The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Which is worse? TMNT 3 or TMNT 2014? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=48791)

mexichrist83 08-10-2014 02:56 PM

Which is worse? TMNT 3 or TMNT 2014?
 
Now that the new movie is out I started to become really curious about which TMNT movie is now considered the worst (amongst people who did NOT like the 2014 movie).

I'm going to just say that I think 2014 was worse. Don't get me wrong. I still think 3 is a bad movie but it was more enjoyable as a TMNT movie (or a movie in general) than the 2014 movie.

TerranigmaFreak 08-10-2014 03:19 PM

TMNT 2 is the worse.

Warhorse 08-10-2014 03:23 PM

TMNT 3 is what happens when you absolutely pander to soccer moms and studio execs.

TerranigmaFreak 08-10-2014 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 1328478)
TMNT 3 is what happens when you absolutely pander to soccer moms and studio execs.

They got to use their weapons in Turtles 3 though.

Leo656 08-10-2014 03:38 PM

I'm curious to see how it ends up in my own head. Although I do chuckle at TMNT 3. Tossing aside the fact it was made super-cheap - sometimes, you just have to roll with that, unfortunately - the worst thing about it just was that it was pretty boring. A lot of stuff happens, but nothing really happens, y'know? It just kind of meanders around until its over, the ending comes without much struggle or conflict at all, and then they throw in the whole "Y'know, what? F*** Master Splinter and those other guys, let's just stay here and keep screwing up history!" angle in at the last second, to try and create some artificial conflict right before the end. I don't think it's "bad", exactly, as much as its entirely unimpressive.

I think the new one might be worse from an entirely different direction, but I don't know for sure yet.

CyberCubed 08-10-2014 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 1328478)
TMNT 3 is what happens when you absolutely pander to soccer moms and studio execs.

How on earth did you come to that conclusion?

Mona_Lisa 08-10-2014 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TerranigmaFreak (Post 1328472)
TMNT 2 is the worse.

I loved TMNT 2! I liked the new movie also, was it everything I hoped for? No.... But it was still good!!!!:D Probably would have been better if I had not read ALL the spoilers! lol.
TMNT 3 was the worse out of all TMNT movies imo

Warhorse 08-10-2014 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TerranigmaFreak (Post 1328480)
They got to use their weapons in Turtles 3 though.

Not much. I remember some intro where they are practicing, and Leo using his swords like scissors to cut off some guy's ponytail, but that's all i remember. Mikey got to use his chucks against a villain?

THGhost 08-10-2014 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TerranigmaFreak (Post 1328472)
TMNT 2 is the worse.

..........
Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1328500)
How on earth did you come to that conclusion?


CyberCubed 08-10-2014 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 1328505)
Not much. I remember some intro where they are practicing, and Leo using his swords like scissors to cut off some guy's ponytail, but that's all i remember. Mikey got to use his chucks against a villain?

There are 5 big fight scenes throughout the film.

Warhorse 08-10-2014 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1328513)
There are 5 big fight scenes throughout the film.

5? Are you sure? With the Turtles?

Commenter 42 08-10-2014 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1328494)
I'm curious to see how it ends up in my own head. Although I do chuckle at TMNT 3. Tossing aside the fact it was made super-cheap - sometimes, you just have to roll with that, unfortunately - the worst thing about it just was that it was pretty boring. A lot of stuff happens, but nothing really happens, y'know? It just kind of meanders around until its over, the ending comes without much struggle or conflict at all, and then they throw in the whole "Y'know, what? F*** Master Splinter and those other guys, let's just stay here and keep screwing up history!" angle in at the last second, to try and create some artificial conflict right before the end. I don't think it's "bad", exactly, as much as its entirely unimpressive.

I think the new one might be worse from an entirely different direction, but I don't know for sure yet.

A friend saw it last night. I got a blow by blow from start to finish, and man, I can't wait until you see it. The best part was, this friend was trying to convince me how great it was, and I just kept laughing.
Nice girl, but jeebus, after this, I wouldn't trust her to boil water unsupervised.

Leo656 08-10-2014 04:21 PM

It's very odd, some of the things some cats are most excited about, are things that make me just cringe. I'unno man.

It'll be interesting when I do see it. The wife isn't looking forward to it at all so it might not even be worth going in theaters if she's gonna be cranky. I'unno, we'll see. She actually likes the third movie, but not a whole lot.

Stugehen 08-10-2014 04:22 PM

Reading the various threads I would've suspected the poll to be closer. I guess the few who said 2014 was worse are just VERY vocal about it.

Mr._Mutant_Man 08-10-2014 04:30 PM

TMNT III is still worse. With all its flaws, the new TMNT at least holds your attention. Even as a kid, I remember watching TMNT and wishing one of the bad guys from the cartoon was in it.

Purse Grabbin Puke 08-10-2014 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commenter 42 (Post 1328544)
A friend saw it last night. I got a blow by blow from start to finish, and man, I can't wait until you see it. The best part was, this friend was trying to convince me how great it was, and I just kept laughing.
Nice girl, but jeebus, after this, I wouldn't trust her to boil water unsupervised.

You really have no credibility in your opinion on the new TMNT because you haven't seen it. But I guarantee even if you did see it, you would just force yourself to hate it.

TMNT 3 is SO bad. How does the puppetry and technology of the Turtle's faces get WORSE with time?! The opening to the movie feels like a sitcom. Overall it just feels like a made for TV movie.

And TMNT 2 was the one they pandered to soccer moms.

chrisdude 08-10-2014 04:44 PM

This poll is absurd. But I'm glad the results are out there. Everyone who likes the movie or dislikes the movie complains that they're being oppressed. It's nice to see polls.

Hawkeye 08-10-2014 04:48 PM

I voted Turtles III.. even though it's still awesome.

Aaronardo 08-10-2014 04:52 PM

TMNT III because TMNT 2014 does NOT suck.

Cipher 08-10-2014 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commenter 42 (Post 1328544)
A friend saw it last night. I got a blow by blow from start to finish, and man, I can't wait until you see it. The best part was, this friend was trying to convince me how great it was, and I just kept laughing.
Nice girl, but jeebus, after this, I wouldn't trust her to boil water unsupervised.

Sometimes a friend or acquaintance will start telling me about how much they like a certain film/series/other fiction and I'll start going through the mental checks of "Why am I friends with you? How much do I value our relationship?"

Not a great place to be. I'm sorry.

Re: thread: I'll let you know when I catch 2014 on Netflix or something.

TerranigmaFreak 08-10-2014 05:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by floydbanks7 (Post 1328573)
And TMNT 2 was the one they pandered to soccer moms.

That reminds me though. Did anyone see the turtles were their weapons in this movie? I see Leonardo use his sword a few seconds in the sewers in the final battle. Raphael used his Sai to block for Leonardo. Donatello used his Bo a little in the sewer fight and popping the car, and Michaelangelo used his nunchucks to grab on from falling. That's about all I can remember about the weapons being used in the fights.

mexichrist83 08-10-2014 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrisdude (Post 1328591)
This poll is absurd. But I'm glad the results are out there. Everyone who likes the movie or dislikes the movie complains that they're being oppressed. It's nice to see polls.

How is this an absurd poll? It's a legitimate query I have for people who did not like the new movie. The poll is not going to accurate because while this poll is mostly for people who did not like the new movie I know it's going to be thrown off by people who did like the new movie and will vote for TMNT 3 just so the 2014 movie won't have as many votes.

This isn't a general "did you think the new movie sucks?" thread.

nelodiavolo 08-10-2014 05:09 PM

Hands down 3 was the worst move thus far. I remember seeing it way back when it came out as a kid and instantly saw how much worse the puppetry was compared to the original two. The plot was the definition of forgettable. Even though its terrible, I still watch it from time to time just to have a good laugh.

The 2014 movie actually surprised me. I went in knowing of all the negative media and forum hype. Other than a few gripes with the pacing with the origin, I thoroughly enjoyed it. Can't wait for the sequel.

Commenter 42 08-10-2014 05:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by floydbanks7 (Post 1328573)
You really have no credibility in your opinion on the new TMNT because you haven't seen it. But I guarantee even if you did see it, you would just force yourself to hate it.

TMNT 3 is SO bad. How does the puppetry and technology of the Turtle's faces get WORSE with time?! The opening to the movie feels like a sitcom. Overall it just feels like a made for TV movie.

And TMNT 2 was the one they pandered to soccer moms.

Now you want to Argue? And we were doing so well!

I really wish people would get my point. I just don't need to see it. I've seen enough movies to be able to look at a trailer an know what it's going to be.
There isn't anything in the trailers that I find appealing. Not one.. shred.:lol:
The real point of not going to see the movie, is to not give them any more money. I'll eventually see it...but I refuse to pay for it on principal. I will not support the continuation of this iteration. i will shout it down every chance I get. If you liked it, that's great and all, but this is not a TMNT movie in my opinion. I don't think I should go to the theater just so I can speak to specifics. It won't change anything for me, and in doing so, i'm telling them, please, make MORE. It goes against everything i've said.

As I mentioned in another thread, a friend went last night. She recounted everything. It's actually worse than I'd thought.

I did as you said I should, with both MOS and TDKR. I was opposed to both films, but I figured, maybe i'm wrong? Maybe I'm just not giving it a chance.

MOS made me so incredibly angry I wanted to beat the **** out of Snyder. I paid to be insulted.
"evolution always wins" says the villain.
What in the hell does that mean? Evolution is a process, not a bloody casino. Evolution doesn't win anything, any more than brewing a coffee "wins".
The Christian iconography was brow beating, and Amy Adams is no Lois Lane.
Worst of all, baby Kal-el absorbed a skull of alien DNA. Those are just a tiny handful of what this movie did wrong.

I rated the films we've gotten so far. TMNT 1990 is the best of them, BUT it's about 50% of what a live action TMNTcould be.
SOTO isn't great, I know that, I have eyes...lol.
TMNT3 is garbage I couldn't watch it all in one sitting. it's really bad, and the animatronics are bad.

But if you really wanted to compare the quality of the films, you can't judge effects separated by decades. That's rather unfair. All you can do is judge how the tools were used, and to what effect.

Let's try and keep the discussion civil. I think we can do that.

Bry 08-10-2014 05:10 PM

They're both badly-written and badly-directed movies. Both of their plots are stupid and often illogical, not even holding up within their own "worlds". They're kind of equally bad in very different ways. But the overall cheapness of TMNT3 gives it that kinda "so bad it's hilarious" quality that the new movie doesn't have. I'm more forgiving of movies that are bad on a relatively low budget than ones that are bad on a high one. There's much more of a cheese factor that's pretty entertaining itself. TMNT3 movie is a movie you can watch and laugh at. IMO, that gives it a lot more re-watch value than the new one, which is just... kinda dull and obnoxious, but in a way I can't find entertaining.

Slap-Happy 08-10-2014 05:23 PM

The new TMNT isn't boring like III is.

ABrown 08-10-2014 05:32 PM

The thing is, it's kind of unfair to compare the 2014 film to the third TMNT movie. What it really should be compared to is the first TMNT movie from 1990. And while I haven't seen the newest film, I'm willing to bet (based on what I've seen in the commercials and previews, as well as from having seen the first three Transformers films) that it's no where near as enjoyable as the first movie was.

THGhost 08-10-2014 06:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by floydbanks7 (Post 1328573)
You really have no credibility in your opinion on the new TMNT because you haven't seen it. But I guarantee even if you did see it, you would just force yourself to hate it.

TMNT 3 is SO bad. How does the puppetry and technology of the Turtle's faces get WORSE with time?!

Because Jim Henson died, perhaps? I dunno, that's the only reason I've heard people say. Anyone else know differently? Please clue me in, because I'd like to know why the suits in III were worse also.

Commenter 42 08-10-2014 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by THGhost (Post 1328709)
Because Jim Henson died, perhaps? I dunno, that's the only reason I've heard people say. Anyone else know differently? Please clue me in, because I'd like to know why the suits in III were worse also.

Henson's company didn't do the suits in 2 or 3.
those were the days when sequels had smaller budgets than the original.
They talk about it in the Turtles doc a bit. "Let's do it all again, but for less, because we'll make a lot less money on the sequel."

Leo656 08-10-2014 06:19 PM

They really went over a steep cliff really fast with 2 and 3. I mean, the first one was cheap, but the others were cheeeeeap.

I mean, not like "Superman IV" cheap, but they'd have to be trying to fail to go that far down.

Warhorse 08-10-2014 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TerranigmaFreak (Post 1328620)
That reminds me though. Did anyone see the turtles were their weapons in this movie? I see Leonardo use his sword a few seconds in the sewers in the final battle. Raphael used his Sai to block for Leonardo. Donatello used his Bo a little in the sewer fight and popping the car, and Michaelangelo used his nunchucks to grab on from falling. That's about all I can remember about the weapons being used in the fights.

There were several instances. I might get fuzzy with my memory, but Mikey used his chucks against Shredder, and used them to deflect the daggers being flung at them. Raph as well, had tried to use his sais in the his solo fight with Shredder, and used them to block flying blades and poisoned darts. Donny and Leo used their weapons the most. But it's hard to see, because of the shaky cam and the quick edits.

Commenter 42 08-10-2014 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1328723)
They really went over a steep cliff really fast with 2 and 3. I mean, the first one was cheap, but the others were cheeeeeap.

I mean, not like "Superman IV" cheap, but they'd have to be trying to fail to go that far down.

No question about it, but then again, Golden Harvest was hardly a big company.

Warhorse 08-10-2014 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commenter 42 (Post 1328731)
No question about it, but then again, Golden Harvest was hardly a big company.

I am still surprised, after the huge hit Jurassic Park was, with the CGI being used for the dinosaurs, and the TMNT being backed by Newline, that they didn't jump on that bandwagon to use TMNT live action with CGI all the way back then. It would have been around 94.

Leo656 08-10-2014 06:34 PM

That would'a looked horrible, though. They weren't gonna spend Jurassic Park money on a TMNT movie back then. If anything, it would've looked like some Hercules/Xena sh*t. Just that truly awful early-90s TV CGI, but in a movie. That never would've looked any good. They weren't there yet.

Shark_Blade 08-10-2014 06:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TerranigmaFreak (Post 1328472)
TMNT 2 is the worse.

I agree with this statement.

ryukenden 08-10-2014 07:30 PM

The third movie is still at the bottom of the barrel for me. The 2014 movie is sort of in the middle of the barrel for me.

RaphaelinSTL 08-10-2014 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bry (Post 1328634)
They're both badly-written and badly-directed movies. Both of their plots are stupid and often illogical, not even holding up within their own "worlds". They're kind of equally bad in very different ways. But the overall cheapness of TMNT3 gives it that kinda "so bad it's hilarious" quality that the new movie doesn't have. I'm more forgiving of movies that are bad on a relatively low budget than ones that are bad on a high one. There's much more of a cheese factor that's pretty entertaining itself. TMNT3 movie is a movie you can watch and laugh at. IMO, that gives it a lot more re-watch value than the new one, which is just... kinda dull and obnoxious, but in a way I can't find entertaining.

Basically this. TMNT 3 is the kind of the movie that's fun to laugh at, but it's kind of charming in a way. That Angry Nintendo Nerd review of the movie just made me appreciate it even more.

TMNT 2014 is just a bad, boring movie.

mb1025 08-10-2014 08:51 PM

Tmnt
tmnt 2
tmnt 2014
tmnt 2007
tmnt 3

Purse Grabbin Puke 08-10-2014 09:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commenter 42 (Post 1328633)
Now you want to Argue? And we were doing so well!

I really wish people would get my point. I just don't need to see it. I've seen enough movies to be able to look at a trailer an know what it's going to be.
There isn't anything in the trailers that I find appealing. Not one.. shred.:lol:
The real point of not going to see the movie, is to not give them any more money. I'll eventually see it...but I refuse to pay for it on principal. I will not support the continuation of this iteration. i will shout it down every chance I get. If you liked it, that's great and all, but this is not a TMNT movie in my opinion. I don't think I should go to the theater just so I can speak to specifics. It won't change anything for me, and in doing so, i'm telling them, please, make MORE. It goes against everything i've said.

As I mentioned in another thread, a friend went last night. She recounted everything. It's actually worse than I'd thought.

I did as you said I should, with both MOS and TDKR. I was opposed to both films, but I figured, maybe i'm wrong? Maybe I'm just not giving it a chance.

MOS made me so incredibly angry I wanted to beat the **** out of Snyder. I paid to be insulted.
"evolution always wins" says the villain.
What in the hell does that mean? Evolution is a process, not a bloody casino. Evolution doesn't win anything, any more than brewing a coffee "wins".
The Christian iconography was brow beating, and Amy Adams is no Lois Lane.
Worst of all, baby Kal-el absorbed a skull of alien DNA. Those are just a tiny handful of what this movie did wrong.

I rated the films we've gotten so far. TMNT 1990 is the best of them, BUT it's about 50% of what a live action TMNTcould be.
SOTO isn't great, I know that, I have eyes...lol.
TMNT3 is garbage I couldn't watch it all in one sitting. it's really bad, and the animatronics are bad.

But if you really wanted to compare the quality of the films, you can't judge effects separated by decades. That's rather unfair. All you can do is judge how the tools were used, and to what effect.

Let's try and keep the discussion civil. I think we can do that.

Not picking a fight, I just think it's lame to be SO certain of something you haven't even seen. I was CERTAIN that GotG was going to suck. And I loved it.

Regardless, after reading that you hated MOS and TDKR, I'm convinced you don't like anything. I loved MOS, and saw it more times in the theater than any movie ever(this will be broken with TMNT). TDKR is fantastic, and that's coming from someone who's favorite Batman series is Knightfall. But this is all taste in movies, I just have a better understanding of what you hate. I'm guessing you loved Watchmen, Sin City, and 300 because they're just taking page and putting it to screen? Basically you want a moving comic.

Autbot_Benz 08-10-2014 09:50 PM

I am just glad the new movie doesn't have Wet Willy Time.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.