Star Wars Episode 8

[ProactiveMan]

Ep.1 is a steamer, but I think Ep.2 may be the worst. It felt reactionary to me, like Uncle George was trying to clean up his mess by giving the people what they wanted. Unfortunately he had no idea what that was, but even so, he fell victim to one of the classic blunders. Never listen to your fans; most of them don't know what's good for them.

I'd like to have seen an Ep.2 and 3 written in a total vacuum. They probably wouldn't be great, but at least they wouldn't be compromised.

[Zak The Neutrino]

Originally Posted by ProactiveMan

Ep.1 is a steamer, but I think Ep.2 may be the worst. It felt reactionary to me, like Uncle George was trying to clean up his mess by giving the people what they wanted. Unfortunately he had no idea what that was, but even so, he fell victim to one of the classic blunders. Never listen to your fans; most of them don't know what's good for them.

I'd like to have seen an Ep.2 and 3 written in a total vacuum. They probably wouldn't be great, but at least they wouldn't be compromised.

It really is. If you fast forward from Naboo to back to Naboo it's not that bad but that middle part of the movie is crap.

Ep 2 is just horrible and the worst movie of all 7. Only the last 30 minutes are entertaining.

Ep 1-3 would have been much better was one movie taking out a lot of the side BS.

[TigerClaw]

Originally Posted by Zak The Neutrino

It really is. If you fast forward from Naboo to back to Naboo it's not that bad but that middle part of the movie is crap.

Ep 2 is just horrible and the worst movie of all 7. Only the last 30 minutes are entertaining.

Ep 1-3 would have been much better was one movie taking out a lot of the side BS.

EP 1 has its moments, The Podrace, The 3 way Lightsaber fight.

Same for EP 2 and 3, if you look pass all that stuff, and just look at those epic action scenes.