Quote:
Originally Posted by hypered1
As I said in my previous comment, it was Bebop and Natsu who decide they wouldn't compete.
The person on reddit was trying to say that it was the crowd and/or the turtles that wouldn't let them play which isn't the case at all. Sally did tell them to leave the club but that was after Rocksteady began threatening to start a fight.
Either the reddit person was incorrectly repeating what they've only heard about the issue or they've actually read it and they're being deliberately disingenuous with the facts to twist them into something sounds far worse than the truth.
|
Um, Jennika plays, Bebop and Rocksteady both act out of character and don't end up competing, and then when he protests, they get kicked out of the club without getting to play, then leave without a fight. Nothing in the original account contradicts the events of the comic, and everything that was said was entirely within the spirit of what happens. Nothing about it is "deliberately disingenuous." The points you take issue with almost seem like nitpicking at this point.
As for the arc itself, it was one of the absolute dumbest things TMNT has ever done. Every problem it has has already been desribed in great detail on the other issue threads, but I think the easiest way to see why it failed is that they tried to do a Battle of the Bands, a story that requires
sound, in a print medium. There was never any chance of a real payoff even if both sides did compete. And even if they did, all that would happen would be that they would take 5 extra pages to tell us that Jennika won and we'd have to take their word for it since we wouldn't be able to hear any of it anyways.