![]() |
|
|
#1 |
|
Foot Elite
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
|
Let's Talk About the Coloring in IDW "Tales" Vol. 4
Finally picked this up today, after falling somewhat behind on releases. For reference, this is the book that collects issues #5-8 of Tales Vol. 2.
By and large I've been pretty neutral on the coloring in the "Classics" and Tales lines (distinct from the largely superior job in the "Color Classics"/"The Works" books). It's obvious that they're done with a quick, factory-like approach (I'm sure the colorists don't have much time with the volume of work to belabor many creative decisions), but mostly I've found it unobtrusive and thought it even improved some of the Tales Volume 1 issues. This, though, this is rough. Has anyone else seen this yet? Remember the kerfuffle over Lucindra in the "Classics" line, when she looked white? They've done the same thing with Cha Ocho here. He's so light (and has so much digital sheen), he easily looks white for the majority of his issue. He's several shades darker on both the new Jim Lawson cover for the book and the cover of his own issue, so, man ... it really highlights the problem. I don't know if it's intentional, but it's super-duper problematic. On a side note, #6 is, I think, also one of the clearest instances of the coloring style just blowing the tone for an issue. The amount of bright colors and shine just don't work here. And then there are just weird decisions like coloring the blood splatter in the church a shade of pink light enough to blend into the statue behind it, ruining what the panel is supposed to do. No bueno. This book also provides the first sustained look at this team's coloring on Jim Lawson's post-2000 style (Volume 3 had him on one shorter issue). The team likes to add barely-blended shading onto everything, even accentuating facial features that aren't in the line work (which has occasionally led to some weird 3D-model looking panels; not great), but it really doesn't work with Lawson's style. The crazy thing is that the cover of the book makes it work. As did the coloring on his short in the 30th Anniversary issue. As does coloring in this collection itself on the "The Raison" backup. Whoever did that portion totally gets it, using bold, flat colors to let Lawson's art stand out as the bit of underground-inspired cartooning it is. And as usual, strange and bad-looking choices abound, including a truly hideous red-and-yellow sweater on Cha in one scene, and a bizarre full-body red costume for the Hamato ninja who shows up in #8 (rendered in a much more understandable dark blue on the Mirage cover of a later issue). Man. Who do we write to about this? Again, this is the first volume of the series where I think the color really hurts the experience in all but a few spots. And just jeez with that white-washing thing. Which is a shame because the book contains some great issues. Last edited by Cipher; 08-18-2014 at 05:11 PM. |
|
|
|
|
|