![]() |
|
|
#10 |
|
Banned
![]() Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 8,450
|
I disagree that a character needs to perfectly resemble who they are based upon. It just depends on what you value in a story, but to me that's trivial.
I'm not acting as if a certain type of person doesn't exist, but yes you are narrowing your potential for finding talent if you limit your search to "white guy who can grow a good moustache!" For Gordon (sticking with this example). Of course, you can find a good white actor with a moustache, but that doesn't mean he's the best for the role or better than the guy next to him who happens to be black, Asian, etc. Again, its just trivial in the grand scheme of most stories, which is why I dont care. It simply matters not, beyond a superficial level in most cases. Exceptions exist of course. You're saying that if a character is race-swapped, you might as well not adapt the story at all? Agree to disagree. That sounds utterly boring and lame to me. I don't understand the need to adapt something 1:1, in the vein of Snyder's Watchmen or just not doing it at all. I just feel like it's a super unimaginative and dull way to look at adaptation. It's needlessly stubborn to the detriment of good storytelling. But that's just my opinion. |
|
|
|
|
|