The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   If the next movie were an adaptation, what would you like to see. (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=24381)

turkishproverb 06-21-2008 04:24 AM

If the next movie were an adaptation, what would you like to see.
 
I was wondering what everyone thought would make a good storyline.

For my part, I think Return to new York would be a good choice, given it could be done as a pseudo sequel to movie 1, or 2, or 4, or all of them, or none with similar effectiveness, and require minimal, if any prelude.

It would also keep some of the more Iconic elements in the turtles without massive rewrites. (shredder, for example)


After Shredders final death, a sequel in the form of City at War could begin being advertised with a Dark KNIGHT style guerrilla campaign. (Welcome to the War posters, fake newscasts, etc) could be worked in easily, due to the destabilization of the NY underworld after his disappearance.

Toonami Tom 06-21-2008 09:32 AM

Very good ideas. I would also like to see a Return to New York movie.

Mr._Mutant_Man 06-21-2008 04:24 PM

I guess after Shredder the next thing to do would be to have the Turtles face Baxter Stockman.

The Triceratrons would be cool too.

ToTheNines 06-21-2008 06:11 PM

I say nay to RTNY, I mean we've got the comic version then cartoon and it was loosely adapted into the first movie, makin it into a CGI movie would be pushin it.

The origin would be nice for Direct to DVD, but... ya know....

I voted for "Rise of Baxter", it would have to have more elements to the story than the comics have, but I feel if made into a move it would be best for Don, who got hosed in TMNT 07.

Roseangelo 06-21-2008 06:59 PM

TMNT really just needs to get away from adaptations in general. The same stories keep getting recycled again and again and again. It's fun and all, but all it does is prevent NEW stories from being created. It prevents the TMNT universe from expanding beyond the core shell of Volume 1 (not completely unlike what is expressed in this thread). Aren't you people tired of that yet?

TMNT needs to move forward and blast off, not stay stagnant.

Raph'N'Roll 06-21-2008 08:53 PM

Well TMNT had a "new" story but wasn't up to much, I mean come on, what Turtles fan wouldn't want to see a accurate adaptation of RTNY, I'd love to see this in movie form, it's a story I'd never get tired of!
Plus there'd be a ton of action and carnage, which TMNT lacked.

Roseangelo 06-21-2008 10:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RAPH 'N' ROLL (Post 617301)
Well TMNT had a "new" story but wasn't up to much, I mean come on, what Turtles fan wouldn't want to see a accurate adaptation of RTNY, I'd love to see this in movie form, it's a story I'd never get tired of!
Plus there'd be a ton of action and carnage, which TMNT lacked.

TMNT may not have been the BEST story, but I think it was a really good move to go with a NEW story. I have great appreciation for that, really.

Instead of using adaptations as a crutch, as is continually done, why not focus on making BRAND NEW stories - full of action and carnage (and heart!).

And I don't just mean this with movies, but also with TV and comics. They need to let go of the past and start building a fantastic future with room to revisit the past once in awhile. I'm tired of the focus on Utroms and Triceratons. Show me that the great potential seen in TMNT can be harvested into something truly, truly great.

As it stands, I am losing faith in the TMNT's ability to be part of any new story.

turkishproverb 06-21-2008 11:08 PM

Don't get me wrong Rose, I was just saying IF it was an adaptation, what do you think would make sense and why. I'd love to see more origional stuff (heck, movie 3 wasn't as bad as people say)


Although I didn't really see as much RTNY in the first movie as you did, to be honest.

Roseangelo 06-21-2008 11:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by turkishproverb (Post 617323)
Although I didn't really see as much RTNY in the first movie as you did, to be honest.

Was this towards me or someone else? I haven't seen one bit of RTNY in any movie.

Dragon Turtle 06-21-2008 11:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RAPH 'N' ROLL (Post 617301)
Well TMNT had a "new" story but wasn't up to much, I mean come on, what Turtles fan wouldn't want to see a accurate adaptation of RTNY, I'd love to see this in movie form, it's a story I'd never get tired of!
Plus there'd be a ton of action and carnage, which TMNT lacked.

TMNT did rehash the Leo vs Raph fight from RTNY, which quite frankly is the last time I hope to see a Leo vs Raph fight, the whole sibling rivalry angle has gotten a bit well-worn.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617314)
TMNT may not have been the BEST story, but I think it was a really good move to go with a NEW story. I have great appreciation for that, really.

Instead of using adaptations as a crutch, as is continually done, why not focus on making BRAND NEW stories - full of action and carnage (and heart!).

And I don't just mean this with movies, but also with TV and comics. They need to let go of the past and start building a fantastic future with room to revisit the past once in awhile. I'm tired of the focus on Utroms and Triceratons. Show me that the great potential seen in TMNT can be harvested into something truly, truly great.

As it stands, I am losing faith in the TMNT's ability to be part of any new story.


Although I can't say the same about the comics, the new movie and the upcoming TMNT:BttS show some signs of moving in new directions, Laird seemed pretty happy nothing from the upcoming tv season would be adapted from the comics.

Roseangelo 06-21-2008 11:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 617328)
TMNT did rehash the Leo vs Raph fight from RTNY, which quite frankly is the last time I hope to see a Leo vs Raph fight, the whole sibling rivalry angle has gotten a bit well-worn.

I would disagree with this. TMNT had a Leo vs. Raph fight, but it really didn't have any similarities to the one in RTNY.

Although I do agree that Raph and Leo being constantly at each other's throats is getting old.

Andrew NDB 06-22-2008 01:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617314)
TMNT may not have been the BEST story, but I think it was a really good move to go with a NEW story. I have great appreciation for that, really.

Credit where it is due. Yes, I agree. Kevin Munroe & co.'s willingness to stick to their guns about "No Shredder, he's done... we're doing something new here" I was very impressed with. Absolutely the right way to go about it. Some other random filmmaker might just go, "Ehh... I bet kids and the cartoon nostalgiacs miss Shredder and Technodromes and cowabungas from those 80s children cartoons, let's try to get back to that."

The only problem was... what they came up with instead was -- eh, I better stop right there.

And no, the Leo vs. Raph scene in TMNT Part 4 bore no resemblance to the one in the RTNY. Raphael actually K.O.ed him in the comics, to state just one difference.

To answer the main topic of the thread, I think none of the above. A new movie at this point pretty much needs to be a Ground Zero reboot, so let's go back to TMNT Vol. 1, #1. Flesh that out. Obviously if you just take the events in the issue itself, you're not going to end up with an hour and a half movie, so that gives them room for... other stuff. Perhaps events could be rearranged so that we actually move linearly through the story... we begin in Japan, then move through the years as we see the TMNT grow older creating a dichotomy while we see Saki's ascent in the Foot Clan (back and forth between the Turtles growing up/training and Saki rising to power and becoming the Shredder), finally being rewarded with the NYC Foot, back and forth, until we arrive in the present day... when Splinter finally tells the TMNT that he has trained them from their mutation to one day assassinate Oroku Saki... and then the movie shifts into high gear.

Dragon Turtle 06-22-2008 03:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617336)
I would disagree with this. TMNT had a Leo vs. Raph fight, but it really didn't have any similarities to the one in RTNY.

Actually, I meant just the act of Leo and Raph coming to actual physical blows, not that it was an actual recreation of the "RTNY" fight, I should have worded it better, my mistake. :)


Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 617348)
Credit where it is due. Yes, I agree. Kevin Munroe & co.'s willingness to stick to their guns about "No Shredder, he's done... we're doing something new here" I was very impressed with. Absolutely the right way to go about it. Some other random filmmaker might just go, "Ehh... I bet kids and the cartoon nostalgiacs miss Shredder and Technodromes and cowabungas from those 80s children cartoons, let's try to get back to that."

The only problem was... what they came up with instead was -- eh, I better stop right there.

And no, the Leo vs. Raph scene in TMNT Part 4 bore no resemblance to the one in the RTNY. Raphael actually K.O.ed him in the comics, to state just one difference.

To answer the main topic of the thread, I think none of the above. A new movie at this point pretty much needs to be a Ground Zero reboot, so let's go back to TMNT Vol. 1, #1. Flesh that out. Obviously if you just take the events in the issue itself, you're not going to end up with an hour and a half movie, so that gives them room for... other stuff. Perhaps events could be rearranged so that we actually move linearly through the story... we begin in Japan, then move through the years as we see the TMNT grow older creating a dichotomy while we see Saki's ascent in the Foot Clan (back and forth between the Turtles growing up/training and Saki rising to power and becoming the Shredder), finally being rewarded with the NYC Foot, back and forth, until we arrive in the present day... when Splinter finally tells the TMNT that he has trained them from their mutation to one day assassinate Oroku Saki... and then the movie shifts into high gear.


Personally, I'm not all that fired up to see another origin story, it was a good thing that TMNT simply chose to bypass it. A retelling of the first TMNT story would be perfect for a straight to dvd project, but for bigger project such as a movie, I would prefer something new or at least something that drives the TMNT universe forward.

Although you can always incorporate a Shredder/Oroku Saki origin in a new story, despite his stature as the turtles arch-nemesis, he always felt like a bit too much of a mustache twirling pantomine villain, he could use the extra character development.

Andrew NDB 06-22-2008 05:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 617354)
Personally, I'm not all that fired up to see another origin story,

Me neither. It's not for you or I, but for fresh new fans (the only thing a proper TMNT, ground zero can really bank on). The last time we saw the TMNT origin on the big screen was 18 years ago... so unless their target audience is that coveted 30-60 year old demographic (...), it's not exactly without reason to take a new TMNT origin in stride at this point.

Dragon Turtle 06-22-2008 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 617361)
Me neither. It's not for you or I, but for fresh new fans (the only thing a proper TMNT, ground zero can really bank on). The last time we saw the TMNT origin on the big screen was 18 years ago... so unless their target audience is that coveted 30-60 year old demographic (...), it's not exactly without reason to take a new TMNT origin in stride at this point.

I believe fresh fans (people who still have zero idea who the TMNT are, even after a movie was released only a year ago) from the 13-40 demographic, probably are not going to care a great deal if a TMNT movie is based around their origins from issue #1. If there is a dire need to revisit their origin, then you can just insert a cliffnotes version via flashback in a new movie, which would probably take less then ten minutes.

Since it was set up in the the last movie, I can see a semi-adaption of CAW/RTNY being the subject of a new movie, especially now that Imagi appears to be out of the picture, they were the ones who rejected Mirage's CAW pitch, or at a least a straight-forward version of it.

Roseangelo 06-22-2008 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 617397)
I can see a semi-adaption of CAW/RTNY being the subject of a new movie, especially now that Imagi appears to be out of the picture, they were the ones who rejected Mirage's CAW pitch, or at a least a straight-forward version of it.

We have no idea what Mirage pitched. Was it something CAW-like? Possibly, but no confirmation on what it was exactly has ever been given.

Dragon Turtle 06-22-2008 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617398)
We have no idea what Mirage pitched. Was it something CAW-like? Possibly, but no confirmation on what it was exactly has ever been given.

Murphy did say that while CAW was a possibility for a sequel storyline, CAW (or at least a pure CAW adaptation)was losing favor, so CAW had to have been pitched by someone.

Roseangelo 06-22-2008 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 617451)
Murphy did say that while CAW was a possibility for a sequel storyline, CAW (or at least a pure CAW adaptation)was losing favor, so CAW had to have been pitched by someone.

Like I said, it's likely something CAW-ish may have been pitched, but it's not a conclusion we can draw as fact.

Dragon Turtle 06-22-2008 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617453)
Like I said, it's likely something CAW-ish may have been pitched, but it's not a conclusion we can draw as fact.

Basically, I don't believe we will be seeing a straight-forward adaption of any Mirage story, if any story from the comics are adapted, they will be modified from the original source material. It's possible that the "pure" CAW adaption was killed off by Mirage themselves, before it ever made it to the official pitch stage.

Andrew NDB 06-22-2008 10:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 617397)
I believe fresh fans (people who still have zero idea who the TMNT are, even after a movie was released only a year ago) from the 13-40 demographic, probably are not going to care a great deal if a TMNT movie is based around their origins from issue #1.

You're missing the point entirely.

turkishproverb 06-22-2008 11:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617325)
Was this towards me or someone else? I haven't seen one bit of RTNY in any movie.

It was adressing TO the Nines comment that RTNY was basically adapted in the first movie..

Dragon Turtle 06-22-2008 11:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 617484)
You're missing the point entirely.

And what point would that be? At this point there is no need for a reboot, nor is one required to bring in new fans, as long as the movie is good and well promoted that will be the best way to bring in new fans.

Revan 06-23-2008 04:41 AM

http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/b...ics/reboot.jpg
Let's reboot this baby! And do it right.

thebrownranger 06-23-2008 05:07 PM

Right now the best choice would be city at war. Return to ny has somewhat been done in the first movie.

odupianist 06-24-2008 08:31 AM

I would like an original idea as well with throwbacks to some original source material. Whether they mention it, show it in the background or whatever.

Roseangelo 06-24-2008 09:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebrownranger (Post 617633)
Right now the best choice would be city at war. Return to ny has somewhat been done in the first movie.

Nothing about the first movie is similar to RTNY. :|

The first movie takes inspiration from the story arc from Leo #1 + 10-11, which unfortunately doesn't have an easy to refer to name, but that's what it is.

NameGoesHere1066 06-24-2008 10:30 AM

this makes me mad! I want CAW damn it!! :evil:

ToTheNines 06-24-2008 03:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 617786)
Nothing about the first movie is similar to RTNY. :|

The first movie takes inspiration from the story arc from Leo #1 + 10-11, which unfortunately doesn't have an easy to refer to name, but that's what it is.

You're jokin right? After the fight at April place (Leo #1 + 10) they run to the farm and chill for a while (11). After that they... return to new york (ironically enough: RTNY). They end up fighting the foot and then Shredder on a roof top and kill him.

Obviously it was a very loose adaption (if you even call it that) of those issues, but there is no denying that the basic elements of them were incorperated into that segment of the movie.

Roseangelo 06-24-2008 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 617846)
You're jokin right? After the fight at April place (Leo #1 + 10) they run to the farm and chill for a while (11). After that they... return to new york (ironically enough: RTNY). They end up fighting the foot and then Shredder on a roof top and kill him.

Obviously it was a very loose adaption (if you even call it that) of those issues, but there is no denying that the basic elements of them were incorperated into that segment of the movie.

I have to heartily disagree. Yeah, of course they return to New York, but that action alone does not make for any resemblance to Return to New York from the comics. If anything, the rooftop battle mirrors TMNT #1 more closely than anything else. All of the other elements don't come from any of the comics.

shuriken 06-24-2008 11:04 PM

Out of those a City at War movie would be bithchin. But as stated before a new idea with a fresh slate (by that I mean a non adaptation that includes Villians from the comics but doesn't rely solely on a particular set of comics and or a comic). For example, use a Baxter Karai Team up against a rebel Foot Group which also includes the Purple Dragons with the Turtles getting into the mix, which also incorperates City At War elements.
Or April getting a Job with Baxter and the creation of the mousers. Baxter sells thousands of Mouser units to eliminate the huge mouse/rat problem in NY. But he also controls the mousers to steal millions of dollars and hold the city ransom. Thus attracts the attention of Both the Turtles and a new villain, the Rat King!(these are just an idea so don't hurt me). Or they could use more aliens and aztec gods or whatever...

Spitfire 06-25-2008 03:28 AM

After seeing what I have and experiencing more about film making and the process of it all what us fans want isn't out of question but at the same time it's not some super easy task either.

If we want any of these story lines adapted then it would need to at least be a PG-13 film I would have to say. For that to happen we need a demographic large enough to accept a PG-13 turtles film, not going to happen. So the only route, and smart one to go in my opinion, is the independent route. A film funded by Mirage and companies like BAVAC that give out funding. They did movies like "Army Of Darkness" on shoe string budgets and they still came out with a film that had good creature effects in most cases and holds up just fine today. The same can be done with turtles if the effort was put forward.

Sounds retarded and out of the question but it's true. And if the world wants to accept a PG-13 turtles movie, or hell they could do R if they went the independent route, then the major movie studios might second guess all this dicking around they've been doing with the series and allow it to break out of the kids medium. There are plenty of independent films made today with low budgets that have great effects, like the ones needed to have four turtles for example, and the acting isn't half bad either. Really depends, you can get big names to do films like this as well very easily because a lot of Hollywood actors and actresses like doing movies like this because it;'s artistic and their not just making it for a buck.

It's all marketing, you have to know the audience your writing for. I have a few films I want to do currently that I'm writing. I know for a fact one of them will never see wide release if I go forward with it because it deals with subjects people are uneasy about. Others however I could see getting wide release because it's a lot more light hearted and something a wider audience would find entertaining.

The other route is out sourcing. Let a country like Europe or New Zealand take care of it. Over there you can do all kinds of stuff in pictures your not allowed to here. Things are much more accepted. A rated R turtles movie might fly in a place like that. Course over here it'd be limited release still but it would still be a way to get a big budget turtles movie just not made here. Special effects and movie making in general is cheaper in places like that so movies that look great come out of those countries with half the budgets of Hollywood's movies but the same if not better quality.

That's just the way I see things. Obviously this will never ever happen because I don't see Mirage, or Laird, taking the risks involved in trying something this bold. It's a loyalty based movie in my opinion. They could risk it all and even if it bombs at least the fans got what they wanted but if they try hard enough and make it well enough it could not only become an instant cult classic but generate enough interest to harbor a sequel. It's happened before it can happen again.

Sage Ninja 06-25-2008 12:04 PM

I think what needs to happen is the independent rout just like Spit just described, I think it's the only way a decent TMNT movie will ever be given a chance and done right. Although I wouldn't be opposed to it being done over seas like in New Zealand. Maybe you should get in contact with Laird and send them your post Spitfire666xXxXx.

Spitfire 06-25-2008 02:19 PM

As good of an idea as that might be Laird would listen to anyone else before me. I pried at him pretty hard on his blog and I'm sure he doesn't like me too much for that. He reads this message board he will see my post most likely if he likes the idea one would hope he might run with it. It's good to see someone, hopefully others, agree this could work.

SHREDDER-X 08-18-2008 11:25 PM

I would love to see the Turtles in Space/Triceraton/Fugitoid saga. Lets put the turtle sci/fi elements in a movie for a change, instead of the old turtles vs. the Foot.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.