CDs That Disappointed You

[Spitfire]

We all have favorite bands and I'm sure all the bands we listen to have had some bad albums that we didn't like. Or didn't get what we expected out of.
Here are mine

In Flames - Reroute To Remain
I expected a decent album here. I read the reviews and after hearing Clayman*The studio album before this one* I was ready for another good In Flames release. But no...the whole album sucked. It's not like they slowly turned into some Korn rip off band*I hate Korn by the way*. It happened all in one album. And I hate it.

Cradle Of Filth - Nymphetamine
This album was boring. It hardly has any worth while songs on it. Damnation And A Day wasn't that good either so I guess I wasn't as dissappointed with it. But I heard the title track and expected a better album.

Metallica - The Black Album
What the hell was this? I didn't even regonize it as Metallica until the guy on the radio said it was. The guitar sounded like crap and the vocals we're just awful. So lame, why did Cliff have to die?

Slayer - God Hates Us All
Okay so I hear Bloodline and I think "Hey Slayer got good again" but then I hear the album and it sounds like their totally out of ideas.

What are yours?

[That Matt Guy]

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx

Metallica - The Black Album
What the hell was this? I didn't even regonize it as Metallica until the guy on the radio said it was. The guitar sounded like crap and the vocals we're just awful. So lame, why did Cliff have to die?

I enjoyed the black album somewhat, of course it is nothing compared to say Kill Em' All or Master of Puppets. I was more upset with Metallica's bloody ejaculate fests "Load" and subsequent "Reload"; honestly Load was so horrible I threw the CD in the trash. Reload at least had Fuel on it, which is the only song on that entire album that is worth listening to.

[Barkworm]

I love pretty much everything from Metallica...
Anyway, I was really disappointed with Pearl Jam's "Binaural". That album was just boring.

[Raphael29]

Metallica's St. Anger, that was just awful, all it sounded like to me was steel drum solos and random screaming.

Metallica - The Black Album
What the hell was this? I didn't even regonize it as Metallica until the guy on the radio said it was. The guitar sounded like crap and the vocals we're just awful. So lame, why did Cliff have to die?

Gonna have to completely disagree, Enter Sandman is one of their best songs and while nothing can compare to Master of Puppets or Ride the Lightning to me it's still a great album.

Originally Posted by Matthew138

honestly Load was so horrible I threw the CD in the trash.

I liked Load, I don't know why everyone bashes it so much while it is different and isn't as metal as the other ones, it's still good.

[Anarky]

Hmmm, I remember a band from back in the day. Papa Roach. When I was like 13 "Last resort" was a great song and the hidden track on "infest" is great. Infact, "Infest" is a good album, allthough I never really listen to it anymore.

Then came "lovehatetragedy", which was halfway hearable. Too many slow songs and it just didn't feel right anymore.

And the newest album "Getting away with murder" is, aside from one track, a total waste of CDs.

[Cerpin Taxt]

I loved the Black Album. I think every album after it sucked...hard.

As for cds that disappointed me?

The Dandy Warhols - Welcome to the Monkey House
It was too poppy. The old Dandy Warhols albums had somewhat sloppy and unorganized lyrics and riffs, but it all somehow fit together and sounded awesome on each record. They ditched this sound and went for a lighter approach to everything.

Billy Corgan - TheFutureEmbrace
Billy Corgan is like a god to me. However, his solo cd sucked. It was industrial emo crap (two things that should not be combined), and didn't feature any amazing guitar that he was known for in the Pumpkins and such. I mean, when buying this, you shouldn't expect a Smashing Pumpkins album, but you also shouldn't expect this crap.

Marilyn Manson - The Golden Age of Grotesque
Too much use of the drum machine. The guitar in each song sucked. The lyrics were stupid as hell (everything made reference to 30's and 40's Germany. I don't have anything against Germany, but it makes for a ****** concept album.) Tim Skold is not the genius that Manson claims him to be (take that, KMFDM fans!). The tour sucked, too.


System of a Down -Mezmerize
It didn't have the same sound or feeling that the other three records had. It was a change in style for the band, and it wasn't really good. To top it off, it was being released as a two cd released one at a time, and this one is about 30-40 minutes long. Rip off.


cKy - An Answer Can Be Found
Too bass oriented. Nothing like their old records. It's like my least favorite songs from "Infiltrate.Destroy.Rebuild." put onto a record and somewhat worsened through the process. Bad description, but...meh

Weezer - Make Believe
I've loved pretty much everything Rick Rubin has touched (except for Mezmerize and a few other records), but he totally screwed up Weezer. Not that Maladroit was amazing or anything, but Weezer has now turned into even more of a stereotypical emo band with this.

That's all I can think of right now.

[Brodie]

I was kind of disapointed with Gorillaz- Demon Dayz. I love the Gorillaz, but it seemed like just mindless beats, and borderline techno.

[Mr. Stay Puft]

Originally Posted by President Dead

System of a Down -Mezmerize[/B]
It didn't have the same sound or feeling that the other three records had. It was a change in style for the band, and it wasn't really good. To top it off, it was being released as a two cd released one at a time, and this one is about 30-40 minutes long. Rip off.

I love the new System of a Down. Sure, it's different, but that's why I love it.

My disappointing albums:

Finch - Say Hello to Sunshine
The title isn't the only thing that sucked about this album. None of the songs stand out. They don't grab your attention like their previous albums, Falling into Place and What it is to Burn

The Used - In Love and Death
Waaaaaaaayyyyyyyyy too poppy. Avoid this album at all costs.

Funeral for a Friend - Hours
One of my favorite things about this band was the way they layered the drummer's metacore-style screaming over the singers melodic vocals. Sadly, they did away with this on the new album. At least they kept the 'Iron Maiden gone punk' style guitar riffs.

Incubus - anything after SCIENCE
SCIENCE was an amazing album. Everything after was nothing but radio-friendly crap. Especially Morning View

Any Staind album after Break the Cycle
Because "It's Been Awhile" and "Outside" were such big hits, they decided to become a bunch of p*ssies and make everything sound like a Three Doors Down song. Give me back my "Mudshovel" and "Can't Believe", you sellouts!!

[Cerpin Taxt]

Originally Posted by Mikeys_in_tha_hizouse

Incubus - anything after SCIENCE
SCIENCE was an amazing album. Everything after was nothing but radio-friendly crap. Especially Morning View

I disagree. Morning View (in my opinion) was an awesome CD. A Crow Left Of The Murder was pretty good (though "Talk Shows On Mute" pisses me off) as well. As a friend who's obsessed with Incubus keeps telling me, their style changes with each record. And, again in my opinion, it aways has been for the better.

The only Incubus album I really don't like is Fungus Amongus, which is their first album.

[Mr. Stay Puft]

Originally Posted by President Dead

I disagree. Morning View (in my opinion) was an awesome CD. A Crow Left Of The Murder was pretty good (though "Talk Shows On Mute" pisses me off) as well. As a friend who's obsessed with Incubus keeps telling me, their style changes with each record. And, again in my opinion, it aways has been for the better.

The only Incubus album I really don't like is Fungus Amongus, which is their first album.

I just really liked the whole funk/rock/metal thing they had going with the early albums. Make Yourself wasn't bad, but Morning View, to me, just screams "Radio-friendly," and "Let's sell out!" I do like the song "Circles" off that album, though.

[Cerpin Taxt]

Originally Posted by Mikeys_in_tha_hizouse

I just really liked the whole funk/rock/metal thing they had going with the early albums. Make Yourself wasn't bad, but Morning View, to me, just screams "Radio-friendly," and "Let's sell out!" I do like the song "Circles" off that album, though.

Radio friendly? Let's sell out?

Nobody's done that better than the bands you mentioned. Not an insult or an opinion, but a fact. It's in like a book or something.

Morning View was supposed to be a much more mellow record. It was recorded in a mansion right on the water, and they wrote songs reflecting the atmosphere. That's where the overall tone for the album comes from, not from pressure from the record label or the idea of, "Hey, if we metaphorically take it in the face and make a record the masses would enjoy instead of us expressing our talent, we would make a lot of money!"

[Mr. Stay Puft]

Originally Posted by President Dead

Radio friendly? Let's sell out?

Nobody's done that better than the bands you mentioned. Not an insult or an opinion, but a fact. It's in like a book or something.

Morning View was supposed to be a much more mellow record. It was recorded in a mansion right on the water, and they wrote songs reflecting the atmosphere. That's where the overall tone for the album comes from, not from pressure from the record label or the idea of, "Hey, if we metaphorically take it in the face and make a record the masses would enjoy instead of us expressing our talent, we would make a lot of money!"

True. The only band I can think of that has never really disappointed me would be the Deftones. Can't wait for their next one.

I pretty much feel the same way about Terry Date as you do about Rick Rubin. Everything he touches is usually good (SCIENCE, all 4 Deftones albums, Staind's Dysfunction), but he kinda screwed up on FFAF. "GGGarth" Richardson is a very good producer, as well.

[Spitfire]

I don't like The Black Album because it marks the end of Metallica. They were so mainstream when it came out. And it lead them to make even worse albums. It just didn't sound like Metallica and it was hardly metal. And for some horrible reason most people, ones who just heard about Metallica on the radio, thought The Black Album was their first album <_< Bothered the Hell out of me. But all bands have to end somewhere, they just had an early end...

Iron Maiden were great, their last good album was Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son. Then No Prayer For The Dying...and Fear Of The Dark...and many more came out. Some of them had one or two good songs but most of them were horrible to listen to. The X Factor came out in '95 and they had a new singer namer Blaze. He just plain sucked. I hated his regin was the singer <_< But Finially in the year 2000 Maiden came back with a kick ass album! Brave New World. And then they came out with Dance Of Death which was also very kick ass! And when I saw them on tour last they said their going to make one more! I can't wait ^^

[raphael_is_cool]

1039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours - Green Day
After hearing Kerplunk I figured some earlier Green Day might be alright. But this just plain sucks, it's simple pop punk without an ounce of energy to it either.

Warning - Green Day
No, just no.

Before Everything and After - MxPx
I was anticipating this album for a while. It was alright but nothing spectacular. Thank God we now have Panic.

Foo Fighters - Foo Fighters
My friend said it was better than The Colour and the Shape. My friend does however have a lot of wrong opinions. While not necessarily bad, thanks to the hype it became a disappointment.

Borders and Boundaries - Less Than Jake
Couple of alright tracks, other than that it is just bad. The production is a mess, just a bunch of fuzz. Roger was given way too many lead vocals on terrible tracks that sound ad hoc, in a bad way.

Live From Camp X-Ray - Rocket From The Crypt
Some great tracks, but not enough variety and it is far too short

Any albums after 'Ixnay' - The Offspring
Again, some okay tracks and a lot of variety but generally average overall.

[Mr. Stay Puft]

Originally Posted by raphael_is_cool

1039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours - Green Day
After hearing Kerplunk I figured some earlier Green Day might be alright. But this just plain sucks, it's simple pop punk without an ounce of energy to it either.

Warning - Green Day
No, just no.

Before Everything and After - MxPx
I was anticipating this album for a while. It was alright but nothing spectacular. Thank God we now have Panic.

Foo Fighters - Foo Fighters
My friend said it was better than The Colour and the Shape. My friend does however have a lot of wrong opinions. While not necessarily bad, thanks to the hype it became a disappointment.

Borders and Boundaries - Less Than Jake
Couple of alright tracks, other than that it is just bad. The production is a mess, just a bunch of fuzz. Roger was given way too many lead vocals on terrible tracks that sound ad hoc, in a bad way.

Live From Camp X-Ray - Rocket From The Crypt
Some great tracks, but not enough variety and it is far too short

Any albums after 'Ixnay' - The Offspring
Again, some okay tracks and a lot of variety but generally average overall.

I pretty much agree with everything you said, though Americana wasn't a bad album. I prefer Smash myself.

[Jed]

Foo Fighters' first album is one of my favorite albums, and recently I can't stop listning to Binaural by Pearl Jam.

Ones that have disappointed me are

NoFX - Maximum Rock n Roll
I'd probably like it now, and I have it on mp3 somewhere, but when I got it years ago I just thought it was totally unlistenable.

Me First And The Gimme Gimmes - Ruin Johnny's Bar Mitzvah
I was really looking forward to this live Gimmes album but it's just.... not very good. The songs are poor and I know Gimmes are supposed to be shoddy live but this was just too shoddy!

REM - Around The Sun
Save for Leaving New York and Electron Blue I just don't like the album.

Red Hot Chili Peppers - Red Hot Chili Peppers
I love Freaky Styley, Uplift Mofo and Mother's Milk so I thought I'd love this too. I bought it about 5 years after the rest and it's just too tame, but I do love True Men Don't Kill Coyotes.

That's all I can think of right now, aside from the Punk-O-Rama CDs becoming incresingly worse.

[Cerpin Taxt]

Um...Foo Fighters came out before The Colour and the Shape. It was the debut album. I thought it was awesome, and I thought "Monkey Wrench" was a crappy single. The new album sucks, though. And I do miss Pat Smear oh so much...

As for Green Day: They pretty much sucked from Warning on. Nimrod was...meh. Warning was a load of crap. American Idiot is too pop/emo for me to stand. They've sold out and have done it in a craptastic way.

I do, however, like Green Day's old stuff on the (now failing) Lookout! Records label. If they didn't succeed and build a name for themselves, Lookout! would never have done the same and come out with awesome artists like Ted Leo/RX. Not really relevant, but whatever.

[The Stryker]

50 Cent: The Massacre

Alright i was closet fan of 50, his debut album "Get rich or die tryin" was a great album among the rap community and boasted catchy beats and lyrics that were truly from a down on his luck MC with no where to go but up.

But that was then, The massacre just was bad on every level, no catchy beats and lyrics that just sound like every other crappy rapper out there.

The Album should've been called 50 Cent: I know how to have sex, Really really really, Wanna hear me talk about it?

Man..that was 16 bucks i'll never get back.

[Cerpin Taxt]

That reminds me. Over the course of my life, I've cut myself by accident with a sharp object about 4 times. Do you think I can make a rap career out of it by bragging about it?

Oh, and add Sing the Sorrow and The Art of Drowning by AFI to the list. They went soft. They used to be an awesome punk band. Stupid Davey Havok.

[The Stryker]

Fifty was good in the first album and really talked about the troubles in NY and crap like that and it made sense and told a story....


I guess the money got to his Yankee hat