PDA

View Full Version : Ask a Question: IDW's TMNT Editor Thread


Pages : 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

Bobby Curnow
03-26-2016, 01:24 PM
That's in the reprint domain, I don't know about any future plans. Sorry!

TurtlePower96
03-26-2016, 03:21 PM
Is there any chance of Ace Duck or possibly Pizza Face appearing in the comic at some point?

Bobby Curnow
03-26-2016, 04:25 PM
It's certainly a possibility, sure. It all depends if we have a story to tell with them that fits in our universe.

CyberCubed
03-26-2016, 07:36 PM
Bobby do you have a favorite Turtle? Or one you liked when you were younger as a kid/teen when you were first introduced to the franchise? Kevin favors Raphael and Peter Laird has said his favorite is Donatello.

Utrommaniac
03-26-2016, 07:41 PM
Krang's mother has never been explored at all-- I don't think anyone internally has ever even brought her up. In retrospect, I think we've done pretty poorly by mothers. Outside of April's mom, they are all dead (Tang Shen, Casey's mom, Angel's mom) or non-existant (Oroku Saki's mom, Krang's mom). It's a blind spot of ours that I'm not proud of.

So maybe we'll see Krang's mom one day, she could still be alive somewhere in Dimension X, maybe. Though personally i'm kind of attracted to the idea that the Utroms don't have genders and have some peculiar method of reproducing. I can say we will be diving into the uniqueness of the Utrom species down the road.

<After a few months with plenty of thought and new information>

Now that Ma'riell is on the scene and has been expressly listed as a female Utrom, then it seems like Utroms wouldn't be genderless.

I have realized that between Saki's mother and Krang's, it would be easiest to explain why Saki's mother isn't around. There's a very strong possibility that she died in childbirth. Given the time period and that she didn't appear to be around when he was a small boy, it might jut be the case.

However, it's highly unlikely for that to be the reason for the absence of Krang's mother. Utroms would be far more capable of curbing maternal deaths, not just because of Ooze, but by other means as well. The best explanations I can think of are that she died later (maybe in battle?) or was captured by enemies and was eventually believed to be dead after rescue could not be achieved. The idea that she might still be alive somewhere in Dimension X might even suggest that others are too.

Bobby Curnow
03-26-2016, 08:33 PM
Bobby do you have a favorite Turtle? Or one you liked when you were younger as a kid/teen when you were first introduced to the franchise? Kevin favors Raphael and Peter Laird has said his favorite is Donatello.

I was a Leonardo kid (TWO swords!!) and I think that preference has stuck around a bit, and though it's a cliche, I do really love them all.

MikeandRaph87
03-26-2016, 10:40 PM
It is not TMNT related, but IDW related. I don't know if you would know the answer or could get the answer. I bought two other Blondie comic strip trades IDW printed in 2011 and 2012 respectively. There was a third one planned, but got pushed back 4 times and seems to be in publishing hell. I was wondering it was cancelled or will eventually get released? I rather enjoyed the opportunity of reading the strip's earliest years.
http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/614MOt0HYbL._SX258_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg

Thank you for any assist in the manner. Also enjoy your Easter.

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 12:16 AM
Literally no idea, I didn't even know we reprinted Blondie. But when that happens it's typically because the sales on the previous volume didn't indicate that it is profitable to continue the line. Which sucks, I know!

Veg
03-27-2016, 01:40 AM
Hi Bobby,

How much thought went in to launching the TMNT series at the same time as DC relaunching with the New 52? Were there worries your series would be buried amongst all the #1's?

I discovered the series because of DC rebooting and introducing me to the world of comics.

Do you get to see what the other IDW teams are doing? Any stand out books from IDW you read each month? I love Transformers MTMTE as well.

Thanks,
Kane. Southland, New Zealand.

OK to print

ToTheNines
03-27-2016, 06:58 AM
I've a couple of LH questions:

1. How did he mutate if Mutagen wasn't invented until 2011? The ooze would have given him extended longevity, but he shouldn't have mutated right?

2. Where did he get his education? He's not the genius that 4kids LH was but he is very well spoken, and I assume is functioning without the aid of the psychotropic serum. I know 300 years is a long time, but someone had to teach him.

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 12:34 PM
Hi Bobby,

How much thought went in to launching the TMNT series at the same time as DC relaunching with the New 52? Were there worries your series would be buried amongst all the #1's?

I discovered the series because of DC rebooting and introducing me to the world of comics.

Do you get to see what the other IDW teams are doing? Any stand out books from IDW you read each month? I love Transformers MTMTE as well.

Thanks,
Kane. Southland, New Zealand.

OK to print

We were aware it would be at around the same time as New 52, though we did get #1 out about a month before. But we really didn't have any idea how it would impact our series. Fortunately all signs point to it helping a lot, as many new readers like yourself were able to jump into the book.

Zage
03-27-2016, 12:38 PM
We were aware it would be at around the same time as New 52, though we did get #1 out about a month before. But we really didn't have any idea how it would impact our series. Fortunately all signs point to it helping a lot, as many new readers like yourself were able to jump into the book.I say that it's the best comic book series, out there. And to be honest, I'm actually really surprised that it's not in the Previews top 100, on a monthly basis.

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 12:46 PM
I've a couple of LH questions:

1. How did he mutate if Mutagen wasn't invented until 2011? The ooze would have given him extended longevity, but he shouldn't have mutated right?

2. Where did he get his education? He's not the genius that 4kids LH was but he is very well spoken, and I assume is functioning without the aid of the psychotropic serum. I know 300 years is a long time, but someone had to teach him.

I can't get into these answers too much as we're right in the middle of the Leatherhead story, which is still unfolding. I think I can answer the first question though:

Mutagen was invented long before, as shown by the Triceratons. However, in the modern day Krang, with the Utrom homeworld destroyed, lacked the technical means to create more efficiently, so hired Stockman to synthesize it. But the stuff that seeped into the lagoon in Turtles in Time could been both Ooze and Mutagen that Krang had previously stockpiled. (which was then destroyed by the pirates, which also explains why he had to basically wait until human science caught up a bit, with his help, and was able to contract Stockman to make more).

Pertaining to the other thread, I think you're right Nines, I had forgot that we had mapped out the timeline with those captions that dated the events of Slash's mutation. I don't think it will be a continuity error in terms of the B & R miniseries, but obviously can't speak more to that until the series comes out.

MikeandRaph87
03-27-2016, 12:52 PM
Thanks. I thought it would have been a reprint department question, but I asked twice and got no reply back. Much appreciated on getting back to me and so quickly at that. I have been hoping for an avenue to read Blondie in reprints, but its been halted.:cry:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy said "In IDW we trust!", I say, "In Bobby Curnow we trust!" Zage, tell your Turtle loving friends and I will do the same then perhaps the most underrated comic book currently on the shelves will break the top 100 as it should regularly.

In continuity where would Bebop and Rocksteady Destory Everything fit? Between #51 and #52 or concurrently with #59 and #60 which will be printed at the same time?

TMNTooze
03-27-2016, 01:36 PM
Hey Bobby,

Any chance that there will be any other color classics after The Works Vol 5 is released? Wondering if they might make Ultimate Vol 6 in color?

Thanks,
Justin

Zage
03-27-2016, 01:47 PM
Which is your favorite Punk Frog?

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 02:25 PM
Hi Bobby,

Do you get to see what the other IDW teams are doing? Any stand out books from IDW you read each month? I love Transformers MTMTE as well.


I missed this. I don't read nearly as many IDW books as I should considering that I can get them all for free. I've never really been a Transformers fan, but I've read enough to really respect what they are doing in those books. I try and stay on top of a lot of our creator owned. Of course Locke and Key is one of my favorite series ever.

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 02:27 PM
In continuity where would Bebop and Rocksteady Destory Everything fit? Between #51 and #52 or concurrently with #59 and #60 which will be printed at the same time?

Short answer is that i'm not entirely sure yet-- it's pretty separate from events in the ongoing, so any number of places could work post-#50. Not #59/60 though!

Let me reexamine this question after the series is done. Basically you don't need to know anything that's going on in the ongoing post-#50 to enjoy B&RDE.

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 02:28 PM
Hey Bobby,

Any chance that there will be any other color classics after The Works Vol 5 is released? Wondering if they might make Ultimate Vol 6 in color?

Thanks,
Justin

I don't think so, I haven't heard anything about it.

old_hob88
03-27-2016, 02:32 PM
Short answer is that i'm not entirely sure yet-- it's pretty separate from events in the ongoing, so any number of places could work post-#50. Not #59/60 though!

Let me reexamine this question after the series is done. Basically you don't need to know anything that's going on in the ongoing post-#50 to enjoy B&RDE.

This is good to hear. I've got a friend who just got back into comics recently and this seems like it'd be a fun series to introduce him to your fantastic comic series

Bobby Curnow
03-27-2016, 02:32 PM
Which is your favorite Punk Frog?

I can't recall any of the original ones having much in the way of individual personality, so I don't have much of an opinion. I really enjoy how Chad Thomas draws Napoleon in the upcoming Amazing Adventures story featuring them. Genghis Khan was one of my more favorite historical figures when I studied history growing up, so maybe i'd chose his frog counter-part.

ToTheNines
03-27-2016, 07:47 PM
Mutagen was invented long before, as shown by the Triceratons. However, in the modern day Krang, with the Utrom homeworld destroyed, lacked the technical means to create more efficiently, so hired Stockman to synthesize it. But the stuff that seeped into the lagoon in Turtles in Time could been both Ooze and Mutagen that Krang had previously stockpiled. (which was then destroyed by the pirates, which also explains why he had to basically wait until human science caught up a bit, with his help, and was able to contract Stockman to make more).

Ah, of course. I shoulda thought about that, thank you.

Pertaining to the other thread, I think you're right Nines, I had forgot that we had mapped out the timeline with those captions that dated the events of Slash's mutation. I don't think it will be a continuity error in terms of the B & R miniseries, but obviously can't speak more to that until the series comes out.

10-4, looking forward to it.

Zage
03-28-2016, 07:26 PM
Do you think that, maybe, in a future issue, April will become a News Reporter?

Bobby Curnow
03-28-2016, 08:03 PM
No, I don't think we have any interest in that. We'd like to keep her with her science roots.

old_hob88
03-30-2016, 12:25 PM
Bobby,

Now that TMNT Deviations is out I'm curious if there's any chance of seeing more of these Elseworlds style stories for TMNT. Either continuing the continuity after this story, or other branches from the main continuity.

I really enjoyed Deviations and think it'd be cool to get more of these issues as an every once in a while kind of thing.

neatoman
03-30-2016, 04:08 PM
So I have some questions about mutant test subjects from an in-universe perspective.


Why was Bludgeon chosen for mutation? We know Koya was a falcon trained by Shredder, Alopex was probably good for Kitsune to control and Bebop/Rocksteady proved themselves in the eyes of Karai. Was there any special reason why Bludgeon in particular was selected or did they just think any shark would do?
Why did Karai choose to mutate humans rather than just animals like everyone else?
What animals is the Mutagen Man based on?

Bobby Curnow
03-30-2016, 04:21 PM
Bobby,

Now that TMNT Deviations is out I'm curious if there's any chance of seeing more of these Elseworlds style stories for TMNT. Either continuing the continuity after this story, or other branches from the main continuity.

I really enjoyed Deviations and think it'd be cool to get more of these issues as an every once in a while kind of thing.

It's possible, but there's no plans at this time. We've talked about doing more Deviations, but with a different batch of properties.

Bobby Curnow
03-30-2016, 04:26 PM
So I have some questions about mutant test subjects from an in-universe perspective.


Why was Bludgeon chosen for mutation? We know Koya was a falcon trained by Shredder, Alopex was probably good for Kitsune to control and Bebop/Rocksteady proved themselves in the eyes of Karai. Was there any special reason why Bludgeon in particular was selected or did they just think any shark would do?
Why did Karai choose to mutate humans rather than just animals like everyone else?
What animals is the Mutagen Man based on?


I think the main reason was that tactically it made sense for Shredder to have an aquatic mutant in his ranks, since he already had land and air covered. Knowing he was meeting Krang on his boat, it made sense for him to debut Bludgeon then, if he was needed.

I would imagine that the Foot Clan wanted to see if they could get stronger, better soldiers out of mutating humans. Bebop and Rocksteady proved themselves in combat, but they were still expendable-- so if their mutations went wrong, no big loss to the Clan. In short, mutation is a new field, and they were exploring it.

We haven't decided on a set list of animals that Mutagen Man draws on. It's flexible/open-ended at this point.

CyberCubed
03-30-2016, 07:33 PM
Any chance of a Halloween or Christmas themed issue for the holidays later this year?

Utrommaniac
03-30-2016, 08:55 PM
We haven't decided on a set list of animals that Mutagen Man draws on. It's flexible/open-ended at this point.

I like to think he's got human in him for sure...or at least some kind of ape, judging from his brain and skull parts.

mrmaczaps
03-30-2016, 09:18 PM
What are the odds of naming a (deformed) Utrom after me? Haha

Or how about a simple contest to be drawn into the comics as a background character, eating a slice at Mikey's favorite Pizza place or a civilian being attacked by the Foot Clan (rogue ones, since Splinter is currently in charge) or some gang bangers...?

Bobby Curnow
03-30-2016, 09:22 PM
Any chance of a Halloween or Christmas themed issue for the holidays later this year?

Maybe!

Here's some more words to make the letter count.

Bobby Curnow
03-30-2016, 09:24 PM
What are the odds of naming a (deformed) Utrom after me? Haha

Or how about a simple contest to be drawn into the comics as a background character, eating a slice at Mikey's favorite Pizza place or a civilian being attacked by the Foot Clan (rogue ones, since Splinter is currently in charge) or some gang bangers...?

Tom names the characters, go bug him!

I've toyed with the idea of some sort fan contest like that. There's usually too much on my plate to organize it though, as there's a whole legal headache thing to contend with. Maybe one day.

mrmaczaps
03-30-2016, 09:53 PM
Tom names the characters, go bug him!

I've toyed with the idea of some sort fan contest like that. There's usually too much on my plate to organize it though, as there's a whole legal headache thing to contend with. Maybe one day.

Haha, thanks, maybe I will... a friend drew me as a zombie once on the cover of one of his zombie anthology books and it's one of the cooler items in my collection.

Utrommaniac
03-30-2016, 10:39 PM
What are the odds of naming a (deformed) Utrom after me? Haha

Tom names the characters, go bug him!.

I actually did question what deformity would look like in Utroms (besides the very obviously prongs in 2003 Ch'rell - those are definitely a congenital abnormality). The most I could think of in regards to most IDW Utroms (varying from artist to artist) would be split-ended tentacles (basically their version of having extra digits), heterochromia, asymmetrical eye sizes, and maybe crooked jaws.

...I love speculating Utrom biology...I even did a quick doodle of what that might look like.
https://36.media.tumblr.com/dc7e0c9187cb64495da2746319c4bd27/tumblr_o4vwyhclXM1rfuylgo1_250.png

myconius
03-31-2016, 12:31 PM
i can't find if anyone has asked this yet or not?

but i was wondering if Zack Howard was going to be doing any more interior art for the Ninja Turtles?

it took me a bit to realize after seeing Deviations that he also the artist that did one of my ALL time favorite IDW Tmnt covers :) https://media.archonia.com/images/samples/37/81/133781_s0.jpg

not sure how these things come together? but i'd be awesome to get to see him do more Turtles! :D

oh! on a side note ....
i honestly didn't think i'd love Deviations as much as i did!!!

seriously! i wasn't expecting so much to happen in a one-shot, but WOW did you guys show what can be done in a single issue! :D


by the time City Fall had come out IDW Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles had long since taken the spot of my favorite comic to look forward to each month.

Leonardo has always been my favorite character, since ......always!
so it was brutally painful to see him get taken and corrupted by the Shredder!
reading issue #23 still pains me to this day!

oddly though, reading Deviations it wasn't seeing Dark-Leo again that had so much of an effect on me as Michelangelo.

once i saw Mikey all evil and corrupted attacking his father in a playful yet malicious manner, my eyes literally began to fill with tears!
so very powerful! i wasn't ready for that, but it was AMAZING!!!!

i really enjoyed the way everything played out! and i absolutely LOVED the happy (not-so happy) ending!!!

anyway i just wanted to say congrats on another GREAT issue!!! :D

and i'm STILL trying to figure how Kitsune was able to pull the wool over Leonardo's eyes without more resistance of defiance from Leo??? :lol:


:D

ProphetofGanja
03-31-2016, 01:06 PM
Here's some more words to make the letter count.

lmao :lol:

but yeah, a Halloween issue would be pretty dope. The story possibilities are ample, what with the Turtles able to roam around more freely than normal as everyone would just think they're in costumes, like in the Mikey one-shot way back when

Bobby Curnow
03-31-2016, 01:27 PM
but i was wondering if Zack Howard was going to be doing any more interior art for the Ninja Turtles?

and i'm STILL trying to figure how Kitsune was able to pull the wool over Leonardo's eyes without more resistance of defiance from Leo???

No, I don't think we'll see any more interiors from Zach, at least not in the foreseeable future. He's a great artist, but it's hard to make the scheduling work. That great art takes a lot of time.

There was an entire issue of brainwashing! That's a hard thing for a teenager to fight!

pferreira
03-31-2016, 03:09 PM
Enough to cover through City at War (how far we went with the Color Classics reprints). Not sure how many volumes that is. I'd guess 5.As of March I think it's Volume 3 Issue 15 but I could be wrong.

myconius
03-31-2016, 03:28 PM
No, I don't think we'll see any more interiors from Zach, at least not in the foreseeable future. He's a great artist, but it's hard to make the scheduling work. That great art takes a lot of time.


i suppose there are a lot of elements to factor in scheduling, especially when trying to plan around such highly rendered pencils as well as inks as his?

thank you for the reply! :D

ProphetofGanja
04-01-2016, 05:58 PM
Hey Bobby

I am absolutely loving the post-#50 TMNT. Things are wildly different than they have been and it's keeping me on my toes.

My question is, do the shorter arcs that have come after have names? I know the TPB that collects #51-55 is called Order from Chaos after those first two issues, and I vaguely recall hearing the others referred to as Mikey & the Mutanimals and Breaking Point, respectively. Was that official or fandom-created? Or maybe I just imagined it. Anyways, keep up the good work and I'll keep being a fan!

P.O.G.

(fit to print)

Bobby Curnow
04-01-2016, 10:17 PM
No... we, or at least I, don't pay much attention to the titles in general, that's more of something we have to do for the collections (though on occasion, we'll put the names of stories in the pages themselves, like City Fall or Attack on Technodome). I've never heard the names "Mike & the Mutanimals" and "Breaking Point" before personally...

Thanks!

Mayhem
04-02-2016, 04:23 AM
I've never heard the names "Mike & the Mutanimals"
You always take the pizza, take the pizza, the pizza with you? :P

Zog The Magnificent
04-03-2016, 11:03 AM
Hey Bobby, I'm curious, is there any particular story-line in the IDW line of TMNT that was just a nightmare to edit?

Bobby Curnow
04-03-2016, 02:44 PM
Logistically, all of City Fall and the Villain micros were pretty hard to pull off, that was the first thing of that scope that I edited. I was excited and it was fun though, so I wouldn't classify it as a "nightmare". Within that arc was one one of the most unpleasant single issues to work on though: Nickelodeon was extremely tough on TMNT #22, the brainwashing issue. They just did not like it, and we had to do many revisions on the script.

The Infestation two-parter was probably THE most difficult thing. Both Tristan and Mark were a pleasure to work with, so no complaints there, but Nickelodeon really, really, really disliked the whole concept and execution. It was a struggle from start to finish. I think it left a bad taste in everyone's mouth.

In the years since I think we've earned a lot of trust and goodwill from Nickelodeon and they are significantly more hands off now.

ToTheNines
04-03-2016, 03:02 PM
Yeah, I remember Tristan hinting that he didn't care for working with Nickelodeon. Bummer.

Interesting to hear about #23 though, especially since it turned out so perfectly. It's a highlight of the series for me, all of those artists killed their spreads. Any thing you can share about what was originally going to happen compared to what we got?

neatoman
04-03-2016, 03:10 PM
Logistically, all of City Fall and the Villain micros were pretty hard to pull off, that was the first thing of that scope that I edited. I was excited and it was fun though, so I wouldn't classify it as a "nightmare". Within that arc was one one of the most unpleasant single issues to work on though: Nickelodeon was extremely tough on TMNT #22, the brainwashing issue. They just did not like it, and we had to do many revisions on the script.

The Infestation two-parter was probably THE most difficult thing. Both Tristan and Mark were a pleasure to work with, so no complaints there, but Nickelodeon really, really, really disliked the whole concept and execution. It was a struggle from start to finish. I think it left a bad taste in everyone's mouth.

In the years since I think we've earned a lot of trust and goodwill from Nickelodeon and they are significantly more hands off now.

Yeah that reminds me, did Nickelodeon demand any changes to the initial pitch?

I know the Nickelodeon cartoon was initially going to have Splinter dead before the story started, as well as some other concepts that didn't end up in the show.

myconius
04-03-2016, 04:01 PM
Nickelodeon was extremely tough on TMNT #22, the brainwashing issue. They just did not like it, and we had to do many revisions on the script.

AH HA!!!!! so it was THEIR fault!!!! :lol:

see!!! i KNEW there was something wonky with the brainwashing issue that just didn't jive to me!!!

i only wish i could have seen the original vision before they started stepping all over your creative process.


but that's the world these days! some people just don't understand that when you get in the way of creativity, the art suffers.

at least the idea of bringing back all the previous artists from the different arcs was still awesome!!! :D

MikeandRaph87
04-03-2016, 04:09 PM
AH HA!!!!! so it was THEIR fault!!!! :lol:

see!!! i KNEW there was something wonky with the brainwashing issue that just didn't jive to me!!!

i only wish i could have seen the original vision before they started stepping all over your creative process.


but that's the world these days! some people just don't understand that when you get in the way of creativity, the art suffers.

at least the idea of bringing back all the previous artists from the different arcs was still awesome!!! :D

I suspect Deviations: TMNT is a response to that.

The time for Convention is fast approaching. I attend Heroes Convention in Charlotte, N.C. annually, but know you all generally stick to SDCC( your backyard so to speak) and NYCC. Any chance of any of IDW's staff attending this year? I bet the group of who attend can crowd fund you all.:) PLEASE!!

myconius
04-03-2016, 04:18 PM
I suspect Deviations: TMNT is a response to that.


it makes me all the more grateful for Deviations then!!! :D

Bobby Curnow
04-03-2016, 08:20 PM
Yeah, I remember Tristan hinting that he didn't care for working with Nickelodeon. Bummer.

Interesting to hear about #23 though, especially since it turned out so perfectly. It's a highlight of the series for me, all of those artists killed their spreads. Any thing you can share about what was originally going to happen compared to what we got?

I don't remember very well any more, but I think it was a lot looser and impressionistic, much less of a progression of plot beats. For what it's worth I don't think the end product was better or worse than the earlier drafts. Which is what made the process frustrating-- it was a lot of work for something that didn't ultimately make much difference. At least it wasn't worse, in my opinion. (to myconius, I suspect if you didn't like the end product, I suspect you would not have liked the original draft either)

I would say overall that Nickelodeon has helped significantly more than they've hindered.

Bobby Curnow
04-03-2016, 08:21 PM
I suspect Deviations: TMNT is a response to that.

The time for Convention is fast approaching. I attend Heroes Convention in Charlotte, N.C. annually, but know you all generally stick to SDCC( your backyard so to speak) and NYCC. Any chance of any of IDW's staff attending this year? I bet the group of who attend can crowd fund you all.:) PLEASE!!

IDW officially isn't going to Heroes, though maybe someone is going privately, but I haven't heard anyone talk about it.

CyberCubed
04-03-2016, 08:30 PM
Did Nickelodeon have any objections to the reincarnation origin? I mean that's a pretty big change to TMNT lore with the Turtles being human in past lives, and reincarnation has the whole religious aspect to it in some cultures. And also because it was literally in the first story arc when you guys first started working on the comic, so was there any early skepticism there?

Bobby Curnow
04-03-2016, 08:56 PM
No, as I recall that's one of the things they took a quick liking to.

Xav
04-03-2016, 09:19 PM
What happened to the IDW forums are they gone for good?

Zage
04-03-2016, 10:18 PM
Will IDW be at ECCC, this year, next week?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-03-2016, 10:34 PM
Bobby, could you explain the process between deciding when to incorporate backstory or material into a one-shot or mini-series as opposed to the ongoing volume? For instance, what criteria were used to decide to explain so much of City Fall (Hun, Karai, Alopex, and Bebop & Rocksteady) in the one-shots as opposed to explaining it in the main story?

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 12:27 AM
What happened to the IDW forums are they gone for good?

I have no clue!

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 12:28 AM
Will IDW be at ECCC, this year, next week?

Yes, I think we have a booth and several employees will be there.

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 12:31 AM
Bobby, could you explain the process between deciding when to incorporate backstory or material into a one-shot or mini-series as opposed to the ongoing volume? For instance, what criteria were used to decide to explain so much of City Fall (Hun, Karai, Alopex, and Bebop & Rocksteady) in the one-shots as opposed to explaining it in the main story?

No easy answer for this. Just that that we try to cover "the essentials" in the ongoing, and if we know we have an opportunity to flesh out a supporting character in a micro or something, we will take advantage of that real estate. For instance, since we knew we had the Alopex micro, we knew that we could tell that story there-- if we didn't have that micro we may have tried to work that story into the ongoing. If that makes sense!

Zage
04-04-2016, 01:21 AM
Will there be anymore micros? Maybe ones that introduce new to IDW characters, that will later pop up in the ongoing series?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-04-2016, 09:23 AM
No easy answer for this. Just that that we try to cover "the essentials" in the ongoing, and if we know we have an opportunity to flesh out a supporting character in a micro or something, we will take advantage of that real estate. For instance, since we knew we had the Alopex micro, we knew that we could tell that story there-- if we didn't have that micro we may have tried to work that story into the ongoing. If that makes sense!

That makes sense, but leads to another question:

How do you and the team decide to assign side-stories such as micro- and mini-series? How did you know you were going to do, say, an Alopex issue? Or that "Secret History of the Foot Clan" would take place in a mini-series?

ProphetofGanja
04-04-2016, 10:34 AM
That makes sense, but leads to another question:

How do you and the team decide to assign side-stories such as micro- and mini-series? How did you know you were going to do, say, an Alopex issue? Or that "Secret History of the Foot Clan" would take place in a mini-series?

I'm interested in the answer to that question as well. Do you guys plan for mini-series to introduce story beats that will be followed up on later in the main series or is the goal usually to flesh out stories/characters that have already been introduced?

Looking back at all the one-shots and mini-series we've had it seems like a mix of both, so do you guys just think about the upcoming stories that are plotted out for the main series and try to decide what would work best?

myconius
04-04-2016, 01:39 PM
this might have (probably was) already asked?

in the Batman/Tmnt cross-over--

who came up with the idea of mutagen not existing in the DC Universe, making it deadly for the Turtles and Splinter to be there for too long?

CyberCubed
04-04-2016, 02:22 PM
I've forgotten, are Bludgeon and Koya still with the Foot Clan, or did they leave like Bebop/Rocksteady?

ChosenOne
04-04-2016, 02:36 PM
I've forgotten, are Bludgeon and Koya still with the Foot Clan, or did they leave like Bebop/Rocksteady?

Still with the Foot, they joined Karai on her trip to Japan.

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 03:19 PM
Will there be anymore micros? Maybe ones that introduce new to IDW characters, that will later pop up in the ongoing series?

None planned, no.

Mew
04-04-2016, 03:21 PM
Will Kirby: The Fifth Turtle be in IDW?

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 03:22 PM
That makes sense, but leads to another question:

How do you and the team decide to assign side-stories such as micro- and mini-series? How did you know you were going to do, say, an Alopex issue? Or that "Secret History of the Foot Clan" would take place in a mini-series?

If we know we have a spot on a publishing schedule, then I will either seek out a creative team for an idea I have, or seek out cold pitches. I had the title and thought Mateus could do a good job on it, and he took it from there, with Erik's help.

We knew we wanted to focus on supporting villains during City Fall, as they were important to that plot. We knew we wanted to explore Alopex more, so it made sense for her have her own story.

So, no real magic here. Just a matter of if there's a story to be told that fits for a given time.

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 03:23 PM
I'm interested in the answer to that question as well. Do you guys plan for mini-series to introduce story beats that will be followed up on later in the main series or is the goal usually to flesh out stories/characters that have already been introduced?

Looking back at all the one-shots and mini-series we've had it seems like a mix of both, so do you guys just think about the upcoming stories that are plotted out for the main series and try to decide what would work best?

Varies from case to case.

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 03:24 PM
Still with the Foot, they joined Karai on her trip to Japan.

This is correct.

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 03:25 PM
Will Kirby: The Fifth Turtle be in IDW?

No plans at this time. Keep in mind, like all questions about the future, this would likely be my response regardless of if it is true or not.

myconius
04-04-2016, 11:16 PM
Bobby, i know you said that you don't have much to do with re-prints.

but i was wondering if there was the slightest possibility to drop the suggestion to doing a special black and white (uncolored) printing of Tmnt: Deviations?

the more i see of the pure inks they are just incredible!!!!

Bobby Curnow
04-04-2016, 11:30 PM
That'd be great, but I don't see it happening. At least not the entire issue. Maybe a few more in the TPB though, who knows!

myconius
04-04-2016, 11:32 PM
That'd be great, but I don't see it happening. At least not the entire issue. Maybe a few more in the TPB though, who knows!

sounds good to me!!! :D

thanks Bobby!

mrmaczaps
04-05-2016, 09:18 AM
Any chance for using Metal Head and the Justice Force in the near future? Or the Super Hero alternative version of the Turtles?

Bobby Curnow
04-05-2016, 09:37 AM
A chance, sure. Again, spoilers territory here!

neatoman
04-05-2016, 10:52 AM
So here's a question that does not relate to spoilers.

The Deviations issue is centered around the idea Casey died from Shredder stabbing him instead of just ending up in the hospital, was there any consideration of actually killing Casey at that moment in the regular series?

Bobby Curnow
04-05-2016, 04:29 PM
No, at that point we wanted to play out the whole father/son relationship between him and Hun. I don't want to kill characters unless we plan to actually keep them dead, and Casey had way too much story potential at that point.

Zage
04-05-2016, 04:55 PM
Since I know that you like Ace Duck, did you see my Ace Duck thread, & if so, what do you think about that idea, for him?

Powder
04-05-2016, 05:53 PM
Any chance for using Metal Head and the Justice Force in the near future?

You must be the only guy on earth who likes them. :tlol: They are reviled by most Mirage fans.

ToTheNines
04-05-2016, 06:30 PM
Yeah, I will be royally pissed if the justice force ever shows up in any capacity beyond joke/easter egg.

Way too campy for IDW's tone.

mrmaczaps
04-05-2016, 06:53 PM
Must be, but I think it'd be great to see them running a comic shop and see them for a page or three... sitting behind the counter at a comic shop and April & Casey pop in to get some more comics for Mikey... some Mirage comics maybe... just for fun.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
04-05-2016, 06:54 PM
This is NOT a discussion thread. You wanna talk the Mirage Justice Force, go create a thread for it.

Bobby Curnow
04-05-2016, 08:53 PM
Since I know that you like Ace Duck, did you see my Ace Duck thread, & if so, what do you think about that idea, for him?

I don't recall it, no. I try and avoid any and all ideas/pitches that i'm not directly soliciting. Sorry, nothing personal!

Zage
04-05-2016, 09:42 PM
I don't recall it, no. I try and avoid any and all ideas/pitches that i'm not directly soliciting. Sorry, nothing personal!
That's ok :D

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-06-2016, 12:01 AM
Question Bobby, will the characters and ideas introduced in the Bebop and Rocksteady mini make it back into the main series, or are they just for the mini?

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 12:27 AM
Question Bobby, will the characters and ideas introduced in the Bebop and Rocksteady mini make it back into the main series, or are they just for the mini?

Everything that happens in B&RDE will be fodder to build on in the future, yes.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-06-2016, 12:40 AM
Everything that happens in B&RDE will be fodder to build on in the future, yes.

Yes! Thankyou! :) I figured asking if the stuff in the mini could show up wouldn't be spoilerish! Very Awesome!

Zage
04-06-2016, 12:41 AM
What are the chances of Chester "Chet" Manley making a cameo in the comics?

Powder
04-06-2016, 12:55 AM
Chet was already given a nod in Fugitoid's human disguise, I don't see them doing anything beyond that.

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 11:03 AM
Powder is correct.

MikeandRaph87
04-06-2016, 12:23 PM
What comics did you read growing up? Also, which heroes did you follow if you did not necessarily read a title of the character(s)?

Cryomancer
04-06-2016, 12:47 PM
Hey I have a dumb question, how are you liking the technodrome?

Or on that theme, as an Important TMNT Person, any stories about encounters with crazy fans? Get any threatening letters for changing a minor thing about a character or anything like that? Or has it been pretty much just all good times?

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 01:22 PM
What comics did you read growing up? Also, which heroes did you follow if you did not necessarily read a title of the character(s)?

When I first started reading comics at around 8 or 9, Batman and Spiderman were my favorite. I also read some TMNT Adventures at the time! As I got into my pre-teen years, I stayed with Batman and Spiderman but also started reading X-Men and some other Marvel books. I continued with those titles, but when I became a teenager, I also started getting into Mirage and also some indie comics like Milk & Cheese, Bone and Stray Bullets. I stopped reading comics for a few years when I got a car at 16 (gas or comics, I only had money for one!), but then returned when I got to college and made some friends who were still reading.

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 01:28 PM
Hey I have a dumb question, how are you liking the technodrome?

Or on that theme, as an Important TMNT Person, any stories about encounters with crazy fans? Get any threatening letters for changing a minor thing about a character or anything like that? Or has it been pretty much just all good times?

This is going to sound like pandering, but hopefully it's backed up by the frequency with which I visit the forum, but I think it's great. There's always some people who take it a bit too far, but overall i've found the TMNT fandom to be extremely intelligent and friendly and doesn't get too bogged down in dumb or alienating debates (yes, TMNT fans do this of course too, but compared to some other fandoms, everyone is pretty level-headed and fun to talk to)

We got a couple very angry letters when we "killed" Donatello, and on occasion we get a letter here and there with what I would say are well-reasoned complaints about various things we've done. (Pretty much all of those have been printed in Ninja Notes) But by and far it's been a lot of fun and very supporting.

neatoman
04-06-2016, 01:48 PM
Speaking of Metal-Don, would have liked that to on a bit longer or did you think it went on for just long enough?

ProphetofGanja
04-06-2016, 02:46 PM
Speaking of Metal-Don, would have liked that to on a bit longer or did you think it went on for just long enough?

Interesting note here, but I just reread all everything after the Ghostbusters crossover, and it finally really hit home that those ten issues of the main series (Attack on Technodrome and then the Vengeance arc) all take place in a time span of like two days. Really, Donnie was only in Metalhead for a day or so, not much longer than 24 hours.

So for us it was half a year of Robo-Donnie, but really no time at all in continuity. Just interesting to think about

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 02:58 PM
Speaking of Metal-Don, would have liked that to on a bit longer or did you think it went on for just long enough?

I very much would have liked us to explore Metal-Don more in depth, if not longer. My hope is we can still go back and revisit that time in the future.

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 02:59 PM
Interesting note here, but I just reread all everything after the Ghostbusters crossover, and it finally really hit home that those ten issues of the main series (Attack on Technodrome and then the Vengeance arc) all take place in a time span of like two days. Really, Donnie was only in Metalhead for a day or so, not much longer than 24 hours.

So for us it was half a year of Robo-Donnie, but really no time at all in continuity. Just interesting to think about

Some time definitely passed while Shredder was recuperating at Baxter's and the Flyborg swarm was being created. Not long, but more than a few days.

CyberCubed
04-06-2016, 03:56 PM
Speaking of above, do you get feedback for the comic anywhere else other then here, the letters you get to Ninja Notes, or the reviews on various comic book websites? I've often wondered myself how the IDW series is received by fans who don't tend to visit these forums.

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 04:05 PM
The methods you mentioned, as well as meeting fans in person at convention, and social media, are the main ways we get feedback.

Cryomancer
04-06-2016, 04:11 PM
Glad to hear the TMNT fans are at least mostly non shitheads. It's nice having you guys around too, even if we mostly just ask dumb questions you can't possibly be allowed to answer.

ProphetofGanja
04-06-2016, 09:52 PM
Some time definitely passed while Shredder was recuperating at Baxter's and the Flyborg swarm was being created. Not long, but more than a few days.

I went back and reread Vengeance again, this time with the FCBD issue in the suggested place but I still can't figure out the timeline.


Obviously, #45 picks up right after #44, and Fugitoid scrambles to save Don's life. It appears to me that most of the other scenes are taking place concurrently or in normal chronological order, like Koya and Bludgeon telling the Foot that Shredder is dead and Karai telling them that moving forward they will not be working with outsiders, and while that's going on Casey chases off all the Purple Dragons terrorizing his neighborhood, save for Hun, who he sees entering April's parents' antique shop.

We then see Harold and the Fugitoid finish fixing up Donnie while his brothers wait anxiously outside. Raph gets mad and storms out, Alopex leaves to console him. We see a brief scene of Shredder regaining consciousness after passing out from both his injuries in battle and the rapidly changing atmosphere on Burnow Island just hours before. Back at the lab, Donnie wakes up inside Metalhead.

Then in the FCBD issue, Splinter is meditating at the Turtles' home and contemplating everything his family has been through *recap*. We see that Donnie's unconscious body has been brought home to be cared for there.

Out on patrol, Donnie's brothers watch as a gang of Purple Dragons terrorizes the street below. They discuss everything their family and friends have been through recently *recap*. Leo and his brothers attack the Purple Dragons when the Hun appears out of nowhere and challenges the Turtles. Hun and the Turtles fight until Koya and Bludgeon arrive to question Hun, but they're immediately distracted by the Turtles and Hun runs off, unnoticed by anyone.

Donnie-via-Metalhead arrives and creates an opportunity for his brothers to escape and they all flee the Foot mutants and regroup a ways away. Donnie's brothers greet him and tell him it's great to see him. Metalhead has now been repaired, as when he first woke up inside it Metalhead only had three limbs. Elsewhere, Stockman and Shredder oversee production of flyborgs and mousers. THE END of FCBD issue

Issue #46 opens up and four-armed Metalhead Donnie is explaining the finer points of caring for his physical body while it heals. They are still at Harold's lab. Donnie states that he'll help make preparations to transport his body back home. Raph is still outside being comforted by Alopex (or, alternatively, everyone left for a while then came right back to the same positions??). Leo and Mikey come outside to tell Raph that he should quit moping and go on patrol with them and Raph says **** it, let's go. Mikey goes to find the Mutanimals and he and Leo go to check on the Foot. Alopex and Angel leave to do some patrolling as well.

We then see Casey confronting his drunk father, who has just entered the antique shop, as seen in #45. Before a fight breaks out, Alopex and Angel arrive in the nick of time and Hun slinks off. Angel and Alopex are introduced to the O'Neils and everyone enjoys small talk for a while.

Karai tells the Foot that they will no longer tolerate any outsiders (but not being like, racist against mutants or anything, she just means non-ninjas), as its always screwed them over in the past. Everybody gets pumped up and cheers.

Back at the lab, Harold cleans up all his broken stuff while Donnie gets used to having a digital brain. Out doing his own thing, Mikey catches up with his pizza guy friend. On a school campus somewhere, Dr. Miller gets got. Elsewhere, Stockman shows Shredder his fancy building full of killer robots.

Back at the O'Neils' apartment over the Second Time Around shop, the group is done talking, as they refer to it having been a long and eventful night. So either everything in these first two issues has taken place in this one night, or Casey, Alopex, and Angel all left, went home for a few days, put on the same clothes, went back over to the O'Neils' apartment for coffee and had a completely different and unrelated long and eventful night, when Hun shows up super drunk out of the blue? Except not, because then Casey goes outside and confronts his dad and the Purple Dragons, and he asks Malo if he'd had enough abuse for one night, as he broke Malo's nose earlier that same night when he prevented them from robbing Arune's store. Then there's a big fight and Hun goes to jail and then the next three issues all take place that same night, as the Shredder sends Stockman's robots after them and then the now infamous Gauntlet battle and all that. Then of course Issue #51 opens roughly a month after that night, but of course Donnie was back in his body the same night as the Gauntlet.

I can't figure out how this doesn't make sense, or allow for any other periods of time to be inserted between these events? Unless some scenes were in a different chronological order than the one they were presented in the comic book? Also it seems like Hun was in two places at once or something?

EDiT: ok I think the time loop inconsistencies or whatever can be explained if you accept that the scene with Casey chasing away hoodlums in the first part of #45 takes place after all the other events in that issue, and then you move all of the events of the FCBD issue to during issue #46, in between when the three Turtles and the A-Team leave the lab to go on patrol and the scene of Casey confronting his father (right before this is where you would stick that scene with Casey from #45). During this time is when Splinter would have transported Donnie's body back to their lair while Donnie probably continued to talk to Fugitoid about his new condition, and the Turtles went on their own patrols. If that's the case, then Angel and Alopex were out roaming the streets for a really long time, because Hun went to the antique store twice in one night, once alone and once with back up, but both times drunk, and he didn't appear drunk in his brief encounter with the Turtles. Hun states that the reason he was celebrating (drinking) that night was because the Foot Clan was no more, so it follows that that scene is taking place the same night as the Foot Clan's near-total destruction, which would be the same day/night/whatever that the Turtles minus Donnie went to Burnow Island, tricked Krang and Shredder into nearly killing each other, imprisoned Krang, dealt with Donnie's near death, and then got hunted down and nearly killed by Stockman's robots, only to be saved by Karai and allowed to challenge the Shredder to a final battle.

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 10:23 PM
I don't have time to put too much thought into it, but it seems to me there are lots of places where significant amounts of time could have passed. Such as:

"We then see Harold and the Fugitoid finish fixing up Donnie while his brothers wait anxiously outside. Raph gets mad and storms out, Alopex leaves to console him.
****
We see a brief scene of Shredder regaining consciousness after passing out from both his injuries in battle and the rapidly changing atmosphere on Burnow Island just hours before. Back at the lab, Donnie wakes up inside Metalhead."

Where I put the **** could have been a day, or several days. I would imagine it would take time to set up the mind transfer to Metalhead. We didn't call it out with a caption, but the point is I think time could have elapsed there, and at other places.

I'm sure with careful enough examination holes can be poked in that theory, that's for sure. Chalk that up to my error!

ProphetofGanja
04-06-2016, 10:43 PM
I don't have time to put too much thought into it, but it seems to me there are lots of places where significant amounts of time could have passed. Such as:

"We then see Harold and the Fugitoid finish fixing up Donnie while his brothers wait anxiously outside. Raph gets mad and storms out, Alopex leaves to console him.
****
We see a brief scene of Shredder regaining consciousness after passing out from both his injuries in battle and the rapidly changing atmosphere on Burnow Island just hours before. Back at the lab, Donnie wakes up inside Metalhead."

Where I put the **** could have been a day, or several days. I would imagine it would take time to set up the mind transfer to Metalhead. We didn't call it out with a caption, but the point is I think time could have elapsed there, and at other places.

I'm sure with careful enough examination holes can be poked in that theory, that's for sure. Chalk that up to my error!

its really just a minor detail but timelines have always been one of the first things to jump out at me with any new media property I get into, so that's just me being super anal. but yeah I can't imagine all the work that goes into editing a major comic series like this, and then don't you do more than one?? that's a lot to keep track of

for real though, you, Tom, Mateus (or whoever the artist happens to be for any given story, and everyone who's ever illustrated an issue), Ronda, you the real MVP, all the work you guys do is so different but so vital and equally difficult, all to bring us the greatest possible creation you can. thanks a lot guys :tcool::tlol::tgrin:

Bobby Curnow
04-06-2016, 10:58 PM
Thank you!

Utrommaniac
04-06-2016, 11:02 PM
You said earlier that there was some trouble working with Nick on a few storylines, especially the brainwashing story.

But was there anything that you were surprised made it through them when they were being a little more stingy? (Much like the way 98% of content made it through the Powers that Be in all of Steven Speilberg's cartoons in the 90's.)

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 01:04 PM
Not really, no... I don't think we could have got Bebop & Rocksteady approved a couple of years back, but I think we've earned trust and are able to go crazy a little bit more now.

I also think TMNT #50 would have been difficult to pull off if it wasn't for the fact that since the first year we were saying "we're building up to Splinter beheading Shredder... we'll make it tasteful..." etc, etc. So that was a long time in the making but by the time it came around, it was no problem.

neatoman
04-07-2016, 02:08 PM
For how long was TMNT Universe planned?

ChosenOne
04-07-2016, 04:32 PM
Like I said in the thread for the announcement of TMNT Universe, between Leatherhead and Bishop in the main title, the Deviations one-shot, the crossover with Batman, and the upcoming Bebop & Rocksteady mini, 2016 is the best year yet for IDW TMNT. A second monthly title is pretty much excitement overkill at this point, but the real question is: are there any other surprises you folks are waiting to spring on us before the year is out? I'm not asking for specifics or announcements, just... Any more minis or micros or annuals or one-shots or anything of the like lying in wait that we don't know about yet?

Also, regarding TMNT Universe, will the stories being told in that title all take place concurrently with the main ongoing? Or can we expect a few stories set in the past, future, alternate timeline, alternate universe, etc, whether they be framed by narrative devices in the present or not?

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 04:37 PM
For how long was TMNT Universe planned?

I've been wanting to do a "Tales..." book for a while, and while there are significant differences between this and what Mirage Tales was, Universe essentially fills the same role. So in some respect, years. More concretely though, since mid-last year, a little before TMNT #50. We knew that Batman/TMNT would go on for a while, and then we did B&R to coincide with the new movie, so we wanted to do something big to follow those two things.

neatoman
04-07-2016, 04:39 PM
I've been wanting to do a "Tales..." book for a while, and while there are significant differences between this and what Mirage Tales was, Universe essentially fills the same role. So in some respect, years. More concretely though, since mid-last year, a little before TMNT #50. We knew that Batman/TMNT would go on for a while, and then we did B&R to coincide with the new movie, so we wanted to do something big to follow those two things.

For how long do plan for it to last?

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 04:40 PM
Like I said in the thread for the announcement of TMNT Universe, between Leatherhead and Bishop in the main title, the Deviations one-shot, the crossover with Batman, and the upcoming Bebop & Rocksteady mini, 2016 is the best year yet for IDW TMNT. A second monthly title is pretty much excitement overkill at this point, but the real question is: are there any other surprises you folks are waiting to spring on us before the year is out? I'm not asking for specifics or announcements, just... Any more minis or micros or annuals or one-shots or anything of the like lying in wait that we don't know about yet?

Also, regarding TMNT Universe, will the stories being told in that title all take place concurrently with the main ongoing? Or can we expect a few stories set in the past, future, alternate timeline, alternate universe, etc, whether they be framed by narrative devices in the present or not?

Ha, no, this is it for the year I think, though maybe we'll sneak something in December-- don't count on it though. I know I have my hands full, so i'm certainly not looking to add anything else!

Most of the Universe stories will be taking place around the same time as the ongoing, though the flexibility of the title is designed to allow stories that fill in blanks from the past (or future?!) as well as alternate universes, if desired. I anticipate those stories that don't fall in the same time period of the ongoing (or "now") will be very clearly identified as such.

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 04:41 PM
For how long do plan for it to last?

It's an ongoing, so for as long as sales support it. I very much hope or a couple years at least.

ChosenOne
04-07-2016, 04:47 PM
Ha, no, this is it for the year I think, though maybe we'll sneak something in December-- don't count on it though. I know I have my hands full, so i'm certainly not looking to add anything else!

That's good to know, in a bittersweet way. My poor heart had barely just recovered from the announcement of B&RDE when... Bam! Universe comes out swinging! Even if that December thing does come to pass, at least I know I'll have a few more months to process all of this and stop reeling from so much awesome before it is announced. :D

Thank you!

mrmaczaps
04-07-2016, 04:57 PM
Any plans for any kind of work with Peter Laird again in the near future? A cover, a pinup or any such thing. The 30th anniversary issue was awesome.

Thanks!

playmate
04-07-2016, 05:02 PM
Cowabunga Mr Curnow.
I hope to clarify if there will be an additional book to compliment #60 in July, and once August offers #61 & Universe #1, if we can ever expect any micro/mini on top? Thanks in advance for your insight; this is extremely exciting news!!!!

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 05:05 PM
Any plans for any kind of work with Peter Laird again in the near future? A cover, a pinup or any such thing. The 30th anniversary issue was awesome.

Thanks!

I always hope!

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 05:06 PM
Cowabunga Mr Curnow.
I hope to clarify if there will be an additional book to compliment #60 in July, and once August offers #61 & Universe #1, if we can ever expect any micro/mini on top? Thanks in advance for your insight; this is extremely exciting news!!!!

No side book for July, no. And the idea is that Universe will take the place of various micros and mini-series. So no plans for anything else, but that could always change depending on circumstances in the future.

CyberCubed
04-07-2016, 05:22 PM
So will the Turtles themselves be in most of the issues from the Universe series, or are they likely to be absent from most of them? For example we'll see issues with just Hob and the Mutanimals, or some just of Angel, Casey, Alopex, etc...or a Triceraton story, or just all villains, etc.

Or will the Turtles themselves still be present in most of them?

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 06:29 PM
So will the Turtles themselves be in most of the issues from the Universe series, or are they likely to be absent from most of them? For example we'll see issues with just Hob and the Mutanimals, or some just of Angel, Casey, Alopex, etc...or a Triceraton story, or just all villains, etc.

Or will the Turtles themselves still be present in most of them?

A mix-- the first storyline heavily features the Turtles and other characters. Subsequent stories will feature just supporting characters, no Turtles. Other stories still could focus on just one or a couple Turtles. In short, any combination is possible. Basically look at it like an ongoing made up of mini-series and micros.

Powder
04-07-2016, 06:47 PM
It'll have a revolving door of different artist/writer duos in the way that Tales did, right?

Bobby Curnow
04-07-2016, 10:03 PM
Correct-- creators will stay on for the length of whatever story they are telling and then a new team. Expect new folks and ones you've seen before.

Zog The Magnificent
04-07-2016, 10:17 PM
Is this sister series going to be chronological to the main series or all over the place like the original tales?

Mayhem
04-08-2016, 04:19 AM
I actually worked out where Chet might have come from for Fugitoid's alter ego in the lab. However, where did Allen come from? The only other Allen I could think of was one of the incarnations of The Flash. Asking because hey, that's my surname, and it was kind of cool to see it in a TMNT comic book :)

Red Robin
04-08-2016, 05:00 AM
So if the Universe books might also be set in alternate universes, does that count for something like Deviations, or may we hope to get an expansion of the Image or Mirage universe?

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-08-2016, 09:29 AM
So if the Universe books might also be set in alternate universes, does that count for something like Deviations, or may we hope to get an expansion of the Image or Mirage universe?

The universe series is NOT set in alternate universes, it's all stories set in the IDW universe. Miniseries or oneshots set in alternate universes would be cool though.

CyberCubed
04-08-2016, 12:20 PM
Yeah I'm curious why they went with the "Universe" subtitle too, before I clicked the thread I did think it was some sort of TMNT crossover thing just from the title.

Did IDW originally intend to title it "Tales of the TMNT" but couldn't because of copyright reasons or something? Or was the TMNT Universe title decided from the start?

ProphetofGanja
04-08-2016, 12:39 PM
Yeah I'm curious why they went with the "Universe" subtitle too, before I clicked the thread I did think it was some sort of TMNT crossover thing just from the title.

Did IDW originally intend to title it "Tales of the TMNT" but couldn't because of copyright reasons or something? Or was the TMNT Universe title decided from the start?

I think its a cool name, and it leaves them open to do alternate-universe stories if they ever decide to

Bobby Curnow
04-08-2016, 12:46 PM
Is this sister series going to be chronological to the main series or all over the place like the original tales?

I think the majority of the stories will take place at roughly the same time (give or take a few issues) as the ongoing. But there will definitely be opportunities to explore other periods in the timeline. I intend to make the when/where of those stories explicitly clear.

Bobby Curnow
04-08-2016, 12:47 PM
I actually worked out where Chet might have come from for Fugitoid's alter ego in the lab. However, where did Allen come from? The only other Allen I could think of was one of the incarnations of The Flash. Asking because hey, that's my surname, and it was kind of cool to see it in a TMNT comic book :)

I have no clue! That would be a question for Tom, methinks.

Bobby Curnow
04-08-2016, 12:49 PM
So if the Universe books might also be set in alternate universes, does that count for something like Deviations, or may we hope to get an expansion of the Image or Mirage universe?

Anything is possible, though not necessarily likely. I will say if we were to do something set in an Image or Mirage or Archie universe I would only want to do so if it was done by, or with the explicit approval of, the creative teams involved in those series. For instance, I have no interest in doing a Mirage story that wasn't either by or blessed by Peter, or by proxy, Jim Lawson or someone on that level. The 30th Anniversary book is a good guide in that regard.

Bobby Curnow
04-08-2016, 12:58 PM
Yeah I'm curious why they went with the "Universe" subtitle too, before I clicked the thread I did think it was some sort of TMNT crossover thing just from the title.

Did IDW originally intend to title it "Tales of the TMNT" but couldn't because of copyright reasons or something? Or was the TMNT Universe title decided from the start?

I had originally lobbied hard for it to be "Tales of the TMNT". There were a couple reasons we did not go in that direction:

1) Ease of retail ordering. If something is listed as "Tales" first, there's a greater chance that it will not be found as something Turtle related. Keep in mind that the majority of people who are not TMNT fans aren't familiar with the title. Having "Turtles" or "TMNT" first makes things easier. When that was brought to my attention, I suggest "TMNT Tales". (sidenote: I've been meaning to ask Kevin if having "Tales" first in title did actually create any confusion back in the day for retailers... still need to do that!)

2) Since we do reprints of "Tales of TMNT" (and did not label it differently like "Tales of TMNT Classics" or something) there could be confusion about what is what for both fans and retailers, especially when we start putting out TPBs of this new series.

3) There was the perception in the company that the name "Tales" implies something that's not quite as important or as legitimate... like it's a fable that might not be true or something.

Like I said, I really wanted to name it "Tales..." just because of the history and it would fit for the type of series it would be. But I couldn't deny that all of the above were very good, legitimate points. So we traded a few ideas back and forth internally. A few people really wanted to go with "TMNT Forever" but that seemed like a big mistake to me-- that name conjures something very specific to TMNT fans. Ultimately "Universe" was something that sounded legitimate but also implied a wider world to be explored.

Bobby Curnow
04-08-2016, 01:20 PM
Possible, but not likely.

The Fifth Turtle
04-09-2016, 08:50 AM
I know this isn't your area per say but can you tell us if the new Tales tpb coming out will include issue #21 with the C.O.W.boys? If not will that issue be collected at some point?

Bobby Curnow
04-09-2016, 11:40 AM
I know this isn't your area per say but can you tell us if the new Tales tpb coming out will include issue #21 with the C.O.W.boys? If not will that issue be collected at some point?

I'm not sure, sorry.

ChosenOne
04-09-2016, 04:13 PM
At this moment in time, how far ahead have you folks mapped out the plot for the main ongoing? Do you know what you want to do for, say, issue #75? #100? Anything past that?

Speaking of, is it safe to say there will be a big overarching City Fall-style arc somewhere in the #70's, starting in a year or so, as a bridge of sorts between #50 and #100? Or do you feel that would be too predictable and possibly even trite?

Finally, regarding Rat King and Kitsune and whoever else's game, do you feel that everything has been planned sufficiently in advance that when it finally unravels, we'll look back at what seem to be their constant moments of gloating and cryptic comments, and go "Aha! So that's why X and Y happened!"? I've seen some criticism regarding this matter and while I do not necessarily agree, they are the closest thing you have so far to mustache-twirling villains... But I do have faith everything will fall into place and make sense eventually.

Thanks!

Utrommaniac
04-09-2016, 05:05 PM
I realized a lot recently, and I wondered why it hadn't been brought up within the storyline.

Why did Krang feel the need to terraform the entirety of Earth from the very start?

Because there is a lot of holes in that idea that don't stop at the immorality of it. Wouldn't Burnow Island be able to last them long enough to be comfortable, and if they needed to expand, they could just take another island or two and not hurt the rest of the planet? With their advancements in technology, they might even be able to benefit the outside world. Fugitoid even says that the Utroms already had a fairly small population on Utrominion anyway, so why bother? And they somewhat needed the support and protection of the planet's other inhabitants anyway.
The Utroms are mostly all harmless civilians save for Ch'rell, and a lot of them are scientists, who would have spent a lot of time dedicated to learning about the Earth. They probably would not have been very happy to see everything they dedicated so much research on destroyed. As well as the fact that they've basically been moved from one planet full of corpses to another. Which is just full of moral and ethical faux pas.

I can't help but think that this would be Churk's position. He who seemed particularly dedicated to learning about Earth's lifeforms. "You know nothing about this planet!"
sPbjPOgRtyA

It seems like Krang didn't fully think this through. Especially since he's not as science-minded as the original. I would think that taking the entire Earth would have gotten him on the bad side of the scientific Utroms, and the ones that were basically regular civilians who wouldn't have wanted to cause any harm.

With that in mind, why couldn't Krang have had a few other Utroms to keep him anchored? Scientific Utroms who would know enough about Earth to say, "Hey, here's a really long list of reasons of why that's a dumb idea!" Psychologically speaking, it seems like he derailed after several years of not having other Utroms out and about with him. He certainly couldn't keep the entire population, but if Krang can support himself, why not another one or two others?


The last thing I realized is that it seems like all the Utroms are adults. Why are there no children among them? Surely at several of the Burnow Utroms had young offspring on Utrominion that they would basically have left behind to die horribly. Wouldn't Krang have attempted to rescue at least a few families, and prevented an age chasm once they started repopulating?

AquaParade
04-10-2016, 01:46 PM
Hey Bobby,

Wondering if you think there is any chance we will see the original Mirage run reprinted in it's original coloring? Definitely my favorite representation of those issues.
Have you seen the Shredder reveal in issue #10? Fantastic coloring!

Bobby Curnow
04-10-2016, 04:41 PM
At this moment in time, how far ahead have you folks mapped out the plot for the main ongoing? Do you know what you want to do for, say, issue #75? #100? Anything past that?

Speaking of, is it safe to say there will be a big overarching City Fall-style arc somewhere in the #70's, starting in a year or so, as a bridge of sorts between #50 and #100? Or do you feel that would be too predictable and possibly even trite?

Finally, regarding Rat King and Kitsune and whoever else's game, do you feel that everything has been planned sufficiently in advance that when it finally unravels, we'll look back at what seem to be their constant moments of gloating and cryptic comments, and go "Aha! So that's why X and Y happened!"? I've seen some criticism regarding this matter and while I do not necessarily agree, they are the closest thing you have so far to mustache-twirling villains... But I do have faith everything will fall into place and make sense eventually.

Thanks!

We've got all of the major beats planned out through #100. Some things may shift around, so what we're currently considering #75 might not actually end up there, but we know the general path we're on and where it's heading.

It all depends on what you would consider a "big story". I'd consider City Fall and Attack on Technodrome both to be big stories, but they were very different in terms of length and pacing. I think it's safe to say that we will be hitting "bigger" things in some form, at some time!

Regarding your Rat King/Kitsune question, I think it depends entirely on the individual on to how well that will "pay off". Could be that we botch it, or botch elements of it, or that it's not worth the build up, etc. I don't really have any way of predicating how people will react to things that haven't happened yet.

Bobby Curnow
04-10-2016, 04:50 PM
I realized a lot recently, and I wondered why it hadn't been brought up within the storyline...



I think Krang is much more of a survivalist and a cynic in terms of how he sees inter-species relations. I think he knew that humans, being the dominant life form on the planet, would not take kindly to what are basically aliens with advanced technology, hanging out publicly. He understood human behavior well enough to know that conflict would happen and the safety and freedom of his race was at stake. Better to just wipe everyone out so the Utroms can be guaranteed to have peace and space to expand. I don't know what you mean when you say they would need the protection of other species on the planet. Those species are their main threat! Better to have no threats, right? (I'm saying this from the viewpoint of Krang)

In terms of what the other Utroms think, Krang doesn't strike me as the type of guy who really would give a damn what anyone else thinks. He probably kept them all in stasis in part so he wouldn't have to listen to anyone questioning his methods. Once the planet was terraformed, the safety of his people was secured, and then others could complain about the ethics as much as they want, his goal would already be complete.

Bobby Curnow
04-10-2016, 04:50 PM
Hey Bobby,

Wondering if you think there is any chance we will see the original Mirage run reprinted in it's original coloring? Definitely my favorite representation of those issues.
Have you seen the Shredder reveal in issue #10? Fantastic coloring!

I haven't heard any plans regarding this, no.

Bossanova
04-11-2016, 12:57 PM
I've been thinking lately about how great all the black and white comics are, and how you have been printing and reprinting all of the classic tmnt stories in color, my question is, are there any plans to do the opposite and print the current IDW ongoing In black and white, inks only in omnibus or tpb form? However unlikely, wouldn't that be rad. (No disrespect towards Pattison cause her coloring has been top notch since the beginning.)

Bobby Curnow
04-11-2016, 01:53 PM
No plans for that, but it would be fun to see-- i'm in a very privileged place of being one of the few people to see all of the inks come in, and it is a treat.

But I don't think there would be the belief in the company that there would be a large market for something like that.

John Pannozzi
04-11-2016, 02:59 PM
Any chance of the TMNT Deviations oneshot being included in TMNT IDW Collection Vol. 3? The Deviations oneshot showed an alternate outcome to Cityfall, the same storyarc that the IDW Collection Vol. 3 hardcover is collecting.

Bobby Curnow
04-11-2016, 03:23 PM
No, it's not in continuity, and therefore doesn't fall under the IDW Collection banner.

neatoman
04-11-2016, 03:39 PM
Not really anything to do with IDW's comics but what did you think of the new trailer for the movie? Do you think the whole "we could be human" plot seems like a good idea or not?

VAbRg7xUtVU

Bobby Curnow
04-11-2016, 04:08 PM
Actually first time i've seen this trailer, thanks for sharing. I think this trailer looks more fun than the first, and that one of course seemed a lot more promising than the last film.

As for the "human" plot-- seems like a good opportunity for character advancement if the Turtles have differing opinions abut it. I think that plot has been pretty well covered in X-men or any story with non-human looking protagonists, but if it's done well, could be cool. It's not like the Turtles would stay human by the end of the film. (or I assume not!!)

ProphetofGanja
04-11-2016, 05:27 PM
Actually first time i've seen this trailer, thanks for sharing. I think this trailer looks more fun than the first, and that one of course seemed a lot more promising than the last film.

As for the "human" plot-- seems like a good opportunity for character advancement if the Turtles have differing opinions abut it. I think that plot has been pretty well covered in X-men or any story with non-human looking protagonists, but if it's done well, could be cool. It's not like the Turtles would stay human by the end of the film. (or I assume not!!)

Title for the next film: Teenage Ninjas! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Xav
04-11-2016, 08:55 PM
In terms of what the other Utroms think, Krang doesn't strike me as the type of guy who really would give a damn what anyone else thinks. He probably kept them all in stasis in part so he wouldn't have to listen to anyone questioning his methods. Once the planet was terraformed, the safety of his people was secured, and then others could complain about the ethics as much as they want, his goal would already be complete.But what about Ch'rell? I mean he doesn't seem like someone who would have a problem with Krang's methods so why didn't Krang revive him? Why save such a violent warrior if he wasn't going to use him to help him conquer Earth?

ToTheNines
04-11-2016, 08:58 PM
Title for the next film: Teenage Ninjas! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Well all the actors are thirty something. So just Ninjas... except not really.

Bobby Curnow
04-12-2016, 12:51 AM
But what about Ch'rell? I mean he doesn't seem like someone who would have a problem with Krang's methods so why didn't Krang revive him? Why save such a violent warrior if he wasn't going to use him to help him conquer Earth?

Krang didn't have a say in who was or wasn't revived, he's under custody in Dimension X. That was Fugitoid's call. (which, spoilers, I think we get into more in the next issue, if I'm remembering the events of particular issues correctly)

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-12-2016, 10:34 AM
Bobby one question-why no comics or anything for the new TMNT movies from platinum dunes? IDW was all the the transformer films, why not even a single prequel or tie in comic here?

ProphetofGanja
04-12-2016, 10:51 AM
Bobby one question-why no comics or anything for the new TMNT movies from platinum dunes? IDW was all the the transformer films, why not even a single prequel or tie in comic here?

Because those movies suck!

Bobby Curnow
04-12-2016, 11:40 AM
Bobby one question-why no comics or anything for the new TMNT movies from platinum dunes? IDW was all the the transformer films, why not even a single prequel or tie in comic here?

Tom and I read the script for the first one and determined that there was not much to do with it. Couple that with the fact that the movie-tie in comics don't do much in the way of sales (you'll note that it's been many years since we've done a TF tie-in comic now) we decided to just let it lie.

Utrommaniac
04-12-2016, 12:56 PM
Krang didn't have a say in who was or wasn't revived, he's under custody in Dimension X. That was Fugitoid's call. (which, spoilers, I think we get into more in the next issue, if I'm remembering the events of particular issues correctly)

I think he meant more along the lines of "why didn't Krang keep him awake with him".

To which I would say, as much as a loyal servant he might have been, Ch'rell might be the last Utrom he'd want awake with him for fear of being usurped. As well as Ma'riell/Churk/any Utrom closely involved with studying Earth. Lorqa might have been one that he kept around; Krang respected his philosophy (post-Zog battle) and he probably would have kept him grounded. However, he probably would have died naturally long before the others could be revived.

Still, Krang had some value in their presence, since he seems to go to the stasis room just for the sake of it, such as when Stockman first saw it.

Bobby Curnow
04-12-2016, 02:15 PM
I think he meant more along the lines of "why didn't Krang keep him awake with him".

To which I would say, as much as a loyal servant he might have been, Ch'rell might be the last Utrom he'd want awake with him for fear of being usurped. As well as Ma'riell/Churk/any Utrom closely involved with studying Earth. Lorqa might have been one that he kept around; Krang respected his philosophy (post-Zog battle) and he probably would have kept him grounded. However, he probably would have died naturally long before the others could be revived.

Still, Krang had some value in their presence, since he seems to go to the stasis room just for the sake of it, such as when Stockman first saw it.

It didn't serve our story purpose to have more Utroms around at that time, and you could just make up some in-world reason why that wasn't viable-- not enough Ooze left for more than one non-stasis Utrom. At the end of the day I just don't think Krang would want/need any help. He's pretty confident in his abilities.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-12-2016, 02:29 PM
Another question; do you think we'll be seeing any martial arts/eastern mystcism-themed stories coming up soon? Stuff like the Ninja Tribunal from 4kids, or the urn of Chaka-hachi story from the OT. We have lots of sci-fi with the utroms and bishop coming up, so anything of the mystical sort on the horizon?

Bobby Curnow
04-12-2016, 03:29 PM
Possibly! That falls under the category of future spoilers, so not too much I can say one way or another.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-17-2016, 02:04 PM
This is probably true, but I just wanted to ask to confirm; were the flyborgs that Baxter Stockman created a tribute to Baxter's two fates in the two previous TMNT shows? (fly in Fred Wolf, cyborg in 4kids?)

Zage
04-17-2016, 03:01 PM
This is probably true, but I just wanted to ask to confirm; were the flyborgs that Baxter Stockman created a tribute to Baxter's two fates in the two previous TMNT shows? (fly in Fred Wolf, cyborg in 4kids?)Yes, I believe I read that somewhere, that that's what they were. :D A sweet & fitting tribute, I think. :D

Zog The Magnificent
04-17-2016, 04:28 PM
I don't know if this is too spoilery, but is there a chance of ever seeing Lord Dregg in the comic? The Nick show has done a pretty good job with him and it would be cool to see IDW's take.

Bobby Curnow
04-17-2016, 04:45 PM
This is probably true, but I just wanted to ask to confirm; were the flyborgs that Baxter Stockman created a tribute to Baxter's two fates in the two previous TMNT shows? (fly in Fred Wolf, cyborg in 4kids?)

You'd have to ask Erik Burnham as he created them. That would be my guess though.

Bobby Curnow
04-17-2016, 04:46 PM
I don't know if this is too spoilery, but is there a chance of ever seeing Lord Dregg in the comic? The Nick show has done a pretty good job with him and it would be cool to see IDW's take.

It's possible, sure!

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-18-2016, 02:24 PM
Hey, another question; when should we be looking for an announcement on the details and summary of TMNT universe's first story arc?

Bobby Curnow
04-18-2016, 03:32 PM
August Previews should be out in mid-May. Beyond that I'm not sure if you're going to get much more than that.

Joey Kamikaze
04-18-2016, 10:56 PM
I'm going to do my letter to the editor the lazy way. Okay to print:

Hi, Bobby and everyone at IDW! I've been reading since I found #1 at Floating World Comics when I lived in Portland. Your book and every micro, mini and crossover has followed me every month across a couple more states since. Thanks for creating such a high quality, "ultimate" version of the TMNT, one that uses all 30+ years of their lore while still trying new things too. It's what I wanted from the property for years before y'all made it happen.

But instead of boring general praise, have some specific adulation: I love the crossovers. I grew up with the old Archie and Mirage books, so I'm used to seeing the boys meet other comic characters. Ghostbusters and Batman have been great; the X-Files tie-in gave me nostalgia. Let me suggest hunting down the Infestation tie-ins to anyone who's jumped on the book more recently; that TMNT/Cthulhu mythos story was one of my favorites the first year, but it wasn't collected in the TMNT trades so it's easy to miss.

Crossovers have always been a TMNT comic tradition, and it's great to see IDW stepping up to the plate, even if not all of the results are "canon." If you're planning future crossovers... Might I suggest TMNT Meet Afterlife With Archie, for old time's sake?

Looking forward to Bebop & Rocksteady Destroy Everything, and especially the TMNT Universe ongoing! I'm so ready for a Tales-like companion to the IDW book.

-The Czar of the Northwest

Bruz
04-19-2016, 08:21 PM
Bobby, what's up with Peter Laird's annotations in The Ultimate Collection vol. 6? He seemed really bitchy and uninterested, and had nothing at all to say in the last 2 stories. Conversely, Kevin at least offered a lot of insight, even in the stories he didn't have much to do with. Peter's comments (or lack-there-of) made a bad impression on me. The turtles made him rich and famous, but disregarding them like this can only result in him losing fans. If he had nothing to say, why even agree to partake in this?

Powder
04-19-2016, 08:25 PM
:tlol: I doubt he's gonna lose fans over it. We've all known his personality to be that way for like 15 years at least. He's tired as hell of the TMNT, & makes no bones about it.

CyberCubed
04-19-2016, 08:47 PM
Most of Ultimate Collection 6 consisted of short back-ups from various Mirage artists and from the Shell Shock trade, so PL didn't have anything to do with the writing/art of most of those. Its understandable he wouldn't have much to say about them. Also he posts his opinions in a blunt manner, but you can tell how much he appreciated the art and stories since he usually complimented the artist who created them.

If there is ever an Ultimate Collection 7 I'd be more than happy to see both Kevin/Pete back again for commentary.

Bobby Curnow
04-19-2016, 09:47 PM
Bobby, what's up with Peter Laird's annotations in The Ultimate Collection vol. 6? He seemed really bitchy and uninterested, and had nothing at all to say in the last 2 stories. Conversely, Kevin at least offered a lot of insight, even in the stories he didn't have much to do with. Peter's comments (or lack-there-of) made a bad impression on me. The turtles made him rich and famous, but disregarding them like this can only result in him losing fans. If he had nothing to say, why even agree to partake in this?

I have nothing to do with the Ultimate Collections, and confess I haven't even got around to reading the annotations in that book. If I were to hazard a guess, he agreed to do commentary for all of the books, but just didn't have much to say about the material in that volume. And Peter, as far as I can tell, has never been shy about stating his opinion. Which is a good thing, I think.

Anyway, your guess is as good as mine.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-20-2016, 01:47 PM
Bobby, just a silly little curiosity here; do we know what each of the individual turtle's favorite Pizza toppings are? Oh, and I know it's not important, but might there ever be a chance we'll find out what Yoshi's four sons real names were?

Bobby Curnow
04-20-2016, 02:03 PM
Bobby, just a silly little curiosity here; do we know what each of the individual turtle's favorite Pizza toppings are? Oh, and I know it's not important, but might there ever be a chance we'll find out what Yoshi's four sons real names were?

Ha, I have no clue!

No plans for their real names-- it strikes me as something that doesn't need to be known. If there's a story reason for it in the future, then sure!

ProphetofGanja
04-20-2016, 02:34 PM
Bobby, just a silly little curiosity here; do we know what each of the individual turtle's favorite Pizza toppings are? Oh, and I know it's not important, but might there ever be a chance we'll find out what Yoshi's four sons real names were?

Ha, I have no clue!

No plans for their real names-- it strikes me as something that doesn't need to be known. If there's a story reason for it in the future, then sure!

I bet you could go back and list every reference made by the turtles to pizza or pizza toppings and tally them up and come up with some guesses

Erik Burnham
04-20-2016, 06:06 PM
This is probably true, but I just wanted to ask to confirm; were the flyborgs that Baxter Stockman created a tribute to Baxter's two fates in the two previous TMNT shows? (fly in Fred Wolf, cyborg in 4kids?)

Tribute to previous Baxter fates in general (he got cyborged up in the comics first, IIRC)

So, yep.

(Besides, the term FLYBORG is just too daggone much fun to type and also say. Heh.)

THGhost
04-20-2016, 06:25 PM
Hi Bobby,

This has no doubt been asked a thousand times already but, will IDW be reprinting Image Volume 3 once they're finished with Tales of the TMNT Volume 2? Feel free to refer me to a previous answer if need be.

Bobby Curnow
04-20-2016, 06:30 PM
No worries! The answer is I don't know at this time. I've heard various things pointing in both directions.

THGhost
04-20-2016, 06:32 PM
No worries! The answer is I don't know at this time. I've heard various things pointing in both directions.

Okay. Fingers crossed. Thanks. :tcool:

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-20-2016, 10:44 PM
Tribute to previous Baxter fates in general (he got cyborged up in the comics first, IIRC)

So, yep.

(Besides, the term FLYBORG is just too daggone much fun to type and also say. Heh.)

Thanks! They were an awesome army of grunts to give Baxter, far more effective than JUST the mousers!

Sewer Turd
04-22-2016, 02:28 PM
I noticed that the 2012 tmnt annual will actually be collected in the upcoming tmnt idw collection vol 3... could you confirm that the annual will be collected in full colour rather than black and white? Thanx

neatoman
04-22-2016, 02:44 PM
So I was joking about this in the #57 preview thread, but what's the deal with Utrom mohawks? Kleve has one and so does a few others.

Bobby Curnow
04-22-2016, 03:32 PM
I noticed that the 2012 tmnt annual will actually be collected in the upcoming tmnt idw collection vol 3... could you confirm that the annual will be collected in full colour rather than black and white? Thanx

I don't know, and likely won't until the book is completed. Sorry!

Bobby Curnow
04-22-2016, 03:32 PM
So I was joking about this in the #57 preview thread, but what's the deal with Utrom mohawks? Kleve has one and so does a few others.

Utroms have weird anatomy!

Utrommaniac
04-22-2016, 03:37 PM
So I was joking about this in the #57 preview thread, but what's the deal with Utrom mohawks? Kleve has one and so does a few others.

http://passel.unl.edu/Image/siteImages/PunnettSquarePlainLG.gif
The answer is "aa" No wait, it's "AA" (since it's probably a dominant phenotype like cleft chins/dimples/freckles in humans)

I have my own explanation that I might have to take somewhere else. I want to make an entire retrospect on Utrom biology, and the mohawk thing is just a small part of it.

AquaParade
04-22-2016, 03:38 PM
I noticed that the 2012 tmnt annual will actually be collected in the upcoming tmnt idw collection vol 3... could you confirm that the annual will be collected in full colour rather than black and white? Thanx

I just love Kevin's tmnt art. I would love to see him team up with Tom more often on the book. No question, just commenting.

Utrommaniac
04-23-2016, 07:18 PM
I had to make sure I hadn't asked this yet, but it's been another boggler.

Whatever happened to the Utrom that was killed when Karai took its Ooze? Did Krang have it preserved so it could have a proper burial once the others were revived, or was it done immediately and he had just planned to break the bad news without any ceremony?

I personally suspect Baxter Stockman might have tried to steal it under Krang's nonexistent nose to study it, personally. Speaking of nonexistent noses, how do Utroms even smell? (DON'T. I know you want to!) (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=in7yLZJ7A6Y)

Bobby Curnow
04-24-2016, 11:25 AM
That's unknown, but my guess is that he got rid of the body in some efficient but respectful manner.

Zage
04-24-2016, 01:46 PM
What are the chances of possibly seeing previously unreleased character, in the new continuity? Such as the Selected, or Kirby, or others?

Powder
04-24-2016, 01:52 PM
Viacom does not known The Selected, that's Ryan Brown's property, which he never even published.

neatoman
04-24-2016, 03:45 PM
So I should probably ask Erik about this, and it's probably coincidental anyway, but was the Baxter Stockman backstory inspired by the backstory of Seto Kaiba?

It's just that I noticed certain parallels like the chess playing father and the son tricking him out of his company using the skills he taught him.
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_145.jpg
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_146.jpg
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_147.jpg
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_148.jpg

Bobby Curnow
04-24-2016, 04:43 PM
What are the chances of possibly seeing previously unreleased character, in the new continuity? Such as the Selected, or Kirby, or others?

I'm not exactly sure what you mean by "unreleased" but I would imagine it would differ from character to character. I would also imagine, if I'm understanding correctly, that it would not be worth the hassle to try and get legal approval to use such a character.

Bobby Curnow
04-24-2016, 04:44 PM
So I should probably ask Erik about this, and it's probably coincidental anyway, but was the Baxter Stockman backstory inspired by the backstory of Seto Kaiba?


Yeah, you'd have to ask him, but I would imagine it's coincidental.

psychturtle
04-25-2016, 08:16 AM
Now that Godzilla: Oblivion is up and running, when will we see a Godzilla/TMNT crossover? Both stories have capabilities of time travel to different universes. This may sound odd but if the right creative juices are flowing, it could work. Krang tries to harness Godzilla to destroy the planet but Turtles have to stop krang. Nothing too sophisticated but fun.

funatic
04-25-2016, 08:55 AM
Now that Godzilla: Oblivion is up and running, when will we see a Godzilla/TMNT crossover? Both stories have capabilities of time travel to different universes. This may sound odd but if the right creative juices are flowing, it could work. Krang tries to harness Godzilla to destroy the planet but Turtles have to stop krang. Nothing too sophisticated but fun.

Man I'd kill to see James Stokoe do that crossover! He's done a few arcs for Godzilla and his art is absolutely insane. His main series Orc Stain is one of the few comics I've collected in singles outside of TMNT. I bet his turtles would look amazing.

Bobby Curnow
04-25-2016, 09:31 AM
Now that Godzilla: Oblivion is up and running, when will we see a Godzilla/TMNT crossover? Both stories have capabilities of time travel to different universes. This may sound odd but if the right creative juices are flowing, it could work. Krang tries to harness Godzilla to destroy the planet but Turtles have to stop krang. Nothing too sophisticated but fun.

Toho is against any sort of crossover, so I feel confident saying it won't happen any time soon.

psychturtle
04-25-2016, 02:01 PM
Well crap. Would have been perfect! So much lines up right now with the stories (e.g. dimensional travel). Maybe they will make the exception given how well Batman/TMNT has done.

Bobby Curnow
04-25-2016, 03:42 PM
I don't think so. We've proposed crossovers between Godzilla and bigger properties than TMNT, and they've gone nowhere.

But who knows, maybe Toho will change their approach some day.

neatoman
04-25-2016, 03:45 PM
Any idea which companies are cool with you making crossovers and which ones aren't?

Bobby Curnow
04-25-2016, 05:04 PM
Yes, but it's not something I can get into here, and every situation comes with it's own particular set of road blocks, so there's no simple answer.

Anima Gemini
04-25-2016, 07:02 PM
Yes, but it's not something I can get into here, and every situation comes with it's own particular set of road blocks, so there's no simple answer.

I just wanted to say that I appreciate all the effort you've put into making things like that happen, despite the many road blocks in the way. I also appreciate the fact that you don't just do crossovers for the sake of doing them, and the thoughtful care that's been put into them. How well things like TMNT/Ghostbusters turned out are a testament to that. Thank you! :tgrin:

Bobby Curnow
04-26-2016, 12:21 AM
Ha, don't thank me. In theory I'm against crossovers, except my precious dream of Usagi/TMNT. They just always feel like cashgrabs to me. But I will say working on Ghostbusters/TMNT was a delight and I'm happy it happened and I got to work on it. Same for Batman/TMNT. They ended up fun despite my cynicism!

But point is, I've not done much to encourage them, so your thanks should be pointed elsewhere! Nice to hear though.

Powder
04-26-2016, 02:32 AM
Given there's a small chance it could one day happen, an answer to that question would be a potential spoiler. So I doubt Bobby will want to go into it. But, for what it's worth, while Pete has stated those crossovers are Mirage canon, Stan has gone on to say that he does not consider them canon for Usagi's universe. So I imagine were he to agree to something, it'd be it's own endeavor, no strings attached.

Bobby Curnow
04-26-2016, 08:30 AM
I would see it as you suggested, where Usagi recognizes them, but the IDW Turtles don't know Usagi. And of course, yes, it would be up to Stan to decide how canonical the meeting was for Usagi.

CyberCubed
04-26-2016, 12:37 PM
I figure the people over at the Nick cartoon have been pushing for an Usagi crossover too. Maybe Viacom can somehow convince him to let Usagi appear in both the Nick cartoon and IDW comic.

Stan Sakai and Peter Laird are close friends hence why Usagi appeared in Mirage, the original cartoon and 2k3 series, but now that PL sold the property I don't think Stan Sakai feels comfortable with letting people write Usagi who he doesn't know about. Shame, I also wonder what Usagi would look like in CG in the Nick cartoon too...

Anima Gemini
04-26-2016, 11:37 PM
Ha, don't thank me. In theory I'm against crossovers, except my precious dream of Usagi/TMNT. They just always feel like cashgrabs to me. But I will say working on Ghostbusters/TMNT was a delight and I'm happy it happened and I got to work on it. Same for Batman/TMNT. They ended up fun despite my cynicism!

But point is, I've not done much to encourage them, so your thanks should be pointed elsewhere! Nice to hear though.

Well, the way I see it, perhaps it's that healthy cynicism that it partially to thank for raising the bar and helping to avoid the pitfalls of cashgrabiness. So, thanks for that.

And as far as pointing my thanks elsewhere, a huge thank you goes out to Tom, Erik, and everyone else over there for making such great stories and helping to elevate crossovers as well. Thanks, guys!

Oh, one more thing: If Stan doesn't want to do a new Usagi crossover, what about Space Usagi? I think that would be really original and fun! Just my two cents. :tsmile:

Bobby Curnow
04-27-2016, 12:37 AM
Ha, I'd totally be down for Space Usagi... in Dimension X!

neatoman
04-27-2016, 04:16 AM
Ha, I'd totally be down for Space Usagi... in Dimension X!

Wouldn't that be Jedi Bucky O'Hare?

Anyway, seeing how Usagi does seem unlikely in the first place, have you guys thought about creating a subsitute character? You know, similar enough for fans to get what's going on but just different enough to avoid legal trouble?

ProphetofGanja
04-27-2016, 08:38 AM
Is #57 still being released today? I can not find it on comixology

old_hob88
04-27-2016, 08:45 AM
Is #57 still being released today? I can not find it on comixology

Me neither :/ it should be coming out today since the preview was up last friday. Maybe a bug in comixology?

ToTheNines
04-27-2016, 08:48 AM
Wouldn't that be
Anyway, seeing how Usagi does seem unlikely in the first place, have you guys thought about creating a subsitute character? You know, similar enough for fans to get what's going on but just different enough to avoid legal trouble?

I would hate nothing more.

ProphetofGanja
04-27-2016, 09:05 AM
Me neither :/ it should be coming out today since the preview was up last friday. Maybe a bug in comixology?

Now I'm on the website on my computer and I found it but it's still listed as a pre-order

Bobby Curnow
04-27-2016, 10:41 AM
Wouldn't that be Jedi Bucky O'Hare?

Anyway, seeing how Usagi does seem unlikely in the first place, have you guys thought about creating a subsitute character? You know, similar enough for fans to get what's going on but just different enough to avoid legal trouble?

That would hold zero appeal for me. Everything great about Usagi as a character comes from the thought and care that Stan Sakai puts into creating it. I honestly don't think I could live with myself if we did something like that! (sorry, Usagi is a long time inspiration for me! I feel strongly about that book!)

Bobby Curnow
04-27-2016, 10:42 AM
Is #57 still being released today? I can not find it on comixology

As far as I know it should, though I do know Diamond has had some shipping problems for our books recently. I had not heard that #57 was affected. But I have not heard it wasn't, either!

ProphetofGanja
04-27-2016, 12:17 PM
As far as I know it should, though I do know Diamond has had some shipping problems for our books recently. I had not heard that #57 was affected. But I have not heard it wasn't, either!

Yeah for whatever reason comixology is listing it's release date as May 4th :ohwell:

mrmaczaps
04-27-2016, 12:48 PM
No Ghostbusters today either! Major bummer!

neatoman
04-27-2016, 02:32 PM
I have a few questions I thought up when reading through these other ones.


Shredder's armor in Turtles in Time #4 is the same as in the Shredder Micro, is the implication that he gained that armor in the afterlife or before?
In that same issue we saw a bunch of clones of Bebop and Rocksteady, were the original Bebop/Rocksteady dead by that time and why make so many clones?
I'm not saying it's even remotely bad to pull ideas from different versions, it's actually pretty awesome but does it ever feel weird? For example, Hun was more or less created to replace Bebop and Rocksteady, yet now he's depicted as co-existing with them. Again, not bad but does it feel weird to mix and match elements that were mostly intended to be completely separate?

Bobby Curnow
04-27-2016, 04:19 PM
Bobby, since this is something covered way back in the Shredder micro, and not a spoiler for a future story, I'll ask... Following his Splinter-aided Seppakku, is Oroku Saki now currently ruling over that afterlife for lost warriors, as was shown in the micro issue?

Good question! I can see us going either way on revisiting that afterlife, so i'll abstain from answering since it could happen. Would be interesting to see if anything has changed in that cycle.

Bobby Curnow
04-27-2016, 04:25 PM
I have a few questions I thought up when reading through these other ones.


Shredder's armor in Turtles in Time #4 is the same as in the Shredder Micro, is the implication that he gained that armor in the afterlife or before?
In that same issue we saw a bunch of clones of Bebop and Rocksteady, were the original Bebop/Rocksteady dead by that time and why make so many clones?
I'm not saying it's even remotely bad to pull ideas from different versions, it's actually pretty awesome but does it ever feel weird? For example, Hun was more or less created to replace Bebop and Rocksteady, yet now he's depicted as co-existing with them. Again, not bad but does it feel weird to mix and match elements that were mostly intended to be completely separate?


1. You're the first person I've seen pick up on that! Much like the previous question, I'll hold on answering it as we might find out more in the future. (but might not!)
2. While you won't get a concrete answer, you may get a hint as to the answer to this question in a comic this year. Stay tuned.
3. I personally don't find it weird, no, as long as the characters are modified in such a way where they still 'make sense' as that character, but are changed enough to fit into the IDW universe. I suspect those of us on the inside of making this comic are the wrong people to ask. I guess i'd be curious if YOU thought it's weird. I could see how that could be the case.

neatoman
04-27-2016, 05:04 PM
1. You're the first person I've seen pick up on that! Much like the previous question, I'll hold on answering it as we might find out more in the future. (but might not!)
2. While you won't get a concrete answer, you may get a hint as to the answer to this question in a comic this year. Stay tuned.
3. I personally don't find it weird, no, as long as the characters are modified in such a way where they still 'make sense' as that character, but are changed enough to fit into the IDW universe. I suspect those of us on the inside of making this comic are the wrong people to ask. I guess i'd be curious if YOU thought it's weird. I could see how that could be the case.

I don't find it weird in context of the comics themselves, if I read them without without much knowledge of older TMNT material I would most likely never even think about it. It all feels like it belongs in the same world, it's not like you just took the old Bebop/Rocksteady and threw them into stories with Hun, THIS Bebop/Rocksteady and THIS Hun feel like they are part of the same world.

It's only weird when you consider the real life backstory. Mirage and FW basically gave each other the finger for a decade, FW and 4Kids had very different ideas of how to make TMNT for kids, so seeing their ideas come together now seems weird when you know all this.

Edit: I realise that mixing ideas like this is fairly common practice when you let new authors freedom to mess around with an old franchise, so it wasn't unexpected that it would happen after Peter sold the rights. When the Mirage fans, the generation that grew up with FW and the generation that grew up with 4Kids all work together you can pretty much expect this sort of hybrid, which I did. The only thing that makes it weird is that it wasn't really allowed to happen for such a long time...

Erik Burnham
04-28-2016, 03:17 PM
So I should probably ask Erik about this, and it's probably coincidental anyway, but was the Baxter Stockman backstory inspired by the backstory of Seto Kaiba?

It's just that I noticed certain parallels like the chess playing father and the son tricking him out of his company using the skills he taught him.
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_145.jpg
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_146.jpg
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_147.jpg
http://z.mfcdn.net/store/manga/291/05-040.0/compressed/05_148.jpg

Total coincidence!

I like chess -- but don't have the patience for it. I retained just enough knowledge to have Bobby tell me just how mixed up I was once or twice. (;

Erik Burnham
04-28-2016, 03:21 PM
Total coincidence!

I like chess -- but don't have the patience for it. I retained just enough knowledge to have Bobby tell me just how mixed up I was once or twice. (;

I should note that once or twice is also the average amount of times Bobby tells me I'm mixed up on any given project, so I'm glad to stay at par.

psychturtle
04-28-2016, 09:45 PM
How much would it cost to get the #8 color classic license with Cerberus? Just wondered

Need color classic fugitoid :)

Ninjinister
04-28-2016, 10:37 PM
I don't remember Bebop and Rocksteady being cloned. When was this?

Xav
04-28-2016, 11:41 PM
Like he said Turtles in Time #4.

Ninjinister
04-29-2016, 12:03 AM
Like he said Turtles in Time #4.

I missed the "in the same issue part"

I don't remember this happening at all though.

neatoman
04-29-2016, 04:33 AM
Total coincidence!

I like chess -- but don't have the patience for it. I retained just enough knowledge to have Bobby tell me just how mixed up I was once or twice. (;

Ok thanks!
... Does Baxter play trading card games though? :lol:

I missed the "in the same issue part"

I don't remember this happening at all though.

When Shredder shows up to attack, he has a posse of Bebop and Rocksteady clones with him. They are right here:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-EB8QAFqc7Ew/VBotoRgTvwI/AAAAAAAAOPc/XL0jn-_hFus/s1600/4-4.jpg

Bobby Curnow
04-29-2016, 10:47 AM
How much would it cost to get the #8 color classic license with Cerberus? Just wondered

Need color classic fugitoid :)

I wouldn't know offhand.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-30-2016, 10:55 PM
Not a question about what's going to directly in the book, but about TMNT in general; In any TMNT continuity, do you believe the mantle of the shredder should be something that passes from person to person, or should belong to Oroku Saki exclusively?

Bobby Curnow
04-30-2016, 11:30 PM
I think either way could work, depending on the circumstances.

Ninjinister
04-30-2016, 11:33 PM
When Shredder shows up to attack, he has a posse of Bebop and Rocksteady clones with him. They are right here:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-EB8QAFqc7Ew/VBotoRgTvwI/AAAAAAAAOPc/XL0jn-_hFus/s1600/4-4.jpg

Hurm. I don't remember that in the slightest. Thanks.

Utrommaniac
05-04-2016, 09:27 PM
When and how did the decision come for Ch'rell to have a sister? Will it ever be specified which one of them is the elder sibling?

Bobby Curnow
05-05-2016, 05:46 PM
I think Tom just wanted to name a character after a big fan of the book who works at IDW, Mariel Romero. And with a tweak it made sense to connect her to Ch'rell.

We haven't talked about who is older.

Utrommaniac
05-05-2016, 06:40 PM
Aww! That's really sweet of him.

Bobby Curnow
05-05-2016, 07:30 PM
Leeshawn is Shawn Lee, our longtime letterer on the book. The other new Utroms I believe are also variations of names of friends of Tom, I believe, though I'm not familiar with them.

Utrommaniac
05-05-2016, 07:32 PM
Ah, so that's why Tom's the name guy :D . Still really awesome of him.

ctt4lfecw
05-06-2016, 04:50 PM
I want to know what Leatherhead has against the Utroms. I mean they were in stasis the whole time he was wandering Burnow. Unless Krang experimented on him?

neatoman
05-06-2016, 04:58 PM
Kitsune called Oroku Saki's sons "our sons", was that in a literal biological sense or did Saki have a human consort on the side? And if Kitsune is indeed their biological mother, is Karai part of that lineage?

Bobby Curnow
05-06-2016, 05:04 PM
I want to know what Leatherhead has against the Utroms. I mean they were in stasis the whole time he was wandering Burnow. Unless Krang experimented on him?

I'll reserve any comment on this matter until next issue comes out!

Bobby Curnow
05-06-2016, 05:07 PM
Kitsune called Oroku Saki's sons "our sons", was that in a literal biological sense or did Saki have a human consort on the side? And if Kitsune is indeed their biological mother, is Karai part of that lineage?

Sounds literal to me, but I suppose it's open to interpretation. Hard to say about Karai. That's one of those areas that we purposefully leave vague-- gives us something to play with in the future if we want to. There's a lot of specifics we have planned out well ahead of time, but I'd say there's just us much we haven't formally decided on so that we can keep things flexible for the future, should we desire to revisit.

neatoman
05-06-2016, 05:15 PM
Speaking of Karai, this might be a silly question but since she is Shredder's "granddaughter" in these comics, could you convince one of the artists to do a Rick and Morty tribute cover featuring the two of them? :lol:

Bobby Curnow
05-06-2016, 05:50 PM
I haven't seen enough Rick and Morty to catch the reference, but I suspect the answer is no!

CyberCubed
05-06-2016, 07:58 PM
Is it a coincidence that Slash knocked out Hun all 3 times they met? It seems every time Hun is causing trouble for the Turtles, Slash is always the one to knock him out.

ctt4lfecw
05-06-2016, 08:38 PM
Is it a coincidence that Slash knocked out Hun all 3 times they met? It seems every time Hun is causing trouble for the Turtles, Slash is always the one to knock him out.

Nice observation!

neatoman
05-07-2016, 04:14 AM
Is it a coincidence that Slash knocked out Hun all 3 times they met? It seems every time Hun is causing trouble for the Turtles, Slash is always the one to knock him out.

If I had to guess myself, I'd say it's because Hun is strong as hell but he's not an idiot who can be tricked like Bebop and Rocksteady, so he has to be taken down with equal or greater force and Slash is the only ally to the turtles who has that kind of power.

Mormegil
05-07-2016, 08:29 AM
Is it a coincidence that Slash knocked out Hun all 3 times they met? It seems every time Hun is causing trouble for the Turtles, Slash is always the one to knock him out.

The third time they fought I thought for sure they were going to have Hun win. Now it's like a thing. Slash is near the top of my favorite character list, I hope he keeps it up.

neatoman
05-07-2016, 01:22 PM
Does April's sister Robyn exist in the IDW-verse?

psychturtle
05-07-2016, 10:07 PM
Will we be getting a new FCBD TMNT issue next year? Would love to hunt one of those down

AquaParade
05-08-2016, 03:13 AM
Bobby, apologies if you've been asked this before, but in your mind (and Tom, I'd love to hear your perspective too), is it 100% certain that the turtles are reincarnated creatures?
Is this also something you guys leave open or do you feel that you have acknowledged it as a basic truth within the story?

One of my favorite elements of the earlier issues was Donatello and Leonardo hashing out their difference of opinion on the matter, basically boiling down to science vs faith. I found it to be really compelling because each side had valid points. Thanks for your time.

ProphetofGanja
05-08-2016, 09:50 AM
bobby, apologies if you've been asked this before, but in your mind (and tom, i'd love to hear your perspective too), is it 100% certain that the turtles are reincarnated creatures?
Is this also something you guys leave open or do you feel that you have acknowledged it as a basic truth within the story?

One of my favorite elements of the earlier issues was donatello and leonardo hashing out their difference of opinion on the matter, basically boiling down to science vs faith. I found it to be really compelling because each side had valid points. Thanks for your time.

an even better question for bobby is; is yoshi the only one truly reincarnated, and the four turtles not really his sons?


:-? :-? :-?