The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Comic Discussion

Notices

View Poll Results: Which is the better comic, TMNT Adventures (Archie) or IDW TMNT?
TMNT Adventures (Archie) 18 69.23%
IDW TMNT 8 30.77%
Voters: 26. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-07-2026, 01:28 PM   #1
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,630
TMNT Adventures (Archie) vs. IDW TMNT

Which one is better? Let's take it to the polls!
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 01:39 PM   #2
liugeaux
Hench Mutant
 
liugeaux's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 330
I like them both, and the Archie highs are VERY high, but so much of that series is marred in misplaced conservationist propaganda, its easy to say IDW is better even factoring in the post-100 weirdness.

I have such a fondness for the Archie, but when I read it today, much of it feels like Murph wasn't interested in writing about the TMNT at all. He wanted to indulge his interests in history, religion, and saving the world. My love for it is probably fueled mostly by nostalgia.

IDW has its problems, but for the most part, it's cohesive and reverent to TMNT history while still bringing fresh ideas.
__________________
My Blog: liugeaux.com
My Podcast!: Reality Breached
My Ninja Turtles Podcast: Shellheads: A TMNT Podcast
liugeaux is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 02:10 PM   #3
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,630
Quote:
Originally Posted by liugeaux View Post
I like them both, and the Archie highs are VERY high, but so much of that series is marred in misplaced conservationist propaganda, its easy to say IDW is better even factoring in the post-100 weirdness.
There wasn't even worse propaganda in the "post-100 weirdness"?
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 02:23 PM   #4
liugeaux
Hench Mutant
 
liugeaux's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 330
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
There wasn't even worse propaganda in the "post-100 weirdness"?
At least that propaganda was behind thinly veiled metaphors. Murph's often was just paragraphs about the earth being killed by humans and entire pages explaining the local customs and/or beliefs of indigenous people.

With the post-100 stuff, it's possible to read it as just mutants dating mutants. That doesn't make it good, it just makes it less aggressively preachy.
__________________
My Blog: liugeaux.com
My Podcast!: Reality Breached
My Ninja Turtles Podcast: Shellheads: A TMNT Podcast
liugeaux is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 02:28 PM   #5
ToTheNines
Col. Stinkmeaner
 
ToTheNines's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 19,425
If you asked me this 10 years ago, I might have been conflicted. But TMNTA wins easily for me, now.

Adventures certainly had its ups and downs, but that’s because it took risks!
ToTheNines is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 04:50 PM   #6
TheLabRat
Stone Warrior
 
TheLabRat's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2023
Posts: 836
The problem is execution and how long can stick to these fresh ideas. This is precisely the shortcoming of IDW TMNT.
TheLabRat is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 05:39 PM   #7
ToTheNines
Col. Stinkmeaner
 
ToTheNines's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 19,425
Tight race!
ToTheNines is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 05:55 PM   #8
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToTheNines View Post
Tight race!
Not any more, Both series are great, But the Archie comics always holds a special place for me.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 06:21 PM   #9
ToTheNines
Col. Stinkmeaner
 
ToTheNines's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 19,425
It’s literally tied 5-5
ToTheNines is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 06:41 PM   #10
Heyowakka
Stone Warrior
 
Heyowakka's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2025
Posts: 525
Well, I had to spend my free time today thinking about it, taking into consideration the pros and cons, and highs and lows of both series; in the end I can’t help but pick TMNT Adventures.
A lot of it is honestly just nostalgia, but in the end there’s more I dislike about IDW than Adventures and more fond memories I have reading Adventures than IDW.
Heyowakka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 06:57 PM   #11
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by Heyowakka View Post
Well, I had to spend my free time today thinking about it, taking into consideration the pros and cons, and highs and lows of both series; in the end I can’t help but pick TMNT Adventures.
A lot of it is honestly just nostalgia, but in the end there’s more I dislike about IDW than Adventures and more fond memories I have reading Adventures than IDW.
Its the reason why the Saturday Morning Adventures comics has been gaining in popularity. those of us that are nostalgic about the 87 series, which Archie was loosely based on.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 07:32 PM   #12
DrSpengler
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
Both IDW and Archie have their triumphs and their shortcomings, but I had to choose Archie.

The one shortcoming both TMNT books seemed to have in common are their preachiness, but if I had to choose which one was less insufferable, I'd have to go with Archie's. Murphy was obnoxiously direct with his political statements and wrote them with the grace of a Captain Planet cartoon, but at least there was variety to what he preached about. One issue it was the rain forest, another it was the whales, then maybe he was bitching about the plight of the Native American. Heck, sometimes he could really surprise me by condemning Chinese military aggressions in Tibet (something we would NEVER see touched in Viacom era TMNT, seeing as how much Chinese money is pumped into Paramount movies).

Point is, for all the preaching, at least it wasn't a broken record. He switched it up on the regular.

Waltz's era of IDW, to it's credit, wasn't preachy hardly ever, and that's a huge feather in its cap. But when Campbell took over, that's all the book became. And it was only ever one tiresome topic, issue after issue, year after year. Agonizing. Monotonous. Enough to finally make me drop the book.

Thinking about the prime years of IDW, namely Waltz's 100 issue stretch, I would want to give it the edge. But then I remembered just how hard that book was to read due to dozens of tie-ins, all of which were mandatory to the ongoing plot. It rarely felt like you could read two consecutive issues of the main series without needing to also pick up a tie-in mini, a whole tie-in series, or one of a thousand one-shots. The IDW Collection hardcovers are genuinely the only lucid way to read that series and I pity anyone trying to get into it any other way. Just trying to read one year of IDW TMNT in singles is more of a baffling ordeal than trying to read the entirety of the Spider-Man Clone Saga.

Or imagine ordering a burger and being given a map to a scavenger hunt requiring you to spend hours searching for the buns, meat, cheese, lettuce, pickles and ketchup so you can put the burger together yourself and THEN eat it. That's what trying to read the IDW TMNT comic is like.

Archie's TMNT had its tie-ins, and the Mutanimals stuff was definitely mandatory reading, but the majority of comics outside the main series were optional. If you didn't know Donatello & Leatherhead existed, you'd be missing nothing. Likewise for most of the seasonal Specials. As a self-contained reading experience, the Archie TMNT book is much more reasonable.

Then there's also pacing. IDW's TMNT comics were plotted around the 4-issue TPBs, so you could always predict the dramatic structure of each arc. And that was only worsened by the desire to hinge big status quo shakeups on "milestone" numbered issues, like a 25 or a 50 or a 75, etc. So story arcs would have to spin wheels and accomplish nothing because they hadn't gotten to a number divisible by 25 yet.

Since the Archie series came from a time when floppies were more popular than trades, the storylines ran as long as they needed to or would feature arcs within arcs (the World Tour storyline being made up of several smaller arcs that were sometimes one-offs, sometimes 2 or 3 or 4 parters, etc.). It didn't have some asinine editorial mandate to not do anything interesting until it hit issue 50, or to make sure to stretch every idea out to 4 issues and to always wrap those ideas up by issue 4 so that it'd be trade-friendly.

I could go on for hundreds more words. But ultimately, the Archie TMNT book is more fun to read no matter how preoccupied it can be with lecturing the reader. The IDW book could be very good very often (during the Waltz era), but the amount of tedious decompression and the incomprehensible scattering of story chapters across multiple books and tie-ins renders those triumphs harder to appreciate and harder to find.
DrSpengler is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 07:46 PM   #13
TheLabRat
Stone Warrior
 
TheLabRat's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2023
Posts: 836
Quote:
Originally Posted by TigerClaw View Post
Its the reason why the Saturday Morning Adventures comics has been gaining in popularity. those of us that are nostalgic about the 87 series, which Archie was loosely based on.
Although 1987 Pantheon is just some kind of intergalactic crime syndicate, but I think Saturday Morning Adventures comic handle them well. At least much better than IDW version.
TheLabRat is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2026, 08:09 PM   #14
TigerClaw
Mutant Tiger
 
TigerClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Hialeah, Florida, USA
Posts: 14,167
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheLabRat View Post
Although 1987 Pantheon is just some kind of intergalactic crime syndicate, but I think Saturday Morning Adventures comic handle them well. At least much better than IDW version.
And how they bring back some of our beloved characters from the 87 series. With the addition of reintroducing some of the IDW characters as 87 versions. Like Old Hobs for example.
__________________

Follow me on my Tiktok
https://www.tiktok.com/@tygerclaw305
TigerClaw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-08-2026, 02:39 PM   #15
ToTheNines
Col. Stinkmeaner
 
ToTheNines's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 19,425
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrSpengler View Post
Thinking about the prime years of IDW, namely Waltz's 100 issue stretch, I would want to give it the edge. But then I remembered just how hard that book was to read due to dozens of tie-ins, all of which were mandatory to the ongoing plot. It rarely felt like you could read two consecutive issues of the main series without needing to also pick up a tie-in mini, a whole tie-in series, or one of a thousand one-shots. The IDW Collection hardcovers are genuinely the only lucid way to read that series and I pity anyone trying to get into it any other way. Just trying to read one year of IDW TMNT in singles is more of a baffling ordeal than trying to read the entirety of the Spider-Man Clone Saga.
I don't know that this should necessarily count against it, since that stuff was fun to follow as it was coming out. But as far as revisiting goes... yeah, that's an intimidating slog to get through.

Especially since it never hits a satisfying ending. The book started really going downhill for me starting with #75 but I decided to stick it out to 100. That last year was an absolute BURDEN to get through, and #100 didn't really hit for me. And now they've brought Splinter back to life, so it doesn't even have that going for it.

TMNTA is a less intense commitment, and now we have a nice "ending" with Forever War finally out (I'm still enjoying everything that's coming!).

Once those omnibuses are all out, I'm really looking forward to doing a TMNTA binge. With IDW... I kinda want to revisit it, but it feels pointless and ultimately just depressing.
ToTheNines is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-08-2026, 04:07 PM   #16
DrSpengler
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToTheNines View Post
Especially since it never hits a satisfying ending. The book started really going downhill for me starting with #75 but I decided to stick it out to 100. That last year was an absolute BURDEN to get through, and #100 didn't really hit for me. And now they've brought Splinter back to life, so it doesn't even have that going for it.
There was definitely a glut of compounding storylines that began to weigh the IDW series down little by little, a stone at a time, until it was just too much unresolved "Lost" style storytelling with no satisfactory resolution in sight. I mean, they introduced Madame Null fairly early on during the Mutanimals mini, but when did they actually get around to making that pay off? Every year there'd be another reminder that Null and her mutants like the scorpion lady were around and up to something, but then no followup or pay off for years and years. Just constant go-nowhere open threads.

The bloat began to overwhelm me during the Triceraton Invasion arc; that thing just wouldn't end, especially when you factored in the prequel chapters and interquel chapters from TMNT Universe. Then City at War and the lead up to issue 100 was even longer and more bloated than THAT.

At first I thought the paring down for Campbell's run after 100 would be a relief, but it wound up being even more tedious with inane drivel like Battle of the Bands stuff, Mutant Town, relationship drama, and the Turtles being sidelined for OCs to the point of becoming guest stars in their own comic. I gave the post 100 era of IDW's TMNT a good 2 years before I finally cancelled my subscription, which I think was a more than generous attempt. That Steven Universe fanfic disguised as a TMNT comic just wasn't for me.

Archie, on the other hand, built a big mythology and had plenty of longform stories, but the way Murphy handled piecemealing it out helped prevent openended narrative bloat. Like when Maligna showed up, they made a big story arc out of her, but it was a closed arc with a satisfying conclusion. She came back much later for another solid story, but it wasn't like Maligna showed up for an arc, dropped a ton of storyline threads, then disappeared for 6 years to leave everything hanging, which is what IDW so frequently did.

Murphy's approach had a good method of handling one thing at a time but using each arc as a building block for the overall universe of the series. I found that approach far more enjoyable than the mystery box stuff that plagues so much modern storytelling, not just the IDW TMNT comic.
DrSpengler is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-08-2026, 05:24 PM   #17
CyberCubed
Overlord
 
CyberCubed's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 43,917
Yeah I think even during Waltz run, the fact that the villains never really "end" is an issue. Old Hob is basically doing the same exact thing he's been doing for 100+ issues now, he's an anti-hero who dislikes humans and wants a safe haven for mutants. Granted he doesn't want to kill all humans anymore, but he's still in pretty much the same place.

They did end Krang's story (for a second time), but the Utroms and Triceratons are STILL on Burnow Island with no resolution in sight. Can you believe they're been off-screen since Sophie's run began? Are they even all still there? Why did the Utroms never scout a new planet in space to move to?

And yeah, Null is still around too, Baxter is still the Mayor, now Shredder is back again, it just never ends.
CyberCubed is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-08-2026, 11:03 PM   #18
Darth Knuckles
Stone Warrior
 
Darth Knuckles's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mutani-Isle
Posts: 703
For me it's easily Archie on this one. TMNT Adventures was the first comic series I started "collecting" and it does have a special place in my heart. Things like Stump Asteroid, Wrestling Turtles, Future Turtles, Cyber Samurai Turtles, Ninjara, The Mighty Mutanimals, Cudley the Cowlick, The Warrior Dragon, my favorite version of Slash for many years, Sarnath the Triast, globe-trotting around the world, Terrorcide, Maligna, Mr. Null, Death, War, Famine, Pestilence, Noi Tai Dar, Chien Khan, Armaggon, The Future Shark Trilogy, Verminator-X, Wyrm among other things in this series are some of my favorites and great to me. And the crazier things that you can't forget like the May East Trilogy and Raph punching Hitler in the face. It's one of my favorite versions of TMNT and the stories and characters are certainly interesting in this series. I love it!
__________________
"Shredder, what have you done!?!" - Tiger Claw (Annihilation: Earth!)
Darth Knuckles is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-08-2026, 11:03 PM   #19
TheLabRat
Stone Warrior
 
TheLabRat's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2023
Posts: 836
IDW Karai get a evil sword, but eventually this is just for Shredder and Kitsune's cheap redemption arc, not her story development. Now, she got a dragon magic power, but whether is Aaron's run or Shredder's minicomic, they just created other filler character(Hale and the Mourner) to involve in the story, instead of Karai.

As for the main characters. The Turtles didn't have much permanent positive character development, they keep fell into new traumas and repeat the same mistakes. They even have a Batman-no kill logic.
TheLabRat is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:25 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.