The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Comic Discussion

Notices

View Poll Results: Will we hit issue 200?
Yes 36 48.65%
No 38 51.35%
Voters: 74. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-26-2022, 11:13 AM   #61
IMJ
Emperor
 
IMJ's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Midwest, U.S.A.
Posts: 8,915
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChosenOne View Post
That's a damn shame, you're missing out on a great career at IDW.

Dromer post of the month, right there! I'll admit that I used to like that IDW was carrying the "revive and continue the aging I.P." torch. Way more than a decade ago now I liked it.

But I think as for the rest of the mud-flinging in this thread it's safe to say that IDW has embraced woke nonsense to an extreme and their creative staff at large has doubled down on their virtue signaling even as sales have tanked and IDW has lost licenses. IDW has largely become a trash factory. It's not even a valid conversational-premise anymore as to whether or not their titles have merit or could be defended - it's a sinking ship. Only IDW-planted-posters and the deepest of clingers-on to their books continue to claim otherwise.

It's another example of woke $#!( idiots going on about "haters" and other such nonsense, but in complete disregard for the fact that the people they are rallying against as their "haters" don't even begin to touch the number of the world population who is not buying the books. If you sell a paltry 9,000 copies of a comic in a month globally and you complain that the people who aren't reading it are "bigots", "haters" and other nonsense then you are failing to realize that you are assaulting 99% of the world who doesn't want to read your woke $#!(. Therefore the problem is you and not your alleged "hate brigade".

When are you woke $#!( people going to realize that? You aren't fighting the "good" fight. Your just creating a fight.

BTW - ChoseOne, your post was honestly great. The rest of my post wasn't directed at your comment at all - you know... in case the context is lost to the internet ether and all that.

Last edited by IMJ; 01-26-2022 at 11:22 AM.
IMJ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 11:31 AM   #62
Bahamut810
Stone Warrior
 
Join Date: May 2021
Location: USA
Posts: 704
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrmaczaps View Post
Why not? What're you gonna do about it?
No one can really do anything except the mods. The thing is, there is no need to do it. How she views herself is up to her. She is not around you at all. I'm not on her social media all the time or anything...but she seems pretty chill about some of the more woke twitter stuff out there and is not crapping on everyone who has different opinions (that I have seen). If she were, then yeah be and asshole about it. At the moment, she just writes a story you don't like.

BUT...I was wondering about the lies as well. I don't recall every hearing about anything solid she has lied about/stolen. You can dispute things that come down to opinion, which were the only thing mention, but not fact. If you are going to make an accusation then back it up with fact otherwise its a statement that can and *should* be disregarded.
Bahamut810 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 11:38 AM   #63
ChosenOne
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 3,951
Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post

Dromer post of the month, right there!

(...)

BTW - ChoseOne, your post was honestly great. The rest of my post wasn't directed at your comment at all - you know... in case the context is lost to the internet ether and all that.
Thanks!

Also, you guys... Please remain civilized and don't hate on Campbell for who she is/believes she is. That's her own personal matter and beside the point when it comes to the damage she has wrought on this comic, not to mention it does nothing but make us - her critics - look bad. There's plenty to criticize her for, no need to go below the belt in such a vicious manner.
ChosenOne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 12:41 PM   #64
mrmaczaps
Banned
 
mrmaczaps's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Maine
Posts: 2,619
Quote:
Originally Posted by AquaParade View Post
I get it. I don't get why it bothers anyone though. Literally has zero effect on your life.

Either way, I really dig Sophie's art and while I'm not into the story she's crafted over the last 25 issues, I still respect her. And I bet I'd be reading the book, flaws and all, if she were actually allowed to cut loose a bit.
Demanding people play into your delusions does affect them. And in some places, not playing into their delusions can land someone in jail. Thats a bit much. I don't HAVE to respect anyone, unless they first earn it.
mrmaczaps is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 12:44 PM   #65
mrmaczaps
Banned
 
mrmaczaps's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Maine
Posts: 2,619
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChosenOne View Post
Thanks!

Also, you guys... Please remain civilized and don't hate on Campbell for who she is/believes she is. That's her own personal matter and beside the point when it comes to the damage she has wrought on this comic, not to mention it does nothing but make us - her critics - look bad. There's plenty to criticize her for, no need to go below the belt in such a vicious manner.
Its out there because Campbell wishes everyone to play into Campbell's delusion. I do not hate Campbell. I feel bad that rather than getting good help for the issues of the brain, this "modern" route was taken.... and everyone wishes the world to comply with it. I used to enjoy Campbell's work on the Turtles back during Mirage but this 101-124 hot garbage... Not even remotely.
mrmaczaps is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 01:10 PM   #66
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
That's not actually what I was getting at BUT I like that people are thinking.

So here's three right off the top of my head. Which triggered1 or some other plant/apologist is going to no doubt refute by moving the goalposts back and saying it's not good enough. But since baby needs their bottle, I'll indulge even though I don't have to.

1: Insisted that Sheena the punk-rocker was in no way influenced by the Ramones song "Sheena Is A Punk Rocker". Totally unrelated, you guys. Even though that song is one of only two Ramones songs anyone has ever heard of, and in fact EVERYONE has heard because it still gets daily radio play and is a popular staple of movies, TV shows, etc. Anyone who ever saw "Pet Semetary" has heard it, specifically right before the kid gets hit by the truck.

When confronted about this VERY on-the-nose reference, Campbell doubles-down and insists they've never even HEARD of the song. Yeah, okay. It's not even a big deal, it's a dumb reference since it's so blatant BUT not the kinda thing a person should lie about. Just admit "Yeah, I thought it was funny but I guess not everyone does." That's all. Chose to lie instead. Boo. Offsides.

2. When confronted about how their "The fate of the future depends on winning a Battle of the Bands!" plotline was heavily-derivative of Bill & Ted, and furthermore, that the timing of it was a bit suspect since Bill & Ted 3 was coming out at the exact same time... Campbell denies the similarity of concept AND - here's the kicker - says with a straight face "I had no idea Bill & Ted 3 was coming out or even existed." Despite the fact that it was one of THE most-hyped and heavily-advertised movies of the early pandemic, with commercials for it running CONSTANTLY. "I had no idea it was a thing!" Jesus. If a person went online AT ALL in 2020 - and we know for a fact that Campbell is online fairly often - they knew damn well about that movie. YouTube only made it an unskippable ad and every single entertainment website was only promoting it for weeks and months with articles and banner ads. But yeah, totally obscure. Come on.

3. At one point when a particularly bad issue of TMNT came out and people were being "mean" about it, Campbell's usual gang of blue-haired snowflakes went running to Twitter with cocoa and hugs. I was called out by name on there by some idiot, so despite not having Twitter I decided to see what people in the thread were saying. Turns out it was just the usual "That Technodrome place is full of Big Meanies! Don't let them get to you!" ass-licking nonsense.

BUT. Campbell indeed replied to someone by claiming, "I actually haven't been there (this forum) for months." Other times they claimed to have quit the forum entirely.

I can personally attest that at that time, and in fact EVERY time Campbell claimed to have quit the forum, not been on in months, whatever... I nonetheless saw them logged in EVERY SINGLE DAY for weeks and months during those supposed "breaks", often for hours at a time, checking on threads just like this one. Like clockwork, whenever there was a thread with people crapping on the way Campbell was writing the book, Campbell would be online at 3am or some such going over every post with a fine-tooth comb like some sort of masochist.

Which is their prerogative. But it's also A LIE to claim you haven't looked at a forum for months when you're presently still on it every day for hours, and the Current Activity tab gives your position away so you can't even claim "I was just replying to PMs."

To their credit, after I made a comment about how they sure are on here a lot for someone who publicly said they quit the place numerous times, I haven't seen them here at all. BUT, they most likely just set their name to "Hidden", is what I would guess.

Are these "big deal" lies? Nah. But they establish a consistent pattern of behavior about how when caught in a lie this person just weaves another web instead of just saying "Ya got me." I don't respect that. Not from anyone.

I happen to put a premium on honesty, and therefore it is my personal belief that there are no "small lies", and that even innocuous stuff is indicative of a person's general character. Especially when they get caught. SO, to some of you this stuff is all "Who cares?"-level, and I do get that. I'm more concerned with the Big Picture, and the fact that this person is SO committed to their own BS, great or small, that they're seemingly incapable of just saying "Okay, that may not have been completely honest" as situations warrant.

To me, a person who lies is simply a liar, and I never give that person the benefit of any doubt ever again. Others may see and think differently.

Meanwhile, Campbell can SAY they're "really" all about blood-n-guts TMNT while they stuff the book full of fuzzy pink unicorns discussing their feelsies over pudding, and then claim "The editors have me handcuffed, maaaaaan!", and people can choose to believe that if they want to. I, personally, take that statement with a shaker full of salt. Again, "pattern of behavior".

Some will claim those are "stupid examples". Okay. We have different values and different requirements for "honesty", I guess. Regardless, you asked and I answered.
------------------------------

And for the last time, I do not hate gay people. Just women.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 01:55 PM   #67
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
Okay I'll give credit where it's due and fair enough you've actually provided some examples, small potatoes that they are, but a few things:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
1: Insisted that Sheena the punk-rocker was in no way influenced by the Ramones song "Sheena Is A Punk Rocker". Totally unrelated, you guys. Even though that song is one of only two Ramones songs anyone has ever heard of, and in fact EVERYONE has heard because it still gets daily radio play and is a popular staple of movies, TV shows, etc. Anyone who ever saw "Pet Semetary" has heard it, specifically right before the kid gets hit by the truck.
When confronted about this VERY on-the-nose reference, Campbell doubles-down and insists they've never even HEARD of the song.
I've heard of the Ramones and of Pet Semetary, but I'd not heard of the song before this myself and I'll even admit that I thought the name was a reference to the singer Sheena Easton, but maybe I was wrong.
So is it possible Sophie was in the same boat? Sure. But we have no way of knowing either way.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
2. When confronted about how their "The fate of the future depends on winning a Battle of the Bands!" plotline was heavily-derivative of Bill & Ted, and furthermore, that the timing of it was a bit suspect since Bill & Ted 3 was coming out at the exact same time... Campbell denies the similarity of concept AND - here's the kicker - says with a straight face "I had no idea Bill & Ted 3 was coming out or even existed." Despite the fact that it was one of THE most-hyped and heavily-advertised movies of the early pandemic, with commercials for it running CONSTANTLY. "I had no idea it was a thing!" Jesus. If a person went online AT ALL in 2020 - and we know for a fact that Campbell is online fairly often - they knew damn well about that movie. YouTube only made it an unskippable ad and every single entertainment website was only promoting it for weeks and months with articles and banner ads.
First off ad-blockers are a thing, but as with the first example you can be aware of the existence of a piece of media and still not know anything about it, same situation here and again no definitive proof leaning in either direction.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
3. At one point when a particularly bad issue of TMNT came out and people were being "mean" about it, Campbell's usual gang of blue-haired snowflakes went running to Twitter with cocoa and hugs. I was called out by name on there by some idiot, so despite not having Twitter I decided to see what people in the thread were saying. Turns out it was just the usual "That Technodrome place is full of Big Meanies! Don't let them get to you!" ass-licking nonsense.
BUT. Campbell indeed replied to someone by claiming, "I actually haven't been there (this forum) for months." Other times they claimed to have quit the forum entirely.
I can personally attest that at that time, and in fact EVERY time Campbell claimed to have quit the forum, not been on in months, whatever... I nonetheless saw them logged in EVERY SINGLE DAY for weeks and months during those supposed "breaks", often for hours at a time, checking on threads just like this one. Like clockwork, whenever there was a thread with people crapping on the way Campbell was writing the book, Campbell would be online at 3am or some such going over every post with a fine-tooth comb like some sort of masochist.
Which is their prerogative. But it's also A LIE to claim you haven't looked at a forum for months when you're presently still on it every day for hours, and the Current Activity tab gives your position away so you can't even claim "I was just replying to PMs."
To their credit, after I made a comment about how they sure are on here a lot for someone who publicly said they quit the place numerous times, I haven't seen them here at all. BUT, they most likely just set their name to "Hidden", is what I would guess.
I'll be honest I haven't seen the tweets/ messages that this relates to so I can't speak to the accuracy of what you've stated here, but regardless who really cares whether someone frequents this forum or not? (Not to mention your own self-admitted behaviour of watching her movements comes across as pretty stalker-ish - yikes.)

All-in-all these are pretty weak examples and even then only really the third one has any kind of verifiable veracity - they're all leagues away from supposedly having an issue of a comic book be ghostwritten.

What this really boils down to is a bunch of mysogynists and transphobes who are terrified of admitting that they actually enjoyed something written by someone they've spent months damning out of the fear of being seen as weak or a conformist by their peers all for the sake of protecting their fragile egos.
__________________
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 02:53 PM   #68
AquaParade
Banned
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 8,450
Gotta admit that last one is sort of I like “I followed her home, snuck in thru the garage, hid in her closet all night, and in the morning I caught her picking her nose.”

Leo, you already know this, which is why there is a giant disclaimer at the bottom of your post.

I can’t speak to the other examples. They sound pretty weird, if they are lies. Not a good sign of character. But I mean, I guess I don’t care enough to not give the benefit of the doubt. Not worth it.
AquaParade is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 02:59 PM   #69
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
"Chastises people for pushing 'conspiracy theories'. In the same breath, pushes a conspiracy theory about why people claim to hate Campbell's IDW TMNT." Typical Lefties, you can set your watch to 'em.

Here's something your ilk typically struggles with, but it will serve you well once you finally start applying it: When people tell you who they are (or what they're about) LISTEN, don't project.

In this case, people hate the IDW TMNT comic because it's boring, goes nowhere, has nothing to do with TMNT, actively displaces the central characters in favor of the author's Mary Sue and other fanfic characters, has taken two whole years for f*ck-all nothing to happen outside of various abrupt gay romances popping up everywhere, and on the whole, is about ten miles removed from what MOST people agree that a TMNT comic "should" be.

People have been saying Exactly That - loudly and often - for almost two whole years. Therefore, saying stuff like "They're all just bigots, maaaaaan" and projecting other motives as to why they hate the run when they have been VOCAL about exactly what they dislike, is unseemly. Don't do that.
-----------------

Since we're "giving credit", I have to applaud you for doing exactly as predicted. "Your examples aren't good enough!" Blow me.

Here's the thing: They ARE "small lies" and I admitted as such. That is not the POINT. The point is, these aren't things any person should feel compelled to lie about, at all. Just come clean. When a person CHOOSES to lie about things of such little consequence, it establishes a pattern of behavior and forces me to ask what ELSE they might make it a point to lie about. Because if they are willing to lie about whether or not they've ever heard a song that every person under age 50 has heard of, or whether or not they knew one of the most heavily-advertised movies of an entire calendar year even EXISTED... You're forced to admit they probably lie about bigger things, too.

As for making it a point to notice when various members are online, I do that with lots of people. When you've been here as long as I've been, you can't help it. Andrew, for example, tends to lurk often between the hours of 3am-6am EST whether or not he's actively posting. I notice this because I'm often online around the same time. Sumac, Zarius, and others have a similar pattern.

I guess I am "stalking" all of them, as well. It CAN'T just be as simple as "Whenever I log in between those hours, I see the same specific cluster of names and after X years it becomes very noticeable." CAN'T be as simple as THAT, goodness knows.

And again, if Campbell wants to lie about their forum activity in order to assuage the legions of ass-kissers on their Twitter by insisting "I don't see what they say, nor do I care," that's their prerogative. BUT. When you say such things when you spent hours logged in THE DAY BEFORE scrolling through every single post where anyone even mentioned your name... You're a liar AND a bit of a twat. Not my fault I caught them in an obvious lie. Don't lie, these things won't happen. Very simple.

It's like a person who gets caught cheating, and when caught, says "Well... YOU weren't supposed to find out about it! How DARE you invade my privacy!" Like, THAT is NOT the POINT, and deflection only compounds the sin.

I don't expect you to "get it". But others will, and do, and that's fine.

EDIT: Aqua, see above. I notice MANY people who are on the same time as I am. And I already explained the situation. Someone libeled me on Campbell's Twitter, I looked at it to see how/why, saw their claim about "not being on there in ages" and it jumped out at me because I had LITERALLY seen them on every single day for weeks.

Misdirection will not help anyone's case. The person was caught in a lie and the fact that I'm aware of the posting habits of MANY people here does not in any way diminish that fact.

Me noticing how they spend their forum time is NOT a bigger "issue" than Someone being a liar. So kindly don't paint it as such, mmmmmmkay. Just like the person who catches their spouse cheating by following them home from work is NOT "worse" than the one doing the cheating. Try and keep up, kids.

Last edited by Leo656; 01-26-2022 at 03:30 PM.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 04:59 PM   #70
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
And once again we catch you backtracking to try to save face; You can indeed see who's online at any time by the 'Active Users' panel at the bottom of the forum boards but that only shows you that they are logged in - which just means a person is logged in not that they are actually reading, posting or doing anything else on the forum at any given time - and yet you specifically claimed to have watched Sophie *checking on threads just like this one* which is only possible if you were not only watching on her user page but regularly refreshing it to see the status actually changing.

And before you try to accuse me of anything I tested this out using a second window where I wasn't logged in and watched my own user page as I changed threads on the window where I am logged in.

At this point your behaviour is clearly not only stalker-ish but downright obsessive - it's actually amazing that you haven't been banned yet considering that cyber-stalking is a crime that you've freely admitted to.
__________________

Last edited by hypered1; 01-26-2022 at 05:05 PM.
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 05:11 PM   #71
MikeandRaph87
Jedi Master
 
MikeandRaph87's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: JLA Satellite Headquarters
Posts: 11,189
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
"Chastises people for pushing 'conspiracy theories'. In the same breath, pushes a conspiracy theory about why people claim to hate Campbell's IDW TMNT." Typical Lefties, you can set your watch to 'em.

Here's something your ilk typically struggles with, but it will serve you well once you finally start applying it: When people tell you who they are (or what they're about) LISTEN, don't project.

In this case, people hate the IDW TMNT comic because it's boring, goes nowhere, has nothing to do with TMNT, actively displaces the central characters in favor of the author's Mary Sue and other fanfic characters, has taken two whole years for f*ck-all nothing to happen outside of various abrupt gay romances popping up everywhere, and on the whole, is about ten miles removed from what MOST people agree that a TMNT comic "should" be.

People have been saying Exactly That - loudly and often - for almost two whole years. Therefore, saying stuff like "They're all just bigots, maaaaaan" and projecting other motives as to why they hate the run when they have been VOCAL about exactly what they dislike, is unseemly. Don't do that.
-----------------

Since we're "giving credit", I have to applaud you for doing exactly as predicted. "Your examples aren't good enough!" Blow me.

Here's the thing: They ARE "small lies" and I admitted as such. That is not the POINT. The point is, these aren't things any person should feel compelled to lie about, at all. Just come clean. When a person CHOOSES to lie about things of such little consequence, it establishes a pattern of behavior and forces me to ask what ELSE they might make it a point to lie about. Because if they are willing to lie about whether or not they've ever heard a song that every person under age 50 has heard of, or whether or not they knew one of the most heavily-advertised movies of an entire calendar year even EXISTED... You're forced to admit they probably lie about bigger things, too.

As for making it a point to notice when various members are online, I do that with lots of people. When you've been here as long as I've been, you can't help it. Andrew, for example, tends to lurk often between the hours of 3am-6am EST whether or not he's actively posting. I notice this because I'm often online around the same time. Sumac, Zarius, and others have a similar pattern.

I guess I am "stalking" all of them, as well. It CAN'T just be as simple as "Whenever I log in between those hours, I see the same specific cluster of names and after X years it becomes very noticeable." CAN'T be as simple as THAT, goodness knows.

And again, if Campbell wants to lie about their forum activity in order to assuage the legions of ass-kissers on their Twitter by insisting "I don't see what they say, nor do I care," that's their prerogative. BUT. When you say such things when you spent hours logged in THE DAY BEFORE scrolling through every single post where anyone even mentioned your name... You're a liar AND a bit of a twat. Not my fault I caught them in an obvious lie. Don't lie, these things won't happen. Very simple.

It's like a person who gets caught cheating, and when caught, says "Well... YOU weren't supposed to find out about it! How DARE you invade my privacy!" Like, THAT is NOT the POINT, and deflection only compounds the sin.

I don't expect you to "get it". But others will, and do, and that's fine.

EDIT: Aqua, see above. I notice MANY people who are on the same time as I am. And I already explained the situation. Someone libeled me on Campbell's Twitter, I looked at it to see how/why, saw their claim about "not being on there in ages" and it jumped out at me because I had LITERALLY seen them on every single day for weeks.

Misdirection will not help anyone's case. The person was caught in a lie and the fact that I'm aware of the posting habits of MANY people here does not in any way diminish that fact.

Me noticing how they spend their forum time is NOT a bigger "issue" than Someone being a liar. So kindly don't paint it as such, mmmmmmkay. Just like the person who catches their spouse cheating by following them home from work is NOT "worse" than the one doing the cheating. Try and keep up, kids.
__________________
Michelangelo: This looks like a job for the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles!
Raphael: Sheesh, Mikey this ain't a cartoon!
MikeandRaph87 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 06:44 PM   #72
Bahamut810
Stone Warrior
 
Join Date: May 2021
Location: USA
Posts: 704
Wow...this thread sort of went to hell. Its extremely off the original topic now
Bahamut810 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 06:47 PM   #73
FredWolfLeonardo
This ***** used to be Fun
 
FredWolfLeonardo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2016
Location: Woke paradise
Posts: 5,399
Quote:
Originally Posted by hypered1 View Post
And once again we catch you backtracking to try to save face; You can indeed see who's online at any time by the 'Active Users' panel at the bottom of the forum boards but that only shows you that they are logged in - which just means a person is logged in not that they are actually reading, posting or doing anything else on the forum at any given time - and yet you specifically claimed to have watched Sophie *checking on threads just like this one* which is only possible if you were not only watching on her user page but regularly refreshing it to see the status actually changing.

And before you try to accuse me of anything I tested this out using a second window where I wasn't logged in and watched my own user page as I changed threads on the window where I am logged in.

At this point your behaviour is clearly not only stalker-ish but downright obsessive - it's actually amazing that you haven't been banned yet considering that cyber-stalking is a crime that you've freely admitted to.
You can also see what people are doing by going on Quick Links and then "Who's Online". You don't have to go on someone's profile, not that it matters.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 View Post
The biggest villains were the censors. What they could do without being held back is my question.

Shredder could've done more than blow up the Channel Six building. I don't mean as far as murdering Splinter, but think of the possibilities if censors were not an issue.

Shredder and Krang combined had the biggest arsenal of any villains in all of the cartoons.
FredWolfLeonardo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 07:49 PM   #74
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
Quote:
Originally Posted by FredWolfLeonardo View Post
You can also see what people are doing by going on Quick Links and then "Who's Online". You don't have to go on someone's profile, not that it matters.
That doesn't make it any better, you still have to refresh that page to see changes to what anyone is doing, which means that 656 would still have to be deliberately refreshing the page to follow Sophie's movements and watch her go from thread to thread.
__________________
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-26-2022, 08:10 PM   #75
frank_one
Mad Scientist
 
frank_one's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southern Europe
Posts: 2,271
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656 View Post
Here's the thing: They ARE "small lies" and I admitted as such. That is not the POINT. The point is, these aren't things any person should feel compelled to lie about, at all. Just come clean. When a person CHOOSES to lie about things of such little consequence, it establishes a pattern of behavior and forces me to ask what ELSE they might make it a point to lie about.
I'm with you on this. It's not the size of the lies that makes a person a liar, it's the pattern of behavior.
frank_one is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-27-2022, 01:58 AM   #76
neatoman
Overlord
 
neatoman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,096
Jesus ****ing Christ, this thread... I don't want to clarify this but I feel I have to.

OK:
  1. If the writing of 125 is radically different from 101-124, which it is and it doesn't some hyper-focused analysis to determine that it is, it is a very sudden change and of course people are going to question if some anonymous person was part of the writing process. If that is indeed the case, we don't know who it is and trying to claim we only believe it because of bigotry doesn't make sense, because for all we know this person could be someone else who could be a typical bigotry target. We may suspect who it is but we don't know.
  2. The reason Campbell's writing sucked so hard in 101-124 is that virtually nothing of importance happened, it tended to be very low stakes with a lack of real conflict and could easily have been compressed to 5-8 issues. It is not, as some might claim, because there weren't enough fight scenes or because it shows some kind of character development under different circumstances. There are other problems as well but those are the big ones.
  3. Trying to claim it is only disliked because Sophie is a transwoman is a false equivalence. Are there bigoted people who don't like that a transwoman is writing the book? Yes, there are. However, if the arguments for why the writing is bad have nothing to do with her gender identity, why assume the person making them is a bigot?
  4. Being a transwoman does not shield Sophie from fair criticism. Nothing, and I mean nothing, should shield anyone from fair criticism. "Campbell should not write because trans" is obviously not fair criticism of course, but "Sophie is a bad writer because she has no sense of pacing" is. Saying that any criticism of Sophie or her writing is just evidence of bigotry is moronic. If I'm served spoiled sashimi by a Japanese chef and call him out on it, that would not mean I hate the Japanese, it would mean I got served a bad meal by an incompetent chef.
  5. Writing is not all subjective. There may be certain aspects of writing that are, preferences towards certain themes and what not, but there are objective qualities to writing stories. There is a reason why comic books, American comic books in particular, usually have the writer and artist as separate people. They are different disciplines that take a lot of practice to get good at, if you focus your career in area, you're not likely to be very good at the other. Sophie Campbell, much like Todd McFarlane or Jim Lee, was primarily an artist and not a writer before scripting this book and it shows. Sophie is indeed a good artist, this is difficult to deny but the writing is still bad. I don't think anyone would claim Todd McFarlane or Jim Lee are good writers, which is probably why they ended up handing off the writing duties to others on their creator owned books. Writing is hard and not anyone can do it.
  6. A pattern of lying is not a guarantee someone did lie, no. That is correct, it is a fallacy to assume someone lies because tend to lie. However if we are talking about suspicions about a ghost writer being involved then the pattern is sort of irrelevant. The question "Did you get someone else to write for you with the intention of you getting the credit?" will almost always be "no", especially if we're talking about something that was published last week. If the official writer did indeed write the book, the answer will be "no" because it is the truth. If a ghostwriter is involved then the answer would still be "no" because the intention is to make seem as if the official writer is the actual writer. In either case, no matter how truthful the person is otherwise, they are not a reliable source for determining if a ghostwriter was involved. I hate using this comparison because it makes the use of ghostwriters look like some ethical problem but I can't think of a better alternative, it is like asking someone directly if they cheated on a test, why would they ever tell you that they did?

I really, really, really don't like to bring up Sophie's gender identity and I have actively tried to avoid bringing it up as much as possible. This is not because I disapprove of transpeople or anything like that, because I really don't. I believe that quality of writing and the criticism of bad writing should be consistent regardless of who writes it. The problem is that quite a lot of people seem to have a difficult time not factoring in the fact that a transwoman wrote this comic and somehow feel it must be brought up as either in criticism or defense of it. It is very unfortunate that the transwoman in question turned out to be a terrible writer because it makes it difficult to criticise the book publicly, regardless of how fair the criticisms may be, because someone who really ought to know better can't help but to assume it's rooted in bigotry.

What I am ultimately trying to get across is that it isn't fair to harp on Sophie for being a transwoman, but Sophie being a transwoman doesn't make this book worth defending.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH View Post
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.
Hahahaha!

Last edited by neatoman; 01-27-2022 at 02:13 AM.
neatoman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-27-2022, 02:37 AM   #77
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,630
Sophie being trans is a non-issue to me and always has been. When she came out I immediately changed her name in "Odyssey" for her contribution to it and I was happy to do it. I'm happy if she's happy and that's that. And regarding different kinds of storytelling previous to now... I don't know, I find this kind of insulting. Writers can shift gears and do so often. Plus we have no idea what has been going on behind the scenes at IDW. Perhaps there was an edict to deliver a certain kind of story over a certain amount of time... and maybe that edict has been lifted or shifted. Again, what I KNOW is that Sophie is perfectly capable of delivering the kind of story in 125 (or even far darker fare) and always has been.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-27-2022, 02:50 AM   #78
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
This did get side tracked a couple of times but as I said before it just boils down to a bunch of people who don't have balls to admit that they actually liked something that Sophie wrote to point that they're trotting out idiotic theories that it must've been written by someone else and when they're then provided ample evidence to the contrary and that Sophie has a history of writing in this style (vis à vis her time on the Mirage iteration of the comic) they immediately ignore it like it was blasphemy.
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-27-2022, 03:09 AM   #79
neatoman
Overlord
 
neatoman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,096
Except Sophie Campbell hasn't written for Mirage. She did some covers and two front pieces but no writing. So to say she wrote for Mirage is straight up incorrect, it didn't happen as far as I can find. In fact, I can find very few writing credits Sophie has outside of this book and they're still more consistent in style with 101-124 than 125. So no, 125 is still a bit off here if we assume Sophie is the sole writer.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH View Post
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.
Hahahaha!
neatoman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-27-2022, 03:28 AM   #80
hypered1
Mad Scientist
 
hypered1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,404
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
Except Sophie Campbell hasn't written for Mirage. She did some covers and two front pieces but no writing. So to say she wrote for Mirage is straight up incorrect, it didn't happen as far as I can find. In fact, I can find very few writing credits Sophie has outside of this book and they're still more consistent in style with 101-124 than 125. So no, 125 is still a bit off here if we assume Sophie is the sole writer.
So now you're calling Andrew a liar?
If you want to just stick with the IDW run then Sophie also wrote the 'Toad Baron's Ball' 2-parter and the 'Karai's Path' arc both the in Universe and they're more like #125 than the rest of the post-#100 issues.
__________________
hypered1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:25 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.