The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Verdict on: TMNT Adventures (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=42377)

Cipher 04-22-2013 06:30 PM

Verdict on: TMNT Adventures
 
After ignoring them for a while, I finally decided to spring for IDW's TMNT Adventure collections (even though the MRSP for the content is still rather high). I already owned the first four Tundra trades and have read most of the later material through a combination of single issues and online scans (which really obligates me to buy the rest of this run now that it's being reproduced legally), but the cartoon adaptations were new to me this time, and I was surprised by how much I enjoyed them for what they were.

That all said, though, and I've been thinking about this since revisiting the material -- how does the series really hold up? I think I have something of a love/hate relationship with it (though maybe either is too strong a word). On the one hand, it embodies a lot of the wacky, colorful action I think most of us remember from the '90s TMNT video-games and toyline but that the Fred-Wolf series never really delivered. And in that regard, I love it, and later in its run it offers probably the single best version of that aesthetic/era of the Turtles.

On the other, I put collecting these volumes on back burner for a long time for a reason: They're very clearly for children, in a way that shows in how often the series cuts corners, leaves out explanations, peters out in its climaxes, etc. I almost get the feeling that there's more fun to it picked up in the form of the occasional, mysterious issue as a kid than there is really going through the whole run at once, where all its faults shine through. Parts of it really drag for, again, its sloppy storytelling and its frequent environmental moralizing (which, while I actually admire it and think was the right thing to do with the platform, doesn't make for an easy read coming back to it as an older reader). And its most successful aspect to me -- really capturing that raw, wacky/cool vibe of the toyline -- is something I can really only recommend on pure nostalgia. As a work removed from childhood fondness, even the often-limply delivered Fred-Wolf series stands better on its own, with its truly funny humor when it's on.

So, where does TMNT Adventures stand for you? It's a bold, creative kids' series that I'd guess that it would still go over well with its intended audience. But as a longtime fan/older reader? I think, at the end of the day, I really enjoy it, but I acknowledge that depends on a level of sheer nostalgia that would prevent me from recommending it to any other adult reader. It gets the '90s Playmates vibe in spades and it pushes its envelope in all sorts of ways, but for all its fun ideas and nostalgic tone, it's really hard to give its execution an objective pass.

CyberCubed 04-22-2013 07:09 PM

I'm surprised you have to ask this, since TMNT Adventures is still one of the strongest comic series for the franchise. The only real downside to it is the constant enviornmental messages and "Captain Planet" themes, but ignoring that, its quite good. The very beginning of the series is fairly standard kid stories, no worse than standard episodes of the original cartoon or Nick series. But as it progresses around issues 30+ the stories are much deeper and the story arcs become excellent.

Lastly you get to see all the mutant characters used better than the OT did, particularly Mondo Gecko, Ray, Wingnut/Screwloose, and the new characters who were never in the cartoon.

Likewise the new villains created for the comic, particularly Malinga, Null, Armaggon and Verminator-X are some of the best TMNT villains created, and its such a shame they never broke into the other TMNT universes.

Cipher 04-22-2013 07:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1087804)
I'm surprised you have to ask this, since TMNT Adventures is still one of the strongest comic series for the franchise.

I think that's why I feel compelled to ask, actually. I know it's one of the more popular versions of the franchise among longtime fans ("stronger" is debatable), and I get a huge kick out of it too. But I don't think it actually carries itself very well outside of the whole nostalgia-driven, Fred-Wolf alternative thing, or being a competent kids' series.

Like, there's no way that, if someone had a low level of TMNT knowledge and was looking to get into the franchise, I would ever recommend this over Mirage or IDW, and I'd debate recommending it over several of the TV incarnations.

It's fun for its time and place, and will probably always have a well-deserved softspot with people who grew up with the Playmates toys, Konami games, etc. But as a stand-alone series, it's pretty flawed, and in either context is often better in concept than in execution.

But that's just me. Honestly, I'm waiting for someone to jump in here and talk about why it's worth reading on something other than a nostalgic level. (And I don't mean that antagonistically; I honestly want to see some discussion on the series as a whole.)

CyberCubed 04-22-2013 08:51 PM

I don't think that's the case, I think its just the fact that the comics are very old now and a lot of people have never read them. So now when people decide to get into comics, they go for all the Mirage issues they never read before, not the Archie ones. These comics are nearly two decades old now.

The Archie series is basically what a plot-driven version of the original toon would have been. And the later issues are quite dark for a kids comic, its interchangeable with a lot of Mirage issues ignoring the color bandanas and the amount of mutants running around.

The only two things I don't like about Archie, and its trivial, is the total lack of Casey Jones (I cannot believe he didn't show up even ONCE), and no Baxter Stockman. Given they're in every other series, the fact that Baxter was dropped after the cartoon adaptions is very odd. I would have loved to see what Murphy would have done with mutated fly Baxter.

Cipher 04-22-2013 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1087842)
The Archie series is basically what a plot-driven version of the original toon would have been.

That's just it, though. That doesn't say anything about the series on its own. I feel like a lot of the fun of this series comes solely from the idea of, "Hey, remember the show from when you were a kid? What if it were cooler like you always wanted it to be? That's this comic."

Which is fine, and like I said, I totally enjoy it on that level.

But would you ever hand it to someone over the age of ten and tell them, "Here. Here's where you should start reading Ninja Turtles. Here's what it means to me"? Would you ever do that for someone who wasn't into '90s Turtlemania?

I'd argue no way in hell. Because if you're not coming in with the hype of it being that "serious" version of the Fred-Wolf cartoon, it's just kind of sloppy and confusing.

CyberCubed 04-22-2013 09:17 PM

Can't you say the same for anything though? If someone never saw the TMNT before, I wouldn't tell them to start with the Nick cartoon either. Hell I wouldn't even tell them to start with Mirage.

I'd probably tell them to start with the IDW series, then the first movie, and then either the original cartoon or 4kids cartoon, and then go from there.

Also for the Archie series, I'd probably recommend people at least be familiar with the original cartoon before trying it, given it spins off from it.

Cipher 04-22-2013 09:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1087852)
Can't you say the same for anything though? If someone never saw the TMNT before, I wouldn't tell them to start with the Nick cartoon either. Hell I wouldn't even tell them to start with Mirage.

I would absolutely tell them to try either. Ditto IDW, which a lot of people seem to have done. Same goes for the Fred-Wolf cartoon and the 4Kids series, as long as they're comfortable with children's cartoons.

All of those hold up infinitely better as stand-alone series than Adventures. And I don't mean that in the sense that it started out as a Fred-Wolf adaptation. I mean that in the sense that it really just doesn't read very well period and sort of gets a pass because of how cool it is to those of us who grew up with the '90s TMNT aesthetic.

CyberCubed 04-22-2013 09:33 PM

Well its purposely viewed as a spinoff. It originally wasn't meant to stand on its own like the 3 cartoons, or Mirage and IDW. That's probably in the back of everyones mind when they think of it, just like the new Nick comic based on the show will be viewed that way.

Once the series progresses past its initial 25-30 issues it begins doing its own thing entirely and stands on its own with new villains and great story arcs. I read the later Archie issues with Armaggon, Null and Malinga and they stand up very well next to what IDW is doing.

The only thing I could see people turned off by was the sheer mass of mutant characters running around. The Turtles interact more with other animal mutants than actual humans, and I can see why that might bother people. It started to feel like one of those cartoons with all talking animals after a while even though April and other humans were still around in some capacity.

darthsmozers 04-23-2013 07:04 AM

I just can't wait until the trades enter the Chris Allan era. Those were mostly excellent stories worth reading in trade format :-)

DrSpengler 04-23-2013 08:51 AM

When TMNT Adventures was good, it was great. When TMNT Adventures was bad, it was heinous.

To get the cons out of the way:

Steve Murphy is a preachy, opinionated guy and he used TMNT Adventures as his own personal soapbox. I've no problems with writers trying to work messages into children's media, but he rarely employed subtlty or grace and the end result is that he more often than not talked down to children, which is an attitude I find reprehensible.

And toward the end of the series, when he was having trouble with the management at Archie and Laird was offering him no support, you could tell his storytelling was beginning to fall apart. The Cyber Samurai arc is a mess of half-formed ideas and ill executions. The end result is that the arc becomes guilty of everything Victor Gorelick accused Murphy's TMNT of being; cynical, gratuitously violent and controversial for the sake of being controversial. There are good ideas in there, but he doesn't cultivate them and the whole thing is a dud (save for the art, but I'll get to that). The Moon Eyes saga is a lot of mush at best, and full of creepy pedophilic connotations at worst.

But when the book was GOOD, look out.

Murphy wrote some incredible stuff. Mostly, the arcs between the South American Tour and when his burn-out became noticeable around Megadeath/Terracide. There's a great run of challenging stories, mythology/unvierse building, increasingly higher stakes and an overall internal storytelling consistency not seen in the supposedly more sophisticated Mirage book. The title really GROWS, leaving behind the Fred Wolf and Playmates toyline elements early on so that it can change and branch out. There are duds scattered about the run, but the good arcs outweigh the bad by a wide margin. The World Tour arc is one of my favorites, as it's an example of Murphy's skills when he tries to fold his educational agenda subtly into an entertaining narrative. There are some missteps along the way (Mang-Thrasha being a Yellow Peril stereotype, boring historical dissertations on Islam), but it's one of his best arcs, at least so far as trying to be "educational".

And, of course, there's the art. Chris Allan really saves the book when it's at it's lows and elevates the book through the roof when its at its highs. I loved Ken Mitchroney, but when the title took a turn for the heavier, Allan's style really stepped up and adapted with the book. Even at the end of the run, when Murphy was fumbling at the 1 yard line with his last couple of story arcs, Allan's art makes them at least fun to LOOK at if not so much read.


So I think TMNT Adventures benefits from having a singular creative mind spearheading its run, though that also invites various troubles, too. For the most part, it's better for it and is a good read (or at least the middle chunk is).

CyberCubed 04-23-2013 11:29 AM

Also the Turtles are ALWAYS traveling in Archie. You'll be surprised at how little the Turtles stay in New York in this series.

They traveled through South America, through the Middle East, to Jerusalem, to Japan, to Alaska, to Tibet, to Egypt to Scotland....and of course to outer space.

I think there are only a handful of stories that actually take place in New York...lol.

funatic 04-23-2013 12:02 PM

I'm just going to let Spengs speak on my behalf for all my TMNT-related opinions from now on. :trazz: Well put, all of it.

DrSpengler 04-23-2013 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1087851)
But would you ever hand it to someone over the age of ten and tell them, "Here. Here's where you should start reading Ninja Turtles. Here's what it means to me"? Would you ever do that for someone who wasn't into '90s Turtlemania?

That's a good question worth considering.

To weigh both sides of the argument, I think the fact that it was written as an All Ages book gives it more legs and broadens its demographic appeal; you can definitely show this book to a wider range of individuals than you could, say, the Image series. While that does pigeonhole it as a "kids" book, I imagine most reasonable people wouldn't shun it by that virtue alone. I often find media, be it comics or cartoons, that are created for kids or All Ages to be more intelligent and less juvenile than media created strictly for adults.

What I think might sink TMNT Adventures more as a series to be read on its own is the fluctuating quality of the writing and that it DOES take a long time to "get to the good stuff". And there's more to it than just that it starts out adapting the cartoon. I enjoy The Final Conflict arc (#5 through #13), but it is, as you say, a Playmates toyline ad and my enjoyment is fueled more on terms of nostalgia than sincere quality. The South American Tour arc is excruciating. The Mighty Mutanimals arc is better, but still saddled with that "save the rain forest" stuff.

The Slash Trilogy tends to be the turning point; it's where Chris Allan joins the team and the Fred Wolf baggage is written out, but that's what? 25 issues into the run?

I can definitely see the problem, there.


But on the other hand, I don't know if I'd say the Mirage series is a more intuitive reading experience, either. An unitiated reader going into Mirage from Vol. 1 is at a great disadvantage, trying to figure out what "counts", where various Tales issues and Micros go (as they're essential to the coherent ongoing narrative) and, if they make it past Vol. 1, they've got the deal with a LOT of dropped storylines and unresolved arcs.

It takes... homework to read the Mirage series and that's daunting to newcomers, I think.


Honestly, I think if I were to give a newcomer a TMNT series and say "read this, it's intuitive and it's got everything Turtle you need in it", I'd honestly go with the current IDW series. It's far from perfect, but it reads well and its plotted in advance. The micros and minis can give that feeling of "homework" to figure out where they go in regards to the ongoing, but unlike Mirage, you can read IDW #1-21 and not hit weird roadbumps like "guest issues that don't count or maybe they do we really don't know" etc.

And more than that, it has a good blend of Mirage-isms and Fred Wolf/Archie-isms to cover a good spread.

Then, if a newcomer reads the IDW issues and decides they want to know allllll about the TMNT, then I'd say they should hit the Mirage or Archie books.

darthsmozers 04-30-2013 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1087971)
Also the Turtles are ALWAYS traveling in Archie. You'll be surprised at how little the Turtles stay in New York in this series.

They traveled through South America, through the Middle East, to Jerusalem, to Japan, to Alaska, to Tibet, to Egypt to Scotland....and of course to outer space.

I think there are only a handful of stories that actually take place in New York...lol.

And when they are in NY, its likely a future version of it :lol:

CyberCubed 04-30-2013 11:40 AM

Yeah that's really strange about Archie TMNT. They never stayed in NY and were always visiting other countries...they never stayed on their home turf.

I realizes its because Murphy was obsessed with exposing kids to other geography and cultures and religions...the whole book was basically Captain Planet and exposure to different customs.

Panda_Kahn_fan 04-30-2013 11:20 PM

I would definitely reccomend it to younger readers, I loved the series characterizations and character development, but dislike the enviromentally preachy story lines. This was my favorite turtle comic until IDW came along, as I'm not exactly a fan of Mirage, myself.

Andrew NDB 04-30-2013 11:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1091000)
Yeah that's really strange about Archie TMNT. They never stayed in NY and were always visiting other countries...they never stayed on their home turf.

I realizes its because Murphy was obsessed with exposing kids to other geography and cultures and religions...the whole book was basically Captain Planet and exposure to different customs.

Never bothered me. Though I can see now and conjecture, if I'd have actually kept reading as a kid past where I stopped, that I'd probably have eventually gotten "travel fatigue."

CyberCubed 04-30-2013 11:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1091230)
Never bothered me. Though I can see now and conjecture, if I'd have actually kept reading as a kid past where I stopped, that I'd probably have eventually gotten "travel fatigue."

I figured it was supposed to be read at the same time kids were watching the cartoon, so in one place you saw New York with Shredder/Krang in every episode, and in another you saw the Turtles traveling facing new villains.

Its obvious Murphy didn't want to do the same thing the show was doing at the time, but at the same token, the lack of New York and the sheer mass of culture/geography and religion introduced in the book was a bit strange.

Cipher 05-01-2013 12:13 AM

To be honest, the world-travel aspect is always one I liked as a kid when I would pick up the odd issue, and one I still like now.

I am also totally pro the cultural/religious education slant the book picked up later in its run, considering its target audience.

AnarkyLantern 05-01-2013 08:46 AM

This was the first comic book I remember reading and certainly the first I followed best I could at that age. I still have all the issues bought as a kid,starting with a hugely worn out #22 (Still remember where i bought it and did get earlier issues later on). I loved seeing April fight alongside the turtles and I enjoyed the story. So I have been picking up the trades with original stories- it's incredibly goofy (um, i could picture ray fillet sounding like something out if ygo abridged) and the art inconsistent to terrible at times, but it does bring me back to #22(which I don't dare open up anymore in the shape it's in lol) and the great stuff I know that followed, so I'm in for the whole run of these.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:16 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.