PDA

View Full Version : Thoughts on the new movie!


Pages : 1 2 [3]

Spitfire
04-07-2007, 12:32 AM
I'm not saying the art sucked or that it was poorly written -- I don't like the concept of cyborg Donny and Leo Skywalker... and apparently neither did Mirage. It was fine, even great for a side what-if kind of thing, but I just don't like permanently messing with the characters like that.

Guess you hate Volume 4 then, Gamera Raph, Mini Don. To me that's way lamer then cyborg Don and Raph with a jacked up face.

But yeah I too am glad it was a side thing and just what if.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-07-2007, 12:36 AM
Yup. Image comics. (Vol. 3). I read the summaries. Interesting detour for Raphie-boy.;)

It would have been kinda cool if they incorporated that into the movie. The Leo/Raph fight would have been even more intense :D

Fledermaus
04-07-2007, 01:02 AM
Guess you hate Volume 4 then, Gamera Raph, Mini Don.

WITH A PASSION... :evil: Concepts, writing, AND artwork (for the most part) in Volume 4 disgust me (not counting Tales of the TMNT...)

Plus... We sort of had Raph take that detour already of donning the mantle of a figure whom Leo is not very fond of. (My syntax grows all the more interesting as the night progresses.) It would have been interesting to see him as Shredder, but.... I kind of agree that it was best not to have him (or even a likeness of Shredder) featured in this movie. Instead, we get another Image comics reference: Knight Watchman.

Shark_Blade
04-07-2007, 01:31 AM
I'm sure there would be tons of bitching and moaning from some that Karai has just s**tted on the holy Shredder by donning the outfit. But if it's done right, there will be a slightly stronger voice of approval to balance the complainers.

I'm sorry. I'm not very positive today, am I? :D

I will be most displeased if Karai being a Shredder wannabe.:cry:

I prefer Karai unknown to the turtles, has saved the Shredder and tries to revive him back to normal extracting the ooze chemical from his blood(that explains his absense in the 3rd and fourth movie+Karai said about familiar face from the past). Put in some weird scientist and we have Oroku Saki back on track.;)

DavieBoy
04-07-2007, 02:57 PM
I voted A.


I have seen the movie 5 times now, and have enjoyed it each time, but I didn't think it was spectacular. I did however think it was a very good film.

The relationship explored between Leonardo and Raphael was, as always, compelling and touching. There is a deep competitiveness there, and a feeling of resentment/jealousy and, whilst he will never admit it, perhaps inferiority on Raphael's part. Their competitive streaks sort of reminds me of my own relationship with my brother. The fight between the two was paramount and was a shock for Leonardo because it finally cast doubt upon his strongly reinforced belief that he is indeed the best ninja of the turtles. It also cememnted and proved to Raphael that he COULD be the leader, if as Splinter said, he tempered his qualities with compassion and humility, thus making him feel more adequate. Raphael is such a complex, troubled individual and reminds me somewhat of myself, and I empathise and admire him. His loving, loyal, protective nature which is hidden behind a facade of bravado. He is quickly becoming my favourite turtle, becasue when I was a kid I was intelligent and logical (and thus liked Donatello), but as I grew up I began to experience intense emotions and attachments towards people (a la Raph).

As that was potentially the main theme of the film, Michelangelo and Donatello didn't get much screen time. However. Donnie came across as the old head on young shoulders the real incarnation of him is, and he tried to steer Mikey on the right path.

The combat was reasonably engaging, the CGI freed the Turtles up to be outstandingly acrobatic, something live action would have made impossible. but the fight between Leo and Raph stands above all else.

No disrespect to Mako, but I am not sure his was the correct voice for Splinter. He just sounded TOO old and his voice was that of a very old man which contradicted the fighting he was able to perform at the movie's cilmax.

These are just my personal thoughts, and are in no way 100 per cent true. All in all though, it is a pretty good movie which I would award about 8/10. I am also very pleased with Karai's insinuation of a sequel involving the Shredder.


OH, I apologize for not being here often, I have had some personal prolems and thus had limited internet access.

MAESTAS
04-07-2007, 08:45 PM
I loved the movie! I can't wait to own it on dvd. The turtles looked sweet, and there was nothin bad about the movie. I don't have a favorite turtle, but I definitely have something in common with all 4 of the turtles.

METALHEAD
04-08-2007, 12:45 AM
[QUOTE=METALHEAD;485018]
ummmmm yeah I happen to be friends with some people who do that while I dont dig it I don't care what other people do as long as they arent having sex with real animals.
And the thing I said "to many freaks in the club" is a well known saying...like to many chefs in the kitchen i mean really you don't see any chefs coming in here and flipping out do you?
And I'll thank you to read the whole thread of before you jump down one persons throat.:evil:
p.s. please stop taking yourself so seriously I really find it funny from one person that dresses up and does caberet stage shows to another who dresses in animal costumes to really get pissed over something that insignificant it really makes you look insecure.

srry >.> ...i get easily angery.....the crap i put up in highschool...i easily over react...........

Leonardo's_Girl
04-08-2007, 11:10 AM
I actually though it was really fantastic to the point I had to add it to my favorite movies list. It contains a good plot, good CGI (compare to alot of the CGI movies we got in 2006, well except for Ice Age 2, Cars, Monster House, Happy Feet, and Over the Hedge, they were all good), kick-butt action, lessons of honor, as well as brotherly relationships (especially of that and the conflicts between Leonardo and Raphael). There wasn't much of Donatello and Michelangelo mentioned, but it still remained at its greatness. I wouldn't even be surprised if the Shredder returned in the sequel, after all, Karai did mentioned that she and the foot would return with someone or something from the past. Anyway, it's a enjoyable movie, and I only recommendation I would give to kids younger than five, is that its good depends on that kid is used to watching. If a kid's not used to violence and action-packed stuff like that, I wouldn't recommend it for the kid, it might terrify it.

aabxx
04-08-2007, 01:06 PM
I saw it for the first time just now because of certain complications.

AND OMFG IT was F****** INCREDIBLE.

Finally, FINALLY, after so many years, we have a brilliant TMNT-movie. And it looked SOOOOOO good... THANKYOU MR. MUNROE! THANKYOU!!! It was like past and present merged, and dream and reality became one. And I went with two kids who had never seen the turtles before and they shared my enthusiasm.

It looked oh so F****** good. And the soundtrack HIT YOU LIKE AN ORG***. And the turtles were like... I mean... they came to LIFE, plain and simple. And every moment was AWE-INSPIRING. I can't describe how F****** awesome it felt. I mean, it was so awesome I just want to scream F****** AWE****. I laughed, I cried, I cheered... and just now I screamed FU***** A***** and my sister just asked... what did you just say? And I screamed FU***** AWE**** again.

So you see... I really, really liked it. Shame on anyone who thinks it was anything short of F****** AW*****.

And warner bros, if you don't put out a sequel... I swear, I'm gonna **** **** *** ****.

LogicDonny
04-08-2007, 01:24 PM
whoa dude, slow down there, Cowboy.. too much excitment :lol: Glad you enjoyed the movie.

Kunoichi_Haruko
04-08-2007, 01:26 PM
I see merging in this thread's future....

And also, why'd you censor "awesome"? :ohwell:

Revan
04-08-2007, 01:27 PM
After watching it awhile, I didn't realize it was CG as much. When the shots are just of the turtles and splinter it looked almost live action to me.

It's those pesky people that made me realize, Oh yeah I forgot this is CG

Revan
04-08-2007, 01:28 PM
got it. you like

LogicDonny
04-08-2007, 01:29 PM
I see merging in this thread's future....

And also, why'd you censor "awesome"? :ohwell:

ya it is strange he would post this outside of my thread I mean that thread is so big now..

He's a new user. let him have his 30 seconds of fame :)

Like Spider Man says in Family guy when he saved Peter "You only get one!"

LogicDonny
04-08-2007, 01:31 PM
It is pretty awesome how far CG has come.

Speaking of CG, there was this channel that shows off cg shorts and one of them was this really old CG with a bird flying smiling at a fish in the water.. Oh if I could see that again..

JetsAndHeels
04-08-2007, 01:39 PM
Hey aabxx, did you enjoy the movie?

My thoughts would be, "**** yes I did!!"

Glad you had a great time. :)

aabxx
04-08-2007, 01:55 PM
I just wanted to stir up some enthusiasm... so I almost had to start a new thread ;)

But seriously, it was F***** A******. I didn't get to watch it before today because of certain complications, but some of you guys had me a bit worried with all your moaning... but like seriously... it was so F****** extraordinarily F***** A***** that I can't believe any single one of you would dare critisize it or have any complaints. It was a piece of art, a mona lisa for this millennium.

We should be kissing the ground upon which Mr. Munroe walks. Okay, maybe not literally but he made our dreams come true, fellows! My sister (the one with the kids) said she was skeptic about how good a movie about mutated ninja turtles could be, but she took that back, thought it was great and I even made her shout cowabunga together with me. But she thought I was overdoing it a bit when I kept shouting F****** A***** just a while ago.

I'm going to take a bath now. If I stumble, hit my head somewhere and fall into the water and die, I won't mind. Why? Because the movie was F****** A******.

TheAnimatedSeries
04-08-2007, 02:18 PM
I just wanted to stir up some enthusiasm... so I almost had to start a new thread ;)

But seriously, it was F***** A******. I didn't get to watch it before today because of certain complications, but some of you guys had me a bit worried with all your moaning... but like seriously... it was so F****** extraordinarily F***** A***** that I can't believe any single one of you would dare critisize it or have any complaints. It was a piece of art, a mona lisa for this millennium.

We should be kissing the ground upon which Mr. Munroe walks. Okay, maybe not literally but he made our dreams come true, fellows! My sister (the one with the kids) said she was skeptic about how good a movie about mutated ninja turtles could be, but she took that back, thought it was great and I even made her shout cowabunga together with me. But she thought I was overdoing it a bit when I kept shouting F****** A***** just a while ago.

I'm going to take a bath now. If I stumble, hit my head somewhere and fall into the water and die, I won't mind. Why? Because the movie was F****** A******.

Yeah it was like a B-. Thats pretty good.

Only one movie has ever been so awesome that it somehow managed to make the word awesome dirty and explicit, and that movie is of course the a****** Hulk Hogan vehicle No Holds Barred.

Mr. Snackpants
04-08-2007, 02:21 PM
I just wanted to stir up some enthusiasm... so I almost had to start a new thread ;)

But seriously, it was F***** A******. I didn't get to watch it before today because of certain complications, but some of you guys had me a bit worried with all your moaning... but like seriously... it was so F****** extraordinarily F***** A***** that I can't believe any single one of you would dare critisize it or have any complaints. It was a piece of art, a mona lisa for this millennium.

We should be kissing the ground upon which Mr. Munroe walks. Okay, maybe not literally but he made our dreams come true, fellows! My sister (the one with the kids) said she was skeptic about how good a movie about mutated ninja turtles could be, but she took that back, thought it was great and I even made her shout cowabunga together with me. But she thought I was overdoing it a bit when I kept shouting F****** A***** just a while ago.

I'm going to take a bath now. If I stumble, hit my head somewhere and fall into the water and die, I won't mind. Why? Because the movie was F****** A******.

It was really A******, huh?

Shark_Blade
04-09-2007, 04:42 AM
lol aabxx. I admire your enthusiasm:DXD

zkarlette
04-09-2007, 01:34 PM
I totally loved the New movie , I would do some minimal changes but it was so good it doesn't really matter, seen it three times, would see it again ,and I'm waiting desperately for the DVD to come out.

Warhorse
04-09-2007, 09:50 PM
Right after Raph had his fight with Leo, and came back in the lair, and went into a tantrum, turning over those weights. How heavy did you think that weight rack was?

Also, right after he did that, and Splinter hollard out to him, I, for the briefest second, thought Splinter yelled "WHAT THE HELL!" But then I realized he said Raphael.

I thought I was the only one to goof up, but I had some friends who thought Splinter had cursed for a milisecond as well.:ohwell: Well, he did have a heavy accent.

Kunoichi_Haruko
04-09-2007, 09:55 PM
Also, right after he did that, and Splinter hollard out to him, I, for the briefest second, thought Splinter yelled "WHAT THE HELL!"

:lol: You too? I thought the same thing.

KROW
04-09-2007, 09:58 PM
I thoroughly enjoyed the movie. The story was nice, the fight scenes were good, the voice-acting felt right and accurate, the effects were cool, and the animation was beautiful. Though, in my opinion, the humans looked a bit too gangly. I liked the comedy and the drama, as well.

Warhorse
04-09-2007, 10:19 PM
:lol: You too? I thought the same thing.

:lol: Now that is funny. What the hell and Raphael do sound alike though!:D

Spawn Guy
04-12-2007, 12:39 PM
So I did my bit today and saw. Nice to know I can say I saw a Ninja Turtle film in my life time. And for including Black Betty in the Nightwatcher vs Jersey Devil, I love Kevin Munroe as much as a heterosexual nerd can love another man without my heavily catholic parents stepping in.


(Bull, if your reading this you know it's not what you think)

Buslady
04-12-2007, 12:52 PM
Right after Raph had his fight with Leo, and came back in the lair, and went into a tantrum, turning over those weights. How heavy did you think that weight rack was?



a rack like that, not terribly impossible for one so well built(Raph that is) to knock over easy.

I loved how Splinter didn't have to SEE Raph to know it was him. 'course that ratty sense of smell may have tipped him off.

RaphistheBest
04-12-2007, 12:58 PM
I loved it. Plain and simple.

Warhorse
04-12-2007, 06:41 PM
a rack like that, not terribly impossible for one so well built(Raph that is) to knock over easy.

I loved how Splinter didn't have to SEE Raph to know it was him. 'course that ratty sense of smell may have tipped him off.

You know, I would really like to know how strong the Turtles and Splinter's senses are. You think Splinter could smell his sons from a distance?

Shark_Blade
04-12-2007, 11:07 PM
He knows anthing that is noisy and sounds of things broken, it's Raphael. ;)

Warhorse
04-14-2007, 02:06 AM
I was wondering.

I love the cgi in this movie. It is really top notch in my opinion. Blows anything Pixar has done right out of the water.

I also really like the new 2k3 toon. But, what would it look like if they were to use the episodes of 2k3 and just change the animation to cgi? How do you think that would come out?

Shark_Blade
04-14-2007, 03:34 AM
CGI is very expensive my good man!:eek:

Warhorse
04-14-2007, 03:54 AM
CGI is very expensive my good man!:eek:

Did you mean my god man, or did you mean my good man, because it could be a bitchin idea? (Just to let you know, I'm a girl!)


But just imagine it. The fight in Shredder Strikes back in cgi?

Oh well, like people were saying, maybe they'll make the City at War storyine into the next movie. One can dream, can;t they?

She-ruken
04-14-2007, 05:36 AM
My thoughts on TMNT:

First a bit of background. I, like every other 80s kid on the planet, was of course a Turtles fan as a kid. I stopped following them years ago, but the first trailer for TMNT brought back all that nostalgia. I thought the animation was surprisingly good, the trailer's punchline was funny, and I was all ready to see it.

Then the longer trailer hit. I have to say the 2nd trailer does not do the film justice. Obviously it was marketing more to kids than old fans, and to be honest it made the film look bad to me. There was no way this was gonna be a good movie, I thought. And I decided not to waste my money.

Well, fast forward to me and a friend out one night, and we make the impromptu decision to see the movie as a joke. We thought it was going to be another Eragon experience, a movie you know is bad but you watch it anyway to laugh and make MST3K type comments at.

But hell if the movie wasn't surprisingly good! Not only did it have all that nostalgia on its side, but I was getting wrapped up in it anyway. A lot of the humor worked for me, and a lot of the animation was better than it appeared on my small TV screen during commercials. The only bit of glaringly bad animation is during the epic prologue which was obviously just too big for their budget to handle properly. A small complaint. The turtles themselves look great.

Do I have other issues with the film? Yes, but the point is that it was fun. 90 minutes of pure escapism. So I am happy to say the movie has turned me into a Turtles fan again (I'm even listening to the soundtrack), and I hope there's a sequel because it can only improve upon the solid foundation TMNT made as a reinvigoration of the franchise.

So I rated it an A+ because it completely exceeded my expectations.

Swany
04-14-2007, 05:50 AM
WHat annoys me the most is that the movie doesent seem to be getting any good press where I love. In the news paper it said "The story is over complicated and lacks a single decent joke. But if youre under 10 it will probably be as cool as it comes"

Im kinda ragin' about that. Especially considering all the other movies got positive or just informative reveiews (not counting "premonition" whick is a "poor thriller" it seems)

It just felt as though they were saying that because it was originally a kids show.

Still, its not all bad. One of my friends who was in New York last week wants to go see TMNT so I'm gonna see it with her.

Shark_Blade
04-14-2007, 07:01 AM
Did you mean my god man, or did you mean my good man, because it could be a bitchin idea? (Just to let you know, I'm a girl!)


But just imagine it. The fight in Shredder Strikes back in cgi?

Oh well, like people were saying, maybe they'll make the City at War storyine into the next movie. One can dream, can;t they?yikes, sorry miss.:P I thought you're a male based on your username, clearly I'm wrong.

btw She-ruken, glad you have a good time. I enjoy the movie much more after watching it again and again.

@Swany: In Malaysia, it's got good reviews. One of my top teen entertainment magazine in the country speak highly of TMNT. I just bought the magazine today and might scan it later for you guys if I had the time today.
Anyway it mention how incredible the franchise is considering they have beaten '300' in just 4 days, collecting USD 26 million. TMTN was also feature as the front cover of the magazine(that's why I bought it lol).

Sezmo
04-14-2007, 08:52 AM
Saw the movie yesterday! It's such a fun film to watch! The animation was amazing! Better than the old movies. Especialy the fighting scenes. Splinter is hilarious, and the individuality of the turtles were well portrayed. Would definately watch it again!8)

Peace out dudes.

AquaParade
04-14-2007, 12:07 PM
since you loved it so much, you should get to your nearest theater and watch it again;) :lol:

Masked Ninja
04-14-2007, 12:13 PM
I love the cgi in this movie. It is really top notch in my opinion. Blows anything Pixar has done right out of the water.I'd have to disagree with you on that one. :trazz:

In all seriousness, though. I think the look is competitive. The textures and lighting were awesome and definitely different from anything Pixar does. (I will say that yeah, the textures were better, because Pixar tends to keep theirs simple. Though there is some freaking good stuff showing up in the Ratatouille trailers...) The effects animation was also competitive.

I'll even say that the "family tension" side of the story was deeper than most Pixar stuff, except for maybe The Incredibles. Though the monster story gets owned.

But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.

Though I do love to see an animated movie with a darker feel, both visually and story-wise. Certainly fresh and different... but I wouldn't say "better." But that's just me being an animation nerd. :tpizza:

Warhorse
04-14-2007, 08:14 PM
I'd have to disagree with you on that one. :trazz:

In all seriousness, though. I think the look is competitive. The textures and lighting were awesome and definitely different from anything Pixar does. (I will say that yeah, the textures were better, because Pixar tends to keep theirs simple. Though there is some freaking good stuff showing up in the Ratatouille trailers...) The effects animation was also competitive.

I'll even say that the "family tension" side of the story was deeper than most Pixar stuff, except for maybe The Incredibles. Though the monster story gets owned.

But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.

Though I do love to see an animated movie with a darker feel, both visually and story-wise. Certainly fresh and different... but I wouldn't say "better." But that's just me being an animation nerd. :tpizza:

We all have our differences and opinions. I jsut think the fact that detail to the breathing of the Turtles alone, was ages away from Pixar.

As for the lip sync, i found no problem with this movie. Did you see the same movie I did? Did you see the reaction and tension built during the Raph vs Leo part? When they were arguing, with Raph shouting out that he is calling his own shots, and Leo blasting on him for what was he thinking, endangering the lives of the family. What about Leo spitting like a real fighter would when getting the wind knocked out of him by Raph. I have seen nothing from Pixar that comes even close to this.

Fledermaus
04-14-2007, 08:30 PM
But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.

Budget and time. To me the animation in TMNT is so mixed.:ohwell: If you looked at several scenes in this movie, the animation (not just the texturing) looked like the 3/4 stage of animation in a Pixar movie. It looked mostly done, but not completely. As far as lip-sync goes, all they needed was a few more weeks to tweak it AGAIN. That's part of why Pixar movies are so... practically perfect. They go over things so many times until voila -- you have a great movie with NO rough spots.

TMNT had a lot of rough spots. It was still, overall, very enjoyable, however we are talking about the technical quality.

Now, where I think you and I may disagree is on what principles CG animation should be based. I'm definitely more of a follower of Chris Landreth (director of Ryan) when it comes to character animation in CG movies.

Call me nuts, but I think another reason why I liked quite a bit of the animation in TMNT was because it didn't look very disney/pixar at its roots, nor did it have that pixie-stix bounce of Dreamworks cartoony cartoons...

The standard wisdom in commercial and educational circles, these days, is that the strongest foundation for creating believable characters in CG is still the 12 principles of 2D classical animation. These groundbreaking fundamentals, which include such concepts as stretch and squash, anticipation and the use of arcs, were developed by Disney animators in the 1930s to give their drawn animated characters more life. But is this really the best and only approach for CG?

Landreth, who came into animation through a side door instead of through the usual animation schools and studio apprenticeships, certainly challenges this idea and has been adamant about exploring other paths � ones that don�t follow the old rules to the letter. Up for re-examination are the use of gesture and exaggeration and the whole pose-to-pose approach.

Take, for example, the idea of ambiguity. Landreth explains that 2D classical technique is based on clarity of gesture and emotion from one pose to the next. So if a character is supposed to be sad, the face and body posture should convey a united front of sadness. But though emotionally clear, the end result of this approach is stagy and the lack of ambiguity actually gets in the way of creating realistic, original CG performance.

Are the principles the only problem here or do technical limitations also get in the way of creating subtle performance with CG characters?

�Look at a film like Final Fantasy,� Landreth says, �The problem there is not a lack of controls, in, say, the face. I�ve seen the rigs for a lot of these characters and they are immensely complex. It�s a relatively straightforward thing to add tons of controls, which can make anything happen to the face. If anything, a 3D animator has way more controls than he needs, rather than not enough.�

Where the 2D mentality sets in, then, is in how the animator chooses to use those controls and how he/she approaches them technically. For example, a lot of the animators on Ryan liked using dope sheets because they make it very easy to break down the individual motions in a character. But that is part of the posy approach, which Landreth was trying to get away from.

Ultimately, Landreth succeeded in weaning his animators off the dope sheets. Instead he encouraged them to use the graph editor � a more left-brain way to look at the animation � and from that to gain a better understanding of waveform. �People don�t move in curves,� says Landreth, �Their nerves impulsively fire off a muscle contraction and that means that motions begin with an abrupt twitch and then trail off. The pattern looks like a shark fin instead of a smooth arc.� And then, because there is also muscle, there is momentum, follow through, mass etc. to be accounted for.

He also encouraged his animators into giving individual characteristics to different parts of the body. And into working with straight ahead animation, rather than laying out timed poses and then defining where the inbetweens are, which tends to create a very cartoony acting style � one gesture per accent of dialogue, no ambiguity allowed.

The results of these changes were spectacular, exceeding even Landreth�s own expectations. But the roots of this success go back a few years, to the late `90s when Landreth immersed himself in a study of the human body: how it was structured, how it moved, how it expressed emotion. The key to this was the detail that Landreth went into. Interestingly, this was exactly the kind of detail that classical animators learned to leave out in order to make actions and emotions read more clearly in 2D.

So Landreth studied finger movements and noticed the shark fin patterns they created. And he studied the performances of great film actors to understand the role that tiny facial muscles play in expressing the subtleties of emotion. I�ll never forget the time he came out to a class I was teaching at Sheridan, in the midst of this study and had us all staring intently at Dustin Hoffman�s chin, watching how an almost invisible muscle would begin to pull downward as Hoffman�s tension increased.

Not that TMNT approached even what Ryan had... but I like that it seemed to rely more on subtlety and ambiguity than supa-creative-drama-in-yo-face stuff that I remember from such performances as Marlin's in Finding Nemo...

Read the rest here (http://mag.awn.com/index.php?ltype=Columns&article_no=2329&page=2).

Can we have an thread just for discussing the character animation in TMNT?? I wonder how many people would be interested.:D I want to butt heads with the other animators at the Drome. :evilgrin: CG animation is a slightly different medium than traditional animation, in my opinion. "Sfumato" -- not only in the face but in overall bodily movements -- becomes much more important because you're animating at a full 24 fps -- not to mention the 3d quality. Pixar may know how to polish like there's no tomorrow, but the hallowed Way-of-Disney is not the be-all-end-all to CG animation. Especially CG animation.

But I have to go back to work now... :(

Gothamite
04-15-2007, 06:09 AM
I rated it B purely because of the confusing and annoying plot. Everything else rocked.

Barkworm
04-15-2007, 12:11 PM
The movie was kind of a mixed bag. All the scenes with just the Turtles (and Splinter, Casey and April) were great. Everything about the monster plot was pretty awful though. Really lame stuff and full of plot holes too.

MAESTAS
04-15-2007, 03:27 PM
I was going to watch it again yesterday but we were an hour early so I went to blockbuster and rented God of War 2. Anyway the movie was great the firtst time I saw it and can't wait until it comes out on dvd.

Masked Ninja
04-15-2007, 06:48 PM
We all have our differences and opinions. I jsut think the fact that detail to the breathing of the Turtles alone, was ages away from Pixar.

As for the lip sync, i found no problem with this movie. Did you see the same movie I did? Did you see the reaction and tension built during the Raph vs Leo part? When they were arguing, with Raph shouting out that he is calling his own shots, and Leo blasting on him for what was he thinking, endangering the lives of the family. What about Leo spitting like a real fighter would when getting the wind knocked out of him by Raph. I have seen nothing from Pixar that comes even close to this.Well, the Leo vs. Raph sequence was nearly perfect. And yes, I like that scene more than most of what Pixar has done, I will admit... they don't tend to go for the raw arguments (and when they do something close, you still never really get the sense that the two characters may never make up, much less one might come within a hair of killing the other). Plus most of the acting in that part was great. THAT part was top notch.

But I stand by my assertion that while it was acceptable most of the time, there were parts where I cringed at the awful lipsync. There are a few moments like that in the Leo/April talk inthe beginning. One of the worst cases is when Mikey say "Oho! Someone's cranky!" that makes me wonder if they changed the voice clip at the last minute and left the animation as it was.

I'm not bashing TMNT as a whole; it will go down in history as being severely underrated. It did quite a few things Pixar hasn't touched (I'll have to watch again for the breathing - of course Pixar characters will do it when called for, but having it go on all the time? Maybe a rewatch of both TMNT and my favorite Pixars will be in order. :)), but Pixar's still got it beat in some ways.

Ahh, and enter the Fled. :evilgrin: You know, I do agree that CG animation can't be treated quite the same as 2D, especially since some of the zanier stuff looks way better as a collection of lines than a solid virtual shape. (That was part of my beef with Madagascar, along with many other things... while I appreciated the use of intense squash and stretch, it was overdone and the 'tooniness got annoying after a while) And yeah, overacting is not necessarily the best way. Why I like how Pixar does their stuff are the little acting subtlties that a lot of other companies don't take to that level. There's some overacting, sure, but it reads a lot better in animation than live action.

The acting issues I have in TMNT are the occasional overdone bits. There's a bit between Raph and Don where Raph goes "Yeah... you got me all figured out!" and he moves way more than I would think Raph would, tilts his head, and even points for effect. Though there are some times where the animation acting is understated and it does read better.

Again, I'm not trying to say that Pixar is still leagues ahead. TMNT is dang close. I'm just noting that there was still room for improvement, which could probably have been aided by a bigger budget and more time to check over animation in some scenes. (the lipsync issues are the most annoying - acting problems are only here and there)

This topic makes me feel like a pessimist who hates the movie. :( I don't... in fact, I loved it a lot. There are plenty of subtle things that just make it work. But I'm also an animation major and one of the best ways I can learn is by picking apart what others have done.

Fledermaus
04-15-2007, 10:44 PM
The acting issues I have in TMNT are the occasional overdone bits. There's a bit between Raph and Don where Raph goes "Yeah... you got me all figured out!" and he moves way more than I would think Raph would, tilts his head, and even points for effect. Though there are some times where the animation acting is understated and it does read better.

Hm.... Hm.... I'll have to watch that particular Raph-Don scene again. (The head tilting I agree with, but I attribute that more to the fact that the animators are Chinese people trying to make their characters seem American. Overall... I really think it lacked time. See, if there had been a Pixar-level investment in polishing, someone could have pointed out some of the more awkward bits. I keep thinking again of the budget and the time and the experience of those in charge... eh. Remember, I ranted about how crappy the movie looked when I saw the first trailer. I ranted about how it looked like a video game (which it certainly does in some sequences). I believed that there was little to no hope for this movie and that I could only be utterly disappointed. If I remember correctly, you were a lot more hopeful despite the fact that TMNT had a supa low budget with a first-time film director whose only background has been in... just look up Kevin on IMDB ... compared to Pixar. (correct me if I'm wrong, I apologize).

You know what? I'm done comparing TMNT to Pixar. TMNT's always been this underground thing to begin with whereas Pixar is more about creating art and great cinema. Just compare TMNT to itself. We know sure as hell what could have been improved.

This topic makes me feel like a pessimist who hates the movie. :( I don't... in fact, I loved it a lot. There are plenty of subtle things that just make it work. But I'm also an animation major and one of the best ways I can learn is by picking apart what others have done.

:roll: :P You don't need a degree to be an animator or to study animation compulsively. Some people just take the side-entrance. ;)

But I don't think you look like a pessimist. Just look at all those people in the several "things I found annoying about the movie" thread. They're picking TMNT apart despite the fact (perhaps because of the fact) that they loved it.

My frustration as far as looks go had to do, I think, with the budget of this film; I got the impression that there wasn't enough experienced, professional direction (for movies, that is; I realize that a lot of these guys were professionals, but I remember reading that their backgrounds were mostly in TV and video game animation), not to mention any cultural barriers despite best attempts at communication. Those are much bigger roadblocks than I think most people realize.

So you see, that is why I get so bent out of shape about how much money there is for a sequel. I'll be genuinely pissed if they are unable to improve on the "cleanup" or spotting repetitiveness and awkward moments in the animation. It would be a major shame if money or the need to cater to a rating or time limit got in the way of things.

I think that, with the current leadership and the animation staff, it is unrealistic to expect that the animators will settle for anything better than generic acting. It only got awkward when the generic acting (like Raph's wild head tilting, the excessive pointing -- which I thin only worked really well in the rain scene -- or Mikey's exuberant expressions in front of the TV... :dead: ) lost sight of staying understated.

The same principle applies in real-life acting. Damn how do i say this?... I remember how my director would get on our case about being over the top when our main idea wasn't that special or creative. That's when generic acting crosses the line from looking natural (not very theatrical, but at least dignified) to looking forced (trying to hard to be bigger than it is).

BTW, another instance of repetitive animation...

A lot of people praised the "subtle" action of Don holding Mikey back so that Raph and Leo could have some down time at the battle. I thought it was appropriate. Maybe it was. However, when Splinter does the exact same thing to Raph only five minutes later, I started wondering. Did Raph have some special bond with Max? Did he have some particular tendency that needed to be addressed by this action?... My guess is probably no and that that was thrown that in for the hell of it. Though stuff like this did not outweigh the many strong scenes, thank God. But it was still noticeable *grimaces* ... The look and animation in TMNT felt like, at worst, an unfinished project, overall well done, but certainly not lacking in its sloppy moments.

Now over the hedge did not have standout sloppy moments. But ultimately, I care more about whether the CG movie has ANYthing that makes me go -- woooooww.... TMNT had this. Over the Hedge, for all its cleverness and professional finished quality, did not.

Sorry for the long Fledermaus post. :(

Ryzar
04-16-2007, 12:26 AM
The movie was kind of a mixed bag. Really lame stuff and full of plot holes too.

What kind of plot holes did you think there were?

The only one I remember is being confused as to why they needed those monsters so the portal would work.

Barkworm
04-16-2007, 01:13 AM
Actually there was only one huge plot hole: How did the monsters get to New York?

Masked Ninja
04-16-2007, 01:28 AM
You know what? I'm done comparing TMNT to Pixar. TMNT's always been this underground thing to begin with whereas Pixar is more about creating art and great cinema. Just compare TMNT to itself. We know sure as hell what could have been improved.Haha. I try not to all that much. And it does stand quite nicely on its own two legs.

And the lipsync is a big improvement from the live-action movies, to be sure. :P Love the suits and all - they were awesome. That was just a limitation they had.

I enjoy reading your long posts, no worries. And there's a lot in there I do agree with. I think it's a little interesting too how you went in thinking it'd be crap and came out loving it. I went in with certain expectations and came out thrilled, if a little disappointed. Must be the Leo in me... my eye tends to zoom in on the flaws even in films I enjoy.

The fact that I've only seen the movie once is probably another factor. Now that I've analyzed the heck out of things on the first shot, I need to go back, see it again, and look for the awesome details I missed or overlooked the first time.

Maybe after finals. :dead:

Fledermaus
04-16-2007, 01:34 AM
Actually there was only one huge plot hole: How did the monsters get to New York?

Some of them, like the huge bat monster, probably flew to New York. They got there one way or another. Perhaps by foot, by sea, by subway... over years some of them. I'm guessing that as they sensed the aligning of the stars (god I hate saying that :dead: ) they started making their way towards New York.

This is implied, by Winter's choice of words "I'm expecting some friends to arrive... Greet them warmly"

Jersey Devil, by his name, has obviously been in New York for many years.

Lots of implications, but very little of anything got spelled out for us audience members in bold red letters. It didn't bother me that they didn't spell everything out. They already did too much of that by spelling out the legend at the beginning. And then again in the middle of the movie...

It doesn't matter so much how the monsters got to New York. Do you really want to see giant gorilla man sneaking in all ninja like onto an ocean liner? Did you care that much about him? There are 11 other monsters. I personally didn't care about the monster plot enough period to get antsy about such details. I understood the whole thing well enough on the first viewing -- it wasn't complicated to me. It was just... a rather underdeveloped plot device.

Spitfire
04-16-2007, 02:00 AM
Actually there was only one huge plot hole: How did the monsters get to New York?

They supposedly explain that in Don's prequel comic. One thing about the movie that pisses me off is you enjoy it alot more after reading those comics.

Shark_Blade
04-19-2007, 07:13 AM
Actually how did the monster ended up in New York for thousands of years. Shouldn't that disrupt the city development?

I hope they would explain that maybe the monsters were statues all these years and when the planet started to align, they we're freed from their stone prisons.
And how the heck Winters freed his generals?

johnnyblaze
04-19-2007, 10:52 AM
Actually how did the monster ended up in New York for thousands of years. Shouldn't that disrupt the city development?

I hope they would explain that maybe the monsters were statues all these years and when the planet started to align, they we're freed from their stone prisons.
And how the heck Winters freed his generals?

the monsters are urban legends: bigfoot, jersey devil, a vampire ect. they were all over the world (all those strange creatures that people all over teh world keep claiming they see--were those creatures) and began migrating into the city as the movie begins because the star events are drawing them into NYC.

And Winters used his technology to free his generals. They show him placing the red glowing device into their chests and it reanimates them) in teh beggining of the film, after April retrieves the final statue.

Shark_Blade
04-19-2007, 11:06 AM
wow.:eek:I have no idea. You must have read the novel to know that far. It makes sense too.:)

johnnyblaze
04-19-2007, 11:15 AM
yeah one of the things I didn't like was that they had the answers to so many of the questions people had about the film in the book and in the prequel comics, but they didn't put it in the film. I imagine it was simply an editiing thing.

MoreCowbell5263
04-19-2007, 06:21 PM
My biggest tift with this movie, even though I liked it, was that Don and Mike were hardly in it. Mike had that whole skateboarding scene which was pretty cool, but Don didn't have too much action, or anything in the movie. If a sequel gets made, me, and a ton of people on imdb.net feel that Don and Mike deserve more screentime. The plot was ok, I would've preferred just a simple like Foot Soldiers, not really a supernatural thing like aliens and urban myths and stuff. I think the movie should've been a lot longer like, a half hour or maybe even an hour longer so that Don and Mike could have more screentime and equal character development. I know a lot of people like seeing the tension between Raph and Leo, but I feel like it's been done in the first two movies and it resolved in the first two movies. In both of them, Raph throws a hissyfit and leaves and fights solo for a bit and eventually joins back up with the team. But yeah, I liked this movie a lot, but I don't think it was as good as the first, but I don't expect any future sequels to match the first one any time soon.

Haddyskelly
04-24-2007, 05:58 PM
i think the new tmnt movie was great!!! but i think they should also make 1 a bit more mature maybe a lvl higher in the violence and maybe a lil bit in course language but not 2 stronge then that would really make me interested.

MoreCowbell5263
04-24-2007, 06:25 PM
Well, the first movie had the language because at the time, the only two incarnations of the Ninja Turtles was the old cartoon which had been around for like 2 years, and the comic books which had been around longer. The cartoon only being out for that much time as opposed to the comics, I think the filmmakers thought most people seeing the movie would comic book fans, so they thought the little bit of language wouldn't hurt. But now, there are so many incarnations of the Turtles, different versions, only the original comic books are intended for mature adults, and all the cartoons are still aimed more at little kids. I don't think the language will change, I think TMNT has now gotten to the point where it'll forever be something that kids will watch too, and it'll be a long time before ALL the fans are adults. The action could get raised a little, I'd like to see a more realistic plot, like just something with the Foot Clan rather than go all out sci-fi with aliens and stuff, unless they were aliens mentioned in the comics, but I don't like the idea of future TMNT movies being all original plots with new villains like the ones in this most recent movie. I did like this movie, but the story could've been better.

Haddyskelly
04-24-2007, 06:33 PM
yea the movie was great and all but i also agree they could of made the story better.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2007, 06:42 PM
Its hard to say what they could have done because from what we have all seen and heard they had some limits to think about.
I would have love to see a plot with some of long standing TMNT bad guys instead of a whole new plot but this was a re introduction and they had already done it in the other films.
We know they were aiming at kids while still trying to make us long time fans happy. I would have loved to sit in on some of the conceptual meetings.
They had to reopen a door and given the opportunity I think they did pretty well and maybe we will see some of the changes we are hoping for if we do get a sequel. They have re established the guys and maybe their will be some additional freedom next time around, like PG-13. We already heard Kevin Monroe wants to explore the realm of mature rated all CGI films, how cool would it be if Turtles was one of the first to do it in the theaters

Haddyskelly
04-24-2007, 07:05 PM
yea that would be awesome

Revan
04-24-2007, 07:12 PM
haddy, you would probably find the thoughts on the new movie thread interesting. also the violence in the pg thread might catch your fancy. You should do some thread searches to find topics that interest you and read what other fellow dromers had to see on the subject. :)

Jo Dawn
04-24-2007, 09:35 PM
I believe this belongs in the movie discussion thread...

C.R.Ebi
04-27-2007, 07:54 AM
I injoyed the moveie very much but i agree with the rest of you the movie could have added a little more to it to make it more interesting. But again there are allot of little kids that Like TMNT now and it iad to be safe for them to watch...Just wished it wasent :sighs: I could hve done with out the little kids talking though the move could have enjoyed it more :sighs:

Splinter's Iroonna
05-05-2007, 02:07 AM
Having finally downloaded the "soundtrack"-- and being in a position to listen to the cut called "I Love Being A Turtle", which basically is a montage of MANY bits throughout the movie (Splinter looking at the trophies, the Generals marching, the scene where the "monsters" cages are being affected by the vortex, and so on)-- I am MORE THAN EVER IN love with this move! I need to take the time and put my feelings into a meaningful and understandable post, rather than something that sound like a purely emotional lovefest. I am considerably older than the rest of you; I "remember" the comic when it was first around; I can only remember the original toon's song, NO episodes-- I willingly went to the first movie (several times, btw)-- and I have a HUGE love for the "current" series BC (Before Cody)-- but this movie has been a HUGE influence on me! I've not wanted to see something so many times since I was in my 20s.

I hate that it will all pass into the "remember when" category, especially as the "big" movies are now coming out (btw, I was NEVER a Spidey fan-- but you KNOW that that is all we're gonna hear until the Fantastic Four, and Harry Potter, and Transformers come out). But I have much happiness from this movie. I have rediscovered through the current series (well, NOT Fast Forward) my love of comics, of writing--

Of FUN!! :D

Warhorse
05-05-2007, 09:44 AM
Having finally downloaded the "soundtrack"-- and being in a position to listen to the cut called "I Love Being A Turtle", which basically is a montage of MANY bits throughout the movie (Splinter looking at the trophies, the Generals marching, the scene where the "monsters" cages are being affected by the vortex, and so on)-- I am MORE THAN EVER IN love with this move! I need to take the time and put my feelings into a meaningful and understandable post, rather than something that sound like a purely emotional lovefest. I am considerably older than the rest of you; I "remember" the comic when it was first around; I can only remember the original toon's song, NO episodes-- I willingly went to the first movie (several times, btw)-- and I have a HUGE love for the "current" series BC (Before Cody)-- but this movie has been a HUGE influence on me! I've not wanted to see something so many times since I was in my 20s.

I hate that it will all pass into the "remember when" category, especially as the "big" movies are now coming out (btw, I was NEVER a Spidey fan-- but you KNOW that that is all we're gonna hear until the Fantastic Four, and Harry Potter, and Transformers come out). But I have much happiness from this movie. I have rediscovered through the current series (well, NOT Fast Forward) my love of comics, of writing--

Of FUN!! :D

Well. For the most part. It seems our Turtles is getting more praise from it's fans than Spider-Man 3 is. So our boys did their part.

I'm also curious to the percentage Spiderman 3 will rake in as profit compared to the Turtles. I dont mean the exact numbers, but TMNT cost 35 million to make, and brought back 80+ million in BO.

Spiderman cost 250 million to make. It would have to make 500 million to break even, and this time, it has stiff competition from POTC 3, Harry Potter, Shrek 3, and Transformers. Not to mention there might be another sleeper hit like 300 on the horizon.

Andrew NDB
05-05-2007, 12:05 PM
I'm also curious to the percentage Spiderman 3 will rake in as profit compared to the Turtles. I dont mean the exact numbers, but TMNT cost 35 million to make, and brought back 80+ million in BO.

35 million dollar production budget. Factor everything that has gone into marketing, distribution, and the fact that neither WB or Imagi own the rights to TMNT (Laird is pocketing a good %)... 80 million is a far cry from a success.

Rooish
05-05-2007, 12:13 PM
The more I think about this movie, the more frustrated I am. And here is why: I did not feel I was watching a Ninja Turtles movie. I feel like anyone could have been thrown in to deal with that monster plot--after all, it took no special TMNT skills to fight the monsters; all they had to do was look at a star chart and then invade a courtyard. Anyone with similar fighting skills could have done that. We could have seen human ninjas do that. Also April and especially Casey overshadowed Splinter, Mike and Don, leaving a movie where the main focus of the Turtles--the mutant freaks trying to find their place in the world--is completely gone.

There were so many distractions that we barely saw the Turtles in their element. We still have yet to see Don and Mike do any substantial fighting, and what else is a Ninja Turtles movie for? Leo and Raph were portrayed very well, true. The VAs were great. The animation was great. But that doesn't make a good movie when the movie has no reason to exist.

When I come out of a movie, I often think, "What was the point?" And I did not see a point to this movie. It had no moral, except that family was important, and they showed this by having two brothers beat the crap out of each other. It had a dark "comic book" feel, but it was lacking in the Ninja Turtle feel. We start out with this laughable melodramatic introduction about three thousand years ago, which deals with the fact that there will be no Shredder very lamely, and then we end up in a jungle in "Central America" (could they not have picked a country in Central America? It's not hard. Here, I will. Belize). This does not have a TMNT feel. It has a disjointed ancient myth feel.

There were horrendous plot holes that have been mentioned. Also, if the movie was trying to please TMNT fans, it could have done fine without the monsters/generals/Winters. Or, if it must have had the monsters/generals/Winters, it could have done fine without Karai and the Foot, which had no point except to confuse the public and suggest that a (hopefully) better sequel was coming. If the movie was trying to please the public, it needed to give a reason to draw people in. Having 239124776424 plot lines does not do that. Having a script that oozes cliches and jokes that fall flat does not do that. Giving no indication that the Turtles are in some way special does not do that. Some parts of the script were good, but other parts were among the worst lines I have heard in movies. Especially the "When this is over, I'm calling the architect" line. Ugh, just ugh! Why the hell would anyone say that? Is that supposed to be clever? Oh, the building fell. Let's call the architect!

I do have some affection for the film and plan to buy the DVD. The (very few) interactions between the Turtles, and the fight scenes, are great. When I left the theatre after my first viewing, I was traumatisingly disappointed, considering it one of the worst movies I've seen in a long time despite the fact that I should have loved seeing characters I love so much. I sort of convinced myself it was better, but now I'm going back to my initial instincts. That movie could have been much, much better and I consider it an enormous loss.

jenna
05-05-2007, 12:40 PM
The more I think about this movie, the more frustrated I am. And here is why: I did not feel I was watching a Ninja Turtles movie. I feel like anyone could have been thrown in to deal with that monster plot--after all, it took no special TMNT skills to fight the monsters; all they had to do was look at a star chart and then invade a courtyard. Anyone with similar fighting skills could have done that. We could have seen human ninjas do that. Also April and especially Casey overshadowed Splinter, Mike and Don, leaving a movie where the main focus of the Turtles--the mutant freaks trying to find their place in the world--is completely gone.

There were so many distractions that we barely saw the Turtles in their element. We still have yet to see Don and Mike do any substantial fighting, and what else is a Ninja Turtles movie for? Leo and Raph were portrayed very well, true. The VAs were great. The animation was great. But that doesn't make a good movie when the movie has no reason to exist.

When I come out of a movie, I often think, "What was the point?" And I did not see a point to this movie. It had no moral, except that family was important, and they showed this by having two brothers beat the crap out of each other. It had a dark "comic book" feel, but it was lacking in the Ninja Turtle feel. We start out with this laughable melodramatic introduction about three thousand years ago, which deals with the fact that there will be no Shredder very lamely, and then we end up in a jungle in "Central America" (could they not have picked a country in Central America? It's not hard. Here, I will. Belize). This does not have a TMNT feel. It has a disjointed ancient myth feel.

There were horrendous plot holes that have been mentioned. Also, if the movie was trying to please TMNT fans, it could have done fine without the monsters/generals/Winters. Or, if it must have had the monsters/generals/Winters, it could have done fine without Karai and the Foot, which had no point except to confuse the public and suggest that a (hopefully) better sequel was coming. If the movie was trying to please the public, it needed to give a reason to draw people in. Having 239124776424 plot lines does not do that. Having a script that oozes cliches and jokes that fall flat does not do that. Giving no indication that the Turtles are in some way special does not do that. Some parts of the script were good, but other parts were among the worst lines I have heard in movies. Especially the "When this is over, I'm calling the architect" line. Ugh, just ugh! Why the hell would anyone say that? Is that supposed to be clever? Oh, the building fell. Let's call the architect!

I do have some affection for the film and plan to buy the DVD. The (very few) interactions between the Turtles, and the fight scenes, are great. When I left the theatre after my first viewing, I was traumatisingly disappointed, considering it one of the worst movies I've seen in a long time despite the fact that I should have loved seeing characters I love so much. I sort of convinced myself it was better, but now I'm going back to my initial instincts. That movie could have been much, much better and I consider it an enormous loss.

It's a shame they felt compelled to include the monster / generals / winters story. The film would have really benefitted from going deeper into the family plot and exercised the ninja element through interaction with the foot, or even a less ridiculous concept for a villain. I think the monster / winters story was a tool to make the film more accessible to the kids and to non-TMNT fans which i think is a real shame that Warner felt that that was the only way to secure a profit.

As for me, I love the film but spend my time pretending that the monster / winters plot line doesn't exist. I love it for the Raph / Leo plot line and for the VA work and animation. I would be overjoyed to be able to love it for everything. I have been telling my friends how good it is based on these merits (and in most cases I have "forgotten" to mention the more silly elements to the plot - which is a real shame).

I think you're right, Rooish (as much as I wish it weren't so) the film is a loss in a way. It was a wonderful opportunity to really expand on the TMNT's already solid base and allow it to grow.

Rooish
05-05-2007, 12:54 PM
The weird thing is, I don't think adding the monsters would really draw in children or the public ... they just make the film more complicated and cheesy. So I don't think it worked the way they had intended, although I agree, jenna, that that's why they put in the monsters.

Unless Kevin Munroe just really loves monsters.

Andrew NDB
05-05-2007, 12:55 PM
The answer is toys. Merch. Big picture.

jenna
05-05-2007, 01:07 PM
The weird thing is, I don't think adding the monsters would really draw in children or the public ... they just make the film more complicated and cheesy. So I don't think it worked the way they had intended, although I agree, jenna, that that's why they put in the monsters.

Unless Kevin Munroe just really loves monsters.

Yup, absolutely. It didn't work. Children aren't stupid like a lot of film makers seem to think they are. It's not really appropriate for us to find out the answers to apparent plot-holes (like why the monsters were all in NYC) through reading the book and comics - that's just bad narrative. The film should be able to stand on its own, and it really doesn't. We know the answers because we've done the reading, but with these glaringly obvious ommissions, to someone who hasn't read the backing literature, it just looks like sloppy film making.

It would be a different story, I think, if the film had been allowed to live a natural run-time, but the 87 minutes was quite simply too short. They would have used an extra 20-30mins to tie up plot holes and add some more depth to the monster narrative (thus making it less cheesey and more realistic (if such a term can be applied)) and to flesh out Mike and Don a bit, and for there to be some more emphasis on the ninja element. It just felt like the film came to an ubrupt end, and there were still loose ends to tie. The monster / winters narrative could have worked.

But I'm just rambling now...

Andrew NDB
05-05-2007, 04:01 PM
Here's my review of the movie I've posted elsewhere. Disclaimer : These thoughts are my own, and it's not my intent to attack Munroe or anyone involved with this movie. I also don't mean to attack any fans that genuinely enjoy the movie, or fans that are just happy to have a movie -- we're all TMNT fans and all have our own views and histories with the franchise.

---

Saw it with Lisardo back on opening day.

Overall, hey, good times. Definitely "lite" (diet?) TMNT... sadly it's no grittier than the original movie, and, in fact, quite a bit less gritty than that, in fact. Absolutely no trace of blood or bruises (OK, we see a couple bandages at one point), and Mikey doesn't even get to use his nunchuks... or, at least, we don't get to SEE him using them in ANY capacity for spineless reasons, which is beyond stupid. Why not make a Spider-Man movie where Spidey can't shoot webs? A Wolverine film where he has no claws, maybe? I got it, a Punisher movie with no guns!

What worked :

Anything and everything to do with family, and particularly the aspect that is hammered home of brotherhood and forgiveness, unity. This is the glue that binds things together, and when we see it, it does, and well. Nice visuals, the CGI is top notch and I 5hit you not -- you can see the very individual pigments of the TMNT's skin at a close glance, and it's quite incredible. Action is fast-paced, and choreographed damned well (though, with CGI, what is choreography, really?).

What didn't :

Pretty much everything else. If you know me well, you know what this film probably means to me. That said, this movie makes no bones that it is intended pretty much for pre-teens (and it is, after all, rated PG... not even a dignified PG-13, which would suggest a movie called "Teenage" Mutant Ninja Turtles is actually to be viewed by teenagers)... which, in itself, is more than a little disturbingly ironic.

The original TMNT is probably the film I've seen that tries to push the PG envelope to the maximum. I was really hoping to see this new CGI film try and dance that same line as close as it possibly could (nevermind the idiocy of a PG rating for a superhero film with teenaged ninjas anyway), unfortunately it seems to have gleefully embraced the PG rating even from its inception.

I remember TMNT in 1990... there wasn't a great deal of blood or what-have-you, but there was an everpresent realism to the action on the stage. We spend a bit of time and get to know the very human members of the Foot Clan, the kids that run with them. The Turtles get cut; they bleed. They cut the Shredder; he bleeds. They use their weapons, we see it. Hell, Raphael gets rather violently knocked into a rather bloody/bruised coma for a good part of the film. In this film, some 17 years after the original film (!!!) there is no trace of blood or bruises to speak of, and shame on the filmmakers for not having the balls to show Michelangelo (and yes, Laird does exert his influence, I'd assume, to "correct" the spelling of his name in a subtitle shown in the film upon his reintroduction). Mikey wields his nunchuks, yet we never see him use them... in any kind of TMNT rulebook, this is just criminal. In a feature film intended to launch a new film franchise, simply shameful.

I won't say the plot is hackneyed, but I'll just say it's not what it "should" be, which might not be fair... no review should be about what a film "could" be, but rather what it is. What it is at its core is the TMNT against some enchanted stone statues led by a dude that wants to do a Pokemon, "Gotta Catch'em All!" with a series of weird and wacky monsters to avert some sort of global dominion.

In a follow up, a serial, or a cartoon, I'd have no problem with any of this. And to the writers' credit (and I believe Munroe himself is more or less the sole writer, who's only really ever been involved with video games prior to this movie), this is pretty much an entirely original tale of the TMNT -- taken as a whole, we've never seen any story like this in TMNT in any incarnation, any universe.

As the fourth feature film (and it's obviously presented as, at the very least, a loose continuation of the first three films... note the "Death" of Shredder mentioned, the advanced relationship of Casey and April, the presence of the TGRI canister from TMNT II, the presence of the exact likeness of Shredder's mask from TMNT II, and the presence of the Sceptre from TMNT III at the end), or if you prefer, the first in what is obviously intended to be a theatrical rebirth of the franchise... it comes up short.

What we needed was a still relatively kid-accessible TMNT film, yet still grassroots... but at the same time still possessing some modicum of BALLS. No monsters and magic and the like... the TMNT need to be the weirdest aspect of the story -- their enemies grounded in our own reality. Why not just adapt the old "City at War" story arc from the Mirage comics to suit the aftermath of the first three films, with the fallout of the (final) death of Shredder in TMNT II? But I digress...

The greatest TMNT story arcs in the comics -- or, I'd even go so far as to say the larger TMNT universe at large, the Fred Wolf cartoon or 4Kids series, Archies -- are ones that don't feature oddities like monsters, magic, and the like (to be fair, there are some, even some classics). Nevertheless, as a starting point for a renewed movie franchise, this leaves something to be desired.

And April O'Neil... I have no problem with her characterization here, or her voiceover by Buffy. Perfectly sound voice casting, and I won't even speak ill of the cartoony proportions applied to not only her but pretty much all of the human characters in the film (the Turtles, however, are damned spot-on!). I will speak ill, however, of the gigantic, dramatic leap of faith that is asked of us to believe that April, over the course of just a casual interest in martial arts and swordplay, is able to completely dismantle and subdue Karai, the leader of the entire Foot Clan -- Shredder's superior, were he still alive, no less.

The end is laughable... no, literally. In what should have been a fairly poignant, sad moment in the end, instead is robbed of this and becomes a laugh-out-loud fest with Michelangelo turning things into a chuckle-fest for the benefit of the apparently coveted pre-teen audience.

In summation, I'll just say what I've said before. As the fans that have supported and followed the TMNT over the years (or hell, even ones that have become disillusioned with the TMNT, "outgrown" them, and are willing to give it another go) get older and older, the TMNT property at large continues to aim younger and younger, even younger than previous incarnations did.

I only speak for myself, but this is a disturbing, self-destructive cycle of events that I can only imagine will repeat itself yet again in another 10 years or so. TMNT 1 (rated PG) pushed it about as far as it could go -- we saw blood, mild language, and actual consequences to the fighting... seventeen years later, we get a movie that backpeddles and gives us NONE of the above (in lieu of the above, we get some Pokemon monster tom-foolery with nonsensical alignment-of-stars-opens-secret-Stargate -- nonsense I'd expect to see in a Playstation 1 game, not a TMNT feature film).

Sorry, folks. Didn't like it.

The most successful comic book films to date are ones that have stuck closest to the source material. Comics like Fantastic Four and Spider-Man are WAY kiddier than the Mirage TMNT, in which the Turtles would drink, swear, and chop off heads... yet while Fantastic Four and Spider-Man get relatively faithful adaptions of their comics with PG-13 ratings... TMNT gets kiddy nonsense and a PG rating? I'll never understand it.

No chance in hell of a sequel, theatrically. A movie needs to break at least 80 million domestically for a sequel to even be a consideration, as sequels are expected to earn only half of what an original earns by financiers. And even today, to make a film that earns 100 million isn't even considered a "hit" anymore.

May get Munroe's "TMNT 2: The Nonsense Return of Shredder"... but it'll be going straight to DVD folks, and that's if we're lucky. With Munroe's initial ideas for a sequel (straight from the horse's mouth, can point you to a recent interview) being the TMNT time-traveling to ancient Mayan times to fight off a space alien invasion... I'm not even sure I'd say we'd be lucky to see such a sequel.

Rooish
05-05-2007, 05:06 PM
It's not really appropriate for us to find out the answers to apparent plot-holes (like why the monsters were all in NYC) through reading the book and comics - that's just bad narrative. The film should be able to stand on its own, and it really doesn't. We know the answers because we've done the reading, but with these glaringly obvious ommissions, to someone who hasn't read the backing literature, it just looks like sloppy film making.

So true. I have a feeling that anyone who saw that movie and didn't know much about the Turtles would walk out thinking, "WTF just happened? What was the point of that weird little movie?"

I'm also disappointed about the general lightness of the movie compared to the first TMNT film, Andrew NDB. Yes, the Leo/Raph fight was intense, but that was the only real dark part. They definitely had way more guts in 1990, releasing that movie when 9/10ths of TMNT fans had never read the dark comics, but had watched the cartoon.

I think that Kevin Munroe seems like a very nice guy, and I don't mean to attack him personally. Unfortunately, since he wrote such a disappointing plot and script, I don't trust him for a sequel. I suppose it's impossible to please everybody when TMNT has such a diverse fanbase, but everybody could have been pleased better through a more carefully constructed movie. You can't just slap pretty art and some popular characters on something and then "fill in the gaps" with the storyline and script. Those are the two most important things!

Also I wish Casey Jones was not so emasculated in this movie and the 2k3 toon.

I loved the soundtrack, though. ;)

Mecha Cow
05-05-2007, 05:13 PM
Didn't realise this thread was still going.

Saw the movie a while back. First in an abandoned theatre in Dutch. Was so disgusted afterwards that I willed the English version to appear on my computer.

I liked it. It was a kid's movie for sure, and I think you'd definitely have to be at least something of a TMNT fan to enjoy it to its fullest. The whole monsters/stars alligning thing kind of turned me off, but again, a kid's movie. The plot didn't make much sense to begin with anyway, the character interactions were the main event here. Fortunately those were handled really well.

It could have been better, but for what it was I was satisfied. I'm looking forward to a sequel, hopefully with less monsters and whatnot. And I know the character is overplayed...but dare I hope for Shredder too?

*E* No chance in hell of a sequel, theatrically.
You sure? Wasn't one confirmed a while back?

Rooish
05-05-2007, 05:16 PM
You know, that movie made me wish for Shredder. And I was sick of Shredder before the new toon even started.

Andrew NDB
05-05-2007, 05:23 PM
You know, that movie made me wish for Shredder. And I was sick of Shredder before the new toon even started.

Not me. If the TMNT trilogy did anything to death, it was Shredder and camp. The new movie brings in the camp, and then goes on to make it clear Munroe wants to bring back Shredder in the next one.

The part in the movie where they really beat us over the head with it, where Karai is telling the Turtles, "You will see a familiar face from your past!" and the Turtles are like, "No... it can't be... him?" is just eye-rolling. It's literally like Munroe and the financiers are leaning into the theatre going, "You see, kids? If you see this movie enough, make us enough money to make another one, you'll see THE SHREDDER in the sequel! We promise! No, really!"

Ugh, keep him out of it. If TMNT absolutely needs Shredder in every outing to survive, it doesn't deserve to continue. And I'm the biggest Shredder/Oroku Saki fan you'll find (not sure about relegating him to Shredder Shark in the current volume of Tales, though).

Rooish
05-05-2007, 05:26 PM
Not me. If the TMNT trilogy did anything to death, it was Shredder and camp. The new movie brings in the camp, and then goes on to make it clear Munroe wants to bring back Shredder in the next one.

The part in the movie where they really beat us over the head with it, where Karai is telling the Turtles, "You will see a familiar face from your past!" and the Turtles are like, "No... it can't be... him?" is just eye-rolling. It's literally like Munroe and the financiers are leaning into the theatre going, "You see, kids? If you see this movie enough, make us enough money to make another one, you'll see THE SHREDDER in the sequel! We promise! No, really!"

Ugh, keep him out of it. If TMNT absolutely needs Shredder in every outing to survive, it doesn't deserve to continue. And I'm the biggest Shredder/Oroku Saki fan you'll find (not sure about relegating him to Shredder Shark in the current volume of Tales, though).

Hear, hear. I just meant that the bad guys in the new movie were so bad that I wished for Shredder ... and that is saying a lot, since he is so overdone.

Andrew NDB
05-05-2007, 05:26 PM
You sure? Wasn't one confirmed a while back?

Nope. Chances for one are even said to be "slim," and that's coming from Mirage as recently as this week.

Revan
05-05-2007, 05:38 PM
First of all, Andrew, let me just say, nice review.

In this film, some 17 years after the original film (!!!) there is no trace of blood or bruises to speak of, and shame on the filmmakers for not having the balls to show Michelangelo (and yes, Laird does exert his influence, I'd assume, to "correct" the spelling of his name in a subtitle shown in the film upon his reintroduction). Mikey wields his nunchuks, yet we never see him use them... in any kind of TMNT rulebook, this is just criminal. In a feature film intended to launch a new film franchise, simply shameful.

Mike's name spelling was switched from Michaelangelo to Michelangelo for 2k3. They decided since they were starting a new series to "get it right."

As for the chucks, I never understood the big deal. Yes they are dangerous, but they are weapons . Is that not the point of having weapons. And plus, they are no more dangerous than katana. Even if it is a PG movie, I have seen guns in PG movies before and you can't tell me nunchaku are more dangerous than guns.

What we needed was a still relatively kid-accessible TMNT film, yet still grassroots... but at the same time still possessing some modicum of BALLS. No monsters and magic and the like... the TMNT need to be the weirdest aspect of the story -- their enemies grounded in our own reality. Why not just adapt the old "City at War" story arc from the Mirage comics to suit the aftermath of the first three films, with the fallout of the (final) death of Shredder in TMNT II? But I digress...

I agree. CaW would have been much more, and I hate to use this word, realistic. Mutant talking turtles employing martial arts are by no means realistic but you get the picture.

Sorry, folks. Didn't like it.

The most successful comic book films to date are ones that have stuck closest to the source material. Comics like Fantastic Four and Spider-Man are WAY kiddier than the Mirage TMNT, in which the Turtles would drink, swear, and chop off heads... yet while Fantastic Four and Spider-Man get relatively faithful adaptions of their comics with PG-13 ratings... TMNT gets kiddy nonsense and a PG rating? I'll never understand it.

I'm not trying to change your mind or even influence it for that matter but here are my 2 cents.
Over the years, TMNT have slowly been grouped into the comedy genre rather than where it was initially intended to be... action/badassness.:)

Other comic book movie adaptations have got away with pg-13 rating because they were not changed to a comedic series. The 87 series, though one of my favorites of all time, kiddyfied the turtles and is, IMO, a big reason why people refer to the turtles as "cute."

Those other comic book movies you refered to that secured pg-13 ratings were always intended to be that dark. TMNT gained popularity with their 87 series, comedy angle.

No chance in hell of a sequel, theatrically. A movie needs to break at least 80 million domestically for a sequel to even be a consideration, as sequels are expected to earn only half of what an original earns by financiers. And even today, to make a film that earns 100 million isn't even considered a "hit" anymore.

I hope you are wrong on this one. I'll admit that I know little of sequel requirements but I have seen many "bad" movies yeild sequels so you never know. (Not saying TMNT was bad by any means. I thought the movie was good)

I thought they did a good job with TMNT. I would have rather watched a CaW adaptation but I have zero say in those matters. They had to appeal to the largest possible audience since they pushed for a pg rating and with that, comes the kiddyness. Kids like monsters and magic and of course mutant turtles. Sure most of the tmnt fan base is teenagers and above but the filmmakers had to make a choice (which was probably a tough thing to do)

All things considered, decent picture. And I respect your opinin too. I even agree with most of the things you said I just liked the movie and you didn't seem to. No big deal

Andrew NDB
05-05-2007, 05:53 PM
Mike's name spelling was switched from Michaelangelo to Michelangelo for 2k3. They decided since they were starting a new series to "get it right."

Actually, it was first switched in Volume 4 of the comics in 2001. The 4Kids series ran with it in 2003. Laird wanted to finally "set the record straight!"

I don't feel strongly about it one way or the other but "Michaelangelo" never bothered me. Laird wants to "Fix" it, that's fine, too.

Over the years, TMNT have slowly been grouped into the comedy genre rather than where it was initially intended to be... action/badassness.:)

True, which is why it's sad this opportunity was blown. The best thing that could happen to TMNT before this movie was made was a good, long lull period. Say, 10 years. No cartoons, no toys, no TMNT socks or backpacks, nothing but maybe the Mirage comics anywhere in the media. Let a good generation or two pass, and let folks and the media forget about that stuff. Then BOOM, come out of left field with a proper, edgy PG-13 comic book adaption.

Now, with this movie sort of bottoming out, even if in 10 years Laird and co. really get serious about making a grassroots, actual comic book adaption film, studios and financiers will laugh and go, "Again? You guys tried that in 2007 and barely broke even!"

Rooish
05-05-2007, 09:23 PM
You're right. Such a wasted opportunity. Now I fear that the Turtles will fade away for good, as the Mirage guys get old and disillusioned and the comics end and the cartoon stops.

Revan
05-05-2007, 09:30 PM
You're right. Such a wasted opportunity. Now I fear that the Turtles will fade away for good, as the Mirage guys get old and disillusioned and the comics end and the cartoon stops.

Jeez, no sugar coating at all eh. I really hope, against my better judgement, that you are wrong. :(

Long Live TMNT

CJStyles
05-06-2007, 12:00 AM
Hey if we have to deal with Toby Mcquire for three movies with him dressed in a blue and red suit with his horrible acting why cant we get another TMNT sequal?... and yeah I went there, I called out Spider man lol

Revan
05-06-2007, 01:10 AM
Hey if we have to deal with Toby Mcquire for three movies with him dressed in a blue and red suit with his horrible acting why cant we get another TMNT sequal?... and yeah I went there, I called out Spider man lol

Ha you are one brave soul. Spider-man has already made more money in one weekend than tmnt made total

Swany
05-06-2007, 08:40 AM
Yeah, but the spidey movies suck. (I say that having only seen the first one....)

Spawn Guy
05-06-2007, 09:28 AM
So the Spidey movie sucked.

And no it didn't.

bullet
05-06-2007, 01:51 PM
nope. i felt it suited him just right.

Revan
05-06-2007, 02:22 PM
I loved Mako's version. I thought he was perfect for the part.

I can't seem to duplicate his dialect. I've been reciting the movie to my roomie but whenever I get to Splinter's lines, I am so far off. :lol:

Mako was king

Andrew NDB
05-06-2007, 02:32 PM
It's not what we're used to, but a perfectl acceptable take on it.

Dunno about those shoulder pads, though...

Brandatello
05-06-2007, 03:47 PM
i didnt like it at first but the more i watch it the more i enjoy it...

Splinter's Iroonna
05-06-2007, 03:53 PM
Praised with faint damns...

:D

Splinter's Iroonna
05-06-2007, 03:59 PM
When Munroe announced in San Diego last year that Mako was their only name choice/consideration for Splinter, I was thrilled beyond belief! I think that he did a fine job. It was not only appropriate to have an actual Japanese-American actor playing a Japanese rat, but I've been a fan of his since childhood. And I TOTALLY ENJOYED his Aku in Samurai Jack (especially the feature about the making of same!).

I think he did a beautiful job. But I recognize that others may not agree. We tend to associate certain tones/voices with certain characters.

Spawn Guy
05-06-2007, 04:15 PM
He was okay. Sounded convincing.

I actually liked the guy who did his voice for the game, but that's the first version of Splinter that actually sounded old to me.

Tabularasa
05-06-2007, 05:14 PM
At first it was off but now I love it. So sad that he has passed away. I think he did the best voice for Splinter yet.

Avatar Yuffie
05-06-2007, 06:22 PM
He's the reason I wanted to watch TMNT. Before then, I really didn't care. Now I learned my lesson.

Mako voiced one of my favorite characters, Iroh, in Avatar the Last Airbender. He was awesome. And the fact he wore that kimono that reminded me of the Fire Nation had me all giddy in nerdness.

And I'm glad they chose a Japanese VA for a Japanese mutant rat. That's a good move, IMHO.

MoreCowbell5263
05-06-2007, 06:34 PM
I think it could've been better, I don't like how loud and deeper it was, I prefer the softer sounding, wiseman kinda voice. But he was alright, at least it wasn't like Justin Timberlake or some other young actor like the ones who played Casey and April, but I didn't mind Casey and April's voice. Morgan Freeman could've had a cool Splinter voice, haha, I could see it, but yeah, I'd prefer a softer tone like in the original cartoon. The more I think about it, Mako sounded like the original Splinter from the first two movies, just louder. I like the first movie voice of Splinter the best.

ToTheNines
05-06-2007, 07:48 PM
Dude, he sounded nothing like the old movie Splinter.

Anyways, none of my freinds liked his voice either. I wasn't too high on it at first but I got used to it because I watched the featurette and the IGN clips so many times. I give Mako's performance two thumbs up.

Rooish
05-06-2007, 10:02 PM
Jeez, no sugar coating at all eh. I really hope, against my better judgement, that you are wrong. :(

Long Live TMNT

That sad thing is, I think Kevin Munroe really thought he was putting together a movie that would please everyone. I just think the movie could have used the input of more than one person.

What Peter Laird needs to do is realise that he's out of ideas (I mean, he put his comic on hold due to writer's block--how do you get writer's block when you have 40 plot threads to focus on?), and he needs to find an heir. ;) Seriously. An heir with good ideas. And maybe a really ****ing good artist, who can put out the dark, angsty comics that we've missed, and possibly allowing them to reach a decent level of popularity. Then we can see if a sequel would be of any use.

CJStyles
05-06-2007, 10:03 PM
I personally just dont like Toby as Spidey, i understand they need a geek but c'mon.

Ra
05-06-2007, 10:24 PM
Well, it's been long over due, but I've finally seen the movie. And you know what?

It.

Totally.

ROCKED!!

I'm serious! It's been worth my ridiculously extended wait. If I could die today, I will die happy. I have seen something truly remarkable, and I know it. The fine details in the movie just made me grin, and I couldn't see any mistakes what-so-ever. I'm sure everyone who's worked on this movie went over it with a fine toothed comb to make sure it looked perfect for the fans. My only disappointment is that it felt like it needed to be a bit longer, but oh well. I got enough of a high from it to run out of the cinema screaming "I LOVE BEING A TURTLE FAN!!, so it has to be good at some point. I'll suggest the movie to any kids, turtle fans, or fans of CGI. I'm not to sure about people who aren't fans of the TMNT, but I'm sure they will enjoy the movie on some level.

My hats off to the people behind making this great movie. You too, Kevin ;) A+ from me! :D

Dragon Turtle
05-06-2007, 11:44 PM
My grade: B

I have to say I really enjoyed the movie, best comicbook movie of the
year so far(better then any comicbook movie released last year for that
matter).


The animation was very impressive, espicially given the time and financial
constraints, not to mention this was Imagi's first theatrical release.

The subplot with Leo and Raph was well done, their fight scene was
easily the best setpiece of the movie.

I personally have no problem with the monster plot in itself other then it felt
underdeveloped, but I was kinda expecting that after I heard the runtime
for this movie was only around eighty minutes.

Some of the problems I felt that the movie had was of course not
enough Donatello and Mikey, especially when you already have a
built in plot device in the monsters. While Leo and Raph are off pounding
each other into mush, Donny and Mikey could have been dealing the monsters,
giving them more face time and adding more depth to the main plot.

While I agree with the decision not to go with Shredder as the main
villain, I would have liked it if they had started the movie off with
a "final battle" between the turtles and Shredder(forgetting the lame
death from the second movie).

As for the Villains in this movie, Karai needed much more development
then what she got, perhaps more then other character outside of the
four turtles. Max Winters was nicely done, but since he was not really
a villain, more attention should have been given to the generals,at least
General Aguila.


And I too will have to join others in saying that I was not a big fan of
the human designs by Jeff Matsuda.





True, which is why it's sad this opportunity was thblown. The best thing that could happen to TMNT before this movie was made was a good, long lull period. Say, 10 years. No cartoons, no toys, no TMNT socks or backpacks, nothing but maybe the Mirage comics anywhere in the media. Let a good generation or two pass, and let folks and the media forget about that stuff. Then BOOM, come out of left field with a proper, edgy PG-13 comic book adaption.



If not for the cartoon and toys there would not have been a new TMNT
movie(at least not anytime soon), since one of the big reasons for green lighting the new movie was the success of the toyline for the 2003 cartoon.

And no matter how many generations pass, people and the media will
always associate the turtles with merchandising(unfairly) and the 80's cartoon, especially those who prefer the 80's cartoon over the mirage comic.



Now, with this movie sort of bottoming out, even if in 10 years Laird and co. really get serious about making a grassroots, actual comic book adaption film, studios and financiers will laugh and go, "Again? You guys tried that in 2007 and barely broke even!"


I definately can say that the movie performed better then what the WB
execs thought it would do, they basically gave the movie up for dead.
Also, if Warner Bros' keeps pumping out flops like the "The Reaping",
those TMNT numbers start looking better and better.:D

Warhorse
05-07-2007, 02:12 AM
Well, I loved the movie. It wasn't the best, but with what it had to work with, it was great.

Also, I think the movie was severely handicapped by WB insisting on a PG movie, instead of letting it become something more raw. And you cant blame this on Kevin Monroe. If I remember correctly, they wanted to do a rated R TMNT at one point. But no one would fund it.

It would be nice to see WB let a sequel come, but this time, just step out of the creation process and allow for a more edgier, adult friendly version.

Also, if WB does decide not to do a sequel, it does not mean that the door is closed indefinitely on the Turtles. Another production company can come and treat the Turtles right!

Andrew NDB
05-07-2007, 02:41 AM
If not for the cartoon and toys there would not have been a new TMNT
movie(at least not anytime soon),

Which is really my argument. I'd rather wait for a properly done one than one rushed out to sell toys and cater to pre-teens (even though it's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles).

Look at something like Hellboy. A niche, really almost underground comic with a cult following. Was never really all that popular, probably the comic never did gangbusters in sales, much like the Mirage TMNT comics. Yet, after 2000 and the success of X-Men, movie rights were being bought up like candy, and eventually we got a Hellboy that is nearly frame-for-frame a comic book adaption, toned down a bit to PG-13, but still very much faithful. There's already an animated follow-up that is equally faithful, and a live-action sequel on the way that promises to be also as faithful.

The new PG movie has squandered the opportunity for a cinematic comeback. No financier with half a brain for business is going to fund a sequel when WB passes on a sequel (and they will), whether it's 5 years or 10 years from now... they've tried it now. Didn't work. They won't even care about the "Why" of it -- it's bad business.

Why devote all the manpower and money toward a CGI project that is only going to deliver meager, barely breaking even returns? They'd much sooner put that same money toward some original movie (i.e., a film they themselves own the rights to so that it's 100% profit), probably some other Penguin movie or something.

Warhorse
05-07-2007, 07:02 AM
Which is really my argument. I'd rather wait for a properly done one than one rushed out to sell toys and cater to pre-teens (even though it's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles).

Look at something like Hellboy. A niche, really almost underground comic with a cult following. Was never really all that popular, probably the comic never did gangbusters in sales, much like the Mirage TMNT comics. Yet, after 2000 and the success of X-Men, movie rights were being bought up like candy, and eventually we got a Hellboy that is nearly frame-for-frame a comic book adaption, toned down a bit to PG-13, but still very much faithful. There's already an animated follow-up that is equally faithful, and a live-action sequel on the way that promises to be also as faithful.

The new PG movie has squandered the opportunity for a cinematic comeback. No financier with half a brain for business is going to fund a sequel when WB passes on a sequel (and they will), whether it's 5 years or 10 years from now... they've tried it now. Didn't work. They won't even care about the "Why" of it -- it's bad business.

Why devote all the manpower and money toward a CGI project that is only going to deliver meager, barely breaking even returns? They'd much sooner put that same money toward some original movie (i.e., a film they themselves own the rights to so that it's 100% profit), probably some other Penguin movie or something.

And you need to stop being so negative and bringing this forum down. You come across as very argumentive, and to the point of possibly getting some threads closed. Keep it up, and they jsut might do that, unless that's what you want.

And for the record, the 2k3 toon is one of the best animated events I have ever seen. I'm glad they didn't keep the Turtles dormant. They will always be here, always. Get used to it. You can b!tch and cry all you want, it's not going to erase the Turtles out of existence.

And you are really coming across as a TROLL! You dont contribute anything positive on this forum.

The Turtles will be back!:P

Dragon Turtle
05-07-2007, 09:19 AM
Which is really my argument. I'd rather wait for a properly done one than one rushed out to sell toys and cater to pre-teens (even though it's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles).

Look at something like Hellboy. A niche, really almost underground comic with a cult following. Was never really all that popular, probably the comic never did gangbusters in sales, much like the Mirage TMNT comics. Yet, after 2000 and the success of X-Men, movie rights were being bought up like candy, and eventually we got a Hellboy that is nearly frame-for-frame a comic book adaption, toned down a bit to PG-13, but still very much faithful. There's already an animated follow-up that is equally faithful, and a live-action sequel on the way that promises to be also as faithful.

Other then Helllboy, how many other smaller independent comics have been
made into major movies? There are no guarantee's (even if a studio picks up
the rights to movie) that movie will be made. The whole comicbook to
movie adaption process is an utter crap shoot.






The new PG movie has squandered the opportunity for a cinematic comeback. No financier with half a brain for business is going to fund a sequel when WB passes on a sequel (and they will), whether it's 5 years or 10 years from now... they've tried it now. Didn't work. They won't even care about the "Why" of it -- it's bad business.


Here's the thing about WB, they expected this movie to flop(making about
8-12 mil opening weeked), thus they did not bother to promote the movie.
Yet in a crowed market place, TMNT opened at #1, knocking off 300. Internally WB knows this. They also found out that there are people
over the age of twelve who were interested in TMNT, something
that didn't occur to them before. If anything TMNT strengthend the argument for a PG-13 movie. And most importantly, it still made a profit
(no matter how small).


As it stands right now TMNT is a bigger success then Hellboy, which was
produced at 66 mil, (not counting the marketing budget) it only made 59 mil
domestically and 99 mil worldwide. I would say that from a financial standpoint, Hellboy was a flop and Columbia agreed
and dropped the franchise, yet still another studio (Universal Pictures) picked it up, why? Because it still turned a profit.
And ask yourself this, who's happier with their movie, WB with TMNT? New Line with The Last Mimzy? Paramont with Shooter? or Dimension with Grindhouse?






Why devote all the manpower and money toward a CGI project that is only going to deliver meager, barely breaking even returns? They'd much sooner put that same money toward some original movie (i.e., a film they themselves own the rights to so that it's 100% profit), probably some other Penguin movie or something.

Desparation, a lack of ideas, Hollywood execs thinking they're smarter then
other Hollywood execs, there are many reason why studios return to movies
that barely break even.

Andrew NDB
05-07-2007, 12:05 PM
And for the record, the 2k3 toon is one of the best animated events I have ever seen.

Agreed, the 4Kids show is the best thing to happen to TMNT in a long time. It's amazing how much they were able to adapt from the Mirage issues with minimal concessions.

Andrew NDB
05-07-2007, 03:25 PM
Here's a question: What is the new movie called in Europe and other parts? Is it "TMHT" or "TMNT"?

Swany
05-07-2007, 04:11 PM
Im scotland its "TMNT"

That was something I wondered before It came out, if it would be TMNT of TMHT.

The cinema had it listed at TMNT:Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
so it was REALLY obvious.

But, im pretty sure its TMNT everywhere.

Zelda
05-11-2007, 08:14 AM
I think his acting was fine, but something in the timber of the voice sounded 'really' off to me....I found it really distracting as well. And agreed about the shoulder pads. The writing and inflection were great, the rest was kinda off....face looked weird.

I do appreciate that he actually had a REAL Japanese accent ;p

Mandi-chan
05-11-2007, 12:49 PM
I liked it, but not as much as Kevin's Splinter. I needed to get used to it, that's all.

I love Mako's acting, I just needed to get used to him as Splinter.

aabxx
05-11-2007, 10:38 PM
He did (RIP) a really different Splinter compared to what we are used to but I loved it. Brilliant performance.

Actually all the voices worked out surprisingly well. I was worried about Gellar in particular and even though the character of April was not my favourite portrayal Gellar pulled off the voice work surprisingly well. I didn't sit their thinking it was Buffy talking and that's a job well done!

Nostalgia82
05-12-2007, 10:36 AM
I think Splinters Best voise was the one they used in the origional TMNT cartoon. It sounded wise yet warm. This was just...not it:-?

jenna
05-13-2007, 11:43 AM
Im scotland its "TMNT"

That was something I wondered before It came out, if it would be TMNT of TMHT.

The cinema had it listed at TMNT:Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
so it was REALLY obvious.

But, im pretty sure its TMNT everywhere.

Yeah in England it's just TMNT. Definitely no more of the TMHT sh*t. That was gone by 2k3 series.

Scandia
05-14-2007, 08:53 AM
A+ Totally awesome! I would have gone to the theater to watch it a second time, but I'm too stingy to do so. When it comes out on DVD, I will definitely be checking it out from the library I work at as soon as possible.

dj mav
05-20-2007, 09:50 AM
great movie, just waiting for the dvd now. :)

RaphaelsOnlyGirl
05-20-2007, 11:33 AM
This is my favorite movie ever. Raphael/Nightwatcher was especially AMAZING. I didn't really like Splinter's voice though, it seemed a little to rough for him. I really really hope they make a sequal!!

magidkaiser
05-28-2007, 04:45 AM
nice movie !but not the best !!live action was better ..

Spike Spiegel
05-29-2007, 06:51 AM
I just saw this movie yesterday. I thought that it was pretty good, but there was room for improvement. My mom went with me and she slept through like 85 percent of the film. It felt more like an episode of the cartoon than a movie, but they had to do SOMETHING to revitalize the TMNT in cinema. Now what I want to see next is a return to the urban awesomeness of New York City that was so dominant in the original movies and the 1980s and 2k3 cartoons.

Hopefully, "City at War" will be the next plot line. If there is a sequel, that is.

Shellsweet
06-07-2007, 03:43 PM
I give it a A+ I enjoyed It Alot! I went on the first day with my family then went sometime in apirl with my Friend.

Shredder_Fan
06-09-2007, 08:14 PM
The New Movie Sucks 100%

Andrew NDB
06-09-2007, 08:23 PM
The New Movie Sucks 100%

Incorrect. Only about 85% of it sucks (strictly talking story here).

Spitfire
06-09-2007, 08:57 PM
The New Movie Sucks 100%

Why cause Shredder wasn't in it?

Shredder_Fan
06-10-2007, 07:23 AM
Why cause Shredder wasn't in it?

yes thats right


TMNT with no Shredder sucks 100%
The Shredder is the one and only enamy of the Turtles
Just like in the old and new cartoon

Scandia
06-10-2007, 07:26 AM
Come on. The new movie rocked. It has the TMNT. The story is good or at least decent. None of the characters were seriously distorted. I only have one bone to pick with it- and it has nothing to do with Shredder or any of the villains. It was good enough to make me want to watch it a second time. And I should have instead of watching the piece of junk that POTC3 is.

Shredder_Fan
06-10-2007, 07:37 AM
Still i think that Shredder is the one and only villain of the TMNT

in the movie part 2 that he is Super Shredder and at the end he's dead

not cool...he is Super at that point so he must return somehow.

as the Super Shredder or normal, and then with Krang and the Technodrome

I think no Shredder in movie....the movie sucks

Andrew NDB
06-10-2007, 08:32 AM
Still i think that Shredder is the one and only villain of the TMNT

in the movie part 2 that he is Super Shredder and at the end he's dead

not cool...he is Super at that point so he must return somehow.

as the Super Shredder or normal, and then with Krang and the Technodrome

I think no Shredder in movie....the movie sucks

That's horrible, horrible thinking.

Shredder_Fan
06-10-2007, 09:20 AM
That's horrible, horrible thinking.


NO !....it's not

A TMNT movie with no Shredder sucks ! really i mean it

Shredder is the real enamy of the turtles.

thats it.


Look at all the old cartoon shows
you see Shredder more than someone else.

The Terror of Death
06-10-2007, 10:07 AM
That's horrible, horrible thinking.

Quoted for truth. Yes, Shredder is the archnemisis in the old toon, new toon, and movies but he is not the "one and only villain of the TMNT". Larid even told me himself that he really did not want Shredder to be in the new film. He said he doesnt understand why some people think of Shredder as the turtles only main villian when he was barely in the original comics. The turtles have dozens of villians so its not like they are only worried about the Shredder. Some villians even pose a greater threat than him.

You have a right to think the movie sucked but please get some of your facts straight before you start saying stuff. The whole "he is Super at that point so he must return somehow.
as the Super Shredder or normal, and then with Krang and the Technodrome" does not make a lick of sense.

Shredder_Fan
06-10-2007, 01:07 PM
Quoted for truth. Yes, Shredder is the archnemisis in the old toon, new toon, and movies but he is not the "one and only villain of the TMNT". Larid even told me himself that he really did not want Shredder to be in the new film. He said he doesnt understand why some people think of Shredder as the turtles only main villian when he was barely in the original comics. The turtles have dozens of villians so its not like they are only worried about the Shredder. Some villians even pose a greater threat than him.

You have a right to think the movie sucked but please get some of your facts straight before you start saying stuff. The whole "he is Super at that point so he must return somehow.
as the Super Shredder or normal, and then with Krang and the Technodrome" does not make a lick of sense.



I MEAN IT WILL BE COOL THAT HE WILL RETURN IN THE NEXT MOVIE
WITH KRANG AND THE TECHNODROME....I THINK THERE ARE MORE FANS THAT LIKE IT....IF IT HAPPENS thats my point so it makes sense

TMNT
06-10-2007, 01:32 PM
Shredder_Fan, we all get what you're saying. We're just saying that looking at it from a narrow point of view such as that, is wrong. You should be more open minded about it. When the creator himself is sick of Shredder, one should realize this and move on so to speak. Give the film a chance based on its own merit and not based on your childhood days. Yes, it's fun to think how the movie could've been and what not, but the fact remains that movie was made how it was made. I'm not trying to call you out or anything. I'm just saying, give it a chance.

Spitfire
06-10-2007, 02:04 PM
Still i think that Shredder is the one and only villain of the TMNT

in the movie part 2 that he is Super Shredder and at the end he's dead

not cool...he is Super at that point so he must return somehow.

as the Super Shredder or normal, and then with Krang and the Technodrome

I think no Shredder in movie....the movie sucks

Your either trolling to be annoying or your one of the stupidest TMNT fans alive.

Read the f***ing comic book Shredder is in it for ONE issue and he gets killed. That's it, ONE issue. Then the Shredder made of worms is in a few more issues and that's it.

99% of the comics don't have Shredder in it. Your argument = complete failure.

Shredder_Fan
06-10-2007, 02:48 PM
Your either trolling to be annoying or your one of the stupidest TMNT fans alive.

Read the f***ing comic book Shredder is in it for ONE issue and he gets killed. That's it, ONE issue. Then the Shredder made of worms is in a few more issues and that's it.

99% of the comics don't have Shredder in it. Your argument = complete failure.




The TMNT comic books is never coming out in Holland

Mecha Cow
06-10-2007, 03:05 PM
Actually, you can get them in specialised comic shops.

cowabunga14
06-10-2007, 05:01 PM
Or they can be ordered online from comic shops that ship internationally.

Andrew NDB
06-11-2007, 12:50 AM
Your either trolling to be annoying or your one of the stupidest TMNT fans alive.

Read the f***ing comic book Shredder is in it for ONE issue and he gets killed. That's it, ONE issue. Then the Shredder made of worms is in a few more issues and that's it.

99% of the comics don't have Shredder in it. Your argument = complete failure.

I don't want to be mean, but that pretty much sums it up.

Spitfire
06-11-2007, 01:07 AM
The TMNT comic books is never coming out in Holland

Maybe not but I bought almost my entire collection off Ebay. Plus the first like 5 or more issues are up on the site for free read. On top of summaries of all the issues

The internet is your friend
http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/1610/ninjacat28ov.jpg

General Traag
06-16-2007, 10:40 AM
I have to admit i would personally kidnap a producer to get a sequel with atleast krang and the technodrome in it.

C'mon, a cgi-animated, corny, talking brain in a one-eyed giant tank/spaceship? How could that one not become a cult-classic?

As for the movie, i liked it.
I'm not that familiar with the 2k3 cartoons or the comic books so i had no clue who karai is and where she suddenly came from, but i didn't have any problem with that.

NightwatchersOnlygirl
06-16-2007, 11:22 AM
The movie was good,

1. The Nightwatcher/Raphael
2.Mikey's burp
3, Raphael eating breakfast


Best of all was

The Nightwatcher

*Oh Baby*

*Passes Out*

jenna
06-17-2007, 01:29 PM
The movie was good,

1. The Nightwatcher/Raphael
2.Mikey's burp
3, Raphael eating breakfast


Best of all was

The Nightwatcher

*Oh Baby*

*Passes Out*

Hey! Nice to hear more that 3 words out of you. Keep it up! :)

Shellsweet
07-15-2007, 03:34 PM
LOL, well, I have hardly any complaints, 20 more mintutes longer it would be perfect! and more Donny and Mike >.>

And if you guys really want to read more details into this, get the novel, its a easy read but it shows some parts they should've put on the movie.

I think Max winters and the generals were a good choice, if they would have used shredder again (knowing that Mr.laird didnt want people thinking he was the Dark vader in this and that hes 'the only villain' which is Highly untrue)

especailly reading the tales of the TMNT vol. 2...I think they could beat any other comic with the most villians! XD

I really cant wait to get my hands on the DVD, and watch it till my mind explodes. x3

mattmanw54301
07-20-2007, 01:38 PM
My only objections were what has already been said here. Not enough run time, not enough Donnie and Mikey. But all in all, it was fantastic IMO. Made me remember how much fun I had going to see TMNT 2: Secret of the Ooze in the theater. I had my Turtle figures with me, and acted out the scenes with them!!!!! Good times.

Euan Buchan
07-20-2007, 07:02 PM
I've not seen it yet but when I saw posters on the bus I was excited seeing what it felt like seeing old friends again remebering their names etc. When I looked up the website I noticed it was 3D and thaught it ruined the magic for me it be better if they had the similar puppetters then the other films. but once the DVD is out I'll give it a try.

gobo
07-20-2007, 08:08 PM
Umm... Why do you think they would need puppeteers? O_o

mattmanw54301
07-20-2007, 08:50 PM
I think he means if it was live action like the previous ones. Which is one of the main objections I have heard. But I urge everyone to give it a shot. Go in with an open mind!!! U may enjoy it!!!

jenna
07-21-2007, 01:51 PM
Honestly though, in terms of the depiction of the turtles, I think the CGI turtles are just so much better than the puppets. The puppets were awesome but limited to an extent. There are facial expressions in this film that couldn't be portrayed in the live action films and the characterisation is all the better for it.

Yeah, I agree: an open mind is what is required. :)

J Legault
07-30-2007, 02:28 AM
Despite it being another different flowing plot of the turtles. I find it to be a likable as the original trilogy.

Every charater we know has a different look. But same personallity.

i also liked how they got a cast of familar cartoon and video game voice actors like Jim Cummings and Billy West.

As a TMNT I liked every bit of it. Since there's never a dull moment in it.

Only thing it doesn't waist time with background story or flashbacks. Those who aren't a knowledgable with TMNT would be slightly clueless.

Coola Yagami
08-05-2007, 12:46 AM
After finally seeing the movie, I had a few questions in terms of comparing the trailer to the actual movie. I'll watch it again tomorrow to be sure.

First, when Mike said the whole 'looked like your mom, dude' his laughing sounded different than on the trailer, and the shot seemed to only show Don, and not Mikey busting up in the background like the trailer did. Was this a fullscreen VS widescreen issue?

I never heard Don say the 'I have a bad feeling...' thing from the trailers.

I don't remember seeing that drawing of the 4 turtles I've being seeing on several people's sigs here. I did see the bad-ass Shredder pic though.

I never saw the part when Karai told Leo 'I know the role you played in the past' unless she blurted it out real fast during their fight, since it was really quick.

So, any help here, guys?

raphael_is_cool
08-05-2007, 05:24 AM
I've noticed a lot of films will include things in the trailer that don't feature in the final film, although these are usually comedies and those bits resurface in deleted scenes on the DVDS. I remember the Monsters Inc trailer had a bit that was never included in the final cut, maybe because it just didn't work and then other times stuff may be altered to make a harder-hitting preview.

It's been a while but I don't remember a lot of those instances either.

johnnyblaze
08-05-2007, 11:23 AM
After finally seeing the movie, I had a few questions in terms of comparing the trailer to the actual movie. I'll watch it again tomorrow to be sure.

First, when Mike said the whole 'looked like your mom, dude' his laughing sounded different than on the trailer, and the shot seemed to only show Don, and not Mikey busting up in the background like the trailer did. Was this a fullscreen VS widescreen issue?

I never heard Don say the 'I have a bad feeling...' thing from the trailers.

I don't remember seeing that drawing of the 4 turtles I've being seeing on several people's sigs here. I did see the bad-ass Shredder pic though.

I never saw the part when Karai told Leo 'I know the role you played in the past' unless she blurted it out real fast during their fight, since it was really quick.

So, any help here, guys?
Its just alternate dialogue kind of like the Mike and Don
"Got any moves left?"
"Just this one, AHHHHH!"
exchange was changed in the film (I actually prefer the above one personally)

The Karai line above I never heard of but its a safe bet that it was exchanged with Karai's "You!" and then her trying to off Leo

Warhorse
08-11-2007, 05:30 PM
I'm watching the movie now for like the third time since I got it. The part where the Turtles start to go towards the construction site that has the monste and the Foot, and Raph is climbing the beam, and he says something like it smells like a monkey cage. His voice had a hint of the Rob Paulsen voice from the old toon for a second. ANyone else think that?

Rooish
08-11-2007, 09:19 PM
Yeah, I noticed that too. It sounded great.

I love his voice in that movie because it wasn't too deep like John Campbell's or too high like Rob Paulsen's.

Ecto Jedi
08-11-2007, 09:28 PM
One question that's been nagging me: where is Rooish's sig picture from? Was that in the trailer? Or perhaps a shot from an extended beginning scene?

Warhorse
08-11-2007, 09:42 PM
I know, Rooish has a neat pic. I hate saying it, but Mikey looks kind of stoned, but in a funny sort of way!

Ecto Jedi
08-11-2007, 09:55 PM
I know, Rooish has a neat pic. I hate saying it, but Mikey looks kind of stoned, but in a funny sort of way!

Sig, not avatar. But yeah, that's a funny Mikey pic. What's he been smoking?

Rooish
08-11-2007, 11:44 PM
Heh, wow, thanks guys! It's from the International Featurette that was put out to advertise the movie. Here it is at Apple Trailers (http://www.apple.com/trailers/wb/teenagemutantninjaturtles/internationalfeaturette/).

Raven
08-16-2007, 01:18 AM
The movie was good,

1. The Nightwatcher/Raphael
2.Mikey's burp
3, Raphael eating breakfast


Best of all was

The Nightwatcher

*Oh Baby*

*Passes Out*


Yeah..........



Um keeping with the subject after watching the DVD I have to say I still had the same feeling as watching it in theaters. I love the whole trying to keep a family thats falling apart together. Its a common theme in most such as X-Men but I really like how this was, I see more why mikey and don scenes were cut but it still would have been really neet to have those in there.

Mako is still the best Splinters hands down, damn he did a fantastic job.

Serp
08-19-2007, 03:27 PM
Saw it last night on the campus.

It was enjoyable at times, but I thought that the film had some major flaws.

I felt a lot needed to be explained, like Karai and the revival of the foot clan, the monsters in the street, and April's new found fighting skill's as well as the elevation of her relationship with Casey.

Mike and Don didn't get enough screen time and developement. I mean we know Mike is a jokester but he can have so much more depth to him. I wish the newer movies and cartoon would go farther in his perona. Why not flesh out Mike's passion for writting, or express the fact that he didn't have to fight, he wouldn't. As with Don, I can't remember him doing anything in this move. I think of this movie, than I think of Donatello and I see blank. Maybe I just have a terrible memory, but I can't even recall how Donatello's voice even sounds.

While I enjoyed seeing the Foot. I wish they could have had a slightly bigger role. They were the Pawns of Max, but they seemed so useless. Maybe they really didn't need a major role, but could have came to scene to get revenge on the Turtles for causeing their down fall. Karai could have introduced herself as the new leader of the Foot Clan and how she was out to avenge Shredder or something and the Foot clan could be a road block for the turtles furthur complicating their problems. I also think the other Stone warrior characters could have had a bit more developement as well.

While the fights were good, I felt that they were too short. They seemed to be leading up into something great but never quite reached it. When it showed the Turtles Splinter, April and Casey fighting the hord of Foot Soldiers. I was getting so stoked. the the fight was just done and they left and my excitement was left in the cold.

There were things that I like about this movie though. The whole mood worked so well, I felt that this movie was light hearted enough dark hearted enough. I like Max's whole back story. And I love the message that makes brought about "Immortality is a curse". I like the character designs. When I first saw the designs of the turtles, I was filled with distaste. I thought that they looked so childish, but when I saw this movie, I realized that they looked fine. I like the human designs as well. I like the voice acting and the fight scenes.

Overall I would grade this Movie as a C.

Magdolin
08-21-2007, 12:38 PM
I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVVVVVVVEEEEEEEED IT! That is all.

Dragon Turtle
08-21-2007, 11:14 PM
I felt a lot needed to be explained, like Karai and the revival of the foot clan, the monsters in the street, and April's new found fighting skill's as well as the elevation of her relationship with Casey.



A lot of Casey and April's relationship was cut from the final movie and there was a bit about April talking about training under Splinter from the novel, which might have made it into the deleted scene section, but I couldn't tell given Monroe's commentary over the scene.



Mike and Don didn't get enough screen time and developement. I mean we know Mike is a jokester but he can have so much more depth to him. I wish the newer movies and cartoon would go farther in his perona. Why not flesh out Mike's passion for writting, or express the fact that he didn't have to fight, he wouldn't. As with Don, I can't remember him doing anything in this move. I think of this movie, than I think of Donatello and I see blank. Maybe I just have a terrible memory, but I can't even recall how Donatello's voice even sounds.




Mike and Don were both victims of editing, even the few deleted scenes with them would have been much appreciated.



While I enjoyed seeing the Foot. I wish they could have had a slightly bigger role. They were the Pawns of Max, but they seemed so useless. Maybe they really didn't need a major role, but could have came to scene to get revenge on the Turtles for causeing their down fall. Karai could have introduced herself as the new leader of the Foot Clan and how she was out to avenge Shredder or something and the Foot clan could be a road block for the turtles furthur complicating their problems. I also think the other Stone warrior characters could have had a bit more developement as well.





I thought the movie would have been a great way to develop Karai(especially with the Shredder out of the picture), the Foot's background may or may not have been lost with the big TMNT/Foot fight that was cut.


While the fights were good, I felt that they were too short. They seemed to be leading up into something great but never quite reached it. When it showed the Turtles Splinter, April and Casey fighting the hord of Foot Soldiers. I was getting so stoked. the the fight was just done and they left and my excitement was left in the cold.



I had always assumed the courtyard battle was the big action setpiece of the movie and was dissappointed, but after finding out about the previous
scraped big fight scene, the way the courtyard battle plays out makes sense, given that saving Leo and stopping Winters was a bigger priority. I do wish
the fight with the stone generals were longer and even the Leo/Raph fight could have used a few extra minutes.

Nice review.:)

Revan
08-21-2007, 11:28 PM
I thought the movie would have been a great way to develop Karai(especially with the Shredder out of the picture), the Foot's background may or may not have been lost with the big TMNT/Foot fight that was cut.)
I'm just glad I knew who Karai was before watching the movie and I felt for those moviegoers who had no clud who the hell this new chick was. Think about it. If we didn't know Karai before this movie, I would have been so confused about how she gained control of the organization.

Mike and Don didn't get enough screen time and developement. I mean we know Mike is a jokester but he can have so much more depth to him. I wish the newer movies and cartoon would go farther in his perona. Why not flesh out Mike's passion for writting, or express the fact that he didn't have to fight, he wouldn't. As with Don, I can't remember him doing anything in this move. I think of this movie, than I think of Donatello and I see blank. Maybe I just have a terrible memory, but I can't even recall how Donatello's voice even sounds.
No one can argue that Mike and Don took a backseat to Leo and Raph and I'm not going to suggest that Mike and Don got a fair shot, but Mike and Don did get to fight onscreen as well. The Leo/Raph clash was great and needed to be in the movie IMO. Their struggle both internal and physical was done beautifully.

No doubt they didn't get as much screen time, but the movie didn't require their presence in every scene to be successful. If one was not a fan of any particular turtle, he/she may have been more satisfied with the film that say a Mike or Don fan.

ToTheNines
08-22-2007, 10:28 AM
Personally I think Mike got enough screen time, but his character was again abused as comic relief. So I'm not totally happy with his usage, but for different reasons.

Hellboy
08-22-2007, 02:16 PM
Personally I think Mike got enough screen time, but his character was again abused as comic relief. So I'm not totally happy with his usage, but for different reasons.

So true. Mikey used to be my favorite turtle but I almost hated him in this movie. He used to be a normal dude that didn't take things too seriously. He was just a happy-go-lucky kinda guy but this time they just made him dumb.
Things like that loud annoying burp and his dumb comments on everything really ruined the character for me in this movie.

Warhorse
08-22-2007, 07:26 PM
So true. Mikey used to be my favorite turtle but I almost hated him in this movie. He used to be a normal dude that didn't take things too seriously. He was just a happy-go-lucky kinda guy but this time they just made him dumb.
Things like that loud annoying burp and his dumb comments on everything really ruined the character for me in this movie.

Yeah, I miss the wisekicking, ass kicking Turtle that was not ashamed, or restricted by British censhorship, in showing off his nunchuck skills. And quite frankly, while the skateboarding scene was cute, it still didn't compare to his nunchuck duel in the first flick.

Andrew NDB
08-22-2007, 10:03 PM
Oddly enough, you pop in the TMNT movie video game and can chuk away on your Wii or such.

Criminal.

Dragon Turtle
08-22-2007, 11:36 PM
Yeah, I miss the wisekicking, ass kicking Turtle that was not ashamed, or restricted by British censhorship, in showing off his nunchuck skills. And quite frankly, while the skateboarding scene was cute, it still didn't compare to his nunchuck duel in the first flick.



I wonder what's to become of poor Panthro in the upcoming WB Thundercats movie(I believe he too had many his nunchuck scenes cut out by the BBC).

johnnyblaze
08-23-2007, 10:07 AM
Yeah, I miss the wisekicking, ass kicking Turtle that was not ashamed, or restricted by British censhorship, in showing off his nunchuck skills. And quite frankly, while the skateboarding scene was cute, it still didn't compare to his nunchuck duel in the first flick.
i do sigh when i think about the missed opportunity with mikey's fighting. i just keep remembering something munroe said in an interview about what the censors told him about mikey's weapons (i'm paraphrasing): 'you can't have him hitting that guy over the head with the nunchucks'.

plus on the dvd they had some behind the scenes footage with some killer footage of them doing tests with mikey's nunchucks and you see him wielding them around quickly. it looks so killer, it sucks that they didn't get to let loose like they obviously planned

ToTheNines
08-23-2007, 10:55 AM
(i'm paraphrasing): 'you can't have him hitting that guy over the head with the nunchucks'.


Oddly enough, he did just that! It was only once, but it was awsome.

johnnyblaze
08-23-2007, 12:07 PM
the impression i got is that munroe and his crew simply tried to get away with as much as they could. there is alot of implied heavier violence( i.e the turtles offing shredder, mikey commenting while he was fighting a stone general "wow, these guys really are immortal" kind of gives me the impression that he tried to hit her with a move meant to kill her, but ofcourse didn't, leonardo and what he did with the man/men robbing the village at the beggining of the story, ect.) next to some of the, i guess the studio would call them, more controversial martial arts moves they slipped in.

Andrew NDB
08-23-2007, 11:54 PM
the impression i got is that munroe and his crew simply tried to get away with as much as they could. there is alot of implied heavier violence

I'll agree on that much. Munroe and the gang at Imagi really did genuinely try to get away with the absolute most they could. It seems, however, they were all on an insanely tight leash. And that's unfortunate.

ToTheNines
08-23-2007, 11:57 PM
I'll agree on that much. Munroe and the gang at Imagi really did genuinely try to get away with the absolute most they could. It seems, however, they were all on an insanely tight leash. And that's unfortunate.

Yea, the only way to avoid that would be get some asshole like Speilberg's name attached to the movie, or lie and say it was made by Pixar.

Warhorse
08-24-2007, 09:01 PM
Yea, the only way to avoid that would be get some asshole like Speilberg's name attached to the movie, or lie and say it was made by Pixar.


I really would love it if Spielberg had an interest in the Turtles and helped them find more firmer footing. And I'm actually surprised that Steven Spielberg never did approach Laird and Eastman a long time ago, the property seemed it would be right up his alley. While he does like the kid stuff, like E.T, Steven Spielberg has also been known to get away with some intense material in his PG and PG-13 flicks, like Jaws (PG, even with the guy getting bitten in half) Jurassic Park 1 and two, and he apparently had a hand in Disturbia, some sort of producer that persuaded the MPAA to change the rating from an R to a PG-13.

mattmanw54301
08-24-2007, 09:14 PM
Keep in mind though, when JAWS came out there was no PG-13. There was G, PG, and R. So you had to have an awful lot of nastiness to get that R rating.

And for the record, now that I have TMNT, I watch it at least once a week.

Sage Ninja
09-24-2007, 12:37 AM
Personally I think Mike got enough screen time, but his character was again abused as comic relief. So I'm not totally happy with his usage, but for different reasons.


at least his portrayal wasn't as obnoxious as he is in the new toon Mikey can be. But I'm starting to realize that we adult Michaelangelo fans might not ever get to see him portrayed as any thing else than comic relief, which is a shame because there is so much to work with in his character. Plus the censorship of his nunchucks doesn't help in bringing forth a truly lethal Michaelangelo unfortunately.

triplexxx
09-24-2007, 01:12 AM
Well, as I said before, at least we got to see him kick the Generals' asses as well as his bros. And truthfully, as long as blood and guts ain't allowed, "lethal" can never be used to describe any of them I think.

Mr._Mutant_Man
10-02-2007, 01:01 AM
I finally saw this movie. I would rate it a B. The original Ninja Turtles movie will always be the best IMO for following the original story rather closely. Plus the movie didn't seem to have all that strong a beginning IMO. I hope if there is a sequel they get into some action a little more quickly.

The fight between Raph and Leo was really something. It was cool to see them kick butt in front of Winters' building.

I would have liked to have seen more of Karai, or get more detail about her character.

But I hope there is a sequel, and it ends up being even better. Maybe get some utroms or triceratrons in there.

turtlelover
10-05-2007, 05:29 AM
i loved the new movie but hated that they kept talking over the deleated scenes so you couldnt hear the dialogue

Mr._Mutant_Man
03-02-2008, 11:55 AM
I just saw the movie again and I think I liked it a little more the second time. After realizing that there isn't much TMNT vs. Foot Clan action, which is really what disappointed me the first time I saw it, I was able to just kind of sit back and enjoy seeing these characters in a movie again. The movie could have used more Jersey Devil though. :)


So I guess after a second viewing, I'd change my grade from a B to a B+.

If there's a sequel, I definitely want to see more ninja action though.

bwwd
03-23-2008, 12:33 PM
Well i was disappointed very much , i had a laugh only 2 times with mike scenes.

MoreCowbell5263
03-23-2008, 12:38 PM
I'm actually glad it wasn't a comedic movie and more dramatic. It didn't go well with my brother Brian, whose only exposure to the Ninja Turtles is the old cartoons and Secret of the Ooze.

Any step in a more dramatic direction for the Ninja Turtles on the big screen is a step in the right direction to me.

Revan
03-23-2008, 09:16 PM
Well i was disappointed very much , i had a laugh only 2 times with mike scenes.

good. It shouldn't be a comedic franchise anyway

doomiscool
01-24-2009, 12:11 PM
I really love it! It's one of the things that got me back into loving the TMNT :D

Scarletspeedster
02-12-2009, 09:50 PM
I grew up on the first TMNT movie and the Secret of the Ooze. back in the early 90's I probably watched those movies at least a few times a week. The new movie was good, but I have and automatic bias towards the first two, don't think anythings gonna be able to top those for me

Vivi
02-15-2009, 02:17 AM
I absolutely loved the movie (though, I probably would of liked it even better with less monsters & strange epic backstory & more screen time for the TMNT!)

The animation, voices etc were brilliant, I cannot wait until the next one...

Andrew NDB
02-15-2009, 04:49 AM
I cannot wait until the next one...

Should start practicing.

Vivi
02-15-2009, 07:50 AM
Should start practicing.

I need Bishop's secret to immortality, more likely. :)

Andrew NDB
02-15-2009, 04:17 PM
I need Bishop's secret to immortality, more likely. :)

Yes, that would work, too.

saiyan_monkey
02-16-2009, 03:55 AM
I really love it! It's one of the things that got me back into loving the TMNT :D

I had lost the Turtles in my life somehow and Im sure it was the movie that re-ignited that old love for them. Im unsure when America first had TMNT but NZ never got it till 1990 when we got our 3rd TV channel......

I wouldnt change anything in the movie but a more adult orientated movie would be good.