The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > General Forums > General Discussion > Everything Else

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 11-13-2013, 02:53 PM   #161
Davetello
Banned
 
Davetello's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Greater Glasgow, Scotland, The Ununited Kingdom
Posts: 1,712
Type 97 - I don't disagree with everything you've said, in fact you've made some good points too (I've been having a similar debate elsewhere) but at the same time your apologist tone is making me really uncomfortable, as I said. I've had this debate many times before and it is very dodgy ground, so let's agree to disagree as I can see myself becoming extremely frustrated. I do have things I would like to say but I get the feeling you wouldn't acknowledge them anyway, so let's just wrap things up here.
Davetello is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-13-2013, 02:56 PM   #162
Davetello
Banned
 
Davetello's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Greater Glasgow, Scotland, The Ununited Kingdom
Posts: 1,712
Quote:
Originally Posted by Type 97 Chi-ha View Post
I should also add that I did take one college course in Asian history and one in Latin American history (which I agree should be taught in lower grades too), and I've learned that many of the post colonial problem facing these nations were as much the result of post colonial leaders' corruption or stupidity as any aftereffects of colonialism. Example: in India, inoculating the population against diseases inadvertently caused the nation's population to explode because the death rate was reduced without slowing the birth rate.
As an example of what I said above, I never disagreed with that. My issue is that you seem unwilling to hold the west even partially accountable for its actions.

"Certainly Asia and Africa were not nice places before the colonial era."

So because they weren't nice places a) it absolves colonialists of blame because they were in a mess anyway and b) presumes that they wouldn't have been able to develop without our dubious 'help'?

Your entire argument seems to be that they should be thankful to us for doing them a favour. If that is indeed your argument then I disagree with every fibre of my being.

But, again, let's not get into it.
Davetello is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-13-2013, 03:02 PM   #163
Dawnatello Turtle Chick
Mad Scientist
 
Dawnatello Turtle Chick's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Mineral Wells, TX
Posts: 1,178
Quote:
Originally Posted by DarkLightDragon View Post
I have a mild case of Asperger's that I was diagnosed I believe around kindergarten or 2nd grade.

While it doesn't hinder me all that much since I can open up and talk to people and manage to leave a good impression on people, I just been one to prefer being alone and prevent any awkwardness that follows me around. It also helps that the people I feel like talking to share my common interests hence why I decided to join a couple years back. This forum isn't the only place I go to, but for a while, it was the forum I would visit the least.

Thanks for sharing. As I mentioned earlier (or elsewhere, I forget), my husband has Aspergers, but unfortunately he didn't find out until he was an adult. It is a blessing to find out much earlier in life so that you can learn why you act the way you act or why people don't react to what you perceive as normal the way you think they should. My husband has had a harder time of it trying to figure it all out as an adult when how he acts at work can follow him. Figuring it out as a school aged kid, while difficult, is easier to do. Most people don't remember half of what their classmates did in school anyway once you're in the real world. Life is a learning process no matter who you are, so kudos to you for pressing forward to enjoy your life without worrying about people judging you. Glad to get to know you better! We're all the same here anyway- Turtle fans!
__________________
These are here-->[IMG][/IMG]<---and here.
Dawnatello Turtle Chick is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-13-2013, 03:49 PM   #164
Type 97 Chi-ha
Mad Scientist
 
Type 97 Chi-ha's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Brookfield, IL
Posts: 1,333
Quote:
Originally Posted by Davetello View Post
As an example of what I said above, I never disagreed with that. My issue is that you seem unwilling to hold the west even partially accountable for its actions.

"Certainly Asia and Africa were not nice places before the colonial era."

So because they weren't nice places a) it absolves colonialists of blame because they were in a mess anyway and b) presumes that they wouldn't have been able to develop without our dubious 'help'?

Your entire argument seems to be that they should be thankful to us for doing them a favour. If that is indeed your argument then I disagree with every fibre of my being.

But, again, let's not get into it.
I won't, except to say that I never said that colonialism was benign. Far from it. But it is equally bad to say that the West is responsible for all the Third World's problems. Mao Zedong, after all, was far more murderous toward the Chinese people than the Japanese or any Western colonialists were-even though past colonial nations are still unpopular in China.
Type 97 Chi-ha is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-13-2013, 03:56 PM   #165
Davetello
Banned
 
Davetello's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Greater Glasgow, Scotland, The Ununited Kingdom
Posts: 1,712
Quote:
Originally Posted by Type 97 Chi-ha View Post
I won't, except to say that I never said that colonialism was benign. Far from it. But it is equally bad to say that the West is responsible for all the Third World's problems. Mao Zedong, after all, was far more murderous toward the Chinese people than the Japanese or any Western colonialists were-even though past colonial nations are still unpopular in China.
Indeed. However, I don't believe that the west is fully responsible for the developing world's ills. As with most things, it's not black and white, and there are faults on both sides. However, it cannot be denied that what we did was self-serving and evil, even if it ultimately had unintentional positive consequences. However, those were a by-product of less than noble intentions.

My entire issue was that you seemed to be attempting to remove all responsiblity from the west. You seem like a reflective sort of guy so I think we both know that that wouldn't be the correct stance to take.

We can extrapolate all manner of theories and deductions from the actions of our ancestors, and we can try to excuse their actions with the usual arguments ('it was a different time, people weren't as civilised and it's easy to place guilt with the benefit of a contemporary lens' etc) but we played our part in causing untold suffering to millions of people and, whilst we have aided former colonies in some ways, we've also constrained them in others.

That's my only point, that things aren't black and white. I won't deny that I think the British empire - for example - was evil, but I also don't deny that some good came out of it, ironically.

The genocidal tendencies of power-mad dictators is something I'm in agreement with, but again, two wrongs don't make a right.

Anyway, it's good to talk to someone else who's passionate about such subjects, even if we have butted heads.

EDIT: my original comment regarding despising western culture was more about modern media networks and attempts at censorship than historical accounts of slavery or colonialism, by the way (although it is all interconnected). Just to make that clear.
Davetello is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-15-2013, 10:15 AM   #166
Storm Eagle
Saved by
 
Storm Eagle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: New York
Posts: 3,394
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dawnatello Turtle Chick View Post
Thanks for sharing. As I mentioned earlier (or elsewhere, I forget), my husband has Aspergers, but unfortunately he didn't find out until he was an adult. It is a blessing to find out much earlier in life so that you can learn why you act the way you act or why people don't react to what you perceive as normal the way you think they should. My husband has had a harder time of it trying to figure it all out as an adult when how he acts at work can follow him. Figuring it out as a school aged kid, while difficult, is easier to do. Most people don't remember half of what their classmates did in school anyway once you're in the real world. Life is a learning process no matter who you are, so kudos to you for pressing forward to enjoy your life without worrying about people judging you. Glad to get to know you better! We're all the same here anyway- Turtle fans!
A few years ago, I was diagnosed with having traits of Aspergers, although the psychologist said that she wouldn't necessarily say I have the syndrome point blank. I have a friend who does have Aspergers, and when I got to meet her, and I got to meet her parents. Some time later, my friend told me once that her mom suspects I may have it too, since she found me to be very polite, and says my friend and I appear to be very close.

Before that though, my mother suspected I might be autistic on some level because of some habits I had. She talked about how I keep lists of things, but I always thought I was just being creative, or trying to keep organized. I keep episode guides of some of the shows I watch with information such as premiere dates, and writer and director information. I also have notes on episode premieres that tell if an episode aired on a different date or time than usual, and when an episode might have premiered out of chronological order. I've seen other people from fandoms do such things, and they've proven to be helpful to others. So I just thought I'd make these kinds of notes for myself. I figured it would be fun.

I know not many people do these kinds of things, but then there are also those average ordinary everyday things that people might do, and others who don't understand them would be quick to suspect that they've got some sort of disorder, and that's not fair. It's as though everything the person does is wrong, or everything the person says is wrong. So how are they supposed to live their lives?
Storm Eagle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-15-2013, 01:21 PM   #167
Dawnatello Turtle Chick
Mad Scientist
 
Dawnatello Turtle Chick's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Mineral Wells, TX
Posts: 1,178
Quote:
Originally Posted by Storm Eagle View Post
A few years ago, I was diagnosed with having traits of Aspergers, although the psychologist said that she wouldn't necessarily say I have the syndrome point blank. I have a friend who does have Aspergers, and when I got to meet her, and I got to meet her parents. Some time later, my friend told me once that her mom suspects I may have it too, since she found me to be very polite, and says my friend and I appear to be very close.

Before that though, my mother suspected I might be autistic on some level because of some habits I had. She talked about how I keep lists of things, but I always thought I was just being creative, or trying to keep organized. I keep episode guides of some of the shows I watch with information such as premiere dates, and writer and director information. I also have notes on episode premieres that tell if an episode aired on a different date or time than usual, and when an episode might have premiered out of chronological order. I've seen other people from fandoms do such things, and they've proven to be helpful to others. So I just thought I'd make these kinds of notes for myself. I figured it would be fun.

I know not many people do these kinds of things, but then there are also those average ordinary everyday things that people might do, and others who don't understand them would be quick to suspect that they've got some sort of disorder, and that's not fair. It's as though everything the person does is wrong, or everything the person says is wrong. So how are they supposed to live their lives?
I know what you mean by your last statement. When my husband and I were engaged (before he got his diagnoses) he would do or say things that didn't make sense to others or if he got overwhelmed sensory-wise and basically have a meltdown while we were out shopping, he would just leave me there and drive off. On the surface this makes him look like a jerk, but once we understood that he had hit capacity as far as tolerating that much chaos and he was dealing the only way he knew how- leaving the triggers, driving around to calm down, it made sense. But people don't understand that if they don't understand the autistic/Aspergers spectrum. You can be "normal" with Aspergers tendencies, you can be very Aspergers borderline Autistic. You can be Austic and still be very high functioning and maybe even social in certain settings. Bottom line, you are who you are and if people can't accept that you didn't need them anyway. The good news is that Aspergers and Autism are becoming much more accepted and understood by the general public. If it weren't for people like you who make lists, people like me would just keep wondering, lol, because I wouldn't think to write that kind of stuff down, I'd just wonder about it later...
__________________
These are here-->[IMG][/IMG]<---and here.
Dawnatello Turtle Chick is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-15-2013, 04:10 PM   #168
Storm Eagle
Saved by
 
Storm Eagle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: New York
Posts: 3,394
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dawnatello Turtle Chick View Post
I know what you mean by your last statement. When my husband and I were engaged (before he got his diagnoses) he would do or say things that didn't make sense to others or if he got overwhelmed sensory-wise and basically have a meltdown while we were out shopping, he would just leave me there and drive off. On the surface this makes him look like a jerk, but once we understood that he had hit capacity as far as tolerating that much chaos and he was dealing the only way he knew how- leaving the triggers, driving around to calm down, it made sense. But people don't understand that if they don't understand the autistic/Aspergers spectrum. You can be "normal" with Aspergers tendencies, you can be very Aspergers borderline Autistic. You can be Austic and still be very high functioning and maybe even social in certain settings. Bottom line, you are who you are and if people can't accept that you didn't need them anyway. The good news is that Aspergers and Autism are becoming much more accepted and understood by the general public. If it weren't for people like you who make lists, people like me would just keep wondering, lol, because I wouldn't think to write that kind of stuff down, I'd just wonder about it later...
Right. Besides, even "normal" people do some rather questionable things that would make others scratch their heads. I'm probably "normal with Aspergers tendencies" and even I know that. Then I think to myself "and people think I'M weird".

It also baffles me how people make a big deal out of ordinary things, or think that someone else has some sort of problem if they do things slightly differently than they do. When I was in high school, a few people made a big deal out of never seeing me talk to any girls. It's kind of a double standard since there were a few other guys who didn't really go out of their way to talk to girls and nobody ever wondered about them. Besides, I did socialize with girls although I was no Casanova, and I didn't really make it a point to get into their pants or anything. I also dealt with this once some place where I used to work, where a guy actually wondered if I might be slow or retarded just because I never really talked to our female co-workers. Not that it's anyone's business on why I never really did, but I guess I just didn't feel an obligation to. It's just something that didn't happen. Besides, they could have spoken to me, right?
Storm Eagle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-15-2013, 06:32 PM   #169
Kas
Thug
 
Kas's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 68
Well, since I was 11 more or less, I have been afflicted with social anxiety, I wasn't able to have a conversation with my classmates, which helped me to become a target of bullying by all my classmates. At 13 I was diagnosed with depression and began to be under therapy. The situation improved when I made friends at 15 with some boys and girls from my town by the internet. I felt so alone (I had no friends) so I had no choice but to remedy the problem. Since then, I've met people who I appreciate, and thanks to which I feel so loved. I spent two years without being under therapy until, at age 16, I had another attack of depression and anxiety. I tried to overcome the problem myself, but each time was getting worse. Gradually I was isolating myself from my beloved ones, I started having insomnia and lost weight to dangerous levels. At 18 I started to go to a psychiatrist and he prescribed me antidepressants, which I have been consuming until today. I have recently put myself under psychological therapy, which has helped me to understand better myself and my problems.

I could not tell if I suffer from a disorder or stuff, but since childhood I have always had a very strong temper, which my parents have always repressed making me feel guilty about my personality, so I have been living in fear of conflict with others, even to lose respect for myself only for not showing my true colors when people bothered me or hurt me. In short, I've been keeping my anger inside me for not getting angry with people who deserved it because I didn't want to become a bad person.

Of all the problems that I have, I think this is the most limitating one. On the other hand, I have a great difficulty concentrating, but thankfully I've never been very dumb so I could get good grades. Yes, I have many stories about teachers yelling at me to make me stop drawing or come back to my "astral travellings" xD.

Last edited by Kas; 11-15-2013 at 06:43 PM.
Kas is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-15-2013, 11:50 PM   #170
Dawnatello Turtle Chick
Mad Scientist
 
Dawnatello Turtle Chick's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Mineral Wells, TX
Posts: 1,178
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kas View Post
Well, since I was 11 more or less, I have been afflicted with social anxiety, I wasn't able to have a conversation with my classmates, which helped me to become a target of bullying by all my classmates. At 13 I was diagnosed with depression and began to be under therapy. The situation improved when I made friends at 15 with some boys and girls from my town by the internet. I felt so alone (I had no friends) so I had no choice but to remedy the problem. Since then, I've met people who I appreciate, and thanks to which I feel so loved. I spent two years without being under therapy until, at age 16, I had another attack of depression and anxiety. I tried to overcome the problem myself, but each time was getting worse. Gradually I was isolating myself from my beloved ones, I started having insomnia and lost weight to dangerous levels. At 18 I started to go to a psychiatrist and he prescribed me antidepressants, which I have been consuming until today. I have recently put myself under psychological therapy, which has helped me to understand better myself and my problems.

I could not tell if I suffer from a disorder or stuff, but since childhood I have always had a very strong temper, which my parents have always repressed making me feel guilty about my personality, so I have been living in fear of conflict with others, even to lose respect for myself only for not showing my true colors when people bothered me or hurt me. In short, I've been keeping my anger inside me for not getting angry with people who deserved it because I didn't want to become a bad person.

Of all the problems that I have, I think this is the most limitating one. On the other hand, I have a great difficulty concentrating, but thankfully I've never been very dumb so I could get good grades. Yes, I have many stories about teachers yelling at me to make me stop drawing or come back to my "astral travellings" xD.
I'm so glad you felt like sharing. It is very hard growing up with anger issues, I did up through Jr. High school (I was always very, very shy) until I figured out how to make people laugh. Then I would get in trouble for disrupting class, but finally I learned that if you make the teacher laugh they can't get mad at you! I think much of my anger growing up was the frustration of wanting friends but being so shy that I avoided them. I have worked very hard on my level of patience (I used to have none!) and not spending time worrying about things I can't change, coupled with not spending all my time pleasing everyone but myself. These were all very difficult lessons for me, for many years, but I am much happier and healthier for my troubles. I hope you can find what helps you to reach out to others in friendship and finding what things you can do that bring joy to your life!
__________________
These are here-->[IMG][/IMG]<---and here.
Dawnatello Turtle Chick is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:28 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.