![]() |
|
|
#1 |
|
Mouser
![]() Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 13
|
Hey Mr. Munroe,
First of all, I'd like to wish you Happy Holidays. I hope you and yours had a wonderful break. Second of all ... I'd like to say I was really dissapointed with the "theatrical trailer" that was recently released. The first teaser was brillaint. It was dark, and serious. Yet it also had the perfect composition of a threatning situation, with the typical TMNT comedic moments. And then the theatrical version just killed the aura and mood that the teaser created. It seemed too focused on jokes. Not to mention it came off as really cliched. I mean the second you hear: "Every 3000 years, the stars allign unleashing an army of monsters." The movie just looses any sense of real world danger, and just goes into corny territory. Even for a movie primarily based at reaching a child audience. I guess to really get down to it, I am not really digging your approach to this film. It comes off as a psuedo-sequel. Which is going to create confusion, which is just what happened with Superman Returns who based their story, like yours, as a movie that picks up after a certain movie yet also isn't a direct sequel and may ignore the other movies from a series. It just doesn't make sense. I mean, if you're trying to break a new audience for the Turtles, why wouldn't you go for an updated and contemporary origin that fits into the new CGI format for your story telling? You could've meshed the TMNT 2k3 origin, and created something new, yet still using the old classic elements that made the first movies so successful. I mean, I always thought the TMNT worked best when they faced real life situations and dangers. Or at least feasible dangers, that still had elements of the fantastical. But a bunch of monsters? Meh. No Shredder? The kingpin, and the only worth advesary of the turtles not even making an appearance? BOO to you. That's another thing. By not re-starting, you are continuing off the TMNT 2 plot, where Shredder died. Which means, we will never see him again?!? You wrote off the main villain, because you didn't have the vision to do a re-start? That just stinks man. You could've had the whole Ancient Foot v.s. Utroms / Guardians (there is your monsters for the flick) combined with the origin and rise of the Ninja Turtles. It would've been beautiful. It could've possibly competed with TMNT 1990. It also would've gave you infinite room for creativity for quality sequels. I think the route you took it in, leaves you kind of constricted. Sorry for the rant, but I just had to get it off my chest. Don't take any of this as me looking down on you as a person or an artist. I hope your movie is successful, and your career takes off. I'm just voicing my displeasure with the project. I believe you have gotten plenty of praise here, I just wanted to let you know some criticism. I would be delighted if you could in some way or form respond to any of my questions or displeasures. Beyond the story, from a looks perspective ... your movie is absolutely jaw dropping. Which is why I was so dissapointed with the story. Your movie looks like a flat out CGI replica of the TMNT 1990 world. The shadows, and that real gritty / urban feeling. Fits the mythos perfectly. The way you had the turtles moving. Oh man, was it fantastic. BTW, what is this I hear about you guys re-interpreting scenes from TMNT 1990 into the new CGI format? Is that true? If so, will the fans ever get a chance to see it? I am willing to bet I'd cream my pants, as would the rest of the TMNT fan base. Anyway, thanks for your time and I hope to hear from you soon. |
|
|
|
|
|