateboard scene was not only for the animation (though it did look pretty nice) but the fact that it showed how freaking hard it is to find the lair. These Turtles are well-hidden, which I liked very much... in the live-action movies it always seemed like any idiot could bungle into the lair. It was also a great personality showcase for Michelangelo, as he spent most of the movie in the back seat. Too bad Don didn't have a similar scene to shine... except for his horribly lame "this has Winter's name all over it!" joke. I guess Don's enough of a geek to make a bad joke like that, but yeesh. I like to see him being a cool geek. :)

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 01:31 AM
How do I conclude they make more money then you? They are working a major motion picture here... they are going to get paid a big chunk of change.

And right I feel that little Susie has more intelligence ... and I would love to hear your views on cartoons for not being realistic and made with a click of a mouse...

You have no clue about my background, that conclusion makes no sense.
We're talking about the CGI animators right? Well how much do you think their yearly salary is?

Cascadia
03-25-2007, 01:31 AM
The only other time that Donnie was being weird is the phone at the beginning of the movie. But I agree it is too bad that he did not have too many good scenes. As for the CGI, I loved how it was done....I did not mind it.

Rooish
03-25-2007, 01:31 AM
Aaaahhhhh everyone chill out. He isn't a troll because he claims that he hated the animation. If he hated it, that's his opinion. I thought the humans looked pretty bad myself, although other parts were sweet.

He is a troll when he embraces the term, though.

Edit: Just read his post to Kevin Munroe. Yeah, troll.

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:37 AM
Am I the only one that doesn't mind CGI not looking realistic? It's like in 2D animation - sometimes it's broad and cartoony, sometimes it's semi-realistic, and sometimes they go as close to full realism as they can. You know, style. As in, not a reflection of capability. Dreamworks' humans are pretty realistic, but they have a deadness to them (esp. the eyes) that I'm really glad TMNT didn't have. Even Advent Children, while looking quite nice and realistic, still looked dead to me... again, it was the eyes.

If they were trying to be realistic in this movie... then they failed. But amazingly enough, that was not their intent! How crazy!

I agree with iris in that my main appreciation for the skateboard scene was not only for the animation (though it did look pretty nice) but the fact that it showed how freaking hard it is to find the lair. These Turtles are well-hidden, which I liked very much... in the live-action movies it always seemed like any idiot could bungle into the lair. It was also a great personality showcase for Michelangelo, as he spent most of the movie in the back seat. Too bad Don didn't have a similar scene to shine... except for his horribly lame "this has Winter's name all over it!" joke. I guess Don's enough of a geek to make a bad joke like that, but yeesh. I like to see him being a cool geek. :)

I have no problems with it not looking realistic. But the "This has Winter's name written all over it" joke was pretty funny in that cheesy way, in my showing friday it made the entire audience laugh. Also the skateboarding sense made sense for 2 reasons transportation for a long ass travel to his home, and its fitting for the Mikey character.


As for Blueoakleyz I would really would love to know what you do that you can make better money then an Animator

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 01:38 AM
I have no problems with it not looking realistic. But the "This has Winter's name written all over it" joke was pretty funny in that cheesy way, in my showing friday it made the entire audience laugh. Also the skateboarding sense made sense for 2 reasons transportation for a long ass travel to his home, and its fitting for the Mikey character.


As for Blueoakleyz I would really would love to know what you do that you can make better money then an Animator

It'd be nice to know how much animators made don't ya think?
I'm certain it can't be more than 100k/year?

Revan
03-25-2007, 01:43 AM
Originally Posted by blueoakleyz
What?

the CGI was awful. The turtles looked good of course, but everything else looked awful. It was just an awful awful medium for a martial arts action movie.

I disagree. By doing CGI, the boys can show off actual ninja skills. In the live action movies, the fighting was pathetic compared to what we got in TMNT. The boys jumped from rooftops, flipped, jumped from planes, rode motorcycles, skateboarded... so on so on so on...

The first live action movie had none of that. Keep in mind, the first movie will always be special to me but I tend to think that many fans will agree that the turtles are more flexible and skilled in a cgi movie. Am I wrong? Agree? Disagree?

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:47 AM
average $44,000. highest60,000. But it all depends on the reigion and employer of the animator

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:48 AM
I disagree. By doing CGI, the boys can show off actual ninja skills. In the live action movies, the fighting was pathetic compared to what we got in TMNT. The boys jumped from rooftops, flipped, jumped from planes, rode motorcycles, skateboarded... so on so on so on...

The first live action movie had none of that. Keep in mind, the first movie will always be special to me but I tend to think that many fans will agree that the turtles are more flexible and skilled in a cgi movie. Am I wrong? Agree? Disagree?

I totally agree with you on that

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 01:50 AM
average $44,000. highest60,000. But it all depends on the reigion and employer of the animator

Dude that's not that much.. I'm sure the joy of doing what they love doing is more than enough satisfaction but that's not a wealthy living exactly. It's not bad at all though!

Not entirely sure how what everyone makes $$ is relevant

but I'm not going to BS you and say I make more than that since I'm just a senior in college. When I graduate in a year I'll get (current, as in I just came up with this last night, career track) an entry level job, probably paid oh I donno 30k or so in some management position. Work a couple years, get an MBA, work my way up.. and say when I'm 35 or so make over 100k a year.

CJStyles
03-25-2007, 01:54 AM
Sure you may very well do that. But you're still a dumbass to think that the animation is awful

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 01:55 AM
Sure you may very well do that. But you're still a dumbass to think that the animation is awful

well guess I'm a dumbass then

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 02:48 AM
dude, as the creator of this thread, please be quiet and stop repeating yourself of the cgi we heard you, bro. You need to get your eyes checked.. the animation is really impressive. I love hte way the cgi brings out the turtles unlike the live action where they couldn't do all the stuff you saw in the cgi movie.

Look, u say you enjoyed the movie, tell us 3 things of the movie you enjoyed,

Fledermaus
03-25-2007, 02:56 AM
dude, as the creator of this thread, please be quiet and stop repeating yourself of the cgi we heard you, bro. You need to get your eyes checked.. the animation is really impressive. I love hte way the cgi brings out the turtles unlike the live action where they couldn't do all the stuff you saw in the cgi movie.

Look, u say you enjoyed the movie, tell us 3 things of the movie you enjoyed,

It's not that he finds the CG in TMNT to be of poor quality -- it's that he hates CG period. :roll:

I disagree. By doing CGI, the boys can show off actual ninja skills. In the live action movies, the fighting was pathetic compared to what we got in TMNT. The boys jumped from rooftops, flipped, jumped from planes, rode motorcycles, skateboarded... so on so on so on...

The first live action movie had none of that. Keep in mind, the first movie will always be special to me but I tend to think that many fans will agree that the turtles are more flexible and skilled in a cgi movie. Am I wrong? Agree? Disagree?

Amen, amen. That's what I love so much about these CG turtles -- they actual look LETHAL. They move faster and with better precision and agility, which convinces me even more of their exceptional skills as martial artists/assassins! :D

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 02:56 AM
dude, as the creator of this thread, please be quiet and stop repeating yourself of the cgi we heard you, bro. You need to get your eyes checked.. the animation is really impressive. I love hte way the cgi brings out the turtles unlike the live action where they couldn't do all the stuff you saw in the cgi movie.

Look, u say you enjoyed the movie, tell us 3 things of the movie you enjoyed,

at least the stuff in the real live action movies was REAL. There is nothing enjoyable about watching something some guy did with a freakin mouse
in other words, it doesnt count if its cgi

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 02:57 AM
It's not that he thinks the CG quality of TMNT sucks -- it's that he hates CG period.:roll:
and thats ok now every knock it off geezzz this thread is giving me a head ach!!!:x

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-25-2007, 02:57 AM
at least the stuff in the real live action movies was REAL. There is nothing enjoyable about watching something some guy did with a freakin mouse
in other words, it doesnt count if its cgi

Dude, they were big muppets. That doesn't count as real either.

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 02:58 AM
there were people actually doing stuff though

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 02:59 AM
at least the stuff in the real live action movies was REAL. There is nothing enjoyable about watching something some guy did with a freakin mouse
in other words, it doesnt count if its cgi

:lol: hey boy, real
? the turtles were freaking puppets..

they can't do 100x stuff the turtles in the cartoon and cgi can do..

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 03:02 AM
:lol: hey boy, real
? the turtles were freaking puppets..

they can't do 100x stuff the turtles in the cartoon and cgi can do..

Unfortunately I can't stick a cord to your head and link you to my brain so you understand the sentiment and thoughts I have in my head which are a bit too complicated for words.

Let me put it another way

Would you rather see a movie with Bruce Lee, Jack Chan etc doing martial arts, or a CGI movie with characters doing martial arts?

The answer is obvious and the reason is because the real actors are actually using skill to do it. You're impressed with either their skill or their realistic illusion. CGI martial arts? ARe ya kidding me? How am I supposed to enjoy/be impressed by something that was relatively child's play by being created on a computer?

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 03:04 AM
didn't they motion capture the movement of the turtles in the movie?

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 03:06 AM
edited out edited out

poobone
03-25-2007, 03:07 AM
i'm a little intoxicated as I write this but I saw the movie today and my opinion on it is crystal clear. I'd give it a 7/10. I LOVED everything that had to do with the turtles, but Max Winters was a boring/derivative character, and the entire 13 monsters plot was just boring. The quarrel between Leo and Raph was awesome. I liked the movie a lot, but I thought that Karai/the foot clan should have been the main nemesis. The sequel (if/when it comes out) should be better. I also loved the teaser from karai at the the end. Anyway, I loved the turtles stuff but everything else involving the villain felt really generic. Also, april was too skinny.

Also, there were some actually funny parts. I laughed out loud when Raph threw the smoke pellet and then Casey was just standing there lol.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 03:07 AM
Dude, they were big muppets. That doesn't count as real either.
Ok dude you better stop now before you knock the muppets and be on my personal Sh1t list forever.
there were people actually doing stuff though
doesn't mean you have to stoop to the same level:roll:
:lol: hey boy, real
? the turtles were freaking puppets..

they can't do 100x stuff the turtles in the cartoon and cgi can do..

they where not puppets they are foam laytex costumes with animatronic heads and at the time they where very cutting edge and I'll thank you not to knock the work of one of the greatest minds of our time Jim Henson.:x
You guys are seriously starting to piss me off and you're not even talking to me just because he's knocking cgi does not mean you need to knock the history of movie making geez grow up!

The answer is obvious and the reason is because the real actors are actually using skill to do it. You're impressed with either their skill or their realistic illusion. CGI martial arts? ARe ya kidding me? How am I supposed to enjoy/be impressed by something that was relatively child's play by being created on a computer?
and man you just need to give it up everyone in the world today likes cgi thats why millions of puppet builders, makeup artists, and traditional movie makers are now out of jobs. it's disgusting but true.

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 03:11 AM
Ok dude you better stop now before you knock the muppets and be on my personal Sh1t list forever.

doesn't mean you have to stoop to the same level:roll:


they where not puppets they are foam laytex costumes with animatronic heads and at the time they where very cutting edge and I'll thank you not to knock the work of one of the greatest minds of our time Jim Henson.:x
You guys are seriously starting to piss me off and you're not even talking to me just because he's knocking cgi does not mean you need to knock the history of movie making geez grow up!
e.

I love the muppets and jim henson.. I would never ever say anything bad about them, ever.

I forgot about that stuff they used in tmnt 1-3 movies. I just called them puppets becuase I thought that what they were called.

I am not trying to make you mad, that otehr guy is making us more annoyed than I would when I was making the bad sig or my chaos on the video game discussion a month ago.

So ya

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 03:16 AM
I love the muppets and jim henson.. I would never ever say anything bad about them, ever.

I forgot about that stuff they used in tmnt 1-3 movies. I just called them puppets becuase I thought that what they were called.

I am not trying to make you mad, that otehr guy is making us more annoyed than I would when I was making the bad sig or my chaos on the video game discussion a month ago.

So ya

well listen the hell up I'm sick of it I wanna talk about the turtle movie the dudes stoped bu everyone keeps egging him the F%ck on so everyone stop it and shut the hell up geez!
And good I wasn't really talking to you I hate cgi as well but the turtles movie really helped me like it because it's finally starting to get to be nice I hate it in the past for being so flat. With this movie they made cartoons with allot of detail and I like that allot.
But what this guys talking about is that the old movie turtles are physical not real and I know you guys all know that unless you're all that dence seriously.
And I know you guys aren't so seriously stop it I'm here to chat not be given a damn daycare head ach!

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 03:17 AM
didn't they motion capture the movement of the turtles in the movie?

it doesn't matter
they can feed all the motion capture in the world into a computer, and then with a click of a mouse do anything they want with it. You can't do that in real life. It's like a magic button and to me it automatically makes everything not count. It's like those tv shows where all kinds of bad stuff happens and it turns out to be a dream.

Take a 30 second fight scene.
With computers, you can have 500 guys work 6 months just to manipulate that scene until it's perfect.
With humans in real life, you only actually HAVE 30 seconds to make it perfect, and maybe a few takes.

The real life fight scene is always going to be 10000000x more impressive because it took real skill and hard work.

The reverse is true as well. A guy can go to a beautiful mountain cliff overlooking a canyon filled with water and on the other side is a beautiful color forest with aurora borealis in the sky. He can take a picture and that's nice and all but everyone knows he hardly did any work. Or you can take a computer artist and have him spend 2 years in photoshop duplicating it by hand, THAT would be much more impressive.

To be quite honest I think CGI has just ruined movie making. It's a crutch for lazy and/or poor uncreative movie makers.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 03:21 AM
it doesn't matter
they can feed all the motion capture in the world into a computer, and then with a click of a mouse do anything they want with it. You can't do that in real life. It's like a magic button and to me it automatically makes everything not count. It's like those tv shows where all kinds of bad stuff happens and it turns out to be a dream.

Take a 30 second fight scene.
With computers, you can have 500 guys work 6 months just to manipulate that scene until it's perfect.
With humans in real life, you only actually HAVE 30 seconds to make it perfect, and maybe a few takes.

The real life fight scene is always going to be 10000000x more impressive because it took real skill and hard work.

The reverse is true as well. A guy can go to a beautiful mountain cliff overlooking a canyon filled with water and on the other side is a beautiful color forest with aurora borealis in the sky. He can take a picture and that's nice and all but everyone knows he hardly did any work. Or you can take a computer artist and have him spend 2 years in photoshop duplicating it by hand, THAT would be much more impressive.

To be quite honest I think CGI has just ruined movie making. It's a crutch for lazy and/or poor uncreative movie makers.
ok and this is all that needs to be said right now we get it from you and everyone else.
the next step will be for krang to be contacted because my last nerv has been hit tonight.:(

Seiza
03-25-2007, 03:29 AM
Hi, lurker here, just dropping by with some comments.

I was honestly scared to death that the movie would phail in Singapore, but I was extremely surprised when Saturday night's movie sold out. Also amusing to note that most of the audience comprised teens my age--20-year olds who were enjoying a piece of their childhood.

A lot of what I liked about the movie has already been said. Of course, the Leo/Raph scene snatched first place, but I also loved the little side-scenes. That scene where Leo returns to the lair and smiles so tenderly at Mikey and Don sleeping, then Mikey HUGGED him! (Finally! It's sweet justice after the stupified disbelief when Leo and Don just shook hands in Prodigal Son.) Raph and his "better go say hi before [Leo] leaves again"--sure, Splinter tells us Raph was deeply affected by his brother's absence, but that line just made it so real.

Humour was spot on in most cases. It's funny how there was such concern about the burping way in the beginning, yet it was only in that once scene.

I liked the caricatured look for the humans. It fit, is all I can say. And Karai was beautiful.

I didn't cringe at the "stars aligning" bit, as I found that typical storyline fare. I guess I went in looking for the family dynamics, and left the monster subplot as a very distant second concern. The one line I do remember cringing at was Raph's "Except when [families] fight together" (or something along those lines) at the end. Seemed like the writers were forcing themselves to churn out something witty there.

My two main critiques would be Leo's portrayal and the final fight:

- Leo's portrayal has been discussed here, so I won't go into it too much. I just think that this would be his strongest movie incarnation if you factored in his off-movie (i.e. comics and cartoons) emotional baggage. Anyone going into this movie fresh as a newborn babe would likely only see a leader in name who got kidnapped. Ouch. Especially after all the taunting. But then, it has been said that this movie is for the fans, so perhaps the writers are expecting us to pull on off-movie knowledge.

- The final fight (strictly speaking, the one against the Generals) was quite underwhelming. If we're gonna focus on families fighting together and teamwork, why have the turtles fighting separately for most of the time? I might have missed it due to all the action going on, but it seemed the only time they worked together was when they kicked the Generals into the portal. I would've liked to see more of when Don gave Raph that lift during the skirmish with the Foot, just with Leo and Mikey mixing the pair-ups.

Gave it an A. I came out smiling and wanting more.

blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 03:37 AM
double-post. Many apologies.

dude i dont think anyone's gonna get pissed

RskimB
03-25-2007, 03:46 AM
I'm too lazy to get into detail but I saw the movie last night and rate it a B. Definitely a great experience and overall I think it worked though I wished the movie could have been longer. Even as a Raph fan I was suprised at the lack of screentime Donny got and the intro was a bit cringe inducing/awkward. Also I thought the fight with the Foot was way too rushed(it would have been cool if they dragged it more) and seeing April fighting alongside the turtles is still weird for me. Awesome movie I cant wait for the dvd release, overall TMNT(2007) >>>>> TMNT 2 & TMNT 3.

bean
03-25-2007, 06:26 AM
I like the film and going back to watch it this weekend coming but I gave it B.

Brandatello
03-25-2007, 07:26 AM
the only things that bothered me was....
-they didnt show them defeating shredder just artwork
-splinters voice was a little hard to understand at times
-casey and april = love?
-the pans around made me dizzy
but the rest was awesome...i loved it A+

The Terror of Death
03-25-2007, 09:57 AM
Pros:
Animation was amazing.
Felt like an extra long episode of the new toon.
Raph, Leo, April, Casey, and Don were spot on imo.
Leo vs Raph.
Most of the music.
The dialogue for most of the main characters.
TMNT'S acrobatic feats.
Hint at the Shrdder by Karai.
Excellent voice acting.
Opening and ending sequence.

Cons:
Mikey should have been more like the new toon version.
Fights were okay.
Needed more fights.
Movie felt too short.
Movie could have done without the monsters.
Generals needed more depth.
Casey outshined Don and Mikey.
The kiss felt like it was done at the wrong.
Karai's voice hurt my ears.

Overall I give TMNT a 4 out of 5. 8)

jenna
03-25-2007, 10:43 AM
I have already managed to squeeze three viewings in and my thoughts are...

First of all, the animation was awesome! There were times I had to remind myself it was CGI, not real. I particularly liked the design of the turtles. Their eyes were amazingly expresive and I really liked that they were smaller than previous incarnations, appearing younger and more like teenagers, but this vulnerability did not interfere with their strength and robustness. I also loved the detail to them, like the dents in Raph's shell and the veins on Mikey's hands etc.

The plot to me was bizarrely inconsequential. Whilst the monster thing is a bit naff, I found that it didn't really matter to me as I was so absorbed by the family element and the conflict between Raph and Leo. The confrontation between them, for me, is long overdue and a brave inclusion in the narrative. it was perfectly executed - the scene in the rain (as I believe most people have already commented) was the strongest scene and the most emotional.

The characters were, in a word, perfect. I loved that Mikey was very definitely the little brother, and this was portrayed well through his facial expression - the way he moved his mouth was so unique and innocent. His best moment was when he was watching the Nightwatcher article on the news, getting all excited and when he saw the portal and said "I want one."

Unfortuantely, Donatello suffered from a bit of 2-dimensionalism... (perhaps something a longer cut would have rectified). Particularly liked the moment when Splinter was rebuking him and he was wearing the goggles, magnifying his eyes.

Leonardo I think was the best screen version of him to date. He was powerful, authoritative, ego driven. His facial expressions were fantastic - especially in the scene with April by the fire. His best moment was his exasperation at Raphael on the roof top.

The treatment of Raphael in this film was beautiful and empathetic. Once again, the best portrayal to date. There was a sadness to him as well as a real grittiness. I loved him falling asleep on the roof, but his best moment was the exchange between him and General Aquilla in the final battle.

The Voice Acting was incredible, and the four dudes who voiced the turtles were absolutely outstanding, especially Nolan North.

My only real complaint (a greedy one, I know) is that the film could have benefitted from another twenty-minutes or so run time. Those scenes from the novelisation which didn't make the final cut would have fleshed the narrative out nicely. Hoping for a director's cut on the DVD for this.

I could bang on and on about the cinematography, the mise en scene and the musical score etc, but I'll just say that it was all brilliant and I loved every minute- Kevin Munroe and his clan did a stand up job.

Thrilled to see the turtles on the big screen again and hoping for a nice sequel, perhaps one more aimed at the older audience so that can show blood and a bit more action.

Anarky
03-25-2007, 11:29 AM
Bwahahaha! Splinter and Karai both sounded like they were drunk. "We mosh fight wi'onour." It was hilarious. And I must say, I liked Mako way better as Aku. It just seemed so much more right for him.

All in all, it was a fine movie, albeit with a bit underdevelopped characters. Sure, the TMNT, Splinter, April and Casey have been around for 20 years and we all know who they are, but Winters' generals were terribly handeled. Head henchmen or not, they deserved more. But then again, this movie wasn't about them, was it? The turtles were excellently handled, I must say. It was nice to see them in big action again.

I'm still not too fond of the whole CGI-bit though. Sure, it's what's cool today, but please... it sucks. The Turtles and Splinter had wonderful models, the monsters and generals looked fine and so did the environment. But the humans were still atrocious. It's not that they were badly animated, in fact, I was rather impressed with that. But their shapes were all wrong, and so were some of the movements.

On to the story, it was wonderful. Really. It was fantastic. I loved the family-moments, the dialogue, the emotional impacts. And we finally get to see where the turtles get their money from.

And I'm rooting for a sequel too. Just because the whole thing felt right and good and therefore deserves a sequel.

Jester
03-25-2007, 11:38 AM
Hey, Anarky. Can I ask you to elaborate on why CGI "sucks." I mean, I, by no means, jump up and down and dance screaming, "OMG another movie done on a computer, that alone makes me wanna watch it," but I think for certain movies it works, and this one of them. TMNT as a live action franchise was great, in it's time (and I know you're not saying that that's what you'd prefer), but with CG you can get so much more. Should the human characters have been less like caricatures, maybe? Just askin'. I respect your opinion, as always.

Spitfire
03-25-2007, 11:47 AM
And again ignored, I wonder why I post here anymore.

Anarky
03-25-2007, 11:48 AM
I don't know what I would have preferred, but this whole CGI-thing bothers me greatly. The people in the movie, even if they're turtles, look as if they're made of plastic. They seem unreal, intangible. And while you know that they're only a drawing in a cartoon, they try to sell you the illusion of photorealism (with artistic liberties of course) and they just don't have that skill yet. They need more experience, better models and better animations. Sometimes, the figures look incredibly unreal, even for mutant turtles.

I'm not particularly unhappy with the CGI in this movie, except when it comes to the humans, but the stuff still looks cold, as if it was made of plastic. And of course, there need to be these scenes added that are only there to show off how awesome their CGI-skills are. In this movie it was the scene on the Red Eye, where it just had to rain and everyone should go "Man, look at the water! It looks so real!" And while they're busy showing off water and having different angles of people standing in the rain, the story starts lacking, the moment starts to feel awkward and it essentially spoils the whole scene. So it's not just the unreal look, it's also the animators' vanity that bothers me.

Jester
03-25-2007, 12:01 PM
And again ignored, I wonder why I post here anymore.
Wha? Did I miss something? Sorry Spitz, I've even gone back several pages to find your post, and nada. Link me?

Rooish
03-25-2007, 12:08 PM
I loved that Mikey was very definitely the little brother, and this was portrayed well through his facial expression - the way he moved his mouth was so unique and innocent. His best moment was when he was watching the Nightwatcher article on the news, getting all excited and when he saw the portal and said "I want one."


I thought he looked really horny when he was watching the Nightwatcher. It was kind of disturbing.

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-25-2007, 12:10 PM
I thought he looked really horny when he was watching the Nightwatcher. It was kind of disturbing.

:lol: :lol: :lol: Yeah, you're right. NO ONE gets that excited by the news. No one. :)

Spitfire
03-25-2007, 12:14 PM
Wha? Did I miss something? Sorry Spitz, I've even gone back several pages to find your post, and nada. Link me?

Don't fret on it. Just seems everytime I post anything no one responds to it unless they want to bash me. And that only happens in the video game section haha

But if you want to see my post it's on page 9 I think. I was just surprised no one had anything to say about it since almost everyone seemed to enjoy the film.

jenna
03-25-2007, 12:16 PM
I thought he looked really horny when he was watching the Nightwatcher. It was kind of disturbing.

Haha! Yeah! I just thought it was really funny the way he got all excitable. :lol:

Rooish
03-25-2007, 12:32 PM
Don't fret on it. Just seems everytime I post anything no one responds to it unless they want to bash me. And that only happens in the video game section haha

But if you want to see my post it's on page 9 I think. I was just surprised no one had anything to say about it since almost everyone seemed to enjoy the film.

Spitfire, hey, no one bashed you though, and you were criticizing the movie! I think it's a good sign that people read your post and didn't disagree enough to get pissed off. The problems you had with the movie were bsaically the same as the ones I had. I was really disappointed, and it was basically just seeing the Turtles again, looking awesome and sounding awesome, that appeased me.

Jester
03-25-2007, 01:00 PM
Ahh, I remember reading your post. I guess i remained silent because you state your opinion and support it. I couldn't disagree too much. You spelled it out, and heck maybe I agree with you more than I care to admit.

Spitfire
03-25-2007, 01:02 PM
Ahh, I remember reading your post. I guess i remained silent because you state your opinion and support it. I couldn't disagree too much. You spelled it out, and heck maybe I agree with you more than I care to admit.

I'll take that as a compliment. I know that seems to be why alot of arguments break out around here. It's nice to know I reinforce my opinions well.

The Terror of Death
03-25-2007, 01:16 PM
And again ignored, I wonder why I post here anymore.

Well, I agree with most of what you had to say. But you cant really expect someone to respond to everyone with a forum that has so many people. I get ignored all the time. :ohwell:

Jester
03-25-2007, 01:20 PM
I do too...and I'm the charismatic one. :P

Spitfire
03-25-2007, 01:23 PM
Well, I agree with most of what you had to say. But you cant really expect someone to respond to everyone with a forum that has so many people. I get ignored all the time. :ohwell:

That's one way to look at it, but I wasn't just talking the movie forum. Either way problem solved.

Jester and me post way to often for you to ignore us, even if you want to hahaha

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 01:53 PM
That's one way to look at it, but I wasn't just talking the movie forum. Either way problem solved.

Jester and me post way to often for you to ignore us, even if you want to hahaha
hahah don't forget me I'm the brainy one with the good looks *bats eyelashes!*:anime:

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 02:25 PM
So this topic has quieten down and this was moved too! What the!?

So anyways, glad to see this topic back to normal now. I don't ignore you 2. I see alot it just too many posts are there after you guys.

So yes.

wyze2099
03-25-2007, 03:13 PM
i also got the impression slightly that there was a bit of a Leo/April romance somewhere. Tell me if i am "off my sewer slider rocker", but that was just my impression. To those of you that haven't seen the movie, you may see it periodically through the movie when their characters interact and know where i got this idea/impression from.

Heh, I kinda got that impression as well. The two did seem awfully close, and it seemed to me that April had more chemistry with Leo than with Casey, which is rather amusing. I dunno if I would necessarily call that chemistry a romance, though, because (and I'm speaking from experience here) platonic friendships between members of the opposite sex can be just as deep -- or even more so -- than romantic relationships.

But it might be interesting to see if this movie inspires Leo/April 'shipper fanfics. :)

ZariusTwo
03-25-2007, 03:16 PM
I did'nt see any of that. April and Leo's conversations came off like brother and sister, she was heavily into Casey.

God, when it comes to 'Shippers, there is no SANE conversation.

Warhorse
03-25-2007, 03:53 PM
Heh, I kinda got that impression as well. The two did seem awfully close, and it seemed to me that April had more chemistry with Leo than with Casey, which is rather amusing. I dunno if I would necessarily call that chemistry a romance, though, because (and I'm speaking from experience here) platonic friendships between members of the opposite sex can be just as deep -- or even more so -- than romantic relationships.

But it might be interesting to see if this movie inspires Leo/April 'shipper fanfics. :)

You know, I started to get a weird feeling, very akward actually, when April fell into that hole in Leo's arms. That scene was, well, kind of weird. Definitely made me feel like, oookkeeeaaayy.

Good thing it wasn't Donny, he probably would have dropped her!:D

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:01 PM
I did'nt see any of that. April and Leo's conversations came off like brother and sister, she was heavily into Casey.

God, when it comes to 'Shippers, there is no SANE conversation.

I didn't see that either but hell what do I know I'm more into packers than I am Shippers anyways :lol:

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 04:05 PM
You know, I started to get a weird feeling, very akward actually, when April fell into that hole in Leo's arms. That scene was, well, kind of weird. Definitely made me feel like, oookkeeeaaayy.

Good thing it wasn't Donny, he probably would have dropped her!:D

Why would he?

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:06 PM
Why would he?
I know right! she looks like she ways what maybe 10 pounds in the movie lol
I'm suprised she didn't split in half as she was falling lol:lol:

ikology
03-25-2007, 04:15 PM
yeah, especially her waist, my god, did you see how thin they made her around the waist?! lol
at first it was so noticeable and ridiculous looking that I couldn't help but laugh
But then I kind of just wrote it off as them maybe trying to have their own unique style in their character design, kinda like the Turtles' exaggerated hands and feet

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 04:16 PM
I know right! she looks like she ways what maybe 10 pounds in the movie lol
I'm suprised she didn't split in half as she was falling lol:lol:

That didn't answer my question.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:17 PM
"I know right! she looks like she ways what maybe 10 pounds in the movie lol
I'm suprised she didn't split in half as she was falling lol"


yeah, especially her waist, my god, did you see how thin they made her around the waist?! lol
at first it was so noticeable and ridiculous looking that I couldn't help but laugh
But then I kind of just wrote it off as them maybe trying to have their own unique style in their character design, kinda like the Turtles' exaggerated hands and feet
same!
That didn't answer my question.
please phrase your question in the form of a ........question.

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 04:28 PM
I already did!

My question was "Why would he (Don)?" in response to:

You know, I started to get a weird feeling, very akward actually, when April fell into that hole in Leo's arms. That scene was, well, kind of weird. Definitely made me feel like, oookkeeeaaayy.

Good thing it wasn't Donny, he probably would have dropped her!:D

cowabunga14
03-25-2007, 04:33 PM
Ok I just saw it.
I have to say the CGI completely took me out of the movie. I hate CGI. They made all the humans look completely ridiculous. Seeing things like Mikey skateboard had absolutely no impact on me because it wasn't real at all.

The story was alright, it drew me in for sure. I wasn't left wanting more, which is a good thing I think.
I actually didn't mind that seeing as I'm into skateboarding.

VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:37 PM
I already did!

My question was "Why would he (Don)?" in response to:
oh wasn't sure what part you ment but maybe because he's not as strong as the other guys? *shruggs*

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 04:51 PM
Back to business. I've decided that between A and B, I'll go with B. It does go along better with my 7.5/10 rating and well...

Pros:
Perfect voice acting.
Breakthrough CGI.
Pretty funny. I'm not a big laugher though so I didn't in the theatre.
Conveyed the emotions of the TMNT perfectly.
Action was swift and pretty cool.
Good new direction.

Cons:
Sometimes it felt like it could've been an episode from either series instead of a film.
Somethings I feel were indeed cut more than others--mainly it's just my feeling that I wanted that longer version.
Could've been a bit more mature/dark.
Got a little lost about the plot.

ZariusTwo
03-25-2007, 04:56 PM
I already did!

My question was "Why would he (Don)?" in response to:

Fix your sarcasm detector please.

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 05:04 PM
Fix your sarcasm detector please.

I wasn't trying to be sarcastic! I was just trying to know what Warhorse meant!

P.S. It's your attempt at sarcasm right there that sucked!

Warhorse
03-25-2007, 05:20 PM
Why would he?


What I meant about that, is that in some incarnations, Donny I thought had a bit of a crush on April, and to have her in his arms like she was in Leo's, I think he would panic and drop her. That's all. Just a little humor that didn't go over. My bad.

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 05:23 PM
Oh........

Rooish
03-25-2007, 05:37 PM
At any rate, I, too, noticed an awkward romantic tension between Leo and April ... when she landed in his arms and then the music got all dramatic and it froze on his heroic face, I burst out laughing.

But then, maybe those smiles just looked romantic. Leo and Raph shared one of those, two, when Leo said he needed Raph near the end. :P

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 05:42 PM
At any rate, I, too, noticed an awkward romantic tension between Leo and April ... when she landed in his arms and then the music got all dramatic and it froze on his heroic face, I burst out laughing.

But then, maybe those smiles just looked romantic. Leo and Raph shared one of those, two, when Leo said he needed Raph near the end. :P

Not to mention you've got a picture of Raph and Mikey seemingly hugging each other in all your messages.

Kunoichi_Haruko
03-25-2007, 05:45 PM
Not to mention you've got a picture of Raph and Mikey seemingly hugging each other in all your messages.

If it's any consolation, Raph doesn't look too thrilled to be receiving said hug. :P

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 05:50 PM
I know. I saw that episode.

wyze2099
03-25-2007, 06:05 PM
I did'nt see any of that. April and Leo's conversations came off like brother and sister, she was heavily into Casey.

God, when it comes to 'Shippers, there is no SANE conversation.

Yeah, they came off as brother and sister to me, too. Notice the part in my post where I mentioned that while the two of them interacted in a way that could be viewed as romantic, I could see it more as a deep platonic friendship. There's more than one way to view their interactions; the difficulties I encounter are with people who get bent out of shape if everyone has to see it ONE particular way.

I have to admit I'm a bit mellow about the topic of 'shipping, partly because I've done a lot of fanfiction writing and a lot of the fanfiction community is comprised of 'shippers. Arguments about relationships can get heated and ridiculous, but one thing I've learned from it is that there are plenty of ways to interpret a dynamic between two characters. There are more possible relationships than the romantic, as I've noted above, though romantic/sexual relationships are fixated on the most because it's not often explored in media canon. One advantage of fanfiction is that it can go places that the source material can't or won't for various reasons.

There's no skin off my nose if the Turtles never enter into a romantic/sexual relationship with April, Karai, or any other character, but hey, if it happens, great. And the idea of it happening could make for some interesting stories. There are plenty of interesting stories to be had of platonic, brother/sister relationships as well.

How's that for "a SANE conversation"? :)

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
03-25-2007, 08:18 PM
Rooish I too like that picture of mikey hugging Raph...which episode is that from by the way...lol i don't even remember that image :P

Warhorse
03-25-2007, 08:41 PM
Did you notice how tall the Turtles were in this movie? In the cartoon, they are quite, uh, squat. In the Old movies, they were tall, because there were men in suits, minus Mikey.

In here, I noticed that April was just like an inch or two taller than Leo. Kind of cool detail. Leo was also taller than Raph when they were arguing.

Laurael
03-25-2007, 08:42 PM
I voted A+ because even though, yes, it wasn't totally perfect and could have been improved in parts, it was still awesome to me. :D

Rikirk
03-25-2007, 08:52 PM
I loved the movie....It was good to see them on the big screen again.

The tension betwenn Raph and Leo was great, and also taking the movie seriously and getting rid of the cheese helped alot.

I would have much rather seen the 4 taking on street gangs than monsters, but I guess the monster element was for the kids.


still a great movie, definitely will consider getting the DVD.

;)

Revan
03-25-2007, 09:46 PM
I would have much rather seen the 4 taking on street gangs than monsters, but I guess the monster element was for the kids.;)

I hope the next movie shows the boys kicking more street thugs around. Superhero movies don't show enough of this. Spider-man didn't do it enough, superman didn't, Daredevil did it somewhat but that movie was horrible. The first fight scene in the dark from the first movie was awesome. More of that would definately satisfy me.

Jester
03-25-2007, 11:13 PM
Anyone else wonder if the Foot Ninja that went with Karai, Casey, and April and who seems to be injured may in fact be...
Oroku Saki

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-25-2007, 11:15 PM
I hope the next movie shows the boys kicking more street thugs around. Superhero movies don't show enough of this. Spider-man didn't do it enough, superman didn't, Daredevil did it somewhat but that movie was horrible. The first fight scene in the dark from the first movie was awesome. More of that would definately satisfy me.

Thing is, after a very short while, the street thug thing gets tiresome. They'd probably do that for the opening scene, but don't count on that beign the main plot point.

Seiza
03-25-2007, 11:38 PM
At any rate, I, too, noticed an awkward romantic tension between Leo and April ... when she landed in his arms and then the music got all dramatic and it froze on his heroic face, I burst out laughing.
My friend and I were whispering turtle backstories before the movie started, and we made it to discussing April's lovelife. My friend tried to remember who it was that loved her, and I asked, "Human or turtle?"

Then the movie started and we shushed. When it got to that Leo/April scene, she actually whispered back, "Oh, so Leo's the one!" :lol: Too bad I was actually thinking of Don...

I can see where any potential shippers might come from, but these two obviously work just as well in a platonic friendship/sibling-ish feel. Kinda nice to see big-sister!April and Leo together, since I usually see her interact with Mikey in that manner.

Anyone else wonder if the Foot Ninja that went with Karai, Casey, and April and who seems to be injured may in fact be...
I guess it's because it seems odd to see Karai interact so much with one Foot Ninja, but I still doubt it. It just seemed more for comedic value.

ZariusTwo
03-26-2007, 01:26 AM
Anyone else wonder if the Foot Ninja that went with Karai, Casey, and April and who seems to be injured may in fact be...
Oroku Saki

Wow. That was probably dumber than the people I've seen who insist it was Chaplin:P

But I doubt that Ninja was who you say it is...kind of humanizes him, especially since his interaction with Karai was in two comedic scenes.

LogicDonny
03-26-2007, 04:05 AM
Well today is the day I will be seeing it ! :D Can't wait.

I'll give my impressions later tonight.

Draconic
03-26-2007, 08:11 AM
***he following may contain spoilers for TMNT 1 & 2***

But...
Did anyone else hear Karai's sequel bait lines at the end of the movie...:D Yeah...but what would it be called...*Looks to Angry Nintendo Nerd for guidance*

Yeah,
Karai: We will have business soon, involving faces from the past
turtle: She doesn't mean...
http://i95.photobucket.com/albums/l143/draconix86/Walker.jpg


By the way, how long will it take to find out how well the turtles faired on opening weekend? The theater were packed at the 9:55 over here on opening night, and earlier shows had sold out completely. When I went back on Sunday to watch Reign Over Me, people were still buying tickets so I'm kind of excited to hear the numbers.

Jo Dawn
03-26-2007, 08:30 AM
*Walks into thread*

*Ahem* I will now speak briefly on my thoughts.

This movie... is beyond awesome. I heartily approve. *stamps the Jo-Approval Official Stamp of Greatness on the movie and Kevin's forehead*

(Really, I'll give a more detailed account of my thoughts later. I'm at college, heh).



And one more thing...


I did'nt see any of that. April and Leo's conversations came off like brother and sister, she was heavily into Casey.

God, when it comes to 'Shippers, there is no SANE conversation.

Hear, hear! I knew when I saw that scene that people would say that. Jeez, people! They're like brother and sister and we all know that.

...And besides. Everyone knows that the only true canon crush we have is Don/April. And that's a fact, straight from Laird. Thank you.

*bows out of thread*


PS - WOO HOO!! (I can't wait to gush on this later!!)

Rooish
03-26-2007, 08:51 AM
:lol: I know, I know. Don likes April. That's why I thought it was so weird, in the movie, how into each other Leo and April seemed. I ain't no shipper and I thought that was bizarre.

Draconic ... LMFAO.

Warhorse ... I noticed that the Turtles were pretty tall here. To be honest, I like them short. But I did think the height differences between the Turtles were pretty cool. Leo looked taller than Mikey or Raph.

raphroehler2003, the episode I got my signature pic from is "Secret Origins, Part 3." Really funny part. And no, I'm not a Mikey/Raph shipper :lol:

Jo Dawn
03-26-2007, 10:18 AM
Really? I seriously just got the 'we've been freinds FOREVER' vibe from them. I'd look fondly upon a friend I hadn't seen for a year or so too.

I shall speak like a broken record until people LISTEN TO ME. ;) :lol:

Hahaha...

But seriously. I'm thinking maybe the relationship thoughts may need their own thread soon. It's startin' to kinda tie up general movie thoughts.

Rooish
03-26-2007, 11:35 AM
Yeah, I can see it that way, too, which makes it pretty darn cute. Long-time fans who get that there's never been any sexual tension between Leo and April would interpret it as a sibling-like, warm bond. But I can also see how people who are less familiar with it all would think that Leo heroically caught April and then they gazed at each other. :P

Revan
03-26-2007, 03:44 PM
I can also see how people who are less familiar with it all would think that Leo heroically caught April and then they gazed at each other. :P

That is disgusting. I understand that the boys are teenagers who will never be able to mate with anything. But if there is one thing tmnt movie makers should avoid, it's inter-species mating.:lol:

MAESTAS
03-26-2007, 06:10 PM
I thought the movie was great. It didn't show Michelangelo and Donatello that much. It was still a great movie, I will probably go see it again.

Revan
03-26-2007, 06:17 PM
I paid full admission for my ticket so don't come after me when I tell you I have been watching clips from fake user accounts on youtube. It's such a beautiful movie. Even better the second time you see it.

P.S. keep an eye out for pirate vids on youtube and alert the forum when they surface! FLAG THOSE VIDS!

Warhorse
03-26-2007, 09:49 PM
Yeah, I can see it that way, too, which makes it pretty darn cute. Long-time fans who get that there's never been any sexual tension between Leo and April would interpret it as a sibling-like, warm bond. But I can also see how people who are less familiar with it all would think that Leo heroically caught April and then they gazed at each other. :P

People did chuckle when Leo and April looked at eachother. I was like, Oh brother! But the second they started to talk about the family, all those weird funky feelings between those two dissappeared. But just for that second, it was akward.

Besides, I thought it was Leo and Karai that were the big shippers?;)

Rooish
03-26-2007, 11:02 PM
Oh lordy. Not touching Leo/Karai with a ten-foot pole. :)

MAESTAS and Neutrino, I agree with you both. Mikey and Donny weren't in it enough. But it was beautiful. And it's better the second time. (I can't wait for the third!) Man, I keep going back and forth between loving it to death and being disappointed.

Warhorse
03-26-2007, 11:17 PM
Oh lordy. Not touching Leo/Karai with a ten-foot pole. :)


Is that really a ten (12 inches per) foot pole, or a pole made of 10 foot ninjas?

Rooish
03-26-2007, 11:19 PM
:D

It would take ten Foot Ninjas to keep Leo and Karai off each other! ;) :lol:

Warhorse
03-26-2007, 11:25 PM
:D

It would take ten Foot Ninjas to keep Leo and Karai off each other! ;) :lol:


:D Sorry, I couldn't resist. You know, that whole Karai/Leo thing is almost like a F@#$%^ up version of Romeo and Juliet.:lol:

Revan
03-26-2007, 11:41 PM
:D Sorry, I couldn't resist. You know, that whole Karai/Leo thing is almost like a F@#$%^ up version of Romeo and Juliet.:lol:

It's so weird that a human could feel anything for a giant mutant turtle.

Has anyone ever thought of how crappy it would be to be a teenager and have no one to fool around with. ie) the tmnts

bummer

Warhorse
03-26-2007, 11:44 PM
It's so weird that a human could feel anything for a giant mutant turtle.

Has anyone ever thought of how crappy it would be to be a teenager and have no one to fool around with. ie) the tmnts

bummer

I think that is one of the biggest issues concerning Raph and his frustrations and anger. Considering he probably possesses the most testosterone out of all the Turtles.

wyze2099
03-27-2007, 12:11 AM
I think that is one of the biggest issues concerning Raph and his frustrations and anger. Considering he probably possesses the most testosterone out of all the Turtles.

Seriously. That turtle really. Really needs to get laid.

METALHEAD
03-27-2007, 04:14 AM
[QUOTE=Putrescent;482976]I thought those where people who dressed up in the costumes or are those plushies...oh my to many freaks in the club for me lol:lol:


<o.O> i'm a furry jack ass. and i'll have you know we're more normal and we're nicer people then starwars and startrek fans and tmnt is anthro-related most furries are into tmnt...i take o'fence of your comment sir but i will ignore that just as i ignore everyother idiot who thinks furries are sexual freaks which i'll have you know not ALL furries are like that:tmad:

VaughnMichael
03-27-2007, 06:11 AM
[QUOTE=Putrescent;482976]I thought those where people who dressed up in the costumes or are those plushies...oh my to many freaks in the club for me lol:lol:


<o.O> i'm a furry jack ass. and i'll have you know we're more normal and we're nicer people then starwars and startrek fans and tmnt is anthro-related most furries are into tmnt...i take o'fence of your comment sir but i will ignore that just as i ignore everyother idiot who thinks furries are sexual freaks which i'll have you know not ALL furries are like that:tmad:
ummmmm yeah I happen to be friends with some people who do that while I dont dig it I don't care what other people do as long as they arent having sex with real animals.
And the thing I said "to many freaks in the club" is a well known saying...like to many chefs in the kitchen i mean really you don't see any chefs coming in here and flipping out do you?
And I'll thank you to read the whole thread of before you jump down one persons throat.:evil:
p.s. please stop taking yourself so seriously I really find it funny from one person that dresses up and does caberet stage shows to another who dresses in animal costumes to really get pissed over something that insignificant it really makes you look insecure.

Fledermaus
03-27-2007, 11:44 AM
Am I the only one who got the impression that the ridiculous plot in TMNT was possible homage to the Ghostbusters movie, which came out in 1984 same as the first comic book? :D I swear, the swirling green portal/vortex looks just like the one above the skyscraper of the "Gate Keeper." And what about the Jersey Devil's uncanny resemblance to those cute, evil critters from Gremins -- which, interestingly, also came out in 1984? Did you guys spot anything else? :)

Spitfire
03-27-2007, 11:49 AM
[QUOTE=Putrescent;482976]I thought those where people who dressed up in the costumes or are those plushies...oh my to many freaks in the club for me lol:lol:


<o.O> i'm a furry jack ass. and i'll have you know we're more normal and we're nicer people then starwars and startrek fans and tmnt is anthro-related most furries are into tmnt...i take o'fence of your comment sir but i will ignore that just as i ignore everyother idiot who thinks furries are sexual freaks which i'll have you know not ALL furries are like that:tmad:

My X was into that ****. All her friends smelled like ass and they were the biggest group of ugliest nerds I have ever seen.

And I'm not shallow.

Moral of the story, this is why I avoid anime conventions.

Anarky
03-27-2007, 11:52 AM
Ladies, Gentlemen and Furries, would you please stop insulting the fluffier kind of humanity? And don't we all, deep down, crave a little yiffing?

No, seriously, thou shalt not bash minorities and minorities shalt not bash back, starting now.

Revan
03-27-2007, 11:53 AM
Am I the only one who got the impression that the ridiculous plot in TMNT was possible homage to the Ghostbusters movie, which came out in 1984 same as the first comic book? :D I swear, the swirling green portal/vortex looks just like the one above the skyscraper of the "Gate Keeper." And what about the Jersey Devil's uncanny resemblance to those cute, evil critters from Gremins -- which, interestingly, also came out in 1984? Did you guys spot anything else? :)

Ha there was so much more.

Winters' death = Beauty and the Beast
Opening battle in the past = Walled city of Troy in the background
Planets align unleashing monsters = Disney's Hercules

just to name a few

Fledermaus
03-27-2007, 11:56 AM
Ha there was so much more.

Winters' death = Beauty and the Beast
Opening battle in the past = Walled city of Troy in the background
Planets align unleashing monsters = Disney's Hercules

just to name a few

Actually... I meant stuff from the 80's in particular...

But yeah.:D TMNT started off as a pop culture parody, and it seems like it was done quite a bit in this film as well (though... perhaps too much:sweatdro: )

iris
03-27-2007, 12:18 PM
But yeah.:D TMNT started off as a pop culture parody, and it seems like it was done quite a bit in this film as well (though... perhaps too much:sweatdro: )

That's a good point. Kinda cool. And if it takes you multiple viewings and deep thought to see the pop culture parody (or influences), it probably wasn't overdone.

There's a lot of weird circular and parallel and metaphorical stuff going on in this movie, and I don't know how much of it was intentional. I'm really curious, because TMNT as parody has usually been pretty subtle, on average. Closer to a self-aware homage. TMNT rarely comes off like Shrek, which hits you over the head with its references.

For once, I can't wait for the director's commentary track on the DVD.

VaughnMichael
03-27-2007, 01:49 PM
Ladies, Gentlemen and Furries, would you please stop insulting the fluffier kind of humanity? And don't we all, deep down, crave a little yiffing?

No, seriously, thou shalt not bash minorities and minorities shalt not bash back, starting now.

um dude no one was bashing him he came into the thread posted not a single thing about the movie started bahsing me and I wasn't even the friggin one to start talking about shippers!:roll:

MadPirateBunny
03-27-2007, 04:25 PM
WOOHOO!

That friggin rocked!

Am very happy I got to see it! YAY!!!

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
03-27-2007, 05:50 PM
OK i'm back for good now :) and thank you for the kind words from other very nice board members :)

Went out to clear my head for a while and finally saw the new film today...would have seen it earlier but having no car has its' disadvantages.

The new film definately brought a smile to my face, and cheered up my day :) I was amazed by the musical score in this picture....it was handled with care and brought a little oomph to the emotion in the flick.

I do realize after seeing the film what people meant about the lack of Mikey and Donny....clips in commercials, etc. definately made me think they would have been in it longer. But the screen time they did have were very nice to see. Being a big Raphael fan it definately brought a few smiles to my face...especially his intro with the wonderful music behind it equaled fun times.

It does seem like some scenes were abruptly cut/missing...or maybe that was just me. I can't put my finger on why I think that though. And was it me or did the ending seem a little...quick? lol I'm sure it's just me...it's still a fine way to end the flick.

It's too bad there were really no Mikey/Raph moments...I love their 'buddy cop' like relationship in the new toon, and Mikey being a fan of the Nightwatcher I thought their would be some more moments between those 2 characters...but that's just my own geeky gripe.

Other than that the film is a well voiced, beautiful looking, wonderful addition to the TMNT universe.

LogicDonny
03-27-2007, 06:15 PM
Sup friends.

Sorry to take so long to get here but I had work and was busy.

I just saw it today because my friend was very tired and didn't want to go last night so we waited till this afternoon and catch the early show. hardly anybody there becuase of school for them.

I finished work while he had the day off so ya.

We both thought it was a really awesome movie. He isn't a big fan of the turtles like me but he enjoyed every second.

He said the animation, fight, soundtrack was really good.

I agree with him. the only thing that bothered me is how short it was.

Now what did Karai say at the end of the movie when she spoke to the turtles after the big fight?

I really was impressed with the movie. The fight between Leo and Ralph/Nightwatcher was really beatiful and the rain made the scenry more cooler.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
03-27-2007, 08:50 PM
Mini-spoilers (just putting that up just in case)

LogicDonny I think Karai says something to the effect that they are as good of fighters as she was told...and to live it up now cause in the future there will be 'further business' with someone 'familiar faces from your past'

Or in other words, Shredder

GK Punk
03-27-2007, 11:04 PM
Just saw it.

Wow. Just wow. I liked it so much better than I figured I would. A great movie.

Kingpun
03-28-2007, 12:30 AM
You know, I was a Leonardo fan for as long as I could remember and after rewatching the original trilogy a few years ago, I couldn't see why he was my favorite turtle. I think it was because blue was my favorite color and that's enough for a kid. However after watching TMNT, I am a born again Leo fan. This was such a well done movie, and easily the most beautiful CG movie I've ever seen. I've run into a lot of people who hated Splinter's voice but I thought he stole the show. He wasn't weak and frail anymore. And yet again Klaus Badelt has stepped in as a replacement composer and hit one out of the park. I'm dying to see TMNT 2, or 6...whatever.

If the movie had one weakness however, I don't think it can stand alone. If I didn't already know and love the characters, I'm not sure how much this movie would have pulled me in. You sort of need some nostalgic familiarity with the turtles' personalities prior to going in, cause it really seemed like a sequel. However I know these characters better than I know some of my extended family so it didn't bug me one bit.

LogicDonny
03-28-2007, 01:02 AM
Mini-spoilers (just putting that up just in case)

LogicDonny I think Karai says something to the effect that they are as good of fighters as she was told...and to live it up now cause in the future there will be 'further business' with someone 'familiar faces from your past'

Or in other words, Shredder

ok thanks.

Brandatello
03-28-2007, 04:59 PM
You know, I was a Leonardo fan for as long as I could remember and after rewatching the original trilogy a few years ago, I couldn't see why he was my favorite turtle. I think it was because blue was my favorite color and that's enough for a kid. However after watching TMNT, I am a born again Leo fan. This was such a well done movie, and easily the most beautiful CG movie I've ever seen. I've run into a lot of people who hated Splinter's voice but I thought he stole the show. He wasn't weak and frail anymore. And yet again Klaus Badelt has stepped in as a replacement composer and hit one out of the park. I'm dying to see TMNT 2, or 6...whatever.

If the movie had one weakness however, I don't think it can stand alone. If I didn't already know and love the characters, I'm not sure how much this movie would have pulled me in. You sort of need some nostalgic familiarity with the turtles' personalities prior to going in, cause it really seemed like a sequel. However I know these characters better than I know some of my extended family so it didn't bug me one bit.
yeah leo used to be my least fav turtle but now i like him again...but on the other had i cant stress how great this movie was...it really reminded me of the comics but more kid like....i waould have been juast as happy if it was fully cartoon movie i love cartoon movies...the only thing i didnt like was...the camera mad me dizzy. other than that the movie was great
tony the tiger "there grrreat!" srry bout that i just thought of that now...i dont care what critics thought of the movie if they thought it wasnt the best animated movie of 2007...think about it they have been working thier shells of since 2005 maybe earlier...i think this is the best animated movie ever...the sequel was be just as great.

Warhorse
03-28-2007, 07:43 PM
Wow brandatello. It was those slick camera moves that I thought made this movie stand apart compared to other cartoons or cgi flicks. Just totally cool.

But I guess I can see where you are coming from. My cousin got sick watching Mikey's skateboarding skit.

Revan
03-29-2007, 01:26 AM
My cousin got sick watching Mikey's skateboarding skit.

I just sat with my mouth wide open. I could not believe how beautiful everything looked. The camera zipping around showing tons of angles while Mikey dodges garbage.

The Cowabunga Carl Van seems rediculously far away from the lair. It must be a b$%tch to get there on foot.

LogicDonny
03-29-2007, 01:57 AM
what do you guys was the best cgi moments that made the movie shined.

mine would be the leo/raph fight and the rain and all beatiful

also the courtyard battle too.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-29-2007, 02:24 AM
what do you guys was the best cgi moments that made the movie shined.

mine would be the leo/raph fight and the rain and all beatiful

also the courtyard battle too.

Mikey skateboard scene, Leo vs Raph, Courtyard scene, opening scene.

Warhorse
03-29-2007, 05:46 AM
what do you guys was the best cgi moments that made the movie shined.

mine would be the leo/raph fight and the rain and all beatiful

also the courtyard battle too.

I can't remember exactly what scene, but it was either when Casey spoiled Raph's Nightwatcher disguize, or when they were talking to eachother on the roof before Raph got shot in the arm. But there is a scene where the camera goes from behind Casey and Raph, to above and showing all of New York City, and I thought that was some impressive cgi there. It left me in awe.

As for the fight scene, I think it's more of the excellent sound editing more than the visuals. Someone really knew when to execute the "shinkt" of metal sais and swords being unsheathed and and clashing against eachother.

johnnyblaze
03-29-2007, 09:23 AM
I got a kick out of this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dv0403zv3vE

notice the kid who was so amazed by the turtles ability to beat the crap out of, as he puts it, thousands of foot soldiers. lol, great stuff

Drtooth
03-29-2007, 02:59 PM
What did I think? SHELL YEAH! A++++ With out a doubt, the best one since the fi8rst one in 1990! I especially loved how they didn't dumb things down by telling anyone who Karai was. That's a real service to fans that they don't have to listen to an origen story all over. In fact, Leo and Karai's exchange of "YOU!!!!" pretty much said it all.

The scenes with Raph and Leo were powerful stuff. You can tell there is sibling rivalry, and it may just in fact be the sourse of Raph's violent anger.

And I also like that dispite the fact they had some celebrity voices, they didn't market the entire thing as the movie depended on it (DReamworks...cough cough..)

I also liked the 2 very subtle refferences to the old cartoon series.The design of Cowabunga Carl's head (don't tell me that wasn't intentional) and Mikey eating Pizza with cereal on it.

The only thing I would say negative was it seemed to short overall.

But,as Telly Monster would say, I give this movie 5 Wows!

WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW!!

MAESTAS
03-30-2007, 04:56 PM
I'm not sure if I said this already but they should have involved Don and Mikey more in the movie, they were not in it that much. They should have also put more fighting scenes in the movie too. But it was still the best TMNT yet.

Masked Ninja
03-31-2007, 02:17 AM
Random story: I was going to do laundry in the dorm basement, wearing my huge TMNT nightshirt (aka, adult L T-shirt :trazz: ) and my RA stops me in the hall to tell me she just saw TMNT and it was "soooo good."

Made me smile. :tpizza:

Seiza
03-31-2007, 08:02 AM
I keep seeing random "TMNT!!! (pizza) (turtle) (pizza)" lines on my MSN list. It's awesome. :D

I realise the turtles, Splinter, April and Casey kinda... plowed through the Foot ninjas during the movie at an abysmally easy pace... but other than that, I thought they looked really cool. Professional, almost, with the way Karai just has to make a sound and a wave, and off they go. Very slick and impressive.

Garou
03-31-2007, 08:55 AM
I loved the movie, but I only gave it an A. I would have given it a plus too, if only there had been more screentime for Donnie and Mikey. I missed them once in a while.

I brought a friend to the movies, who isn't one of the biggest fans, but he likes TMNT still. He had to agree, that it was a great movie and that the animation rocked! I couldn't see it before, because it was shone for the first time yesterday where I live.

I was amazed by the fight between Leo and Raph. Both the sound and the animation was beautifully done. Their movements made me sit in awe with my jaw hanging somewhere below my knees :tlol: And just the rain itself amazed me.

blueoakleyz
03-31-2007, 10:40 PM
I hadn't thought about it too much this week, but sorta subconsciously it ate at me. Then I had a dream about it last night. The truth hurts to myself but I honestly did not like this movie. It's kind of disappointing.

I guess I really do stick by the rating I gave it as a goof

I actually didn't mind that seeing as I'm into skateboarding.

So am I, my point was just that seeing him do tricks was pointless to me because in the back of my head I know that it was just some guy sitting there with a computer mouse doing that.. not someone with actual skateboard skill

Fledermaus
03-31-2007, 10:55 PM
Go away!!!!!!:x

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-01-2007, 12:09 AM
I hadn't thought about it too much this week, but sorta subconsciously it ate at me. Then I had a dream about it last night. The truth hurts to myself but I honestly did not like this movie. It's kind of disappointing.

I guess I really do stick by the rating I gave it as a goof



So am I, my point was just that seeing him do tricks was pointless to me because in the back of my head I know that it was just some guy sitting there with a computer mouse doing that.. not someone with actual skateboard skill

And why is that a problem? That sequence showed how talented the animators at IMAGI are.

Spitfire
04-01-2007, 12:11 AM
So am I, my point was just that seeing him do tricks was pointless to me because in the back of my head I know that it was just some guy sitting there with a computer mouse doing that.. not someone with actual skateboard skill

Maybe it was pointless to you because you completely failed to see it was to show his personality. How much fun he likes to have. He has all that fun and then comes home and feels bored and lonely.

Do people even pay attention in movies anymore? Or do they just drool on themselves.

kryka83
04-01-2007, 12:13 AM
And why is that a problem? That sequence showed how talented the animators at IMAGI are.

yeah, those guys really ARE talented...i saw the movie for the 3rd time yesterday and it still amazes me...if you watch closely even the turtles expressions and eye rolling (between raph and leo especially) is very detailed and match how WE would react facially! I really am anticipating seeing this movie on dvd and hoping for extra features and scenes ^_^

blueoakleyz
04-01-2007, 12:13 AM
And why is that a problem? That sequence showed how talented the animators at IMAGI are.

Yeah that impresses me zilch

they can spend 6 months on a sequence that last 30 seconds
real skateboarders only actually HAVE 30 seconds to do it.

Fledermaus
04-01-2007, 12:22 AM
Yeah that impresses me zilch

they can spend 6 months on a sequence that last 30 seconds
real skateboarders only actually HAVE 30 seconds to do it.

In other words: both "tricks" are very difficult to master.:roll:

Masked Ninja
04-01-2007, 12:53 AM
You've never animated anything in your life, have you? :roll:

Scrapmo
04-01-2007, 01:25 AM
my point was just that seeing him do tricks was pointless to me because in the back of my head I know that it was just some guy sitting there with a computer mouse doing that.. not someone with actual skateboard skill

So your in the theater watching Giant Turtles who can talk and learned ninjitsu from a giant rat and your problem with the movie was that the skateboarding wasnt real....:ohwell:

Ecto Jedi
04-01-2007, 01:31 AM
So your in the theater watching Giant Turtles who can talk and learned ninjitsu from a giant rat and your problem with the movie was that the skateboarding wasnt real....:ohwell:

Yeah, he's an idiot. Case closed.

blueoakleyz
04-01-2007, 01:35 AM
Yeah I'm an idiot because I have an opinion
you're real mature

Leonardo Mystic
04-01-2007, 01:59 AM
blue, there's a big difference between on having an opinion and just plain being anal as you are doing. Okay, we've gotten the message; you don't like the new movie because of this, that and the other. That's perfectly fine, but don't continue to jump on someone with your negative two cents on their views because they like it.

If you want to go make your own movie of what you want, go right ahead. You think you can do better. I agree with MN. I don't think you have ever animated anything in your life, and how much hard work really goes into it, especially CGI. It is not just a simple click of the mouse, and BAM! you've got your scene. No, absolutely not. It's almost like traditional drawing only in digitalized 3D.

I'd be very intrigued, and amused, to see you do it.

Revan
04-01-2007, 02:01 AM
I think reality went out the window during the opening sequence (monsters coming through a portal... c'mon really) and never showed it's face again. But that's why the Movie is awesome. I don't go to movies to see the real world cuz frankly, my real world is boring.

Leonardo Mystic
04-01-2007, 02:07 AM
I don't go to movies to see the real world cuz frankly, my real world is boring.

I concur. :) I like to escape the real world, and live in a world such as the Turtles' for awhile.

blueoakleyz
04-01-2007, 02:25 AM
So your in the theater watching Giant Turtles who can talk and learned ninjitsu from a giant rat and your problem with the movie was that the skateboarding wasnt real....:ohwell:

Well humans are just giant monkeys/apes so why would that be unbelievable?

I concur. :) I like to escape the real world, and live in a world such as the Turtles' for awhile.

The whole point of the first three movies was to see the Ninja Turtles in the real world, that's why people were so excited about them.

Fledermaus
04-01-2007, 02:58 AM
Well humans are just giant monkeys/apes so why would that be unbelievable?

...

No comment...

Leonardo Mystic
04-01-2007, 03:03 AM
The whole point of the first three movies was to see the Ninja Turtles in the real world, that's why people were so excited about them.

-_- You don't get it, do you? The Turtles' world is not our own, whether they're people in rubber suits or CGI animated. That's the beauty of it; that's what appeals to the greater audience, because for a little while we can live the lives of our favorite characters instead of ours. Ever read a book even?

You're just another one of those people who is never going to accept something to enjoy it for what it is. You negatively block it all out because it's not what you want. You judge this movie based on your preceptions of other mediums, and it doesn't work.

Tell me something, do you go through your entire daily life like this? Because you're only setting yourself up for disappointment each and every time, and you'll never be happy or acceptive.

blueoakleyz
04-01-2007, 03:06 AM
-_- You don't get it, do you? The Turtles' world is not our own, whether they're people in rubber suits or CGI animated. That's the beauty of it; that's what appeals to the greater audience, because for a little while we can live the lives of our favorite characters instead of ours. Ever read a book even?

You're just another one of those people who is never going to accept something to enjoy it for what it is. You negatively block it all out because it's not what you want. You judge this movie based on your preceptions of other mediums, and it doesn't work.

Tell me something, do you go through your entire daily life like this? Because you're only setting yourself up for disappointment each and every time, and you'll never be happy or acceptive.


I'm done arguing about it, my opinion is what it is.
-Hated the CGI
-Hated the story/plot
-Did not like this movie

Leonardo Mystic
04-01-2007, 03:13 AM
And that should have been all that you needed to say in the first place instead of being a prude. Your opinion would have been a lot better respected.

Fledermaus
04-01-2007, 03:14 AM
I'm done arguing about it, my opinion is what it is.
-Hated the CGI
-Hated the story/plot
-Did not like this movie

Yeah you're done. Until you forget about the whole thing two days from now and come back arguing the same things over and over again. :roll:

Dude...

There comes a time when you've just got to let go of your argument knowing that you will never, ever, no many how many times you repeat yourself, convince the other side of agreeing with you. Ever. You just have to accept it and truly move on. :(

And FYI, the more you keep this up... the more likely someone is to hire a PI to track you down so that he can come after you in the night with an ax whilst you twiddle away at the keyboard -- mercifully putting an end to this madness once and for all...

blueoakleyz
04-01-2007, 03:16 AM
Yeah you're done. Until you forget about the whole thing two days from now and come back arguing the same things over and over again. :roll:

Dude...

There comes a time when you've just got to let go of your argument knowing that you will never, ever, no many how many times you repeat yourself, convince the other side of agreeing with you. Ever. You just have to accept it and truly move on. :(

And FYI, the more you keep this up... the more likely someone is to hire a PI to track you down so that he can come after you in the night in an ax whilst you twiddle with the keyboard -- putting an end to this madness once and for all...

I welcome that

Fledermaus
04-01-2007, 03:20 AM
Ohhhhhh..... He's suicidal. Well that explains it! :lol:

Now I'm gonna leave before I say something really bad and get this thread closed. You're turning this thread into a joke and the fact that we're actually paying attention to you is making it worse.

So I'm gonna change the topic: Tune in tomorrow night (er... I guess that's tonight) -- for the Fledermaus will be seeing the movie for a second time and will doubtless have some new thoughts to share.

Good morning!

Spitfire
04-01-2007, 03:42 PM
I'm done arguing about it, my opinion is what it is.
-Hated the CGI
-Hated the story/plot
-Did not like this movie

Didn't I school you yesterday, why are you still here complaining about this? Oh because you ignored my post, what people tend to do when someone makes them look stupid.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-01-2007, 03:57 PM
I welcome that

You'll never learn, will you?

Scrapmo
04-01-2007, 04:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scrapmo
"So your in the theater watching Giant Turtles who can talk and learned ninjitsu from a giant rat and your problem with the movie was that the skateboarding wasnt real...."

Well humans are just giant monkeys/apes so why would that be unbelievable?



Your right giant ninja turtles are completley believable. :roll:

Lay off the drugs son.

iris
04-01-2007, 04:12 PM
Your right giant ninja turtles are completley believable. :roll:

Lay off the drugs son.

You... you mean they're not real?

:tcry:

Jo Dawn
04-01-2007, 05:46 PM
Alright, let's continue discussing the movie, and not sullying the thread with arguement. For my full thoughts, please read the 'Front Line's thread. Other than that, we're done arguing.

The Shelf
04-01-2007, 05:51 PM
Guess what guys?!?! Turtles RULE!!!!!!!111!!!1!!1!

I just had to get that out. :thyper:

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-01-2007, 06:31 PM
I think I'll see the movie a third time. It just gets better the more you watch it.

Fledermaus
04-01-2007, 08:25 PM
Just saw the film for a second time...

Loved it just as much, perhaps even more.:D Part of what makes it better the second time around is, there's less shock from the CRAZY Max-Winters-and-the-13-monsters plotline. By now, as a viewer, I was able to accept the crazier elements -- and just enjoy the characters. There was a lot in this movie I didn't notice the first time around.

By now, I think I've had my fill of the movie -- If I do see it again, I'll give it at least another two weeks before I return to the theater.

Now, to be fair... as a fan, I'd give the movie an A-. As an average moviegoer, this movie was a fair B. Not perfect, but there was definitely a strong "family" vibe in the movie -- there is a genuine sense of resolution for the characters -- especially Raphael, some for Leo...

And... I did pay more attention to Mikey and Don's characters. We didn't get to see much, but what we DID see always said something about them. Michelangelo, I noticed the second time, really seems to look up to Leo. When he first sees him, he runs smack into him with a heartfelt (sniff, sob) HUG! Then, even sadder, he eavesdrops on Splinter and Raph. The look on the poor guy's face when he hears what's become of his brother. Ah, he is truly the child of the family.:)

Really, just get around to watching it a second time. The reduction of shock factor really makes it much easier to watch... whole suspension of disbelief thing is taken care of second time around.

Yeah. Good movie.:D

kryka83
04-01-2007, 11:18 PM
Just saw the film for a second time...

Loved it just as much, perhaps even more.:D Part of what makes it better the second time around is, there's less shock from the CRAZY Max-Winters-and-the-13-monsters plotline. By now, as a viewer, I was able to accept the crazier elements -- and just enjoy the characters. There was a lot in this movie I didn't notice the first time around.

By now, I think I've had my fill of the movie -- If I do see it again, I'll give it at least another two weeks before I return to the theater.

Now, to be fair... as a fan, I'd give the movie an A-. As an average moviegoer, this movie was a fair B. Not perfect, but there was definitely a strong "family" vibe in the movie -- there is a genuine sense of resolution for the characters -- especially Raphael, some for Leo...

And... I did pay more attention to Mikey and Don's characters. We didn't get to see much, but what we DID see always said something about them. Michelangelo, I noticed the second time, really seems to look up to Leo. When he first sees him, he runs smack into him with a heartfelt (sniff, sob) HUG! Then, even sadder, he eavesdrops on Splinter and Raph. The look on the poor guy's face when he hears what's become of his brother. Ah, he is truly the child of the family.:)

Really, just get around to watching it a second time. The reduction of shock factor really makes it much easier to watch... whole suspension of disbelief thing is taken care of second time around.

Yeah. Good movie.:D

Yeah, i saw it for the 3rd time last night and the facial expressions have captivated me - specifically in the breakfast scene where the boys are arguing and then try to act innocent when Splinter comes in. The characters body language, voices, and personalities are really strong in this movie - by personalities i mean (going back to the breakfast scene) by Donny, Mikey, and Leo all bowing their heads and whispering "morning Sensei" and Raph just being moody and say "sup" or Mikey's playfulness and tendency for lame jokes (the Winters joke at the end was pretty funny honestly. "looks more like Fall to me...get it??? Mikey we already had this discussion, remember?" ^_^ Clumsiness was brilliant too! Donny's calmness and argument with Raphael and logic was brought out, and jumpiness when Raph spooked him.
Sure, plot was mild, but all this detail in bringing everything else to "life" is the most intriguing for me. One of my friends saw it with me and she said that she forgot it wasn't real in some spots, such as when the airplane wheels came down and it zoomed in on Leo, and then in the city skylines.

Overall, pretty brilliant work, even if the skateboarding scenes weren't realistic or whatever it was that some people have been commenting about...i can't recall another movie that HAD that level of difficulty of CGI as it did in that small scene. Refresh my memory if there is one, because i can't think of any...

Daunt
04-01-2007, 11:30 PM
Ok, I managed to see the movie a second time by taking my little bro (uh...25 year old little bro. >_>; ) and he loved it. He dressed up as Leo back in the day (my dad made him a paper mache shell, it was pretty cool!) and had a great time watching the movie.

Now I have to figure out a way to sneak out and see it again. My husband laughed when I told him I wanted to see it again. :( He called me a 'Nerdle'!

....

I am a Nerdle. X)

kryka83
04-01-2007, 11:38 PM
Ok, I managed to see the movie a second time by taking my little bro (uh...25 year old little bro. >_>; ) and he loved it. He dressed up as Leo back in the day (my dad made him a paper mache shell, it was pretty cool!) and had a great time watching the movie.

Now I have to figure out a way to sneak out and see it again. My husband laughed when I told him I wanted to see it again. :( He called me a 'Nerdle'!

....

I am a Nerdle. X)

hurray for Nerdles!!! Hostile takeover should begin soon...^_^ I'm proud to be a Nerdle!!! Are You?

Revan
04-01-2007, 11:38 PM
Now I have to figure out a way to sneak out and see it again.

Ha, have you ever caught 2 or 3 movies on the same ticket stub. It's not even that hard. Just duck into a diff theatre after your movie. Ha. of course I never have.

Daunt
04-01-2007, 11:41 PM
Ha, have you ever caught 2 or 3 movies on the same ticket stub. It's not even that hard. Just duck into a diff theatre after your movie. Ha. of course I never have.

Oooooh, so like, I could score a double showing of Blades of Glory AND TMNT in one sitting! Hah, I'd feel so devious. That'd be the most illegal thing I've done since I turned right on a red when the sign told me not too...

And yes, Nerdles unite! :D

Anarky
04-02-2007, 01:43 AM
I have made a terrible mistake. I watched TMNT, enjoyed it to some extent, saw a flaw here and there but nothing really major. Of course, I went on the Drome and read what you guys had to say. "Groundbreaking CGI", I read, and "Fantastic story" and whatever you all gushed about. And then, Shrek II was on in the evening. I liked Shrek I, so I watched part II. And while I was lying in my bed, watching the tale of the green ogre against Jeniffer Saunders. And while I was watching, I thought about how you were gushing over TMNT and that it was actually a nice movie. Then came the moment when I thought "Waitaminute, if TMNT has got groundbreaking CGI, why does Shrek II have better CGI?" I chalked that up to budget, but my belief in "groundbreaking CGI" was broken. Then I knew that TMNT had many pop culture references, which made me chuckle. Shrek II's pop culture references made me laugh. So TMNT wasn't all that funny anymore. And TMNT's soundtrack wasn't fantastic to begin with. In fact, their rendition of Black Betty was downright horrible, but still, some of the soundtrack fit at certain points... more or less. And then Jeniffer Saunders, Eddie Murphy and Antonio Banderas sang their own soundtrack. How on earth do you want to beat that? The songs weren't new, they weren't spectacularly good but they were so damn awesome in the movie. It was absolutely fabulous.

And while I know I'm going to take heavy fire for this post, since I probably just slaughtered the holy cow, I want to let you know this: Don't watch Shrek II and TMNT on the same day.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-02-2007, 02:18 AM
I just have oto disagree with you.

Even with a lower budget, TMNT still managed scens like these.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQnThyBRCqU
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ii1NQI86tM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmOnsjaKryU

Which are visually more impressive than anything Shrek had to offer. So, really, what does that say about them. On a 75 million dollar production budget, they could'nt accomplish the same quality as a film with a 34 million dollar budget(which is less than what they spent on marketing).

Also, I didn't notice any of the pop culture gags you speak of, most of the humor was character based. Shrek was one pop culture gag after another.

And you consider Eddie Murphy singing a high point for Shrek? Having Eddie Murphy in it at all cost it some respect.

Spitfire
04-02-2007, 02:34 AM
I never liked Shrek at all so that won't be a problem.

Daunt
04-02-2007, 03:33 AM
Anarky, you are allowed to have other opinions! It's ok, no one is going to kill you.

Actually I didn't find the TMNT CGI particularly ground breaking visually. (note: I am totally not an expert, I'm just reacting from a visual standpoint) But it looked awesome to me, groundbreaking or not. Not perfect but definitely awesome. Second viewing made it easier to see the flaws in it. BUT at the same time, I think what made the TMNT movie shine was the great directing and the storyboarding. The director kept the voice actors in tune with his vision and the scenes were very memorable.

Shrek is cool! Loved it. :) I love TMNT too but they're both so different from each other I don't know that I could compare them side by side....

Fledermaus
04-02-2007, 07:24 AM
Anarky... I think most animators agree that TMNT didn't "break new grounds" in the animation dept. -- it only showed off what can be done in a CG animated movie. The movie's main CGI highlights were lighting, texture, and composition -- and the animation in a few select scenes. The animation overall was good, but like Masked Ninja has stated -- not even close to Pixar quality except in one or two scenes. It's strengths were in applying tried-and-true techniques in ways that hadn't really been done before in CG animated movies (mostly with creating a real life/comic book hybrid look throughout the movie). I can say that TMNT had some really beautiful moments. Shrek II may have had better "animation" but didn't feature anything that made me grin with delight. For me, TMNT was "fun to watch" for visual reasons -- whereas Shrek II was fun to watch, because it was "funny."


Though some people disagree on that one too...:sweatdro:

Also, the other reason some may conclude that the animation in TMNT wasn't so great... I got the feeling that quite a number of scenes (like the bad guys hanging from Nightwatcher's chain) did not have the same level of detail or smoothness as other scenes. They actually stood out from the rest of the film in a bad way. A few other scenes looked like they hadn't gone on to the last phase of tweaking the animation. If this had been a Pixar flick, they would have gone over all the scenes again and again and again until each part of the film -- not just a few, or even 3/4 of it, but the whole thing -- was the best it could be.

iris
04-02-2007, 09:07 AM
Anarky... I think most animators agree that TMNT didn't "break new grounds" in the animation dept. -- it only showed off what can be done in a CG animated movie. The movie's main CGI highlights were lighting, texture, and composition -- and the animation in a few select scenes. The animation overall was good, but like Masked Ninja has stated -- not even close to Pixar quality except in one or two scenes. It's strengths were in applying tried-and-true techniques in ways that hadn't really been done before in CG animated movies (mostly with creating a real life/comic book hybrid look throughout the movie). I can say that TMNT had some really beautiful moments. Shrek II may have had better "animation" but didn't feature anything that made me grin with delight. For me, TMNT was "fun to watch" for visual reasons -- whereas Shrek II was fun to watch, because it was "funny."

Yes, that. TMNT used lighting and texture to full effect, which gave most scenes the kind of weight that Shrek only had in small doses.

Except I didn't enjoy Shrek II. Loved Shrek I... excellent film.

Keno
04-02-2007, 11:31 AM
I saw the movie first on opening weekend, I was on my own in a full theatre. I'm kinda glad I went alone because I knew my friends would have a ton of comments and this way, I was able to fully enjoy it. I think like many other people, my first viewing of it was just too emotional..as in, I had too many expectations, as a huge long time Turtles fan ... so it was only after the second viewing was I able to FULLY enjoy it. I think (as a huge Leo fan) I spent the whole film looking forward to the Leo-Raph battle.

I've heard some other people point out that this movie made them appreciate Leo as a character. I have to say, I have been a huge Leo fan for the past few years, but this film made me really start to appreciate Raph. Not that I never enjoyed him before, I always knew he was a great character, but I don't know, seeing it the third time, I think I can say this movie has REALLY made me into a huge Raph fan ... just the way how everyone else moves on but he NEEDS to continue doing what he thinks is right, that is, seeking justice, and I especially love the part when he's trying to give the money back to the Diner guy and he is going "take whatever you want!" and Raph says "Why doesn't anyone get that I'm just trying to help!!" it's just seeing his frustration coming out. I think my favourite scenes in the movie are the Nightwater/Jersey Devil fight scene, I really love it with the music and humour and I think I can just watch that over and over forever, and then how it leads up to the Leo-Raph fight on the rooftops. I also love how Leo is on the rooftop, watching him run. I love how when Raph (as Nightwater) encounters Caset on the roof, and doesn't want to fight him (but then Casey knows it's him), compared to how when he encounters Leo, (who doesn't realize it's him), he fights him fully. I just thought it was sweet how alot of things are interconnected, that I didn't notice at the first time.

Some details I really loved the second time seeing it:

When they're in April/Casey's apartment and April is talking about the legend, and Mikey is sitting on the arm rest of the couch, and his legs are bouncing. For me that's like his energetic personality really coming through in a subtle way. Also, in the Leo-Raph fight, just before Leo takes out his weapons, he sorta takes an extra breath. Love it.

I really noticed and was impressed with the animation the second time around. The first time I really don't know what I was thinking, haha.

The part where the Nightwater is standing on the rooftop, overlooking the city and how the camera pans backwards...that part is spectacular to me.

I too, was a bit dissapointed with the music because I was hoping for something more like th first movie, which I loved the score of (the blend of modern and traditional sounds) I really enjoy the Nightwater score now.

There were alot of plot points I didn't pay attention to until the second viewing .. but one thing that stuck out to me was the Leo being away thing. Was that explained in the prequel comics, maybe? Was it something similar to the stuff that happened in Season 4 of the cartoon? I think if there was more explaination there it would have added more depth to the plot.

Anyways, those are my thoughts. I can't wait to see it again.

Anarky
04-02-2007, 12:52 PM
And you consider Eddie Murphy singing a high point for Shrek? Having Eddie Murphy in it at all cost it some respect. It's not Eddie Murphy per se, but the fact that they had their cast sing for the song. It's not really something I expect from TMNT, but it was simply amazing to hear them. I mean, I knew Jeniffer Saunders could be loud, but her song was mindblowing, really. Also, Eddie Murphy and Antonio Banderas' final was so much better than anything the TMNT-soundtrack had to offer. To me, the TMNT-soundtrack felt like "Oh, here's an album that has 30 of the coolest tracks of today. Let's use those!" while Shrek felt more like "So, what song could we let Jeniffer Saunders sing? And what should Banderas sing?" It felt more inspired, I guess you could say that.

Also, the impact the scenes had in Shrek were way bigger than anything TMNT had to offer. Leo's "I have half a dozen swords that disappear in a second"-shot was nowhere near the Puss in Boots doing the Flashdance-move with the water. I guess, TMNT lacked the... je-ne-sais-quoi, the "Whoomph!" the scenes had. I'm not saying I want more violence, sex and drugs, but they just didn't strike me as awesome as they could have been. If you want a good example, take the "Leo's half a dozen swords"-scene. It should be one of those Goosebumps-moments, right? All it got me doing was raising an eyebrow. The scene was completely out of context, felt awkward and had no connection to what was happening in that scene. Or Raph jumping from the balcony after he threw the terribly unispired stone general down. You expect something to happen. Something awesome, something wicked. But all you get is a guy thrown into some whirly vortex-thing.

See what I mean? And I never said that it's groundbreaking CGI, I just read that here after seeing the movie. I guess I could even dig the post up for you, if you insist. And I'm not saying it's bad. It's fine. The whole animation just lacked impact. It was just "bleh."

Daunt
04-02-2007, 01:16 PM
Anarky, I gotta say that I disagree with ya there. I really found the TMNT movie to have a lot more moments of 'impact' than Shrek, though I did adore Shrek. They just seem too different (to me) to compare like that...

I mean, I loved hearing Antonio sing and the beautiful cg and cleaver jokes etc but that seems like a very different sort of impact than Leo and Raph clashing on a rooftop. It seems more like I "I prefer comedy movies versus action movies" (not that it's what you're implying)...They just are two very different movies and the impact is going to be different between them. Just my opinion though.

I'm not saying you're wrong or that TMNT 2007 is the -best movie ever- (which it's not) it had plenty of flaws. I'm just disagreeing with the 'impact' part of your argument.

Oi vey, forgive me if this makes no sense, I'm short on braincells today. D:

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-02-2007, 01:49 PM
It's not Eddie Murphy per se, but the fact that they had their cast sing for the song. It's not really something I expect from TMNT, but it was simply amazing to hear them. I mean, I knew Jeniffer Saunders could be loud, but her song was mindblowing, really. Also, Eddie Murphy and Antonio Banderas' final was so much better than anything the TMNT-soundtrack had to offer. To me, the TMNT-soundtrack felt like "Oh, here's an album that has 30 of the coolest tracks of today. Let's use those!" while Shrek felt more like "So, what song could we let Jeniffer Saunders sing? And what should Banderas sing?" It felt more inspired, I guess you could say that.

Also, the impact the scenes had in Shrek were way bigger than anything TMNT had to offer. Leo's "I have half a dozen swords that disappear in a second"-shot was nowhere near the Puss in Boots doing the Flashdance-move with the water. I guess, TMNT lacked the... je-ne-sais-quoi, the "Whoomph!" the scenes had. I'm not saying I want more violence, sex and drugs, but they just didn't strike me as awesome as they could have been. If you want a good example, take the "Leo's half a dozen swords"-scene. It should be one of those Goosebumps-moments, right? All it got me doing was raising an eyebrow. The scene was completely out of context, felt awkward and had no connection to what was happening in that scene. Or Raph jumping from the balcony after he threw the terribly unispired stone general down. You expect something to happen. Something awesome, something wicked. But all you get is a guy thrown into some whirly vortex-thing.

See what I mean? And I never said that it's groundbreaking CGI, I just read that here after seeing the movie. I guess I could even dig the post up for you, if you insist. And I'm not saying it's bad. It's fine. The whole animation just lacked impact. It was just "bleh."

I agree with the whole "lack of a bigger battle" thing, but with Warner Bros only giving them 34 mill, I guess it's the best we could hope for.

As for Leo's half dozen swords, they don't instantly disappear, we do see him use them breifly, but you can see Gato knocking them all away.

As for the soundtrack, I had no problem with it, I like indie rock, and Fulled by Ramen(they had 4 of they're artist on the soundtrack). But really, a cast signing on the soundtrack isn't exactly my idea of a high point.

But I still gotta say, I disagree on the animation. Shrek 2 really didn't have the kinda impact TMNT had. When the action kicked up, you felt it. The facial animation were extremley well done, there was alot of emotion behind it. Shreks was good and all, but I didn't get that same kinda "OMG" moment I got when I watched the Leo/Raph battle.

Masked Ninja
04-02-2007, 01:49 PM
I get ya, Anarky. TMNT was enjoyable, but in a lot of ways it couldn't measure up to much of the stuff Pixar and Dreamworks has put out. However, in context of its budget, which was much smaller than most of those big studio films take to make... it is impressive.

That's why I maintain that I'm under no delusions that it was the best CGI movie ever. It wasn't - and I can list all kinds of changes I would have made if I'd been in charge. Including... more jokes that were actually funny, and lipsync that matched the voiceover more of the time. But there were some things about it that were great - the overall visual look for one thing. I know I'd love to see Pixar do something that looks dark and gritty like this, but it'll probably never happen. And while the monsters were cheesy, cliche, etc... I'll always, as a Turtle fan, be drawn back to the family drama at its heart. Heck, I was just glad to see everyone in character, and Leo given some negative qualities for once (as much as I like the boy, I hate seeing him as the "perfect" son).

Do I want to see it again? Yes... especially since many have said it's better the second time when you know the plot and have time to look for some of the details put in. Will I buy it on DVD? Again, yes... so long as it's not as grossly overpriced as a lot of Disney/Pixar discs. Best movie ever? Still not. Though I'd put it on about the level of the first movie for the family bit alone. Both movies have strengths I love and weaknesses I can't stand, so I'm comfortable putting them on the same level.

Revan
04-02-2007, 02:01 PM
I'll just jump in and say something I enjoyed.

I really liked how April wore several outfits during the movie and not just the same yellow jumpsuit/purple tank top and kaki pants.

She also switched up her hair style often. (I thought the pig tails in buns were hot);)

Jo Dawn
04-02-2007, 09:53 PM
Yeah, I liked the costume change... but! What bugged me was her hair, actually. My hair is longer than her was, and I can't do all that with my hair, heh. Wish I could, though. ;)

A minor detail, though, that is easily overlooked.




...See? I already looked over it.

Swany
04-03-2007, 10:52 AM
I have to admit. I hadnt paid much attention to the trailers and during the starting logos I was like "Hang on it isnt CGI turtles in the real world is it?" And breathed a sigh of relief when it was't.

But yeah, frst time I though it was good, great. Having seen it a few times more. Noticed all the subtle little character things, the underlying stuff and trying to figure things out for myself, I love it. I applaud the scripting and voice actors especially. The movie would have been awful without good script writing/reading. But really all the work pt in made this great.
Hoping if there is a sequel. Its as good as this one.

Ryzar
04-03-2007, 01:07 PM
I rated it an A, as there's always room for improvement. 8)

First post I saw when I came in here ... And oddly enough, exactly the same type of response I would say.

So, agreed there.

I thought the movie was great. Storyline was deep enough not to be too cheesy. Even though it's a stretch of reality but hey, nothing we can't overcome.

And I don't know if this was noted before... But did anyone notice the connections to the animated movie Hercules and this one? The part about waiting for the planets to line up in order to release the monsters trapped in the earth below... Very similar to how it happened in Hercules where Hades got the Titans released.

But that's alright. Still overall the movie was cool. Some funny moments, come cool actions moments and very nicely animated.

Grade A goodness.

Shark_Blade
04-04-2007, 03:22 PM
This movie kick ass! I enjoy it even more than 300:D

Swany
04-04-2007, 05:09 PM
I havent seen 300. I asked my friend how it was and her answer was "lots of nipples"

Apparently both manly and the good kind.
XD

AquaParade
04-04-2007, 05:38 PM
Kinda surprised I didnt see anyone metion this, but was I the only one a little dissapointed by the overall audio of the film? Not the voice actors or the music, just the basic effects n such? They just seemed bare-boned to me.

Fledermaus
04-04-2007, 08:11 PM
Kinda surprised I didnt see anyone metion this, but was I the only one a little dissapointed by the overall audio of the film? Not the voice actors or the music, just the basic effects n such? They just seemed bare-boned to me.

Are you talking about a random pirated recording or TMNT in theaters? I thought the audio in the theater was outstanding. The sounds were full of impact when necessary, but were overall pretty natural, I thought. And I prefer natural to ridiculous or over-the-top sound effects. ;)

Revan
04-04-2007, 08:14 PM
I concur fled, awesome sound affects. They stayed pretty close to reality with the them.

Krakko
04-04-2007, 10:17 PM
haven't seen it, but it looks really cheesey, the turtle's heads are squashed, and I refuse to see a movie produced by people who would allow the "your mom" joke to be included in the final cut. Also from the very first trailer (I think) where Mike falls into the dumpster, I could tell I wouldn't be enjoying it too much and it wouldn't be for me. Also the turtles movie like frogs and fly all over the place at impossible speeds. Just my two cents.. I guess everyone has different tastes

Shark_Blade
04-05-2007, 12:52 AM
^why is your status "warned"? where are all the stars?

Anarky
04-05-2007, 04:54 AM
I know it's a bother, but if people actually read the rules before posting, then they'd know that you get warned if you screw up here. You get two warnings, Warned X1 and Warned X1 and then you're out. In other words: Krakko screwed up at some point in the past and got warned for it.

Shark_Blade
04-05-2007, 05:45 AM
I see. Thanks for clearing that up Anarky.

Wildcat
04-05-2007, 10:19 PM
Just saw it....it was really good....like a hour and half episode of the 2k3 series.

Only complaint I have is,I wish they would have used the Party/Pizza van more....like in a battle shooting pizzas.

Something I really liked was at the end when Splinter was putting those helmets on the shelf for display....we see the original Shredder mask from the first 2 Live-action movies....that was cool! 8)

And suprising as it might sound I enjoyed the comedy parts:P

*SPOILER AHEAD*

I hope theres a sequal....since Kari says at the end we will meet again with faces from your past.

Ecto Jedi
04-05-2007, 10:28 PM
What's the likelihood of Shredder not returning in the sequel per se...But instead having Karai don the Shredder armour? How do you guys think that would be received by the general moviegoing public?

Fledermaus
04-05-2007, 10:31 PM
What's the likelihood of Shredder not returning in the sequel per se...But instead having Karai don the Shredder armour? How do you guys think that would be received by the general moviegoing public?

I'm sure there would be tons of bitching and moaning from some that Karai has just s**tted on the holy Shredder by donning the outfit. But if it's done right, there will be a slightly stronger voice of approval to balance the complainers.

I'm sorry. I'm not very positive today, am I? :D

Wildcat
04-05-2007, 10:37 PM
What's the likelihood of Shredder not returning in the sequel per se...But instead having Karai don the Shredder armour? How do you guys think that would be received by the general moviegoing public?

I think Karai taking over the Shredder's costume is cool...like avenging his death and carrying on his ledgend...she did it in the cartoon..whats wrong with the movie?

Ecto Jedi
04-05-2007, 10:39 PM
I think Karai taking over the Shredder's costume is cool...like avenging his death and carrying on his ledgend...she did it in the cartoon..whats wrong with the movie?

I can see it pleasing the fans and seriously messing with the casual moviegoers. Personally, I think I'd rather see Oroku Saki return.

Revan
04-05-2007, 10:41 PM
I fear the fair-weather fans would again hate on our turtles. However there are fans, many on the drome boards, who would love to see Karai, myself included. However they decide to do it, I pray the one in charge does it right.

Wildcat
04-05-2007, 10:51 PM
I can see it pleasing the fans and seriously messing with the casual moviegoers. Personally, I think I'd rather see Oroku Saki return.

Yeah I guess only us hardcore fans would like it....but thats really all that matters...theres thousands if not millions of true fans,so as long as we are happy then TMNT will always be a succsess.

Thats the problem with a series like TMNT...it has so much back story that if your just a casual fan/movie goer your not gona fully understand things.

Kinda like Leo being away in training,like he did in the toon series....you have to fully know there history and the way they work as a family to unserstand why he was away and why its big deal.

ZariusTwo
04-06-2007, 01:23 AM
I think Karai taking over the Shredder's costume is cool...like avenging his death and carrying on his ledgend...she did it in the cartoon..whats wrong with the movie?

The cartoon is it's own thing, the movie prefers to follow the comics a lot closer, and what occurs in them

GK Punk
04-06-2007, 01:36 AM
I See worms in The Shredder's future. Although it'd be awesome if Karai would be Shredder. I'd be happy either way.

Shark_Blade
04-06-2007, 01:47 AM
Karai as Shredder?:eek:


T.T My legendary villain replaced by a woman? No hard feelings.I like Karai too, but Karai is Karai and Shredder is Oroku Saki. Don't do this to me..

Spitfire
04-06-2007, 01:48 AM
Karai as Shredder?:eek:


T.T My legendary villain replaced by a woman? No hard feelings.I like Karai too, but Karai is Karai and Shredder is Oroku Saki. Don't do this to me..

You haven't watched the 4th season of the new toon at all have you?

GK Punk
04-06-2007, 01:48 AM
lol She's already been Shredder once...

LogicDonny
04-06-2007, 02:10 AM
and in the lost season she got her butt kicked by the original shredder

GK Punk
04-06-2007, 02:11 AM
Dammit. I shouldn't have hilighted that spoiler. :lol:

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-06-2007, 02:32 AM
Karai as Shredder?:eek:


T.T My legendary villain replaced by a woman? No hard feelings.I like Karai too, but Karai is Karai and Shredder is Oroku Saki. Don't do this to me..

Shredder is just the mantle, different individuals have taken it up in different incarnations.

Oroku Saki
Karai
Oroku Yoshi
Tengu Shredder
Raphael
Ch'rell

LogicDonny
04-06-2007, 11:34 AM
Shredder is just the mantle, different individuals have taken it up in different incarnations.

Oroku Saki
Karai
Oroku Yoshi
Tengu Shredder
Raphael
Ch'rell

Rapheal? one of the ninja turtles!? was this from the comic?

Kunoichi_Haruko
04-06-2007, 12:00 PM
Yup. Image comics. (Vol. 3). I read the summaries. Interesting detour for Raphie-boy.;)

CJStyles
04-06-2007, 08:48 PM
I would love to see someone new take over the Shredder mantel. Have everyone think its Saki but it turns out to be another member of the Oruku family

Fledermaus
04-06-2007, 10:47 PM
Yup. Image comics. (Vol. 3). I read the summaries. Interesting detour for Raphie-boy.;)

Nooooooo.... :( Please no image comics.... please.

Besides, he already wore a metal helmet in this movie. It would just get redundant to have him... well you know. All over again. :roll:

Spitfire
04-06-2007, 10:49 PM
Nooooooo.... :( Please no image comics.... please.

Why because they were good?

Fledermaus
04-06-2007, 11:37 PM
Why because they were good?

I'm not saying the art sucked or that it was poorly written -- I don't like the concept of cyborg Donny and Leo Skywalker... and apparently neither did Mirage. It was fine, even great for a side what-if kind of thing, but I just don't like permanently messing with the characters like that.

iris
04-07-2007, 12:26 AM
I'm not saying the art sucked or that it was poorly written -- I don't like the concept of cyborg Donny and Leo Skywalker... and apparently neither did Mirage. It was fine, even great for a side what-if kind of thing, but I just don't like permanently messing with the characters like that.Image Donatello made me cry.

I wish I were joking. :tsweatdr:

I like what I have seen of the Image stuff. But I think it's a bit too much for movie material.