Quote:
Originally Posted by Commenter 42
I don't think I could possibly disagree with you more. It's not about making them giant turtles, it's about retaining the animal's characteristics.
|
but where should that line be drawn? turtles don't have muscular humanoid arms, teeth, humanoid eyes, 3 digits on each limb, or any of the other features displayed throughout every version of the turtles.
i guess it's a personal taste thing.
Quote:
|
They also do not "move as ninja's move" in the film...the move like pro wrestlers, or football players, which is clearly not the same. (not that a pro wrestler couldn't be stealthy, but you get my point.)
|
well, those still require the full range of human movement.
Quote:
|
They do not need a humanoid mouth anymore than a parrot needs a humanoid mouth to vocalize.
|
are you saying that you want them to speak as parrots do? as much of an extreme as some may say the PD turtles represent, the turtles vocalizing like parrots with beaks would swing farrrr to the other extreme. personally, i think that would look silly. traditionally, it's always been portrayed that they speak the same way that humans do.
Quote:
|
The 2014 versions are the absolute worst hybridization that could have been formulated, not the best.
|
i don't think i said they were the best? on the other hand i absolutely disagree that they are the worst.
Quote:
|
I can't speak to what they filmmakers were thinking, but I really don't care either, as the result isn't familiar, or interesting.
|
to this i can only say that i'm sorry you aren't getting what you want. i myself am certainly curious, as i find the designs seem to make attempts at conceptual coherence (mutant turtles that need to move and speak as humans do)
Quote:
You realize "bullet proof shells" is an unnecessary added absurdity right?
And how would the lack of a bridge make them stronger?
|
you realize that when you say "you realize", it comes off as really condescending right? so for the sake of civil discussion, maybe we cut back on that.
i think there's a bit of spider-man influence here- the proportionate strength of a turtle in this case. i'm not saying the lack of a bridge makes them stronger...i'm saying that if their shells have a smaller area of fusion (allowing for full human movement) then their greater physical integrity keeps their shells secure to their bodies.
Quote:
Also, please realize, none of this is personal, I just HATE the new designs.
I hate that with all the power they had, of the brilliant talent at ILM, this is where it landed.
|
that's cool. i have my issues as well (the outfits). but i get the feeling a lot of designs were looked at and even tried at the animation stage, and that they didn't work. i suppose we'll find out eventually.
but i do think there was some thought put into the designs, and that it wasn't all about aesthetics.