The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Questions regarding "Archie Comics" (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=46589)

RTMNT 03-12-2014 02:05 PM

Questions regarding "Archie Comics"
 
1 Attachment(s)
Hello, everybody! How is it going here?


First of all, I would like to express my gratitude to "The Technodrome Forums" team for their impressive contribution to the development of a prosperous and informative TMNT discussion nook.

Now I come to the subject of this thread. Time and again I have some queries regarding "TMNT Archie Comics", particularly it pertains to some characters thoughts and their world perception and diverting equivoques, and authors messages, etc. I think it would be really interesting to share our views on the subject while making our conversation in a friendly manner.

So, without any further ado here goes a smallish question concerning "TMNTA #6".

You see, I am trying to conceive the inner world of a character named Jess Harley and there is a page No. 3 in "TMNT Archie, No. 6" issue that I am currently struggling with:
Attachment 6584
How do you personally think, what the author(s) of this issue meant exactly (the word "much", specifically) when they wrote such lines as "There is so much here...", "So much..." (with due account for the context, naturally). Did they mean that Jess was supposed, let say, to ruminate about diversity of New York life and different layers of society (as in "There is so much (paying attention to diversity and unpredictability of life, rich and poor people, etc...) here...", "So much...") or just to simply wonder about the way money "flowing" in the Big Apple (as in "There is so much (money) here...", "So much (money)...")? To put it in a nutshell, the question is "Did Jess mean "money" or "diversity and unpredictability of life (or something else)" by saying the word "much""?

I would really appreciate any appropriate response.

CyberCubed 03-12-2014 02:31 PM

Murphy, the writer, was obsessed with Eco preaching and discrimination and Native American slavery Of the white man.

plastroncafe 03-12-2014 03:20 PM

I think here the author was specifically referring to the disparity between people who inhabit the same city.

Cryomancer 03-13-2014 03:02 PM

He's supposed to be a dude used to living in a rural area if I remember correctly, so he might just mean in general. Like there are just so many different things he's not used to seeing where he's from, big buildings, large groups of people, traffic, and so on.

wilddiverse 03-13-2014 07:00 PM

If you turn the page, Harley's narration continues "So amazed was I with all the sights and sounds... that I failed to see the approaching stranger".

It reads like a backwoods bayou boy overwhelmed by the big city- giant buildings, glamorous rich and homeless hobos, spectacle and noise... you can read too much into it and say Murphy was trying to 'preach' to fill your hate-quota or you can see it as characterization for a new character.

RTMNT 03-14-2014 01:30 PM

Hey, guys, thanks for kindly sharing Your thoughts.

DrSpengler 03-14-2014 01:37 PM

Yeah, Murphy was guilty of "preaching" a million times over, but when he wanted to make a statement... he MADE a statement. Like, the characters stopping what they're doing to address the audience and tell them exactly what they (Murphy) think about a political or environmental topic.

This really doesn't qualify as one of those situations. It's a character moment, as Wilddiverse pointed out, as Jess Harley is merely overwhelmed by an environment completely foreign to him.

ChosenOne 03-18-2014 08:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RTMNT (Post 1226346)
How do you personally think, what the author(s) of this issue meant exactly (the word "much", specifically) when they wrote such lines as "There is so much here...", "So much..." (with due account for the context, naturally). Did they mean that Jess was supposed, let say, to ruminate about diversity of New York life and different layers of society (as in "There is so much (paying attention to diversity and unpredictability of life, rich and poor people, etc...) here...", "So much...") or just to simply wonder about the way money "flowing" in the Big Apple (as in "There is so much (money) here...", "So much (money)...")? To put it in a nutshell, the question is "Did Jess mean "money" or "diversity and unpredictability of life (or something else)" by saying the word "much""?

I don't really know how helpful this might be, but this issue being the first TMNT comic I ever read in my life, I feel a duty to pitch in: here in my country, the second line was translated as "Too much", as I remember distinctly to his day. Maybe it sheds some more light on the matter, maybe not, as it was possibly a case of translator's prerogative... But I felt it was worth pointing out.

Dirty Blond 03-18-2014 10:51 AM

I couldn't finish this volume, even out of obligation as a fan.

I can handle anything with a point of view or a message, but that preaching just got to me.

CyberCubed 03-18-2014 11:58 AM

Yeah the only thing bad about Archie is all the eco preaching.

Without it it's a fun adventure series. Someone should have told Murphy in the 90's to get a blog. Too bad the internet didn't exist back then.

wilddiverse 03-18-2014 12:00 PM

Personally I always agreed with the position that pollution is bad.

Dirty Blond 03-18-2014 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wilddiverse (Post 1229557)
Personally I always agreed with the position that pollution is bad.

Wow, good for you. But I don't like to be preached to in a comic book, I want to be entertained.

That no one could think of an entertaining way to convey an environmental message is where this title and I part company.

wilddiverse 03-18-2014 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirty Blond (Post 1229561)
That no one could think of an entertaining way to convey an environmental message is where this title and I part company.

Wow, good for you too.

RTMNT 03-22-2014 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne
I don't really know how helpful this might be, but this issue being the first TMNT comic I ever read in my life, I feel a duty to pitch in: here in my country, the second line was translated as "Too much", as I remember distinctly to his day.

Hmm, interesting. Thanks a lot! Could you please tell me what was this "Too much" line in the language of your country?
Quote:

Originally Posted by wilddiverse
Personally I always agreed with the position that pollution is bad.

Me too. I personally find the idea of environmental awareness quite useful. I think a message that conveys any good, in our case it's (but not limited to) environmental protection, just can't be bad. TMNT Archie Comics always apealed to me mostly because of the variety of unpredictable and amusing plots, friendly atmosphere, etc.; and an extra credit must be given to the authors that not only did they entertain readers (most of them children, right), but also gave them a piece of an edifying advice. Nowadays, as far as I am aware of it, the most of modern comics tend to be filled with ferocity and with a tincture of some kind of panache. Moreover, from the perspective of the 21st century I can say that at least back in the 80s-90s people seemed to be more concerned about important and significant things.

Yeah, the best is for children!

ChosenOne 03-22-2014 10:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RTMNT (Post 1231921)
Hmm, interesting. Thanks a lot! Could you please tell me what was this "Too much" line in the language of your country?

Sure thing, I'm Portuguese so it was "Demasiado". Funny thing is, I can't remember how the line in the previous panel was translated. I guess a single word is easier to keep in mind all these years. I still have the issue but it's stashed away in a box somewhere, or I'd check.

RTMNT 03-22-2014 04:01 PM

ChosenOne, muito obrigado, amigo! Eu falo português um pouco. Comparar as diferentes traduções é muito curioso. Tanto quanto eu posso ver, "Demasiado" é certamente diferente do "So much".
Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne
I still have the issue but it's stashed away in a box somewhere, or I'd check.

Estou a procura de bons scans. Poderia você verificar "TMNTA #6", por favor? Ficaria muito grato.

ChosenOne 03-22-2014 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RTMNT (Post 1232067)
ChosenOne, muito obrigado, amigo! Eu falo português um pouco. Comparar as diferentes traduções é muito curioso. Tanto quanto eu posso ver, "Demasiado" é certamente diferente do "So much".

Estou a procura de bons scans. Poderia você verificar "TMNTA #6", por favor? Ficaria muito grato.

Em Português: RTMNT, teria todo o gosto em ajudar e fornecer scans, mas não tenho a issue à mão. Está guardada numa caixa juntamente com outros livros e bandas desenhadas da minha infância em casa dos meus pais, longe do sítio onde vivo actualmente. Lamento... No entanto, posso garantir que o texto no painel em questão é "Demasiado"/"Too much", já que fui (aparentemente) uma das poucas pessoas que não se importaram com o tom condescendente da banda desenhada da Archie e a mensagem dessa primeira página ficou gravada na minha memória até hoje. Tenho tentado lembrar-me do texto no painel anterior, e penso que foi traduzido como "Há tanto aqui...".

In English: RTMNT, I'd be glad to help you out with some scans, but I don't have the issue close at hand. It's stored away in a box along with several other books and comics from my childhood at my parents' house, far from where I currently reside. Sorry... However, I can assure you the caption on the panel is indeed "Demasiado"/"Too much", I was (apparently) one of the few people who didn't mind the preachy tone of the Archie series and the message of that first page stuck with me to this day. I've been trying to remember the caption on the previous panel, and I think it was translated as "Há tanto aqui...".

wilddiverse 03-22-2014 04:57 PM

I suspect it's more just a loud, repetitive minority that takes issue with the environmental slant to the TMNT Adventures stories...

RTMNT 03-29-2014 11:06 AM

Thanks again, everybody!

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 04-01-2014 09:58 PM

I don't agree with everything Stephan Murphy tried to shoe horn into a book intended to entertain kids, but I've always thought he was the best writer that ever worked on "Official" Mirage stuff, and while the constant agenda was annoying, the poetry was beautiful. He wasn't the only one at Mirage who felt that way... but Laird and Eastman seemed to be consumed by the capitalism monster while Jim Lawson just wanted to draw dinosaurs and be able to feed his kids.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:46 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.