View Full Version : IDW multi-colored masks
Toby Barrett
12-28-2011, 01:13 PM
Rubbish, right.
Grimlock
12-28-2011, 01:13 PM
That would seem borderline insulting... to the reader, and to the interior artwork it'd be misrepresenting.
If they're going Full Rainbow -- and they have -- they better be putting that rubbish front and center without flinching.
If it's done on a variant I really don't see it as an issue. I'd rather get something red bandana related then nothing at all.
Andrew NDB
12-28-2011, 01:15 PM
If it's done on a variant I really don't see it as an issue. I'd rather get something red bandana related then nothing at all.
Oh, variants are variants... no worries there.
Grimlock
12-28-2011, 01:17 PM
Oh, variants are variants... no worries there.
Yeah, sorry if I didn't word that correctly.:) But with Eastman even doing silly colored bandanas it makes me worried that even variants won't happen.:(
junkboy
12-28-2011, 04:12 PM
I wish interior was still red bandana and we would be seeing the rainbow on silly or funny variants like Sam Kieth's ( which i like , cause that i am fan of Kieth )
but as Grimlock says , i guess we have to accept it. No other choice.
Eastman variant covers would probebly be best for all red bandanas.
But fresh new work ofc. Not like those unnecessary reprints of ( which are not remastered ) old Mirage covers.
Dirty Blond
12-28-2011, 05:34 PM
http://i.qkme.me/35lgaj.jpg
Coola Yagami
12-28-2011, 05:47 PM
http://i.qkme.me/35lgaj.jpg
rofl..... classic. what scene/movie/show is that from?
CyberCubed
12-28-2011, 08:11 PM
That would seem borderline insulting... to the reader, and to the interior artwork it'd be misrepresenting.
If they're going Full Rainbow -- and they have -- they better be putting that rubbish front and center without flinching.
From the covers shown so far, #6-8 still have the red bandanas on the standard covers. Although its possible this early on the covers were made before they were aware of the switch?
If we still see red bandanas on the standard covers of #10 onward though, then I agree its a bit tacky.
Toby Barrett
12-28-2011, 08:13 PM
It was already confirmed that the covers of issues 7 and 8 that see print will have the iconic colored bandanas.
Grimlock
12-28-2011, 09:43 PM
It was already confirmed that the covers of issues 7 and 8 that see print will have the iconic colored bandanas.
Lol, ''Iconic''. Did you refer to the red bandanas that way?
Toby Barrett
12-28-2011, 09:47 PM
No. The better known, colored bandanas.
Samhain
12-28-2011, 09:51 PM
No. The better known, colored bandanas.
I feel a war a-comin'.:lol:
Toby Barrett
12-28-2011, 09:53 PM
The way I see it, if everyone else is going to be a jerk over their opinion, I may as well too.
Andrew NDB
12-28-2011, 09:57 PM
The way I see it, if everyone else is going to be a jerk over their opinion, I may as well too.
I can respect that.
Samhain
12-28-2011, 10:01 PM
Ya know, I have come to terms with the bandana switch. It is what it is. Nothing anyone can do about it. It won't change the fact that I'm in love with this book and it's the best turtle related thing in years.
BUT, can we still get red bandana Turtles on the covers? I mean, that would be a great homage to the original turtles and it would make me happy atleast the Mirage tmnt are getting some recognition. Thoughts?
I like this idea. Hopefully Eastman's variant covers for #7 and 8 won't have the colored bandanas. I understand the switch has happened but damn, we should still get a variant or 2 of the ''Mirage'' style turtles. Eastman's art with those colored bandanas looks really off to me.
The way I see it, if everyone else is going to be a jerk over their opinion, I may as well too.
No worries man. It's your opinion!:)
azrael
12-28-2011, 10:15 PM
I love both versions, just hope leo doesnt change his to yellow for when a female turtle shows up.
I think this is a bit silly arguing bandana colors but when everything else about a series is top notch I guess you have to nit-pick.
Metropoliskid41
12-28-2011, 11:31 PM
I think this is a bit silly arguing bandana colors but when everything else about a series is top notch I guess you have to nit-pick.
Exactly, well said!
Andrew NDB
12-28-2011, 11:57 PM
I think this is a bit silly arguing bandana colors but when everything else about a series is top notch I guess you have to nit-pick.
While I'm willing to bite my tongue on the bandannas going forward in the bigger picture of things, let's not pretend that whole thing is just a "nit." It's in no way equivalent to, you know, "I feel like Tom got this bit of Raphael dialogue wrong in issue #6" or "Dan's plastron for Michelangelo was all wrong in #4."
Toby Barrett
12-29-2011, 07:32 AM
Here's the covers to Issue 7 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/IDW-TMNT-07_Cover-A-Art_Duncan.jpg) and Issue 8 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/IDW-TMNT-08_Cover-A-Art_Duncan.jpg) that will actually see print!
All of my love!
Source is of course, the fantastic rich! (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/)
Metropoliskid41
12-29-2011, 07:41 AM
Awesome! Thanks for posting those!
Donnie
12-29-2011, 12:07 PM
"Heck to the yeah!"
Andrew NDB
12-29-2011, 12:20 PM
"Heck to the yeah!"
Dot dot dot...
http://files.sharenator.com/shocked_cat_RE_Most_fed_up_conversation_ever-s500x332-126007.jpg
Venom
12-29-2011, 12:23 PM
"Heck to the yeah!"
Dot dot dot...
:tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:
Donnie
12-29-2011, 02:33 PM
Dot dot dot...
:lol:
You know I was quoting Mikey, don't ya?
Andrew NDB
12-29-2011, 03:11 PM
:lol:
You know I was quoting Mikey, don't ya?
Precisely.
Grimlock
12-29-2011, 04:37 PM
Here's the covers to Issue 7 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/IDW-TMNT-07_Cover-A-Art_Duncan.jpg) and Issue 8 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/IDW-TMNT-08_Cover-A-Art_Duncan.jpg) that will actually see print!
All of my love!
Source is of course, the fantastic rich! (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/)
Meh, they looked so legit in all red on those covers. While I love the art and coloring, for some reason, I just can't take those colors seriously. I think ''kiddie'' every time I see them. Sigh...
Toby Barrett
12-29-2011, 04:48 PM
Really? I think the original movie, my favorite version of the turtles.
Grimlock
12-29-2011, 04:54 PM
Really? I think the original movie, my favorite version of the turtles.
I think the problem for me is my first ever exposure to the turtles was a Mirage fourth printing of #1. That particular cover has always been stuck in my mind as the ''definitive'' turtles. It's not really a problem I have with those colored bandanas. It's where they are seen I have the issue with.
MikeandRaph87
12-29-2011, 04:56 PM
Meh, they looked so legit in all red on those covers. While I love the art and coloring, for some reason, I just can't take those colors seriously. I think ''kiddie'' every time I see them. Sigh...
That is what is wonderful about the TMNT. People have such different visions of the TMNT. I, myself, can't take all red mask seriously. Lets just hope that IDW's series is something for '87 series fans,Mirage fans, and others. That is the main thing!
Grimlock
12-29-2011, 05:03 PM
That is what is wonderful about the TMNT. People have such different visions of the TMNT. I, myself, can't take all red mask seriously. Lets just hope that IDW's series is something for '87 series fans,Mirage fans, and others. That is the main thing!
Thing is, This series was very much Mirage-ish and now with the bandana change, Bebop, Rocksteady and ''Krang'' here.. it just feels....:ohwell:
Andrew NDB
12-29-2011, 05:06 PM
Here's the covers to Issue 7 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/IDW-TMNT-07_Cover-A-Art_Duncan.jpg) and Issue 8 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/IDW-TMNT-08_Cover-A-Art_Duncan.jpg) that will actually see print!
Meh, they looked so legit in all red on those covers. While I love the art and coloring, for some reason, I just can't take those colors seriously. I think ''kiddie'' every time I see them. Sigh...
I've resolved to adopting a "if I can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all" policy about those bandannas going forward or everyone is going to get sick of me, even the ones who agree.
That is what is wonderful about the TMNT. People have such different visions of the TMNT. I, myself, can't take all red mask seriously. Lets just hope that IDW's series is something for '87 series fans,Mirage fans, and others. That is the main thing!
Wrong. The main thing is it not being out of place on a comic book rack next to Wolverine or The Boys, readable and accessible and "cool" to people who either never bothered with any TMNT or were turned off by the child-like stigma of it in the mass media.
At least, if you want it to survive.
Grimlock
12-29-2011, 05:09 PM
I've resolved to adopting a "if I can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all" policy about those bandannas going forward or everyone is going to get sick of me, even the ones who agree.
I agree Andrew. Complaining isn't changing it.:tcool: I just gotta share my opinion.
MikeandRaph87
12-29-2011, 05:15 PM
Thing is, This series was very much Mirage-ish and now with the bandana change, Bebop, Rocksteady and ''Krang'' here.. it just feels....:ohwell:
That is a problem and you are right. I want to see as much of an '87 series influence as possible since that is how I was introduced and think is the best. I enjoy them more in other media than I do in comics. To be honest before signing up I never thought anyone had attachments to all red mask. Again its orintation and preferences. Others will scream betrayal and murder with mask and characters. That is why me as a primarily other media fan reading the comic a little nervous coming over to this corner. I was hoping IDW would do and expand on what the movies did and incorporate elements of both the '87 cartoon and the Mirage comics successfully. I have been waiting for Bebop and Rocksteady getting a little blood on their hands and taken a little more serious by fans who perfer the comics. If these characters can be given a chance to be developed and adapted I think it will work and they can be accepted. Its just the matter of them getting the chance and being done RIGHT. It is a slippery slope. As long as its not Venus and maybe a random other character or two most can work in a given version if done RIGHT The question is how to incorporate elemetns and characters to make both feel comfortable.:)
Toby Barrett
12-29-2011, 05:30 PM
Wrong. The main thing is it not being out of place on a comic book rack next to Wolverine or The Boys, readable and accessible and "cool" to people who either never bothered with any TMNT or were turned off by the child-like stigma of it in the mass media.
At least, if you want it to survive.
I honestly doubt if someone doesn't think the TMNT are cool that red bandanas would really change their opinion.
Andrew NDB
12-29-2011, 05:42 PM
I honestly doubt if someone doesn't think the TMNT are cool that red bandanas would really change their opinion.
No, but maybe it would help. A rainbow/skittle ninja clan doesn't really scream "Badass" to anyone with a foot left in reality, any cannotation it carries of the McTMNT™ notwithstanding.
But I'm not even talking about bandannas. I'm talking about content, nostalgia (as something that should not be a factor), and raw curbside appeal to raw new readers. Worrying about appeasing any existing TMNT fans -- yes, even us Mirage fans -- should be secondary.
Coola Yagami
12-29-2011, 05:51 PM
Thing is, This series was very much Mirage-ish and now with the bandana change, Bebop, Rocksteady and ''Krang'' here.. it just feels....:ohwell:
Except Krang was referenced since issue 1....
Wrong. The main thing is it not being out of place on a comic book rack next to Wolverine or The Boys, readable and accessible and "cool" to people who either never bothered with any TMNT or were turned off by the child-like stigma of it in the mass media.
At least, if you want it to survive.
You bring a good point. Are there any numbers out there for the general (non Mirage/OT/whatev TMNT fans) consumer picking up this book? Is there any casual comic book fan picking up TMNT alongside his monthly copy of Batman and XMen?
Toby Barrett
12-29-2011, 05:58 PM
I know that with every issue that's released at the shop I go to, all of their copies are gone within days.
Coola Yagami
12-29-2011, 06:14 PM
Hmmm so far I see that the first 4 issues are sold out, including the variants... but I see lots of issues 5s and the Raph issue... I wonder if its slowing down at my comic shop after the reincarnation jazz.
MikeandRaph87
12-29-2011, 06:21 PM
At my shop most non-DC/Marvel have to be preordered for a pull list or one can't get it. Does anyone else have that problem? I know five of us are pulling it yet people that want to sample it to see if they like it can't just pull it off the shelf.
Andrew NDB
12-29-2011, 06:30 PM
At my shop most non-DC/Marvel have to be preordered for a pull list or one can't get it. Does anyone else have that problem? I know five of us are pulling it yet people that want to sample it to see if they like it can't just pull it off the shelf.
A sad reality.
Grimlock
12-29-2011, 07:11 PM
Except Krang was referenced since issue 1....
But the toon bandanas and Bebop and Rocksteady made their first appearace in the Raph micro.:ohwell:
Toby Barrett
12-29-2011, 07:12 PM
And the Raphael micro was awesome! Probobly my favorite issue yet!
Venom
12-29-2011, 07:48 PM
Hmmm so far I see that the first 4 issues are sold out, including the variants... but I see lots of issues 5s and the Raph issue... I wonder if its slowing down at my comic shop after the reincarnation jazz.
See if your shop can get you the Global Conquest editions that just hit.
Dirty Blond
12-29-2011, 11:14 PM
You know, as I think about it, I remember being a little kid and laughing at the box cover from the first Turtles game for the NES. I thought they completely screwed up!
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b7/Tmnt-box.jpg
(They did screw up, just with the game-play, but that's another issue for another day.)
Andrew NDB
12-30-2011, 12:04 AM
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b7/Tmnt-box.jpg
(They did screw up, just with the game-play, but that's another issue for another day.)
Sure the gameplay could have used some tweaking but that remains the only TMNT game that bothered to try and be innovative. The rest were all shameless button-mashing Final Fight clones.
pl212
12-30-2011, 12:34 AM
This is wishful thinking but I really hope a few issues/arcs in either Leo or Don point out they have matured since their past lives (fav. color era) and only sported the rainbow bandanas to please their father's wishes.. later on switching over to red again.
This can probably be done by recycling Tom's explanation (for colors) and go along the lines of "In Raphael's return we became a family again. We will represent this family with this color." type of thing.
And not to forget all the other obvious reasons Andrew pointed out which either Leo or Don can easily see the one color working in their favor.
Andrew NDB
12-30-2011, 11:24 AM
Suddenly the multi-colored bandanna following makes a whole lot more sense:
http://www.oregonlive.com/entertainment/index.ssf/2011/09/seriously_my_little_pony_grown.html
http://www.neatorama.com/2011/06/11/bronies-adult-men-who-like-to-watch-my-little-pony/
Donnie
12-30-2011, 11:49 AM
Suddenly the multi-colored bandanna following makes a whole lot more sense:
http://www.oregonlive.com/entertainment/index.ssf/2011/09/seriously_my_little_pony_grown.html
http://www.neatorama.com/2011/06/11/bronies-adult-men-who-like-to-watch-my-little-pony/
That...is...disturbing. But hey, more power to them!
That one guy with the glasses reminds me of Dwight from The Office. :D
Princess Anri
12-30-2011, 12:05 PM
That...is...disturbing. But hey, more power to them!
Yeah, they're REAL too.
This is my first year teaching high school chemistry and I have a student who is a brony.
He was so surprised that I knew what that meant without him telling me and now he won't shut up about random internet memes.
Kids these days think they invented the internet.
Gyt Kaliba
12-30-2011, 12:38 PM
Can't believe you guys are just now finding out about Bronies heh. I've got a friend who's one and a few female friends that love the show too, but I don't think I could get into it myself.
Donnie
12-30-2011, 12:59 PM
Gyt, your sig banner reminds me of human Turtles...from left to right Raph, female Mikey, female Leo, and Don.
Gyt Kaliba
12-30-2011, 01:12 PM
LMAO! Oh wow. That is a comparison I never thought I'd see made. XD And ironically, based on personality, you'd be pretty well spot on with the Mikey guess there...a little on the Raph maybe.
It's anything but human turtles though, it's actually a manga series I'm really heavily into. But to avoid going further off topic, just click the link if you're interested. ^_^ I never did figure out how to get a picture link to work here...
Cowabunga Carl
12-30-2011, 01:14 PM
This is wishful thinking but I really hope a few issues/arcs in either Leo or Don point out they have matured since their past lives (fav. color era) and only sported the rainbow bandanas to please their father's wishes.. later on switching over to red again.
This can probably be done by recycling Tom's explanation (for colors) and go along the lines of "In Raphael's return we became a family again. We will represent this family with this color." type of thing.
And not to forget all the other obvious reasons Andrew pointed out which either Leo or Don can easily see the one color working in their favor.
I like this idea. Don't think it will happen but I like this idea.
Andrew NDB
12-30-2011, 01:23 PM
Oh, there's plenty of pretty logical ways that the TMNT could eventually either re-don the all-reds or some other defining singular color... but yeah, as hard as it looks like IDW (well, just Tom, it sounds like) lobbied for the rainbow bandannas to squeeze them into the story somehow -- even if haphazardly --it's probably not realistic to expect that they would undo all of that now or anytime in the foreseeable future.
Which is too bad.
Toby Barrett
12-30-2011, 02:24 PM
Suddenly the multi-colored bandanna following makes a whole lot more sense:
http://www.oregonlive.com/entertainment/index.ssf/2011/09/seriously_my_little_pony_grown.html
http://www.neatorama.com/2011/06/11/bronies-adult-men-who-like-to-watch-my-little-pony/
Yea, because preferring the turtles to wear different colored bandanas is exactly the same thing as grown men touching themselves to a cartoon for 4 year old girls.
Andrew NDB
12-30-2011, 02:56 PM
Yea, because preferring the turtles to wear different colored bandanas is exactly the same thing as grown men touching themselves to a cartoon for 4 year old girls.
Now, now... I wouldn't let my 4 year-old girl anywhere near these creeps but I'm reasonably sure they're getting something more than masturbatory relief from their shared interest. Or are they?
Bronies appear to be about grown men who enjoy very bright, very colorful characters that stem from a show for little kids designed to sell toys. Kind of like... nah.
Gyt Kaliba
12-30-2011, 02:58 PM
Yea, because preferring the turtles to wear different colored bandanas is exactly the same thing as grown men touching themselves to a cartoon for 4 year old girls.
While I can agree that it's ludicrous to think that liking the multi-colored bandanas lumps one in with THAT kind of thing, it's also ludicrous to think that every fan of MLP does that...just saying. I mean, I might get my ear talked off all the time by my friends that like it, but that doesn't automatically make them perverts.
Toby Barrett
12-30-2011, 02:59 PM
I like the colored bandanas because my first exposure to the turtles was the original film, and then the archie comic. It has nothing to do with liking bright flashy colors, and just like you, is a preference of what I knew first.
I kinda find it insulting honestly.
While I can agree that it's ludicrous to think that liking the multi-colored bandanas lumps one in with THAT kind of thing, it's also ludicrous to think that every fan of MLP does that...just saying. I mean, I might get my ear talked off all the time by my friends that like it, but that doesn't automatically make them perverts.
Ah, well, the only bronies I've ever met are a bunch of sickos, so...
Powder
12-30-2011, 03:01 PM
So it's nostalgia. I was first exposed to the rainbow gang and love them dearly but I'd still fight tooth & nail to keep this book red.
Toby Barrett
12-30-2011, 03:03 PM
So what if it's nostalgia. I didn't care if the bandanas were red, I was perfectly fine with it. You didn't see me complaining and insulting other's preferences because it was different from mine.
Andrew NDB
12-30-2011, 03:07 PM
I like the colored bandanas because my first exposure to the turtles was the original film, and then the archie comic.
Absolutely respectable. Multi-colored bandannas were the first exposure for you and you acknowledge that it's simple nostalgia is why you like them... nothing wrong with that whatsoever.
It has nothing to do with liking bright flashy colors, and just like you, is a preference of what I knew first.
Like me? The first thing I saw was TMNT cartoons, then a couple Archie comics... and then the Mirage material after I was beginning to outgrow the cartoons, toys, and just watched the third horrible movie and all that. There's no chronological nostalgia to my preference of the red bandannas... they just make the most sense.
I kinda find it insulting honestly. Ah, well, the only bronies I've ever met are a bunch of sickos, so...
I didn't think I needed to include a disclaimer that I'm not seriously comparing the two. There's some general similarities, though I do think "Color Man" (or whoever it was posting earlier in this thread about refusing to read any X-Men comics for 40 years or whatever because the costumes were changed) might have more in common with them than anybody else.
Toby Barrett
12-30-2011, 03:12 PM
I think it's best if I just let this topic be. I'm getting too worked up over colors and bandanas and taking things too personally now, and arguing in circles is becoming pretty tiring... I'm sure it is for everyone honestly.
Grimlock
12-30-2011, 05:33 PM
I think it's best if I just let this topic be. I'm getting too worked up over colors and bandanas and taking things too personally now, and arguing in circles is becoming pretty tiring... I'm sure it is for everyone honestly.
Well, you don't have to post anymore or even come into this thread if it's getting personal to you, dude. We are all fans here, no need for it to be like that. Just sayin.
MikeandRaph87
12-30-2011, 05:41 PM
Like me? The first thing I saw was TMNT cartoons, then a couple Archie comics... and then the Mirage material after I was beginning to outgrow the cartoons, toys, and just watched the third horrible movie and all that. There's no chronological nostalgia to my preference of the red bandannas... they just make the most sense.
I can see and respect that because it is no nostaglia in yours as it is in mine of the four different colors make the most sense having sampled all the ever incarnations. We just like the TMNT in different ways is all.
I think it's best if I just let this topic be. I'm getting too worked up over colors and bandanas and taking things too personally now, and arguing in circles is becoming pretty tiring... I'm sure it is for everyone honestly.
I agree completely here. We all love the TMNT and that is the reason we are posting here. We don't need to need to be like DC Comics diehards going in circles both with valid points when it comes to DCU vs DCnU.:tgrin:
FlawedCoil82
12-30-2011, 07:08 PM
I didn't think I needed to include a disclaimer that I'm not seriously comparing the two. There's some general similarities, though I do think "Color Man" (or whoever it was posting earlier in this thread about refusing to read any X-Men comics for 40 years or whatever because the costumes were changed) might have more in common with them than anybody else.
You are absolutely correct! How could you ever know I love My Little Pony and that I fap to them?!? You are a super sleuth, sir! :roll:
That seriously may be one of the most ignorant things I have ever read on here. Yes, I love the colorful, iconic, entertaining X-Men uniforms from 1990's. Yes, I much prefer the multi-colored bandanas more than the red ones. Yes, you are a presumptious prick fanboy who believes in the diehard phrase "the original is ALWAYS best no matter what". Do you ever wonder why the turtles became so popular after the bandana colors were switched? Do you ever wonder why the X-Men comics have not been nearly as popular since the change from their 90's uniforms? Do you wonder why most X-Men action figures released today feature the X-Men in their 90's uniforms? Of course you don't, because then you would have to admit it, and I suspect that you are simply too proud and stubborn to, but the facts don't lie. Liking to see my favorite comic characters in the uniforms/colors I find most appealing and recognizable has absolutely nothing to do with liking My Little Pony or anything remotely that ridiculous. Grow up and accept that other people are allowed to stay just as loyal to what they like, as what you like.
CyberCubed
12-30-2011, 08:17 PM
If Slash appears I hope he still has a black bandana.
Andrew NDB
12-30-2011, 09:11 PM
If Slash appears I hope he still has a black bandana.
As long as he's not wearing a bandanna at all just for the sake of it.
Grimlock
12-30-2011, 11:00 PM
Do you ever wonder why the turtles became so popular after the bandana colors were switched?
Do you know why the turtles even got noticed enough to make that cartoon? Yeah, the comic. Which had a pretty big following by independent comic standards. Don't act like there was nothing before the cartoon. The comic was first and it had to be a big hit in order for all that other stuff to happen.
OrsonZedd
12-31-2011, 12:09 AM
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/10/102820/1891932-owlman___it_doesn_t_matter_thumb.gif
It doesn't matter.
Andrew NDB
12-31-2011, 12:54 AM
Do you ever wonder why the turtles became so popular after the bandana colors were switched?
My memory is foggy and it's true I can only watch about 6 or 7 or so episodes of the original cartoon (though I honestly intend to shortly with my daughter) before I'm unable to continue... so I guess I missed the episodes where the Turtles began with the all-reds and then switched to the multi-colored ones and the Nielsen ratings went up. Maybe a helpful Fred Wolf fan can clue me in on which episodes these were, as I'd be interested in seeing them.
Now, what I do know is that all red-bandannaed TMNT started a multi-billion dollar empire.
Do you know why the turtles even got noticed enough to make that cartoon? Yeah, the comic. Which had a pretty big following by independent comic standards. Don't act like there was nothing before the cartoon. The comic was first and it had to be a big hit in order for all that other stuff to happen.
It's the classic empty-headed argument against the Mirage TMNT, really: "Pfft, those lousy Mirage TMNT, what would they even be without the cartoons and toys and all that other stuff? Probably cancelled and forgotten about in the 80s or 90s, lousy comic book. Pfft. You Mirage fans should be so thankful for all the cartoons and toys."
It's a very strange stance to take, IMO. Who knows what would have happened if Kevin and Peter hadn't leased out the TMNT to bigger things as they did, or at least retained a much more rigorous (i.e., more Mirage faithful) leash on their creative property in the process? It seems pretty pompous or at least presumptuous of anyone to sit here and retroactively predict doom for the Mirage TMNT and the baseline vision of the TMNT if Kevin and Peter hadn't taken exactly the course of action they did with Surge Licensing and Fred Wolf and all that.
Now, I don't think anyone can sit here and say, "Oh, it would be selling Wolverine numbers off the racks, even now!" No, probably not, at least not without looking like a douchebag, or at least a moron. Personally, I think it would have gone on to do a respectable enough run akin to things like Cerebus or Groo before wrapping up, possibly going on to various mini-series throughout the years and/or revivals. Perhaps it would just continue onward indefinitely as Usagi Yojimbo is, small print runs but a loyal and dedicated following -- I could live with that.
About the bigger picture of things, had there been no Fred Wolf show (or at least a show quite like that one) and "Turtlemania" had not occurred, I don't tend to think that would have been the end of the world. Come the 2000s when X-Men was a hit and movie studios were buying up comic book movie rights left and right... who knows? Perhaps a then-long running indy comic like TMNT would have gotten noticed by the right people (if nothing else, the novelty of the title attracts attention -- The Mask was a small-but-novelty concept comic and that got a pretty faithful movie) and we would have gotten a completely faithful TMNT film adaption, tonally akin to things like the Crow or Blade or Hellboy (I use these as examples of relatively indy comic book films done right but I'm not necessarily suggesting an R-rated TMNT film). After that? Who knows?
Now, I am by no means damning Peter or Kevin for making their deal with Surge and Fred Wolf... if I were in their shoes with that kind of opportunity, with a purse that big being waved in front of me with the potential dividends, you can be damned sure I'd cave in. Where do I sign, right? My main point here is, nobody can say what would have subsequently happened had they not made that deal or if TMNT would be a more or less creatively faithful -- while still viable -- mass media property as a result right now.
Hermano Dyvas
12-31-2011, 07:15 AM
You are absolutely correct! How could you ever know I love My Little Pony and that I fap to them?!? You are a super sleuth, sir! :roll:
That seriously may be one of the most ignorant things I have ever read on here. Yes, I love the colorful, iconic, entertaining X-Men uniforms from 1990's. Yes, I much prefer the multi-colored bandanas more than the red ones. Yes, you are a presumptious prick fanboy who believes in the diehard phrase "the original is ALWAYS best no matter what". Do you ever wonder why the turtles became so popular after the bandana colors were switched? Do you ever wonder why the X-Men comics have not been nearly as popular since the change from their 90's uniforms? Do you wonder why most X-Men action figures released today feature the X-Men in their 90's uniforms? Of course you don't, because then you would have to admit it, and I suspect that you are simply too proud and stubborn to, but the facts don't lie. Liking to see my favorite comic characters in the uniforms/colors I find most appealing and recognizable has absolutely nothing to do with liking My Little Pony or anything remotely that ridiculous. Grow up and accept that other people are allowed to stay just as loyal to what they like, as what you like.
No need to call anyone a prick or throw other nasty insults for that matter. Relax, we're all friends here.
Candy Kappa
12-31-2011, 11:23 AM
Do you ever wonder why the turtles became so popular after the bandana colors were switched? .
The Turtles popularity have nothing to do with colors, but with clever PR and a toy line that swooped kids interest and a cartoon series that aimed for all ages.
The color bandannas just gave the turtles some extra splotches of colors, by your little angry rant, you could use same "arguments" to say the belt buckles made the turtles big.
"Ever wonder why the turtles got so big after belt initials?"
Edit: And by the way, the X-men stopped using uniformed costumes before the 90's, their first costume change that gave them individual looks was issue 87 in 1974.
FlawedCoil82
12-31-2011, 12:51 PM
No need to call anyone a prick or throw other nasty insults for that matter. Relax, we're all friends here.
But it is totally alright for him to imply that I watch My Little Pony and fap to it? Yea, that seems completely fair to me also.
At any rate, this argument can not be won on either side. You will all defend red bandanas to the death, just like I will defend 90's X-Men to the death. Best for everyone to move on.
Coola Yagami
12-31-2011, 02:10 PM
My memory is foggy and it's true I can only watch about 6 or 7 or so episodes of the original cartoon (though I honestly intend to shortly with my daughter) before I'm unable to continue... so I guess I missed the episodes where the Turtles began with the all-reds and then switched to the multi-colored ones and the Nielsen ratings went up. Maybe a helpful Fred Wolf fan can clue me in on which episodes these were, as I'd be interested in seeing them.
Now, what I do know is that all red-bandannaed TMNT started a multi-billion dollar empire.
It's the classic empty-headed argument against the Mirage TMNT, really: "Pfft, those lousy Mirage TMNT, what would they even be without the cartoons and toys and all that other stuff? Probably cancelled and forgotten about in the 80s or 90s, lousy comic book. Pfft. You Mirage fans should be so thankful for all the cartoons and toys."
It's a very strange stance to take, IMO. Who knows what would have happened if Kevin and Peter hadn't leased out the TMNT to bigger things as they did, or at least retained a much more rigorous (i.e., more Mirage faithful) leash on their creative property in the process? It seems pretty pompous or at least presumptuous of anyone to sit here and retroactively predict doom for the Mirage TMNT and the baseline vision of the TMNT if Kevin and Peter hadn't taken exactly the course of action they did with Surge Licensing and Fred Wolf and all that.
Now, I don't think anyone can sit here and say, "Oh, it would be selling Wolverine numbers off the racks, even now!" No, probably not, at least not without looking like a douchebag, or at least a moron. Personally, I think it would have gone on to do a respectable enough run akin to things like Cerebus or Groo before wrapping up, possibly going on to various mini-series throughout the years and/or revivals. Perhaps it would just continue onward indefinitely as Usagi Yojimbo is, small print runs but a loyal and dedicated following -- I could live with that.
About the bigger picture of things, had there been no Fred Wolf show (or at least a show quite like that one) and "Turtlemania" had not occurred, I don't tend to think that would have been the end of the world. Come the 2000s when X-Men was a hit and movie studios were buying up comic book movie rights left and right... who knows? Perhaps a then-long running indy comic like TMNT would have gotten noticed by the right people (if nothing else, the novelty of the title attracts attention -- The Mask was a small-but-novelty concept comic and that got a pretty faithful movie) and we would have gotten a completely faithful TMNT film adaption, tonally akin to things like the Crow or Blade or Hellboy (I use these as examples of relatively indy comic book films done right but I'm not necessarily suggesting an R-rated TMNT film). After that? Who knows?
Now, I am by no means damning Peter or Kevin for making their deal with Surge and Fred Wolf... if I were in their shoes with that kind of opportunity, with a purse that big being waved in front of me with the potential dividends, you can be damned sure I'd cave in. Where do I sign, right? My main point here is, nobody can say what would have subsequently happened had they not made that deal or if TMNT would be a more or less creatively faithful -- while still viable -- mass media property as a result right now.
Yes, it is a mystery what would have been had Eastman and Laird not 'sold out' to Fred Wolf and whatnot... but it's hard for me to imagine a Mirage type cartoon back in the day... maybe more in the 90's when Batman and XMen brought action back into cartoons. Batman had fist-fighting and real guns, and XMen had ongoing storyarcs, something a Mirage show could have used. Didn't they also have a movie pitch that wasn't picked up until after Turtlemania started? As for the Mask, no dude, while the movie did grab elements from The Mask and The Mask Returns, the movie was more of a light-hearted comedy romp for Carrey than the bloody death-left-and-right book of the Mask. In fact New Line Cineman originally wanted to make it their next new 'horror' series after giving Freddy a rest.
Matches Malone
12-31-2011, 06:31 PM
While I'm unquestionably for the all-red side, I do think that those who suggest that it is easy to tell which turtle is which without their weapons are overstating their case a bit. Yes, color tones help but they are definitely subtle. Unless someone can tell me who is who in artwork without their weapons like issue #14 (anyone? bueller? bueller?), I would say colored bandannas being helpful for readers in this regard is a legitimate point. However, it was a terrible idea for the Archie series to make this an in-story reason where Splinter can't even tell the difference between his own sons!
http://s3.amazonaws.com/data.tumblr.com/tumblr_lumaf9WDbm1qly3yjo1_1280.jpg?AWSAccessKeyId =AKIAJ6IHWSU3BX3X7X3Q&Expires=1325463960&Signature=U1LTZoQdcCbO9i%2FpPTDnu0HVP7k%3D
Also, it's equally over-reaching to suggest the success of the TMNT is hinged completely on such a small detail as the color of their bandannas.
Samhain
12-31-2011, 06:36 PM
While I'm unquestionably for the all-red side, I do think that those who suggest that it is easy to tell which turtle is which without their weapons are overstating their case a bit. Yes, color tones help but they are definitely subtle. Unless someone can tell me who is who in artwork without their weapons like issue #14 (anyone? bueller? bueller?), I would say colored bandannas being helpful for readers in this regard is a legitimate point. However, it was a terrible idea for the Archie series to make this an in-story reason where Splinter can't even tell the difference between his own sons!
http://s3.amazonaws.com/data.tumblr.com/tumblr_lumaf9WDbm1qly3yjo1_1280.jpg?AWSAccessKeyId =AKIAJ6IHWSU3BX3X7X3Q&Expires=1325463960&Signature=U1LTZoQdcCbO9i%2FpPTDnu0HVP7k%3D
Also, it's equally over-reaching to suggest the success of the TMNT is hinged completely on such a small detail as the color of their bandannas.
Dude, that cover is a pretty bad example.;) Though, the turtles sure do look like bosses with that get-up.
Matches Malone
12-31-2011, 06:39 PM
Dude, that cover is a pretty bad example.;) Though, the turtles sure do look like bosses with that get-up.
Hmm... not sure how it's a bad example. I was just trying to find a piece with all 4 turtles without their weapons... I mean, I can tell which one is Casey :)
Venom
12-31-2011, 06:44 PM
From left to right:
Don, April, Casey, Leo, Mike, Raph.
IIRC
Samhain
12-31-2011, 06:48 PM
Hmm... not sure how it's a bad example. I was just trying to find a piece with all 4 turtles without their weapons... I mean, I can tell which one is Casey :)
It's a bad example because their expressions are all exactly the same. There really isn't any way to tell them apart based on just looking at that cover. But artists could develop characteristics that only Mikey does with his eyes or a smirk or something like that. That the real fans would pay attention to and pick up on. Not the ''orange party dude''. Not only that but they did have different skin tones in IDW. But, it doesn't matter. IDW gave the turtles those crap bandanas either because they wanted to sell more copies or well, it's obvious they favor the 80's cartoon.
This is supposed to be a Tmnt book for older audiences. Do we really need colors thrown right in our face? As adults can we pick up on certain traits an artist might give the turtles? If he chose to do so? That's much more fun to me.
From left to right:
Don, April, Casey, Leo, Mike, Raph.
IIRC
I was thinking Raph might want those brass knux more than Mikey..Hehe.
Venom
12-31-2011, 06:53 PM
This is supposed to be a Tmnt book for older audiences. Do we really need colors thrown right in our face? As adults can we pick up on certain traits an artist might give the turtles? If he chose to do so? That's much more fun to me.
Actually IDw has stated that it's more of a PG-13 type book, geared for all audiences with a slight skew toward us older fans.
IIRC, about the time issue 2 or 3 came out, Bobby or Tom mentioned something similar to sales being up with younger audiences which is something they were hoping for.
Thus far the series feels to me like a harder Archie, which is not a bad thing at all as I love Murph as a writer!
I would peg it like this on a scale, from "hardest" to "lightest": Mirage, Image, IDW, Archie.
Samhain
12-31-2011, 07:03 PM
Actually IDw has stated that it's more of a PG-13 type book, geared for all audiences with a slight skew toward us older fans.
IIRC, about the time issue 2 or 3 came out, Bobby or Tom mentioned something similar to sales being up with younger audiences which is something they were hoping for.
Thus far the series feels to me like a harder Archie, which is not a bad thing at all as I love Murph as a writer!
I would peg it like this on a scale, from "hardest" to "lightest": Mirage, Image, IDW, Archie.
I mean, I know it's not a ''hardcore'' series but those red bandanas let everyone know that these are NOT your 80's toon turtles. But now, visually, they are.
stormbringer
12-31-2011, 07:14 PM
I mean, I know it's not a ''hardcore'' series but those red bandanas let everyone know that these are NOT your 80's toon turtles. But now, visually, they are.
Well to be fair, the movie and 2k3 turtles both had the multicolor bandanas, and they were nothing like the 80's toon turtles.
Samhain
12-31-2011, 07:38 PM
Well to be fair, the movie and 2k3 turtles both had the multicolor bandanas, and they were nothing like the 80's toon turtles.
I never said the IDW turtles acted like the 80's toon turtles. I said VISUALLY, they are. Because of those bandanas, They are PG-13 turtles with childrens toon colors on. It just doesn't fit.
Powder
12-31-2011, 07:40 PM
I would peg it like this on a scale, from "hardest" to "lightest": Mirage, Image, IDW, Archie.
I would put Image before Mirage on the "hard" scale. Big boobies, brewski's, tons of blood and swearing...
Matches Malone
12-31-2011, 09:07 PM
It's a bad example because their expressions are all exactly the same. There really isn't any way to tell them apart based on just looking at that cover. But artists could develop characteristics that only Mikey does with his eyes or a smirk or something like that. That the real fans would pay attention to and pick up on. Not the ''orange party dude''. Not only that but they did have different skin tones in IDW. But, it doesn't matter. IDW gave the turtles those crap bandanas either because they wanted to sell more copies or well, it's obvious they favor the 80's cartoon.
This is supposed to be a Tmnt book for older audiences. Do we really need colors thrown right in our face? As adults can we pick up on certain traits an artist might give the turtles? If he chose to do so? That's much more fun to me.
I was thinking Raph might want those brass knux more than Mikey..Hehe.
Hey, like I said, I'm essentially on the red side of the issue, I'm just trying to be fair. I like things to be subtle as well; I'm just acknowledging that it's not exactly fair to call less observant fans inferior to so-called "real" fans. Any fans of TMNT are good, in my book. The only point I was trying to make was that while there are ways besides colored headbands to distinguish the turtles from one another, they are generally pretty subtle or up to interpretation (the disagreement on who would wear the brass knuckles is a good example, even), and I don't think it's unreasonable to prefer a more straight-forward visual cue.
I certainly appreciate Leonardo's ninjaken straps, and like that it sets him apart since he is the leader. Even if it's not colored headbands, I would appreciate other visual cues too in the character designs, though it will probably be controversial no matter what. I think Image made an attempt to do this by making Donnie a cyborg, scarring Raph's face (which I think was pretty cool), and cutting Leo's hand off. Perhaps that was too extreme, but it shows that acknowledging the legitimacy of the point doesn't mean you support colored headbands. Anyhow, just trying to be fair is all, and that you don't have to be a dummy to have this opinion.
Samhain
12-31-2011, 09:10 PM
Hey, like I said, I'm essentially on the red side of the issue, I'm just trying to be fair. I like things to be subtle as well; I'm just acknowledging that it's not exactly fair to call less observant fans inferior to so-called "real" fans. Any fans of TMNT are good, in my book. The only point I was trying to make was that while there are ways besides colored headbands to distinguish the turtles from one another, they are generally pretty subtle or up to interpretation (the disagreement on who would wear the brass knuckles is a good example, even), and I don't think it's unreasonable to prefer a more straight-forward visual cue.
I certainly appreciate Leonardo's ninjaken straps, and like that it sets him apart since he is the leader. Even if it's not colored headbands, I would appreciate other visual cues too in the character designs, though it will probably be controversial no matter what. I think Image made an attempt to do this by making Donnie a cyborg, scarring Raph's face (which I think was pretty cool), and cutting Leo's hand off. Perhaps that was too extreme, but it shows that acknowledging the legitimacy of the point doesn't mean you support colored headbands. Anyhow, just trying to be fair is all, and that you don't have to be a dummy to have this opinion.
It's all good bro. We are just discussing, that's all.:tcool:
Matches Malone
12-31-2011, 09:15 PM
It's all good bro. We are just discussing, that's all.:tcool:
Yup, all good. I just saw a few comments that made me feel compelled to play Devil's Advocate. Best to win over folks when it's clear you're being fair and logical and not just trying to get others to agree with your opinion. Discuss away! That's my only two cents at this point as I'm pretty over this subject... :trolleye:
Samhain
12-31-2011, 09:21 PM
I'm pretty over this subject... :trolleye:
As am I....
Hermano Dyvas
12-31-2011, 10:13 PM
But it is totally alright for him to imply that I watch My Little Pony and fap to it? Yea, that seems completely fair to me also.
He never implied this, just said you may have a lot in common with their fans because you like bright colors.
Silly assumption but it's not really on the same level as calling someone a prick.
FlawedCoil82
01-01-2012, 12:16 AM
Perhaps you forgot I was also called "color man"? It was more than a "silly assumption" that I would share anything in common with pony boys. It was an insult. If you are going to lecture me, then make sure you share some of that with him as well. Otherwise you are being biased.
Mr._Mutant_Man
01-01-2012, 12:24 AM
This has really gone 17 pages?
Is the color of the masks really that important?
The comic has been pretty entertaining regardless, a minor aesthetic thing isn't going to kill it for me. I do like the nostalgic feel of the multi-colored masks, but if they had kept the red it would have been fine with me too. Even as a kid, when I saw the all-red masks, I thought it was cool because it was different from what I'm used to.
For me, being more like the cartoon would still be better than what Image did. I thought the Image comics were okay, but they reeked of 90's EXTREME! They can introduce things like Bebop and Rocksteady without all the slapstick of the cartoon.
Maybe they can pull out the red masks when the other ones need to be put in the wash. :ohwell:
Andrew NDB
01-01-2012, 12:39 AM
Is the color of the masks really that important?
If nothing else, I would tend to believe this thread has proven at least that much.
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 12:43 AM
For some of us the color of the masks is more then "Gosh it was cool when we were kids". As I stated before to me the masks signify a family unit and the fact that the book was more serious. The color bandanas don't bother me when it is aimed at a younger audience.
CyberCubed
01-01-2012, 12:48 AM
Well one thing we learned from all this:
Raphael's favorite color was always red, even before mutation.
*nods*
Hermano Dyvas
01-01-2012, 08:05 AM
Perhaps you forgot I was also called "color man"? It was more than a "silly assumption" that I would share anything in common with pony boys. It was an insult. If you are going to lecture me, then make sure you share some of that with him as well. Otherwise you are being biased.
You really find "color man" insulting?
Mr._Mutant_Man
01-01-2012, 10:38 AM
If nothing else, I would tend to believe this thread has proven at least that much.
So long threads where people argue who would win between Superman and Batman show that is an important topic too?:)
I know just posting on a forum about comic books makes me the pot calling the kettle black, I just think it's funny that we fans can go on this long about some funnybooks.
Hermano Dyvas
01-01-2012, 11:00 AM
So long threads where people argue who would win between Superman and Batman show that is an important topic too?:)
I know just posting on a forum about comic books makes me the pot calling the kettle black, I just think it's funny that we fans can go on this long about some funnybooks.
I knew people cared when I started this thread but I didn't expect it to get this many comments.
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 11:30 AM
We do care because in the end for each of us little things about the series is what has made it so endearing to us. There are things that I'm sure I've enjoyed that Andrew and Mr. Mutant Man don't. But to try and make what I prefer anymore important then what they prefer is wrong.
I prefer red bandanas for the comics. Always have and always will. The color work for the cartoons and movies as they are both aimed younger and little kids have a harder time keeping things straight. Plus when it comes to selling toys viraty is better.
Samhain
01-01-2012, 11:45 AM
We do care because in the end for each of us little things about the series is what has made it so endearing to us. There are things that I'm sure I've enjoyed that Andrew and Mr. Mutant Man don't. But to try and make what I prefer anymore important then what they prefer is wrong.
I prefer red bandanas for the comics. Always have and always will. The color work for the cartoons and movies as they are both aimed younger and little kids have a harder time keeping things straight. Plus when it comes to selling toys viraty is better.
I agree. Well said.
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 12:10 PM
That was a half thought. I didn't realize what time it was when I started that and I had to run my Dad to Church. Anyway here is the other half of that thought.
As older fans we should be able to pick up on the turtles personalities. The way each is written and their speech pattern. I'll be the first to admit when I was younger and started reading Mirage it was hard because it was in black and white. But as I got older, paid more attention to how each character was written it became easy to tell the difference.
As I said though I could only imagine parents telling their kids they don't need four turtle toys with all red masks. By making them all different colors it was a brilliant marketing tool. Now parents can't tell the kids to use their imagination that it's their favorite character. For me that's what the colors represent. A way to market to a younger demographic and to suck parents into paying more money.
IDW did handle it fairly well. I was impressed. I can kind of dig the reason for it in the book. I'd like them at some point as someone else mentioned say something along the lines of "We are unique and different but we are brothers, we are family, we are a clan. From this point forward we represent that with Raph's favorite color for with him returned we are whole."
MikeandRaph87
01-01-2012, 12:20 PM
I doubt our age allows us to be able to tell them apart. I've been a fan since 2 with 20 years plus of fandom under my belt. Part of the reason I never got very interested in the b&w comics is because I couldn't tell which one was which. It helps having something that sets them apart from each other for fans and for themselves because they are not the same person but individuals.
Look,those of us who want only four different color mask and those of us who want only red mask will never change our minds for our preset reason. Since we will stick to our beliefs of what the TMNT should be and shouldn't be why bother keeping this going in circles? I want four color only just like a few others while some of you want all red. We awill enver understand or agree the opposite view so let the thread end. Lets just agree to disagree.
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 12:39 PM
Because it is a hot topic. It's something that hits a mark for some of us. If we adopted the whole stance of "lets not talk about it because we will never agree" then nothing would ever get talked about or discussed. It would get boring around here. That's the beauty of opinion.
When people are able to discuss and share their views if done well it can sway people to a new line of thinking. For me the argument that "It helps us tell them apart" seems really weak. I mean each has a very different personality from the rest, that alone is a big thing to tell them apart. The argument they need masks of different colors to tell them apart is like saying that all people of certain races are the same unless they wear different colors.
Mr._Mutant_Man
01-01-2012, 01:04 PM
The argument they need masks of different colors to tell them apart is like saying that all people of certain races are the same unless they wear different colors.
No it's not. We're talking about four characters drawn in a comic book, four humanoid turtles which are fantasy creatures, vs...real life people who have many, many physical characteristics and other traits to tell them apart.
Now there could potentially be other ways to tell the Turtles apart, if the artists wanted to put that much detail into their physical differences. Make one a little taller, give one scarring, etc. Although that would also require fans to keep all those differences straight from month to month, and having the four colors is simpler and already wired in the fan's heads.
For me, if the story is good, I don't really care about the colors. In the original comics, we knew who the different turtles were when it was important, and that's what mattered. If the all-red bandannas had stayed, I would have been fine with it. I just don't see how the multicolored bandannas ruin it for people. I really like the oval Batman logo, but it doesn't ruin Batman for me that they don't use it anymore.
I've now been drawn into the discussion and will admit to being a total hypocrite after pointing out it's been stretched out to 18 pages. :D
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 01:09 PM
It doesn't ruin it for me, it's just I prefer the all red. The only thing that could ruin TMNT for me is probably if they started having relations with each other. The bandana thing is something I'll get over. Just something visually I prefer. But in the end I have the old comics for that.
Samhain
01-01-2012, 01:50 PM
IDW def lost some ''cool points'' with the whole bandana change. If they woulda started multi-colored, then this wouldn't be such an issue. If Nick said they needed to change it, it would suck. But again, there isn't any control over that. But damn, not even the editor wanted to freakin' change the bandanas at first. But they did. I believe because Tom Waltz wanted too. I think I read that somewhere. Which, IMO, freaking blows.
That's what stings. This series started off with great sales and IDW probably thought, ''Hey, these familiar toon color will only sell MORE copies''. ''It can't hurt the sales''. Which I agree, I really don't think a bandana change like this is going to make anyone drop the book. Crappy writing on the other hand will.
But, to any asking ''Is it really that important?''. Let me just say yes. Yes it is.
Powder
01-01-2012, 02:16 PM
That's why it really grinds my gears too, man. Bait & switch. Starts dope, Tom says "Hey I can do what I want!" and boom- Rainbow gang.
Samhain
01-01-2012, 05:01 PM
Well Bobby over at the IDW forums just said that artists are free to use the all red for their variant covers if they choose to do so. I know it's not much but still nice to hear that is still an option.
Meaning that Eastman probably wanted those rainbow colors for his variant to issue #6....
Toby Barrett
01-01-2012, 05:12 PM
Bobby mentioned that Kevin was all for changing to the colored bandanas.
Samhain
01-01-2012, 05:16 PM
Bobby mentioned that Kevin was all for changing to the colored bandanas.
I could see that. Kevin has always been pretty flexible with those kind of changes. I just don't enjoy those colors mixed with his artwork. It just looks off is all. Just not used to it.
Andrew NDB
01-01-2012, 05:57 PM
Bobby mentioned that Kevin was all for changing to the colored bandanas.
Kevin is a class act and is enjoying the hell out of being a part of this at all. If Tom was pushing for the rainbow bandannas, he would be the last person to step in his -- or anyone's -- way.
Meaning that Eastman probably wanted those rainbow colors for his variant to issue #6....
Kevin doesn't color his work. And since I doubt Kevin includes notes on his inked work about, "Make sure the bandannas are in all-red" I'm sure IDW took the liberty of rainbowing them... though that's really their prerogative.
Samhain
01-01-2012, 06:18 PM
Kevin doesn't color his work. And since I doubt Kevin includes notes on his inked work about, "Make sure the bandannas are in all-red" I'm sure IDW took the liberty of rainbowing them... though that's really their prerogative.
I believe he does color some of his stuff. Or paints. He definetly did back in the day and I believe he still does apint. He recently sold his variant Christmas cover and it looked to be painted by him. I also have a Hi-res scan of his #6 variant and it is clearly painted and only has his sig on it. I may be mistaken but it sure looks like his paint work. It's in his style.
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 06:58 PM
Where can I find this variant cover for 6?
Samhain
01-01-2012, 07:05 PM
Where can I find this variant cover for 6?
Here you go, :)
http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/IDW-TMNT-06_Cover-B-Art_Eastman_rich.jpg
Cowabunga Carl
01-01-2012, 07:09 PM
Hmm now I'm wondering who that guy is. With the Turtles in the shadows the color doesn't look to bad.
Andrew NDB
01-01-2012, 07:10 PM
That looks digitally colored. That's not Kevin's work.
JonesyKitty
01-02-2012, 04:50 AM
i think itd been cool if they stuck to just the red bandanas and i'll admit i was a bit surprised when i saw it for myself but i got nothing against it. so far the IDW series kicks ass and i love it wether its true to Mirage or not :)
Metropoliskid41
01-02-2012, 09:05 AM
Hmm now I'm wondering who that guy is. With the Turtles in the shadows the color doesn't look to bad.
Yeah I'm really intrigued as well, his clothes and boots look really...armored. I'm thinking maybe a Guardian or maybe a lab tech escaping from Stockman's lab with some sort of experimental suit.
I really can't wait for this to get here, we got kinda spoiled with #5 & Mikey shipping back to back weeks :trazz:
Donnie
01-02-2012, 02:45 PM
I really can't wait for this to get here, we got kinda spoiled with #5 & Mikey shipping back to back weeks :trazz:
Totally! Why is Donnie not slated until Feb.? :(
Coola Yagami
01-02-2012, 03:44 PM
Yeah I'm really intrigued as well, his clothes and boots look really...armored. I'm thinking maybe a Guardian or maybe a lab tech escaping from Stockman's lab with some sort of experimental suit.
I really can't wait for this to get here, we got kinda spoiled with #5 & Mikey shipping back to back weeks :trazz:
I'm almost 100% convinced the guy on the cover is General Krang. I mean, c'mon, he almost looks like the android body wearing a German/Russian general outfit....
Matches Malone
01-02-2012, 03:48 PM
I'm almost 100% convinced the guy on the cover is General Krang. I mean, c'mon, he almost looks like the android body wearing a German/Russian general outfit....
They're talking about the guy on the #6 Eastman cover... are you sure you're not thinking about the general looking guy on the #7 Duncan cover?
Andrew NDB
01-02-2012, 03:49 PM
Yeah I'm really intrigued as well, his clothes and boots look really...armored. I'm thinking maybe a Guardian or maybe a lab tech escaping from Stockman's lab with some sort of experimental suit.
I really can't wait for this to get here, we got kinda spoiled with #5 & Mikey shipping back to back weeks :trazz:
I'm almost 100% convinced the guy on the cover is General Krang. I mean, c'mon, he almost looks like the android body wearing a German/Russian general outfit....
Yeah, I didn't even think it was a question of whether that is or isn't General Krang on that cover.
Coola Yagami
01-02-2012, 05:43 PM
Yeah, I didn't even think it was a question of whether that is or isn't General Krang on that cover.
oops sorry. i assume it's the cover with the floating baxter/april/hob heads?
Hermano Dyvas
01-03-2012, 04:07 PM
I'm almost 100% convinced the guy on the cover is General Krang. I mean, c'mon, he almost looks like the android body wearing a German/Russian general outfit....
I thought I was crazy recognising the old android body in that drawing, glad I wasn't the only one!
MikeandRaph87
01-03-2012, 04:15 PM
I think we would be more surprised if it turns out General Krang is an actual human or some twist like Bishop opposed to an evil utrom.
CyberCubed
01-03-2012, 04:18 PM
Considering they're blatantly going the old-toon route especially with Bebop/Rocksteady wanting to be mutants, I am sure Krang is...Krang.
MikeandRaph87
01-03-2012, 04:48 PM
Considering they're blatantly going the old-toon route especially with Bebop/Rocksteady wanting to be mutants, I am sure Krang is...Krang.
One thing is for certain in the world of fiction and that is you never know. I hope they add many elements of the original cartoon as that is what I enjoy being primarily a fan of other media and gets me interested in this series. Yes, I know its not too popular among fans primarily of the comics,but its something I want to see.
Jester
01-14-2012, 12:36 AM
I know I'm late to the game, but I figured I'd chime in about the multicolored bandanas...
I'm not a fan. I know it may seem odd coming from someone who's always given Andrew grief for his Mirage purist views, but I feel that it's a good way of distinguishing who the audience intended to be.
The more kid-centered media - Multicolored Masks
The media intended for teens and adults - Red Masks.
Seems odd to me to start in all red and move to the colored ones. I like red bandanas in the comics...well save Archie, but that made sense as it was a spin off of the Fred Wolf series.
Have we ever been told if the color coded masks was a Viacom mandate?
Powder
01-14-2012, 03:46 AM
Have we ever been told if the color coded masks was a Viacom mandate?
To put it as bluntly as I can, Tom did it simply because he could.
Viacom didn't care either way. So yeah, knife in the back.
Jester
01-14-2012, 03:53 AM
To put it as bluntly as I can, Tom did it simply because he could.
Viacom didn't care either way. So yeah, knife in the back.
Well that sucks.
oldmanwinters
01-14-2012, 08:20 AM
Ya'll might hate me for this, but up to this point I've thought that the IDW turtles look a little bland, visually speaking. The only thing about them that attracts the attention of my eyes are their enormous teeth.
So all that to say... yeah, I'm gonna like having colored bandanas to give the book a little more pizazz and to draw my attention back to their eyes and away from their teeth.
CyberCubed
01-14-2012, 10:32 AM
Dan Duncan's style does make them all look too similar.
Donnie
01-14-2012, 10:52 AM
Ya'll might hate me for this, but up to this point I've thought that the IDW turtles look a little bland, visually speaking. The only thing about them that attracts the attention of my eyes are their enormous teeth.
So all that to say... yeah, I'm gonna like having colored bandanas to give the book a little more pizazz and to draw my attention back to their eyes and away from their teeth.
The man brings up a very valid point. They DID all look very similar. The colors + the different skin tones makes it more visually appealing. Those grills were the focal points...now the masks can be.
Samhain
01-14-2012, 01:27 PM
The man brings up a very valid point. They DID all look very similar. The colors + the different skin tones makes it more visually appealing. Those grills were the focal points...now the masks can be.
Again, are we children? Do we really need pretty colors to make it better and more appealing?:ohwell:
Toby Barrett
01-14-2012, 02:22 PM
Only children are allowed to enjoy various designs and colors?
Again, are we children? Do we really need pretty colors to make it better and more appealing?:ohwell:
They all have distinct individual personality, different weapon, different look, so why not have a different color mask as long as it works?
Samhain
01-14-2012, 02:38 PM
They all have distinct individual personality, different weapon, different look, so why not have a different color mask as long as it works?
Wow, you just listed a bunch of reasons why we DON'T need those colored bandanas. Good job.
Donnie
01-14-2012, 02:48 PM
Again, are we children? Do we really need pretty colors to make it better and more appealing?:ohwell:
Why does liking the colors make one a child? Although I'll admit I'm pretty childlike. :D
I was just agreeing with oldmanwinters in that Duncan's TMNT all look really, really similar. The colored bandanas I think work for IDW's TMNT.
Matches Malone
01-14-2012, 03:16 PM
Again, are we children? Do we really need pretty colors to make it better and more appealing?:ohwell:
Are you saying a person's preference for colors is unnecessary? I thought people had opinions because they just have them, not out of a "need" to have the "correct" one.
Samhain
01-14-2012, 03:19 PM
I was simply stating that MOST adults don't need different colors to make things more appealing or interesting. And how the colors were created to appeal to children.
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2012, 03:28 PM
Where do get the idea "MOST" do? The mask is the best indicator of who is who and its established everywhere in except Mirage as the status quo. Peter and Kevin also have no problem with it. I like it better and need it for ID. Its become who the TMNT are.:tsmile:
Matches Malone
01-14-2012, 03:36 PM
I was simply stating that MOST adults don't need different colors to make things more appealing or interesting. And how the colors were created to appeal to children.
It's true that appeal to children was probably a factor in the decision to give the turtles different colored masks, but I don't think that means the colors themselves are inherently kiddy, unless you are disavowing liking all colors ever, which, of course you aren't.
I don't think most here are claiming that the turtles are completely unappealing or interesting without different colored masks, but that they simply find them more appealing and prefer it. There are plenty of good reasons to support the all-red masks (which I do, by the way), but you simply can't argue that liking the way the colored masks look better is an invalid point. What "most" adults like or don't like has absolutely no, and should not have any, bearing on the validity of what any individual likes. You'll just have to accept that people can like whatever they want, even if you think it's kiddy.
Matches Malone
01-14-2012, 08:48 PM
Just to clarify, in the decision to give them colored masks, I was referring to the Fred Wolf cartoon when they very first introduced the idea and not the IDW comic. Don't think appeal to kids had any factor for IDW's decision since it is apparent they are dedicated to doing mature gritty stories probably not best suited for young children.
Andrew NDB
01-15-2012, 12:27 AM
I've decided to make a video about this.
Jester
01-15-2012, 12:42 AM
I've decided to make a video about this.
Really? This'll be interesting.
Andrew NDB
01-15-2012, 12:48 AM
Really? This'll be interesting.
Stay tuned, buddy.
Jester
01-15-2012, 12:58 AM
Stay tuned, buddy.
Oh I will.
Is it sad there's almost a Technodrome Civil War...and it's all about cloth strips with eye holes? Quick someone make the "I'm with colored masks!" and "I'm with all red!" signature banners. :P
Donnie
01-15-2012, 01:09 AM
Oh I will.
Is it sad there's almost a Technodrome Civil War...and it's all about cloth strips with eye holes? Quick someone make the "I'm with colored masks!" and "I'm with all red!" signature banners. :P
:lol: Team Color and Team Red, haha that's great!
Andrew NDB
01-15-2012, 01:20 AM
:lol: Team Color
Now that's being charitable. Why not "Team Rainbow"? ;)
LEOTMNT
01-15-2012, 01:33 AM
i must say in my youth i was always more of a fan of the colors for such reasons as visual attraction and easy association sure, along with just general individuality. however, when i got older i appreciated the mature, more dark aspect of all red, and the mirage line in which they mainly covered are my favorite. that said i couldn't be happier with how IDW handled the situation and the reasoning behind it, i was sad to see them go to color but shall not start any civil war on the subject!! colors can kick ass! to each his own and to themselves the victory is apparent. and donnie i fear a name change is eminent...
Donnie
01-15-2012, 01:48 AM
and donnie i fear a name change is eminent...
;)
(more characters)
marcelangelo
01-15-2012, 06:36 AM
I don't get it....name change?I know it was adressed at donnie only but I still wonder what that was all about...
Jester
01-15-2012, 03:27 PM
I don't get it....name change?I know it was adressed at donnie only but I still wonder what that was all about...
Donnie is now a Mikey fan, so he plans on changing his name to match.
Samhain
01-15-2012, 07:11 PM
I've decided to make a video about this.
I look forward to watching it.
FlawedCoil82
01-15-2012, 07:51 PM
Now that's being charitable. Why not "Team Rainbow"? ;)
I'm all for it! Team Rainbow vs. Team Bland.
Donnie
01-15-2012, 07:59 PM
I'm all for it! Team Rainbow vs. Team Bland.
:lol: Oooooooh!
Samhain
01-15-2012, 08:41 PM
Oh I will.
Is it sad there's almost a Technodrome Civil War...and it's all about cloth strips with eye holes? Quick someone make the "I'm with colored masks!" and "I'm with all red!" signature banners. :P
I'd wear one proudly if someone makes it.:)
I'm all for it! Team Rainbow vs. Team Bland.
Mighty Morphin Ranger turtles vs NINJA turtles.:D
Donnie
01-15-2012, 09:01 PM
I'd wear one proudly if someone makes it.:)
Honestly it would be cool to see how many fans went to each side! I'm just worried it'll turn all nasty and that wouldn't be cool. At the end of the day, we all love the Turtles and are excited that the Turtles are back in comic form.
MikeandRaph87
01-15-2012, 09:03 PM
Honestly it would be cool to see how many fans went to each side! I'm just worried it'll turn all nasty and that wouldn't be cool. At the end of the day, we all love the Turtles and are excited that the Turtles are back in comic form.
Maybe we should have groups formed opposed to banners? That might be interesting and could be more civil. A poster who thinks the opposing view just reads what the other groups says amongst itself and respects it with no arguements? Its just an idea.
Jester
01-15-2012, 09:05 PM
Honestly it would be cool to see how many fans went to each side! I'm just worried it'll turn all nasty and that wouldn't be cool. At the end of the day, we all love the Turtles and are excited that the Turtles are back in comic form.
I guess we could build a poll or something.
[/Pedro]
Sorry....watching the new Napoleon Dynamite series.
Archon_Turtle
01-15-2012, 09:09 PM
Can we have banners that say "I'm with either because I'm not a big ol' douche" ?
Samhain
01-15-2012, 09:11 PM
Can we have banners that say "I'm with either because I'm not a big ol' douche" ?
But, but, you don't need a banner for that..;)
Donnie
01-15-2012, 09:16 PM
Can we have banners that say "I'm with either because I'm not a big ol' douche" ?
I think it would just be cool to see the numbers cause we all kind of know each other in an internet-kinda-way, in my opinion it would just be in friendly fun, I'm personally not looking to debate or anything. This thread has enough of that!
Metropoliskid41
01-16-2012, 07:38 AM
I think its a bad idea and would lead to some heated arguments. This happened during the super stupid "Faction Wars" over at TFANS (Trans Formers forums) in 2004. It really brought out the worst in everyone. It only takes one person to cross the line and something really stupid that sets off everyone else into an all out whiney bitch fest. I'd rather not see that happen here at these great boards.
Powder
01-16-2012, 08:30 AM
I think it would just be cool to see the numbers cause we all kind of know each other in an internet-kinda-way, in my opinion it would just be in friendly fun, I'm personally not looking to debate or anything. This thread has enough of that!
Consider it a done deal... :tgrin:
Toby Barrett
01-16-2012, 09:46 AM
Pretty nifty.
Donnie
01-16-2012, 10:17 AM
Consider it a done deal... :tgrin:
Pretty nifty.
Ha! Nice. I think my banner is already testament to which I prefer. :D
Hermano Dyvas
01-16-2012, 02:12 PM
Go team red! :D
I wonder if Tom Waltz is still reading this thread.
I wonder if he's surprised at how alive this issue about the colors is.
MikeandRaph87
01-16-2012, 03:25 PM
Go team red! :D
I wonder if Tom Waltz is still reading this thread.
I wonder if he's surprised at how alive this issue about the colors is.
I know I am. I didn't know people perferred red before this thread. If anything it has been enlightening and it also shows how much we all love the turtles regardless of the mask color. Well, go team four different colors!:tgrin:
FlawedCoil82
01-16-2012, 08:50 PM
Unfortunately I can't figure out how to make my own custom banner. But consider me as "team rainbow".
Samhain
01-16-2012, 08:51 PM
I'm all set!:D
Toby Barrett
01-16-2012, 10:36 PM
As am I! Found an even better image.
CyberCubed
01-16-2012, 10:50 PM
One day I wish the Turtles would wear a green bandana just to see if it sticks out at all from their skin.
FlawedCoil82
01-16-2012, 10:51 PM
That image is dark. I could barely tell which one they were. Has anyone ever done a poll in the General TMNT Discussion section for this topic? That way it'd be unbiased by only being in the comic discussion section (since most comic readers started with red). That way the overall fandom could be polled.
CyberCubed
01-16-2012, 10:55 PM
That image is dark. I could barely tell which one they were. Has anyone ever done a poll in the General TMNT Discussion section for this topic? That way it'd be unbiased by only being in the comic discussion section (since most comic readers started with red). That way the overall fandom could be polled.
Virtually all the same people visit the general discussion as the comic discussion.
Also probably less than 5% of the people here started reading the comics before the original cartoon.
Jester
01-16-2012, 11:11 PM
That image is dark. I could barely tell which one they were. Has anyone ever done a poll in the General TMNT Discussion section for this topic? That way it'd be unbiased by only being in the comic discussion section (since most comic readers started with red). That way the overall fandom could be polled.
There's another issue at hand. It's not about wither I like the colored bandanas or the red bandanas more in everything, I just wish IDW had stayed all red. I'm not anti rainbow masks, as Andy likes to call them, but I wish the comics would have stuck with the color they've traditionally had in the comics...well aside from comics that spun off from TV series.
Andrew NDB
01-16-2012, 11:27 PM
There's a lot I would weigh in on a lot of these new posts... but all I can say has already been said in the umpteen pages.
All I can do at this point is work on the video, my last, definitive word on the matter. Promise.
Jester
01-16-2012, 11:35 PM
Just as a kind of odd addition, I posted a poll to the Technodrome Facebook group.
"Do you think IDW should have maintained the red masks or are you fine with the change to colored bandanas?"
Red Bandanas
Multi-colored Bandanas
This is a thing why...?
Donnie
01-16-2012, 11:44 PM
I'm feeling the booze a little bit in saying this but honestly, the all-red masks are boring in my humble opinion. The colors give them more personality.
Andrew NDB
01-16-2012, 11:46 PM
I'm feeling the booze a little bit in saying this but honestly, the all-red masks are boring in my humble opinion. The colors give them more personality.
I'm feeling the booze too... but colors do not a personality give -- that's called (hopefully good) writing and characterization.
Imagine Rekall, Inc. (from the Total Recall movie and the Philip K. Dick story) was real and one day you decided, "You know what, I have no personality. I want to go live the life of someone with a lot of personality" and then go in, pay the $400 or whatever to do just that... and all they do is just recreate exactly who you are already, but with the added caveat of, say, violet-colored skin.
Would this give you more personality? Of course not. It just makes you look like an a$$hole.
Jester
01-16-2012, 11:47 PM
Good characters don't need colored masks to have personality....
Man, now I'm starting to not sound like myself.
EDIT: See...totally not me...totally Andy. :D
Donnie
01-16-2012, 11:52 PM
I totally see your viewpoint Andrew, and respect it ten-fold. It's just a thought I had, it almost felt like taboo typing it but it is how I feel...but hey, I'm with ya on practically everything else. :D
Metropoliskid41
01-17-2012, 08:04 AM
I'm gonna go 3rd party here and say I'm on team black and white, as seen in my signature :trazz:
MikeandRaph87
01-17-2012, 08:19 AM
I am surprised you perfer all red mask,Jester. I thouught you were more of a big other media fan like myself.
Different color mask as neccessary for me to tell who is who without the weapons. I tried so hard to figure it out when reading some of the Tales vol.2 but kept mixing them up. With color in this series we can have the iconic four different color mask and there will be no confusion. No matter how big of a fan you are you have to admit without weapons its hard to say who is who and then when you do its a few pages in that a turtle was mixed up. We all see the TMNT in different ways. I see them with four different color of mask and they don't kill. Some think red mask show clan unity while its not the clan unity I am looking for but family and to me family does not need all red to show they are. It also makes for expression of personality and highlight that visually. So while I can enjoy TMNT with red mask as I do the 80s' Mirage stuff the red mask still bother me but at the end of the day its story quality and I think that is one thing that team multi-color, red team, team whatever can agree on. I also, think we can understand each other stances even if we don't agree or see the turtles that way in our definition of them in our personal mindset.
MikeandRaph87
01-17-2012, 08:23 AM
I'm gonna go 3rd party here and say I'm on team black and white, as seen in my signature :trazz:
"Remind me to drop a line to Raph Nadar!" He may be the SAFE alternative choice. :tlol:
Andrew NDB
01-17-2012, 03:43 PM
Different color mask as neccessary for me to tell who is who
I also, think we can understand each other stances
And handicaps.
Matches Malone
01-17-2012, 03:54 PM
This might be controversial, but I actually ended up liking Image's route the most. I thought scarring Raph and turning Donnie into a cyborg was inspired. As I've said, I do like the idea of giving the turtles more visual distinctions, though it's not necessary.
Sure, Donnie's cyborg design should probably be tweaked, but the idea works with me. Leo losing his hand was unnecessarily, especially since his ninjaken straps work well enough as a visual distinction. Raph looked cool with the eye patch, but Casey's mask was just too goofy. And I like the idea that Michelangelo remained untouched. But, I understand not everyone thinks that looks or is cool, so to each his own. I know this is about mask colors, but I just thought I'd throw this in since it's semi-related.
Hermano Dyvas
01-17-2012, 04:08 PM
This might be controversial, but I actually ended up liking Image's route the most. I thought scarring Raph and turning Donnie into a cyborg was inspired. As I've said, I do like the idea of giving the turtles more visual distinctions, though it's not necessary.
Cyborg Donnie was too much for me, scarface Raph and Skywalker Leo I could handle. But I rather they don't get maimed in such exagerated ways, at least not permantly.
MikeandRaph87
01-17-2012, 04:08 PM
Give it a break, Andrew. I know your a Mirage purist and we are opposite ends of die-hard fandom,but it is hard to tell them apart maybe not to you but it is to others.
I can see your stance as well Matches even though I disagree. I like to have intact turtles each with his own mask color. Its what I am trying to say in that we all love the Ninja Turtles but each have different beliefs of how they should be. I will lean more Archie and other media. Some like Andrew towards the Mirage roots while you are more of Image approach. Its the blessing and the curse of so many versions of the same basic formula. I think its a good thing. It shows our passion for the Ninja Turtles and at the end of the day we all enjoy seeing further project with the green team!:tcool:
Matches Malone
01-17-2012, 04:14 PM
Cyborg Donnie was too much for me, scarface Raph and Skywalker Leo I could handle. But I rather they don't get maimed in such exagerated ways, at least not permantly.
I can see your stance as well Matches even though I disagree. I like to have intact turtles each with his own mask color. Its what I am trying to say in that we all love the Ninja Turtles but each have different beliefs of how they should be. I will lean more Archie and other media. Some like Andrew towards the Mirage roots while you are more of Image approach. Its the blessing and the curse of so many versions of the same basic formula. I think its a good thing. It shows our passion for the Ninja Turtles and at the end of the day we all enjoy seeing further project with the green team!:tcool:
Oh, I definitely lean almost entirely on Mirage. I was just saying that I liked the "idea" of what Image was attempting in terms of visual design. Perhaps they could have handled it a bit more subtly instead of all at once. And maybe Don could build some kind of armor instead of being a straight cyborg, so it's not just a matter of maiming our favorite characters :) Like I said, Don utilizing some kind of technology that becomes a permanent part of his design seems pretty natural to me as well as Raph getting scarred in battle, since he can come off as the more battle-hardened turtle.
I love the original Mirage turtles and wouldn't necessarily want the turtles to start off with the Image designs right off the bat, but at the time it was introduced, it seemed like a very natural development (even if not introduced quite as naturally).
And I agree with you, Mikeandraph87, I'm always in favor of respecting other people's opinions and preferences. That's why even though I would prefer all red, I understand people have different tastes. Some may feel they have better reasoning, which they may, but in the end, we're all turtle fans.
Samhain
01-17-2012, 04:21 PM
Give it a break, Andrew. I know your a Mirage purist and we are opposite ends of die-hard fandom,but it is hard to tell them apart maybe not to you but it is to others.
Dude, if you read the books for a little bit you can tell who's who just by facial expressions and the way they write the turtles speech. And maybe for some people that is difficult to pick up on. But most people I know have little trouble knowing what turtle is talking after they read a few issues and picked up on each of their characteristics.
But a question worth answering is are people happy they made the bandana switch because they couldn't tell them apart or is it because they are old toon fanboys and don't agree with the bandana colors the creators gave them? Source is law.
Donnie
01-17-2012, 07:25 PM
But a question worth answering is are people happy they made the bandana switch because they couldn't tell them apart or is it because they are old toon fanboys and don't agree with the bandana colors the creators gave them? Source is law.
"Source is law" is a bogus statement, dude. One that lets no room for change or inspiration for anybody but the creators. IDW has come in just a few issues very close to rivaling Mirage, in my opinion. I'm not an old toon fanboy at all, it's my least favorite incarnation of TMNT, and I prefer the colored masks. I don't dislike all-red. Just prefer colored. Maybe some prefer it because they favor the OT best, but you can't lump all of us who like the colors in with that.
Jester
01-17-2012, 10:09 PM
I am surprised you perfer all red mask,Jester. I thouught you were more of a big other media fan like myself.
In the comics, yeah I do prefer the red bandanas. That's all. Other media, bring on the colors, but I like the comics (save ones based on series where they had colored bandanas) to be red. That and the in continuity reason was pretty weak.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.