Classic movie turtles v2

[OrokuYoshiFilms]

I edited..... so what? Obviously I wasn't clear if you took me that way so I wanted to clarify.

Do you honestly think this perfect figure will ever exist? The people who are unsatisfied with them I feel would be satisfied with a few tweaks of this figure. Everyone's tone seems like they're just downright disgusted with them and I'm like "What is it... Really?" Is there anything else in you guy's collections that got it right in your eyes? So that I can understand why you don't like these. Like who's actually making these perfect figures? TMNT or otherwise.

[Candy Kappa]

You're the only one talking about "perfect figures".

No, I'm a realist, and I'd expect a line of collectible action figures using the name Classics lives up to some form of quality at least on-par with Marvel Legends if not MOTUC. Not something less then the basic line.

[OrokuYoshiFilms]

So in your opinion are those lines the best? ...and do you own figures from these lines as well? Because I wanna go see what you consider the best so I can compare and see why people here think the upcoming Classics are so bad. The true point of my questions earlier. I assumed everyone here would say the NECA turtles were the best.

[Candy Kappa]

I thought it was a better example comparing Playmates with Playmates, as they can and have made better action figures.

[OrokuYoshiFilms]

Ok those (Marvel) are some damn good figures, but the upcoming Classics I just feel need a more definitive head sculpt because they're all over the place but outside of that I think these are very good. Some of the early head sculpts are ugly though especially of Wolverine unmasked. They could use some work too. At this stage in the game though they're knocking it out of the park which I feel these Classics will be. I had the Movie Star turtles growing up so I was happy to see these. There's almost no positive comments on these but there is a boycott campaign. Anything better than these would be perfect which is why I kept throwing the word around.

...and thanks for actually taking me seriously for a second?

[DVD]

It's interesting to note the anger that a toy can engender.
Playmates figures, when first released looked very little like their tv or comic counterparts. The skin tone variations were there from the start. And articulation: what articulation? They were just basic, cute lil figures based around figures from a fledgling cartoon. Most releases had next to nothing to do with the show, and some of those remain to this day, among my favorite figures (Trek and Universal Monster Turtles).
Figuarts are putting out Don and Leo soon at a cost of nearly 4x this newest PM range. Me, I'm looking forward to them as they look great. The cost is justified in the product.
The recent repackaging and addition of accessories and head swaps is, to me a nice step. I'm looking forward to adding these to my collection (after I go back to work) .
I don't think Playmates will ever push hi end, hi retail value figures as its not their end game. That is left to the Fuguart types. They have, in my opinion, put out a set of decent, low price point figures that can be played with by a bunch of kids, or (in my case) be displayed as the toys they are: that's why I like them- they are toys .

[thundermaster612]

The only reason I like these is because I never got the 1990 ones

[slashpieturtlemix]

I think I'll get these. I need a good movie 2 set of figures

[Lil Karai]

As I mentioned in the other thread, if they can't paint the inside of the mouths, that means no $20 from me for that figure. it doesn't have to be perfect but that glaring lameness I just can't get past.


Between Mondo, NECA, FIGUARTS and whomever else is going to be getting in the TMNT game this year trust me there are much better things to save your money for. Announcements and pics will probably come before SDCC but worst case scenario we will see awesomeness in July.

However if you have lots of money and don't care about holding out for something better, go right ahead. Also if you're one of those people who'd rather buy 40 crappy figures at $10 each than 4 PHENOMINAL figures at $100 each, Then have at it! It's your money you can do what you like.

I do agree with Powder though that it's too bad that the people who complain and then still buy the figures are helping to enable inferior figures to be made.

[raph27]

Some of those new head sculpts are awful. One of Donnie's looks like Barney the Dinosaur. You still don't get my money, Playmates.

[strawberryfields]

Funny how some of the same people who buy those god-awful half shell heroes toddler toys are complaining about playmates low-end collectors toys not being high enough quality. There are so many movie accurate options at this point- these are just a cheap option for those who aren't sticklers for accuracy

[Powder]

Originally Posted by strawberryfields

There are so many movie accurate options at this point

By which you mean literally zero, considering nothing will be in stores for many months to come.

& you can both like a cheap toddler's toy & expect quality from an adult one...

[VaughnMichael]

I really hope once again they aren't doing this simply to stick it to NECA.
I'm in full agreement with Powder that while it's a nicer effort than their first release of these it's still sub par compared to what could be done.
If they really want to make some money from collectors have a movie Shredder or Tokka & Rahzar along side these turtles.
Or how about they just release that Shredder & Krang already.

[DVD]

Originally Posted by Powder

...you can both like a cheap toddler's toy & expect quality from an adult one...

Couldn't agree more.
Me, I love those lil HSH figures, and would complain about a design flaw in an otherwise awesome item (like only one door opening in the Big Chief TARDIS). Haha!!
Negative reaction to an unrealised expectation is natural. Me, I have my own expectations of Playmates, and this latest offering exceeds those actually. My expectations of the upcoming Figuart Turtles is way higher, and I'd likely be more critical of imperfections on those ..
Collecting is a funny old business methinks.

[nellyp]

This thread got pretty hostile pretty fast. I can see valid points from both sides. Definitely price plays a big factor. Obviously these are of a better quality than the basic figures in the nick line Playmates is producing which are like $8-$10 but they aren't at the opposite end to command a really high price point either.

$20 isn't too bad but most collectors are compelled to buy all 4 so that would be $80 which is starting to get pricey.

Lately I have been getting back into collecting the vintage playmates figures with a lot coming from eBay so as an example, I got a loose/complete Muckman and after shipping it was like $65. I was ok with it but my partner got really mad at me thinking it was way over priced (at the last few mins I had been outbid and we kinda had to go higher than we agreed on cause I wasn't going to let it get away). She didn't see the value in it though.

When I told her how it would be great to get the 1/4 scale Don from NECA and it would be around $100 US (approx $140 here) she told me I am crazy. She still doesn't see the value. I even told her that it was supposed to be 16" and she didn't care. Of course I will have to clear it with her before getting something like this. They say it's better to beg forgiveness than ask permission but that is just not true

Telling her I want to get a $20 figure (probably like $25 here) at least she is more receptive to that (even though I would rather get these and NECA's as well ). Just like the 1990 movie figures though I don't expect them to come out here though and I doubt I will go out of my way to import them but hard to say.

[DVD]

I like reading about getting permission from a partner to get a toy. Like, partners have replaced parents in the getting or not getting of new toys.
My girlfriend just shrugs off anything I get with a shake of the head and 'more baby stuff' comment. She just gets that I get this stuff..... Then goes and orders gym stuff or whatever, on my account !!! Haha!!
Bottom line tho , is we all get what we like if it is in a price range.
Everyone would like the Porche of the Ferrari but makes do with a Ford. What is neat about this game is there are items out there for all price ranges, and markets.

[strawberryfields]

Originally Posted by Powder

By which you mean literally zero, considering nothing will be in stores for many months to come.

& you can both like a cheap toddler's toy & expect quality from an adult one...

Cheap toddlers toys? If they were 3.99 maybe, but those things were 8 bucks a pack last time I saw them- the price/quality disparity for half shell heroes is far greater than the classic movie turtles v2, in my opinion. I mean look at this sh*t- I wouldn't give that to a 3 year old unless it was for some sort of punishment for misbehaving

http://www.toysrus.com/product/index...:61900116:TRUS

And 20 bucks including tax for this trash? These would hold a kids interest for about 12 hours before making their way to the bottom of the toy box to be forgotten about forever

http://www.target.com/p/teenage-muta...Q&gclsrc=aw.ds


These new movie turtles are probably going to be 20 bucks or less- I think the quality is on par w/ price, and for what they are they're pretty cool. If you don't like what playmates has to offer, wait it out until real adult collectors figures are released. I'm not defending playmates, but c'mon- do you really expect them to make adult grade collectors turtles for 20 bucks?

[I Crave Pizza No More]

They're OK, and I like the concept, but we no longer live in a time where there's a dearth of TMNT collectibles. 5-10 years ago these would have been a must-buy. These days, I have neither the room nor budget for them.

[Powder]

Originally Posted by strawberryfields

Cheap toddlers toys?

do you really expect them to make adult grade collectors turtles for 20 bucks?

When I said cheap I was referring to their quality, not the price point, but that's irrelevant.

Do I really expect them to make adult grade collector's turtles for 20 bucks? Maybe not, considering their track record. But do I see it as a reasonable possibility from a business/creative/etc standpoint, yes, I absolutely do. NECA & a bunch of other companies have built their business model on it, there's no reason Playmates can't try harder. Zero.

[strawberryfields]

Originally Posted by Powder

When I said cheap I was referring to their quality, not the price point, but that's irrelevant.

Do I really expect them to make adult grade collector's turtles for 20 bucks? Maybe not, considering their track record. But do I see it as a reasonable possibility from a business/creative/etc standpoint, yes, I absolutely do. NECA & a bunch of other companies have built their business model on it, there's no reason Playmates can't try harder. Zero.

Then there's zero reason they shouldn't try harder w/ half shell heroes, too. Believe me- if making expensive collector turtles for adults was reasonable from a business perspective, they'd be doing it. They're a company trying to make money- if there was money to be made, they'd be doing whatever they could to make it. The truth of the matter is children are the primary buyers of action figures, and children aren't sticklers for accuracy, and don't like to spend $69 dollars a figure. And even NECA turtles weren't successful enough to release the remaining figures they had planned. Its a niche market, something a mass production company like Playmates isn't looking to waste their time/resources on. I think of playmates collector line as something in between a standard kids line, and an adult line- for people who like turtles, but not enough to spend hundreds for movie or toon accuracy