Depends on what kind of money you're looking to shell out. If you want to just have the stories and aren't worried about collecting the original issues, you'd probably want :
TMNT Collected Book 1 (#1-11 of Vol. 1, plus the Leo, Don, Mike, and Raph specials)
TMNT Collected Book 2 (#12-14 of Vol. 1)
TMNT Collected Book 4 (#19-21 of Vol. 1, awesome)
TMNT Collected Book 6 (#24-26 of Vol. 1, highly recommended)
Tales of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (#1-7, hard to find... actually easier/cheaper just to buy the individual issues of this, strangely)
Of course you'll want the essential City at War, which strangely hasn't been collected. Ever. Grab TMNT Vol.1 #48-62.
And then the various TPBs for the current Vol. 2 of Tales of the TMNT.
Most of the good online-buying-comics places have been pretty well cleaned out by people like you and I, so eBay remains really your best bet of completing your collection. If you ever have any question about what you're buying or thinking about buying, send me a PM.
Here's what you can order DIRECTLY from Mirage themselves :
For the comics themselves :
http://www.ninjaturtles.com/order/catbandw.htm
For the collected books :
http://www.ninjaturtles.com/order/catgn.htm
(only some available)