![]() |
|
|
#1 |
|
Foot Elite
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
|
Verdict on: TMNT Adventures
After ignoring them for a while, I finally decided to spring for IDW's TMNT Adventure collections (even though the MRSP for the content is still rather high). I already owned the first four Tundra trades and have read most of the later material through a combination of single issues and online scans (which really obligates me to buy the rest of this run now that it's being reproduced legally), but the cartoon adaptations were new to me this time, and I was surprised by how much I enjoyed them for what they were.
That all said, though, and I've been thinking about this since revisiting the material -- how does the series really hold up? I think I have something of a love/hate relationship with it (though maybe either is too strong a word). On the one hand, it embodies a lot of the wacky, colorful action I think most of us remember from the '90s TMNT video-games and toyline but that the Fred-Wolf series never really delivered. And in that regard, I love it, and later in its run it offers probably the single best version of that aesthetic/era of the Turtles. On the other, I put collecting these volumes on back burner for a long time for a reason: They're very clearly for children, in a way that shows in how often the series cuts corners, leaves out explanations, peters out in its climaxes, etc. I almost get the feeling that there's more fun to it picked up in the form of the occasional, mysterious issue as a kid than there is really going through the whole run at once, where all its faults shine through. Parts of it really drag for, again, its sloppy storytelling and its frequent environmental moralizing (which, while I actually admire it and think was the right thing to do with the platform, doesn't make for an easy read coming back to it as an older reader). And its most successful aspect to me -- really capturing that raw, wacky/cool vibe of the toyline -- is something I can really only recommend on pure nostalgia. As a work removed from childhood fondness, even the often-limply delivered Fred-Wolf series stands better on its own, with its truly funny humor when it's on. So, where does TMNT Adventures stand for you? It's a bold, creative kids' series that I'd guess that it would still go over well with its intended audience. But as a longtime fan/older reader? I think, at the end of the day, I really enjoy it, but I acknowledge that depends on a level of sheer nostalgia that would prevent me from recommending it to any other adult reader. It gets the '90s Playmates vibe in spades and it pushes its envelope in all sorts of ways, but for all its fun ideas and nostalgic tone, it's really hard to give its execution an objective pass. |
|
|
|
|
|