Playing Favorites: Favorite Turtles Then and Now

[Jester]

This is a thread started in response to Donnie's (I think it was you...) post on the Facebook page about "shifting allegiance" from on Turtle to another. He asked if anyone had ever done the unthinkable: switched which of the Green Team was their favorite. I will eventually answer there...work isn't a fan of the Facebook...but I thought it was a strong enough idea for a thread on the Real Drome (so good in fact, there's bound to already be one).

So what say you? Ever swapped Turtley Allegiances? As for me, I'll let you know in the Fall if my favorite Turtle swaps due to something or another....

[MikeandRaph87]

Since I was in diapers I had my turtles ranked #1-#4 and never changed. I always liked Michleangelo the best with a Raph as a close second. #3 is Leo adn #4 Don. When I say Don is my least favorite I still like him. Can't hate let alone dislike any of them. My favortism of Mike came from Townsend Coleman's version in the original animated series and the movies gave it a boost while the immortal Rob Paulsen made me love the sarcastic hothead of Raph and the movies prominent role of Raph gave that a boost. While I love the '87 cartoon the most I have to say I enjoyed Leo and Don in the '03 cartoon more than their '87 cartoon counterparts. Well, that rant was just my personal experiences and perferences. I don't have to ask if you ever did at least for your favorite turtle.

[rufus]

Michelangelo used to be my favorite turtle but now I would have say that Donatello is when he used to be my least favorite out of the 4 turtles.

[Donnie]

Donatello.

[Jester]

As a kid my list was Raph (thanks to Rob Paulsen's characterization), then Mikey (because he was the 2nd most fun), then Don and Leo last. That list underwent the first change with the 4Kids series, with Raph staying in 1st, followed by Don (Sam Riegel does an awesome job), then Leo, and Mikey is last. Nothing against Wayne Grayson, but Mikey was written very VERY goofy in that series. Too goofy. I'm sure the favorite list will shuffle later this year, when Nick debuted their Turtles.

[oldmanwinters]

I still like OT and Archie Comics Raphael best of all. In the live-action films, I prefer Donatello. In the 2k3 series, Leonardo got all the best episodes, but I felt like the production team was trying to cram his awesome down our throats, so I don't really have a favorite in that series. I really liked Raphael from the 1st season, but it seemed like he began to be written more-and-more as incompetent in battle (throwing his sais away every other episode). In the Mirage Comics, I generally think Raphael has the best stories (at least when Eastman or Berger was involved with them).

I think the franchise works best when each turtle is given his chance to shine and the team succeeds through mutual cooperation and compromise.

Originally Posted by Donnie

But it's a New Year, and I'm proud to declare that Michelangelo is now my #1 favorite Turtle!

Words fail me...

Is nothing constant in this world?

[Jester]

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters

Words fail me...

Is nothing constant in this world?

I know, right. So when can we expect a name change to Mikeie? Or would that be Mikey.

[Donnie]

Edited, what folly was I thinking?

[MikeandRaph87]

Originally Posted by Jester

I know, right. So when can we expect a name change to Mikeie? Or would that be Mikey.

I was thinking about what Donnie here should do. Maybe something like mine which is a double tribute to Townsend's Mike and Rob' Raph. Mike,Mikey(from the former ring of green), and Michelangelo are all taken. What about Mikey&Donnie? or orangeturtle or even Townsend Grayson. Just a few suggestions.

I admit my least favorite of all of the TMNT versions I like(all but NM and Image) was the 2003 cartoon which made him well kinda dumb, spouted too much pop culture and liked to irrate his brothers to the point even Splinter hit him upside the head.

[Powder]

Always Leonardo, right from the beginning.

[SparkyMarky644]

Always been Leonardo and always will be.

[Logan]

Over the years, Raph has come to be an equal or nearly equal favorite to Leo for me. But that's it. Even as a wee lad I wasn't into Mike and I never will be.

[BubblyShell22]

Sorry, my favorite hasn't changed over the years and probably never will. It's been Leonardo all the way.

[Powder]

Originally Posted by SparkyMarky644

Always been Leonardo and always will be.

Originally Posted by BubblyShell22

Sorry, my favorite hasn't changed over the years and probably never will. It's been Leonardo all the way.

Yeah, you guys, you're alright.

[Volvagia]

Leo all the way for me, don't think that's ever going to change.

[CyberCubed]

Fun fact: The only reason Raphael was my favorite Turtle was because I liked his personality in the original cartoon.

While I still liked Movie Raph and Archie Raph, his personality in the Mirage/4kids series wasn't as appealing to me.

But since OT Raph was the one I saw first, that's how I always think of him.

[mysterycolor]

Originally Posted by Donnie

You are correct Jester, I did start that post on the Facebook group! I wanted to get the opinion of my fellow 'Dromers on changing favorite Turtles. My main question was - is it THAT taboo?!

to acknowledge your question mr. donnie... NO it is not taboo... and it doesn't make you a "casual" to change your favorite... most of us arent the same as we were when we first got into TMNT so the reason you had a favorite then might not really apply now...

[Donnie]

I was preaching folly!

[pannoni1]

It has shifted for me. For me, the first order as a preschooler was:

1. Michelangelo
2. Leonardo
3. Raphael
4. Donatello

Being young, Mike was always easy to relate to, and had innocence just like myself at the time. Raph's jokes I couldn't quite grasp so far, and Donatello was just too advanced for me at the time.

Around the time my interest faded in TMNT in the mid-90s, the order was:

1. Leonardo
2. Donatello
3. Raphael
4. Michelangelo

With Mike's role being reduced and approaching my preteens, it was wise to first appreciate a good leader/role model, and Donatello was interesting to watch as I gained more education.

Today, it is:

1. Donatello
2. Raphael
3. Michelangelo
4. Leonardo

Donatello can help me keep my brains focused (plus having an original turtle voice reprising as another turtle) helps. Raphael can be both funny and serious, keeping it from getting boring. Michelangelo's even improved a bit so I can see what can be enjoyable to do when I'm bored or have a bad day. Leonardo, not as much since I will probably never be a true leader in real life, though I still like them all! Now, if we added April and Splinter, both of those would have increased them in ranking each time around, given I was too young to appreciate a woman earlier on, plus Splinter's wisdom sounds more appealing with age.

[KROW]

Originally Posted by Jester

So what say you? Ever swapped Turtley Allegiances? As for me, I'll let you know in the Fall if my favorite Turtle swaps due to something or another....

During the OT's run, my initial fave was Raph. As the series went on for a couple years, Don won out because of his gadgets and involvement in the show. Also, when the movie arrived, I saw Raph's character was more like the Mirage book and not the cartoon, but Don's was pretty much the same (plus his quips with Mikey and Casey were great). So, I guess due to a hidden sense of humor and consistency, Donatello became more my favorite. It's been like that since.