View Full Version : Ask a Question: IDW's TMNT Editor Thread
Pages :
[
1]
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 05:47 PM
Hi guys,
I'm Bobby Curnow, and edit and co-plot the current IDW TMNT comic. I had a "Question" thread over at the IDW forums, but they've been down for a while, so I thought I'd start one here. Feel free to post your questions about any of the IDW TMNT comic books, and I will do my best to answer in an honest and timely manner.
A few "small print" things:
-I will reserve the right to not answer questions that could spoil things like up-coming plot points. Sometimes the mere act of choosing not to answer a question can result in a sorta-spoiler in itself, so bear with me if I ignore a question in regards to future story events, or willfully obfuscate. If I can safely tease something, I may do so, but take it with a grain of salt. It's not set in stone until you read the actual issue. Things can change last minute!
-I get lots of questions about IDW's reprint program. I have almost nothing to do with the reprints, and that department is the most overworked at IDW (just two guys handling EVERYTHING that IDW reprints, which is a lot), so I am very reluctant to take time out of my day and bother those guys. Feel free to ask questions regarding this, sometimes I know or hear things, but don't be upset if I don't have the answer and am unwilling to investigate further. That will probably be the case. It's not my area, and I want to respect the folks whose area it is!
-I've always been impressed with how respectful people are on this forum, but I may chose to not answer questions/statements that I deem to be not respectful to myself or the rest of the creative team (and yes, what is respectful is subjective). That being said, if you've got a concern or critique that is respectfully worded, i'm happy to read it.
-These are my own opinions and thoughts, and as much as is possible, not reflective of IDW or Nickelodeon/Viacom. Though obviously i'm going to tread a line that respects the fact that I am employed by, or work with, them.
Hmm... I think that's it. I'll just take this opportunity, on behalf of Tom, Kevin, the artists and IDW, to thank you all for your support and interest. We are very aware and thankful of it.
EDIT: If you'd like your question to be considered to be included in an upcoming issue of TMNT's Ninja Notes, please mark your post as "OK TO PRINT". Feel free to include your name or place of residence if you'd like, but that is not necessary. I will attribute the question to your screen name if that's all I have.
PangolinFeets
01-13-2016, 05:57 PM
Hi Bobby! Thanks for making this and proving once again that IDW truly values their fans.
My question is...didja get my Ninja Note??? :)
Because pretty much most of my questions were in there...
CyberCubed
01-13-2016, 05:59 PM
Bobby, how does it feel to already be over 4 years and 50+ issues into IDW TMNT already? Sometimes it feels like only yesterday the IDW comic started, I can't believe its already been 4 years and over 50+ issues and mini's.
Did you guys ever think you'd get this far? Was it expected to be a success from the start? Looks like we'll reach issue 100 before we know it.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:01 PM
Hey Bobby! This is GREAT!
I've got a couple of questions for you:
#1. Not to beat that poor departed horse, but any idea when we can expect the first reprint of TMNT Volume 3 from Image Comics? :tgrin:
#2. Will Kevin be doing an annual this year, and why have we had annuals ever other year instead of truly annual?
#3. Now that TMNT has crossed over with the biggest DC comic character, does IDW have any desire to approach any other big non-IDW franchises for potential future crossovers?
More as I think of 'em. :trazz: Thank you for taking the time out of your duties to talk with us fans! It's always a pleasure!
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:12 PM
Hi Bobby! Thanks for making this and proving once again that IDW truly values their fans.
My question is...didja get my Ninja Note??? :)
Because pretty much most of my questions were in there...
I think so...? I honestly can't remember! You can DM me your email address and I can do a search for it.
Allio
01-13-2016, 06:14 PM
Would you want either:
A) IDW x Mirage team-up
or
B)IDW x Nick x Platinum team-up
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:15 PM
Bobby, how does it feel to already be over 4 years and 50+ issues into IDW TMNT already? Sometimes it feels like only yesterday the IDW comic started, I can't believe its already been 4 years and over 50+ issues and mini's.
Did you guys ever think you'd get this far? Was it expected to be a success from the start? Looks like we'll reach issue 100 before we know it.
Thanks, Cubed!
I think we thought it would be at least a moderate success and we'd get at least a couple years of stories. We aimed for 50 pretty close to the end of the first year, so we had that in our sights for a while. What was unexpected was for word to grow and for sales to either be stable, or go up, over the years. That's been great. I hope we can make it to 100, i'm very excited for some upcoming stuff between now and then.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:19 PM
Worst case scenario, Bobby:
If IDW were to have to end its TMNT series, how much notice do you think you, Tom, and Kevin would have, and do you think you would be able to wrap up most of the loose ends and plots in that given time?
Sorry, it's kinda depressing... but thinking about Image Volume 3 and Mirage Volume 4 brought this question to mind.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:25 PM
Hey Bobby! This is GREAT!
I've got a couple of questions for you:
#1. Not to beat that poor departed horse, but any idea when we can expect the first reprint of TMNT Volume 3 from Image Comics? :tgrin:
#2. Will Kevin be doing an annual this year, and why have we had annuals ever other year instead of truly annual?
#3. Now that TMNT has crossed over with the biggest DC comic character, does IDW have any desire to approach any other big non-IDW franchises for potential future crossovers?
More as I think of 'em. :trazz: Thank you for taking the time out of your duties to talk with us fans! It's always a pleasure!
1. I just looked at the publishing schedule and I'm not seeing Vol. 3 Image material, which is news to me. We do look to be continuing Tales and Archie. No clue as to why no Vol. 3, I'm disappointed if that's true. (it might not be, the publishing schedule changes frequently)
I'll see if I can get any more information on this next time I bump into the reprint guys.
2. The Annuals were intended to be annual, but the second one was delayed, well, a year! No plans for one this year, Kevin is busy working on a couple different original projects, outside of TMNT. (though we will still be getting covers, and now that he lives in San Diego, we are having more regular brainstorming sessions with him than ever)
3. Outside of Usagi Yojimbo, which is my favorite comic of all time, I personally usually have no taste for crossovers, so I'm not pushing for any. That being said, i've been pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed both Ghostbusters and Batman. And they've been financial successes, so I'm sure we'll see more in the coming years. Those deals are always hard to figure out though, so it's hard to say when and what and if we'll see another crossover.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:26 PM
Would you want either:
A) IDW x Mirage team-up
or
B)IDW x Nick x Platinum team-up
Like, crossovers of the different character incarnations? I can't say I care one way or another, would depend completely on execution. They both have potential to be cool, or very not cool.
MrTrikey
01-13-2016, 06:28 PM
When we gonna see Zog (again), and more Triceratons? :D
But in all seriousness, thanks for doing this. It's always great to see proof that IDW knows its audience.
I'd REALLY like to ask a question pertaining to the upcoming P* TMNT game, but I know you can't even talk about it yet until Activision FINALLY makes an official announcement about it! :lol:
DrSpengler
01-13-2016, 06:30 PM
Great to have a line of communication again! You know we all appreciate it!
My query...
The trade collection containing issues #51-55 is called "Order from Chaos".
Now, is that the name of the whole arc of those 5 issues, or did you have different names for the different storylines ala "Sins of the Fathers"/"Blood Brothers" (even though the trade containing those issues only went by "Sins of the Fathers")?
And heck, since I'm bugging you, will 5-issue arcs be the new norm over the previous 4-issue formula?
Thanks, as ever!
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:31 PM
Worst case scenario, Bobby:
If IDW were to have to end its TMNT series, how much notice do you think you, Tom, and Kevin would have, and do you think you would be able to wrap up most of the loose ends and plots in that given time?
Sorry, it's kinda depressing... but thinking about Image Volume 3 and Mirage Volume 4 brought this question to mind.
Hard to say, sometimes decisions can be made quickly. I'd like to say that we'd get a year's notice, in which case we could do something that would be a respectful end of the series, though we'd have to omit a lot of stuff we have planned.
Honestly, I think we need at least until issue #100 to properly address everything we are setting up between now and TMNT #65. Maybe we could pull it off by TMNT #75 with the help of mini-series and whatnot.
I could have a different opinion in a month, or six months, or a year. Everything changes with time!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:32 PM
Couple more questions! :tgrin:
#1. Did you and the rest of the team ever consider naming the Foot Assassin in #51/52 Pimiko? I was personally hoping that would happen...
#2. Does IDW have a character blacklist, i.e. are there any preexisting TMNT characters you and the guys would NEVER, no matter what, EVER use in IDW? Not even in a throwaway gag or simple name-drop? Pimiko? Venus? Dogpound and Fishface? Eric Sachs? Cudley the Cowlick? :tlol:
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:33 PM
When we gonna see Zog (again), and more Triceratons? :D
But in all seriousness, thanks for doing this. It's always great to see proof that IDW knows its audience.
I'd REALLY like to ask a question pertaining to the upcoming P* TMNT game, but I know you can't even talk about it yet until Activision FINALLY makes an official announcement about it! :lol:
We have not forgot about Zog or the Triceratons. They will play a big part, but don't expect anything this year.
I don't keep track of the video games or movies (I do watch the Nick Toon), so I wouldn't be any help even if I could talk!
PangolinFeets
01-13-2016, 06:33 PM
I'm really excited about Deviations! Is this just a one-shot or are we going to get more on this particular story? Can you give us any info on the Dark turtles???
Oh, and while you may not have video game info, what about new info on the board game? We got one spoiler image of Casey and it looks great!!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:34 PM
Hard to say, sometimes decisions can be made quickly. I'd like to say that we'd get a year's notice, in which case we could do something that would be a respectful end of the series, though we'd have to omit a lot of stuff we have planned.
Honestly, I think we need at least until issue #100 to properly address everything we are setting up between now and TMNT #65. Maybe we could pull it off by TMNT #75 with the help of mini-series and whatnot.
I could have a different opinion in a month, or six months, or a year. Everything changes with time!
If something catastrophic were to happen, would it be possible for the fans to somehow pitch in and help keep the comic alive? I'm guessing there's not much we can do except keep buying (which we are all thrilled to be able to do), but would there be any possibility of keeping alive in the same vein as the original Star Trek fans demanding the show be brought back for a third season?
PangolinFeets
01-13-2016, 06:37 PM
If something catastrophic were to happen, would it be possible for the fans to somehow pitch in and help keep the comic alive? I'm guessing there's not much we can do except keep buying (which we are all thrilled to be able to do), but would there be any possibility of keeping alive in the same vein as the original Star Trek fans demanding the show be brought back for a third season?
Careful not to fry yourself on the defrib, Cy. TMNT is far from dead. Lol
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:40 PM
Careful not to fry yourself on the defrib, Cy. TMNT is far from dead. Lol
Oh, absolutely. I'm just curious. As someone said in another thread somewhere, TMNT has a long history of starting strong and ending poorly or prematurely.
While I don't expect this to happen with IDW, I am curious if they ever have any contigency plans. 'Cause there have been a LOT of good comic series that ended prematurely while far lesser comics continued to sell month after month even though they're absolutely terrible.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:41 PM
Great to have a line of communication again! You know we all appreciate it!
My query...
The trade collection containing issues #51-55 is called "Order from Chaos".
Now, is that the name of the whole arc of those 5 issues, or did you have different names for the different storylines ala "Sins of the Fathers"/"Blood Brothers" (even though the trade containing those issues only went by "Sins of the Fathers")?
And heck, since I'm bugging you, will 5-issue arcs be the new norm over the previous 4-issue formula?
Thanks, as ever!
Truthfully, we rarely have TPB titles in mind when we're scripting, so when the TPB folk ask us, Tom and I are always like "Uhh... how about... THIS!" Some have worked out well, like City Fall. Others, like Vengeance, I haven't been that found of.
I also think the TPBs make people think we are writing for the trade, when we're not. We've had 4-issue story arcs, single issues, two-parters, seven-parters and a three parter coming up. We write what fits the story we have in mind, and hope it's not too jarring when read in TPB form, which I think we've got lucky with.
"Order From Chaos" is really two 2-parters, and a single stand-alone issue. We don't have individual names for those different parts.
Basically, we just try and come up with something appropriate after the fact. Sometimes, like with "Attack On Technodrome" it's easy, sometimes it's not.
5-issue TPBs are the new norm!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:44 PM
What is one thing you've wanted to do with TMNT at IDW that you haven't yet been able to do? Or would answering that result in spoilers?
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:45 PM
Couple more questions! :tgrin:
#1. Did you and the rest of the team ever consider naming the Foot Assassin in #51/52 Pimiko? I was personally hoping that would happen...
#2. Does IDW have a character blacklist, i.e. are there any preexisting TMNT characters you and the guys would NEVER, no matter what, EVER use in IDW? Not even in a throwaway gag or simple name-drop? Pimiko? Venus? Dogpound and Fishface? Eric Sachs? Cudley the Cowlick? :tlol:
1. No. Pimiko carries a lot of associations with her which were not appropriate for Jennika.
2. We have a "Preferred Character" list from Nickelodeon that has all of the (very many) characters we are legally allowed to use. So basically, I have to check that list when we want to use someone, but it's rare, like Bloodsucker, when we can't. It's not set in stone, but we also try and avoid new characters from new media, at least for a year or two, more as a professional courtesy than anything else. So no plans for Eric Sachs or Fishface, but who knows, could happen in the future.
I'm a big Cudley fan, so i'd love to see the Cowlick sometime!
DrSpengler
01-13-2016, 06:47 PM
5-issue trades! Nice!
Thanks for the answers!
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:48 PM
I'm really excited about Deviations! Is this just a one-shot or are we going to get more on this particular story? Can you give us any info on the Dark turtles???
Oh, and while you may not have video game info, what about new info on the board game? We got one spoiler image of Casey and it looks great!!
Just a one-shot story, but there's actually some elements that happen in Deviations that I think we can build on in weird ways in the TMNT ongoing. Can't really say more than that.
I'll leave it to Nate and crew to share material from the board game, but everything I've seen looks great, and I am eager to play it!
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:51 PM
If something catastrophic were to happen, would it be possible for the fans to somehow pitch in and help keep the comic alive? I'm guessing there's not much we can do except keep buying (which we are all thrilled to be able to do), but would there be any possibility of keeping alive in the same vein as the original Star Trek fans demanding the show be brought back for a third season?
I doubt it. I think we'd manage something that would end things at least partly the way we want it, even if it's not ideal situations. I can't see us stopping cold turkey, mid-storyline like some things in the past. What I could see is us sharing storylines we didn't get to, after the fact. Would be cool to see folks tackle those storylines. But this IS morbid! We're doing great and sales are healthy! :tcool:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:52 PM
This one's probably been asked before, but what first got you into TMNT?
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:52 PM
What is one thing you've wanted to do with TMNT at IDW that you haven't yet been able to do? Or would answering that result in spoilers?
TMNT/Usagi crossover.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:53 PM
TMNT/Usagi crossover.
Oooooh. Yes, that would be great! Hopefully someday...
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 06:55 PM
This one's probably been asked before, but what first got you into TMNT?
I'm 34, so grew up during prime Turtle-mania. So the cartoon and then movie. As I became a pre-teen I got into the Mirage comics in a big way. Though I had come across a couple before that. I recall the first TMNT comic I ever read was some late printing of TMNT #2 that my Mom somehow came across. I thought the Mousers were so cool! (still do!)
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 06:58 PM
I think I'm all outta questions for now. :tlol: Thanks again for taking the time to talk with us on the 'Drome, Bobby! Here's to Issue #100 and #150! :tcool:
MikeandRaph87
01-13-2016, 06:59 PM
How do you decide what characters to include in the comic? Dark Water for example seems quite obscure appearing in just one later 1987 cartoon episode. I felt that the group had potetial never utilized within it's universe of origin not considering any other appearance outside of it. Roundtable discussion of favorite characters? Research through the vast media?
What would you say to the Turtles going abroad or exploring Dimension X? I have wanted to see more from the Nuetrinos after the amazing reworking of them back in the late teens of the ongoing.
mrmaczaps
01-13-2016, 07:11 PM
Are we going to have any new artists in the near future?
Any chance for any of the Mirage Era artists or guest cover artists to work on full issues?
Any chance for a Tales of series to allow for other artists to work within the IDW Universe?
I'd like to see Steve Lavigne, Jim Lawson, Rich Woodall, Ben Bishop, Sal Otero and a few others work on the Turtles. (Just to name a few...)
(Okay to print.)
Ninjinister
01-13-2016, 07:15 PM
Hi Bobby! Thanks for this thread. As you may be able to guess if you look at sigs, I'm the main administrator for Wikia's TMNT Wiki. One thing I've been trying to figure out in terms of structure is how precisely the different incarnations of the TMNT are separated, and how they can be better categorized. Right now they're listed by like, 87 series, 03 series, 12 series, Mirage, Archie, IDW, etc. But I'd like to get a better, coherent categorization like Marvel and DC do with their New/Prime Earth and Earth-616 and the like. If I were to get an official way to designate incarnations, would you or anyone else at IDW be someone I can talk to about that, or would I have to keep trying at the ear of Nick? (I've tried getting in touch with Ciro and others at Nick and have gotten nothing)
Also are we ever gonna see Tristan Jones back on anything TMNT?
neatoman
01-13-2016, 07:16 PM
Where did the reincarnation idea come from? It's without a doubt the biggest deviation from what people expected and I am curious how you guys decided on it.
CyberCubed
01-13-2016, 08:08 PM
Was the low sales of the last two mini's (Mutanimals and April/Casey) the reason there is a long gap before the next mini? I remember you saying the Batman crossover wasn't the reason we won't have a new mini for a few months, so I'm curious.
Its disappointing the Mutanimals mini especially sold so little, I thought it was great! Would love to see more stories with Hob and the other Mutanimals.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 09:18 PM
Hey Bobby, has IDW ever approached Peter Laird or Steve Murphy to write a guest issue for TMNT?
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 09:47 PM
How do you decide what characters to include in the comic? Dark Water for example seems quite obscure appearing in just one later 1987 cartoon episode. I felt that the group had potetial never utilized within it's universe of origin not considering any other appearance outside of it. Roundtable discussion of favorite characters? Research through the vast media?
What would you say to the Turtles going abroad or exploring Dimension X? I have wanted to see more from the Nuetrinos after the amazing reworking of them back in the late teens of the ongoing.
Broadly speaking, we just look to see who would best serve the story we're trying to tell. Specifically, you'd have to ask Tom. I didn't remember them from the cartoon at all!
You'll be seeing more Dimension X in the future, though not for a while.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 09:54 PM
Are we going to have any new artists in the near future?
Any chance for any of the Mirage Era artists or guest cover artists to work on full issues?
Any chance for a Tales of series to allow for other artists to work within the IDW Universe?
I'don't like to see Steve Lavigne, Jim Lawson, Rich Woodall, Ben Bishop, Sal Otero and a few others work on the Turtles. (Just to name a few...)
Yes on new artists. There's one i'm excited about I think maybe coming in after the Leatherhead arc.
I've got complicated thoughts on the Mirage crew. I'm a huge fan of all of them (the 30th Anniversary book was my big love letter to TMNT of the past), but i'm always hesitant to bring them on to the IDW book. Mostly i'd like for us to be blazing our own trail, at least artistically, and it's important to me that the book have it's own identity. That being said, anything is possible.
We've got something in the works that I hope will allow for a wide range of artists, and different types of stories.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 09:56 PM
Hi Bobby! Thanks for this thread. As you may be able to guess if you look at sigs, I'm the main administrator for Wikia's TMNT Wiki. One thing I've been trying to figure out in terms of structure is how precisely the different incarnations of the TMNT are separated, and how they can be better categorized. Right now they're listed by like, 87 series, 03 series, 12 series, Mirage, Archie, IDW, etc. But I'd like to get a better, coherent categorization like Marvel and DC do with their New/Prime Earth and Earth-616 and the like. If I were to get an official way to designate incarnations, would you or anyone else at IDW be someone I can talk to about that, or would I have to keep trying at the ear of Nick? (I've tried getting in touch with Ciro and others at Nick and have gotten nothing)
Also are we ever gonna see Tristan Jones back on anything TMNT?
That would indeed be a question for Nickelodeon, and not something I could help too much with, i'm afraid. Thanks for your work on the wiki!
No plans for Tristan at the moment. Had fun seeing him in Australia last year, though!
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 09:58 PM
Where did the reincarnation idea come from? It's without a doubt the biggest deviation from what people expected and I am curious how you guys decided on it.
The reincarnation aspect is completely Tom's idea, so I can't speak much to where it came from (Tom, if you read this, you should feel free to chime in!). Once he floated it, it seemed like an idea that opened up a lot of story potential, so that was attractive to me. As an added bonus, it does help our TMNT stand out a bit from other iterations.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 10:02 PM
Was the low sales of the last two mini's (Mutanimals and April/Casey) the reason there is a long gap before the next mini? I remember you saying the Batman crossover wasn't the reason we won't have a new mini for a few months, so I'm curious.
Its disappointing the Mutanimals mini especially sold so little, I thought it was great! Would love to see more stories with Hob and the other Mutanimals.
Hmm, I don't recall saying the Batman crossover wasn't the reason for no current mini-series (but I could be misremembering). I think it was the main reason! It was supposed to start earlier too, so that's why there was a break between that and Casey/April.
Both Mutanimals and Casey/April, while not selling as much as say, Turtles in Time, sold perfectly healthy for an IDW book. So that wasn't a factor.
That being said, we also wanted time to prepare for some stuff coming up. If things go the way they are planned, we'll be making up for the draught of side-series set in the IDW universe.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 10:05 PM
Hey Bobby, has IDW ever approached Peter Laird or Steve Murphy to write a guest issue for TMNT?
Peter, while always being polite and respectful to IDW, has made it clear in various ways that he's not interested in doing more TMNT currently (at least that's my interpretation), so I've never seriously approached him.
I think i've said in the past that I'd like to see Forever War finished, and I've talked to Murphy about that. It's something that keeps getting kicked down the road a bit, for various reasons. I'm still hopeful, but at the same time, I don't want to get anyone's hopes up.
MikeandRaph87
01-13-2016, 10:13 PM
Broadly speaking, we just look to see who would best serve the story we're trying to tell. Specifically, you'd have to ask Tom. I didn't remember them from the cartoon at all!
You'll be seeing more Dimension X in the future, though not for a while.
Thank you for the reply. You answered my follow up about the unpublished Forever War. I wondered if after all the series was reprinted and whatever rights have to be secured it would finally see print. I have been eaiting since 3rd grade for this.
I was hoping to see a glimpse of it while checking in on your namesake island.
Your active involvement in the story has me ask, the next time a oneshot within a micro-series is up, what about an issue written by you? I would like to to see what you would do directly as a writer.
mrmaczaps
01-13-2016, 10:42 PM
Yes on new artists. There's one i'm excited about I think maybe coming in after the Leatherhead arc.
I've got complicated thoughts on the Mirage crew. I'm a huge fan of all of them (the 30th Anniversary book was my big love letter to TMNT of the past), but i'm always hesitant to bring them on to the IDW book. Mostly i'd like for us to be blazing our own trail, at least artistically, and it's important to me that the book have it's own identity. That being said, anything is possible.
We've got something in the works that I hope will allow for a wide range of artists, and different types of stories.
Thank you for answering my questions.
PangolinFeets
01-13-2016, 10:46 PM
Do you have a favorite panel or line of dialogue that you are particularly proud of? I know its a team effort, but I'm sure there are certain things that wouldn't have happened without your influence.
Can we get a Christmas issue next year???????
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 11:10 PM
Thank you for the reply. You answered my follow up about the unpublished Forever War. I wondered if after all the series was reprinted and whatever rights have to be secured it would finally see print. I have been eaiting since 3rd grade for this.
I was hoping to see a glimpse of it while checking in on your namesake island.
Your active involvement in the story has me ask, the next time a oneshot within a micro-series is up, what about an issue written by you? I would like to to see what you would do directly as a writer.
I appreciate that! But i'm focused on my own projects and get lots of creative satisfaction from working with Tom on the plot... anything I did with TMNT would be a lot worse without him I think. But who knows, maybe one day.
Bobby Curnow
01-13-2016, 11:18 PM
Do you have a favorite panel or line of dialogue that you are particularly proud of? I know its a team effort, but I'm sure there are certain things that wouldn't have happened without your influence.
Can we get a Christmas issue next year???????
Not really. Most of my contributions are big picture plot things, of which I am proud, but there aren't many small moments or panels. I think i've contributed less than 1% of the dialogue of the series, that's all Tom.
Oh! Herman the Hermit Crab. While his personality came from Tom, the idea of having a crab mutant that uses a dumpster for a shell was my idea. So I get a kick every time I see him. Also, objectively, I think Mateus did an astounding job on his design. The face, the dumpster arsenal, the helmet-- all fantastic and purely Mateus' inspiration.
Haven't thought about a Christmas issue, but maybe! Don't know that it would line up with the seasonal timeline of the series, though we always play pretty fast and loose with that.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-13-2016, 11:24 PM
Not really. Most of my contributions are big picture plot things, of which I am proud, but there aren't many small moments or panels. I think i've contributed less than 1% of the dialogue of the series, that's all Tom.
Oh! Herman the Hermit Crab. While his personality came from Tom, the idea of having a crab mutant that uses a dumpster for a shell was my idea. So I get a kick every time I see him. Also, objectively, I think Mateus did an astounding job on his design. The face, the dumpster arsenal, the helmet-- all fantastic and purely Mateus' inspiration.
Haven't thought about a Christmas issue, but maybe! Don't know that it would line up with the seasonal timeline of the series, though we always play pretty fast and loose with that.
So YOU'RE the guy responsible for my second-favorite IDW character!
Who came up with Old Hob (my absolute all-time favorite)? You, Tom, or Kevin?
PangolinFeets
01-13-2016, 11:44 PM
Not really. Most of my contributions are big picture plot things, of which I am proud, but there aren't many small moments or panels. I think i've contributed less than 1% of the dialogue of the series, that's all Tom.
Oh! Herman the Hermit Crab. While his personality came from Tom, the idea of having a crab mutant that uses a dumpster for a shell was my idea. So I get a kick every time I see him. Also, objectively, I think Mateus did an astounding job on his design. The face, the dumpster arsenal, the helmet-- all fantastic and purely Mateus' inspiration.
Haven't thought about a Christmas issue, but maybe! Don't know that it would line up with the seasonal timeline of the series, though we always play pretty fast and loose with that.
Aha!! Herman is so cool!! So thank you for him. :D
I just love TMNT and Christmas. Variants are my favorite gifts. <3
Thank you for being a champ and answering all these.
Panda_Kahn_fan
01-14-2016, 12:36 AM
Love the book, Bobby! Couple of questions;
- Are any of the movie characters usable (Jordan Perry, Chief Sterns, Keno) in an altered form? Like Master Kahn from the 2003 series is basically Tatsu from the films.
-With Kitsune there, do the foot mystics exist in the IDW universe?
-and this is probably a dumb question, but..... Mona Lisa or Dragon Lord, any chance of seeing either of them in IDW?
Again, really love the book!
Sophie Campbell
01-14-2016, 12:39 AM
Can I write and/or draw the Christmas/holiday issue?
Ninjinister
01-14-2016, 01:29 AM
That would indeed be a question for Nickelodeon, and not something I could help too much with, i'm afraid. Thanks for your work on the wiki!
No plans for Tristan at the moment. Had fun seeing him in Australia last year, though!
Not the answers I'd hoped for, but the ones I'd assumed I'd get. Thanks for answering!
As an aside, I hope if Cudley does get used eventually, he ends up retaining the same "one Cudley throughout the multiverse" aspect instead of just being an "IDW Cudley". Or maybe there IS an IDW Cudley... and he ends up running into the other one at some point.
Can I write and/or draw the Christmas/holiday issue?
I'd like to see that happen.
CyberCubed
01-14-2016, 02:52 AM
I second all the support for a Christmas issue in this thread. It doesn't have to be part of the main ongoing, just a one-shot or mini or something. Since we're only in January you guys would have about 10 months to plan ahead a Christmas related story, it could be fun.
member_removed
01-14-2016, 04:46 AM
Are we going to have any new artists in the near future?
Any chance for any of the Mirage Era artists or guest cover artists to work on full issues?
Any chance for a Tales of series to allow for other artists to work within the IDW Universe?
I'd like to see Steve Lavigne, Jim Lawson, Rich Woodall, Ben Bishop, Sal Otero and a few others work on the Turtles. (Just to name a few...)
I think it would be fun to get those guys in to do an annual (if Kevin's, schedule allows him only time to do one annual every 2 years). Have a year on/year off rotation, Kevin/old school Mirage.
Peter, while always being polite and respectful to IDW, has made it clear in various ways that he's not interested in doing more TMNT currently (at least that's my interpretation), so I've never seriously approached him.
I'd rather Pete focus whatever creative energies he has on Mirage Vol 4 anyway!!! :tgrin:
PangolinFeets
01-14-2016, 06:27 AM
Can I write and/or draw the Christmas/holiday issue?
http://i.imgur.com/cKFurgV.jpg
Harukuro
01-14-2016, 07:53 AM
Let me just start by saying that I love what you and Tom Waltz have done with Mikey in this comic. Most incarnations of TMNT place Mikey solely in the role of "comic relief" as opposed to giving him actual depth and character development. So thank you very much for that, especially since he's my favourite turtle.
As for my question: I have been curious about something for a while now. Back when Slash was going to inject himself with the psychotropic compound he cites Mikey as a reason for it because he wants to be a "hero" like Mikey. This emphasis on being a "hero", as well as his admiration for Mikey, is something that has consistently been present in Slash's character. But while I can see why Slash admires Mikey so much, I am not certain why he views the turtle as a "hero" specifically.
So my question basically is: why does Slash see Mikey as a hero, and when did this specific focus on being a "hero" begin?
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2016, 08:30 AM
I think I have a resolution to the above, what if we get a backup for the next December issue focused around the Holiday season? We only have the Michelangelo one-shot from all those years ago for a TMNT Christmas story and we could use another one. If only a short one. Campbell can do the art and guest writer and friendly neighborhood editor Bobby Curnow writes it?
On the subject of the ooze serum to enhance Slash's intellect why not do so for Pete? If there was only that one sample that is cool, but it feels like a plot hole as to why not make Pete take it as well in-story?
turtlefanforever
01-14-2016, 08:59 AM
Any chance the TMNT will cross over with The Incredible Hulk?
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 09:11 AM
So YOU'RE the guy responsible for my second-favorite IDW character!
Who came up with Old Hob (my absolute all-time favorite)? You, Tom, or Kevin?
It was a long time ago, but I actually think Editor-in-Chief Chris Ryall came up with the idea of eye-patched cat as villain. I believe Tom named him. And obviously, gave him his personality.
I had virtually no story contribution the first year. If I recall, the first contributions I had were making Chet Fugitoid, wanting to explore the origins of the Foot in "Secret History" and making Leo the son of Saki, an idea that would morph into "City Fall", all stuff that came about at the end of our first year.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 09:16 AM
Love the book, Bobby! Couple of questions;
- Are any of the movie characters usable (Jordan Perry, Chief Sterns, Keno) in an altered form? Like Master Kahn from the 2003 series is basically Tatsu from the films.
-With Kitsune there, do the foot mystics exist in the IDW universe?
-and this is probably a dumb question, but..... Mona Lisa or Dragon Lord, any chance of seeing either of them in IDW?
Again, really love the book!
I'm not at the office right now and would double check, but i'm pretty sure the movie-specific characters are among the main ones we CANNOT use. Tatsu is out, but I imagine we could use Master Kahn.
We haven't seen Foot mystics, but they could exist. Basically a way of saying: "undetermined"!
No plans for Mona Lisa or Dragon Lord at this time. But understand this is the exact type of question I would respond to in this exact manner if we DID have some major surprise plans for those characters!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 09:16 AM
Can I write and/or draw the Christmas/holiday issue?
Yes. You know you have an open invitation, Sophie!
plastroncafe
01-14-2016, 09:20 AM
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/92/f0/00/92f000ee55a86775d74b73f74f18aaf6.jpg
Well my day has just been made!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 09:22 AM
Let me just start by saying that I love what you and Tom Waltz have done with Mikey in this comic. Most incarnations of TMNT place Mikey solely in the role of "comic relief" as opposed to giving him actual depth and character development. So thank you very much for that, especially since he's my favourite turtle.
As for my question: I have been curious about something for a while now. Back when Slash was going to inject himself with the psychotropic compound he cites Mikey as a reason for it because he wants to be a "hero" like Mikey. This emphasis on being a "hero", as well as his admiration for Mikey, is something that has consistently been present in Slash's character. But while I can see why Slash admires Mikey so much, I am not certain why he views the turtle as a "hero" specifically.
So my question basically is: why does Slash see Mikey as a hero, and when did this specific focus on being a "hero" begin?
This question is very familiar to me... did you send it in to Ninja Notes? If so, I think I answer it in an upcoming issue!
But to keep you from waiting: While Hob took Slash in, he's not the nicest of guys. So Mikey was the first person to show Slash any sort of kindness in his entire life, when he offered Slash a candy bar during City Fall. This made a big impression on Slash's then-mental-state, that carried over to his full intelligence. Basically, I think Slash was exposed to a lot terrible things early on in his life, so when he sees the Turtles (other creatures like himself) do good and strive to be good, it makes a big impression and he considers them heroes.
Good question, thanks!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 09:28 AM
I think I have a resolution to the above, what if we get a backup for the next December issue focused around the Holiday season? We only have the Michelangelo one-shot from all those years ago for a TMNT Christmas story and we could use another one. If only a short one. Campbell can do the art and guest writer and friendly neighborhood editor Bobby Curnow writes it?
On the subject of the ooze serum to enhance Slash's intellect why not do so for Pete? If there was only that one sample that is cool, but it feels like a plot hole as to why not make Pete take it as well in-story?
Don't forget TMNT #5 is set at Christmas! But if someone pitches a Christmas story, i'd be happy to consider it. It's not something that's really on my personal radar at the moment. But will keep it in mind!
I think in-story the explanation would be that that sample of serum is used up, or that Hob already messed up Pete's mutation too much in the initial attempt of it (unlike Slash, who was a monitored lab experiment) for the serum to be effective. I don't think we thought it was important enough to mention all of that during the story.
The real reason is that we all like Pete as he is. He provides a nice contrast to a lot of other characters.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 09:31 AM
Any chance the TMNT will cross over with The Incredible Hulk?
No plans at this time. I believe IDW has approached Marvel with crossover ideas (I know we pitched Godzilla vs. the Avengers, a few years back, as I edit the Godzilla line) but they have respectfully declined.
Hulk Vs. TMNT would be fun to see though!
myconius
01-14-2016, 09:38 AM
Bobby it was really an honor meeting you at last year's NYCC.
this here is not a real question (and you probably don't remember) my brother and i were two of the last people to show up to get passes to meet Kevin.
i really hope i wasn't geeking out TOO badly? :lol:
OK! so my question is about the Free Comic Day 'Prelude to Vengeance' issue.
it was released right after issue #55, but the Trade Paperback places it after issue #56.
i was wondering what was the reading-order placement for the Free issue?
thank you :D
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 10:27 AM
Bobby it was really an honor meeting you at last year's NYCC.
this here is not a real question (and you probably don't remember) my brother and i were two of the last people to show up to get passes to meet Kevin.
i really hope i wasn't geeking out TOO badly? :lol:
OK! so my question is about the Free Comic Day 'Prelude to Vengeance' issue.
it was released right after issue #55, but the Trade Paperback places it after issue #56.
i was wondering what was the reading-order placement for the Free issue?
thank you :D
Ha, i've seen a lot of people geek out about meeting Kevin. No worries, I was one of them too the first time it happened (probably first, like, ten times)
FCBD, due it's release date not being something I had any direct control over, is a little bit of a weird thing-- especially as we needed to have it finished well in advance of TMNT #45 due to Diamond's special printing schedule for FCBD.
Basically, part of FCBD happens after TMNT #46 (Shredder surveying Stockman) and part of it happens before (Hun vs. TMNT). I'm just glancing through the issues right now, so I may have part of that wrong, but it's something along those lines. There's no way it slots in perfectly, so I think either placement for your personal reading order will work. Nothing crucial happens in FCBD from a story perspective, so you could also just skip it.
myconius
01-14-2016, 10:39 AM
Ha, i've seen a lot of people geek out about meeting Kevin. No worries, I was one of them too the first time it happened (probably first, like, ten times)
FCBD, due it's release date not being something I had any direct control over, is a little bit of a weird thing-- especially as we needed to have it finished well in advance of TMNT #45 due to Diamond's special printing schedule for FCBD.
Basically, part of FCBD happens after TMNT #46 (Shredder surveying Stockman) and part of it happens before (Hun vs. TMNT). I'm just glancing through the issues right now, so I may have part of that wrong, but it's something along those lines. There's no way it slots in perfectly, so I think either placement for your personal reading order will work. Nothing crucial happens in FCBD from a story perspective, so you could also just skip it.
hahaha! well i probably geeked out just as much after i had realized that you were YOU!!!!! :D
Bobby, thank you so much for explaining that!!! :D
i've been re-reading all my IDW TMNT single issues now (micro's, mini's, everything)
once i reach that part i'll probably place the FCBD issue after issue #46 now?
thanks again man! and keep up the good work!!!
LOVE what you guys are doing!!! :D
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2016, 11:10 AM
Don't forget TMNT #5 is set at Christmas! But if someone pitches a Christmas story, i'd be happy to consider it. It's not something that's really on my personal radar at the moment. But will keep it in mind!
I think in-story the explanation would be that that sample of serum is used up, or that Hob already messed up Pete's mutation too much in the initial attempt of it (unlike Slash, who was a monitored lab experiment) for the serum to be effective. I don't think we thought it was important enough to mention all of that during the story.
The real reason is that we all like Pete as he is. He provides a nice contrast to a lot of other characters.
I think too much into stories whether it be a IDW comic or a Oscar nominated film. Its a fault of mine. I assumed the real world reason but wondered how it was explained in-story and it makes sense the way you explained it. Thanks.
I do remember #5 being set at Christmas time. There was the small decorated Christmas tree in the last page, but only seemed like a reference to real time for us not really getting to the plot itself.
Looks like we might get that Christmas plot yet thanks to the writer/artistic combo punch that is Campbell.
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2016, 11:18 AM
No plans at this time. I believe IDW has approached Marvel with crossover ideas (I know we pitched Godzilla vs. the Avengers, a few years back, as I edit the Godzilla line) but they have respectfully declined.
Hulk Vs. TMNT would be fun to see though!
I see Spider-Man, Daredevil, and the X-Men being able to mesh with the TMNT. Of those I would love to see Spider-Man. Having both of my other favorites team up with the Turtles....:D
I hated how poorly executed an episode of Power Rangers was that cofeatured the Next Mutation version of the Ninja Turtles. I still hold resentment towards Saban to this day. If working with fellow third party comic company Boom! with the original Mighty Morphin group being brought back to the comics it would be cool to see what fans of both franchises had hoped to see back then instead of what we got.
Jasper-X
01-14-2016, 11:31 AM
Hey Bobby! Thanks for taking questions. So I read earlier that Deviations is just a one shot. I love the idea behind it, so I was wondering, with all the different crossovers the main IDW turtles have had, and how successful they are, any chance we could see the turtles from Deviations crossover into the main TMNT ongoing series? Because that would be epic.
Harukuro
01-14-2016, 11:52 AM
This question is very familiar to me... did you send it in to Ninja Notes? If so, I think I answer it in an upcoming issue!
But to keep you from waiting: While Hob took Slash in, he's not the nicest of guys. So Mikey was the first person to show Slash any sort of kindness in his entire life, when he offered Slash a candy bar during City Fall. This made a big impression on Slash's then-mental-state, that carried over to his full intelligence. Basically, I think Slash was exposed to a lot terrible things early on in his life, so when he sees the Turtles (other creatures like himself) do good and strive to be good, it makes a big impression and he considers them heroes.
Good question, thanks!
:tcouch: Yes I did ask this via Ninja Notes. I just really love Mikey and Slash's relationship, it is just so genuinely good and sweet (no pun intended). I love their interactions together (hence why I've been enjoying the current story arc so much).
To be honest this is what I assumed had happened, but getting some confirmation is always awesome.
Thank you for answering my question (twice :tanime:), and I look forward to seeing what happens next with these characters!
Also, Sophie Campbell doing a TMNT Holiday special? Yes, yes, and yes!!!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 11:54 AM
Hey Bobby! Thanks for taking questions. So I read earlier that Deviations is just a one shot. I love the idea behind it, so I was wondering, with all the different crossovers the main IDW turtles have had, and how successful they are, any chance we could see the turtles from Deviations crossover into the main TMNT ongoing series? Because that would be epic.
Who knows, maybe one day!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 11:56 AM
An unintended possible side-effect of this thread... I may get less Ninja Notes!! And that would be bad, as we've been running low recently, and questions make the best letters (we get so many "i've been a TMNT fan for years!" letters, which get boring to read fast, though I appreciate getting them)
Point is, happy answer questions here, but I hope folks will consider saving some and sending them in. Get your name in print!!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-14-2016, 12:10 PM
At the risk of further depopulating Ninja Notes :tlol:, do you have any planned story arcs to bring back Renet? Also, Mirage did a lot of future Turtle glimpses off and on... any chance of getting a glimpse at another future, now that Donnie (hopefully) prevented the future of Turtles in Time #4?
I'd love to see Savanti Romero, too, but that, of course, is a spoilerific question. :tlol:
Stugehen
01-14-2016, 12:15 PM
Many creative teams behind established properties rehash the same story for a new generation since it’s easy to make money for a while off of nostalgia. With such a huge wellspring of TMNT lore to pull from I’m consistently impressed at how original your ongoing story has been, now more than ever. At the same time I’m positively glowing with nostalgia each issue I read.
This is a big open question, but will you offer some insight into your creative process? Or more specifically, when formulating story arcs and direction how do you balance original content with just enough inspiration from past iterations to keep things fresh, but in sync with what TMNT means to so many fans?
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2016, 12:21 PM
An unintended possible side-effect of this thread... I may get less Ninja Notes!! And that would be bad, as we've been running low recently, and questions make the best letters (we get so many "i've been a TMNT fan for years!" letters, which get boring to read fast, though I appreciate getting them)
Point is, happy answer questions here, but I hope folks will consider saving some and sending them in. Get your name in print!!
Don't worry, I got one I am writing in my head about diverse settings. More on that in Ninja Notes!:D
myconius
01-14-2016, 12:27 PM
An unintended possible side-effect of this thread... I may get less Ninja Notes!! And that would be bad, as we've been running low recently, and questions make the best letters (we get so many "i've been a TMNT fan for years!" letters, which get boring to read fast, though I appreciate getting them)
Point is, happy answer questions here, but I hope folks will consider saving some and sending them in. Get your name in print!!
i'll have to finally muster up my guts to finally ask a question in 'Ninja Notes'!
i've been wanting to for the longest time, but honestly have been a WEE bit nervous to do so! :D
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 12:27 PM
At the risk of further depopulating Ninja Notes :tlol:, do you have any planned story arcs to bring back Renet? Also, Mirage did a lot of future Turtle glimpses off and on... any chance of getting a glimpse at another future, now that Donnie (hopefully) prevented the future of Turtles in Time #4?
I'd love to see Savanti Romero, too, but that, of course, is a spoilerific question. :tlol:
We do have plans for Renet. That's about all I can say in response to this question.
Utrommaniac
01-14-2016, 12:32 PM
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/c0/02/5a/c0025a9dca6a8321bb62c309716ab1ef.gif
It's been a long time coming, and I can at last ask a question that's been bugging me for a while.
Where on Earth (or Utrominion?) is Krang's mother? I don't think there's room for an in-story explanation and it's just a very minor inconvenience. But it's still something I've been wondering about. For now, I'm assuming she died before the Krang on Morbus event, but some confirmation would be nice.
With that as a base, what exactly went on in the feud between Quanin and Traxus? Was Krang's mother in the crossfire like how Tang Shen was in the crossfire between Yoshi and Saki? Why was Traxus imprisoned on Morbus?
Why am I the only one asking these questions as far as I know?
In the meantime...*Gleeful squawk for A Sophie Campbell Christmas*
CyberCubed
01-14-2016, 12:41 PM
A minor thing, will April grow her hair long again, or will she remain with short hair for the rest of the series?
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 12:44 PM
Many creative teams behind established properties rehash the same story for a new generation since it’s easy to make money for a while off of nostalgia. With such a huge wellspring of TMNT lore to pull from I’m consistently impressed at how original your ongoing story has been, now more than ever. At the same time I’m positively glowing with nostalgia each issue I read.
This is a big open question, but will you offer some insight into your creative process? Or more specifically, when formulating story arcs and direction how do you balance original content with just enough inspiration from past iterations to keep things fresh, but in sync with what TMNT means to so many fans?
At any given time we've got a couple long-term plans in mind that we are working on building to. Then, we take a look at where we've been recently, in terms of plot and character development, and ask what makes sense next. Then you mix in a dollop of spur-of-the-moment ideas that hopefully make a short or long term plan better.
Tom and I, and in the past year Kevin has been very involved in this process as well, have a sit and discuss the next storyline coming up. While we do that, we usually get ideas for upcoming story lines further down the road.
So basically we have a skeleton of the overall story leading to, say #50, or #100. From month to month, we fill in some internal organs on storylines that are anywhere from six-to-twelve months ahead, while putting the skin, hair, and clothing on the storylines that we are currently writing and producing. So one foot in the present, one foot in the near future, one foot in the long term. Yes, i've just described some hideous, three-footed semi-formed monstrosity, but that's storytelling!
In terms of original vs. old characters, if an old character serves a purpose in the story we're telling, then we will usually include them to get the pleasant bonus of a little nostalgia hype going (but it's important to note that we only do that when it serves the story. It'd be easy to trot out characters for no purpose other than that instant nostalgia hype, but we try to wait for the right moment, like we did with Bebop and Rocksteady, or Rat King, etc). If no old character comes to mind that serves the story, then we create a new character.
Sometimes, we have situations where old characters COULD maybe fit, like Armaggon for Bludgeon, but the old characters are so different in purpose and personality, that they are not a good fit for the story we are telling, even if they seem so on paper.
Long story short, we feel all of this stuff out as we go!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 12:50 PM
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/c0/02/5a/c0025a9dca6a8321bb62c309716ab1ef.gif
It's been a long time coming, and I can at last ask a question that's been bugging me for a while.
Where on Earth (or Utrominion?) is Krang's mother? I don't think there's room for an in-story explanation and it's just a very minor inconvenience. But it's still something I've been wondering about. For now, I'm assuming she died before the Krang on Morbus event, but some confirmation would be nice.
*Gleeful squawk for A Sophie Campbell Christmas*
Krang's mother has never been explored at all-- I don't think anyone internally has ever even brought her up. In retrospect, I think we've done pretty poorly by mothers. Outside of April's mom, they are all dead (Tang Shen, Casey's mom, Angel's mom) or non-existant (Oroku Saki's mom, Krang's mom). It's a blind spot of ours that I'm not proud of.
So maybe we'll see Krang's mom one day, she could still be alive somewhere in Dimension X, maybe. Though personally i'm kind of attracted to the idea that the Utroms don't have genders and have some peculiar method of reproducing. I can say we will be diving into the uniqueness of the Utrom species down the road.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-14-2016, 12:52 PM
Krang's mother has never been explored at all-- I don't think anyone internally has ever even brought her up. In retrospect, I think we've done pretty poorly by mothers. Outside of April's mom, they are all dead (Tang Shen, Casey's mom, Angel's mom) or non-existant (Oroku Saki's mom, Krang's mom). It's a blind spot of ours that I'm not proud of.
So maybe we'll see Krang's mom one day, she could still be alive somewhere in Dimension X, maybe. Though personally i'm kind of attracted to the idea that the Utroms don't have genders and have some peculiar method of reproducing. I can say we will be diving into the uniqueness of the Utrom species down the road.
The Utrom idea sounds really cool! My 2 cents, go with that!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 12:52 PM
A minor thing, will April grow her hair long again, or will she remain with short hair for the rest of the series?
Most character designs are dependent on the artist having a strong feeling about it, like Sophie did during Northampton. Tom and I almost never indicate physical/fashion changes, as we like to let the artists do their own thing whenever possible.
So, no plans to change it, but if an artist really wanted to, they could.
CyberCubed
01-14-2016, 12:54 PM
If I remember correctly were the Utroms in Mirage genderless? I don't really remember.
I guess people always want to view Krang as male though since that's how his character was in the original cartoon.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-14-2016, 12:57 PM
If I remember correctly were the Utroms in Mirage genderless? I don't really remember.
I guess people always want to view Krang as male though since that's how his character was in the original cartoon.
Nope. Dr. X was female.
Utrommaniac
01-14-2016, 01:02 PM
As well as Dr. X, we also have Professor Obligado's mother - at least from his memory of her.
And now we have at least a reference to a female Utrom in the IDW - Ma`riell. Who I'm hoping we can get to meet. Just from being a chief scientist, she sounds like she'll be fun.
If it weren't for legal boundaries, I'd be happy to lend my concept of Krang's mother, but I know you guys can't probably can't accept it.
Jasper-X
01-14-2016, 01:49 PM
An unintended possible side-effect of this thread... I may get less Ninja Notes!! And that would be bad, as we've been running low recently, and questions make the best letters (we get so many "i've been a TMNT fan for years!" letters, which get boring to read fast, though I appreciate getting them)
Point is, happy answer questions here, but I hope folks will consider saving some and sending them in. Get your name in print!!
In response to this: I have never written a ninja note in hopes that it would be published, and I had never really thought about doing that. That does not mean that I wouldn't like to have one of my questions published along with its answer in an actual TMNT comic. Seeing as many people jumped at this thread to ask you many questions, would it be possible to have questions from this thread be published in the ninja notes section if we provide the necessary personal information to go along with the question? Getting questions from a site based around TMNT fans seems like it should be fairly easy... I hope:tgrin:
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 01:54 PM
In response to this: I have never written a ninja note in hopes that it would be published, and I had never really thought about doing that. That does not mean that I wouldn't like to have one of my questions published along with its answer in an actual TMNT comic. Seeing as many people jumped at this thread to ask you many questions, would it be possible to have questions from this thread be published in the ninja notes section if we provide the necessary personal information to go along with the question? Getting questions from a site based around TMNT fans seems like it should be fairly easy... I hope:tgrin:
That's a good idea. If you'd like your question to be considered for Ninja Notes, just add "OK to PRINT" Include as much personal information (name, city or state of residence) as you want.
I'll edit the opening post to include that!
Jasper-X
01-14-2016, 02:18 PM
That's a good idea. If you'd like your question to be considered for Ninja Notes, just add "OK to PRINT" Include as much personal information (name, city or state of residence) as you want.
I'll edit the opening post to include that!
Awesome, thanks! I'd be happy to have my question printed, I'll re-post it below! (with a few edits for print)
Hey IDW Team! So I read that the upcoming Deviations issue (where in an alternate universe, the TMNT join Shredder) is just a one shot. I love the idea behind it, so I was wondering, with all the different crossovers the main IDW turtles have had, and how successful they are, any chance we could see the turtles from Deviations crossover into the main TMNT ongoing series? Because that would be epic!
OK to Print!
Chris McKenna
New York
Ninjinister
01-14-2016, 02:20 PM
Why are the original movie trilogy characters off the table? It was my understanding that Mirage had the rights - which is why Tokka and Rahzar showed up in things long after the movies (and you guys have even published two series where the latter appears) and Pennington was in a Mirage book, along with plans for Keno at one point...
Allio
01-14-2016, 02:25 PM
can you tell us anything about Mutants in Manhatten?
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 03:18 PM
Why are the original movie trilogy characters off the table? It was my understanding that Mirage had the rights - which is why Tokka and Rahzar showed up in things long after the movies (and you guys have even published two series where the latter appears) and Pennington was in a Mirage book, along with plans for Keno at one point...
No clue. Might be that the actors have some sort of rights with the character, but that's pure speculation.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 03:19 PM
can you tell us anything about Mutants in Manhatten?
I don't know what that is!
MikeandRaph87
01-14-2016, 03:30 PM
I don't know what that is!
It is a new game in development that has not recieved official unveiling, but confirned. Classic elements are fratured with information suggesting Bebop, Rocksteady, Slash, and Wingnut.
http://www.xboxachievements.com/game/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutants-in-manhattan/achievements/
Can I get any drawing tips from the awesome arists? I wanna make comics one day....
Redeemer
01-14-2016, 03:39 PM
It is a new game in development that has not recieved official unveiling, but confirned. Classic elements are fratured with information suggesting Bebop, Rocksteady, Slash, and Wingnut.
http://www.xboxachievements.com/game/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-mutants-in-manhattan/achievements/
I am sure he was being sarcastic lol
Bobby or Tom
I was wondering is there any chance that we can have in house IDW artist
Rob Duenas draw a mini-series or a few issues on the ongoing title???
For anyone who does not know his work here is an example http://www.deviantart.com/art/Commish-80-TMNT-Noir-212895807
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 04:26 PM
Can I get any drawing tips from the awesome arists? I wanna make comics one day....
You'll have to ask them! You're probably better than me!
Mayhem
01-14-2016, 04:26 PM
Funny you mention Rob there Redeemer, I was recently introduced to him by a mate, and he's definitely talented. He's also the one who helped me get the swag from the recent dinner in San Diego with Kevin heh. He's worked with Kevin before, almost ten years ago, and I know he'd love to work with Kevin again, so I think a TMNT gig would be excellent :)
Also been speaking to Mike Dialynas, who's doing the current issues, and getting a commission from him next month. Pity all his issues were done digitally, otherwise I'd consider buying a page or two.
So oooooooooooon that note, question for you Bobby... is there any artist you'd like to invite on to do a TMNT issue or more, or any that you've wanted to get and be unable to so far?
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 04:33 PM
I am sure he was being sarcastic lol
Bobby or Tom
I was wondering is there any chance that we can have in house IDW artist
Rob Duenas draw a mini-series or a few issues on the ongoing title???
For anyone who does not know his work here is an example http://www.deviantart.com/art/Commish-80-TMNT-Noir-212895807
I actually didn't know the name of it! Like I said earlier, I don't really pay attention to movie/video game stuff. So no help there from me!
I don't want this to come off the wrong way, but I'll take this opportunity to say that i'm not really looking for artist suggestions (though I appreciate the intention/thought). I've got a good roster, and do my own looking for future talent, so i'm pretty up to date on folks creating TMNT art for the most part.
The vast majority of artists that fans suggest can do a good cover or pin-up, but those are pretty common in the comic book world-- i've never had trouble getting that stuff when needed. What is of more interest is someone who has proven, in a professional sense, that they can 1) handle interior sequential storytelling and 2) can do so on a monthly schedule.
That's tough and whittles the field down by a whole lot.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 04:41 PM
So oooooooooooon that note, question for you Bobby... is there any artist you'd like to invite on to do a TMNT issue or more, or any that you've wanted to get and be unable to so far?
Oh, there's a ton! Just today I talked to Brahm Revel about something down the line. I've been trying to get him on something substantial for about two years now. (He did a TMNT cover a while back, you can google it if interested. Also check out his fantastic Oni book "Guerrillas".)
I've wanted Wes Craig (Deadly Class) to do a cover for a long time. I'm pals with Francis Manapul, but haven't been able to get him away from DC yet.
Been trying to get an Art Adams cover for a special occasion too!
And since our TMNT began i've tried to get David Petersen to do interiors.
There's lots and lots more, that's just off the top of my head!
neatoman
01-14-2016, 04:43 PM
So about the minis, we all know the main series is written with a plan in mind but I get a feeling the minis are a little more "go with the flow". Is my hunch hot or cold?
Speaking of plans, not everything can go exactly according to them, so were twists like "Arnold Jones as Hun" or "Angel as Nobody" always planned or was it more of a "wouldn't it be cool if..." type thing?
Redeemer
01-14-2016, 04:44 PM
I actually didn't know the name of it! Like I said earlier, I don't really pay attention to movie/video game stuff. So no help there from me!
I don't want this to come off the wrong way, but I'll take this opportunity to say that i'm not really looking for artist suggestions (though I appreciate the intention/thought). I've got a good roster, and do my own looking for future talent, so i'm pretty up to date on folks creating TMNT art for the most part.
The vast majority of artists that fans suggest can do a good cover or pin-up, but those are pretty common in the comic book world-- i've never had trouble getting that stuff when needed. What is of more interest is someone who has proven, in a professional sense, that they can 1) handle interior sequential storytelling and 2) can do so on a monthly schedule.
That's tough and whittles the field down by a whole lot.
lol I did not mean to suggest an artist honestly, but I guess I enjoy this artist so much I sub-couscously did suggest.
I was honestly just asking if there was any chance of Rob Duenas doing any issues sense he has done work with IDW and apparently Kevin Eastman in the past.
But judging from your reply it sounds like he is not on going to at this time. Thank you for the reply and I apologies I was not trying to tell you how to do your job. I am sure you get a ton of suggestions from fans all the time.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 05:20 PM
So about the minis, we all know the main series is written with a plan in mind but I get a feeling the minis are a little more "go with the flow". Is my hunch hot or cold?
Speaking of plans, not everything can go exactly according to them, so were twists like "Arnold Jones as Hun" or "Angel as Nobody" always planned or was it more of a "wouldn't it be cool if..." type thing?
Well, it depends on the story. The various micros, especially the villain micros, had a lot of involvement and planning from me, as they tied pretty directly into the ongoing. Things like Turtles in Time, Mutanimals and Casey and April, we have more freedom to explore things not related to the ongoing, so I try and give the creative team as much freedom as possible. I've been on the receiving end of "feedback notes" and it can be unpleasant-- so I try and let the creators tell the story they want to tell and stay out of their way.
Fugitoid as Chet, Arnold as Hun, and Angel as Nobody were all things we came up with after the original incarnation of their characters were introduced, sometimes, like with Nobody, a good deal after. Fun fact, Angel as Nobody was Kevin's idea!
CyberCubed
01-14-2016, 05:20 PM
Perhaps the mods should sticky this thread so its at the top of the page and doesn't get buried due to new topics.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 05:21 PM
lol I did not mean to suggest an artist honestly, but I guess I enjoy this artist so much I sub-couscously did suggest.
I was honestly just asking if there was any chance of Rob Duenas doing any issues sense he has done work with IDW and apparently Kevin Eastman in the past.
But judging from your reply it sounds like he is not on going to at this time. Thank you for the reply and I apologies I was not trying to tell you how to do your job. I am sure you get a ton of suggestions from fans all the time.
No worries-- I think it kinda sounded like I was defensive about it or something, but not the case at all. The thought is appreciated. And there's no harm in throwing artists' links on this thread. I probably just won't respond to it, because I don't want to detail my opinion of different folks in public, if that makes sense.
PangolinFeets
01-14-2016, 05:25 PM
It will be extremely unrealistic if April grows her hair out because once girls chop all their hair off they realize it was the best decision of their life and never grow it back. #shorthairdontcare
I want Alopex to learn the true meaning of Christmas!!!
I have another question!!! Just about all the turtles have a buddy that they confide in (Raph has Casey and Alopex, Mikey has Slash and Woody, Donnie has Harold and April) except Leo. He seems to have a stronger bond with Splinter, but he doesn't bond with other characters as much. I thought he was going to end up having a big heart-to-heart with Alopex, but she spends more time with Raph and Angel. Was that a conscious decision to keep him as more of the distant leader figure or are there plans for him in store?
Ninjinister
01-14-2016, 05:36 PM
I actually didn't know the name of it! Like I said earlier, I don't really pay attention to movie/video game stuff. So no help there from me!
I think the reason they asked is that the game uses new Santolouco art for the cover and is speculated to be IDW-based. Since nothing's been said officially, a lot of people are grasping for any new info that can be dug up.
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 05:38 PM
I have another question!!! Just about all the turtles have a buddy that they confide in (Raph has Casey and Alopex, Mikey has Slash and Woody, Donnie has Harold and April) except Leo. He seems to have a stronger bond with Splinter, but he doesn't bond with other characters as much. I thought he was going to end up having a big heart-to-heart with Alopex, but she spends more time with Raph and Angel. Was that a conscious decision to keep him as more of the distant leader figure or are there plans for him in store?
I wouldn't say conscious, no-- but none of those pairings have really been "we need to give X a friend!" it just sort of developed. Leo tends to keep to himself, but that doesn't mean he won't develop relationships with folks. We'll have to wait and see!
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 05:39 PM
I think the reason they asked is that the game uses new Santolouco art for the cover and is speculated to be IDW-based. Since nothing's been said officially, a lot of people are grasping for any new info that can be dug up.
Ah, yeah-- I have seen some stuff in passing, and it looks cool. But that's about all I can say on it... literally, I don't know anything more than that!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-14-2016, 06:21 PM
Hey Bobby, what suggestions would you give an aspiring writer who wants to break into the comics business but doesn't have an artist?
Bobby Curnow
01-14-2016, 07:08 PM
Hey Bobby, what suggestions would you give an aspiring writer who wants to break into the comics business but doesn't have an artist?
First step is to just get really good at writing. Tons of people have ideas and therefore think they can be a writer, but there's a lot more to it than that. I always say that a good measure is to write for an hour every day, for a year. Doesn't even need to be every day, you could stockpile "hours" on the weekend, but keep track and see if you have 365 hours by the end of the year. If you don't that means you made some excuses along the way, and aren't serious about being a writer.
I think a lot of people could save themselves years of fanciful and frustrating dreams if they took that advice. And hey, worst thing that happens if you don't make it is that you can try again the next year, with the knowledge of how hard it is. Hopefully by writing often, you will get better. Can't hurt.
Hey, it's early in the year yet, start now!
I spent some time talking about just writing because too often folks try to jump into the artist stage when they aren't ready. But that being said, getting your writing drawn IS really important-- just be prepared for artists to flake on you, for the results to be subpar, etc. That's part of the learning curve too.
But get to know artists, and how art works. Study comic book art. Spend extra time in your comic book story studying artists in lower-level publishers, or if they have an indie-DIY section. Write down names. Go to online art sites like Deviant Art. Do your research. I think this is a great thing to do during that "test-writing" year. Carve out an hour or two each week to do this research. By the end of that year, you should have a good list of potential artists to work with. If you're realistic, and have a couple dozen potentials, and are willing to pay them, I bet you can get someone to work on your writing.
(I recommend always paying the artist SOMETHING, unless it's a good friend who owes you one).
Start small. Don't make the first thing you hire an artist for be a full issue, or anything bigger. Start with a 5-10 page script. Anything larger, and you will be wasting your money and their time, because you probably aren't ready yet. Once you do that, you can consider doing a one shot comic.
A lot of people think they are serious about becoming a writer, but they can't do the above... which really isn't all that much work if you ARE serious. Becoming a writer doesn't happen over night. Don't expect any success or to get your money back in your second year. Or third. It can take MANY years.
If that sounds disheartening, then writing might not be for you. It should be something you HAVE to do, no matter how high the obstacles are. Those are almost always the folks who DO make it.
Lastly, comic education courses are making strides in recent years. Some colleges offer coursework, and I personally went through Comics Experience, which teaches online classes in writing, art, coloring, and more. Classes, either online or in real life, are a good way to learn, and meet people who are doing the same thing you are doing, and making friends with those people is often more valuable and educational than the actual classes.
Might be more than you personally are asking for, I don't know where you're at in your development, but I get asked that question a lot, so figured I might as well give the full speech. :tgrin:
Hey Bobby, what suggestions would you give an aspiring writer who wants to break into the comics business but doesn't have an artist?
I could be an artist. I've been told my art on pen is better than my posted art...
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-14-2016, 08:11 PM
First step is to just get really good at writing. Tons of people have ideas and therefore think they can be a writer, but there's a lot more to it than that. I always say that a good measure is to write for an hour every day, for a year. Doesn't even need to be every day, you could stockpile "hours" on the weekend, but keep track and see if you have 365 hours by the end of the year. If you don't that means you made some excuses along the way, and aren't serious about being a writer.
I think a lot of people could save themselves years of fanciful and frustrating dreams if they took that advice. And hey, worst thing that happens if you don't make it is that you can try again the next year, with the knowledge of how hard it is. Hopefully by doing writing often, you will get better. Can't hurt.
Hey, it's early in the year yet, start now!
I spent some time talking about just writing because too often folks try to jump into the artist stage when they aren't ready. But that being said, getting your writing drawn IS really important-- just be prepared for artists to flake on you, for the results to be subpar, etc. That's part of the learning curve too.
But get to know artists, and how art works. Study comic book art. Spend extra time in your comic book story studying artists in lower-level publishers, or if they have an indie-DIY section. Write down names. Go to online art sites like Deviant Art. Do your research. I think this is a great thing to do during that "test-writing" year. Carve out an hour or two each week to do this research. By the end of that year, you should have a good list of potential artists to work with. If you're realistic, and have a couple dozen potentials, and are willing to pay them, I bet you can get someone to work on your writing.
(I recommend always paying the artist SOMETHING, unless it's a good friend who owes you one).
Start small. Don't make the first thing you hire an artist for be a full issue, or anything bigger. Start with a 5-10 page script. Anything larger, and you will be wasting your money and their time, because you probably aren't ready yet. Once you do that, you can consider doing a one shot comic.
A lot of people think they are serious about becoming a writer, but they can't do the above... which really isn't all that much work if you ARE serious. Becoming a writer doesn't happen over night. Don't expect any success or to get your money back in your second year. Or third. It can take MANY years.
If that sounds disheartening, then writing might not be for you. It should be something you HAVE to do, no matter how high the obstacles are. Those are almost always the folks who DO make it.
Lastly, comic education courses are making strides in recent years. Some colleges offer coursework, and I personally went through Comics Experience, which teaches online classes in writing, art, coloring, and more. Classes, either online or in real life, are a good way to learn, and meet people who are doing the same thing you are doing, and making friends with those people is often more valuable and educational than the actual classes.
Might be more than you personally are asking for, I don't know where you're at in your development, but I get asked that question a lot, so figured I might as well give the full speech. :tgrin:
Thanks for the in-depth reply, Bobby! I've been writing for a number of years now, and have self-published five novels (sixth in progress). Back when I was trying to figure out what to do with the first three, as my gig with audio drama had fallen through with the company, I considering adapting them to comics. That ship sailed without me, but it's good to know how to start if I ever decide to reopen that idea.
Thanks again!
CyberCubed
01-15-2016, 01:09 PM
Are there any discarded or unused plots you guys decided to abandon that you can share? Like IDW was planning to go in a certain direction with a character or plot, but then decided against the idea and went another way. I don't know if you can share this or not, but maybe some brief idea you guys were kicking around but didn't work so you left it aside?
MikeandRaph87
01-15-2016, 01:57 PM
As a supplement to what Cubed ask, Apolex was not originally intended to paired with Angel, correct? Was she intended to be apart of the Mutanimals instead and was Sally Pride the mutant lioness created due to that to have a female mutant in the group?
Bobby Curnow
01-15-2016, 06:59 PM
Are there any discarded or unused plots you guys decided to abandon that you can share? Like IDW was planning to go in a certain direction with a character or plot, but then decided against the idea and went another way. I don't know if you can share this or not, but maybe some brief idea you guys were kicking around but didn't work so you left it aside?
Nothing comes to mind, really. There's stuff that I wish we could have spent time on, like the various gangs in City Fall, or what Don's mind was like in Metalhead. But we usually at least get to touch on those things, or figure out a way to come back to it in the future in a meaningful way.
There are probably some other things, but I don't have a great memory for that type of stuff.
Bobby Curnow
01-15-2016, 07:06 PM
As a supplement to what Cubed ask, Apolex was not originally intended to paired with Angel, correct? Was she intended to be apart of the Mutanimals instead and was Sally Pride the mutant lioness created due to that to have a female mutant in the group?
Alopex is a character who we had plotted through Northampton. Then we thought more about the Kitsune connection and got her back to New York, and from there the Nobody partnership just sort of naturally occurred. Once we saw Alopex talk to Nobody in whatever issue (#38?) we thought it might be fun to see them together more often.
That was before Mutanimals was ever plotted, we never intended her to be a part of that group, but toyed with the idea-- that's why Hob asks her if she wants to join up. By that point we thought it'd be more fun to have Alopex and Nobody do their own thing, and we wanted to keep Alopex closer to the Turtles.
Sally Pride came from Paul Allor. We discussed how it would be fun to bring in another old character (who ended up being Man Ray) and also bringing in a new character, so the group would be a nice mix of old and new. Sally is all Paul and Andy's creation from there.
neatoman
01-15-2016, 07:38 PM
I have a few questions about choices with the characters, this is a little long so please bear with me.:)
So I noticed how you guys at IDW and the Nick crew seem to pick roughly the same characters from the lore, is it coincidence or does Nickelodeon insist on certain characters?
As for characterisation, how do you guys decide on what to change from earlier incanations and what to keep the same? Some examples here, Bebop/Rocksteady are basically just more violent versions of the characters from the cartoon, Hun is similar to the original Hun but his dynamic with Casey is different and Angel as Nobody is pretty much only similar to the old Nobody in that she's a superhero. All have changes but they are quite different types of changes.
Finally, are there any things that were tempting to do with certain characters but you guys decided against in the end? For example, while I'm personally happy you didn't make April a newsreporter since I don't like the idea of her being a newsreporter, considering that News April is the version of the character many people have nostalgic feelings about, I imagine someone must have been tempted to make her a newreporter? I know some of the Nick crew really wanted to hint that their Teenage Alien Psychic Ninja version of April would somehow become a reporter, so it's not hard to imagine something similar might have gone down over there.
Bobby Curnow
01-15-2016, 09:23 PM
I have a few questions about choices with the characters, this is a little long so please bear with me.:)
So I noticed how you guys at IDW and the Nick crew seem to pick roughly the same characters from the lore, is it coincidence or does Nickelodeon insist on certain characters?
As for characterization, how do you guys decide on what to change from earlier incarnations and what to keep the same? Some examples here, Bebop/Rocksteady are basically just more violent versions of the characters from the cartoon, Hun is similar to the original Hun but his dynamic with Casey is different and Angel as Nobody is pretty much only similar to the old Nobody in that she's a superhero. All have changes but they are quite different types of changes.
Finally, are there any things that were tempting to do with certain characters but you guys decided against in the end? For example, while I'm personally happy you didn't make April a newsreporter since I don't like the idea of her being a newsreporter, considering that News April is the version of the character many people have nostalgic feelings about, I imagine someone must have been tempted to make her a newreporter? I know some of the Nick crew really wanted to hint that their Teenage Alien Psychic Ninja version of April would somehow become a reporter, so it's not hard to imagine something similar might have gone down over there.
Nickelodeon doesn't dictate plot or characters at all. They are great in that regard. I think both we and the Nick toon are just pulling from a lot of different TMNT lore that's come before us, and there's a certain logic as to when to introduce increasingly obscure characters. I'm surprised they waited as long as they did to introduce Bebop and Rocksteady and Fugitoid. But i'm sure the same could be said for us and some of our characters.
In terms of characterization, I don't think I have a very satisfying answer for you. Mostly it's just seeing what aspects of a character fit for the overall world and story we are telling. Basically we just sort of feel it out and let our individual take come through. A lot of supporting characters are either from the cartoon, so aren't very deep, or are obscure to the casual fan. As a result there's a certain amount of freedom to play around with them. This is a better question for Tom, as he is really the one who develops character's personality (BTW, Tom, if you are reading this and have something to add, please chime in!!)
In terms of characterization we didn't go with... hmm, that's an interesting question. The only thing that comes to mind a bit is Casey. I kind of miss the completely nutso original Mirage Casey, but at the same time I don't know how much we personally could have done with that version of the character. Another creative team might have been able to make that Casey work. As for April, I think we always thought there was more to do with her if she was closer to the age of the Turtles and stuck to her science background from her original Mirage appearance... which is something we'll be exploring more soon.
MrTrikey
01-16-2016, 12:07 AM
We have not forgot about Zog or the Triceratons. They will play a big part, but don't expect anything this year.
I don't keep track of the video games or movies (I do watch the Nick Toon), so I wouldn't be any help even if I could talk!
Thanks for the response!
I'll be waiting to see what you do with them. "Utrom Empire" set up so many possibilities, and then there's Zog who I could easily see sliding into a Traximus-like role.
Bonus points if you find some way to incorporate Boss Zukko and his gang, as long as we're finding interesting ways to incorporate "Fast Forward" material~! :D
Harukuro
01-16-2016, 08:51 AM
Are there any plans to incorporate more LGBT+ characters in the story?
Powder
01-16-2016, 10:01 AM
Great thread so far, thanks for taking this on, Bobby!
1. Was Woody's namesake meant to be an homage to the Mikester's original Playmates toy packaging bio-card? I only just recently made the connection between his "origin" there & the pizza delivery boy he kicks it with in your series. If so, that's quite the clever reference. Took me this long to figure it out. :tlol:
https://scontent-atl3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xfp1/v/t1.0-9/12549077_655282568088_4410303654362774440_n.jpg?oh =dd4c9b5c65dfbfed4d6d2fa3af84be4b&oe=570005AE
(In case you're unable to view the image, Michelangelo's birthplace is said to be "Woody's Pet Shop".)
2. Do you have a preference between the two dominant TMNT aesthetics, one being more lean & basic (a'la their look in the beginning of the IDW series) & the other chunky & accessorized (the Nick inspired design that we often see now)? I know you let the artists do their own thing, & that it's fun to have variety, but which suits your tastes on a personal level?
3. If it had been solely your call, without crowd pleasing or sales in mind, would you have kept the red bandanas, or eventually gone/started out with their 4 "iconic" colors? & what of the Playmates/4kids inspired skin tones? Same question.
4. Is there a conscious effort made on part of your creative team not to do anything that may potentially be deemed controversial or too adult, whether it be not to upset the suits or feeling some sort of responsibility for stray kids getting a hold of the book? The recent beheading of Shredder, Casey being gutted by him, etc, there are things to suggest this is not a concern of yours, however the no-kill rule & certain other moral issues that play a part do paint that picture. Similarly, does the spiritual content ever cause complications for you guys? A handful of Archie issues aren't being reprinted due to sensitive material based around religious ideology, & even in that book's era, its writer was sent many an angry letter from parents who didn't like the mere inclusion of "zen" themes & meditation, let alone reincarnation or the introduction of "Gods" & other things of that nature.
5. Beyond the board/video games & specialty packages like IDW limited, will we ever have any IDW TMNT inspired merchandise? Collector figures, busts/statues, etc.? Has it been discussed at all? Funko is releasing a new series of 6" articulated figures based on licenses that as far as I can remember are all being published by y'all at present, the turtles included, leading some to believe that they may in fact be toys from your series. *fingers crossed* Any word on that? :twink:
I'd rather not attach my name, (Powder's fine, right?) but this is OK TO PRINT should you wish to use any of it for whatever reason, & I presently live in Lexington, SC, though I am originally a proud New Yorker.
Raven
01-16-2016, 10:19 AM
I've always been curious how you guys decide which artist is going to work on which story, obviously Santaclous has top pick, but how does that all boil down for you guys? And how can one be considered for such a task?
neatoman
01-16-2016, 10:21 AM
So considering Mikey found a Silver Sentry comic, is he a fictional character this time around or was it some kind biography comic?
PangolinFeets
01-16-2016, 03:28 PM
Great thread so far, thanks for taking this on, Bobby!
1. Was Woody's namesake meant to be an homage to the Mikester's original Playmates toy packaging bio-card? I only just recently made the connection between his "origin" there & the pizza delivery boy he kicks it with in your series. If so, that's quite the clever reference. Took me this long to figure it out. :tlol:
https://scontent-atl3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xfp1/v/t1.0-9/12549077_655282568088_4410303654362774440_n.jpg?oh =dd4c9b5c65dfbfed4d6d2fa3af84be4b&oe=570005AE
(In case you're unable to view the image, Michelangelo's birthplace is said to be "Woody's Pet Shop".)
2. Do you have a preference between the two dominant TMNT aesthetics, one being more lean & basic (a'la their look in the beginning of the IDW series) & the other chunky & accessorized (the Nick inspired design that we often see now)? I know you let the artists do their own thing, & that it's fun to have variety, but which suits your tastes on a personal level?
3. If it had been solely your call, without crowd pleasing or sales in mind, would you have kept the red bandanas, or eventually gone/started out with their 4 "iconic" colors? & what of the Playmates/4kids inspired skin tones? Same question.
4. Is there a conscious effort made on part of your creative team not to do anything that may potentially be deemed controversial or too adult, whether it be not to upset the suits or feeling some sort of responsibility for stray kids getting a hold of the book? The recent beheading of Shredder, Casey being gutted by him, etc, there are things to suggest this is not a concern of yours, however the no-kill rule & certain other moral issues that play a part do paint that picture. Similarly, does the spiritual content ever cause complications for you guys? A handful of Archie issues aren't being reprinted due to sensitive material based around religious ideology, & even in that book's era, its writer was sent many an angry letter from parents who didn't like the mere inclusion of "zen" themes & meditation, let alone reincarnation or the introduction of "Gods" & other things of that nature.
5. Beyond the board/video games & specialty packages like IDW limited, will we ever have any IDW TMNT inspired merchandise? Collector figures, busts/statues, etc.? Has it been discussed at all? Funko is releasing a new series of 6" articulated figures based on licenses that as far as I can remember are all being published by y'all at present, the turtles included, leading some to believe that they may in fact be toys from your series. *fingers crossed* Any word on that? :twink:
I'd rather not attach my name, (Powder's fine, right?) but this is OK TO PRINT should you wish to use any of it for whatever reason, & I presently live in Lexington, SC, though I am originally a proud New Yorker.
I would like to second #5. I would do a lot to get my hands on IDW-themed figured, especially if it were themed after the style of a favorite artist like Campbell or Santolouco. I mean, I'm making my own stuff ATM, but I'd love love love to support authentic merch.
MikeandRaph87
01-16-2016, 04:06 PM
Greetings IDW Crew,
I am a life-long TMNT fan, since the impressionable age of 2 back in 1989. I loved Archie's ' TMNT Adventures comic as a kid. That brings me to ask a few questions. First of all, TMNTA is my first and my all-time favorite title. I strongly believe if you all have your own Future Shark Trilogy IDW's TMNT series will take that crown. Question 1, do you have any plans for Renet in the next year along with the time travel theme? If so could we see either of two time travel related villains from the franchise Savanti Romero (Mirage , 4Kids cartoon ) or the preferred Armaggon, the future shark( Archie)?
Question 2, we saw the Turtles travel to Europe in a side-season of TMNT(1987) and to Japan in the 4Kids cartoon and Archie's TMNT Adventures series which also saw other areas of Asia explored. Do you have plans for it or see the possibility of the Turtles going abroad? It would make for an interesting arc. Hint: To close out the Pantheon storyline, why not do so in Japan?
Question 3, way back in the April micro I recall two cages other than Slash's in StockGen Labs. Was that a dropped plot thread of two other mutant experiments aside from Splinter and the five turtles? I have hoped Groundchuck and Dirtbag get the opportunity to get dusted off and always hoped it would be them or have them appear somehow. My favorite allies, the Punk Frogs as well. I understand that it could be difficult to adapt the four frogs, but here is to hoping.
I want to use this opportunity to thank you all at IDW. I was hesitant when Peter Laird sold off the intellectual property as it was cared for by a select few who had deep ties to it. Then you all stepped up and had even more interaction with the fanbase than I could have hoped for especially the constant presence at Technodrome Forums. You are also using the entire property as your playground to make the best comic series and TMNT universe possible. That was something that Mirage Studios did not do which never sat well with me. Thanks again for hitting one grand slam after another.
MikeandRaph87
Virginia
Okay to print
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 04:55 PM
Are there any plans to incorporate more LGBT+ characters in the story?
Yes. Though with sexuality in general in the series, it won't play a large role in the story.
Redeemer
01-16-2016, 05:12 PM
Question 1, do you have any plans for Renet in the next year along with the time travel theme? If so could we see either of two time travel related villains from the franchise Savanti Romero (Mirage , 4Kids cartoon ) or the preferred Armaggon, the future shark( Archie)?
Question 3, way back in the April micro I recall two cages other than Slash's in StockGen Labs. Was that a dropped plot thread of two other mutant experiments aside from Splinter and the five turtles? I have hoped Groundchuck and Dirtbag get the opportunity to get dusted off and always hoped it would be them or have them appear somehow. My favorite allies, the Punk Frogs as well. I understand that it could be difficult to adapt the four frogs, but here is to hoping.
I curious as well about the other mutant tanks from the april micro and the possibility of Aragon or savant romero story lines involving Renet.
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 05:18 PM
Great thread so far, thanks for taking this on, Bobby!
1. Was...
Good questions, Powder. For space, edited my quoting of you here.
1. Ha, no on Woody, I had no clue about that action figure reference. Woody Dirkins is named after IDW head of marketing Dirk Wood! He is also drawn to resemble him.
http://www.comicsbeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/dirk-wood-561.jpg
2. I'd say my personal preference is probably somewhere in the middle, kind of what Ben Bates was doing in Turtles in Time #3. But I really do dig what all the different artists do, and like you note, it's important to me that artists can put their own spin on the characters.
3. I know I was in support of keeping them in red masks at the start. That being said, in retrospect I think having the multi-color is a smart move long term. Yes, you can tell who is who in Mirage, but there's lots of shots/angles/situations where it's just plain handy to have that color short-hand. My opinion at least. I don't think it's any less ridiculous for them to have multi-colored masks than for them to be wearing masks in the first place. Aesthetically though, I still really dig the all-red.
4. In regards to violence and making it too "adult", a little thought is minded there, but not a lot. I think had we been able to let the Turtles be more violent at the start, we would have done so. We would have explored the Turtles taking 'extreme measures' more. That being said, I think both Tom and I want this book to be accessible to a large range of readers, and having the book be too gory or violent would turn off some readers, regardless of age. I'm also a strong believer in less is more. Events like Don's beating and Saki's decapitation have a bigger impact because we don't have the Turtles and their enemies maiming each other every issue. But I think there are situations where we would have let loose a bit more than we do if the property wasn't owned by Nickelodeon. Overall though, it's not something that we think about very often.
In terms of other things being controversial, I wouldn't say we are interested in being controversial for controversial sake, and we have had very few complaints about storylines in that regard. So not really on our radar.
5. Not that I am aware of, no. No one talks to us about that stuff. No one would love IDW figures more than us. The impact and reach of comics don't really get felt in other mediums until a ways down the line. I'm hopeful that one day we'll get some figures, but I'd be surprised if it was soon.
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 05:23 PM
I've always been curious how you guys decide which artist is going to work on which story, obviously Santaclous has top pick, but how does that all boil down for you guys? And how can one be considered for such a task?
Hmm, that's a good question, but also difficult for me to answer. It's a mix of gut feeling who would be best suited for the story, and who is available. For instance, with TMNT #51-54: Cory Smith was meant to do that entire storyline, but he gave me a good heads up when Marvel came calling for him to do Nova. So, looking at artists that I admired, I started to see who might be interested and available. I thought Ken Garing could handle something relatively somber and dark and with lots of ninja action. Meanwhile, I thought Michael Dialynas would be good fit for the many mutants, some of them goofy, of the subsequent storyline.
Best way to get on my radar is to do some kick ass art in some comic books I come across! I don't hire anyone without a good deal of established professional experience, so step one is to get some books published!
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 05:26 PM
Greetings IDW Crew...
1) Yes, there are plans for Renet in 2016. That's about all I can really say in regards to that question.
2) I'd like to do this one day, but there are no plans at the moment.
3) Ha, we have not forgot about those two other cages, and in fact they have been discussed in just the past few weeks.
Thank YOU guys for reading and supporting us. Means a lot.
CyberCubed
01-16-2016, 05:33 PM
Was the decision to make April a red-head done for the same reason the Nick cartoon went in that direction?
In the 80's and 90's April was always known for being a brunette or having dark black hair. In Mirage she had black curly hair, then in the original cartoon, Archie comics, and the live-action 90's movies she was a brunette.
It was the 2003 cartoon that made April a red-head for the first time, and that seemed to stick with both the Nick cartoon and IDW comic. I find it rather interesting that April's standard hair color changed from brown in the 80's/90's to a red-head across all media in the 2000's.
MikeandRaph87
01-16-2016, 05:39 PM
1) Yes, there are plans for Renet in 2016. That's about all I can really say in regards to that question.
2) I'd like to do this one day, but there are no plans at the moment.
3) Ha, we have not forgot about those two other cages, and in fact they have been discussed in just the past few weeks.
Thank YOU guys for reading and supporting us. Means a lot.
Wow! Thanks, Mr. Curnow. I was thinking your reply may appear in the letters pages in the late #50s'.
I thought I figured out something you all may have forgotten about/dropped in reference to the two other empty cages in StockGen labs. How about a fan poll to help you at IDW decide whether it be in the letters pages of an upcoming issue you ask us to tell you in a letter or a thread here?
liugeaux
01-16-2016, 05:53 PM
First off, thanks for this thread!
Second, this might be somewhere in the forums, but I didn't find it when searching. Has the full combined Vengeance cover image been released in a large digital form and wasn't there some scuttlebutt about a poster being made?
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 06:00 PM
Was the decision to make April a red-head done for the same reason the Nick cartoon went in that direction?
In the 80's and 90's April was always known for being a brunette or having dark black hair. In Mirage she had black curly hair, then in the original cartoon, Archie comics, and the live-action 90's movies she was a brunette.
It was the 2003 cartoon that made April a red-head for the first time, and that seemed to stick with both the Nick cartoon and IDW comic. I find it rather interesting that April's standard hair color changed from brown in the 80's/90's to a red-head across all media in the 2000's.
She's a red head in the original cartoon, right? Red-ish. I think that was just considered the default by Ronda. I don't think there was any real discussion about it, at least not that I remember.
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 06:01 PM
How about a fan poll to help you at IDW decide whether it be in the letters pages of an upcoming issue you ask us to tell you in a letter or a thread here?
I'm afraid I don't understand the question here.
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 06:02 PM
First off, thanks for this thread!
Second, this might be somewhere in the forums, but I didn't find it when searching. Has the full combined Vengeance cover image been released in a large digital form and wasn't there some scuttlebutt about a poster being made?
It was made into a print, yes! We sold it at conventions last year from SDCC forward. Maybe check or write the IDW store from our website? Might be able to get one shipped to you there, i'm not sure.
MikeandRaph87
01-16-2016, 06:17 PM
I'm afraid I don't understand the question here.
I was referring to submitting it for a letter in the back of the ongoing. I was expected an answer if it was chosen to appear instead of answering here. That is all.:tsmile:
Ninturtle
01-16-2016, 07:07 PM
1. Was Krang taking the DNA of Himato Yoshi and his dead sons planned from the start or was it an idea that came to you?
2. Who comes up with the idea above?
3. Where there any ideas in IDW that made it in the the comic that you were hesitant to put in?
4. Are there any things that made it in the comics that you weren't a fan of?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-16-2016, 07:48 PM
Bobby, what's the setting when you, Tom, and Kevin meet to discuss the next issue or story arc?
A Skype meeting with everybody in their own offices remotely, or all three of you sitting around a desk or table somewhere, diet sodas and coffee in hand? I'm really curious to know which it is... :tgrin:
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 07:48 PM
1. Was Krang taking the DNA of Himato Yoshi and his dead sons planned from the start or was it an idea that came to you?
2. Who comes up with the idea above?
3. Where there any ideas in IDW that made it in the the comic that you were hesitant to put in?
4. Are there any things that made it in the comics that you weren't a fan of?
1 & 2: It was something that came up in the last two years. I think it was me who thought of that epilogue to #50.
3. Not that I can think of. There's been pitches for micros and mini-series that had ideas that I was hesitant about, but we ended up not doing them.
4. Related to the previous question, I'm the main person approving or rejecting stories and art, so I tend to be a fan of most things that make it to the printed page. But that doesn't mean I don't think our execution could be better here and there. Sometimes things aren't plotted as well as they could be in retrospect, (looking at myself here!) or deadlines have had an adverse effect on the quality of art.
Bobby Curnow
01-16-2016, 07:55 PM
Bobby, what's the setting when you, Tom, and Kevin meet to discuss the next issue or story arc?
A Skype meeting with everybody in their own offices remotely, or all three of you sitting around a desk or table somewhere, diet sodas and coffee in hand? I'm really curious to know which it is... :tgrin:
The first three years of the book, Kevin lived in LA. Both Tom and I editors at IDW in San Diego. During those three years, Kevin would drive down to San Diego maybe two or three times a year, and we'd sit in the IDW conference room and maybe order a pizza and talk for a few hours. For the rest of the year, it would just be me and Tom chatting with each other (we sat right next to each other in the old IDW office) at any given time of day. We'd type up a proposal and send it to Kevin, and he'd on occasion throw in a note in response over email.
For the past two years, Kevin has lived in San Diego, so we have much more frequent meetings at the IDW office, i'd say once a month. This enables us to focus more intently on the storyline at hand, but we almost always spiral out into ideas which affect things way down the line. For instance, we met just yesterday to move a storyline up in front of another for various reasons both logistical and for storytelling. But of course we spent about an hour discussing things that probably won't happen for a couple years, if ever!
Bobby, how is it working with the TMNT creators?
Etsyturtle2
01-16-2016, 08:19 PM
Bobby, how is it working with the TMNT creators?
Creator- if you are referring to Kevin Eastman who was one of the co creators of the tmnt. Peter laird does not work on this series. But, you may be referring to the others who work on the series such as artists and writers and other people who work on the series. In that case, I'm also curious. Is it cool, knowing that you're a part of such a beloved and popular franchise?
Creator- if you are referring to Kevin Eastman who was one of the co creators of the tmnt. Peter laird does not work on this series. But, you may be referring to the others who work on the series such as artists and writers and other people who work on the series. In that case, I'm also curious. Is it cool, knowing that you're a part of such a beloved and popular franchise?
That's what I meant. Weird auto correct.
Etsyturtle2
01-16-2016, 08:29 PM
That's what I meant. Weird auto correct.
Yeeeeahhhh. We'll go with that.
Yeeeeahhhh. We'll go with that.
It's true, brah.
CyberCubed
01-16-2016, 09:59 PM
How did the idea come to use Fast Forward characters like Jammerhead and Darius Dunn recently? Given these characters are relatively obscure, did you guys binge watch the Fast Forward season on DVD recently and say, "Hey, we can do something with these guys."
Do you guys get DVD files from Viacom of all the episodes or so to watch through them? Seeing relatively obscure TMNT characters show up is rather cool.
Powder
01-16-2016, 10:16 PM
Thanks for the insightful responses to my questions, Bobby! Funny coincidence about Woody, I love that it can have a double meaning if you should want it to. :trazz: Red masks, eh? I knew you were a man of good taste. :tlol: Nah, I totally get it, from a business standpoint there's no smarter move than having the instantly recognizable look there to grab potential buyers or casual fans. At this point I've realized you guys probably did us Mirage fans a favor, too. It'd be weird to see red masked turtles that'd be aesthetically synonymous with Mirage, fighting Fred Wolf villains or making reference to other more kid-friendly material from over the years. I guess that's why I was critical of certain elements in those first few issues. The red masks had me thinking things would go in a somewhat different direction (not that I'm complaining, mind you!).
Anyway, this question would probably be better directed at Tom (or any other prominent writer for IDW's turtle books, for that matter), but since you are directly involved & readily available, hopefully you don't mind handling it. How much influence does he & his scripts have over the layouts of each issue? Do his works, like film scripts often do, depict the scene's appearance? Like say, "Wide shot of the 4 turtles startled expressions" or "Cut to a Manhattan sunset", "Raphael punches a foot soldier while Leonardo kicks an elite guard", that kind of thing. I've always been curious about that!
AquaParade
01-16-2016, 10:48 PM
Bobby, this thread is wonderful to have. Thanks!
I love hearing about Kevin's contribution to the book. Are there any specific story beats you can remember him coming up with?
I really dug the combination of Eastman layouts with Duncan finishes from the first arc and wouldn't mind seeing something like that collaboration again.
Ninjinister
01-16-2016, 11:47 PM
A few things that sprang to mind tonight:
1) Any chance of a wardrobe change for the Turtles, maybe a permanent one? I really enjoyed their Stump Wrestling uniforms (although a few of them, if ever re-used in a more modern setting, might have to be tweaked a bit due to being pretty overwhelmingly nineties), and I felt that their "Vision Quest" uniforms from the current cartoon should've stayed as their primary appearances... I know the boys have an "iconic" look and that you guys (as a whole and with every individual artist) have given your own individual "spin" to them... but sometimes a costume change in an iconic character might actually be more beneficial, y'know?
2) Among the same lines of "permanent change"... were any of the major shakeups in the dynamic (Dark Leo, Metal Don, Mutanimal Mike) at any point given consideration to be permanent? Would that be a thing that could ever possibly happen, or do you feel like those above you would shoot it down?
3) Can we expect any sort of development and expansion on Koya + Bludgeon and the Mutanimals as individuals (outside of Slash 'n' Hob since we knew them before the team) anytime soon? I'd especially be interested in Koya and Bludgeon's sibling-esque relationship, why Mondo and Herman adopted the personae they have, and pretty much anything about Sally and Ray.
I actually had another one but it escapes me at the moment....
Thanks again for everything! Hope our questions aren't keeping you *too* busy!
Utrommaniac
01-17-2016, 12:02 AM
I'll be waiting to see what you do with them. "Utrom Empire" set up so many possibilities, and then there's Zog who I could easily see sliding into a Traximus-like role.
I did wonder where Zog had gone off to after he dropped Krang out of the ship. He just sort of vanished after that, and there's no word on if he's dead or not. Makes me think of that bit from ATLA.
http://33.media.tumblr.com/64a6017c5e5c33153b23303f17dffd2e/tumblr_naqsrtVTkA1tec4njo1_500.gif
It would be silly to ask if the Triceratons are waiting to spring from the shadows, because they most likely are. Probably getting into the place that they typically hold and looking like big hypocrites after their part in rebelling against the Utroms.
neatoman
01-17-2016, 06:37 AM
So from the looks of it, the cartoon tie-in book isn't doing so well even after you rebranded it. Is it in danger of of being chancelled or is it safe for a little while longer?
There's also the matter of the Archie reprints, do you regret that you opted to ignore the controversial issues instead of simlply editing them? I know depicting Mohammed is a bit of touchy since it has spurred acts of violence, so I understand why you did it.
Wentos
01-17-2016, 11:18 AM
Hey Bobby, thanks for doing this. I love how friendly with the fans the IDW crew is. My question is, what exactly does the Foot Clan do when they aren't fighting other people? And what is their ultimate goal?
One thing I always liked about the Mirage Foot Clan is that they existed as their own entity with their own agenda long before the turtles even came on the scene. Their motives as a group were simple and easy to understand.
http://s17.postimg.org/allnc750v/TMNT1p16.png
And to be honest, one of my pet peeves with other versions of the Foot is that they seem to serve no purpose other than to give the turtles a headache. I understand that the Foot's primary function is to be the turtles' antagonist, but the mark of good writing is that every character (or group of characters) has an agenda outside of being an obstacle for the protagonist.
Does the Foot serve a purpose beyond being Shredder/Splinter's private army? And what do they as a group ultimately want?
Hey Bobby,
I always wondered why the Foot Clan moved to USA in IDW. I think so far it's not explained. In Mirage it was just the smaller US branch of Foot with Saki as the leader, and Karai as her 'boss', but obviously it's not the case with IDW. I guess USA becoming a superpower, thus making sense to move there from Japan with the aim of world domination makes sense... except Shredder was sleeping at that time, and wasn't there with his grandiose plans.
Any chance for exploring this terrority more in the comic later? I know that the next logical step is exploring the phanteon stuff, but it would be nice, to also learn more about the Foot clan's history. ;)
Redeemer
01-17-2016, 03:33 PM
Hey Bobby,
I always wondered why the Foot Clan moved to USA in IDW. I think so far it's not explained. In Mirage it was just the smaller US branch of Foot with Saki as the leader, and Karai as her 'boss', but obviously it's not the case with IDW. I guess USA becoming a superpower, thus making sense to move there from Japan with the aim of world domination makes sense... except Shredder was sleeping at that time, and wasn't there with his grandiose plans.
Any chance for exploring this terrority more in the comic later? I know that the next logical step is exploring the phanteon stuff, but it would be nice, to also learn more about the Foot clan's history. ;)
In the early issues Karia was narrating a brief history of the foot clan and how they became greedy with no honor and moved to a financial market scheme. The biggest financial market in the world is the U.S. so I assume thats why the moved to New York specifically.
phillytmnt
01-17-2016, 04:02 PM
Hi Bobby, I have a couple of questions.
1. When will the pantheon story really kick into gear? It has been building up for a while but with all of the new story points introduced after issue 50, it seems like it will be a while before Kitsune and others have their plans play out.
2. Is there more with the whole dragon warrior stuff with the shredder than what was brought up so far or was it just a way for Kitsune to manipulate Saki? After SHOF it seemed to be forgotten about until issue 49 when Kitsune calls him it. Also in SHOF, it was brought up that Shredder became immortal after he was resurrected. Did that mean he just doesn't age ever? It was never really brought up again.
3. I was curious in issue 50 about the conversation between Yoshi and Saki when Yoshi says"It is true, you are very powerful Saki but it is a power that chose you and you not it. A power that deludes you into believing you cannot be defeated, cannot be destroyed." I was wondering if I could have your take on it. Was Yoshi talking about Saki's desire for dominance or more about his natural fighting ability and desire to be the best like when he beat up that foot member when they were young in the issue?
Thanks to you and the IDW team! I absolutely love what you guys are doing.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:28 PM
Bobby, how is it working with the TMNT creators?
Not a very interesting answer: it's great. I've been really lucky in that i've enjoyed working with everyone working on the book. Virtually everyone has been a big TMNT fan themselves, so they are excited to be working on the book. No one has had a big ego. Some people are difficult with deadlines, and that causes some stress, but otherwise everyone has been easy to work with, and it's been great to see the creativity, energy and humor they've brought to the job.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:31 PM
How did the idea come to use Fast Forward characters like Jammerhead and Darius Dunn recently? Given these characters are relatively obscure, did you guys binge watch the Fast Forward season on DVD recently and say, "Hey, we can do something with these guys."
Do you guys get DVD files from Viacom of all the episodes or so to watch through them? Seeing relatively obscure TMNT characters show up is rather cool.
Fast Forward characters are all Tom's idea, so that's a question for hm. We didn't get any DVD files from Viacom. I've tried to watch as much 2K3 as I can through various sources at the start of our run, but after season 3 I have big holes in my personal viewing. I think Tom has seen it all though, so he's much more familiar with those characters.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:34 PM
Anyway, this question would probably be better directed at Tom (or any other prominent writer for IDW's turtle books, for that matter), but since you are directly involved & readily available, hopefully you don't mind handling it. How much influence does he & his scripts have over the layouts of each issue? Do his works, like film scripts often do, depict the scene's appearance? Like say, "Wide shot of the 4 turtles startled expressions" or "Cut to a Manhattan sunset", "Raphael punches a foot soldier while Leonardo kicks an elite guard", that kind of thing. I've always been curious about that!
I'd say it's what would now be considered standard comic book script-- breaking the page into whatever number of panels, and then describing what is happening in those panels. The amount of description Tom gives depends on what's going on. If it's straight forward and flexible, it could just be: "Mike is talking" but sometimes he'll suggest "camera angels", expressions, more room for a certain panel on the page, etc. But we always allow the artists to be flexible with the panel instruction. They know better than we do what will look good.
MikeandRaph87
01-17-2016, 05:39 PM
To play off of Powder's question, how much input into the plot/story if any do the artist themselves have in the story they help create? I know there have been several examples of artist stepping up to help the writer with setting up the story.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:40 PM
Bobby, this thread is wonderful to have. Thanks!
I love hearing about Kevin's contribution to the book. Are there any specific story beats you can remember him coming up with?
I really dug the combination of Eastman layouts with Duncan finishes from the first arc and wouldn't mind seeing something like that collaboration again.
It's easier to remember what Kevin has contributed when i've got a prompt in front of me, like when someone mentioned Nobody above (Kevin had the idea for Angel to be Nobody). The things that are recent, and I can remember most clearly, are things coming up and can't talk very much about (for instance, there's a framing device in TMNT #55 that was Kevin's idea). Usually his ideas are related more to how characters might interact with others-- character beats, I suppose is the easiest way to describe it. He's also helped with suggestions in regard to how action scenes could potentially play out, which is always cool because Kevin can bring an artist's sensibility to the conversation, something that Tom and I can't.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:49 PM
A few things that sprang to mind tonight:
1) Any chance of a wardrobe change for the Turtles, maybe a permanent one?
2) Among the same lines of "permanent change"... were any of the major shakeups in the dynamic (Dark Leo, Metal Don, Mutanimal Mike) at any point given consideration to be permanent? Would that be a thing that could ever possibly happen, or do you feel like those above you would shoot it down?
3) Can we expect any sort of development and expansion on Koya + Bludgeon and the Mutanimals as individuals (outside of Slash 'n' Hob since we knew them before the team) anytime soon? I'd especially be interested in Koya and Bludgeon's sibling-esque relationship, why Mondo and Herman adopted the personae they have, and pretty much anything about Sally and Ray.
I actually had another one but it escapes me at the moment....
Thanks again for everything! Hope our questions aren't keeping you *too* busy!
1) I think if we had a good story reason, that'd be fun to see. Just hasn't come up in a way that makes sense. The Turtles will have little breathing apparatuses during their upcoming time on Burnow Island, so that's something!
2) I think something like that would have been shot down by Nickelodeon in the first two years of the series, but now they trust us really well so I think it could happen if we wanted. I think it was really satisfying for Don to return in his body in TMNT #50, but if I could have my cake and eat it too, I would have liked him to be Metal Don for longer, and have us explore that longer. But we always intended for him to return to his own body. I think overall it's important that the experiences of the past stay with our characters, and inform their actions, but that they retain some essential "coreness" so that the book is still accessible to new readers. As we go on though, I can see changes like that staying around longer, and indeed, perhaps be permanent.
3) I think each of the mutanimals will have some nice character beats in the next issue, but in terms of deeper exploration: there are plans, but I can't really say "soon". Depends on your definition of that, and I need to be vague about that regardless.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:51 PM
I did wonder where Zog had gone off to after he dropped Krang out of the ship.
It would be silly to ask if the Triceratons are waiting to spring from the shadows, because they most likely are. Probably getting into the place that they typically hold and looking like big hypocrites after their part in rebelling against the Utroms.
We saw a changed Zog in the Battle Nexus in Kevin's Annual. We have plans to come back to him.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 05:56 PM
So from the looks of it, the cartoon tie-in book isn't doing so well even after you rebranded it. Is it in danger of of being chancelled or is it safe for a little while longer?
There's also the matter of the Archie reprints, do you regret that you opted to ignore the controversial issues instead of simlply editing them? I know depicting Mohammed is a bit of touchy since it has spurred acts of violence, so I understand why you did it.
The Animated book does do well in digital and collection, so that helps the bottom line. That being said, our traditional "danger zone" in terms of cancellation is between 4-6K, depending on the creative cost of the book. If the book continues on its current trajectory, I think we'll get to at least issue #12. We'll see. (a reminder that the numbers that are listed online are often incorrect, sometimes greatly so. That being said, on average, they probably give a somewhat accurate depiction of the book's health.)
I have nothing to do with the reprints, and sometimes the reprint department is constricted in what they themselves can do. I personally would always like to see all material reprinted, but I understand things are often out of our hands.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 06:05 PM
Hey Bobby, thanks for doing this. I love how friendly with the fans the IDW crew is. My question is, what exactly does the Foot Clan do when they aren't fighting other people? And what is their ultimate goal?
One thing I always liked about the Mirage Foot Clan is that they existed as their own entity with their own agenda long before the turtles even came on the scene. Their motives as a group were simple and easy to understand.
http://s17.postimg.org/allnc750v/TMNT1p16.png
And to be honest, one of my pet peeves with other versions of the Foot is that they seem to serve no purpose other than to give the turtles a headache. I understand that the Foot's primary function is to be the turtles' antagonist, but the mark of good writing is that every character (or group of characters) has an agenda outside of being an obstacle for the protagonist.
Does the Foot serve a purpose beyond being Shredder/Splinter's private army? And what do they as a group ultimately want?
Under Shredder, the Foot was primarily a way to acquire power over the criminal underworld of NYC, and then hopefully to expand his scope beyond that. With that power presumably comes a great deal of material wealth (at the end of City Fall, we saw other crime organizations giving tribute). As to why Shredder wanted that sort of power, I personally think it came from a sense of hidden insecurity-- he didn't want anyone to threaten him or his Foot family, so he thought the best thing to do was to conquer and control. He wanted order, but specifically his own brand of order. Then, after Attack on Technodrome, he realized that Splinter and the Turtles were the greatest threats to his order, so he focused everything on them, ("Vengeance") to the detriment of the Clan, which of course Karai took notice of. We'll be exploring what the Foot Clan "is" under Splinter more in coming issues.
I would think the Foot Clan, besides controlling other crime organizations, is also involved in all sorts of bad things (extortion, theft, blackmail) that ninjas might be especially good at. I do wish we would have explored these things in more depth, and round out the Foot Clan as an organization more. We've hinted here and there, but would be fun to see more. If things go as planned we'll have the opportunity to do that in the future.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 06:08 PM
In the early issues Karia was narrating a brief history of the foot clan and how they became greedy with no honor and moved to a financial market scheme. The biggest financial market in the world is the U.S. so I assume thats why the moved to New York specifically.
Yep, the Karai micro best explains this, but Redeemer has it right.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 06:21 PM
Hi Bobby, I have a couple of questions.
1. When will the pantheon story really kick into gear? It has been building up for a while but with all of the new story points introduced after issue 50, it seems like it will be a while before Kitsune and others have their plans play out.
2. Is there more with the whole dragon warrior stuff with the shredder than what was brought up so far or was it just a way for Kitsune to manipulate Saki? After SHOF it seemed to be forgotten about until issue 49 when Kitsune calls him it. Also in SHOF, it was brought up that Shredder became immortal after he was resurrected. Did that mean he just doesn't age ever? It was never really brought up again.
3. I was curious in issue 50 about the conversation between Yoshi and Saki when Yoshi says"It is true, you are very powerful Saki but it is a power that chose you and you not it. A power that deludes you into believing you cannot be defeated, cannot be destroyed." I was wondering if I could have your take on it. Was Yoshi talking about Saki's desire for dominance or more about his natural fighting ability and desire to be the best like when he beat up that foot member when they were young in the issue?
Thanks to you and the IDW team! I absolutely love what you guys are doing.
1. It depends on what you mean by "kick into gear". The Pantheon is sort of equivalent to the Technodrome in #1-50, something that we'll touch in on, and develop parts of as we go, but the picture won't be complete for a while yet. Anything I say beyond that is probably too much of a spoiler.
2. I think it's important to remember that the Foot history book (forget the exact name, Ashi something, I don't have my reference in front of me right now) is, like any old and important text, probably prone to embellishment and mythology-making that literal fact. I think it was just referring to the idea that Saki never really died, he was in deep sleep, and was destined to return-- ergo he will "live" forever. Obviously the book does not dictate the reality of the future. As for Shredder being referred to as the "Dragon Warrior" could just be a term of endearment from Kitsune.
3. I think that Splinter was referring to Shredder's return to waking life, and all of the power that came with his place in the Foot Clan in the present day. That was all largely beyond Saki's direct control, but he acted like it was his and he had earned it. Saki bought into his own hype, thinking that the fear he inspired and control he wielded would give him ultimate power forever. But Splinter wasn't scared of him and showed that that power was fleeting.
Bobby Curnow
01-17-2016, 06:25 PM
To play off of Powder's question, how much input into the plot/story if any do the artist themselves have in the story they help create? I know there have been several examples of artist stepping up to help the writer with setting up the story.
In the ongoing, not much, as we usually have things well plotted out a good deal in advance before an artist even comes aboard for a given story arc. Some artists will suggest things that would be cool, either as action or design. (Sophie comes to mind in this regard-- Sophie is a good writer as well, and always has lots of fun ideas. Pepperoni is Sophie's idea, for instance)
And of course, Mateus plotted Secret History very thoroughly.
CyberCubed
01-17-2016, 06:55 PM
Fast Forward characters are all Tom's idea, so that's a question for hm. We didn't get any DVD files from Viacom. I've tried to watch as much 2K3 as I can through various sources at the start of our run, but after season 3 I have big holes in my personal viewing. I think Tom has seen it all though, so he's much more familiar with those characters.
I see, that makes sense. When obscure TMNT characters pop up there's obviously no way anyone would be familiar with those characters unless they watched the episodes they were in, so I was curious. Same with Alex Winter and Dark Water.
I guess Tom must be binge watching TMNT DVDs then. :)
turtlefan27
01-17-2016, 08:49 PM
Tom-I was just wondering why Donny hasn't developed a phone for them to use like they had in the original show.a phone would be useful in certain situations..also will the guys ever use different weapons like how mikey is doing currently.
Zog The Magnificent
01-17-2016, 10:16 PM
This is more of a production question, but seeing as you own the comic rights now, are there any plans to reprint the image series in black and white? It's just hard to find and it would be nice if TPBs of it existed. Second, are there any plans for a Bludgeon/Koya Miniseries? I would love to see a little more of them. Thanks for whatever you can tell me!
Bobby Curnow
01-18-2016, 12:23 AM
This is more of a production question, but seeing as you own the comic rights now, are there any plans to reprint the image series in black and white? It's just hard to find and it would be nice if TPBs of it existed. Second, are there any plans for a Bludgeon/Koya Miniseries? I would love to see a little more of them. Thanks for whatever you can tell me!
It looks like we aren't planning to print the Image series, but i'm hoping to dig into the reason for that a little more soon.
No mini-series with B & K planned, but we'll explore them more eventually!
Red Robin
01-18-2016, 02:10 AM
I am really sorry to hear that the Image series doesn't get a reprint.
Can you tell something about Volume 4? Are there plans on reprinting them? Because many people, who are new to the Mirage series, have problems to get their hands on the issues 23-32.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-18-2016, 09:07 AM
It looks like we aren't planning to print the Image series, but i'm hoping to dig into the reason for that a little more soon.
No mini-series with B & K planned, but we'll explore them more eventually!
I'm honestly crushed by that news, Bobby. :tcry: Is it a sure thing of "NEVER" or just "Not right now"?
Also, what about Volume 4?
Shedder
01-18-2016, 09:56 AM
No Vol 3 is crushing news. Was really looking forward to collecting and reading that
Duke Nukem
01-18-2016, 10:00 AM
Personally, I'd rather they focus on delivering more original content than reprints, whether it's continuing and expanding the ongoing, or adding to past volumes (like finishing Forever War).
Powder
01-18-2016, 10:02 AM
It's two separate departments altogether, reprints have no bearing on the pace the main series takes.
Duke Nukem
01-18-2016, 11:24 AM
Sure, but they share common money and other resources at some level. I have no idea which is more profitable.
Bobby Curnow
01-18-2016, 01:04 PM
I'm going to look more into Vol. 3 and try and figure out what the obstacles are. I'll ask about Vol. 4 too, I don't know.
I don't think anything is absolute. Things can change over time, but that doesn't necessarily mean it will.
CyberCubed
01-18-2016, 01:09 PM
The only obstacle I can think of is several Image owned characters guest star in the book like Savage Dragon and other Image superheroes, but I remember Erik Larsen (head of Image), saying that he would be OK with IDW reprinting the series.
Unless its because of the violence, but honestly, Image isn't *that* much more violent than Mirage. I mean the whole story with Don smashing his shell and becoming a cyborg seemed to be the inspiration for IDW's story with Don becoming Metalhead. Raph's face gets scarred but it gets bandaged up quickly and then he wears Casey's mask over it.
AquaParade
01-18-2016, 07:09 PM
Thanks for looking into vol. 3, Bobby. It's a fan favorite.
CyberCubed
01-19-2016, 01:30 AM
Speaking of Image, was Don's shell being smashed and put in Metalhead's body inspired by Don's shell being smashed and becoming a cyborg in the Image series?
It seemed too similar to be a coincidence. I know Tom likes to pull things from all the different TMNT universes and this seemed to be very Image inspired.
Sophie Campbell
01-19-2016, 08:56 AM
I think we've talked a bit about it before, but a Christmas/holiday issue being brought up in this thread got me thinking about it again, do you guys ever think about doing seasonal specials? Like a Valentine's Day special or a Halloween special? I've always loved that kind of thing, I'm disappointed I didn't get to draw the Jem holiday special and the Valentine's issue. Just think about how cool a TMNT Halloween special would be!
MsMarvelDuckie
01-19-2016, 09:26 AM
That would be awesome! The Halloween episode of the 4Kids series was one of my favorites. A comic like that would be fun.
Shedder
01-19-2016, 10:05 AM
Correct me if I'm wrong but that 2k3 episode was based on one of the Vol. 1 Tales issues. Wasn't that a Halloween issue?
Also there is that one short story about the guys breaking into the 2nd Time Around shop and the Turtles all being dressed in their Halloween costumes getting ready to meet April at a Halloween Party and they had to defend the shop. It was just collected in the Ultimate Collection 6 book. I believe its called "Don't judge a book"?
Bobby Curnow
01-19-2016, 10:11 AM
Speaking of Image, was Don's shell being smashed and put in Metalhead's body inspired by Don's shell being smashed and becoming a cyborg in the Image series?
It seemed too similar to be a coincidence. I know Tom likes to pull things from all the different TMNT universes and this seemed to be very Image inspired.
It came from thinking about Fugitoid-- how Don and Fugitoid were friends and had the conversation about what happened to souls during teleportation in Krang War (a conversation that came completely from Tom, btw). It seemed odd to me that there was this mind-into-machine technology in the TMNT universe and it was relatively unexplored, and this seemed like a good time to do so.
But after the fact I did remember that aspect of Image and noted the similarity. I don't doubt that must have played a strong subconscious role. It was around the same time that we planning the 30th Anniversary Special, so it would have been fresh in my mind.
Bobby Curnow
01-19-2016, 10:14 AM
I think we've talked a bit about it before, but a Christmas/holiday issue being brought up in this thread got me thinking about it again, do you guys ever think about doing seasonal specials? Like a Valentine's Day special or a Halloween special? I've always loved that kind of thing, I'm disappointed I didn't get to draw the Jem holiday special and the Valentine's issue. Just think about how cool a TMNT Halloween special would be!
Not something we've actively thought about, they are kind of difficult to plan, but i'm up for it if someone pitches a good seasonal story. *Squints at Sophie*
Sophie Campbell
01-19-2016, 12:13 PM
Correct me if I'm wrong but that 2k3 episode was based on one of the Vol. 1 Tales issues. Wasn't that a Halloween issue?
Also there is that one short story about the guys breaking into the 2nd Time Around shop and the Turtles all being dressed in their Halloween costumes getting ready to meet April at a Halloween Party and they had to defend the shop. It was just collected in the Ultimate Collection 6 book. I believe its called "Don't judge a book"?
Yeah! I love that short. It was originally published in TMNT & Other Strangeness. All the Turtles' costumes get ruined in the fight so they decide to just go to the party as themselves.
Not something we've actively thought about, they are kind of difficult to plan, but i'm up for it if someone pitches a good seasonal story. *Squints at Sophie*
We can do a sappy mushy Valentine's issue featuring romantic pairings of Raph/Alopex, Koya/Bludgeon, Angel/April, and Sally/Lindsay. Or I'd introduce Mona Lisa and then everyone would hate me. :D
CyberCubed
01-19-2016, 12:34 PM
We can do a sappy mushy Valentine's issue featuring romantic pairings of Angel/April, D
Whoa, Angel/April? Now there's a pairing I could go for. :lol:
I always figured that if Casey/April break up in this series, that Angel would be his "rebound" girl for Casey, since Angel and Casey have the whole childhood friendship thing going on. Not to mention Angel clearly likes Casey as you can tell by the scene at the hospital and show talks to him.
Never thought of Angel/April, but that sounds good to me. :P
Utrommaniac
01-19-2016, 12:39 PM
I'm down with some sappy Valentines. So long as it's utterly saccharine and enjoyably gross, like a cake decorated with 90% marzipan.
At this point now, I'm confused as to what Bludgeon and Koya's relationship is. Is it sibling-y or romantic-y...or platonic close friendship? Either of those ways, someone will ship a bird and a shark. Someone that is totally not me. In no way what so ever. I do not chuckle thinking about Koya at a Foot Clan karaoke night belting Bette Middler's Wind Beneath My Wings mostly to Bludgeon.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-19-2016, 12:50 PM
Guys, can we keep the discussion to a minimum and try to keep the thread to questions only? It'd probably make it easier for Bobby to reply if he doesn't have to wade through us discussing and theorizing...
$0.02
MikeandRaph87
01-19-2016, 03:11 PM
Agreed with CKD,if you fail to comply you will be tomstoned by Leo656.
As for my question, was there always a set number of members of The Pantheon? I keep wondering if we have seen all of Kitsume's siblings yet.
Bobby Curnow
01-19-2016, 04:45 PM
First, I just want to say i've looked a bit more into Image reprinting. I don't want to get anyone's hopes up as there is no official change in its status and won't be for a while yet, if ever.
But it does seem like it's possible, just depends on a couple factors i'm not at liberty to discuss, which look to be slow to move. I will continue to prod at it and keep folks updated if things develop.
Bobby Curnow
01-19-2016, 04:46 PM
As for my question, was there always a set number of members of The Pantheon? I keep wondering if we have seen all of Kitsume's siblings yet.
No, that is something that has, and could continue, to change.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-19-2016, 04:52 PM
First, I just want to say i've looked a bit more into Image reprinting. I don't want to get anyone's hopes up as there is no official change in its status and won't be for a while yet, if ever.
But it does seem like it's possible, just depends on a couple factors i'm not at liberty to discuss, which look to be slow to move. I will continue to prod at it and keep folks updated if things develop.
Thanks Bobby. Fan favorites are worth waiting for; just tell the reprint guys whenever they do make it happen, there's a group of us on here who will immediately preorder.
Any ideas when Volume 4 might start getting collected, as Volume 2 was finished last summer?
Bobby Curnow
01-19-2016, 05:01 PM
Thanks Bobby. Fan favorites are worth waiting for; just tell the reprint guys whenever they do make it happen, there's a group of us on here who will immediately preorder.
Any ideas when Volume 4 might start getting collected, as Volume 2 was finished last summer?
Not currently on the schedule, but could just be waiting until Adventures or Tales get further along. I believe the current thinking is that the market can only support so many TMNT reprints at a time.
neatoman
01-19-2016, 05:02 PM
So are there any more crossover plans when your little collaboration with DC is over?
Bobby Curnow
01-19-2016, 05:54 PM
So are there any more crossover plans when your little collaboration with DC is over?
Some possibilities, but nothing more than purely theoretical at this point.
member_removed
01-19-2016, 08:49 PM
Any chance of a Star Trek crossover in the future (or other IDW properties).
ProphetofGanja
01-19-2016, 08:57 PM
Any chance of a Star Trek crossover in the future (or other IDW properties).
as a lifelong Star Wars fan who knows next to nothing about Star Trek (other than having seen the two new movies and like one episode of The Next Generation), I think that would be dope yo
Venom
01-19-2016, 09:51 PM
Some possibilities, but nothing more than purely theoretical at this point.
Hey Bobby, can I sticky your thread? Cause I'ma sticky your thread. *sticks*
On the subject of crossovers, has IDW ever explored the possibility of crossing the Turtles over with the Gargoyles?
Back when that show was on, it felt like a natural fit for the two properties to complement the other, even being from two different companies. Perhaps it's the shadows and darkness, the ambience of the night they share, but it would also be a lot of fun to have seen Saki and Zanatos attempt to broker a deal.
Another Q if I may A: In the Shredder micro, we got to see the future with a cybernetic-looking Shredder reigning supreme over a land of mutated monsters..with his departure from the physical realm, does that render that future, and the one the Turtles visited, altered? Or is that an untold tale?
Speaking of Tales, when is IDW going to take the plunge and allow the Turtles a semblance of the indie days by reviving Tales under a banner that has creators from across the industry a chance to tell us a story? They don't have to be in continuity. Perhaps experiment with a biannual or quarterly? Maybe even convince Remender to have another go at a Turtle story, or bring T-Rex and Paul Harmon back together!
Thanks for rocking, Bobby!
funatic
01-19-2016, 11:03 PM
or bring T-Rex and Paul Harmon back together!
yes plz. this plz.
Thanks for rocking, Bobby!
also this.
Wentos
01-20-2016, 11:32 AM
Speaking of Tales, when is IDW going to take the plunge and allow the Turtles a semblance of the indie days by reviving Tales under a banner that has creators from across the industry a chance to tell us a story? They don't have to be in continuity. Perhaps experiment with a biannual or quarterly? Maybe even convince Remender to have another go at a Turtle story, or bring T-Rex and Paul Harmon back together!
I've had this thought myself. I'd love to see more stuff like the 30th Anniversary Special, where creators from different times in TMNT history would be able to tell new stories with the characters outside of IDW continuity. I've done my fair share of grousing about Eastman's artistic involvement with the IDW series, but I would love to see new TMNT work from him outside of the IDW universe context. And of course, a collab between Eastman and Laird would be an absolute dream come true. I would also love love LOVE to see more work from Tristan Jones and Paul Harmon. Their Tales run was the crown jewel of post-relaunch Mirage.
(This is more fan suggestion than question, but oh well :D)
bushido
01-20-2016, 12:11 PM
I wonder if Paramount commissioned a comic book adaptation of the recent movies or are they unaware that it's also a comic and not just a cartoon from the 80s? By the way did the production contacted you at some point?
Bobby Curnow
01-20-2016, 01:20 PM
Any chance of a Star Trek crossover in the future (or other IDW properties).
No plans for TMNT/Star Trek. Can't speak to ST plans beyond that, I don't know.
Panda_Kahn_fan
01-20-2016, 01:22 PM
Bobby, any chance of the neutrinoes popping up again soon? And any chances for a second tmnt ongoing?
Bobby Curnow
01-20-2016, 01:26 PM
Hey Bobby, can I sticky your thread? Cause I'ma sticky your thread. *sticks*
On the subject of crossovers, has IDW ever explored the possibility of crossing the Turtles over with the Gargoyles?
Another Q if I may A: In the Shredder micro, we got to see the future with a cybernetic-looking Shredder reigning supreme over a land of mutated monsters..with his departure from the physical realm, does that render that future, and the one the Turtles visited, altered? Or is that an untold tale?
Speaking of Tales, when is IDW going to take the plunge and allow the Turtles a semblance of the indie days by reviving Tales under a banner that has creators from across the industry a chance to tell us a story? They don't have to be in continuity. Perhaps experiment with a biannual or quarterly? Maybe even convince Remender to have another go at a Turtle story, or bring T-Rex and Paul Harmon back together!
Thanks for rocking, Bobby!
No plans for TMNT/Gargoyles. Keep in mind that with these types of crossover questions I would have to answer the same even if there WERE plans in the works-- I can't announce publishing plans here. So i'm going to have to go with a generic "no plans" answer on all things that would be major announcements, regardless of the truth of the matter. Something to keep in mind. (but for this one time I'll say that there definitely aren't any plans for these crossovers at this time, promise!)
We'll explore the concept of altered timelines later in the year, so stay tuned.
Hoping that current plans will allow for elements along the lines of what you are speaking of in this third question. Again, gotta be vague.
Bobby Curnow
01-20-2016, 01:30 PM
I wonder if Paramount commissioned a comic book adaptation of the recent movies or are they unaware that it's also a comic and not just a cartoon from the 80s? By the way did the production contacted you at some point?
For the first movie, Tom and I drove up to LA to read a draft of the script (what the actual film ended up being was a bit different). At the time IDW had not had great success with movie-tie-in books, so there wasn't a great pressure for us to do something on either side. Tom and I didn't think there was a lot of creative opportunity for us to do something on the comic side, so we declined to do anything with the movie.
Nothing has come up since, we haven't been contacted or read the script for the second film, you guys probably know more about it than I do.
Fun story though, Tom and I completely plotted the Northampton story arc during that ride up to LA. Fond memories!
Bobby Curnow
01-20-2016, 01:32 PM
Bobby, any chance of the neutrinoes popping up again soon? And any chances for a second tmnt ongoing?
There are definite plans for the Neutrinos, but probably not what you'd consider "soon". Not in this calendar year.
After Batman/TMNT we'll see a return to a "sister book". What exactly the format and duration of that book might be, I can't get into.
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 01:34 PM
For the first movie, Tom and I drove up to LA to read a draft of the script (what the actual film ended up being was a bit different).
Was this the first script where they planned for the Turtles to be aliens in the movie, and Shredder was intended to be Eric Sachs rather than Oroku Saki? The whole movie had hasty re-writes (which is why the film turned out to be so lackluster, worst TMNT movie ever), and the original Blue Door script was posted online where the Turtles were in fact...written as aliens and Shredder was Eric Sachs and turned out to be an alien too.
I'm glad there isn't any movie tie-in comic especially if that means we lose a mini in the IDW universe.
Bobby Curnow
01-20-2016, 01:48 PM
Was this the first script where they planned for the Turtles to be aliens in the movie, and Shredder was intended to be Eric Sachs rather than Oroku Saki? The whole movie had hasty re-writes (which is why the film turned out to be so lackluster, worst TMNT movie ever), and the original Blue Door script was posted online where the Turtles were in fact...written as aliens and Shredder was Eric Sachs and turned out to be an alien too.
I'm glad there isn't any movie tie-in comic especially if that means we lose a mini in the IDW universe.
I'm sure it's all old history and I could talk about it, but we did sign a non-disclosure about it, so i'll refrain from doing so, just in case. I think it was a draft somewhere in the middle of the rewrites.
Was this the first script where they planned for the Turtles to be aliens in the movie, and Shredder was intended to be Eric Sachs rather than Oroku Saki? The whole movie had hasty re-writes (which is why the film turned out to be so lackluster, worst TMNT movie ever), and the original Blue Door script was posted online where the Turtles were in fact...written as aliens and Shredder was Eric Sachs and turned out to be an alien too.Sacks wasn't in the Blue Door script that was Colonel Schrader.
CyberCubed
01-20-2016, 04:53 PM
I've been re-reading the first year of IDW lately, and I know this has come up in the past, but has there been any talk about revisiting the human lives of the Turtles in Feudal Japan in a flashback issue? A lot of people are still curious what the Turtles human Japanese names were, something that still hasn't been revealed after all this time.
It also would be interesting to see how Yoshi and his sons survived in the mountains for a while before Saki eventually caught up to them and killed them. As I said I just re-read issue 5 so I'm just reminded how much I liked the reincarnation bit and am curious to see if their human lives will be revisited.
MrTrikey
01-20-2016, 04:54 PM
On the subject of crossovers, has IDW ever explored the possibility of crossing the Turtles over with the Gargoyles?
Funny thing there is that I believe it's been stated that the Gargoyles actually hate pizza. If that wasn't a thing that'd quickly have the Turtles and "the Trio" at each other's throats, I don't know what would! :D
Bobby Curnow
01-20-2016, 05:10 PM
I've been re-reading the first year of IDW lately, and I know this has come up in the past, but has there been any talk about revisiting the human lives of the Turtles in Feudal Japan in a flashback issue? A lot of people are still curious what the Turtles human Japanese names were, something that still hasn't been revealed after all this time.
It also would be interesting to see how Yoshi and his sons survived in the mountains for a while before Saki eventually caught up to them and killed them. As I said I just re-read issue 5 so I'm just reminded how much I liked the reincarnation bit and am curious to see if their human lives will be revisited.
That time of their lives is something that has been discussed and has potential to be revisited at some time.
PangolinFeets
01-20-2016, 11:11 PM
This is a longshot, but was there ever a pitch to make a more mature, animated adaptation of TMNT based on IDW? Would be so cool. ;_;
Bobby Curnow
01-21-2016, 01:31 PM
This is a longshot, but was there ever a pitch to make a more mature, animated adaptation of TMNT based on IDW? Would be so cool. ;_;
No, i've never heard anything along those lines.
Panda_Kahn_fan
01-22-2016, 11:17 AM
A spoilery question, bet one that might be vague enough to get an answer; will we see any more familiar faces among the still un-revealed members of the pantheon?
Bobby Curnow
01-22-2016, 11:34 AM
A spoilery question, bet one that might be vague enough to get an answer; will we see any more familiar faces among the still un-revealed members of the pantheon?
Can't answer that, sorry!
MikeandRaph87
01-22-2016, 12:09 PM
Can't answer that, sorry!
Thanks for saying, "yes, there is at least one familiar face in the pantheon concept yet to be revealed" without actually saying it. We may not have the solid number you all currently have set of them, but know there are others and someone old renewed again. You did not even have to answer.
The Previews website list #55 the first week of February. I would like it to be true, but doubt it. What is the currently slated date for #55 of the ongoing? Thanks.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-22-2016, 12:31 PM
Thanks for saying, "yes, there is at least one familiar face in the pantheon concept yet to be revealed" without actually saying it. We may not have the solid number you all currently have set of them, but know there are others and someone old renewed again. You did not even have to answer.
The Previews website list #55 the first week of February. I would like it to be true, but doubt it. What is the currently slated date for #55 of the ongoing? Thanks.
Bobby would say the exact same thing regardless of the truth of the matter. :tlol: As he has already clearly stated...
Bobby Curnow
01-22-2016, 12:37 PM
The Previews website list #55 the first week of February. I would like it to be true, but doubt it. What is the currently slated date for #55 of the ongoing? Thanks.
Should be the last week of February.
CyberCubed
01-22-2016, 05:20 PM
Does it get hard to juggle screentime between all the characters now that the cast has grown quite large over the last 4 years?
The ever growing list of Mutanimals, the seperate mutants like Koya/Bludgeon, Alopex, Bebop/Rocksteady. Then all the recurring human villains like Karai, Hun, Baxter, etc. And on top of that Kitsune, The Rat King, Null...and now Darius/Jammerhead, etc.
The only two main villains taken out of commission for the time being are Krang and Shredder, and while we all know they'll come back eventually, it seems the main villain or recurring mutant cast is quite large. With only a certain amount of pages per each comic and mini's only every so often, it seems like there's a large cast here all trying to get screentime. In the first few years it didn't matter so much because the cast was smaller, but now there's a lot of characters in IDW TMNT.
Aside from literally killing characters off, how are you guys going to juggle such a huge cast of recurring villains and mutants going forward? It feels like the universe has exploded now.
mikey22
01-23-2016, 03:06 PM
Hello,
I recently started reading the comics thanks to finding a book at Barnes and Noble selling IDW collection #1 which features the first 12 issues.
I know there is another IDW collection book coming in late Feb, early March.
Where do you recommend I go to find the rest of the issues so I can fully read the series? Is there a website link you have where I can purchase them?
Thanks in advance!
Mike
Bobby Curnow
01-23-2016, 03:10 PM
The short answer is yes, there are a lot of characters to juggle, and I think some, like let's say Bludgeon for example, haven't been as developed as I would like as a result. I'd say that we shouldn't introduce so many characters, but at the same time I think each one has served a purpose that couldn't necessarily be filled by another character. And it's okay for not all of the characters to be developed equally. Though I do worry that the Turtles themselves get a little lost in the crowd sometimes.
The easy solution is to simply not focus in on characters for long stretches of time. We have long term plans for characters like Null and Stockman, but it's not necessary that we touch in with them for a year or more. Basically, if they are not actively needed in a story, we can put characters on a shelf and bring them back when needed. It's the same with any long running comic property. Our cast is small compared to say, Spider Man, and it's okay when they don't have the Vulture around for a year or two, to use an example.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-23-2016, 03:12 PM
Hey Bobby, maybe this isn't your department, but I'm quite curious as to why the Mirage TMNT reprints have been colorized when the original books weren't: what was the main impetus for doing so? Just that color books typically sell better than B&W and that B&W isn't really done anymore?
MikeandRaph87
01-23-2016, 03:17 PM
Is that why Baxter Stockman seems to have just gone into hiding? I have been wondering what happened to him as he was not defeated and just seemed to slip away.
Of all the characters out there, who would you like to see appear that has not? I am not trying to be sneaky and asking for who might we see in the near future.
Bobby Curnow
01-23-2016, 03:52 PM
Hey Bobby, maybe this isn't your department, but I'm quite curious as to why the Mirage TMNT reprints have been colorized when the original books weren't: what was the main impetus for doing so? Just that color books typically sell better than B&W and that B&W isn't really done anymore?
I don't know for sure, but yeah, I believe the thinking was that coloring would sell better and make it an option for folks who already had the B & W.
Bobby Curnow
01-23-2016, 03:55 PM
Is that why Baxter Stockman seems to have just gone into hiding? I have been wondering what happened to him as he was not defeated and just seemed to slip away.
Of all the characters out there, who would you like to see appear that has not? I am not trying to be sneaky and asking for who might we see in the near future.
Baxter realized he had nothing more to gain by sticking around the Foot Clan in #49, so yeah, he got while the getting was good.
I have a couple: Wingnut & Screwloose, Pizza Face and Cudley the Cowlick. All are great designs and I think would be very fun characters.
CyberCubed
01-23-2016, 04:58 PM
Are there any plans to revisit the Battle Nexus concept from the 2014 annual? Or is that a story saved for a future annual?
mrmaczaps
01-23-2016, 05:57 PM
Baxter realized he had nothing more to gain by sticking around the Foot Clan in #49, so yeah, he got while the getting was good.
I have a couple: Wingnut & Screwloose, Pizza Face and Cudley the Cowlick. All are great designs and I think would be very fun characters.
Cudly would be awesome! Would this mean, if he is used, that you could potentially do a "Turtles Forever" type story where the IDW Turtles visit their Mirage/Image counterparts?
Because that would be amazing!
Thanks again.
Utrommaniac
01-23-2016, 06:39 PM
Will we ever learn more about Traxus and Quanin's "long list of failures"?
CyberCubed
01-23-2016, 11:05 PM
Something else I'm curious about, what happened to Traag and Granitor after the attack on Burnow Island? The last we see of them on panel is them walking away after their fight with Koya/Bludgeon, but we don't see them teleport or anything...just walk off. That was back in issue...37 or so? Its been a while.
Obviously with Krang under custody of the Neutrinos, Burnow Island now home to the Utroms under stasis, and where Fugitoid and Leatherhead worked on fixing Don's shell together, they can't still be there either. Or else they'd be causing trouble.
Did they teleport back to Dimension X off-screen or something?
MikeandRaph87
01-23-2016, 11:13 PM
Something else I'm curious about, what happened to Traag and Granitor after the attack on Burnow Island? The last we see of them on panel is them walking away after their fight with Koya/Bludgeon, but we don't see them teleport or anything...just walk off. That was back in issue...37 or so? Its been a while.
Obviously with Krang under custody of the Neutrinos, Burnow Island now home to the Utroms under stasis, and where Fugitoid and Leatherhead worked on fixing Don's shell together, they can't still be there either. Or else they'd be causing trouble.
Did they teleport back to Dimension X off-screen or something?
The two rock soldiers are slated to appear at the end of #56 and in #57 as he villains of the next arc. I suspect all of your related questions will be answered by the time the arc is over. I assume the arc is #56-#59.
http://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/tmnt-blog/
CyberCubed
01-23-2016, 11:14 PM
The two rock soldiers are slated to appear at the end of #56 and in #57 as he villains of the next arc. I suspect all of your related questions will be answered by the time the arc is over. I assume the arc is #56-#59.
http://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/tmnt-blog/
Oh really? Thanks, I didn't know that. Looks like I'm getting to see them sooner than expected.
Bobby Curnow
01-24-2016, 01:12 PM
Are there any plans to revisit the Battle Nexus concept from the 2014 annual? Or is that a story saved for a future annual?
No plans at this time.
Bobby Curnow
01-24-2016, 01:14 PM
Will we ever learn more about Traxus and Quanin's "long list of failures"?
Maybe, no plans. That was just the type of thing any rebel would say about the establishment he was fighting, I think. Wasn't really meant to refer to specific things we had in mind.
Bobby Curnow
01-24-2016, 01:16 PM
Something else I'm curious about, what happened to Traag and Granitor after the attack on Burnow Island? The last we see of them on panel is them walking away after their fight with Koya/Bludgeon, but we don't see them teleport or anything...just walk off. That was back in issue...37 or so? Its been a while.
Obviously with Krang under custody of the Neutrinos, Burnow Island now home to the Utroms under stasis, and where Fugitoid and Leatherhead worked on fixing Don's shell together, they can't still be there either. Or else they'd be causing trouble.
Did they teleport back to Dimension X off-screen or something?
Yes, we last saw them at the end of "Attack on Technodrome" in TMNT #44 I think.
I think declaring them "villains" in an upcoming story line is making some pretty major assumptions.
ProphetofGanja
01-24-2016, 02:05 PM
Was this the first script where they planned for the Turtles to be aliens in the movie, and Shredder was intended to be Eric Sachs rather than Oroku Saki? The whole movie had hasty re-writes (which is why the film turned out to be so lackluster, worst TMNT movie ever), and the original Blue Door script was posted online where the Turtles were in fact...written as aliens and Shredder was Eric Sachs and turned out to be an alien too.
I'm glad there isn't any movie tie-in comic especially if that means we lose a mini in the IDW universe.
I've been re-reading the first year of IDW lately, and I know this has come up in the past, but has there been any talk about revisiting the human lives of the Turtles in Feudal Japan in a flashback issue? A lot of people are still curious what the Turtles human Japanese names were, something that still hasn't been revealed after all this time.
It also would be interesting to see how Yoshi and his sons survived in the mountains for a while before Saki eventually caught up to them and killed them. As I said I just re-read issue 5 so I'm just reminded how much I liked the reincarnation bit and am curious to see if their human lives will be revisited.
No plans at this time.
can we expect an annual this year? they seem to come out in even-numbered years
Bobby Curnow
01-24-2016, 03:42 PM
can we expect an annual this year? they seem to come out in even-numbered years
Ha, no. None planned in the near term. Kevin is working hard on some new creator-owned stuff.
Can you legally use Zanramon and Traximus? I ask because for some reason both of those characters were renamed in the 2012 cartoon.
Bobby Curnow
01-26-2016, 12:27 PM
Can you legally use Zanramon and Traximus? I ask because for some reason both of those characters were renamed in the 2012 cartoon.
I don't know offhand-- I'd have to check the list, and i'm out of the office today.
Kingoji
01-26-2016, 12:30 PM
When the IDW Collection reaches that point, will the Ghostbusters crossover be... ahem... contained ?
neatoman
01-26-2016, 05:51 PM
So in the near future, can we expect more orginal characters, more classic characters or more focus on already introduced characters?
Bobby Curnow
01-27-2016, 12:51 AM
When the IDW Collection reaches that point, will the Ghostbusters crossover be... ahem... contained ?
That's a good question. I would guess not, as that would mean we'd need to split the revenue again. Not sure though.
Bobby Curnow
01-27-2016, 12:51 AM
So in the near future, can we expect more orginal characters, more classic characters or more focus on already introduced characters?
All three, fairly evenly distributed, I think.
Kingoji
01-27-2016, 03:48 AM
Thanks, Bobby!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.