The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Comic Discussion

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-04-2021, 06:20 PM   #81
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
The only thing I've ever seen you have a negative opinion on was "Rise", and I suspect that if there was more Furry Shipping in it you would've been in love with that, too.

This book ain't doing it for me. None of these lesbians are even hot, fer Chrissakes. What good is it? If it was, like, Krystal from Star Fox and Lola Bunny-caliber anthros making kissy-face, I might have time for it. But as-is? Feh!
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 06:25 PM   #82
Dejablue
Stone Warrior
 
Dejablue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: In the USA
Posts: 637
Omg I wasn't the only one who thought Angel being Nobody makes no sense in context...because there is no context.
__________________

^^^^
SHELLHEADS Inc.- A TMNT Discord!
Dejablue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 06:37 PM   #83
skylord
Thug
 
Join Date: Dec 2013
Posts: 64
It's been a while since I read that comic but I believe somebody makes a remark about her being nobody ie. unimportant and she spins it around on them in the end. In the context of the comic, it's a callback/clever retort and works fine as that but it feels pretty forced to become her alter ego.

Not the worst thing in the world but I think it's a symptom of a much bigger problem the series has with shoving every reference/character it can into it.
skylord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 06:58 PM   #84
CyberCubed
Overlord
 
CyberCubed's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 43,917
The Mirage Nobody is kinda a "nothing" character. I mean he's just a police officer when not in costume, so it's not like he was anything special either.
CyberCubed is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 07:17 PM   #85
Dejablue
Stone Warrior
 
Dejablue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: In the USA
Posts: 637
Yeah but the costume actually made sense. You couldn't tell who he was. Angel's costume has a clear face visor.
__________________

^^^^
SHELLHEADS Inc.- A TMNT Discord!
Dejablue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 08:24 PM   #86
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
Well, I'll say this, at least discussion on the comic seems more lively and heartfelt now than in recent memory.

Something good had to come out of this quagmire.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
I get a real kick outta you, man. Please post more often. I'm digging you more and more.
I assume this was addressed to me. Coming from the most creative person in the forums, this is a tremendous compliment, so thank you. It's also a huge responsibility to place on my measly shoulders. I'll see what I can do.

Quote:
Originally Posted by DragonSoul View Post
IDW TMNT brings no value in story or TMNT Lore.

BESIDES the Leatherhead and parasitic utrom arc (the only good thing). A tragic end for Leatherhead that is both terrifying and exhilarating for what can come next in terms of storytelling in the TMNT world. Perhaps Ch'rell and Saki lol.
I was going to ask if you don't see the same potential in Saki's arc. After reading it again, I believe that's what you meant by your last line? Ch'rell just has to be somehow different from Krang as well, there'd be no point in introducing him otherwise. Especially because the writers knew Krang would be coming back before too long.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
I don't think "It feels like fanfic" really nails the argument. I think "It feels like some female Smith College Gender Studies student's fanfic" is really more specifically the issue people are having.

Call me crazy, but I *think* that the broader TMNT audience wants less girl-on-girl action and multiple pages of characters talking about feelings, and more fistfights and Ninja Stuff. Basically, a more "masculine" presentation.
If it feels like it, reads like it, quacks like it...

Indeed, I (and probably most of the other readers) have no problem with romance or even girl-on-girl relationships. It only becomes problematic when those things threaten to overtake everything else in a book, especially one that's as rooted in martial arts and just action and adventure in general as TMNT.

This is a problem with most pop culture forays into PC culture: instead of creating something that can stand on its own two feet, such authors tend to hijack pre-existing works and fill them with anathemic themes and ideologies, which in turn causes said works to crumble from within because they're no longer organic and can no longer engage the public that made them popular. And yet they keep on doing this, either failing to realize the problem or just not caring so long as they get their message out there.

Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
This comic has literally been going for a decade now. By now we have multiple criminal organisations, Evil corporations, para-military forces, ninja clans, government conspiracies, time travel, alternate realities, a pantheon of deities, various alien races and dozens of characters.

The series had plenty of world building as is, only difference is that now the series literally ignores what it built up in favor of setting up even more characters and forcing the setting to be a boring slum.

Having various sub-plots, seeing multiple characters interact, shift allegiences to move their agenda along, finding new assets, new hinders and constantly shifting the setting is what kept the series interesting.

If you think making the rolling ball screech to a halt in favor of trying to get a lumpy piece of lead rolling instead is somehow a good direction, I'm not sure a hundred hours of lectures on narrative structure could help you understand why people are frustrated with this direction.
Thank you for putting this so much more beautifully than I ever could despite my numerous attempts.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TigerClaw View Post
I guess the comic in its current iteration isn't for everyone. But I'm enjoying what I been reading so far
Please don't construe this as anything other than an attempt to understand and maybe even empathize with your perspective, but given how short and "prepackaged" your compliments of the comic's current direction usually come across, could you elaborate on why you enjoy it so much? Isn't there a single element that you're not too fond of right now? Or in the past, if that helps?
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 09:01 PM   #87
lonewarrior20
Mad Scientist
 
lonewarrior20's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: pekin,IL
Posts: 1,879
i like it because we're getting to see the turtles growing up and actually socializing with a place that for the most part accepts them and see's them as people rather than freaks. you don't always need to fight, some times finding a peaceful resolution is the best way to do things. you guys are also forgetting something, sophie doesn't answer to us. campbell has to get idw/nickelodeons approval on stuff and has been told no on stuff. the worlds always changing and that's just it. who knows what thing's will be like 5 to 10 years now. maybe the comics canceled or still going on. one thing that's been proven is that the older generation tends to hate what the new generation does because it's different and that makes it threatening.

to put it bluntly i like what i like and you like what you like.

we're getting to see their feeling and it's not some confounded internal monologue. the pain in their eyes over past mistakes, wanting redemption, and trying to find their place in life after the death of splinter. and yes i know that we're focusing on 2ndary characters more than usual but they might play a key role in what's coming up.
__________________
Join my Patreon to help production for my Tmnt/GIJoe fan-comic
https://www.patreon.com/cw/lonewarrior20



"If the sun comes up tomorrow, it is only because of men of good will. That is all there is between us and the devil."
Kenny O'Donnell

https://www.deviantart.com/lonewarrior20 my fan comic/episodes of the lost season, weird ideas and my collection pics
lonewarrior20 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 09:04 PM   #88
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by lonewarrior20 View Post
i like it because we're getting to see the turtles growing up and actually socializing with a place that for the most part accepts them and see's them as people rather than freaks. you don't always need to fight, some times finding a peaceful resolution is the best way to do things. you guys are also forgetting something, sophie doesn't answer to us. campbell has to get idw/nickelodeons approval on stuff and has been told no on stuff. the worlds always changing and that's just it. who knows what thing's will be like 5 to 10 years now. maybe the comics canceled or still going on. one thing that's been proven is that the older generation tends to hate what the new generation does because it's different and that makes it threatening.

to put it bluntly i like what i like and you like what you like.

we're getting to see their feeling and it's not some confounded internal monologue. the pain in their eyes over past mistakes, wanting redemption, and trying to find their place in life after the death of splinter. and yes i know that we're focusing on 2ndary characters more than usual but they might play a key role in what's coming up.
That's one of the things I love about this current arc. The Turtles finally get to do the things they always dreamed about but couldn't among humans. Now they have the opportunity to make a difference by helping this mutant town community. I'm so glad to read the comics at this point because I didnt want to read about what I already know. Having known the history of TMNT, I decided to skip a big chunk of it because to me its the same old story again. So I rather read when everything is already established.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ChosenOne View Post
Please don't construe this as anything other than an attempt to understand and maybe even empathize with your perspective, but given how short and "prepackaged" your compliments of the comic's current direction usually come across, could you elaborate on why you enjoy it so much? Isn't there a single element that you're not too fond of right now? Or in the past, if that helps?
I'm enjoying all the quieter moments where you see the characters interacting and being themselves, when they are not always saving the world.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305

Last edited by TigerClaw; 02-04-2021 at 09:10 PM.
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 09:43 PM   #89
Dejablue
Stone Warrior
 
Dejablue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: In the USA
Posts: 637
Quote:
Originally Posted by lonewarrior20 View Post
i like it because we're getting to see the turtles growing up and actually socializing with a place that for the most part accepts them and see's them as people rather than freaks. you don't always need to fight, some times finding a peaceful resolution is the best way to do things. you guys are also forgetting something, sophie doesn't answer to us. campbell has to get idw/nickelodeons approval on stuff and has been told no on stuff. the worlds always changing and that's just it. who knows what thing's will be like 5 to 10 years now. maybe the comics canceled or still going on. one thing that's been proven is that the older generation tends to hate what the new generation does because it's different and that makes it threatening.

to put it bluntly i like what i like and you like what you like.

we're getting to see their feeling and it's not some confounded internal monologue. the pain in their eyes over past mistakes, wanting redemption, and trying to find their place in life after the death of splinter. and yes i know that we're focusing on 2ndary characters more than usual but they might play a key role in what's coming up.

I want to agree as this is what I wanted. But she didn't do enough with the time she had and focused most characterization of any significance on Jennika alone. The turtles have been backup singers to her inner angst for most of this.

Im thinking back to whats happened to the turtles on a personal level and so far all we got was:

- Leonardo reading books and growing flowers. He didn't really need Mutant Town to exist to do these things. You might argue he teaches at the dojo, but he is already the leader of his clan and trains them daily, I think if Lita had bonded to him instead of Jennika I would like this development more.

I mean damn they even had Leo say he has a hard time dealing with kids. So it felt like a wide n obvious opening for character development.

- Michelangelo starts a radio show in service of the writer's political agenda (he becomes a mouth piece so it doesn't even feel like Michelangelo)

- Donatello becomes Fix It Felix which is fine I guess. Mona Lisa makes bedroom eyes at him until he tells her the truth of his origins and she dumps him before they even become a couple. Sooo that was pointless.

- Raphael probably has the most benefit by going on a proper date with Alopex, after literal years of being told that they like each other, we are finally getting to see it.

- Jennika gets to handle all the deeper issues of identity and loss with her page time, and in her mini she is actually making narrative progress to finding a solution to Mutant town. Also starting a band and it just feels wrong to me that none of the brothers want to get in on that.
__________________

^^^^
SHELLHEADS Inc.- A TMNT Discord!

Last edited by Dejablue; 02-04-2021 at 10:07 PM.
Dejablue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 09:49 PM   #90
neatoman
Overlord
 
neatoman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,097
Quote:
Originally Posted by lonewarrior20 View Post
i like it because we're getting to see the turtles growing up and actually socializing with a place that for the most part accepts them and see's them as people rather than freaks.

you don't always need to fight, some times finding a peaceful resolution is the best way to do things.

you guys are also forgetting something, sophie doesn't answer to us. campbell has to get idw/nickelodeons approval on stuff and has been told no on stuff. the worlds always changing and that's just it. who knows what thing's will be like 5 to 10 years now. maybe the comics canceled or still going on.

one thing that's been proven is that the older generation tends to hate what the new generation does because it's different and that makes it threatening.

to put it bluntly i like what i like and you like what you like.

we're getting to see their feeling and it's not some confounded internal monologue.

the pain in their eyes over past mistakes, wanting redemption, and trying to find their place in life after the death of splinter.

and yes i know that we're focusing on 2ndary characters more than usual but they might play a key role in what's coming up.
Is your shift key broken?

Anyway. Here's a rebuttal:
  1. You don't need to have "the place that accepts them" literally consume the entire narrative to have a function in said narrative.
  2. The series was not all about fighting up until this point, there was literally a trial arc in case you don't remember, as well as several other non-violent aspects to what the characters did. If you think this arc somehow introduced non-violent solutions, you have simply not been paying attention. All it really did was minimize conflict and make it easily resolved, which is lame. No, you don't need violent solutions or super high stakes to make a story interesting, but you still need persistant conflict that is difficult to resolve and the resolution needs to have consequences.
  3. Yes, Sophie is beholden to the word of Viacom, so what? So was Tom, Mateus, Dustin and all the other writers. We all know they were. How is this even remotely an argument?
  4. If your argument is about the creative freedom Sophie may or may not have, that isn't important. It doesn't matter where the comic falls on the spectrum between "The writer gets to do whatever she wants" to "Basically written by a committee". If the comic has flaws it doesn't matter who is behind it or why they are there, they should still be adressed.
  5. You can't dismiss complaints as people feeling "threatened". You need to analyse the argument and make a counter-argument that adresses what they're trying to say.
  6. A "blunt" statement like "i like what i like and you like what you like" is not an argument because it doesn't adress any actual points.
  7. Wanting to fix what went wrong isn't a bad concept but it is handled in an awkward way. We don't need pages upon pages of montages to convey that. It just takes up way more space than it needs to and it legitimately makes this frustrating to read.
  8. Yeah they "might" play a bigger role... Or maybe Lita ends up getting eaten alive by a Salamandrian? For all we know, there are no big plans for these new characters, they could just fade away as soon as a different writer takes over. What they shouldn't do however is essentially replace the characters we were already invested in, because their arcs clearly nowhere near done. It basically just feels like the series went off the rails.

In short, I am not complaining because there isn't violence, or because the writer doesn't "answer to me" (whatever that means). I am critisising this arc because the conflict is minimalistic, there are too few consequences to the characters' actions, some character actions make very little sense to me, the characters are stuck in a slum, various conflicts are being ignored, multiple characters have been shoved to the sidelines, way too many new characters have been introduced, these new characters haven't done much to alter the stakes and it has been very slow.

And I'm sorry but not all of these critisms are based on purely subjective problems, they can't all be dismissed as a matter of taste. Some of these problems break the core pillars of storytelling, a very fundamental flaw indeed.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH View Post
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.
Hahahaha!
neatoman is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 10:17 PM   #91
Mutant Ninja Anole
Stone Warrior
 
Mutant Ninja Anole's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: USA
Posts: 591
I have mixed feelings about the current arc.

Not going to comb through every objection here, but I guess I’ll talk about what sort of things I like. While I do enjoy my hard hitting superhero and anime fights and listen to my share of power metal, I never clicked Ninja Turtles quite as firmly into the Richard Corben style “Male Fantasy” that some people seem to have. Well that and my version of a “Male Fantasy” might involve conquering a foreign army or it might involve having coffee at 6:30 am on a scenic porch with a clothbound book. Depends on the mood.

(strap in, perhaps with a cup of coffee) TMNT came at a certain point in young MNA’s development. Looking back, it probably affected a lot of my tastes, and one aspect of that is that I do love a good transformation scene/story. Whether it’s scary like the wolf-man, a kind of ‘power fantasy’ like the Hulk, etc, or just the “Wouldn’t it be cool to turn into a ninja dinosaur?” that 10 year old me found intriguing. Also about this time, I had read to me Mrs Frisby and the Rats of NIMH in class, and it became one of my favorite books. Obviously there’s the aspect of animals becoming smart but also the question of what happens when this group of non human beings has to build a society from scratch. Is it okay to steal from humans? Should they work to become self sufficient? Does intelligence demand morality? What if the rats became organized and numerous enough to build a society to compete with humanity? Stay with me, this will be relevant in a moment.

As I grew older I also appreciated things like Kafka’s Metamorphsis, transformation as a metaphor for other things, alienation, exploring what it means to be human, etc. And I have always had, in my mind, though I never bothered to write fanfiction on the TMNT myself, what sort of story you could tell with the Turtles and TMNT mutants trying to build their own society. Plus politics, war, the stuff that itches my history loving side. We’ve had similar stories I know, but that sort of world building just appeals to me. I could plot out maps and charts describing fictional countries and cultures for hours.

What I’m saying is that ‘effeminate’ storytelling or not, Mutant Town as a concept appeals to me on several different levels. Throw in Campbell’s artwork, things like a cool new Mona Lisa design and I will forgive a lot of other stuff. Heck I like the teasing of a relationship with Mona and Don, they make sense and get a weird kick out of those fans who didn’t like it (weirdly, I saw fans in other parts of the web complaining about it because obviously Donatello is gay and hooking him with Mona is erasure, ha). And yes, I do like seeing the Turtles actually being able to live out in the open.

What sort of disappoints me is that I feel they could be doing more with what they have and some of the stuff they are doing just...seems off. Sally stepping up as an alternate leader to Hob? Awesome. Trying to have an election? Eh...stretches my belief. And the dialogue, I just can’t explain it but it bugs me. There’s other things but truthfully, it just hadn’t always clicked for me in quite the way I was hoping. I do think the Jennika Mini series has, on average, done a better job of getting to some of the stuff I really want Mutant Town to explore: People struggling to adapt to their new life, how the rest of the world is reacting, new factions, alliances and developments. I’d love to see a person who was at first angry at Hob for mutating them gradually become radicalized into joining him as a devout Mutanimal. Or April weighing her position with Stockman and playing the long game against what the Turtles see as day to day needs for the mutant inhabitants. What about Null? as has been suggested a bunch.

The result of all this is when I see people praising the main series as the greatest thing ever I cringe, but most of the time when people complain I end up not agreeing with their criticisms. And I’m frustrated by people calling for Mutant Town to go away because the potential is so huge in my mind, and we’ve already seen post apocalyptic mutant futures teased several times. Part of me really wants the world to get gradually turned into the old Tabletop RPG.

A final note, while some metaphors are specific, both X-men and TMNT Mutants are probably best seen less as 1 to 1 analogies for anything, but as broad examples of feeling alienated and apart, being an ‘other.’ Could be a person of a different ethnicity, could be an evangelical kid stuck in a public school surrounded by kids trying to get him to cuss and use drugs, or even just being the “Weird kid.” Even the most normal of us understand that feeling and even if not all experiences are equal, it is a way for us to all identify with a fictional character when we fill in the blanks ourselves.
__________________
My stupid Tumblr

Last edited by Mutant Ninja Anole; 02-04-2021 at 10:55 PM.
Mutant Ninja Anole is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 10:21 PM   #92
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mutant Ninja Anole View Post
I have mixed feelings about the current arc.
I agree with pretty much everything you said. That's what I was expecting from our time in Mutant Town before it turned into a slog through one uninteresting arc after another.

And FWIW, I could totally see Donatello being asexual. Gay, not so much.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mutant Ninja Anole View Post
Well that and my version of a “Male Fantasy” might involve conquering a foreign army or it might involve having coffee at 6:30 am on a scenic porch with a clothbound book. Depends on the mood.
Sounds like something one would do after conquering a foreign army.
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 10:25 PM   #93
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Y'know what it kinda reminds me of? Chuck Austen's run on Action Comics. Lotta the same problems. Particularly Superman being sidelined for big chunks of it so that Chuck could do stuff with other characters instead (and several other characters being written pretty wildly out-of-character in service to Chuck's story whether or not it made sense). And it had some lousy villains. They spent a year on it and in the end it felt like just a complete waste of everyone's time. Like, obviously the stuff he was writing was super-important to him... but nobody else cared one bit.

That situation was actually way worse, though. Particularly because there were three other monthly Superman books coming out at that time, and that only amplified just how bad that one was. BUT, on the upside... there were three other Superman books coming out every month, so if you didn't like Action Comics you could still get your fix elsewhere. So... maybe it wasn't altogether worse after all.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ChosenOne View Post
I assume this was addressed to me. Coming from the most creative person in the forums, this is a tremendous compliment, so thank you. It's also a huge responsibility to place on my measly shoulders. I'll see what I can do.
Aw, shucks. You're alright, You.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 10:37 PM   #94
staypuftweepel
Foot Soldier
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 169
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dejablue View Post
- Jennika gets to handle all the deeper issues of identity and loss with her page time, and in her mini she is actually making narrative progress to finding a solution to Mutant town. Also starting a band and it just feels wrong to me that none of the brothers want to get in on that.
There’s a lot of things I really dislike about the new Tmnt comic Since 101 and Jennika being in a band is really high up on that list. It’s the most cliched thing they could have done with her. “She’s the brand new hip female turtle! She’s totally punk rock and plays in a band!” She’s the same female character that shows up in every book now. Maybe she can be in a band with Spider Gwen. While I thought Jennika was a jumping over the shark point in the book I still read it and tried to give her a shot. Personally I’d prefer her personality when they were introducing her. She at least seemed mysterious and you didn’t know much about her yet. That was better. It’d be better if they went in a different direction with her instead of just trying to appease the Twitter masses.

I read this in Lonewarrior20’s response above “one thing that's been proven is that the older generation tends to hate what the new generation does because it's different and that makes it threatening.“

And that’s completely wrong. There’s lots of things I love about new turtles media. I liked the 2012 cartoon a lot. For a time I really liked the IDW comic. As long as somethings good people will buy your stuff even if they’re hesitant at first because it’s new and scary. I think it’s also incorrect to think that the new generation is going to keep this book afloat. While there may be some younger people reading this book, the majority of people are old fogey’s like myself who still buy Tmnt comics. I’d be curious to see the sales numbers, but comichron hasn’t been too up to date lately.

Last edited by staypuftweepel; 02-04-2021 at 10:43 PM.
staypuftweepel is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 10:39 PM   #95
lonewarrior20
Mad Scientist
 
lonewarrior20's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: pekin,IL
Posts: 1,879
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
Is your shift key broken?
it's just how i type. i'm gonna be quiet for a while and think about things.
__________________
Join my Patreon to help production for my Tmnt/GIJoe fan-comic
https://www.patreon.com/cw/lonewarrior20



"If the sun comes up tomorrow, it is only because of men of good will. That is all there is between us and the devil."
Kenny O'Donnell

https://www.deviantart.com/lonewarrior20 my fan comic/episodes of the lost season, weird ideas and my collection pics
lonewarrior20 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2021, 11:36 PM   #96
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Yeah, I kinda think the whole "Old people are just afraid of New Things" argument people love to pull out nowadays needs to be put to bed. It's one of the worst defenses people try and pull out about stuff like this.

Part of that "age" business includes experience and perspective. With regard to reading stuff, that can have a huge impact. Sometimes, you can read something as a kid, a teen, a young adult, and a regular adult, and it's only at that later stage that you start to notice certain things that maybe didn't matter to you as a kid or young adult. Stuff like "Structurally, this is bad" or "This dialog is terrible". Could be any book or movie or story. There's stuff I thought was brilliant when I saw it at age 20 but looking at it again now is like "Holy sh*t, that's awful." And that includes things I myself have written. 20-year-old Me thought he was a genius; Me Today wants to slap the sh*t out of that guy.

Has very little at all to do with "old people are afraid of New Things." For one thing, nobody is "threatened by" or "afraid of" anything.

What it is, is a natural evolution to the state of one's ability to think critically. As a kid, you don't notice things suck. As a teen and young adult, you start to notice that things suck, but can't particularly articulate as to Why that is. And then later on, as a an adult who's seen more, done more, and in this case read and/or written more, you can not only tell when something sucks, but WHY that is. That kind of a critical lens only develops with time and perspective.

And so whenever anyone pulls the "Old People are just afraid of New Ideas" card, I just roll my eyes. "New Ideas" are fine... when they justify themselves. Not all of them do that, unfortunately. Sometimes Yes, Sometimes No.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2021, 12:30 AM   #97
DragonSoul
Random Punk
 
DragonSoul's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2020
Location: Canada
Posts: 36
Before continuing my argument I do need to say that I am not against Fanfiction as I enjoy it for the exploration of ideas. My interest in fanfiction is also what made me realize how much IDW TMNT's story is strikingly similar to fanfiction from the past. I also feel like I need to clarify what I mean by using the term "fanfiction." By fanfiction I mean the overemphasis on:
  • Dailiness without conflict
  • Romance heavy plots for the sheer sake of it
  • Character portrayals that color outside the lines
  • Story arcs that explore without adherence to logic
  • Godmoding OCs

Of course bad writing can afflict anyone who dares to write a story. So, I do not strictly view Fanfiction as bad writing as there are good ones. Yet it is also true that the majority of Fanfiction suffers greatly from my points made above which results in the labelling as Fanfiction-esque.

and I have to agree with some of the points made before that it generally does suck that the turtles: Leonardo, Donatello, Michaelangelo, and Raphael are simply side characters in their own story. Furthermore, I also dislike their excessive need to disparage anyone that is not Leonardo and the OCs.

I would like to add the the tally that I too hate Mutant Town because at its core it is just a furry version of X-men with tons of "shipping." My anthropology background also dislikes the logical pitfalls of Mutant Town as well.
DragonSoul is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2021, 01:59 AM   #98
Dejablue
Stone Warrior
 
Dejablue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: In the USA
Posts: 637
My problem with Mutant Town is, given the overall tone of IDW TMNT, this premise doesn’t make sense as it is currently presented. It feels more at home in Rise. I’m pretty sure even 87 TMNT you would get a generic torches and pitchfork type scene of civy mutants running through the streets trying to find who is responsible.

So Old Hob nukes a slice of Manhattan, which according to a vaguely detailed map, kind of looks like it is near the Empire State Building. A friend tells me this would grind the entire island to a halt as most of the economy runs through and around that area. And instead of it being a mere hundred to 3000 people mutated, the number is more likely closer to 10,000 people mutated. No wonder there is a food shortage. Or at least there was one. That plot thread went nowhere. Everybody seems pretty well fed.

So Hobs is failing to properly distribute food,(but not really) my biggest issue with this is why is Hob even still there? Him , Manray, Pete and Herman should have gotten the hell out of dodge. Why did they stay behind the walls with the masses of newly mutated civilians who, under the best of circumstances, would be in the eager process of murdering him right now. Or they would have done so months ago, and Sally would probably also be dead. And Raphael too as he had a hand in this. Hob wouldn’t be able to sit and ‘Max Payne drink’ his day away in peace.

This is like ISIS rolling up to America after bombing a building and being like “we are president now.” What the Mutanimals did was an act of terrorism, not the start of some new nation.
  • Do mutants still get to vote?
  • Do they have to pay taxes?
  • Are they all using the internet to blog about what it’s like to be a mutant?
  • Does anybody besides Jennika have a plan besides sitting around talking about their feelings?
  • Will Alopex ever be a ninja instead of just Raph’s girlfriend ever again?
    Who knows.

Speaking of voting, why do these people even give a crap about voting for a mayor, in this situation they should only care about food, shelter, not dying, and getting un-mutated. Electing a new mayor solves none of these issues, confronting Hob does. Thinking about the insane fringe, groups like Q-Anon spread so quickly under peaceful circumstances, there should be gangs and cults all over the place in a scenario as extreme as this.

The area infected isn’t large enough to sustain anything so it's not like these mutants can just wake up and go to work, most of them probably didn’t live near their jobs anyway. So scenes of mutants walking around like life is normal are just silly. The streets should be deserted outside of looting and wanton destruction after 6 months of no sign of a possible cure in sight. And don’t even get me started on suicide statistics. Things ought to be very grim by now, “not hip and cool furry rock concert time”. This is why the scene with Mona-Lisa on Mikey’s radio show rubs me the wrong way. The problem is not something democracy can solve. It’s insane that these people haven’t lynched Hob by now anyway let alone “peacefully protest”.

A big chunk of this rant is Hob centric. On top of him weirdly deciding to stay and incompetently govern the very people he hated, he is also doing the very thing that drove him to terrorism in the first place. In kahoots with Karai? Exploiting mutants? Why? It makes no sense.
__________________

^^^^
SHELLHEADS Inc.- A TMNT Discord!

Last edited by Dejablue; 02-05-2021 at 02:04 AM.
Dejablue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2021, 03:38 AM   #99
Zog The Magnificent
Stone Warrior
 
Zog The Magnificent's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2015
Posts: 830
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dejablue View Post
My problem with Mutant Town is, given the overall tone of IDW TMNT, this premise doesn’t make sense as it is currently presented. It feels more at home in Rise. I’m pretty sure even 87 TMNT you would get a generic torches and pitchfork type scene of civy mutants running through the streets trying to find who is responsible.

So Old Hob nukes a slice of Manhattan, which according to a vaguely detailed map, kind of looks like it is near the Empire State Building. A friend tells me this would grind the entire island to a halt as most of the economy runs through and around that area. And instead of it being a mere hundred to 3000 people mutated, the number is more likely closer to 10,000 people mutated. No wonder there is a food shortage. Or at least there was one. That plot thread went nowhere. Everybody seems pretty well fed.

So Hobs is failing to properly distribute food,(but not really) my biggest issue with this is why is Hob even still there? Him , Manray, Pete and Herman should have gotten the hell out of dodge. Why did they stay behind the walls with the masses of newly mutated civilians who, under the best of circumstances, would be in the eager process of murdering him right now. Or they would have done so months ago, and Sally would probably also be dead. And Raphael too as he had a hand in this. Hob wouldn’t be able to sit and ‘Max Payne drink’ his day away in peace.

This is like ISIS rolling up to America after bombing a building and being like “we are president now.” What the Mutanimals did was an act of terrorism, not the start of some new nation.
  • Do mutants still get to vote?
  • Do they have to pay taxes?
  • Are they all using the internet to blog about what it’s like to be a mutant?
  • Does anybody besides Jennika have a plan besides sitting around talking about their feelings?
  • Will Alopex ever be a ninja instead of just Raph’s girlfriend ever again?
    Who knows.

Speaking of voting, why do these people even give a crap about voting for a mayor, in this situation they should only care about food, shelter, not dying, and getting un-mutated. Electing a new mayor solves none of these issues, confronting Hob does. Thinking about the insane fringe, groups like Q-Anon spread so quickly under peaceful circumstances, there should be gangs and cults all over the place in a scenario as extreme as this.

The area infected isn’t large enough to sustain anything so it's not like these mutants can just wake up and go to work, most of them probably didn’t live near their jobs anyway. So scenes of mutants walking around like life is normal are just silly. The streets should be deserted outside of looting and wanton destruction after 6 months of no sign of a possible cure in sight. And don’t even get me started on suicide statistics. Things ought to be very grim by now, “not hip and cool furry rock concert time”. This is why the scene with Mona-Lisa on Mikey’s radio show rubs me the wrong way. The problem is not something democracy can solve. It’s insane that these people haven’t lynched Hob by now anyway let alone “peacefully protest”.

A big chunk of this rant is Hob centric. On top of him weirdly deciding to stay and incompetently govern the very people he hated, he is also doing the very thing that drove him to terrorism in the first place. In kahoots with Karai? Exploiting mutants? Why? It makes no sense.
That's a really good way of explaining it, actually. I actually like the idea on principle, but the problem is that the breather is starting to go on for too long, and like you've articulated, they haven't actually written a story that fullly addresses the implications of the situation they've created. The potential is what stops this from being a bad idea outright, but you've put it very well; it has essentially become a setpice, in the same way that Community's later seasons didn't actually use the fact that they were at a community college all that much. Mutant Town is, in many ways, no more than a location where the story is, rather than what the story is about.
Zog The Magnificent is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2021, 05:53 AM   #100
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dejablue View Post
Thinking about the insane fringe, groups like Q-Anon spread so quickly under peaceful circumstances, there should be gangs and cults all over the place in a scenario as extreme as this.

(...)

It’s insane that these people haven’t lynched Hob by now anyway let alone “peacefully protest”.
There are. We all know what "peaceful protest" is BLM-speak for...

I do indeed like the ideas you've put forward, especially the one of Hob, the other Mutanimals and even Raph being hunted down for their part in the bomb going off. This whole concept has been terribly underutilized. I'd even like to see a scenario where the residents of Mutant Town become fed up with the whole thing and decide to storm the walls, leading to a tense stand-off and eventually the EPF (it is the EPF doing perimeter security, right? I forget) opening fire on the mutated civilians when they try to get out of the zone, and the Turtles having to handle both the riot and the trigger-happy agents. At least then, if there were any unsubtle political messages inserted into the plot, they wouldn't feel so tone-deaf and inappopriate.
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:13 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.