There sure are a LOT of Heidi movies.

turtle1237 · 05-09-2020, 08:52 AM

Yeah but which ones fits the feel of Heidi I guess?

grow up with Shirley Temple's version as a kid, but I know that one is no were NEAR close to the novel.

Jennifer Edwards version? made for tv?

The 1968 version in America is know for ruining a football game, but I heard its faithful? (Way before my time)

They had a more "Updated" one in the 70's with Heidi living in modern times, but I am not going for that.

Disney did have there own version in the 90's.

I have the 2005 and 2015/17? versions on dvd, and found them both pretty good. But I favor the 2005 version over the 2017.

Just wondering with all these Heidi movies, which one would you think is more true to the novel?

05-09-2020, 08:52 AM	#1
turtle1237 Stone Warrior Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 986	There sure are a LOT of Heidi movies. Yeah but which ones fits the feel of Heidi I guess? grow up with Shirley Temple's version as a kid, but I know that one is no were NEAR close to the novel. Jennifer Edwards version? made for tv? The 1968 version in America is know for ruining a football game, but I heard its faithful? (Way before my time) They had a more "Updated" one in the 70's with Heidi living in modern times, but I am not going for that. Disney did have there own version in the 90's. I have the 2005 and 2015/17? versions on dvd, and found them both pretty good. But I favor the 2005 version over the 2017. Just wondering with all these Heidi movies, which one would you think is more true to the novel?