PDA

View Full Version : Supposedly Someone Who Has Read The Script Had This To Say About It


Pages : 1 [2]

Donnie
08-27-2012, 03:40 PM
Although I think the script is an abomination of the TMNT franchise, I would be slightly assuaged if the whole "Shrader" thing was worked out. Just make him The Shredder, and make him face the Turtles.

Sophie Campbell
08-27-2012, 03:41 PM
The dangerous thing is if its intensely profitable garbage. If that's the case, then we could see corporate mandate forcing changes from the movie onto the IDW series and the Nickelodeon cartoon. Bumblebee being mute has become cannon across all current Transformers cartoons and video games, for example.

just don't bother with the new post-changes stuff, then. be content with the existing good material, that stuff will never change.

Xav
08-27-2012, 03:55 PM
A life. Get one.Coming from a man posting on a forum for a 80's children's cartoon.

Hey could someone send me a downloadable version of the script?

The Stryker
08-27-2012, 04:24 PM
Coming from a man posting on a forum for a 80's children's cartoon.

Hey could someone send me a downloadable version of the script?

Black slaves once posted on forums you know and they weren't going on about how they got a 'victory' over something that had nothing to do with them.

Spitfire
08-27-2012, 06:13 PM
just don't bother with the new post-changes stuff, then. be content with the existing good material, that stuff will never change.

Opinions but that's not acceptable to me. Yes the good will always be there but that hardly excuses the bad. "If you don't like it ignore it." is good in theory but why should I be denied new good TMNT content? As a life long fan I'd like to enjoy what's being made now as well. As great as the old stuff is eventually you've read/watched it so many times it loses it's punch. Am I to just accept I will never be wowed again or is it really too much to ask that they should put forth effort to please new and old fans alike?

Xav
08-27-2012, 06:21 PM
Black slaves once posted on forums you know and they weren't going on about how they got a 'victory' over something that had nothing to do with them.I have no idea what the hell your talking about.

sgtfbomb
08-27-2012, 06:29 PM
I have no idea what the hell you're talking about.

He's just going for shock value, I'm sure, all just to say that making a big deal about a movie that has not only been put on hold, but hasn't even been cast yet is a bit pointless.

Studios do want profits, but they also want people to like their movies. Opening weekend is a major thing, but they want people to keep coming back to see it. And, it should be noted that it wasn't just TMNT fans making a massive deal about the "alien" thing, it was "average joes" too. At the very least, they will take the negative attention that got- and yes, it went beyond just fan sites and forums- into consideration, whether or not they it is kept in the film, which it probably will. Nobody wants to make a bad film (except Uwe Boll, and probably Troma). But, no, fans aren't usually the first people they have in mind for these things. They want it to have broad appeal, which doesn't have much to do with the liberties taken to the source material, but just making a larger than life action film that most people will want to see.

The Stryker
08-27-2012, 07:05 PM
I was actually giving him a stab about something he said previously but yeah you're spot on.

The movie is two years away. Two years is a long time. Especially for projects like this that always change direction about a zillion times.

TurtleMaster4
08-27-2012, 07:44 PM
when i heard it was taken down, i freaked!!!!! Why? Well, the shredder name change and such and such. I didn't even get to read the whole script!

But it is always calm after the storm.....

I have 2 theories,

1. it's legit.

2.it's a hoax inside a hoax

Let me explain.




There is no official proof from paramount.


He "says" that's what they sent him. but he could have easily typed it up. And worded it to look all official like.


He could of removed it, with out any instructions, just to create turmoil for the fans.


And three, he says peter laird sent him a letter........

no seriously, that's what he said, here, look what "peter" had to say! http://tmntnottant.blogspot.com/2012/08/peter-laird-comments-on-leaked-tant.html

do you seriously think peter would say that, he's trying to stay away from tmnt for one thing, and secondly


"It reminds me of one of the reasons I am glad to not own the property anymore... because I don't have to tear what little hair I have left out while trying to fix junk like this."

i don't think he would been that out going on the alein subject. remember what he said about it when it first came up? He tryed not to get the fans mad, and tried not to sound interested. And now he openly speaks about it like that! here, read it and refresh your memory! http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/03/few-musings-on-turtles-as-aliens.html

Also, you'd thik you would see it on his blog or something, but no.





So there is no "real" proof that it is legit........ but who knows, it could be.

I'm going to try not to focus much on this for a while, and enjoy the comic we have from IDW, and the new show coming soon. Instead as pondering on the alien subject. at least for a while.

Agent 86
08-27-2012, 08:32 PM
I'd appreciate a copy of the script by PM if possible.

It sounds like an ... interesting read.

Bob
08-27-2012, 08:33 PM
And, it should be noted that it wasn't just TMNT fans making a massive deal about the "alien" thing, it was "average joes" too. At the very least, they will take the negative attention that got- and yes, it went beyond just fan sites and forums- into consideration, whether or not they it is kept in the film, which it probably will.

I disagree. The “Average Joe” hasn’t really said much, as the vast majority probably don’t even know about all this hoo-ha. The Average Joe’s you’re referring to are people who run movie news sites and blogs and whatnot. They’re not really Average Joes, either, but just people jumping along for the ride. They exist within the same sphere as Internet fanboys. Also, and it has to be noted, there are a lot of people out there who outright hate Michael Bay, so they'll always jump at the chance to partake in a witch hunt when Bay is involved. I doubt that many of them truly care about TMNT.

By “Average Joes”, I mean the people who don’t really read movie news sites, post on forums or who know nothing of a film before watching it apart from the trailer. The kind of people that just treats going to the cinema as a night out. Those are the kinds of people that the studios are seeking to capture the attention of. And, reading the script, it really does read like the kind of film that has the potential to do well with the “Average Joes”. All the major ingredients are there.

figdonpat
08-27-2012, 08:44 PM
I've been off the grid for a few days. Any way someone could send me a link to the script too? It's been taken down from the tmntnottant blog and the associated google doc. Thanks!

cartoonistaaron
08-27-2012, 09:39 PM
I know we try to keep it clean here on the 'Drome but this was ****ing awful. This wasn't anything like revisions being made to the story, this was the whole thing being changed from the ground up. This script reads like someone tried to do to the Ninja Turtles what those idiots did with the Super Mario Bros. movie.

And I disagree that a few vocal fans didn't make a difference. There was a ton of negative press on this thing, and with all the faithful adaptations of comics lately (Spider-Man, Batman, Avengers, Judge Dredd, etc) and the terrible failure of non-faithful adaptions (Catwoman), you've got to believe the studio figured out "this thing will flop, hard." And it would have.

Col Schrader? SERIOUSLY????

n-zero
08-27-2012, 09:47 PM
Just that an army of fully trained ninjas in this day and age is silly too.



It worked pretty well here:

PgWCZvowEjY

d_osborn
08-27-2012, 09:56 PM
i actually kinda liked it. it's not what i personally would have written, nor was it my ultimateOHMYGODnerdgasm dream TMNT film, but come on... it would be a FUN movie! i can't say that much for anything else in the film franchise, aside for barron's film.

my personal opinion-- save shredder and the foot for the sequel, nix the TMNT as alien approach and go with the TCRI ooze from dimension x angle, and make april our main lens into this world, not casey. i can see why the suits don't want april as our main human protagonist, and it's BS.

anyway, you nut bars can't tell me that the first bit of the facility break-out wouldn't be a riot to see. i'll be there opening night with a belly full of deep dish, and a huge grin on my face.

sgtfbomb
08-27-2012, 10:16 PM
I disagree. The “Average Joe” hasn’t really said much, as the vast majority probably don’t even know about all this hoo-ha. The Average Joe’s you’re referring to are people who run movie news sites and blogs and whatnot. They’re not really Average Joes, either, but just people jumping along for the ride.

I'm not talking about movie blogs. I'm talking about my facebook and twitter accounts lighting up from friends, relatives, and people I 100% know aren't die hard ninja turtle fans. Even people who haven't watched Ninja Turtles since they were in grade school were making fun of it. The usual comment was "Umm.. it's called Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. "

Was it the biggest controversy ever? No, but you are really underestimating it.

The action, humor, and effects were going to be there always. No matter what was going to be written, it was going to have those "ingredients." In fact, most tentpole action films have that combination. That's pretty much a given. However, clearly the studio didn't have too much faith in what they were doing. Their problems, reportedly, weren't just nudging the budget down, but a dissatisfaction with the script itself.

Xav
08-27-2012, 10:24 PM
And three, he says peter laird sent him a letter........
[/LIST]
no seriously, that's what he said, here, look what "peter" had to say! http://tmntnottant.blogspot.com/2012/08/peter-laird-comments-on-leaked-tant.html

do you seriously think peter would say that, he's trying to stay away from tmnt for one thing, and secondly


"It reminds me of one of the reasons I am glad to not own the property anymore... because I don't have to tear what little hair I have left out while trying to fix junk like this."

i don't think he would been that out going on the alein subject. remember what he said about it when it first came up? He tryed not to get the fans mad, and tried not to sound interested. And now he openly speaks about it like that! here, read it and refresh your memory! http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/03/few-musings-on-turtles-as-aliens.html

Also, you'd thik you would see it on his blog or something, but no.He didn't say Peter sent him a letter he said someone posted a comment on Peter Laird's blog, and linked him to the TANT script and yeah it was in his blog. Peter also said this.
John, I think the script that I read is so fundamentally flawed, and -- more to the point -- so NOT a Teenage Mutant NInja Turtles movie, that trying to make piecemeal changes to it in an effort to make it into something halfway decent is probably a fool's errand.

In my opinion, the thing should just be tossed out, deliberately forgotten, and the process of generating a new script -- really a new outline, then treatment, then script -- should be started again. I have no insider knowledge of what's going on with the movie, but from the bits and pieces that have slipped out, it seems like that may be exactly what is happening.

While we're on the subject of this script... I have to say that while reading it, and especially reading the last twenty pages or so, I couldn't help but think of the brouhaha which erupted a few months back when Michael Bay was heard to say that in the upcoming movie, the Turtles would be revealed to be "from an alien race", and following that, all the mental gymnastics indulged in by people who wanted to parse his words and make it seem like "No, he didn't REALLY say they were going to be ALIENS!"… and then this script makes it way out onto the Internet, and if it is legitimate, it's painfully clear that YES, the Turtles WERE, in fact, going to be ALIENS. -- PL
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-579-may-28-2002-re.html#comment-form

The Stryker
08-27-2012, 10:54 PM
It worked pretty well here:

PgWCZvowEjY

You're talking to the wrong person if you really want to use a clip from that series to sell something.

Spitfire
08-28-2012, 12:00 AM
If you can accept 4 giant walking talking turtles and one rat you can accept an army of highly trained ninjas. Especially since this script goes one step further and also has a walking talking Rhino and warthog as well as a disembodied brain. But highly trained ninjas, those are ridiculous.

Xav
08-28-2012, 12:28 AM
Thank you. I was thinking the same thing.

CyberCubed
08-28-2012, 01:13 AM
Why did they come up with the idea to make them aliens in the first place? Seriously, what brought about that decision?

Did they seriously think alien turtles would be easier to accept than mutant turtles? Considering we all accepted them just fine 25 years ago when we were all kids...what the hell were they thinking?

Spitfire
08-28-2012, 01:35 AM
They weren't.

Antrax
08-28-2012, 01:57 AM
Could someone please PM me a link to the script? Thanks

Powder
08-28-2012, 05:13 AM
Lol, I can't believe I'm virtually the only one who thought it would make a really rad elseworld flick.

Leo656
08-28-2012, 05:38 AM
Am I to just accept I will never be wowed again or is it really too much to ask that they should put forth effort to please new and old fans alike?

1. Sadly.... YES.

2. Sadly... YES.

Furthermore, I think some people spend way too much time on the internet. Because whenever I've asked anyone in real life if they're excited or worried about the new TMNT movie - and a lot of these people are at least somewhat aware of TMNT, either as former fans or parents of fans - I've yet to hear any response other than, "They're making another TMNT movie? Seriously?"

2/3s of the "real world" don't even know the movie exists as even an idea. Makes it easy to understand why/how movie studios feel justified taking such liberties with such "well-known" properties, doesn't it? Believe it or not, MOST people don't use the internet to obsess over movies and cartoons. They tend to be boring people by and large, but they don't live in caves, either.

I've given up. I will see it in theaters, since I'm a fan and I've seen worse, but I now know for a fact that any TMNT movie we ever get in the future will just be swill. The fact that even one person thought this script had a shot shows exactly what the people making it were aiming for. They're not gonna change the entire thing just to please a bunch of nerds. If anything they'll show less of Dimension X and fewer "Turtle Warriors" and that'll keep the budget under control, but unless the film gets pushed back until 2015 a lot of the aborted script will still be in there. They simply don't have time to start over if they're still pretending it'll be out by 2014 (Spoiler: It won't be).

figdonpat
08-28-2012, 06:08 AM
I've been off the grid for a few days. Any way someone could send me a link to the script too? It's been taken down from the tmntnottant blog and the associated google doc. Thanks!

I've got it now. Thanks everyone! Reading it over now and I'll post my reactions later.

marcelangelo
08-28-2012, 06:34 AM
please don't call vol 4 issue 23's story garbage man!... I for one really liked it a lot..it was a creepy idea and interesting t read through and then?bam-deal with it!...there are many interesting directions to go from there I guess showing how april is dealing with that information..it'S the old song:if you don't like it doesn't make it garbage...
same is the rule for this movie.none of us knows anything specifc about it to be honest(hey-maybe the people in the studios don't even know anything for certain these days)..I was showered in cold water when I read this 'script' here..and judging from paramounts letter published on ninja pizza yesterday(?) it seems to have been associated with the real thing at least...but a movie is a product with MANY steps in betweeen and many processes before we get what we can see on the canvas in the end..and this could have easily been just one try by someone uring the way...I cannot see kevin's words and other people who were involved, their statements in cnnection with THIS being what they ended up talking about...if you listen to this podcast with the tmnt documentary guys even they are talking about what they have seen or experienced around this new incarnation...hmmm#
I just wouldn't want to see such a movie in the end...

The Stryker
08-28-2012, 06:50 AM
If you can accept 4 giant walking talking turtles and one rat you can accept an army of highly trained ninjas. Especially since this script goes one step further and also has a walking talking Rhino and warthog as well as a disembodied brain. But highly trained ninjas, those are ridiculous.

I love how everyone seems to ignore what I just said in previous posts. I called the army of ninjas silly when some other guy was saying the foot not being ninjas doesn't make sense and is unrealistic. It's all stupid!

I still prefer Robots.

Lol, I can't believe I'm virtually the only one who thought it would make a really rad elseworld flick.

I'm there too. It's kind of a neat idea for an alternate universe story but the fanbase isn't large enough to even entertain the thought of a story that isn't the same thing for the millionth time.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-28-2012, 08:05 AM
It[']s Star Wars meets Ninja Turtles.

No, its Transformers meets Ninja Turtles.

Jephael
08-28-2012, 08:30 AM
LOL, I can't believe I'm virtually the only one who thought it would make a really rad elseworld flick.

I could see it making an interesting elseworld comic book, but certainly not a feature film.

Jester
08-28-2012, 09:03 AM
I could see it making an interesting elseworld comic book, but certainly not a feature film.
IDW should totally do a Multiverse imprint....it would allow for new takes, and new stories from existing universes.

cartoonistaaron
08-28-2012, 09:07 AM
Lol, I can't believe I'm virtually the only one who thought it would make a really rad elseworld flick.

I think it'd be a fun "Elseworlds" style story, but if they're gonna dump millions into a movie, it's not the story I'd like to see. There are so many facets of the property original to the comics (and the cartoon!) that I've longed to see realized in live-action since I was a kid... I'd like to see Triceratons and a Fugitoid and maybe Rocksteady and Bebop or Krang (closer to their cartoon incarnations than in this script).

This script does give me hope, though, that my own self-published ideas are ripe for the plucking by some big-name Hollywood producer. I mean, if THIS crap can sell...

BubblyShell22
08-28-2012, 09:21 AM
Wow. That script sounds terrible, but I'm not going to panic. After all, it was rejected, so I highly doubt all of this stuff will even be in the movie. Some of it might be, but not all. Even though I've never been fond of the aliens aspect, I now think it would be an interesting twist in the universe if done the right way. Don't overreact, people. This isn't the final product. Just chill out.

Bob
08-28-2012, 10:37 AM
I think that's the thing we have to remember, it was rejected, or at least that draft (although I still it was more to with money, than anything else). Another thing we have to remember, though, is that no other writers have come on board, which means they're, at least for now, sticking with these two writers, which also means that they're working from the same skeletal structure at least. Of course, that could all change within the next couple of months.

One thing I have been thinking of, though, is that this script is from January this year. It was likely written and completed before the director was hired. When a director comes on board a project, they come on board with their own ideas, and the script usually goes through further changes as a result of that. So its very likely Jonathan Liebesman would have brought his own things to the table. So, for better or worse, the script has definitely gone through changes by now.

I do think that if there are any more delays, though, the first person to leave will be Jonathan Liebesman. After all, he wants work and he’s not going to wait around for Paramount to twiddle their thumbs. Then another writer(s) will definitely be brought on board. May 2014 is still a hell of a long way off, though, so the start of real post-production is still quite far off (by about three months). I don’t see why people think it won’t make that date. No films that are scheduled for summer 2014 have started production yet.

CyberCubed
08-28-2012, 10:47 AM
They need to trash everything though. Even stuff like Casey being the main character while the Turtles are supporting cast is an awful idea.

It's like the writers think we can't relate to mutant turtles that we need a pretty boy Casey and his hot girlfriend with huge boobs April to carry the movie.

Instead of how April and Casey should be, average looking folks.

Genesis
08-28-2012, 10:49 AM
You know, there's a way that they could put a human in the proverbial front seat of the film that I expected since the whole "Bay" thing began. The focus could potentially start on Chet. I always thought the kid should have had a larger role, and it gives them that "grounded" beginning they seemed to think was so appropriate for the first hour of Transformers.

Maybe they can skip out on the teenage drama bullcrap, this time around.

n-zero
08-28-2012, 11:01 AM
hot girlfriend with huge boobs April to carry the movie.

April having huge boobs wouldn't be a massive change.

http://bigmariosnewyorkstylepizza.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/pril-ONeil.jpg

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTKlE5xh1V5YrmNCsAk7zDUVSv_f0rrK 9auzdzxZXREe6QDvota&t=1

Donnie
08-28-2012, 11:08 AM
You know, there's a way that they could put a human in the proverbial front seat of the film that I expected since the whole "Bay" thing began. The focus could potentially start on Chet. I always thought the kid should have had a larger role, and it gives them that "grounded" beginning they seemed to think was so appropriate for the first hour of Transformers.

Maybe they can skip out on the teenage drama bullcrap, this time around.

I kind of like the idea of Chet kicking things off. Although, they COULD give that role to Casey, even. He could be the original owner and when they mutate he joins them as a vigilante. Kind of odd, but I guess it could work.

The Stryker
08-28-2012, 11:12 AM
Yeah. Making Chet a fully formed character would muck it up I think unless he replaced Casey Jones then you have the Turtles with 3 human companions.

I don't think that'll help with the 'humans the star over turtles' issue. So it's probably better to make their kid owner April or Casey to save time and character real estate. If they even use that origin that is.

Genesis
08-28-2012, 11:27 AM
I suppose that's true. April is a totally necessary character, but I don't think it would be so bad to forego Casey, at least for the first film ('cause, y'know, everything is a freakin' trilogy, these days). Maybe they can make Chet die. Who knows?

cartoonistaaron
08-28-2012, 12:32 PM
Could they maybe just focus on something that DOESN'T involve the Turtles' origin? It seems like that point has been belabored to death, between the first two movies. Let's have the Turtles on an adventure unlike anything that has been in any of the other movies. Send them to D'hoonib, where they and the alien Fugitoid are being chased by the Triceratons, the Federats, and the evil renegade Utrom warlord Krang. That's as crazy as this terrible script but it actually has basis in the source material.

I just don't think "the Turtles are actually aliens" can, in any way, be a good story. I don't care how "well told" a story it is. Kind of like "there was actually a fifth turtle, and she was a GIRL!" Some ideas are just bad.

You've got great characters, an iconic origin story, and enough source material to create a fantastic action/adventure/sci-fi movie. Trying to put your unique "spin" on it isn't necessary. I think comparisons to Transformers are not necessarily appropriate because the Transformers were giant talking robots - the Turtles are basically green humans, in how they act and how they relate to other characters. Following around giant robots for an hour and a half will strike most of the general population as odd, I think, whereas the Turtles are again, for all intents and purposes, humanoid characters and much easier to follow as the main protagonists.

I think most of the population will go see a Turtle movie based on what it looks like in the ads - so why not please the hardcore fans as well as people with fond childhood memories of the property?

Bob
08-28-2012, 01:19 PM
The action, humor, and effects were going to be there always. No matter what was going to be written, it was going to have those "ingredients." In fact, most tentpole action films have that combination. That's pretty much a given. However, clearly the studio didn't have too much faith in what they were doing. Their problems, reportedly, weren't just nudging the budget down, but a dissatisfaction with the script itself.


Although it seems like it, by “ingredients” I wasn’t just referring to action and special effects. I was also referring to the overall tone and feel of the script.

FoxZerro
08-28-2012, 01:42 PM
Is a copy of the leaked script available anywhere on line anymore? TMNT not TANT had to remove their link. Even though it sounds like a crappy script I'd still like to read it

thingy
08-28-2012, 03:48 PM
Wow I completely missed this bit of news. Doesn't sound good but the curious part of me wishes I'd had a read.

Xav
08-28-2012, 04:49 PM
April having huge boobs wouldn't be a massive change.

http://bigmariosnewyorkstylepizza.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/pril-ONeil.jpg

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTKlE5xh1V5YrmNCsAk7zDUVSv_f0rrK 9auzdzxZXREe6QDvota&t=1Man Leo looks really rapey in the bottom pic.

Drose18
08-28-2012, 04:57 PM
Haha funny ^
I think itd be wierd to make april or casey the original owners. :tconfuse:

Xav
08-28-2012, 05:29 PM
Latino Review just posted a video summary of the script.
http://latino-review.com/2012/08/28/exclusive-bays-failed-ninja-turtles-script-review/

Cryomancer
08-28-2012, 05:52 PM
That video is a pretty good summary of the script. I'm sure it's leaving out a few terrible moments that I'm already forgetting and lots of awful dialog but if you wanna know the storyline and so on and can't find it floating around, just watch that and you'll know the gist of it.

Filespit
08-28-2012, 06:05 PM
http://latino-review.com just posted a video review.
http://latino-review.com/2012/08/28/exclusive-bays-failed-ninja-turtles-script-review/
Ok, so instead of trying to get the script and read it I watched this video to get the picture. All I can say is this; I want to strangle the person who wrote this. Seriously, what is this supposed to be? Apparently not a joke as this was a real script written by a real person, who most probably got paid for it. I know the script/draft was rejected, but I don't know if I care about this movie anymore. I won't make a final judgment until I actually see some footage from the movie, but if it contains anything from this crap of a script then I will officially boycott the damn thing. I will forbid myself to go see it and I will watch Batman & Robin repeatedly for a whole week instead. This script has got nothing to do with my Ninja Turtles and I sure hope Paramount make drastical changes here. If they don't, I'll make the movie I want to see myself. Anyone with me?

Rant over.

The Stryker
08-28-2012, 06:26 PM
I'm gonna boycott this guys movie and watch that sh*tty Casey Jones fanfilm thing all week!

Why we gotta be so violent everybody?

sgtfbomb
08-28-2012, 07:32 PM
I like how that is an "exclusive" review even they are like the 5th or 6th website that I've seen tackle the leaked script. I also wouldn't call it a review, as much as a "blow by blow" report.

Bob
08-28-2012, 08:29 PM
When the first Transformers film was coming out, I used to post on the forums at Michael Bay's official website quite a lot. One of the admins of the forums, called Nelson, is actually a personal friend of Bay's who used to give updates directly from Bay's mouth. There's obviously a thread over there regarding Ninja Turtles and the script hoo-ha. He just posted this:

That draft is over 1.5 years old. It was canned. End of story.

Even though the script said 30th January 2012? Whether he's lying or not, it’s clear that, either way, work has definitely been done since this was written. They've either started from scratch (unlikely) or are making a (slight) effort to appease the fans.

sgtfbomb
08-28-2012, 08:57 PM
I don't think Nemec and Appelbaum have even been working on Ninja Turtles for even a year, if that. But the point is that it is an old draft, clearly.

bridgegrn
08-28-2012, 08:58 PM
So did the actual script get leaked? Any downloads someone can PM me?

sgtfbomb
08-28-2012, 09:04 PM
So did the actual script get leaked? Any downloads someone can PM me?

It was leaked. But it was put as a read-only document on Google Docs. As far as I know, that was the only way to read it. Paramount has since had it taken down.

Bob
08-28-2012, 09:20 PM
I don't think Nemec and Appelbaum have even been working on Ninja Turtles for even a year, if that. But the point is that it is an old draft, clearly.

Just looked it up. They were hired last June. They've been on it longer than I thought.

TurtleMaster4
08-28-2012, 09:38 PM
He didn't say Peter sent him a letter he said someone posted a comment on Peter Laird's blog, and linked him to the TANT script and yeah it was in his blog. Peter also said this.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-579-may-28-2002-re.html#comment-form

hmm, didn't see that, thanks for the info. But it still doesn't prove my point invalid. He could have written it himself, and then took it down. but i don't know if i believe that any more.

The point is, it's very likely it's legit, and also very likely it's a hoax.

But if it is legit, i think we are into something...... interesting.


Also, i didn't read the whole thing, dose could some one pm it to me or something???

thelouisguy
08-28-2012, 09:50 PM
Also, i didn't read the whole thing, dose could some one pm it to me or something???

I have a copy and will send it to you. Anyone else can PM me if they want to read it. You can also read my first thoughts on the script here:
http://www.crossovercomics.ca/frontpage/ninja-turtles-2014-script-leaked-first-thoughts/

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
08-28-2012, 10:13 PM
So it's 2 high schoolers who meet aliens and the movie's more about them than the title characters....

So in other words, it's just like the Transformer movies.

Casey as the lead is an atrocious idea...not as the lead...

I don't need an 18 year old Casey and some model (come on, even with Michael Bay producing, I would guarantee it'll be a model) playing April...aka another version of Shia and another version of Megan Fox Part Deux

I would like for, you know, the Ninja Turtles to actually be the leads of their own movie...

Kind of like what Transformer fans have been asking for 3 movies...and still never got...

So granted...maybe the script has changed...I still will not have hope for this. I had no hope for the Total Recall Remake, the Fright Night Remake, the Thing prequel aka precum, or the Elm Street Remake...and to me (MY opinion) they all sucked.

Nothing about this is even remotely interesting to me anymore, and this is from a fan of the characters...I can understand being different...but Being Different doesn't automatically make it GOOD.

And that plotline sounds like something I would see in way back then like Star Kid or Warriors of Virtue or something and I hated those...

sgtfbomb
08-28-2012, 11:26 PM
I still don't see what is so perfect by the first half of this script. It's workable, but I don't see it as perfect.

Oh wow, yeah you're right, Bob, Appelbaum and Nemec have been on it for well over a year. I didn't think it has been that long.

Spitfire
08-28-2012, 11:45 PM
I love how everyone seems to ignore what I just said in previous posts. I called the army of ninjas silly when some other guy was saying the foot not being ninjas doesn't make sense and is unrealistic. It's all stupid!
Ah I totally missed that not reading the whole thread. Touche!

I still prefer Robots.
Well yeah, robots explode! Make for good PG-13 action actually.

Xav
08-29-2012, 12:58 AM
Yeah, but you can get away with bloodless stabbings in a PG-13 movie.

Spitfire
08-29-2012, 01:44 AM
Yeah, but you can get away with bloodless stabbings in a PG-13 movie.

Eh not always. Depends on the mood the MPAA is in at the time. They're a very flawed rating system that changes their mind depending on their personal/religious/political beliefs.

Sides robots you can decapitate so robots kind of win anyways.

Xav
08-29-2012, 02:48 AM
Yeah, but robots would push the budget up. Aren't they trying to lower the budget?

The Stryker
08-29-2012, 08:45 AM
Nobody is saying that they should use robots. Just that robots would be kinda cool.

Also there are many more places to cut the budget. Creating an entire alien world is one. Half CG foot robots wouldn't be that bad in comparison.

VaughnMichael
08-29-2012, 09:48 AM
I can handle change, but these changes seem to be for the sake of change, and not to make a good story.
Sort of like everything else that's gone down since Nick bought them?
Sorry, not everything is bad..the toys have advanced a lot.
But I'm still not sold on the new show and I think the IDW comic is just ridiculous.:ohwell:
I still prefer Robots.
Yeah going with robots would work best if they're going for that old toon vibe.
I mean hell they even have Krang looking for fuel for the Technodrome.:lol:

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 11:43 AM
But I'm still not sold on the new show and I think the IDW comic is just ridiculous.:ohwell:

Virtually everything we know about the new show so far sounds great. The only thing to be worried about is how the CG animation looks in most scenes.

The IDW comics are fine, its an ultimate reboot of the Mirage material.

VaughnMichael
08-29-2012, 01:02 PM
Virtually everything we know about the new show so far sounds great. The only thing to be worried about is how the CG animation looks in most scenes.

The IDW comics are fine, its an ultimate reboot of the Mirage material.
Thank you for allowing me to have my own opinion mein führer.

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 01:06 PM
Thank you for allowing me to have my own opinion mein führer.

You've been negative about this stuff from the moment you found out the show would be in CG. If it was 2D you'd probably not be complaining about anything. Even stuff like April being a teen most people seem to be perfectly fine with now.

VaughnMichael
08-29-2012, 01:22 PM
You've been negative about this stuff from the moment you found out the show would be in CG. If it was 2D you'd probably not be complaining about anything. Even stuff like April being a teen most people seem to be perfectly fine with now.
Dude seriously you are going to try and call me out on something?
You've got a lot of damn nerve, as that's pretty much all you ever do on here is bitch and complain about everything.
I'm quite fine with the cg at this point, it's the character designs outside of the turtles that I'm not that fond of.
The comic though I just can not get into, the art is sub-par and has now gotten worse, the storyline comes off as fan-fiction, and the hell did you say Mirage? I see more Old toon references than anything (not that I mind).
I had a wait and see attitude for that and the new toon and I've got to say out of both the team for the new toon has done a much better job with the balance of everything (besides Mikey, he's still annoying as 2k3).

BubblyShell22
08-29-2012, 01:22 PM
Says the one who's gotten his panties in a bunch over this rejected script since he first saw it. You must have a pretty big wedgie by now, huh? And don't even get me STARTED on the whole thing about the 4Kids series being released on DVD.

Edit: My post was aimed at Cybercubed, not Vaughn. I was just going to post this when Vaugn's post appeared above mine. Just wanted to clarify.

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 02:22 PM
The comic though I just can not get into, the art is sub-par and has now gotten worse, the storyline comes off as fan-fiction, and the hell did you say Mirage?

By that logic anything written now can come across as fanfiction. I don't see how the IDW plots are any more fanfiction then what the 4kids or Nick writers will do.

I had a wait and see attitude for that and the new toon and I've got to say out of both the team for the new toon has done a much better job with the balance of everything (besides Mikey, he's still annoying as 2k3).

I think this Mike seems quite fun so far.

sgtfbomb
08-29-2012, 03:03 PM
And don't even get me STARTED on the whole thing about the 4Kids series being released on DVD.


What's going on with the 4kids series on DVD?

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 03:11 PM
What's going on with the 4kids series on DVD?

As of now, nothing. But 2013 will be the 10th anniversary of the 4kids show, and its possible we might see Nick start to release the series to DVD to celebrate it.

ToTheNines
08-29-2012, 03:16 PM
The more I think about this script the more I hate it. I know it's an old draft and I should get over it... but Applebaum and Nemec are such ****ing hacks!

The whole scope of the universe they tried to create is just piss poor. These turtles are 17 and haven't really done anything... they have one adventure through the course of this movie (with very little of it taking place in NY) and then they get split up at the end!

And the most sickening thing about the Col. Schrader thing is how you can tell they thought they were being SO clever. Idiots.

cartoonistaaron
08-29-2012, 03:20 PM
I drew this to make myself feel better. It's how I imagine the "real" Ninja Turtles are responding to this script.

http://home.comcast.net/~cartoonistaaron/tmntscriptreading.jpg

Donnie
08-29-2012, 03:25 PM
The more I think about this script the more I hate it. I know it's an old draft and I should get over it... but Applebaum and Nemec are such ****ing hacks!

The whole scope of the universe they tried to create is just piss poor. These turtles are 17 and haven't really done anything... they have one adventure through the course of this movie (with very little of it taking place in NY) and then they get split up at the end!

And the most sickening thing about the Col. Schrader thing is how you can tell they thought they were being SO clever. Idiots.

I agree with you 100%, Nines. F*cking idiots.

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 03:55 PM
I never understood what was so hard about making a decent TMNT movie.

Just adapt some parts of the comics like the first movie did and throw in Krang if you have to, and you'll have a decent movie.

Jephael
08-29-2012, 04:00 PM
I drew this to make myself feel better. It's how I imagine the "real" Ninja Turtles are responding to this script.

http://home.comcast.net/~cartoonistaaron/tmntscriptreading.jpg

Awesome pic, but why does Raphael look like he's got a bug up his shell over it? This is the classic toon universe, right? He should be laughing himself to death.

BubblyShell22
08-29-2012, 06:05 PM
Awesome pic. I think it's hilarious, though I agree with Jeph that Raph should be laughing.

TurtleMaster4
08-29-2012, 06:08 PM
This is a great artical, and it's what I've been saying for a while now! Read it! i'm glad some one agrees! http://screenrant.com/ninja-turtles-reboot-script-review/

Also, dose any one out there write some sorta professional scripts out there, cause i was wondering. when your explaining the scean, and it's not going to be said IN the scean, do people usaly swear stiff like hallin brass, minus the, well you know. and stuff like that, cause it seems very unprofessional when it's not in the diologe, but is in the descriptions. just curious.

TurtleMaster4
08-29-2012, 06:43 PM
well just read up to page 39, I have mixed feelings so far, but i'll continue reading it later.

saul
08-29-2012, 08:27 PM
This is a great artical, and it's what I've been saying for a while now! Read it! i'm glad some one agrees! http://screenrant.com/ninja-turtles-reboot-script-review/

Also, dose any one out there write some sorta professional scripts out there, cause i was wondering. when your explaining the scean, and it's not going to be said IN the scean, do people usaly swear stiff like hallin brass, minus the, well you know. and stuff like that, cause it seems very unprofessional when it's not in the diologe, but is in the descriptions. just curious.

The question you're asking is "why did the writers swear when describing scenes?" This isn't unheard of in screenplays. Usually the writers try to match their writing style to the attitude and tone of the movie and scene they are writing. And this script has ATTITUDE. They were going for a high-octane action movie with lots of attitude, and it shows in the writing style. Even the formatting has tons of underlining, CAPITAL LETTERS, and itallics. It's clear they were going for a PG13 rating here.

Now if they were writing a "G" or "PG" movie, that kind of swearing would be very inappropriate.

thelouisguy
08-29-2012, 08:53 PM
well just read up to page 39, I have mixed feelings so far, but i'll continue reading it later.

I know it is a long read, but if you stop yourself before (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=989965&postcount=308) page 88, you will be a lot happier :twink:

Xav
08-29-2012, 10:13 PM
Whoa, Bay himself just commented on this.
The leaked script for Ninja Turtles that different sites continue to comment on was written well before I, or anyone at Platinum Dunes, was involved with the project.

That script saw the shredder a long time ago.

This is tired, old news -- Wait for the movie!

Michael
http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/showthread.php?10567-Ninja-Turtles-Script

Roseangelo
08-29-2012, 10:24 PM
Whoa, Bay himself just commented on this.

http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/showthread.php?10567-Ninja-Turtles-Script

If what he says is true, the date and authors on the script are a lie. I don't feel reassured.

sgtfbomb
08-29-2012, 10:29 PM
Even the formatting has tons of underlining, CAPITAL LETTERS, and itallics.

Capitalizing key words is said to help boost the attention span of the reader, sort of as a tactic to keep them interested and reading. Sort of to draw the reader into things.

I've also seen profanity used in the descriptions before.

The weirdest format I've seen for a screenplay was Ghostbusters II. The character's name would be a paragraph of its own, and the next paragraph would describe what he is doing.

RAY


He is standing there with his spectrometer.

Donnie
08-29-2012, 11:27 PM
If what he says is true, the date and authors on the script are a lie. I don't feel reassured.

Maybe we'll never know. However I am a little reassured in the fact that he is publicly (basically) denouncing the script.

Roseangelo
08-29-2012, 11:31 PM
Maybe we'll never know. However I am a little reassured in the fact that he is publicly (basically) denouncing the script.

And if anyone was still doubting, he just admitted it's legit.

zkarlette
08-29-2012, 11:33 PM
So it Definetly gets worse... The crap is legit...:(

Jester
08-29-2012, 11:37 PM
Yeah, I'm sorry but that script screams "A MICHAEL BAY INVOLVED SCRIPT". I mean, it reads like a rejected Transformers movie. Heck, the plot is very close to Transformers 3 "Bring Cybertron to Earth" bit.

Cure
08-29-2012, 11:44 PM
So the script comes out. "Whine whine whine, what garbage, I hope it was canned".

The producer admits it was canned (shredded even). "Whine whine whine, it was real".

You people.

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 11:45 PM
So the script comes out. "Whine whine whine, what garbage, I hope it was canned".

The producer admits it was canned (shredded even). "Whine whine whine, it was real".

You people.

Probably because they're likely not going to abandon the "TMNT as aliens," thing, something people still hate the most.

zkarlette
08-29-2012, 11:52 PM
I'm not whining about it getting canned and shredded,I'm glad it got canned hopefully we'll get something better, at this rate I just wish they don't decide to throw away the hole project.

CyberCubed
08-29-2012, 11:54 PM
I'm not whining about it getting canned and shredded,I'm glad it got canned hopefully we'll get something better, at this rate I just wish they don't decide to throw away the hole project.

I'd rather have no new TMNT movie at all than an awful one that will stick for years to come.

We were able to live down The Next Mutation because the show was so short-lived and very few watched it in its original run, but something as big as a theatrical movie will leave a much bigger impact.

Powder
08-30-2012, 01:22 AM
I'm not whining about it getting canned and shredded

What you did there, albeit accidentally, I see it.

Xav
08-30-2012, 01:33 AM
More like Schraded.

Walkabout
08-30-2012, 02:03 AM
More like Schraded.

Oh the humanity :lol:

cartoonistaaron
08-30-2012, 02:54 AM
I'm not whining about it getting canned and shredded,I'm glad it got canned hopefully we'll get something better, at this rate I just wish they don't decide to throw away the hole project.

TMNT is far too valuable a property to just abandon plans for a movie. Viacom didn't "shell out" (yuk yuk) $60 million for the Ninja Turtles to not turn it into a movie. The cartoon is all well and good but they won't see the kind of cash flow from a cartoon that a successful movie could give them.

(Though not if it involves Col Schrader...)

Nelson
08-30-2012, 04:10 AM
Can someone please send me this aberration? Thanks in advance.

chrisdude
08-30-2012, 06:10 AM
I tend to think this whole "leaked script" is a hoax. If it does exist in full, I think its weird that everybody seems to have lost it. And the excerpts read like an actual parody of Michael Bay.

I'm not at all convinced that it's real.

PAAATE
08-30-2012, 06:38 AM
I tend to think this whole "leaked script" is a hoax. If it does exist in full, I think its weird that everybody seems to have lost it. And the excerpts read like an actual parody of Michael Bay.

I'm not at all convinced that it's real.

Bay totally paid you off! :P

No no, it's real. Everything points towards it being real.

chrisdude
08-30-2012, 06:46 AM
Bay totally paid you off! :P

No no, it's real. Everything points towards it being real.I dunno. Every article about it seems to point to TMNT NOT TANT (who claims they had to pull the script because of a cease and desist order that they could've just typed up, themselves) and Latino Review, who made that video review that's going around, but the writer says in his own article that he doesn't have the script in his possession.

To my knowledge, no one actually has the script. It's as if this thing hit the web and nobody downloaded it.

I think it's a hoax, and the excerpts are manufactured. And TMNT NOT TANT, a blog that appears to have had near-zero followers before this, may be behind it.

EDIT________________
Seems like dudes here are far more in the loop than I, and I probably have words to eat. I guess it's good I showed up.

ZariusTwo
08-30-2012, 10:28 AM
The TANT script is real. If some are saying it's fake, the same can be said of many other aborted film scripts that have cropped up online like Superman Lives etc, when we all know there real.

Sometimes you just have to accept s*it like this happens and Hollywood IS that stupid.

Bob
08-30-2012, 10:33 AM
"That script saw the shredder a long time ago." I must admit, I do like that. :lol:

I don't believe him. Why has it got the 30th January date, and the two writers’ names who we know are writing the script? Still, at least it proves that the finished film will probably be quite a bit different to that script. But yeah, I doubt the alien angle will be dropped. Face it, it’s in there. It wasn't even the worst thing about the script, anyway. I actually thought the whole alien revelation was handled okay. My main gripe was with Shredder and the Foot. Hopefully that's one of the things that's been altered for the better.

TurtleMaster4
08-30-2012, 02:30 PM
While i've said that it might be false (and was wrong) i never admitted that it was. I wish it was though. I'm just glad it saw the shredder. but dose that mean the completely trashed the whole script?

When Michael bay first hinted about the alien concept, was that still when the iron man writers were on, (it was the iron man writers right?) or was it the guys on board now? If it was the iron man writers, the whole script could have been completely trashed right.

I'm just wondering if this is what they wrote, or what the mission impossible (new guys) wrote?

The question still remains.... why won't they come out clean and say if they are or are not going to be aliens still, if they aren't in the next script? Is it more of a marketing technique, or is it a dark secret that lies within, the scripts?

thelouisguy
08-30-2012, 02:54 PM
I dunno. Every article about it seems to point to TMNT NOT TANT (who claims they had to pull the script because of a cease and desist order that they could've just typed up, themselves) and Latino Review, who made that video review that's going around, but the writer says in his own article that he doesn't have the script in his possession.

To my knowledge, no one actually has the script. It's as if this thing hit the web and nobody downloaded it.

I think it's a hoax, and the excerpts are manufactured. And TMNT NOT TANT, a blog that appears to have had near-zero followers before this, may be behind it.

EDIT________________
Seems like dudes here are far more in the loop than I, and I probably have words to eat. I guess it's good I showed up.

The script is real. I have read it. Read my thoughts on it here:
http://www.crossovercomics.ca/frontpage/ninja-turtles-2014-script-leaked-first-thoughts/

PM me if you want a copy of the script.

MikeandRaph87
08-30-2012, 02:55 PM
I am sure everyone can guess what Peter Laird had to say...
http://screenrant.com/ninja-turtles-movie-script-peter-laird/


If the turtles are mutants instead of aliens everything else would be fine. The next year as new information becomes avaialble it should be atleast interesting to read.

Xav
08-30-2012, 05:21 PM
When Michael bay first hinted about the alien concept, was that still when the iron man writers were on, (it was the iron man writers right?) or was it the guys on board now? If it was the iron man writers, the whole script could have been completely trashed right.

I'm just wondering if this is what they wrote, or what the mission impossible (new guys) wrote?This is what the MI4 guys wrote, and Bay hinted at the Turtles being aliens less than two months after this script is dated.

Nick Kell
08-30-2012, 09:08 PM
My biggest problem with this proposed script is the reliance on Casey. That didn't really work for Transformers and it's less necessary here because history has already proven that people will buy into the Turtles as main characters. I can maybe understand the hesitance in having giant robots lead your story without any human characters for non-fans to relate to, but the Turtles are essentially human leads - just green and without pants.

I have less of a problem with Shredder's portrayal here. Let's not forget Super Shredder in Secret of the Ooze. He basically turned into a spikey monster. Although it does smack of Cobra Commander in the GI Joe movie and that was an utter failure. I didn't even realize Shredder was Japanese in the original cartoon, so I don't spontaneously combust at the notion of him being American or whatever they want him to be here.

He was an alien in the 2000-era cartoon, too!

The turtles being aliens is lazy, because you can clearly still include Dimension X without the Turtles needing to be from there. The "save your real homeland" plot seems too heavy, especially considering how late that plot point seems to be introduced in the story.

I would love to see Krang rendered in a live action movie on the big screen. He's such an insane character, so unless the story is equally out there, he will see wickedly out of place. I don't mind him as a shadowy character for much of the movie, just like the SHIELD people in the Avengers. He's an anthropomorphic brain (with a speech impediment), it's probably best to minimize his screen time and maximize his impact.

Also, Rocksteady and Beebop! In a live-action film! I really hope they survive future revisions.

If you put someone on this movie with enough respect for the source material (there has to be plenty of 30-something Turtle fans writing scripts in Hollywood right now), you can salvage this.

For example, in the scene where the Turtles all choose black headbands before Casey gives them color-coded wraps, you could give them all red headbands as an homage to the original comics and have a line something along the lines of "it's too confusing with you all wearing red". It's the same idea but it ties in the history of the Turtles, which will make the true fans happy.

yagyu
08-30-2012, 09:08 PM
Just read the leaked script, man it is godawful. The turtles are aliens from dimension x who r sposed to fulfill a prophecy to stop the dictator of dimension x krang from merging our dimension and dimension x. OH and theres turtle chicks. Just terrible.

Mutant_Hero_Turtle95
08-30-2012, 10:30 PM
Can someone give me a copy of the script? I want to see this for myself.

Bob
08-31-2012, 11:17 AM
The admin at Bay's site has now posted this:

The deal with the studio was finalized this early spring, and this was the script presented to the studio at that moment. Bay & company didn't get to write their notes until such time.

All this whining is pointless since they have moved on to a new script.

Hope Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady have been kept.

The Stryker
08-31-2012, 11:21 AM
I'm guessing that bit of info is completely ignored in favor of 'I WANNA PUNCH THE WRITER' stuff in about 4 posts.

Bob
08-31-2012, 11:25 AM
TBH, I still wouldn’t expect any major differences. People shouldn’t expect the newer script to all of a sudden be a perfect adaptation of the source material. At the end of the day, the leaked script we all read represents a very early version of what the finished film is going to be.

CyberCubed
08-31-2012, 11:31 AM
Maybe if these half-wits stopped trying to force the Turtles as aliens aspect on us and handle Shredder properly we wouldn't be complaining.

I wouldn't even be opposed to them simply making a movie based on the first 5 episodes of the OT. You could leave out the Neutrinos however.

sgtfbomb
08-31-2012, 04:27 PM
There's no telling what kind of script this is now. Look Cyber, do you like Star Wars? George Lucas went through some crazy ideas, some of them were written into screenplays, and some of them weren't. The screenplays went through several extreme variations until it finally took the shape of what would be Star Wars (of "A New Hope" as it was re-titled in 1980). Even as the fourth draft was fairly close to what was in the film, it went through a revised draft, with Willard Huyk and Gloria Katz spicing up the dialogue, which had been fairly flat and unexciting, sort of like it was in the prequels. The point is you can't judge a final product by its earlier designs.

Bob
08-31-2012, 04:53 PM
This is getting interesting. Bay just posted this:

To end this stupid merry go round and explain the math...Yes we signed on two years ago to Turtles, but with no deal in place. Deal completed towards end of last year. And yes, thats how long deals sometimes take. So no work was done on the script. Blame Paramount, not us for the first draft.

Still doesn't explain the date on the script and why the writers names on the script are the two writers who we know are working on the script. Also confirms that it was a first draft, though. Still, it was Bay himself who first disclosed the alien angle, so I just find it hard to believe that aspect has been dropped altogether.

chrisdude
08-31-2012, 05:01 PM
This is getting interesting. Bay just posted this:



Still doesn't explain the date on the script and why the writers names on the script are the two writers who we know are working on the script. Also confirms that it was a first draft, though. Still, it was Bay himself who first disclosed the alien angle, so I just find it hard to believe that aspect has been dropped altogether.You know, if they're going to do the alien thing, they're not going to confirm it. It'd be a spoiler.

Xav
08-31-2012, 05:04 PM
The admin at Bay's site has now posted this:I couldn't find that, but I did find this post by Bay
http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/showthread.php?10567-Ninja-Turtles-Script/page2

Bob
08-31-2012, 05:49 PM
I couldn't find that, but I did find this post by Bay

http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/showthread.php?10567-Ninja-Turtles-Script/page2

Yeah, this is weird and (maybe) interesting. That post I quoted earlier from the admin has been removed from that thread. I wonder why?

Basically, this is what I think. The script is the real deal, and Bay knows it. It was done when he and the other producers from PD were on the film. I don’t believe him at all. He's just lying. It was written by the MI4 writers. However, judging by the date, it was completed before the s#itstorm struck about the whole alien thing. Also, it was clearly a first draft, anyway. Since then, though, work has obviously been done to it, probably to make it (slightly) more fan-friendly. Still, it is clearly the story they're working from. They’re not writing a whole new script, they're just revising it. That's what happens with every script, anyway. Like it or not, the Turtles are remaining aliens. I will be shocked if they come out with a whole different story, with the Turtles being Earth turtles mutated from ooze. The whole narrative would have to be altered for that to happen. There's not enough time for that, seeing as the film will be heading into pre-production fairly soon.

Roseangelo
08-31-2012, 05:53 PM
None of the comments from Bay make any sense.

Here's the history of the movie/script as I have archived:

July 9, 2009: John Fusco named writer
October 21, 2009: Nickelodeon buys TMNT, Paramount attached to project
May 27, 2010: Michael Bay and Platinum Dunes attached to project
August 18, 2010: John Fusco script determined to be "not great"
August 20, 2010: Art Marcum and Matt Halloway named writers
June 7, 2011: Josh Appelbaum and Andre Nemec named writers
January 30, 2012: Date of leaked Appelbaum/Nemec script
March 13, 2012: Jonathan Liebesman named director

Work was definitely done on the script during Bay's tenure. At best this is the first draft of the Appelbaum/Nemec script, and who knows how similar it is to the previous iterations. But I still can't imagine much has changed since January.

Bob
08-31-2012, 06:53 PM
Bay is clearly being creative with the truth here. Still, at least its confirmation that the makers fully acknowledge what’s going on. I just don’t think anything major will be changed. Although first drafts often do differ quite a bit from what eventually goes before cameras.

prophecy718
09-01-2012, 06:55 AM
The admin at Bay's site has now posted this:



Hope Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady have been kept.

no surprise there about moving on to a new script


hmm, now I wonder if they purposely leaked this script to see how fans would react. Wouldn't be surprised

Xav
09-01-2012, 07:00 AM
Hope Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady have been kept.I don't know isn't four villains kinda overkill?

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 07:47 AM
Bebop and Rocksteady are more like glorified henchmen so whatever.

Jester
09-01-2012, 08:02 AM
Bebop and Rocksteady are more like glorified henchmen so whatever.
^this. 2 villains and 2 "mini-bosses"....that's what we have here.

Vivi
09-01-2012, 08:05 AM
So I read some of the script (and x'ed out of that screen quicker than I slammed twilight shut) the other day and wondered what you guys at the drome thought.

I think they should hand it to Peter Laird and get him to add his own notes, because there is a real laugh to be had there.

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 08:21 AM
I know Peter Laird's writing always makes ME laugh.

Xav
09-01-2012, 10:17 AM
^this. 2 villains and 2 "mini-bosses"....that's what we have here.I know but should we be bringing in sci-fi villains right away? The first film series waited until the second movie before Shredder got his own mutants. Mutant Bebop and Rocksteady didn't show up until the second episode of the OT, and the Turtles didn't fight Krang until the fifth. The Utroms didn't show up in the Mirage books until issue 3, hell in the 4Kids series we didn't see the Utroms in their true forms until episode 26.

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 10:28 AM
It's a new movie. Why should they worry about what the other things did?

If the movie really is more of adaptation of the OT, Bebop and Rocksteady being absent would be weird.

Xav
09-01-2012, 03:18 PM
But it's not really an adaptation of the OT, the Turtles and Splinter weren't aliens, Casey and April weren't 18, Shredder wasn't an alien called Schrader, and the Foot wasn't an black-ops units. Plus there's the fact that the Shredder changes henchmen all the time. It would be weird if Shredder didn't get some original henchmen.

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 04:01 PM
Oy. Well its a loose adaptation then using characters and themes from the OT. Bebop and Rocksteady are still popular characters. You continue to muddy up your point by bring up nonsense. Whats the problem with using those characters?

I'd rather have the known henchmen over new lame stand-ins.

Xav
09-01-2012, 04:08 PM
It's true though. It's an unwritten rule that Shredder's henchmen must keep changing.

Bob
09-01-2012, 04:10 PM
Oy. Well its a loose adaptation then using characters and themes from the OT. Bebop and Rocksteady are still popular characters.

I'd rather have the known henchmen over new lame stand-ins.

Definitely. The script certainly took more from the Fred Wolfe toons than the comics. I would definitely much rather Bebop and Rocksteady than another Secret of the Ooze debacle, where they had a perfect opportunity to use them but still didn’t. Plus, Bebop and Rocksteady, design-wise, would be much more striking than just mere “henchmen”. With motion-capture technology, they could look phenomenal. That’s one of the things that still keeps me going about the whole thing. Unnecessary changes aside, this will be unlike any TMNT film we’ve seen before, visually speaking at least.

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 04:10 PM
It's true though. It's an unwritten rule that Shredder's henchmen must keep changing.


Since when? And who cares if it is? It's a brand new movie!

Xav
09-01-2012, 04:13 PM
Whats the problem with using those characters?Well there's the fact, that when you bring in more mutants, (or aliens in this case) it makes the Turtles less unique.

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 04:22 PM
Well there's the fact, that when you bring in more mutants, (or aliens in this case) it makes the Turtles less unique.

That's not a fact at all. That's an opinion.

sgtfbomb
09-01-2012, 05:22 PM
I never really understood why people like Bebop and Rocksteady. I really don't like incompetent henchman. That cliche needs to die a painful, agonizing death. In fact, I prefer it when the villain does his own handiwork instead of sending a bunch of bumbling buffoons to do it for him.

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 06:30 PM
Yeah well that's your problem. I think it can be funny when done right. B&R are fun and nothing more. Who cares?

Xav
09-01-2012, 06:35 PM
Yeah well that's your opinion.

Toby Barrett
09-01-2012, 06:38 PM
Why is that supposed to be a legitimate answer that works perfectly fine for you, but not for Stryker?

Allio
09-01-2012, 08:53 PM
Why is that supposed to be a legitimate answer that works perfectly fine for you, but not for Stryker?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWdiuanHa7I&feature=player_detailpage#t=110s

Vivi
09-01-2012, 09:59 PM
I know Peter Laird's writing always makes ME laugh.

I'm not sure how you mean this, but yes.

Xav
09-01-2012, 11:05 PM
Why is that supposed to be a legitimate answer that works perfectly fine for you, but not for Stryker?Um, sure if you say so.

sgtfbomb
09-01-2012, 11:46 PM
Yeah well that's your problem. I think it can be funny when done right. B&R are fun and nothing more. Who cares?

Yeah, you're right. I should be more like you and not have standards. :p

The Stryker
09-01-2012, 11:51 PM
Yeah, you're right. I should be more like you and not have standards. :p

Oh. Good one.

It's not about not having standards it's about liking what I like and not getting whiny about villains in a movie for kids not being 'credible threats'.

I'm not sure how you mean this, but yes.

To clarify, I think Laird's writing is a big joke. You read Vol.4? I cried from the laughter of it all.

sgtfbomb
09-02-2012, 01:02 AM
Oh. Good one.
It's not about not having standards it's about liking what I like and not getting whiny about villains in a movie for kids not being 'credible threats'.


Chill dude, I wasn't "whining." I was giving my opinion. :roll: If you don't care about integrity in films, that's your prerogative. But back off from your condescending attitude a bit . ;)

You're being a tad over-generalized with calling the Platinum Dunes film "a kid's movie." Kids will be able to see it, but obviously this is going to be more for a broader audience. Kids, teenagers, twenty-somethings, the gamer crowd, potheads, etc. I seriously doubt the final film will be anything more or less than PG-13, and probably no more of a kid's movie than the Transformers films were.

Jester
09-02-2012, 01:16 AM
Chill dude, I wasn't "whining." I was giving my opinion. :roll: If you don't care about integrity in films, that's your prerogative. But back off from your condescending attitude a bit . ;)
http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQm0H_IrJeBcZWlpPrUPZpZyvXg5qO9n kiTWzYOfYuasZM0y3XBOQ&t=1

Dear God, I'm coming to Stryker's defense. WHAT HATH THOU WROUGHT, SGT. PROFANITY!?

sgtfbomb
09-02-2012, 01:27 AM
http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQm0H_IrJeBcZWlpPrUPZpZyvXg5qO9n kiTWzYOfYuasZM0y3XBOQ&t=1


:lol: Touche' :P

All my sarcasm aside....For what it is worth, I'm not saying Bebop and Rocksteady can't be handled well, or even that they won't be handled well. I just never cared for them. I look back at OT with nostalgia. It was was great when I was 6 years old, but even back then, I was more of a fan of the movies - the first movie- than the series. I tried watching it again a few years ago, but I couldn't get past the first few episodes. My god, that show was bad, and to be fair, that's probably why I don't look back fondly on Bebop, Rocksteady, and Krang.

Xav
09-02-2012, 02:00 PM
It's not about not having standards it's about liking what I like and not getting whiny about villains in a movie for kids not being 'credible threats'.No sorry dude, I don't have to like what you like. I have a mind of my own.

The Stryker
09-02-2012, 02:27 PM
I didn't say that, dude.

I was talking about how they're popular characters and wouldn't be seen as strange in a new movie series. Never said you had to like them or whatever.

You were the one spouting off that 'unwritten rule' nonsense. Why couldn't you have just said you don't like the characters?

Chill dude, I wasn't "whining." I was giving my opinion. :roll: If you don't care about integrity in films, that's your prerogative. But back off from your condescending attitude a bit . ;)

You're being a tad over-generalized with calling the Platinum Dunes film "a kid's movie." Kids will be able to see it, but obviously this is going to be more for a broader audience. Kids, teenagers, twenty-somethings, the gamer crowd, potheads, etc. I seriously doubt the final film will be anything more or less than PG-13, and probably no more of a kid's movie than the Transformers films were.

Integrity. In a ninja turtle movie. Ok then. God forbid the movie has entertaining bits. That would be terrible. I want nothing but biting social and political commentary.

The Transformers movies were for kids. Sure there were adult'ish' jokes but those films were aimed at kids. I'd say the same for every Star Wars film.

Sometimes it's ok to have silly sh*t in a movie.

Xav
09-02-2012, 03:21 PM
You were the one spouting off that 'unwritten rule' nonsense. Why couldn't you have just said you don't like the characters?I don't dislike them. I simply like them less than some other characters.

ZariusTwo
09-02-2012, 03:36 PM
I tried watching it again a few years ago, but I couldn't get past the first few episodes. My god, that show was bad, and to be fair, that's probably why I don't look back fondly on Bebop, Rocksteady, and Krang.

You're part of that tired old "I'm older and everything I liked as a kid sucked" cliche that wore out it's welcome on the internet about five years ago. The type of people that are generally dull as a f*cking rock to listen to after about an hour of browsing the 'net.

Just so you know, there will be kids who will look back on the 4Kids cartoon and think it was awful too. Frankly, I wouldnt blame 'em.

I'll take the classic series and it's nice, compact wholesome storytelling and lovable characters over the grim-as-grit comics and movies anyday. TMNT has always worked much better as a complete farce.

Xav
09-02-2012, 03:41 PM
Wow, I wouldn't exactly call the movies, grim-as-grit.

ZariusTwo
09-02-2012, 03:48 PM
Wow, I wouldn't exactly call the movies, grim-as-grit.

We were lucky the characters were as quirky as the cartoon, but the structure of the first movie was geared towards the soulless comics, and Shredder was quite generic.

I still like the first film, I'm just saying that kind of TMNT isnt what I love about the franchise.

Come to think of, perhaps I shouldnt have boxed ALL the movies in there, just that first one, the closest to the comics.

I really get hot when people badmouth the old show, if it entertained kids, it did it's job, blacklisting it because it doesnt match up to their angsty preferences (which they'll grow out of as they age) isnt on in my view. It holds up even today.

CyberCubed
09-02-2012, 04:17 PM
:lol: Touche' :P

All my sarcasm aside....For what it is worth, I'm not saying Bebop and Rocksteady can't be handled well, or even that they won't be handled well. I just never cared for them. I look back at OT with nostalgia. It was was great when I was 6 years old, but even back then, I was more of a fan of the movies - the first movie- than the series. I tried watching it again a few years ago, but I couldn't get past the first few episodes. My god, that show was bad, and to be fair, that's probably why I don't look back fondly on Bebop, Rocksteady, and Krang.

No it isn't. The OT is a fairly entertaining kids show with wacky sci-fit plots and fun main characters. It was never meant to be a piece of complex plot driven stories and it never tried to be something it wasn't.

Krang could work easily in a movie, and while Bebop and Rocksteady might be tough to handle correctly, it can be done.

sgtfbomb
09-02-2012, 04:28 PM
I didn't say that, dude.
God forbid the movie has entertaining bits. That would be terrible. I want nothing but biting social and political commentary.

I never said that. I said that I didn't like Bebop and Rocksteady and wanted the villains to be more of a threat than a gimmick. I never mention anything about "complex storytelling" and "political satire."


You're part of that tired old "I'm older and everything I liked as a kid sucked" cliche that wore out it's welcome on the internet about five years ago. The type of people that are generally dull as a f*cking rock to listen to after about an hour of browsing the 'net.

Dude, chill! Seriously, personal stabs based one or two comments? You don't even know me. It has nothing to do with me being older. By the way, I'm 26. Not 75. Sure, I've broadened my horizons since I was 5 or 6 years old, but most of the stuff I liked as a kid, I still like to this day. The first Ninja Turtles movie is one of them.

Just so you know, there will be kids who will look back on the 4Kids cartoon and think it was awful too. Frankly, I wouldnt blame 'em.

And power to them. I've only seen a few episodes from it and I liked what I see. This was recently, by the way, you know, me being a salty old fart in my mid to late twenties. :roll:


I really get hot when people badmouth the old show, if it entertained kids, it did it's job, blacklisting it because it doesnt match up to their angsty preferences (which they'll grow out of as they age) isnt on in my view. It holds up even today.

I'm sorry, but you really don't know me at all. I never mentioned anything "angsty." Of course, getting upset when somebody doesn't like a show that you like, isn't that "angsty?" Either way, let me amend my statement. I still don't like the Fred Wolf show, and I'm not a fan of using those elements in a feature film. But any real judgement made on the film won't happen until a trailer is released, or even until I see it. I'm not saying that they can't or won't make a great film. I'm not saying that I don't want a carefree, entertaining film. I'm just saying that I have reservations about those elements in the film, and I'm not saying it's wrong to think otherwise.

Also, I don't care whether something holds up to today. I actually sort of prefer the styles of movies from the past. But, anyway, that is neither here nor there. I bought a couple of the OT DVDs, and I just couldn't get into it. It has nothing to do with when it was made or with how shows are made today.

Xav
09-02-2012, 05:14 PM
You're part of that tired old "I'm older and everything I liked as a kid sucked" cliche that wore out it's welcome on the internet about five years ago. The type of people that are generally dull as a f*cking rock to listen to after about an hour of browsing the 'net.True, but the people that go around saying that everything they liked as a kid was awesome and everything else sucks aren't any better.

sgtfbomb
09-02-2012, 05:33 PM
True, but the people that go around saying that everything they liked as a kid was awesome and everything else sucks aren't any better.

I dunno, everyone has that one movie/tv show/video game/song that everybody likes/doesn't like that you don't think is deserving of the high/low opinions that it gets.

To be fair, I feel the same way Zarius does when people say that they would have preferred Michael Chrichton's dry, serious book to be made over the Jurassic Park film that Spielberg made. Though, I typically direct all my "angsty " retorts towards the Twilight crowd. :P

Koi
09-02-2012, 06:34 PM
Some people like some things some people like other things, which will bring on different mind sets of certain ideas for pretty much everything. Stop saying each other is wrong and just listen to each other and think it over of how they thought up their opinion and learn from it. Other wise you become ignorant and just a stubborn being. Learn, adapt, and play nice. Give out your opinions, but don't smother each other in it and get upset when someone has a different one.

Just try listening and reasoning how the opinions came to be and just roll and learn with each other for once... Or don't say anything.

The Stryker
09-02-2012, 06:46 PM
Ah Yes. Play nice. No arguments or discussions ever. Got it ma'am.

EDIT: Just saying that I am in no way affiliated with Zarius or his viewpoints.

Koi
09-02-2012, 07:20 PM
No, :) just be kinder in replies and consider each other's viewpoints.

Donnie
09-02-2012, 07:41 PM
I know Peter Laird's writing always makes ME laugh.

Why? Is it too in-depth for you to grasp?

The Stryker
09-02-2012, 08:02 PM
Why? Is it too in-depth for you to grasp?

I'm glad I have such a loyal follower. Whatup homie.

Actually no. I grasp it just fine. All the deep and emotional stories such as 'Hey. Donatello is really small now. That's a thing.' and 'April is a drawing so I don't have to actually write a complex story about April being infertile'.

Seriously though. I nearly lost my sh*t when I opened up a random issue and saw Raphael as some godzilla thing. Make sure to like me on facebook and follow me on twitter!

No, :) just be kinder in replies and consider each other's viewpoints.

Gotta love what this is followed up with. Oh drome.

sgtfbomb
09-02-2012, 08:08 PM
April is a drawing

Yeah, that one baffles me.

Jester
09-02-2012, 08:09 PM
Seriously though. I nearly lost my sh*t when I opened up a random issue and saw Raphael as some Godzilla thing.
It's Gamera, get it right.

The Stryker
09-02-2012, 08:12 PM
I guess you're right. I try not think about Gamera ever.

Jester
09-02-2012, 08:13 PM
I guess you're right. I try not think about Gamera ever.
What!? But Gamera is the friend of all children! How dare you have a differing opinion, you idiotic spaz!

Vivi
09-02-2012, 08:17 PM
On a tagent, but somewhat referring to Raphael as gojira:

I think the episodes of 2K3 where Donatello was 'turned' into a mindless beast worked really well.

Jester
09-02-2012, 08:22 PM
On a tagent, but somewhat referring to Raphael as gojira:

I think the episodes of 2K3 where Donatello was 'turned' into a mindless beast worked really well.
I like it better for Don than Raph, since the brains becoming a mindless brute is more tragic than the occasionally mindless brute becoming a slightly more mindless brute.

ToTheNines
09-02-2012, 09:08 PM
I like it better for Don than Raph, since the brains becoming a mindless brute is more tragic than the occasionally mindless brute becoming a slightly more mindless brute.

And it was two and a half episodes, compared to a major chunk of a volume.

Allio
09-02-2012, 09:51 PM
You're part of that tired old "I'm older and everything I liked as a kid sucked" cliche that wore out it's welcome on the internet about five years ago. The type of people that are generally dull as a f*cking rock to listen to after about an hour of browsing the 'net.

Just so you know, there will be kids who will look back on the 4Kids cartoon and think it was awful too. Frankly, I wouldnt blame 'em.

I'll take the classic series and it's nice, compact wholesome storytelling and lovable characters over the grim-as-grit comics and movies anyday. TMNT has always worked much better as a complete farce.

You know, both sides of that argument sucks...

It's true, that just because you liked it once doesn't mean it's bad. But heaven forbid that your taste in shows change. I use to love the old TMNT show as a kid, though I admit I was born in the last half of it's run and I mostly grew up on the three movies; but my taste has changed and the old show doesn't entertain me (still haven't picked up my season 2 dvd in a few weeks)

Though I also hate people that say "Shows from my childhood are the smexiness, and everything today sucks!" For one that's all on opinion, and two most of the people that talk about that is only speaking from Nostalgia and only remember the good part. it irks me like it does with pokemon fans.

Can't people just enjoy whatever the hell they like? sure, I may not enjoy the 87 series as much as say you *and that list in my signature is old, and in no way reflects my taste on the old show* but I really don't care.

The way with Ninja Turtles is the way I see shows like: Ultraman, Kamen Rider, Super Sentai, Digimon, and Precure - you may not like one iteration of the show, but there may be just a version out there that fits your taste.





Seriously though. I nearly lost my sh*t when I opened up a random issue and saw Raphael as some godzilla thing.


and just me being picky cause I picked up the awesome 90's trilogy movies it's Gamera (better than most Godzilla movies I've seen), and I'm sure someone had already corrected you


---

Now as for the whole having Rocksteady and Bebop in the movie... I'd prefer if they stayed in the 87 cartoon, that was their place. It's like just keeping Hun in the 03, Dogpound fishface in 2012, Tokka Razah in the movies... every one has a place, and a place has everyone it needs

like now, I'm kind of sick of Krang, he is in the IDW series and the Nick cartoon... he just doesn't seem all that special anymore as he did in the 87 show

BradsOneManBand
09-03-2012, 08:12 AM
can someone be a pal and PM me the script as well? (preferably not a torrent)

CyberCubed
09-03-2012, 10:56 PM
It's kinda sad when you realize that the writers of the Nick cartoon and the IDW comic can up with better storylines than the writers of a major theatrical movie.

Oh well, 1 out of 3 "bombs" isn't too bad.

ToTheNines
09-04-2012, 06:18 AM
It's kinda sad when you realize that the writers of the Nick cartoon and the IDW comic can up with better storylines than the writers of a major theatrical movie.

Oh well, 1 out of 3 "bombs" isn't too bad.

With Applebaum and Nemec, I think this first draft suffered a lot from the fact that they know almost nothing about Ninja Turtles as a franchise. Now that Liebesman and Eastman are more involved, I expect to see something better.


That being said, it was still an awful script and I'm confident that they are not the right guys for the job. I'm very curious to see what Fusco and the Iron-Man guys had turned in.

marcelangelo
09-04-2012, 10:07 AM
sorry if this is already understood in these halls to everyone maybe, BUT THIS SCRIPT WAS SOMETHING THAT EXISTED PRIOR TO MICHAEL BAY AND PLATINUM DUNES ENTERING IN THE GAME....michael bay corrected this himself a few das ago...I think I had it from roseangelos ninja pizza site...
so, these writers were apperantly not the authours of this 'amateurish script' ....

okay it was not ninja pizza for me this time, but michael bays own blog I guess..
here you go...http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/showthread.php?10567-Ninja-Turtles-Script&p=203369#post203369

Roseangelo
09-04-2012, 10:19 AM
sorry if this is already understood in these halls to everyone maybe, BUT THIS SCRIPT WAS SOMETHING THAT EXISTED PRIOR TO MICHAEL BAY AND PLATINUM DUNES ENTERING IN THE GAME....michael bay corrected this himself a few das ago...I think I had it from roseangelos ninja pizza site...
so, these writers were apperantly not the authours of this 'amateurish script' ....

okay it was not ninja pizza for me this time, but michael bays own blog I guess..
here you go...http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/showthread.php?10567-Ninja-Turtles-Script&p=203369#post203369

These comments are addressed back on page 19 of this thread.

marcelangelo
09-04-2012, 11:09 AM
ah okay...thanks, I missed out on a lot of pages of this thread here...

Xav
09-04-2012, 04:47 PM
so, these writers were apperantly not the authours of this 'amateurish script'If Applebaum and Nemec weren't the authors than why were their names on it?

plastroncafe
09-04-2012, 04:48 PM
According to Eastman, who I heard speak at D*C this past weekend, if there are F-Bombs in the script than the one you're reading isn't real.

Leo656
09-04-2012, 09:47 PM
I gotta agree with Stryker about Vol. 4. It was not the worst thing I've ever seen associated with TMNT - not the worst at all - but it WAS the single most boring. Part of why I'm just fine with people taking liberties with the source material of TMNT is because the simple truth is, not a lot of what the guys who started it has done on their own has been very good. Some of it has been great, some of it just felt forced.

I don't agree TMNT works at its best as a "complete farce", but I think it's lasted longer and done better as more people have tinkered with and added to the formula.

CyberCubed
09-04-2012, 09:54 PM
I gotta agree with Stryker about Vol. 4. It was not the worst thing I've ever seen associated with TMNT - not the worst at all - but it WAS the single most boring. Part of why I'm just fine with people taking liberties with the source material of TMNT is because the simple truth is, not a lot of what the guys who started it has done on their own has been very good. Some of it has been great, some of it just felt forced.

I don't agree TMNT works at its best as a "complete farce", but I think it's lasted longer and done better as more people have tinkered with and added to the formula.

Vol. 4 was only boring by its format, not the individual stories. The mistake was giving each Turtles their own plotlines, plus 2-3 other plotlines for April and Casey, and trying to do them all in one book. So each story only progressed by about 4 pages an issue, rather than giving each one separate time.

I guarantee that when/if IDW collects Volume 4 and people can sit down and read it all in one sitting, they'll enjoy it much more.

Toby Barrett
09-04-2012, 11:18 PM
No, it really was just dull and boring.

Vivi
09-05-2012, 04:57 AM
I'm going to have to be a white knight and defend vol 4. It starts off on the moon for goodness sake.

In other comics a lot of their future is romanticized/unexplained, but I feel like this gives a bit more substance to it.