|
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
|
The reason why Crisis and Zero Hour worked for DC, and the New 52 doesn't, is that, as you said, it was more a "streamlining" than a total reinvention. Certain things that weren't entirely necessary or relevant got swept under the rug - but not entirely erased, as we've seen how DC writers from 2000-2010 basically made a career out of un-doing Crisis and finding a way to work some of those ideas back into regular continuity, mostly with success (although, MUST we constantly revisit Krypto The Super-Dog every few years? Let it go, DC, let it go...).
Some characters had some contemporary tweaks to the origin, like Superman in Byrne's "Man Of Steel" book, but mostly because there were holes in the original story that actually *needed* to be fixed. Now, ten years ago, when they tried it again with "Superman: Birthright", it didn't take. Partly because it was presented as the "new canon" despite it being completely contradictory to the other Superman books in dozens of ways, but also, and I'd argue MORE so, because DC never gave the fans a solid answer to the question of, "Well, what was so wrong with Byrne's version that it needed 'fixing'?" The answer is, there was nothing wrong with it at all, it's by far the simplest and best take on the Superman origin that anyone ever put out, but newer writers wanted to tell stories that didn't "fit" the established storyline. So, rather than changing their stories to fit the canon, as I'd argue they should have done, they made DC go back and retcon out the pre-established stories. "Birthright" was just an example of, "Well, it's been a few years, so let's just wipe everything clean", and in the end, they had to scrap THAT retcon just a couple years later because it so heavily contradicted everything. So, in the long run, they need not have bothered with any of it. What they had worked fine, and their "updated version" only screwed everything up completely.
So, the distinction becomes, there's updating and streamlining and fixing actual mistakes, which is a necessary task from time to time. And again, that's where Crisis came in handy, because it gave a straight, logical reason for the changes, most of which weren't even very prominent. And most importantly, at the end of the day, they way the characters themselves were portrayed was all still very consistent with how they'd always been shown. Nobody had a *completely* different backstory (mostly... let's not open the whole Hawkman/Power Girl can of worms, nobody's EVER fixing those messes), and nobody suddenly woke up one day acting completely out of character. No, "Remember when Starfire almost married Nightwing? Let's just make her someone who has random three-way sex-fests with Arsenal and Jason Todd, just because!" or crap like that.
The New 52, conversely, has mostly been making very sweeping changes to everything, absolutely everything, that's been established over the years, to the point where it's barely even recognizable to anyone who followed it before. Why is Wonder Woman such a cold, bloodthirsty bitch all of a sudden, for example? That's never been her character. She went from someone who preached compassion over fighting, who called everyone her "sister" and told even her enemies that she loved and pitied them, and now, she's ostensibly dating Superman, and when he says he loves her, she rebuffs him. That's... not who Diana is, at all, that's not how she acts, at all. They can say, "Well, it's just a new, different version." Which was necessary, why? Because the book doesn't sell? It's never going to sell, it's f*cking Wonder Woman, no boys will ever buy it and "girls don't read comics", so turning Diana into Season One Xena isn't going to fix anything at all.
Anyways, I like that you mentioned Crisis, because it's a really good example of how, when done right, you can "change everything" without really changing anything, because the important stuff is still the same, so both new and old fans are all still reading essentially the same story with the same major details. Crisis took a cluttered, messy DCU and gave it focus, opening it up for new readers and letting older fans catch up. The New 52 did a lot for the first group, but older readers don't seem to be able to get into it very well. Too much is too different, for no real reason, and arguably nothing is "better" than it was before. And I think the main difference between the two reboots is the intent: Streamlined revision (Crisis) versus Change for the sake of change (New 52). I'd argue that the former is necessary from time to time, the latter, not so much.
|