View Full Version : Ask a Question: IDW's TMNT Editor Thread
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
[
9]
10
11
12
13
14
15
neatoman
06-21-2017, 05:51 PM
First off, props to Ninjinister for noticing the mercenaries in U#11 were
The Gang of Four, clues in the two names mentioned and the cyborg mercenary gimmick.
Here's my question, why were they made so different this time around? If it wasn't for Ninjinister pointing it out, I wouldn't have made the connection myself.
TigerClaw
06-21-2017, 05:52 PM
I'm all for Venus, she really deserves a worthy version to remove the bad taste Next Mutation left on the fandom, she's an interesting character on the right hands, and if someone can give her justice is you guys so if you think she has potencial then by all means go all in.
Actually I would love to see Mona Lisa appear in the IDW comics, a proper version of her, that isn't like the version depicted in the Nickelodeon series.
I hope you guys can bring her into the comics, she could be a Mutanimal, however I read that Hobs doesn't take kindly to human born mutants.
Bobby Curnow
06-21-2017, 06:04 PM
First off, props to Ninjinister for noticing the mercenaries in U#11 were
The Gang of Four, clues in the two names mentioned and the cyborg mercenary gimmick.
Here's my question, why were they made so different this time around? If it wasn't for Ninjinister pointing it out, I wouldn't have made the connection myself.
You'd have to ask the writer, Rich Douek, about that. That was all him.
ToTheNines
06-21-2017, 08:02 PM
First off, props to Ninjinister for noticing the mercenaries in U#11 were
The Gang of Four, clues in the two names mentioned and the cyborg mercenary gimmick.
Here's my question, why were they made so different this time around? If it wasn't for Ninjinister pointing it out, I wouldn't have made the connection myself.
All 4 were named.
You'd have to ask the writer, Rich Douek, about that. That was all him.
It pleases me to hear that this was just a reference and not foreshadowing. I would HATE to see the Mutanimals all murdered.
Ninjinister
06-21-2017, 10:08 PM
Does issue U11 have a title?
First off, props to Ninjinister for noticing the mercenaries in U#11 were
The Gang of Four, clues in the two names mentioned and the cyborg mercenary gimmick.
Here's my question, why were they made so different this time around? If it wasn't for Ninjinister pointing it out, I wouldn't have made the connection myself.
I can't take credit for that. I mean, I did notice on my own, but someone else mentioned it in the thread before me and I didn't even see it until later.
ChosenOne
06-21-2017, 10:25 PM
I can't take credit for that. I mean, I did notice on my own, but someone else mentioned it in the thread before me and I didn't even see it until later.
Not sure, but I think that might've been me?
I didn't even know they were called the Gang of Four until today, much less their individual names, as I don't own those particular issues of Archie, but I saw the way they were behaving in Universe #11 and the cybernetic enhancements, and the lightbulb went off in my head. One quick Google search later, just to make sure (mixing up Venus and Mona Lisa once was quite enough as far as TMNT faux pas I want to make around here), and I brought it up on the thread.
Gotta say, these guys were probably the scariest antagonists in the IDW run so far. Sally, Ray and Dreadmon barely escaped... If they ever do come back, I hope they keep their "can-totally-shoot-the-Mutanimals-down-(again)-and-not-even-blink" demeanor.
Ninjinister
06-21-2017, 10:35 PM
Possibly. I rarely notice who's posting unless I need to. Regardless, after I saw Fist and Waster's names, I was like "waiiiit a minute...."
ChosenOne
06-21-2017, 10:38 PM
Possibly. I rarely notice who's posting unless I need to. Regardless, after I saw Fist and Waster's names, I was like "waiiiit a minute...."
On that note, I'm surprised it took this long for anyone to make the connection, given that Fist was named in the preview. I know I would've, if I had known or remembered their names. Then again, I suppose these four particular characters are far more remembered for what they did than what they're called...
ProphetofGanja
06-21-2017, 10:55 PM
Does issue U11 have a title?
The Jersey Devil
Bobby Curnow
06-23-2017, 01:59 PM
Open call for Ninja Notes letters! We're a little light for TMNT #73.
Write here and label as Ninja Notes or into "
[email protected]"
neatoman
06-23-2017, 02:45 PM
Open call for Ninja Notes letters! We're a little light for TMNT #73.
Write here and label as Ninja Notes or into "
[email protected]"
Alright, time to take up space :).
"Greetings to you all, IDW staff and readers alike. Congrats on officially publishing the longest running TMNT comic ever, you really deserve it. This is quite possibly my favorite incarnation of the series yet, interesting stories and fresh takes that feel like they enrich the characters, without ever feeling like it goes too far. Sort of feels like it's somewhere in between the original comics and 2003 show with a lot of stuff added in as well, very seemlessly I might add. If it wasn't for your TMNT comics, I might have given up on TMNT after the 2003 show ended. Keep up the good work!
Sincerely, neatoman of the Technodrome Forums."
Shedder
06-23-2017, 03:02 PM
dear TMNT Team,
First I have to say that I am loving this iteration of the TMNT. You all brought me back from my many year hiatus from the TMNT. They are my little escape back into childhood every month.
I was wondering how has the Ongoing series changed from when you first envisioned it? Did you see it going in one direction and then something came along and completely changed the path? I know the process is a group one but, are there any early ideas that went to the wayside that you can now share as the time for them has passed? Any characters you wanted but just don't work?
Is there any chance any of you making appearances north of the border (other then Kevin who is gracing us again this year. Thank you Kevin!)
My last question is what books do you find inspiration in and what are you currently reading now? do you even have time to read other books?
Thank you all again
Andrew Shead
Ontario, Canada
Open call for Ninja Notes letters! We're a little light for TMNT #73.
Write here and label as Ninja Notes or into "
[email protected]"
Sent! Thanks for the opportunity Bobby.
funatic
06-24-2017, 12:41 AM
Sent! Thanks for the opportunity Bobby.
Seeing as how you have your own variant cover for the issue I hope you make it in! :D
DestronMirage22
06-24-2017, 01:12 AM
I know reprintings isn't really your department, but do you know or have heard if there's any plans to reprint in some way some of the old TMNT manga? It would be awesome having physical copies of those stories translated in English.
dawwe
06-24-2017, 10:54 PM
Now I can't speak for IDW or Bobby but while it would be nice to see some of the manga overe here I'm pretty sure that it's not going to happen. At least not any time in the near future. It might even be caught up in some legal stuff, but I can't be sure. But hey, never say never.
Seeing as how you have your own variant cover for the issue I hope you make it in! :D
:tgrin: that would be sweet!
Bobby Curnow
06-25-2017, 07:30 PM
I know reprintings isn't really your department, but do you know or have heard if there's any plans to reprint in some way some of the old TMNT manga? It would be awesome having physical copies of those stories translated in English.
I haven't heard that mentioned ever, so I don't think so.
DestronMirage22
06-26-2017, 02:52 PM
I haven't heard that mentioned ever, so I don't think so.
Aw that's too bad.
Thanks for the response though! :D
DevilSpooky
06-26-2017, 05:33 PM
Speaking of foreigner reprints, any chance of reprints of the Fleetway comics that where released on Europe together with the Archie originals? Some of those had stories on par with the current Amazing Adventures comics and they had gorgeous art and would deserve to be put on trades for everyone to enjoy. I know it's not really your department but are those even possible for you guys to pursue?
Bobby Curnow
06-26-2017, 05:45 PM
No clue, sorry.
DevilSpooky
06-27-2017, 08:28 AM
No clue, sorry.
That's ok, I got my hopes up because I just found out you guys released reprints of some UK only comics from Transformers a couple of years back so I figured that TMNT could get the same treatment... :tcry:
CyberCubed
06-27-2017, 12:45 PM
Just curious, will we ever get a Halloween themed issue where the Turtles fight monsters like werewolves/vampires, or one similar to Mirage's in Tales, etc? I realize it can't be done this year, because October's issues will be the Trial of Krang arc, so maybe next year? I remember for a long time people asked about a Christmas issue and then we got one last year.
Bobby Curnow
06-27-2017, 03:50 PM
Maybe, it's possible.
ChosenOne
06-28-2017, 10:03 PM
Just curious, will we ever get a Halloween themed issue where the Turtles fight monsters like werewolves/vampires, or one similar to Mirage's in Tales, etc? I realize it can't be done this year, because October's issues will be the Trial of Krang arc, so maybe next year? I remember for a long time people asked about a Christmas issue and then we got one last year.
Maybe, it's possible.
Well, October 2018 is our one good chance to get a Halloween issue since October 2019 will be issue #99... Not to mention, the last time a question like this was asked, specifically regarding the possibility of more minis/micros alongside the main title and Universe, you (Bobby) were diplomatic enough in your reply to skirt around the fact that Dimension X was already in the works, so... :D
I don't fancy myself a fortuneteller but I also wouldn't be surprised at all if there's a Halloween issue already being planned for 2018, though of course you can't confirm or deny anything. Still, my one request for a Halloween story? Some more Wingnut & Screwloose, even if it's just a teeny tiny cameo!
My birthday is on Halloween too, so it would feel extra special! :tgrin:
ProphetofGanja
06-28-2017, 10:44 PM
I would like to cast another vote in favor of an eventual Halloween issue. The bros don't even have to face any actual supernatural threats (although that would be cool), it would be enough for them to simply be able to get out of the house and wander the streets with others without worrying about their appearance (similar to Mikey at the New Year's Eve costume party in his one-shot).
Also, are we ever going to learn more about Snake Guy??
MikeandRaph87
06-28-2017, 10:58 PM
I would like to cast another vote in favor of an eventual Halloween issue. The bros don't even have to face any actual supernatural threats (although that would be cool), it would be enough for them to simply be able to get out of the house and wander the streets with others without worrying about their appearance (similar to Mikey at the New Year's Eve costume party in his one-shot).
Also, are we ever going to learn more about Snake Guy??
Perhaps have an arc going on and Halloween could be in the background. Similar to #5 showing Christmas decorations. Or even Mike wanting to go to a house for candy after seeing kids do it in costumes. That would be great and not detract from plans!
Thanks for the inclusion of a letter that I submitted,Bobby!
So snake guy was conjured up and sent by Kitsune! That will be my take. Perhaps we can call him Scail Tale?
TurtleWA
06-28-2017, 11:42 PM
Well, October 2018 is our one good chance to get a Halloween issue since October 2019 will be issue #99... Not to mention, the last time a question like this was asked, specifically regarding the possibility of more minis/micros alongside the main title and Universe, you (Bobby) were diplomatic enough in your reply to skirt around the fact that Dimension X was already in the works, so... :D
I don't fancy myself a fortuneteller but I also wouldn't be surprised at all if there's a Halloween issue already being planned for 2018, though of course you can't confirm or deny anything. Still, my one request for a Halloween story? Some more Wingnut & Screwloose, even if it's just a teeny tiny cameo!
My birthday is on Halloween too, so it would feel extra special! :tgrin:
Yeah I second more appearances by wingnut&screwloose. But also Wyrm needs to be in a Halloween issue for sure. I really enjoyed the TMNTU issue with him in it and would be great for a come back!
pferreira
06-29-2017, 09:20 AM
Speaking of foreigner reprints, any chance of reprints of the Fleetway comics that where released on Europe together with the Archie originals? Some of those had stories on par with the current Amazing Adventures comics and they had gorgeous art and would deserve to be put on trades for everyone to enjoy. I know it's not really your department but are those even possible for you guys to pursue?That would be cool. :)
Bobby Curnow
06-29-2017, 11:08 AM
I would like to cast another vote in favor of an eventual Halloween issue. The bros don't even have to face any actual supernatural threats (although that would be cool), it would be enough for them to simply be able to get out of the house and wander the streets with others without worrying about their appearance (similar to Mikey at the New Year's Eve costume party in his one-shot).
Also, are we ever going to learn more about Snake Guy??
Cool, ty for the Halloween input, everyone. It has been duly noted!
I saw the discussion of Snake Guy in the other thread. I'm tempted to say "wait and see!" in this instance, but the truth is there's no plans for him, or anything to learn at this point. Some things we place as very deliberate easter eggs and clues years in advance, and sometimes things are just sort of done in the moment with no major forethought. Then again, sometimes the random things eventually become important, so who knows. In my mind, the snake guy was a mythical creature sent by one of the Pantheon to attack or disrupt the plans of another. Regardless, I wouldn't look too deeply at him. (though this type of note is a sign of deep engagement with the series, and that is always very appreciated!)
ChosenOne
06-29-2017, 11:14 AM
I saw the discussion of Snake Guy in the other thread. I'm tempted to say "wait and see!" in this instance, but the truth is there's no plans for him, or anything to learn at this point. Some things we place as very deliberate easter eggs and clues years in advance, and sometimes things are just sort of done in the moment with no major forethought. Then again, sometimes the random things eventually become important, so who knows. In my mind, the snake guy was a mythical creature sent by one of the Pantheon to attack or disrupt the plans of another. Regardless, I wouldn't look too deeply at him. (though this type of note is a sign of deep engagement with the series, and that is always very appreciated!)
Just one quick question regarding this point, though it probably isn't all that important or even relevant: who is the Pantheon member across from Snakey McSnake in that one panel that was discussed? Is that Chi-You?
Bobby Curnow
06-29-2017, 11:55 AM
I do believe Chi-You was named in the panel description of that panel, yes.
ChosenOne
06-29-2017, 12:42 PM
I do believe Chi-You was named in the panel description of that panel, yes.
Thank you! That puts to rest my doubts about the character's outfit matching Chi-You's.
funatic
06-29-2017, 01:32 PM
Thank you! That puts to rest my doubts about the character's outfit matching Chi-You's.
He probably wanted to change his style up after a few centuries passed, things were smelling a bit like bull dookie so he sent the old duds to the Gothano Laundromat.
ChosenOne
06-29-2017, 01:36 PM
He probably wanted to change his style up after a few centuries passed, things were smelling a bit like bull dookie so he sent the old duds to the Gothano Laundromat.
Gothano, keeper of secrets and laundry slips! :lol:
I could say he's my favorite out of the new Pantheon members, but then there's Toad Baron...
funatic
06-29-2017, 02:07 PM
I could say he's my favorite out of the new Pantheon members, but then there's Toad Baron...
And don't furget Manmoth & Jagwar. I must say, all these newbies are simply DIVINE.
Zog The Magnificent
07-19-2017, 03:20 PM
I can't really tell, how long has it been since #50 in TMNT Universe #12?
Bobby Curnow
07-19-2017, 03:28 PM
That's a good question, and one that we try to avoid nailing down too much so we can keep things flexible. I reserve the right to change this, but unofficially it "feels" like about six months to me.
TigerClaw
07-19-2017, 04:43 PM
With SDCC 2017 being around the corner, can we expect some major announcements, and reveals?
Bobby Curnow
07-19-2017, 04:48 PM
It depends on how you classify "major" but I think so, yes!
In fact, i'm off to the show floor right now! Hope anyone attending comes to the TMNT panel-- Saturday, 11:30-12:30, room 24ABC!
(though the announcement i'm thinking of should actually be tomorrow, I think!)
neatoman
07-20-2017, 07:28 AM
Congratulations on 75 issues and at least a plan for 100! How does it feel?
Bobby Curnow
07-20-2017, 10:04 AM
Great! Most of the time i'm a bit too busy to really process something like that, but we did a signing yesterday and I saw a cover from like, issue #4 or something that I completely forgot we did and I had a laugh with Tom about how we're starting to get old. Conventions are a good time to take stock. There's things we could of course do better, but we're proud.
funatic
07-20-2017, 11:41 AM
Looking forward to all the big panels & announcements this week! & tell Tom we'd love to see him at NYCC this year!
dawwe
07-20-2017, 12:42 PM
You got an exclusive preview for the issue 75 Ben Bates variant cover for us here? Or do you perhaps know when it will be previewed?
neatoman
07-20-2017, 06:21 PM
How long was TMNT/Ghostbusters 2 planned?
Bobby Curnow
07-21-2017, 10:59 AM
You got an exclusive preview for the issue 75 Ben Bates variant cover for us here? Or do you perhaps know when it will be previewed?
Not till the issue comes out, unless Ben posts it himself.
Bobby Curnow
07-21-2017, 11:00 AM
How long was TMNT/Ghostbusters 2 planned?
I would imagine Erik and Tom have had some ideas percolating in their head for a while, you'd have to ask them. But we took on the project earlier in the year, so it's only been on my radar for about that time. Should be fun!
AlZarkovski
07-21-2017, 11:40 AM
Hello, Bobby!
I'm so impressed with the upcoming crossover! Really can't wait! :lol:
I have a small question. Sorry, I know that asking about future releases is a bad tone, but... In December will be the 30th anniversary of the Fred Wolf series. Do you have any plans for this? One-short, maybe? Or special cover?
Utrommaniac
07-21-2017, 06:12 PM
So, I'm not sure if this is something that will be explained (not even sure if I remember asking at this point), but how was Krang able to contact Hakk-r from within a high security prison? And not only that, but pay him to do his bidding?
myconius
07-21-2017, 07:56 PM
Hello Bobby, :)
since the Turtles have parted ways with Master Splinter and The Foot Clan (except for Leo. SHHHHHHHH!)
...has April O'Neil still been hanging around Foot Clan Headquarters deciphering the Pantheon Scrolls?
and if so, has April and Jenika met one another?
they seem so opposite in their upbringing, just wondering what their interactions must be like?
Bobby Curnow
07-23-2017, 11:10 PM
Hello, Bobby!
I'm so impressed with the upcoming crossover! Really can't wait! :lol:
I have a small question. Sorry, I know that asking about future releases is a bad tone, but... In December will be the 30th anniversary of the Fred Wolf series. Do you have any plans for this? One-short, maybe? Or special cover?
No, no plans. Sorry!
Bobby Curnow
07-23-2017, 11:11 PM
So, I'm not sure if this is something that will be explained (not even sure if I remember asking at this point), but how was Krang able to contact Hakk-r from within a high security prison? And not only that, but pay him to do his bidding?
You'll have to read to find out, but I think it's safe to assume that Krang has a lot of connections still in Dimension X.
Bobby Curnow
07-23-2017, 11:12 PM
Hello Bobby, :)
since the Turtles have parted ways with Master Splinter and The Foot Clan (except for Leo. SHHHHHHHH!)
...has April O'Neil still been hanging around Foot Clan Headquarters deciphering the Pantheon Scrolls?
and if so, has April and Jenika met one another?
they seem so opposite in their upbringing, just wondering what their interactions must be like?
We'll find out a bit more about what April has been up to very soon!
ToTheNines
07-25-2017, 07:14 AM
That's a good question, and one that we try to avoid nailing down too much so we can keep things flexible. I reserve the right to change this, but unofficially it "feels" like about six months to me.
So with April's graduation putting Vengeance in May, 6 months later would put Karai's Path a month before #65. Obviously it's separated from the main narrative enough that that's fine, but would you say it's flexible enough to be more like 8/9 months? That way the numbering for Universe stays sequential and I'd say it's still early enough in the year for it to be snowing in the Prey backup.
And while I'm bugging you about continuity, is it safe to share when the Usagi crossover is taking place?
Bobby Curnow
07-25-2017, 10:58 AM
I'm not sure I follow why Karai's path would need to be before #65. It should be around the same time as the current ongoing arc, #71/72. (and could be that April graduated early) But regardless, none of this is official, so feel free to place it where you see fit!
I'd put Usagi/TMNT in-between #72 and #73.
ToTheNines
07-25-2017, 11:10 AM
#65 is December 24th and I was calling Vengeance as being in May, so six months would have been November. But yeah, her graduation is flexible, could have been early or even late/summertime. I'm sure I had other reasons, just been too busy to keep notes lately.
Thanks man!
ChosenOne
07-26-2017, 11:52 AM
Were the visual similarities between Marvel's Sinister Six and the Pantheon in #72 deliberate, or just accidental? Particularly in regards to the cover, which evokes several Sinister Six covers over the years, and the way they stalked the Turtles.
It's funny if we think the Pantheon has their very own Doc Ock (Gothano choking Raph with his tentacle), Kraven (hunter/tracker Jagwar), Vulture (Aka being the only flier there) and Mysterio (Kitsune with her mist and mind games). Even Manmoth resembles Rhino in a way.
Bobby Curnow
07-26-2017, 12:20 PM
Ha, I was a big Sinister Six fan as a kid, so maybe you're onto something that was in my subconscious (can't speak to Kevin and Tom). Never crossed my mind though until this message.
phillytmnt
07-26-2017, 03:52 PM
Hello Bobby,
I have a question about the latest story arch. Why would Kitsune wanna resurrect her father by using Saki's body? Wasn't Saki her lover? I get that she was secretly preparing Saki to be the vessel for her father. But it seemed like she actually loved Saki himself by the way she talked about him when she stole his body. It seems weird that she would want to use Saki to bring back her father instead of another person.
Also will Splinter and the foot come back into play this year and will Kitsune make another move against him?
Thanks!
Bobby Curnow
07-26-2017, 04:02 PM
Good questions, but unfortunately I can't speak too much to them as they spoil future stories. But I can confirm that we'll see Splinter and the Foot before the end of the year at least!
neatoman
07-26-2017, 04:09 PM
How about that Usagi story? Where does it take place?
Bobby Curnow
07-26-2017, 04:34 PM
I'd put Usagi/TMNT in-between #72 and #73.
Utrommaniac
07-26-2017, 04:50 PM
Man, somebody better be sure those poor boys are getting some good naps between all this stuff :lol: . They're busy!
neatoman
07-26-2017, 04:57 PM
Man, somebody better be sure those poor boys are getting some good naps between all this stuff :lol: . They're busy!
Yeah, now I'm imagining that they pop out of existance right in front of Baxter and the gang.
Baxter: Oh crap! Did I just lean back on a button?
CyberCubed
07-27-2017, 03:10 PM
What's the general "power levels" of the Pantheon? Is there one character, like Gothano for example, who is stronger than the rest? Or is it Aka since she seems the oldest and most wise? Since they're all immortal God like creatures I wonder how strong they're intended to be.
Is Jagwar any stronger than a regular mutant? I'm kinda curious how strong these characters are intended to be compared to mortals.
neatoman
07-27-2017, 04:09 PM
I noticed that Manmoth covers his trunk up with cloth, Elephant Man reference?
http://www.sitemason.com/files/x1L43K/ElephantManweb.jpg/main.jpg
Bobby Curnow
07-27-2017, 05:07 PM
What's the general "power levels" of the Pantheon? Is there one character, like Gothano for example, who is stronger than the rest? Or is it Aka since she seems the oldest and most wise? Since they're all immortal God like creatures I wonder how strong they're intended to be.
Is Jagwar any stronger than a regular mutant? I'm kinda curious how strong these characters are intended to be compared to mortals.
Can't really get into any of this as finding out will be part of the fun of future appearances.
Bobby Curnow
07-27-2017, 05:08 PM
I noticed that Manmoth covers his trunk up with cloth, Elephant Man reference?
http://www.sitemason.com/files/x1L43K/ElephantManweb.jpg/main.jpg
You'd have to ask Dave Wacther, that's nothing we noted in the script.
Andrew NDB
07-29-2017, 02:06 AM
Not TMNT-related, but maybe you have an answer or can venture a guess. Do you have any idea why IDW's "Highlander: The American Dream" hasn't been appearing on the charts since #1? These ones, of course: http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales.html
The series is already wrapped with #5, but it's strangely absent from the charts since #1 back in February, I think.
Utrommaniac
07-30-2017, 12:02 AM
So, I noticed that Shawn Lee changed the font used for Hakk-R's speech changed.
http://i.imgur.com/A7S1ruD.png
http://i.imgur.com/xfV6Dpz.png
Is there any particular reason for that? My guess is that the newer version is just easier to read, from my perspective as a graphic design student. It even looks to be the same that's used for Fugitod's speech.
I'm also enjoying the completely different characterization from Hakk-R than I thought it have, just from looking at the interior of its ship. With books everywhere and its tea (how does it even drink it? It's got metal where its mouth should be) and its musical commentary with just a little bit of a sadistic edge. Reading with its legs crossed. I wasn't expecting that, but I love it :lol: . Here I thought it would be broody and skulking around, especially after its appearance in the FCBD issue. I'm actually relieved it didn't end up that way?
Bobby Curnow
07-31-2017, 05:42 AM
Not TMNT-related, but maybe you have an answer or can venture a guess. Do you have any idea why IDW's "Highlander: The American Dream" hasn't been appearing on the charts since #1? These ones, of course: http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales.html
The series is already wrapped with #5, but it's strangely absent from the charts since #1 back in February, I think.
Didn't chart high enough? No clue.
Bobby Curnow
07-31-2017, 05:43 AM
So, I noticed that Shawn Lee changed the font used for Hakk-R's speech changed.
Is there any particular reason for that? My guess is that the newer version is just easier to read, from my perspective as a graphic design student. It even looks to be the same that's used for Fugitod's speech.
Yeah, Shawn just ended up liking the new font more.
AquaParade
07-31-2017, 12:21 PM
Bobby, have you guys ever considered using Kevin's art for the ongoing interiors? You do a great job of incorporating his work on the covers, annuals, etc. but I'm curious as to whether this ever came up as a possibility.
Also, are you hoping to see more Eastman interiors in a future annual?
Bobby Curnow
08-01-2017, 04:25 AM
Kevin did an issue a few years back-- #21 I think? Right before City Fall.
Kevin's got a lot of other responsibilities, and he's always hit his deadlines for me, but sometimes it's been preeettty close. Would need a good deal of lead time, and that's not something we've had for a while. So, no plans at the moment, but hopefully one day again!
TMNTChris1980
08-01-2017, 11:00 PM
Hi Bobby,
I've seen Eric Talbot talk about wanting to do some IDW stuff. Any plans for having him do an issue or 2. I personally would love to see it, but he also has a huge fan following.
Bobby Curnow
08-02-2017, 05:59 AM
Hi Bobby,
I've seen Eric Talbot talk about wanting to do some IDW stuff. Any plans for having him do an issue or 2. I personally would love to see it, but he also has a huge fan following.
No plans at this time.
ChosenOne
08-02-2017, 09:34 AM
Will Stockman, Tragg and Granitor appear or at the very least be mentioned in Trial of Krang? It would make sense for the prosecution to retrieve them as witnesses, seeing as how they were Krang's accomplices in not only building the Technodrome but also various atrocities in Dimension X itself.
Utrommaniac
08-02-2017, 09:39 AM
I didn't really think of that, myself.
Now, Ma'riell joining the prosecution feels like it's going to create some major shakeups with the Utroms, especially those who were in the military. "Well, I know my brother is going to be p*ssed as all getout when he finds out Krang is in prison...guess I have to aggravate him more by making sure Krang stays there."
Something's going rotten in the state of Burnow Island.
CyberCubed
08-02-2017, 01:33 PM
Regarding Leatherhead and the Neutrinos coming to pick him up on Earth, was there a potential Universe issue about that planned before the start of the current arc that was scraped or considered? The flashback of Leatherhead attacking the Neutrinos made me think of some Universe issue we never saw.
I have to say that would have made a good single issue of Universe to see how it played out.
martinitolove
08-02-2017, 03:44 PM
The IDW Turtleverse have took influences from every incarnation of TMNT (Mirage, Archie, Fred Wolf, the movies, Next Mutation, 4kids including Fast Forward). But none from the current Nick show. Why/
Is it because the show is still running? Or because IDW does the show's comic? So in a few months those characters will be free to use?
Hope one day to see:
Choate (or TyrannoShredder) from Mirage - make him the king of the Triceratons
Ancient One and the Ninja Tribunal, Battle Nexus tournament, Touch & Go and that season 7 concept of Ch'rell Shredder Triceraton from 4kids.
Shinigami, Rahzar, kunoichi April, noir feel of the current season from Nick.
Enjoying every moment of IDW. Thank you, team!
Bobby Curnow
08-02-2017, 07:00 PM
Will Stockman, Tragg and Granitor appear or at the very least be mentioned in Trial of Krang? It would make sense for the prosecution to retrieve them as witnesses, seeing as how they were Krang's accomplices in not only building the Technodrome but also various atrocities in Dimension X itself.
Short answer is no. Your reasoning is sound, but just not enough room.
Bobby Curnow
08-02-2017, 07:02 PM
Regarding Leatherhead and the Neutrinos coming to pick him up on Earth, was there a potential Universe issue about that planned before the start of the current arc that was scraped or considered? The flashback of Leatherhead attacking the Neutrinos made me think of some Universe issue we never saw.
I have to say that would have made a good single issue of Universe to see how it played out.
No, not considered.
Bobby Curnow
08-02-2017, 07:04 PM
The IDW Turtleverse have took influences from every incarnation of TMNT (Mirage, Archie, Fred Wolf, the movies, Next Mutation, 4kids including Fast Forward). But none from the current Nick show. Why/
Is it because the show is still running? Or because IDW does the show's comic? So in a few months those characters will be free to use?
Hope one day to see:
Choate (or TyrannoShredder) from Mirage - make him the king of the Triceratons
Ancient One and the Ninja Tribunal, Battle Nexus tournament, Touch & Go and that season 7 concept of Ch'rell Shredder Triceraton from 4kids.
Shinigami, Rahzar, kunoichi April, noir feel of the current season from Nick.
Enjoying every moment of IDW. Thank you, team!
Yeah, just wanted to keep things separate, otherwise it might feel "too Nick". Maybe a few years down the line there will be some incorporations, but since I edit the Amazing Adventures comics I personally feel like I'm getting my fill there. And I don't think Tom has seen too much of it though I could be wrong.
Bobby Curnow
08-02-2017, 07:06 PM
Hello Bobby,
I have a question about the latest story arch. Why would Kitsune wanna resurrect her father by using Saki's body? Wasn't Saki her lover? I get that she was secretly preparing Saki to be the vessel for her father. But it seemed like she actually loved Saki himself by the way she talked about him when she stole his body. It seems weird that she would want to use Saki to bring back her father instead of another person.
Also will Splinter and the foot come back into play this year and will Kitsune make another move against him?
Thanks!
Can't talk about this too much without getting into spoilers, but Kitsune, true to her nature, isn't spilling all the beans.
We'll see Splinter and the Foot this year, but can't really say anything else.
AlessandraDC
08-06-2017, 09:06 PM
This is not a question... more of a request. It would be really neat to see a speed color video of Rhonda Pattison doing a few pages. It would be fun to get more glimpses into the artistic process, since I think overall TMNT has had some really solid art and colors.
eskater
08-06-2017, 09:24 PM
Will the concept of a multiverse be explored even further?
AquaParade
08-07-2017, 05:25 PM
Will the concept of a multiverse be explored even further?
Yes, but only in my universe. Your's will be stuck with, and only with the IDW turtles forever.
*Bamf*
eskater
08-08-2017, 08:40 AM
Yes, but only in my universe. Your's will be stuck with, and only with the IDW turtles forever.
*Bamf*
One I'm ok with IDW Turtles forevvveerrrrr and two, will "bamfing now be a thing?"
*BAMF*
biganimefan
08-08-2017, 11:34 AM
So, first of all a comment. I really enjoy the IDW series a lot. You guys do a fantastic job!
I know that this gets asked every now and again, but are the Image and Mirage Volume 4 comics any closer to coming in Trades? By any chance could you be waiting for the Adventures line to be finished?
Also, the Tales volume 9 TPB was supposedly going to be released about a month ago but it hasn't with no word of a new release date. When can we expect the Tales trades to continue?
Thanks!
Bobby Curnow
08-08-2017, 04:13 PM
Will the concept of a multiverse be explored even further?
In some shape or form, yes. Don't expect a big crossover though, no plans for anything like that.
Bobby Curnow
08-08-2017, 04:14 PM
So, first of all a comment. I really enjoy the IDW series a lot. You guys do a fantastic job!
I know that this gets asked every now and again, but are the Image and Mirage Volume 4 comics any closer to coming in Trades? By any chance could you be waiting for the Adventures line to be finished?
Also, the Tales volume 9 TPB was supposedly going to be released about a month ago but it hasn't with no word of a new release date. When can we expect the Tales trades to continue?
Thanks!
I don't know, or don't have any new information at this time, sorry. I know we're hoping to do Image at least.
myconius
08-10-2017, 07:50 AM
even though Comixology had placed the 2017 FCBD Special in their store as a one-shot, it was still in their actual library in-between issues #69 and #70.
i kept after them to change it to be right before issue #73.
one of their employees finally switched it for me.
......one small victory for nerd-kind. :D
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-14-2017, 07:02 PM
Hey Bobby, have you seen the awesome art Sophie did of Tokka and Rahzar?
I think a lot of us would love to see these two guys show up in IDW, even if it is just a one-shot or alternate reality (like Bebop and Rocksteady Destroy Everything)...
https://orig03.deviantart.net/bf8f/f/2017/144/2/a/master_say_have_fun_by_mooncalfe-dbacdmb.jpg
eskater
08-15-2017, 08:51 AM
hey bobby, have you seen the awesome art sophie did of tokka and rahzar?
I think a lot of us would love to see these two guys show up in idw, even if it is just a one-shot or alternate reality (like bebop and rocksteady destroy everything)...
https://orig03.deviantart.net/bf8f/f/2017/144/2/a/master_say_have_fun_by_mooncalfe-dbacdmb.jpg
so much yes
Bobby Curnow
08-15-2017, 11:34 AM
Hey Bobby, have you seen the awesome art Sophie did of Tokka and Rahzar?
I think a lot of us would love to see these two guys show up in IDW, even if it is just a one-shot or alternate reality (like Bebop and Rocksteady Destroy Everything)...
https://orig03.deviantart.net/bf8f/f/2017/144/2/a/master_say_have_fun_by_mooncalfe-dbacdmb.jpg
I have, yep!
:o I think I'm in love. Those pics are AMAZING!!!! & YES!!! The totally should appear in the comics, now. <3
martinitolove
08-16-2017, 02:55 PM
Hey Bobby, have you seen the awesome art Sophie did of Tokka and Rahzar?
I think a lot of us would love to see these two guys show up in IDW, even if it is just a one-shot or alternate reality (like Bebop and Rocksteady Destroy Everything)...
https://orig03.deviantart.net/bf8f/f/2017/144/2/a/master_say_have_fun_by_mooncalfe-dbacdmb.jpg
Guys, please! IDW's Slash is Tokka. And Nick's skeleton Rahzar is waaaay cooler/frightening than the hairy dog from the old movie.
As much as I enjoy Sophie's art, I suggest the name "Tokka" should be used as an easter egg somewhere. And regarding Rahzar, IDW should wait around a few months after Nick's show is over and use that Rahzar's look in the comics.
eskater
08-16-2017, 03:33 PM
Guys, please! IDW's Slash is Tokka. And Nick's skeleton Rahzar is waaaay cooler/frightening than the hairy dog from the old movie.
As much as I enjoy Sophie's art, I suggest the name "Tokka" should be used as an easter egg somewhere. And regarding Rahzar, IDW should wait around a few months after Nick's show is over and use that Rahzar's look in the comics.
I do think the look for Tokka was taken from Slash to begin with, so I agree that we probably don't need Tokka to be used in the comics.
Sophie Campbell
08-16-2017, 03:36 PM
IDW Slash and Tokka are both big turtles but they're different characters with different roles, they could totally co-exist and each add something different. Tokka and Rahzar are children who don't fully understand what they're doing and don't understand good and evil/right and wrong. Slash's conflict and personality are different than that.
Skeleton Rahzar is stupid, I hate him! Why is he part skeleton??? Haha. He doesn't have anything to do with the original character, he's Rahzar-in-name-only.
Tokka and Rahzar shouldn't be separated the same way Bebop and Rocksteady are always together. Conceptually, they go together.
neatoman
08-16-2017, 03:53 PM
Skeleton Rahzar is stupid, I hate him! Why is he part skeleton??? Haha. He doesn't have anything to do with the original character, he's Rahzar-in-name-only.
Well, Sophie, that's pretty much how the majority of returning characters in the Nick Show can be described. If it makes you feel any better, the next show will probably pretend it's immediate predecessor never happened, so most likely you won't see Skele-Rahzar anymore.
Just wait a little less than one month and the show only has three episodes left to release, which are most likely going to get dumped on DVD soon after as well, the show is probably going to be over this year for all practical purposes.
Anyway, what about Gamera-Tokka? How do you feel about that?
Sophie Campbell
08-16-2017, 07:07 PM
Well, Sophie, that's pretty much how the majority of returning characters in the Nick Show can be described. If it makes you feel any better, the next show will probably pretend it's immediate predecessor never happened, so most likely you won't see Skele-Rahzar anymore.
And that's fine, any character is valid regardless of the inspiration or whatever. It's true that most of the Nick incarnations are that way, you're right. Rahzar, Tokka, Alopex (at least she's some type of fox), Mona Lisa, Wyrm... Lots of weird choices. It's like they make up a new character and then throw the old fans a bone by re-using names.
Just wait a little less than one month and the show only has three episodes left to release, which are most likely going to get dumped on DVD soon after as well, the show is probably going to be over this year for all practical purposes.
Anyway, what about Gamera-Tokka? How do you feel about that?
I haven't watched the show since around season 2 but I've seen snippets since then, Nick Tokka seems cool, I like the design, but it has nothing to do with the original Tokka, haha. Which again is fine, it's a new character, and I'm sure the show's target audience has no idea about the old 1991 movie Tokka.
Anyway, my point was that there's definitely room in IDW TMNT for a spin on the original Tokka and Rahzar. :D I don't want to derail this thread any more than I have!
CyberCubed
08-17-2017, 01:10 AM
Are there any plans for Wingnut/Screwloose or Scumbug to get a story? We only saw quick cameos of them in the Rocksteady/Bebop Destroy Everything Mini but nothing since.
Would be nice to get a Universe issue or two about them.
TigerClaw
08-17-2017, 10:20 AM
And that's fine, any character is valid regardless of the inspiration or whatever. It's true that most of the Nick incarnations are that way, you're right. Rahzar, Tokka, Alopex (at least she's some type of fox), Mona Lisa, Wyrm... Lots of weird choices. It's like they make up a new character and then throw the old fans a bone by re-using names.
I haven't watched the show since around season 2 but I've seen snippets since then, Nick Tokka seems cool, I like the design, but it has nothing to do with the original Tokka, haha. Which again is fine, it's a new character, and I'm sure the show's target audience has no idea about the old 1991 movie Tokka.
Anyway, my point was that there's definitely room in IDW TMNT for a spin on the original Tokka and Rahzar. :D I don't want to derail this thread any more than I have!
I'm not a fan of the Nick TMNT versions of Mona Lisa, Rahzar, & Tokka, they are just new characters who been slapped the names of the originals, I hope you guys can bring the original characters in the IDW Comics, it would be interesting to bring Mona Lisa into the comics, she could be a new member of the Mutanimals, but if I'm not mistaken, Old Hob is not a fan of human born mutants, I hope at some point he changes his views on that, the original Mutanimals were a combination of human born, and animal born mutants.
eskater
08-17-2017, 11:06 AM
Are there any plans for Wingnut/Screwloose or Scumbug to get a story? We only saw quick cameos of them in the Rocksteady/Bebop Destroy Everything Mini but nothing since.
Would be nice to get a Universe issue or two about them.
Wingnut/Screwloose is definitely a mutant I want to see more of.
TigerClaw
08-17-2017, 11:23 AM
Wingnut/Screwloose is definitely a mutant I want to see more of.
They were actually aliens in the Archie comics, and also part of the Mutanimals, but would love to see those two show up too.
Bobby Curnow
08-17-2017, 12:15 PM
Are there any plans for Wingnut/Screwloose or Scumbug to get a story? We only saw quick cameos of them in the Rocksteady/Bebop Destroy Everything Mini but nothing since.
Would be nice to get a Universe issue or two about them.
No plans at this time.
martinitolove
08-17-2017, 02:16 PM
I'm not a fan of the Nick TMNT versions of Mona Lisa, Rahzar, & Tokka, they are just new characters who been slapped the names of the originals, I hope you guys can bring the original characters in the IDW Comics, it would be interesting to bring Mona Lisa into the comics, she could be a new member of the Mutanimals, but if I'm not mistaken, Old Hob is not a fan of human born mutants, I hope at some point he changes his views on that, the original Mutanimals were a combination of human born, and animal born mutants.
Once Lindsey mutates, she is going to become Mona Lisa (I don't like this name!) and Hob is going to change his opinion on human born mutants.
Sophie, than you for your input! It's really interesting to know that one of the IDW creators doesn't like the current cartoon. For me it's exactly the opposite. I've grown up with Fred Wolf one and REALLY despise the original Mirage, FW, Archie and the movies. I think the ideas were great, but they needed the grown up execution. Therefor IDW IS PERFECT, as was 4Kids and Nick now (love both shows!!!). I understand that most ideas originated from the 80-ies and I am thank-/respectfull for them, but I see them mostly as a fantastic quarry. To stay by this metaphor Mirage/FW/Archie found a marmor quarry, but IDW/4Kids/Nick are the real Michelangelo!!!
Long live Skeleto-Rahzar! And Sophie, THANK YOU for AMAZING "Karai's Path" right now! And for Pepperoni. And for Northampton. You are great and keep it up!:tgrin:
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-17-2017, 07:34 PM
Hey Bobby, I hope this question isn't too nosy, but is TMNT universe in any trouble right now sales-wise? I really hope this series will be able to continue! :(
ToTheNines
08-17-2017, 07:43 PM
Hey Bobby, I hope this question isn't too nosy, but is TMNT universe in any trouble right now sales-wise? I really hope this series will be able to continue! :(
You guys are spazzing over nothing. Universe is still a top 5 IDW book. In July it was only beaten by MLP, a new #1 (Diablo House), and 2 other TMNT comics.
TMNTChris1980
08-17-2017, 10:52 PM
What's the minimum order quantity for creating a variant cover?
Ninjinister
08-18-2017, 12:05 AM
IDW Slash and Tokka are both big turtles but they're different characters with different roles
For a second I read this as IDW Tokka as well, not Tokka in general, and thought that it was a subtle hint.
Mayhem
08-18-2017, 04:08 AM
What's the minimum order quantity for creating a variant cover?
Generally 1000 but some places (Jetpack especially) have been able to get away with less. Rich Horn is probably best placed to answer that here ;)
Bobby Curnow
08-18-2017, 12:28 PM
Hey Bobby, I hope this question isn't too nosy, but is TMNT universe in any trouble right now sales-wise? I really hope this series will be able to continue! :(
Yeah, it's doing fine. I'd like to see it stick where it is, but it's fine for the time being.
Bobby Curnow
08-18-2017, 12:29 PM
What's the minimum order quantity for creating a variant cover?
1200 for new art, 1000 for art that already exists. At least that what it was when we ran these things individually as editors... we have someone in the company that handles these orders now, so my info might be out of date.
TMNTChris1980
08-18-2017, 03:10 PM
Generally 1000 but some places (Jetpack especially) have been able to get away with less. Rich Horn is probably best placed to answer that here ;)
1200 for new art, 1000 for art that already exists. At least that what it was when we ran these things individually as editors... we have someone in the company that handles these orders now, so my info might be out of date.
Thanks guys! I would really like to get something setup. If anyone has any contact info to get this kicked off, let me know. I'll also hit up Jet Pack and see what they can do.
Powder
08-18-2017, 06:14 PM
Hey Bobby, re: Cryin' Houn-
He was an Elvis parody, obviously, but the issue was released on the 40th anniversary of Elvis' passing. Did you guys actually plan for that? 'Cause that'd be one hell of a coincidence, if not.
neatoman
08-18-2017, 07:08 PM
Why are you publishing Robotanimals? Is there a contractual obligation to release a certain number of Nick themed issues? Did you decide the Nick Turtles were worth one more series after the Batman crossover sold so well? Did you simply have a few completed issues that were postponed due to the crossover? Did you simply feel like it?
It just seems a little strange to me that you would publish a comic tie-in to show that's basically over when the last issue hits, especially when the previous tie-ins ended up getting outright cancelled. Don't mean to be rude, just a little confused
Weapons@theready
08-19-2017, 01:17 PM
Bobby,
Obviously in regards to Cryin' Hound, you got a lot going on with Houndamania being a play on Hulkamania, and the whole Elvis/Honkey Tonk Man gimmick, but it would totally make my day if when Cryin Hound is picking out his partner that part of his dialogue is in homage to Ric Flair's iconic promo from Royal Rumble 1992 after he wins the title..."a tear in my eye". Am I reading too much into that?
Bobby Curnow
08-21-2017, 02:01 PM
Hey Bobby, re: Cryin' Houn-
He was an Elvis parody, obviously, but the issue was released on the 40th anniversary of Elvis' passing. Did you guys actually plan for that? 'Cause that'd be one hell of a coincidence, if not.
Complete coincidence.
Bobby Curnow
08-21-2017, 02:03 PM
Bobby,
Obviously in regards to Cryin' Hound, you got a lot going on with Houndamania being a play on Hulkamania, and the whole Elvis/Honkey Tonk Man gimmick, but it would totally make my day if when Cryin Hound is picking out his partner that part of his dialogue is in homage to Ric Flair's iconic promo from Royal Rumble 1992 after he wins the title..."a tear in my eye". Am I reading too much into that?
That's a question for Aubrey Sitterson. He's a big wrestling guy, so I wouldn't be surprised.
Bobby Curnow
08-21-2017, 02:05 PM
Why are you publishing Robotanimals? Is there a contractual obligation to release a certain number of Nick themed issues? Did you decide the Nick Turtles were worth one more series after the Batman crossover sold so well? Did you simply have a few completed issues that were postponed due to the crossover? Did you simply feel like it?
It just seems a little strange to me that you would publish a comic tie-in to show that's basically over when the last issue hits, especially when the previous tie-ins ended up getting outright cancelled. Don't mean to be rude, just a little confused
It's a mildly long, confusing tale. We had originally planned to do four mini-graphic novels centered around each Turtle, but publishing plans had to change in accordance with the new show coming out. In short, Robotanimals is a different form of one of those pitches that the company saw merit in printing.
neatoman
08-21-2017, 02:13 PM
It's a mildly long, confusing tale. We had originally planned to do four mini-graphic novels centered around each Turtle, but publishing plans had to change in accordance with the new show coming out. In short, Robotanimals is a different form of one of those pitches that the company saw merit in printing.
That's more interesting than anything I imagined, what were the pitches?
Bobby Curnow
08-21-2017, 03:51 PM
Nothing I can get into, sorry!
CyberCubed
08-21-2017, 05:11 PM
So Robotanimals #3 will indeed be the final Nick era comic from IDW? Not counting stuff like trades or re-releases of course.
Bobby Curnow
08-21-2017, 06:40 PM
That is correct, unless we revisit that iteration at some point in the future. With the new Nick cartoon coming, that's a little hard to picture in the coming years.
neatoman
08-22-2017, 02:30 PM
By "the company" did you mean IDW or Viacom.
TurtleWA
08-23-2017, 01:42 AM
Hello. Are the IDW TMNT comics that you work on published in languages other than English? If yes, what languages and what locations around the world are the comics sold? Thanks. :tsmile:
bushido
08-23-2017, 04:00 AM
Hello. Are the IDW TMNT comics that you work on published in languages other than English? If yes, what languages and what locations around the world are the comics sold? Thanks. :tsmile:
First four volumes were published in France by Soleil (owned by Delcourt) but then they stopped the publication. They publish the Nickelodeon comics time to time. The Batman/TMNT crossover was published here by Urban Comics because they publishing a lot of DC books.
Bobby Curnow
08-23-2017, 10:34 AM
By "the company" did you mean IDW or Viacom.
I meant IDW.
Bobby Curnow
08-23-2017, 10:35 AM
Hello. Are the IDW TMNT comics that you work on published in languages other than English? If yes, what languages and what locations around the world are the comics sold? Thanks. :tsmile:
I couldn't tell you, sorry!
Diorm
08-23-2017, 01:24 PM
First four volumes were published in France by Soleil (owned by Delcourt) but then they stopped the publication. They publish the Nickelodeon comics time to time. The Batman/TMNT crossover was published here by Urban Comics because they publishing a lot of DC books.
Faut croire qu'en france, TMNT se vend moins...
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-23-2017, 01:36 PM
Hey Bobby,
It's been quite awhile since we had any micro-series... could we maybe get a Mutanimals-themed micro-series sometime down the road, each issue focusing on a different member?
Also, how did IDW decide it could support two ongoing series, the main line and Universe as well? What were the criteria for success?
Finally, how on earth did you guys manage to pull off 2017? Two five-week mini-series, two ongoings, and the Usagi crossover? With so much material to write, draw, edit, and plan, it seems like this year must have taken some convincing for people to go along with it!
ChosenOne
08-23-2017, 02:34 PM
Bobby,
Was Lord Dregg considered for an appearance in Trial of Krang/Dimension X? I feel that he would've filled in the part of the crime lord who puts the bounty out on Ace rather well.
Also, and I know this might be spoilery so I fully expect the usual noncommittal reply, are there any plans at all for Lord Dregg to appear in the future?
Apart from Armaggon, he's probably the only major name in the list of popular franchise villains that have yet to grace the pages of the IDW TMNT.
bushido
08-23-2017, 02:48 PM
Faut croire qu'en france, TMNT se vend moins...
En France, la majorité des comics TMNT n'ont pas été publié donc pour la majorité, cette franchise c'est pour les enfants ou au mieux pour les geeks nostalgiques mais toujours liée au dessin animé de 87. D'ailleurs beaucoup de gens ne connaissent que ce dessin animé et c'est la seule vision qu'ils ont de la licence. Le pire c'est que certains connaissent l'existence des comics plus "matures" mais n'ont aucune envie de les découvrir peut être par peur de briser leur nostalgie d'enfance. Soleil/Delcourt n'a pas cherché à faire d'effort pour l'éditer correctement non plus. Vraiment triste...
In France, the majority of the TMNT comics haven't been released so for the majority, this franchise is for children or at best for nostalgic geeks but still related to the 87 cartoon. Moreover many people only know this cartoon and that is the only vision they have of the license. The worst is that some know the existence of comics more "mature" but have no desire to discover them maybe by fear of breaking their childhood nostalgia. Soleil/Delcourt didn't try to make an effort to publish them properly either. Really sad...
Bobby Curnow
08-23-2017, 06:37 PM
Hey Bobby,
It's been quite awhile since we had any micro-series... could we maybe get a Mutanimals-themed micro-series sometime down the road, each issue focusing on a different member?
Also, how did IDW decide it could support two ongoing series, the main line and Universe as well? What were the criteria for success?
Finally, how on earth did you guys manage to pull off 2017? Two five-week mini-series, two ongoings, and the Usagi crossover? With so much material to write, draw, edit, and plan, it seems like this year must have taken some convincing for people to go along with it!
It seems like Universe is where we'd tell those sorts of stories now. (it's not a perfect fit, but TMNT U #11 with Sally and Ray sorta feels like a micro to me).
I think it was just a matter of realizing that whatever secondary TMNT title we do does well enough in sales that it just made sense to consolidate into a single new line. I go back and forth on this a lot. Sometimes I feel like we miss marketing attention on a great story like Karai's Path because it's not it's own mini-series. But at the same time we get to do single issue stories that we might not be able to find a place for (like U#5 or the aforementioned #11). So, it's a mixed bag in my opinion.
And thanks. Don't forget FCBD and that TMNT #75 is double sized! Haven't pulled it all off yet. Honestly, I would have had us do a lot less this year, feels like too much, but perhaps i'm biased. I'll just say that this year has not been pleasant in terms of work load. :howell: Anyway, the reason for the extra material is an odd mix of notable opportunities and milestones combined with business needs. 2018 should (I hope!) be much more low key, so don't get too spoiled with the amount of TMNT comics.
Bobby Curnow
08-23-2017, 06:54 PM
Bobby,
Was Lord Dregg considered for an appearance in Trial of Krang/Dimension X? I feel that he would've filled in the part of the crime lord who puts the bounty out on Ace rather well.
Also, and I know this might be spoilery so I fully expect the usual noncommittal reply, are there any plans at all for Lord Dregg to appear in the future?
Apart from Armaggon, he's probably the only major name in the list of popular franchise villains that have yet to grace the pages of the IDW TMNT.
For Dregg in Dimension X #4, no, wasn't considered. At least not that I know of, that's a question for Ryan Ferrier. and indeed, can't say anything beyond that.
nimajneb
08-24-2017, 04:55 AM
En France, la majorité des comics TMNT n'ont pas été publié donc pour la majorité, cette franchise c'est pour les enfants ou au mieux pour les geeks nostalgiques mais toujours liée au dessin animé de 87. D'ailleurs beaucoup de gens ne connaissent que ce dessin animé et c'est la seule vision qu'ils ont de la licence. Le pire c'est que certains connaissent l'existence des comics plus "matures" mais n'ont aucune envie de les découvrir peut être par peur de briser leur nostalgie d'enfance. Soleil/Delcourt n'a pas cherché à faire d'effort pour l'éditer correctement non plus. Vraiment triste...
In France, the majority of the TMNT comics haven't been released so for the majority, this franchise is for children or at best for nostalgic geeks but still related to the 87 cartoon. Moreover many people only know this cartoon and that is the only vision they have of the license. The worst is that some know the existence of comics more "mature" but have no desire to discover them maybe by fear of breaking their childhood nostalgia. Soleil/Delcourt didn't try to make an effort to publish them properly either. Really sad...
Are sites like Comixology of any help to push international sales?
bushido
08-24-2017, 05:28 AM
Are sites like Comixology of any help to push international sales?
Digital books aren't really popular here and people don't read them in english.
eskater
08-24-2017, 08:45 AM
En France, la majorité des comics TMNT n'ont pas été publié donc pour la majorité, cette franchise c'est pour les enfants ou au mieux pour les geeks nostalgiques mais toujours liée au dessin animé de 87. D'ailleurs beaucoup de gens ne connaissent que ce dessin animé et c'est la seule vision qu'ils ont de la licence. Le pire c'est que certains connaissent l'existence des comics plus "matures" mais n'ont aucune envie de les découvrir peut être par peur de briser leur nostalgie d'enfance. Soleil/Delcourt n'a pas cherché à faire d'effort pour l'éditer correctement non plus. Vraiment triste...
In France, the majority of the TMNT comics haven't been released so for the majority, this franchise is for children or at best for nostalgic geeks but still related to the 87 cartoon. Moreover many people only know this cartoon and that is the only vision they have of the license. The worst is that some know the existence of comics more "mature" but have no desire to discover them maybe by fear of breaking their childhood nostalgia. Soleil/Delcourt didn't try to make an effort to publish them properly either. Really sad...
That sounds awful to me.....I hope y'all get more access to these awesome books sometime soon.
Diorm
08-24-2017, 03:45 PM
It's very very much the same over here in Quebec. Everything you just said. It's really sad.
Vegita-San
08-25-2017, 12:19 PM
none tmnt question.
I know the competition is probably brutal...but what is the chance an unknown could get an opportunity to pitch a new comic idea at idw? :)
AlessandraDC
08-25-2017, 12:25 PM
I just have to say that I am loving the Dimension X settings! Please tell me we could see future stories exploring some of these places, like Palmadise. I feel like there's a lot of potential to tell some really cool stories! (Also, loved the design of that female bounty hunter in Dimension X #4.)
CyberCubed
08-25-2017, 12:30 PM
I love all the varied artists on the Dimension X specials in particular, will we see any of these artists return to do some Universe issues in the future?
Bobby Curnow
08-25-2017, 03:24 PM
none tmnt question.
I know the competition is probably brutal...but what is the chance an unknown could get an opportunity to pitch a new comic idea at idw? :)
It's a bad climate to get any new projects approved right now-- we're in the midst of an industry wide down turn. We've been turning down a lot of solid projects from known creators.
So... not good. But that shouldn't stop you from creating your own comics and pitching them to publishers. The people who make it in the industry are people who make comics for themselves first and foremost.
Bobby Curnow
08-25-2017, 03:26 PM
I just have to say that I am loving the Dimension X settings! Please tell me we could see future stories exploring some of these places, like Palmadise. I feel like there's a lot of potential to tell some really cool stories! (Also, loved the design of that female bounty hunter in Dimension X #4.)
Maybe, it's possible!
Vegita-San
08-25-2017, 03:31 PM
It's a bad climate to get any new projects approved right now-- we're in the midst of an industry wide down turn. We've been turning down a lot of solid projects from known creators.
So... not good. But that shouldn't stop you from creating your own comics and pitching them to publishers. The people who make it in the industry are people who make comics for themselves first and foremost.
sigh, kind of what i thought :).
another new idea,not many places to try it out :).
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-25-2017, 03:37 PM
It's a bad climate to get any new projects approved right now-- we're in the midst of an industry wide down turn. We've been turning down a lot of solid projects from known creators.
So... not good. But that shouldn't stop you from creating your own comics and pitching them to publishers. The people who make it in the industry are people who make comics for themselves first and foremost.
Hey Bobby,
Would that downturn be contributing to the lack of Mirage reprints that's been going on? The reason Tales is presumably canceled, and why Image 3 and Mirage 4 are still just a hope?
Sorry, I know you get asked about those darn reprints a lot... :trazz:
Bobby Curnow
08-25-2017, 04:01 PM
sigh, kind of what i thought :).
another new idea,not many places to try it out :).
I see so many people give up because they can't get their first, or second project greenlit. When the reality is: almost everyone who is a professional in the industry is around for a good 5-10 years, honing their craft, making and completing new projects, day in and out, before anything substantial comes of it.
Make it for yourself, make it the best it can possibly be. Then share it around and prepare to be heart broke. Then do the entire process again, learning from your mistakes. And again. And again. The only people who should do this are people who HAVE to do it, for themselves, first and foremost. They're the only people who will have the determination to get where they want to go.
All that being said, good luck!
Bobby Curnow
08-25-2017, 04:02 PM
Hey Bobby,
Would that downturn be contributing to the lack of Mirage reprints that's been going on? The reason Tales is presumably canceled, and why Image 3 and Mirage 4 are still just a hope?
Sorry, I know you get asked about those darn reprints a lot... :trazz:
Much more likely that the Tales collections just never sold that well in the first place.
As far as I know Vol. 3 reprints are still happening.
Redeemer
08-25-2017, 08:52 PM
It's a bad climate to get any new projects approved right now-- we're in the midst of an industry wide down turn. We've been turning down a lot of solid projects from known creators.
So... not good. But that shouldn't stop you from creating your own comics and pitching them to publishers. The people who make it in the industry are people who make comics for themselves first and foremost.
Can you please elaborate???? :(
I was looking up the sale figures and numbers. It appears that all the sales figures point industry growth not downturn.
Bobby Curnow
08-28-2017, 10:32 AM
Can you please elaborate???? :(
I was looking up the sale figures and numbers. It appears that all the sales figures point industry growth not downturn.
Not sure how to elaborate. You and I must be reading very different reports and talking to different people.
Redeemer
08-28-2017, 11:03 AM
Not sure how to elaborate. You and I must be reading very different reports and talking to different people.
lol I went to a website :lol: that post sales figures and sales numbers that we use on the forum to see how well the TMNT books are selling.
I have a sneaky suspicion that you guys know better than I do ;)
I was just curious, bc the term "downward spiral" sounds bad and has me nervous for future TMNT books :cry:
Bobby Curnow
08-28-2017, 01:16 PM
lol I went to a website :lol: that post sales figures and sales numbers that we use on the forum to see how well the TMNT books are selling.
I have a sneaky suspicion that you guys know better than I do ;)
I was just curious, bc the term "downward spiral" sounds bad and has me nervous for future TMNT books :cry:
I think I said "downward turn" which isn't quite as bas as a spiral!
I wouldn't be too concerned. TMNT is doing fine, and hopefully things will right themselves across the industry. DC seems to be doing well, which is better than if both they and Marvel were both doing bad.
Powder
08-28-2017, 01:32 PM
You guys had Khary Randolph come on board for Dimension X #3, how did that come about? Were y'all aware of his connection with TMNT (did lots of stuff on the 4kids show, but most notably promotional art, DVD covers, etc.) & if so, did it influence your decision to pick him up?
An extension of that, might we see others who've had a past with TMNT that wasn't necessary related to comics themselves, such as he? Do you ever look at the pool of turtle talent to consider one-off artists? I know you guys wanna stray from the Mirage cast so as to give your series its own visual identity but what about younger lesser knowns who only did one or a handful of Tales vol. 2 issues & moved on to Marvel, DC, etc? Andres Ponce being one example that comes to mind. They're not really a "face" of the brand like Jim Lawson is. & you've got your share of cartoon-tied folks like Khary, would you ever reach out to someone like say Ciro Nieli (& yes I'm aware he did variant covers on the Nick series)?
Bobby Curnow
08-28-2017, 03:28 PM
Aubrey Sitterson, the writer, had wanted to work with Khary so that's how that came about.
As for others, it's possible, sure. The schedule has been very tight for a while now, so that makes me shy about working with people who's work habits I'm not familiar with, but on the right project I like to try out new people.
Andrew NDB
08-28-2017, 04:28 PM
I think I said "downward turn" which isn't quite as bas as a spiral!
I wouldn't be too concerned. TMNT is doing fine, and hopefully things will right themselves across the industry. DC seems to be doing well, which is better than if both they and Marvel were both doing bad.
What is your personal opinion or thoughts on why there is a downward turn in mainstream comics right now? Does DC have the right idea? Does anyone?
MikeandRaph87
08-28-2017, 05:06 PM
When developing the comic, was it ever considered to have Shredder and Krang team up it was it always meant for the two to be rivals never to team at any point? Up until #37 it seemed like a strong possibility there would be a business partnership for convinence.
Bobby Curnow
08-28-2017, 09:17 PM
What is your personal opinion or thoughts on why there is a downward turn in mainstream comics right now? Does DC have the right idea? Does anyone?
This is just my own armchair thoughts, so your guess is as good as mine. But in general I think there are simply way too many titles on the market. Too much choice can be a turn off for actually making a choice I think. Add that to event fatigue and too many reboots. Comics have become more accessible but not enough to counter business practices that are essentially short sighted and greedy (i'm in no way exempting IDW from any of this. We're guilty of it too). Plus there's just cycles of creativity. Seems like it's been a while since anyone (or group) has really shook up the industry and caused a fresh breath of air to circulate.
DC's strategy currently seems to be to just keep things relatively simple and accessible, something that I don't think can hurt! (and I say this as primarily a Marvel guy growing up)
Bobby Curnow
08-28-2017, 09:18 PM
When developing the comic, was it ever considered to have Shredder and Krang team up it was it always meant for the two to be rivals never to team at any point? Up until #37 it seemed like a strong possibility there would be a business partnership for convinence.
I'm sure we considered it at one point, but seemed more interesting and unexpected to make them adversaries.
TurtleWA
08-28-2017, 10:14 PM
What is your preferred story length as an editor and also as a comic fan?
Bobby Curnow
08-29-2017, 10:52 AM
What is your preferred story length as an editor and also as a comic fan?
I don't have one in either case. Just depends what is needed for the story!
ToTheNines
08-29-2017, 11:00 AM
And thanks. Don't forget FCBD and that TMNT #75 is double sized! Haven't pulled it all off yet. Honestly, I would have had us do a lot less this year, feels like too much, but perhaps i'm biased. I'll just say that this year has not been pleasant in terms of work load. :howell: Anyway, the reason for the extra material is an odd mix of notable opportunities and milestones combined with business needs. 2018 should (I hope!) be much more low key, so don't get too spoiled with the amount of TMNT comics.
Man, really sorry to hear that. I've worked in 3 very different industries (never comics, obviously), and the one constant negative I've found is management's lack of attention to employee burnout. Never ends up paying in the long run.
Hope stuff chills out for you soon. Sorry for financially supporting your gnarly workload lol.
Bobby Curnow
08-29-2017, 12:55 PM
Haha all good. Hard to complain about working on TMNT, i'm lucky. Thanks though.
Vegita-San
08-29-2017, 01:36 PM
RE: too much content.
sadly this is a problem that I don't see going away.
I've been checking new things out less.
1)too expensive to be picking up so many monthly things.
2)reboot fatigue as mentioned. you can only tell the same stories over again so many times, which is one reason why IDW TMNT has held up nicely.
And 3)cancellation fever. you don't want to start a title only to see that it doesn't have staying power. all this makes finding something new you like a little tougher.
ChosenOne
08-29-2017, 08:44 PM
Bobby, will issues 18-20 of Universe also tie into the "Invasion of the Triceratons" arc or will we see something different?
Bobby Curnow
08-29-2017, 08:56 PM
Bobby, will issues 18-20 of Universe also tie into the "Invasion of the Triceratons" arc or will we see something different?
Currently planning #18 and it looks like that will, yes.
ChosenOne
08-29-2017, 09:09 PM
Currently planning #18 and it looks like that will, yes.
Thanks! I was looking at a chart I've made (because of course I did) of all the issues and minis and whatnot, with each month's releases up until #100 side by side, and I started wondering about that. Safe to say this will be a far-reaching event with plenty of ramifications...
And then when the invasion is over, we'll still be 20 issues of the main ongoing away from the "big finale", there's still so much that could happen in that time!
TurtleWA
08-30-2017, 04:41 PM
Do you consider the numbering when planning things out? Like issue #100 being the final part of an arc such as part 5 of 5. Or could it be the start of something such as 1 of 5. Or could it even be in the middle such as part 3 of 5. Or is it business as usual and the numbering is not considered?
Bobby Curnow
08-30-2017, 04:46 PM
We're planning on #100 being akin to #50 in terms of size and culminating some plot lines while opening up new ones.
Other than that, not really. TMNT #75 wasn't going to be the end of that storyline (much as #25 wasn't the end of City Fall), but then we made #75 double sized, which conveniently ends the arc.
TurtleWA
08-30-2017, 04:51 PM
Thank you for the quick response and the clear answer. I love knowing some about the process and how the creative decisions get made. :tsmile:
ChosenOne
08-30-2017, 09:39 PM
So with Dimension X having concluded today, I vaguely recall some talk months ago about IDW Cudley the Cowlick popping up eventually, if I'm not mistaken. He's traditionally associated with Stump Asteroid, so #3 would have been the perfect place for a cameo or even something a bit more substantial. Was that ever in the cards? Or was it decided against? Is there still a chance we might see him in the future? (As the means of transportation to the Battle Nexus, oh please, please, please! :D)
Also, when was it decided to center such an arc around Krang's trial? I can see how the notion of using it as a gateway to all things cosmic (ie, the Triceratons) might've seeded itself and grew, but was it before or after #50 with the Shredder's demise and the focus shifting onto the Pantheon?
As usual, thanks in advance!
Vegita-San
08-30-2017, 09:52 PM
I see so many people give up because they can't get their first, or second project greenlit. When the reality is: almost everyone who is a professional in the industry is around for a good 5-10 years, honing their craft, making and completing new projects, day in and out, before anything substantial comes of it.
Make it for yourself, make it the best it can possibly be. Then share it around and prepare to be heart broke. Then do the entire process again, learning from your mistakes. And again. And again. The only people who should do this are people who HAVE to do it, for themselves, first and foremost. They're the only people who will have the determination to get where they want to go.
All that being said, good luck!
oh i'm used to heart break :) i'm the guy who does tv and intro recreations that barely get 200 hits in 10 years , while some other guy who copied me has his work go viral over night. go figure :).
I'm basically spending my own money, $100 a page for at least 24 pages, to slowly, get a complete issue done. If I have to, i'll do a limited publication myself to see what people other than friends and family think. i might be able to afford one or two more issues. it's not so much money, as the time my wonderful artist has to work on a freelance project.
but the art is well worth the wait. I have a full 'season' of 24 issues planned out if it ever got lucky enough to b e picked up. with 4 other, less evolved ideas also waiting to b e tried.
all a matter of hoping one hits.
Bobby Curnow
08-31-2017, 10:35 AM
So with Dimension X having concluded today, I vaguely recall some talk months ago about IDW Cudley the Cowlick popping up eventually, if I'm not mistaken. He's traditionally associated with Stump Asteroid, so #3 would have been the perfect place for a cameo or even something a bit more substantial. Was that ever in the cards? Or was it decided against? Is there still a chance we might see him in the future? (As the means of transportation to the Battle Nexus, oh please, please, please! :D)
Also, when was it decided to center such an arc around Krang's trial? I can see how the notion of using it as a gateway to all things cosmic (ie, the Triceratons) might've seeded itself and grew, but was it before or after #50 with the Shredder's demise and the focus shifting onto the Pantheon?
As usual, thanks in advance!
Can't really discuss plans for Cudley, sorry!
I can't recall when we started planning this arc. A few years at least, probably around Attack on Technodrome.
Bobby Curnow
08-31-2017, 10:36 AM
oh i'm used to heart break :) i'm the guy who does tv and intro recreations that barely get 200 hits in 10 years , while some other guy who copied me has his work go viral over night. go figure :).
I'm basically spending my own money, $100 a page for at least 24 pages, to slowly, get a complete issue done. If I have to, i'll do a limited publication myself to see what people other than friends and family think. i might be able to afford one or two more issues. it's not so much money, as the time my wonderful artist has to work on a freelance project.
but the art is well worth the wait. I have a full 'season' of 24 issues planned out if it ever got lucky enough to b e picked up. with 4 other, less evolved ideas also waiting to b e tried.
all a matter of hoping one hits.
That's the thing to do!
Ninjinister
09-01-2017, 03:46 PM
So if Hakk-R's data said that the Occuli were the fifth witness... and pretty much nobody knew that "Polly" would be the one that was to accompany them back....
Why is Polly shown on the list of witnesses in #73?
neatoman
09-01-2017, 04:05 PM
So if Hakk-R's data said that the Occuli were the fifth witness... and pretty much nobody knew that "Polly" would be the one that was to accompany them back....
Why is Polly shown on the list of witnesses in #73?
Dimension X sort of feels like the filler mini-arc of DBZ between Piccolo giving Gohan the sword and Goku. You know, the stuff about Gohan learning not to be such a wuss, only for Gohan to start acting like a wuss again when the show gets back to the plot.
I'm guessing Dimension X is sort of like that, filler of sorts.
Powder
09-01-2017, 04:42 PM
How is Hakk-R meant to be pronounced?
Hock-R? Hack-R? Hacker? Hocker? H'kar?
Bobby Curnow
09-10-2017, 02:08 PM
So if Hakk-R's data said that the Occuli were the fifth witness... and pretty much nobody knew that "Polly" would be the one that was to accompany them back....
Why is Polly shown on the list of witnesses in #73?
The honest answer is me not thinking of that detail and relaying it to Tom when the time was right!
Bobby Curnow
09-10-2017, 02:08 PM
How is Hakk-R meant to be pronounced?
Hock-R? Hack-R? Hacker? Hocker? H'kar?
We've been saying Hack-R in the office.
ChosenOne
09-10-2017, 02:10 PM
We've been saying Hack-R in the office.
Just imagine, Hack-R Noir, the new men's fragrance for interdimensional bounty hunters everywhere! :lol:
Ninjinister
09-10-2017, 02:37 PM
The honest answer is me not thinking of that detail and relaying it to Tom when the time was right!
Sounds like a No-Prize to me!
Utrommaniac
09-10-2017, 03:02 PM
I've just been saying "Hacker"...mostly due to a certain evil green robot genius voiced by Christopher Lloyd from my childhood...("THE Hacker, to you!")
MikeandRaph87
09-10-2017, 05:08 PM
Hi Bobby, Len Wein is one of two writers that can top IDW's Turtle Team(the other is Denny O'Neil). It struck me to learn of his passing. I was wondering if you had any memories associated with his work or any inspiration from him? Thanks.
Powder
09-20-2017, 07:12 PM
Might we see Andy Kuhn again soon?
Bobby Curnow
09-21-2017, 12:51 PM
Hi Bobby, Len Wein is one of two writers that can top IDW's Turtle Team(the other is Denny O'Neil). It struck me to learn of his passing. I was wondering if you had any memories associated with his work or any inspiration from him? Thanks.
Hey sorry, I think I saw this fleetingly and got distracted!
I don't have any personal memories of Len or anything like that. Being 36, I missed reading a lot of his work directly. Clearly his work has made a huge impact on the industry and owes a lot to him. I was more of a Marvel kid than a DC kid, so I love the characters he introduced. I've heard nothing but great things about him from other professionals who have worked and knew him.
Bobby Curnow
09-21-2017, 12:53 PM
Might we see Andy Kuhn again soon?
No plans at this time. Enjoyed seeing him at SDCC this last year though!
ProphetofGanja
09-21-2017, 02:41 PM
TMNTU #16 & #17: is this story arc titled "Freedom" or "From the Heart, For the Herd"?
There is conflicting information between the November and December solicitations
Bobby Curnow
09-21-2017, 03:31 PM
TMNTU #16 & #17: is this story arc titled "Freedom" or "From the Heart, For the Herd"?
There is conflicting information between the November and December solicitations
"From the Heart, For the Herd"
ProphetofGanja
09-21-2017, 03:42 PM
"From the Heart, For the Herd"
Cool, I like it. Thanks man!
Chris
09-28-2017, 01:18 PM
Hey Bobby, with all the talk about the Nick finale recently it got me thinking. I know 100 is going to be like 50, wrapping a lot of stuff up and setting up new plots but do you guys have a vision for where you want the series to end when the time comes?
I'm not thinking like a full plan from now till the end but more just a point you know you want to end at. Like Smallville, whether it went 7 seasons or 10 seasons the end was always going to be Clark becoming Superman. How they got there changed as they went but that was always the destination.
Bobby Curnow
09-28-2017, 01:25 PM
No, not really. In the next few months we're going to nail down a lot of the loose details on the road to #100. After that I imagine we'll have a bigger think about what comes after. Personally, I don't have a set ending in mind other than what is planned for #100. Perhaps Tom has something in mind that we haven't discussed.
neatoman
09-28-2017, 02:14 PM
I'm a little confused about Anemon's contract, why is his testimony still considered null and void because of it? They clearly state the laws it was written under no longer apply, and it's clearly worded to protect Krang's ass (or whatever Utroms have instead of one) from prosecution, so how is it still considered legitimate?
Chris
09-28-2017, 03:20 PM
No, not really. In the next few months we're going to nail down a lot of the loose details on the road to #100. After that I imagine we'll have a bigger think about what comes after. Personally, I don't have a set ending in mind other than what is planned for #100. Perhaps Tom has something in mind that we haven't discussed.
Thanks Bobby. I have to say I'm amazed at how well you and the team juggle everything and keep sowing seeds and paying them off years down the line. So few comics these days are that ambitious. I can't think of any other book I read that's been so consistent for so long. You all do an incredible job.
Bobby Curnow
09-28-2017, 03:51 PM
Thanks very much! I personally feel like maybe we bit off a little bit more than we can chew this year, but that's nice to hear!
eskater
09-29-2017, 09:23 AM
Thanks very much! I personally feel like maybe we bit off a little bit more than we can chew this year, but that's nice to hear!
Even if you did (I don't think so yet), IDW TMNT is really the biggest reason I have a box at my comic shop :tlol:
John Pannozzi
10-01-2017, 09:47 PM
Bobby, you and IDW may want to contact Brian Thomas and Steve Sullivan.
From what I know (emails from Sullivan or Thomas, can't remember who offhand), they own certain incidental characters they introduced in TMNT Adventures.
TMNT Adventures issues they wrote and/or pencilled include #58 and #71-72; Specials #1-2 & 11 and the April miniseries. IDW hasn't reprinted these yet, but #58 should be in the next trade (Vol. 14).
Bobby Curnow
10-02-2017, 10:28 AM
I don't have anything to do with the reprints, sorry!
ChosenOne
10-02-2017, 10:37 AM
For a character so heavily featured on the covers and whose shadow currently looms over our heroes, I'm surprised we haven't even seen Maligna yet in the story itself. Does she get a good amount of paneltime in #75?
Bobby Curnow
10-02-2017, 01:25 PM
More, but I wouldn't say a lot.
Utrommaniac
10-02-2017, 01:56 PM
So...she's basically playing a Sauron role? Being a massive 'head threat' in the incoming ravenous swarm, but doesn't really do a lot herself, while still imposing a lot of fear in her very name?
Bobby Curnow
10-02-2017, 02:10 PM
You'll have to read to find out!
Bobby,
Apologies if this has been asked, but any chance of another TMNT/Usagi crossover, but this time done by the IDW artists/writers and set in the turtles’ world?
It seems like almost all crossovers are in Usagi’s world and/or are drawn by Sakai.
ChosenOne
10-03-2017, 01:21 PM
Bobby,
Apologies if this has been asked, but any chance of another TMNT/Usagi crossover, but this time done by the IDW artists/writers and set in the turtles’ world?
It seems like almost all crossovers are in Usagi’s world and/or are drawn by Sakai.
With art by Santolouco, pretty please!
Bobby Curnow
10-03-2017, 01:41 PM
Bobby,
Apologies if this has been asked, but any chance of another TMNT/Usagi crossover, but this time done by the IDW artists/writers and set in the turtles’ world?
It seems like almost all crossovers are in Usagi’s world and/or are drawn by Sakai.
We've talked about doing a follow up. If it happened, it would have to have Stan's full blessing, and I don't know how he'd feel about someone else handling the writing/art.
Seems only fair to share the creative control. He allowed Usagi to be animated in the Nick cartoon style, so hopefully he’d let someone else draw him (since he got to draw the turtles multiple times) and let him have an adventure on Earth. Him approving the plot is of course understandable. It seems like letting Usagi crossover can get only benefit him as the turtles are the bigger property. Here’s hoping!
Will you be at NYCC? I’ll be attending Friday. Thanks for your time!
Bobby Curnow
10-03-2017, 04:58 PM
Yes, I'll be at NYCC, though more of a vacation than a working show for me, so I'll only be at the booth sporadically. Feel free to say hi if you see me around!
TigerClaw
10-03-2017, 05:20 PM
Yes, I'll be at NYCC, though more of a vacation than a working show for me, so I'll only be at the booth sporadically. Feel free to say hi if you see me around!
I'm sure he could come up with the writers some way, to bring Usagi and his friends into the IDW TMNT universe
I would love to see how Gen would react, to seeing Rocksteady another Rhino.
funatic
10-06-2017, 08:17 AM
I would love to see how Gen would react, to seeing Rocksteady another Rhino.
Ive wanted to see that for years! Almost commissioned Sakai to do it this year but spent all my savings on seeing real rhinos in Africa last month. :trazz:
Zog The Magnificent
10-07-2017, 01:47 PM
This is more of a production question, but as someone who has helped create a comic, you would know. My friend and I are trying to create a comic of our own, and I was wondering: how far would you recommend we plot out the story? Neither of us can agree. Thanks!
Vegita-San
10-07-2017, 01:51 PM
from my experience, I'm treating mine like a TV show.
24 episodes = one season plot line. if I should be lucky enough to get it anywhere, let alone make it that far, I'll worry about the rest later.
I would recommend just concentrating on making issue 1 as good as you can. that's the one people will probably focus on most.
qt.bangerang
10-07-2017, 11:47 PM
I saw this on a Facebook group page...
https://scontent.fbna2-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/22007853_10156850330432715_402384606039960150_n.jp g?oh=3406102be92277a7b0041f8b7f263a40&oe=5A828B33
I thought TMNT/Batman was not canon. Is it now??
TheBlueTurtle1
10-10-2017, 02:10 AM
What issues did Panda khan cross over with the TMNT?
Powder
10-10-2017, 02:38 AM
None, I'm afraid.
TheBlueTurtle1
10-10-2017, 02:41 AM
None, I'm afraid.
I always assumed they appeared in a comic at some point..... So why did he get a figure?
Powder
10-10-2017, 02:43 AM
Same thing as with Usagi. Creator was a friend, they were doing a favor. Supposedly he was gonna have a cartoon appearance but it never panned out for one reason or another.
TheBlueTurtle1
10-10-2017, 02:59 AM
Same thing as with Usagi. Creator was a friend, they were doing a favor. Supposedly he was gonna have a cartoon appearance but it never panned out for one reason or another.
Ok, Thank you for clearing that up. Been wondering what the deal was with him for years.:D
Ninjinister
10-10-2017, 03:15 PM
What issues did Panda khan cross over with the TMNT?
None, I'm afraid.
I mean, unless you count this
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-uQSAcSr8mg0/V7DJ4JUs3PI/AAAAAAAARso/lmMZvoDF6IcDVrkGfIVDYNwgCHalcaVqwCLcB/s1600/Equine%2B6-0.jpg
Probably not a question for the IDW thread, regardless.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-10-2017, 03:22 PM
I saw this on a Facebook group page...
https://scontent.fbna2-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/22007853_10156850330432715_402384606039960150_n.jp g?oh=3406102be92277a7b0041f8b7f263a40&oe=5A828B33
I thought TMNT/Batman was not canon. Is it now??
That can't be official. Shredder was already dead where this timeline places Batman/TMNT.
Bobby Curnow
10-11-2017, 12:36 PM
This is more of a production question, but as someone who has helped create a comic, you would know. My friend and I are trying to create a comic of our own, and I was wondering: how far would you recommend we plot out the story? Neither of us can agree. Thanks!
This is an entirely personal question! As much of a story as you see fit! In terms of pitching to a publisher, I'd say formatting it for a mini-series, (4-6 issues) with potential for more to follow if the first is successful is a good way to go. Warning bells always go off when new writers say that the series has to be 10 to 12 or more issues. That's too much of a commitment for an unproven series. But if you frame it like a four issue series, with potential for two more four issue series, that's much more agreeable.
Bobby Curnow
10-11-2017, 12:37 PM
I saw this on a Facebook group page...
https://scontent.fbna2-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/22007853_10156850330432715_402384606039960150_n.jp g?oh=3406102be92277a7b0041f8b7f263a40&oe=5A828B33
I thought TMNT/Batman was not canon. Is it now??
It is not. This is doubling as a sales tool, so thus it was included.
Vegita-San
10-11-2017, 12:56 PM
This is an entirely personal question! As much of a story as you see fit! In terms of pitching to a publisher, I'd say formatting it for a mini-series, (4-6 issues) with potential for more to follow if the first is successful is a good way to go. Warning bells always go off when new writers say that the series has to be 10 to 12 or more issues. That's too much of a commitment for an unproven series. But if you frame it like a four issue series, with potential for two more four issue series, that's much more agreeable.
the way I approach it is like a TV Series. since I find most comics so convoluted anyway, it tends to be simpler to have stand alone stories. If you don't like one, you can skip it and head onto the next one. that being said, even mine will end on a 4 parter if it ever got that far to issue 24 for the 'season finale' ;o).
TurtleWA
10-12-2017, 06:31 PM
But if you frame it like a four issue series, with potential for two more four issue series, that's much more agreeable.
If IDW committed to this four issue series. What would the payment range be? I know different things may factor into the sum so that's why I asked for a range.
How is financial compensation distributed among all the talent that contribute to making a comic book? What are some ranges?
I hope money is not a weird subject to bring up. I am very curious about the business.
Bobby Curnow
10-12-2017, 07:23 PM
No problem to discuss. We very rarely pay rates on creator owned, you'd have to be a major name in the industry with a proven track record and fan base.
The normal deal is a cut of the profits after expenses. (What the exact percentage is varies from project to project.) That's what my creator owned was. It took two years for me to recoop the money I paid to the artist. I think i've probably made about $800 profit on the book.
TurtleWA
10-12-2017, 07:39 PM
What is the page rate stuff I hear about? Does IDW do that? Is it for artist only or do writers have a page rate?
Bobby Curnow
10-12-2017, 09:49 PM
Well, creatives are paid page rates on work for hire... like the creative team on TMNT gets a certain amount of money per page of work they do.
In terms of creator owned projects, sometimes page rates are included, but not always. Sometimes a page rate is introduced after a series is successful, in addition to the cut of the back end. It depends on the publisher and the type of deal that is reached between said publisher and the creative team. Generally speaking, every deal is different.
TurtleWA
10-12-2017, 10:02 PM
makes sense thanks for the info :tsmile:
Panda_Kahn_fan
10-13-2017, 10:59 AM
Hey Bobby, any chance of the turtles traveling outside of NYC for a long period of time, maybe traveling the world, like in Archie?
Bobby Curnow
10-13-2017, 03:03 PM
There's a possibility, yes. It's actually something we've discussed recently, though I don't the road to 100 is going to allow time for it. Some things are still in works though, so maybe!
ChosenOne
10-13-2017, 05:19 PM
There's a possibility, yes. It's actually something we've discussed recently, though I don't the road to 100 is going to allow time for it. Some things are still in works though, so maybe!
Just having fun here, but if it were completely up to you and you had to make your picks right now, where in the world would you like to take the Turtles in a story like that? Me, I think I'd go with Brazil, France, Egypt, Japan and Australia for a nice blend of cultures and potentially fun environments to explore.
Utrommaniac
10-13-2017, 05:29 PM
Mongolia might have to be a big one too. With Pepperoni in tow of course. Maybe a few of the Utroms stationed there during the dinosaur era. "Oh hey, I wondered where that bit of machinery went."
Bobby Curnow
10-13-2017, 07:31 PM
Just having fun here, but if it were completely up to you and you had to make your picks right now, where in the world would you like to take the Turtles in a story like that? Me, I think I'd go with Brazil, France, Egypt, Japan and Australia for a nice blend of cultures and potentially fun environments to explore.
I went to Iceland earlier in the year, so I think it'd be fun for them to go there. Or hawaii. I dunno, something about the Turtles chilling in a picturesque island is appealing to me. Part of me just wants the Turtles to have a nice mellow vacation. They deserve it!
MikeandRaph87
10-13-2017, 07:36 PM
I went to Iceland earlier in the year, so I think it'd be fun for them to go there. Or hawaii. I dunno, something about the Turtles chilling in a picturesque island is appealing to me. Part of me just wants the Turtles to have a nice mellow vacation. They deserve it!
Reads like a small arc starting in TMNT# 101 by Bobby Curnow to me. :tgrin:
DevilSpooky
10-13-2017, 08:26 PM
I went to Iceland earlier in the year, so I think it'd be fun for them to go there. Or hawaii. I dunno, something about the Turtles chilling in a picturesque island is appealing to me. Part of me just wants the Turtles to have a nice mellow vacation. They deserve it!
They're not strangers to Portugal with them all coming here in the Fred Wolf show or Leo on the Prequel comics to the 2007 CGI movie, we're the big thing latelly with Madonna, Fasbender and a few others moving here :twink:
ChosenOne
10-13-2017, 09:07 PM
They're not strangers to Portugal with them all coming here in the Fred Wolf show or Leo on the Prequel comics to the 2007 CGI movie, we're the big thing latelly with Madonna, Fasbender and a few others moving here :twink:
They did?! I gotta track down that episode and watch it just to see how accurate it was!
Portugal is somehow always incredibly misrepresented in American media (the recent portrayal in the MacGyver reboot comes to mind... ugh) but that could change in the near future, partly due to the very reasons you brought up! :D
According to urban legends, Splinter at least (or the Rat King!) should feel right at home in the tunnels beneath the Mafra Palace... :lol:
ChosenOne
10-13-2017, 09:36 PM
So I went on Wikipedia to look for that Portugal episode (7x06 Ring of Fire), and I saw "Lisbon" followed shortly after by "the annual running of the bulls"... Yeah. No. Sorry. The misrepresentation curse continues. :(
Panda_Kahn_fan
10-13-2017, 11:33 PM
So I went on Wikipedia to look for that Portugal episode (7x06 Ring of Fire), and I saw "Lisbon" followed shortly after by "the annual running of the bulls"... Yeah. No. Sorry. The misrepresentation curse continues. :(
But.. Portugal does have running of the bull festivals. The town of Moitia, just 20 miles south of Lisbon, is known to have a running of the bulls festival.
DevilSpooky
10-14-2017, 12:07 AM
So I went on Wikipedia to look for that Portugal episode (7x06 Ring of Fire), and I saw "Lisbon" followed shortly after by "the annual running of the bulls"... Yeah. No. Sorry. The misrepresentation curse continues. :(
Yeah that's the one, and yes, they did somethings really badly, for example the city of Lisbon looks more like some spanish city or something like that, and the running of the bulls does indeed look out of place in the city, but the Bull arena in Campo Pequeno looks spot on, and there's the beach in Estoril and April's fun pronunciation of it. All in all it's a really weak episode but it's still awesome non the less that they came here at least once :tcool:
ChosenOne
10-14-2017, 06:50 AM
But.. Portugal does have running of the bull festivals. The town of Moitia, just 20 miles south of Lisbon, is known to have a running of the bulls festival.
It does, but it's only one out of two or three total places in the country that do it, and they're all fairly backwards backwater towns. Not to mention the vast majority of people in the country loathe that "tradition" more and more due to animal as well as human casualties, so it's hardly an accurate representation of Portugal. We're nothing like Spain in that regard. They're the granddaddies of that practice and the ones keeping it alive.
Yeah that's the one, and yes, they did somethings really badly, for example the city of Lisbon looks more like some spanish city or something like that, and the running of the bulls does indeed look out of place in the city, but the Bull arena in Campo Pequeno looks spot on, and there's the beach in Estoril and April's fun pronunciation of it. All in all it's a really weak episode but it's still awesome non the less that they came here at least once :tcool:
Why am I not surprised that they completely missed the mark with the running of the bulls but are familiar with Estoril? :lol:
Sophie Campbell
10-14-2017, 06:14 PM
I went to Iceland earlier in the year, so I think it'd be fun for them to go there. Or hawaii. I dunno, something about the Turtles chilling in a picturesque island is appealing to me. Part of me just wants the Turtles to have a nice mellow vacation. They deserve it!
You know where to find me.
CyberCubed
10-14-2017, 06:32 PM
It was said before that 2018 won't see as many TMNT comics published as 2017, as there won't be another 5-week event like Dimension X, or the upcoming Ghostbusters crossover, or the free comic book day issue, Usagi crossover, double-sized issue 75, or the Nick animated comics which finished their run in 2017 with Robotanimals.
Aside from the second Batman crossover, can we just expect the main ongoing and Universe next year, bar maybe a surprise here or there? Is Universe expected to run through all of 2018?
Bobby Curnow
10-16-2017, 12:08 PM
You know where to find me.
Haha, you would be the one!
Bobby Curnow
10-16-2017, 12:09 PM
Too early to say what exactly we'll be seeing next year beyond what has already been announced. There's no plans for Universe to stop at this time.
TurtleWA
10-16-2017, 03:16 PM
Any plans for future Universe issues that include Pitarra and Lees?
Bobby Curnow
10-16-2017, 03:30 PM
Not at this time, no. They are welcome though!
TurtleWA
10-16-2017, 03:43 PM
Okay thanks
Panda_Kahn_fan
10-18-2017, 10:43 AM
Hey Bobby, are there any plans for any kind of 'Rise of the TMNT' comic project next year?
Bobby Curnow
10-18-2017, 11:06 AM
Not anything I can discuss at this time, sorry.
martinitolove
10-19-2017, 02:30 PM
Bobby, will we see the other two amulettes from "Karai's Path" in the future issues? Did she take them from the cave for her henchmen?
martinitolove
10-19-2017, 02:38 PM
When will Groundchuck (Chi-Yuo) meet Dirtbag (Ocho)?
Powder
10-19-2017, 03:10 PM
When will Groundchuck (Chi-Yuo) meet Dirtbag (Ocho)?
They are not Groundchuck & Dirtbag. At all. It's an insult to their creators that you just dismiss their unique qualities & throw them in a Playmates box.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.