View Full Version : IDW TMNT Sales Charts
CyberCubed
10-17-2013, 09:01 PM
From what I've seen there's only like 2-3 people here that said they discovered Mirage first and then the cartoon...of course these people are over 40+ years old though and there aren't many people here that old.
Funnily enough we're starting to get some younger members here who say the 2k3 series was their first TMNT cartoon/experience, and are just now discovering the comics and going back and watching the original toon for the first time.
10 years from now we'll see the current kids watching the Nick cartoon age and come into the fandom, assuming this forum still exists 10 years from now.
liugeaux
10-18-2013, 12:38 PM
...and the TMNT fan base will be nearly as disjointed as the Star Trek fanbase.
CyberCubed
10-18-2013, 12:46 PM
...and the TMNT fan base will be nearly as disjointed as the Star Trek fanbase.
Or the Star Wars fanbase, Batman fanbase, X-men fanbase, etc.
TMNT is now finally old enough to have different generations of fans.
AquaParade
10-18-2013, 10:07 PM
Or the Star Wars fanbase, Batman fanbase, X-men fanbase, etc.
TMNT is now finally old enough to have different generations of fans.
Truly Awesome.
I know I have zero ownership of the franchise, but sometimes it feels like TMNT are our generations underdog-baby competing and slowly earning their place with the timeless, fictional characters from Marvel and DC.
Go Ninja! Go Ninja! Go!
CyberCubed
10-18-2013, 10:11 PM
Yeah, I feel like TMNT is the franchise we grew up with and saw grow with all these established properties looming over it. The great thing is the TMNT franchise started around the time most of us were born....unlike stuff such as Batman/Superman/Spiderman/Star Wars/Star Trek which all started decades before any of us existed.
Heather Breckel
10-20-2013, 01:37 PM
I feel like the Bronies and all of that are somewhat similar to Jack Black fans. Where Jack Black is all about empty-headed facial expressions, mannerisms, and "look at how insanely clever I am at behaving stupidly!" so his fans, themselves, feel clever and "in on the joke," with My Little Pony it's pretty inherently feminine and insular to very young girls so I guess the draw to its 30 year old male fans is something like, "Look at me, look at me, I'm sitting here totally comfortable being a 30 year old man watching a show for 5 year old girls... bet you don't know what to think of me now, dontcha? Dontcha?"
But to the rest of us, the sound minded people... like with Jack Black, we get the joke just fine. In fact, we've always gotten it. We just don't find it funny at all.
I take it I'm weird for being an adult woman that enjoys shows that are targeted at young boys like the Nick TMNT and pretty much the entirety of shonen manga? :lol: I'll never understand why it's okay for me to sit down and watch One Piece or Dragonball, but it's not okay for an adult male to watch a girl's show.
Even as a kid, it was always perfectly fine for me to like stuff directed at boys. But my best friend, a guy who's favorite color was pink and loved MLP, Barbie, etc. got made fun of for liking girl things. Double standards aren't cool.
MLP does well because it's a great show and great comic. (yes, I work on the comic, but I wanted to work on it because I'm a fan of the show) If MLP was merely just girly fluff with no entertainment value or substance, it wouldn't have gotten so popular. I mean, 99% of girl shows are exactly that, and they haven't gotten a big fandom.
It's totally fine if someone dislikes MLP or anything else that I like, we're all different. I'm not going to try to convert people to the show since I respect that we all have different tastes. (and I obviously know on a TMNT board people are likely going to prefer TMNT over MLP) But I'll never get why there is a need to look down on others for liking something they don't like.
ToTheNines
11-27-2013, 10:34 PM
Just realized I never reported October sales:
154. TMNT #27 - 17,042 copies
202. Villain Micro-series: Bebop/Rocksteady - 11,584 copies
262. TMNT: New Animated Adventures - 7,905 copies
B&R got a nice boost out of the Micro-series :)
CyberCubed
11-27-2013, 10:37 PM
I wonder how low the Nick comic can go for them to consider stopping it. I assume 5,000 copies is the minimum.
A real shame if it gets canceled like Dreamwave was. Both 4kids and Nick won't have long spanning comics like Archie.
ToTheNines
11-27-2013, 10:39 PM
IDW has plenty of books that are deeper into their runs with way worse sales. As long as it hangs on until next August, it'll be good. I'm sure the new movie will bring in plenty of new readers.
CyberCubed
11-27-2013, 10:42 PM
Also it's possible the Nick comic could go quarterly rather than monthly if worse comes to worse. I think Nick themselves would want IDW to keep up the cartoon comic as much as possible.
Redeemer
11-28-2013, 10:39 PM
Also it's possible the Nick comic could go quarterly rather than monthly if worse comes to worse. I think Nick themselves would want IDW to keep up the cartoon comic as much as possible.
I can see this happening, I think the best thing that could happen is for them to go to quarterly collect stories. Such a 4 issue length arc compressed into a book. :lol: (sorry new comic collector not sure whether or not to call them graphic novels.)
also glad to hear that R&B did so well for the micro series. and sales are still going well for the onging.
CyberCubed
12-07-2013, 08:37 PM
Does anyone have sales figures for all the IDW trades so far? And by that I mean the Mirage and Archie collections specifically?
ToTheNines
12-08-2013, 01:22 PM
You could research it on comicchron. But you're a lazy ****.
CyberCubed
12-08-2013, 01:34 PM
I'd rather someone just post it here. I don't visit any comic websites really.
ToTheNines
12-08-2013, 06:18 PM
If you spent less time douching it up here, you would have boatloads of free time to check out other websites.
ToTheNines
12-16-2013, 06:04 PM
November:
124. TMNT #28 - 17,045 copies
244. TMNT NAA #5 - 7,112 copies
(Shredder micro numbers won't be out til next month)
http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2013/2013-11.html
MikeandRaph87
12-16-2013, 07:17 PM
November:
124. TMNT #28 - 17,045 copies
244. TMNT NAA #5 - 7,112 copies
(Shredder micro numbers won't be out til next month)
http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2013/2013-11.html
That is only 3 copies difference from last month. Interesting that three readers were picked up. Come on guys let's push this to an average around 20,000 not a little over 17,000.
CyberCubed
12-16-2013, 07:33 PM
The Nick comic dropped by 800 sales though.
Since these comics are mainly aimed at kids instead of adults, its a bit disappointing all the little kids watching the show aren't asking their parents to buy the comic. IDW should get the Nick comic into places like Toys R Us, they sell DC and Marvel comics aimed at kids.
Plasticplayhouse
12-17-2013, 07:21 AM
The Nick comic dropped by 800 sales though.
Since these comics are mainly aimed at kids instead of adults, its a bit disappointing all the little kids watching the show aren't asking their parents to buy the comic. IDW should get the Nick comic into places like Toys R Us, they sell DC and Marvel comics aimed at kids.
yeah, but i'm sure the majority of little kids who watch the show don't even know about the nick comic. now if it was in a grocery store check out isle...they would sell like hot cakes!
liugeaux
12-17-2013, 09:45 AM
Agreed, the tiny sad comic section of TRU is the perfect place for this to sell mad copies.
CyberCubed
12-17-2013, 12:03 PM
I wonder if most of the 7,000 sales of the Nick comic actually come from older TMNT fans like us who follow IDW.
I wonder how much of those sales actually come from little kids asking their parents to buy the comic for them. That's the real target audience, not all the hardcore TMNT fans like us.
Heather Breckel
12-17-2013, 02:56 PM
There are definitely kids that get it, it's been split evenly between kids and adults that come and get their comics signed when I have a table at cons.
ToTheNines
12-17-2013, 05:18 PM
Keep in mind that digital sales aren't reported here. Youngins love those tablets.
ToTheNines
01-16-2014, 08:36 PM
December numbers
137. TMNT #29 - 15,532
159. Micro-series #8: Shredder - 12,829
259. TMNT NAA #6 - 6,649
392. Kevin Easter Cover Gallery - 2,559
CyberCubed
01-16-2014, 08:59 PM
#29 seems to have taken a hit. Is that the lowest sales for the main ongoing yet?
AquaParade
01-16-2014, 10:41 PM
City Fall didn't end as strong as I had hoped leading to a personal delayed purchase of issue #29. Perhaps I wasn't the only one who felt this way.
CyberCubed
01-17-2014, 08:06 AM
Both the ongoing and Nick comic were down about 1,000 sales from the previous month. The Shredder micro didn't do all that hot either.
Pretty disappointing to see sales slip. We're only 2 years into IDW TMNT and I would hope to get at least a 5 year run.
ToTheNines
01-17-2014, 04:55 PM
Quit your bitching, you negative ****. TMNT is still IDW's second best selling franchise. And the Shredder micro sold more than the B&R issue, which sold more than the Hun issue before it.
ToTheNines
02-11-2014, 09:24 AM
January numbers
133. X-Files Conspiracy #1 - 15,576
136. TMNT #30 - 14,979 (down by 553 from #29)
172. Utrom Empire #1 - 11,084 (down by 1,745 from Shredder Micro)
255. TMNT NAA #7 - 6,331 (down by 318 from #6)
Sofistocat
02-11-2014, 09:52 AM
January numbers
133. X-Files Conspiracy #1 - 15,576
136. TMNT #30 - 14,979 (down by 553 from #29)
172. Utrom Empire #1 - 11,084 (down by 1,745 from Shredder Micro)
255. TMNT NAA #7 - 6,331 (down by 318 from #6)
Would you take 4% of the Utrom Empire #1 total to get a count of the 1:25 variant or is it 4% of the total # (11,084)? There has been a recent spike in prices for the Eastman variant cover. Trying to figure out if it's due to anythng else aside from market demand.
MikeandRaph87
02-11-2014, 10:51 AM
Just under 15,000? This is making me nervous. I like it float around 20,000. This is the worst yet I think. Such quality story telling. People should pick it up and see this quality that may not have been in a TMNT comic before this.
What are like those numbers compared to the sales of other IDW comic series?
Redeemer
02-11-2014, 11:35 AM
Both the ongoing and Nick comic were down about 1,000 sales from the previous month. The Shredder micro didn't do all that hot either.
Pretty disappointing to see sales slip. We're only 2 years into IDW TMNT and I would hope to get at least a 5 year run.
I promise you that TMNT will probably get a five year run. When the movie finally comes out, I bet we will see a spike in sale over the long.
Makes me wish IDW would give a way some sort of movie issue tie-in with the movie, then again if the movie was bad it would shoot TMNT in the foot.:ohwell:
Quit your bitching, you negative ****.
Thank you
CyberCubed
02-11-2014, 12:19 PM
This is what I've been talking about for months, now that the initial hype period has faded away, a lot of the casuals are dropping the comics, and only us hardcore TMNT fans are still buying it.
It's a real shame to see the main ongoing only at 14,000 when it used to hover around 18,000-20,000.
This makes me think IDW is going to have to promote some major event in the comic again for another massive spike, or perhaps killing off an important character to drive up hype.
pannoni1
02-11-2014, 02:17 PM
Remember that paper comics have been in a decline in recent years, so its not too surprising that a slight decline has been registered. But remember that January is traditionally a weak month following the Christmas holidays. Hopefully that means more bargain bin deals soon before the movie hypes the casuals back in. Hopefully the end of City Fall will mean a big turn of events, and lots not forget the 30th anniversary promotions to get a boost.
CyberCubed
02-11-2014, 02:26 PM
Yeah but these declines have been happening for a few months, with only a few sales spikes due to incentive covers and the start of certain arcs.
I wonder how much longer the Nick comic will go on especially with it only doing 6,000 in sales. We'll know how low IDW is willing to tolerate TMNT comics selling when the Nick animated comic gets the axe first.
ToTheNines
02-11-2014, 02:59 PM
This is what I've been talking about for months, now that the initial hype period has faded away, a lot of the casuals are dropping the comics, and only us hardcore TMNT fans are still buying it.
It's a real shame to see the main ongoing only at 14,000 when it used to hover around 18,000-20,000.
This makes me think IDW is going to have to promote some major event in the comic again for another massive spike, or perhaps killing off an important character to drive up hype.
For the last ****ing time, TMNT is IDW's second best selling license. Clearly ahead of Transformers, GI Joe and Star Trek. The much newer X-Files stuff is the only other thing vying for the #2 spot right now.
You are now banned from this thread.
Redeemer
02-11-2014, 03:01 PM
Well from what I read these sale number only account for paper comic sales and not digital. so we don't know the actual sale numbers.
apparently 10% of IDW comic sales are digital so use a little math and you can get a rough sale figure of the actual TMNT comic sales
fugitoid9000
02-11-2014, 03:32 PM
I couldn't be happier here...we finally(at least in 2009 I certainly didn't expect there to be a NEW turtles comics book for real...more like somewhere in the distant foggy future with luck there'll be reprints)...I tell you it feels so good to await a new issue each month again, like in the old days..I only got into getting monthly comic books because of mirage tmnt comics...
and now the book is also SO GOOD and EXCITING...with sales numbers staying anywhere near these marks there must be LOTS of years of the new book ahead!thank you idw amigos!!
I agree i read city fall about a week ago and i'm completely hooked. I'm now scrambling to get everything leading up to those issues. The bidding is really competitive for this series on ebay and rightly so, It's Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
Redrumh2o
02-11-2014, 05:34 PM
There is no way they would stop publishing during a movie run. If the first movie does well and sequels are announced....they wouldn't drop the license and give up market share to another publisher. I am sure they are doing fine. When you add up all the $ TMNT brings IDW it has to be decent (Classics, Ongoing, AA, Micros, Ultimate Collections, IDW Limited Offerings, Digital, TPBs...)
Redeemer
02-12-2014, 01:19 AM
When you add up all the $ TMNT brings IDW it has to be decent (Classics, Ongoing, AA, Micros, Ultimate Collections, IDW Limited Offerings, Digital, TPBs...)
Exactly you know IDW is making a killing!!!
Matches Malone
02-13-2014, 02:51 AM
This is what I've been talking about for months, now that the initial hype period has faded away, a lot of the casuals are dropping the comics, and only us hardcore TMNT fans are still buying it.
It's a real shame to see the main ongoing only at 14,000 when it used to hover around 18,000-20,000.
This makes me think IDW is going to have to promote some major event in the comic again for another massive spike, or perhaps killing off an important character to drive up hype.
So are you saying that we need those casuals who buy TMNT? Or are they horrible scum who are unwanted? Because if they're both, that's kind of silly...
Can we just say anyone who puts money down for TMNT is a welcomed fan?
Plus, almost every ongoing series has declining sales. It's either going up or down, and unless you have some crazy momentum going like The Walking Dead, it's going to be down, little by little. For a comic that's approaching 3 years old, I think the sales are pretty solid.
Bobby Curnow
02-13-2014, 03:27 AM
Matches has it right. There are always anomalies, but the vast majority of titles decline over time, either by a little or by a lot. That's just they way it is with anything. With TMNT, it's a pretty gentle decline. Honestly, there's a lot of good hype around the book right now, and for a series this far along, that means more people are picking up the trades to see what the good word of mouth is about. Of course i'd like better numbers, but we're doing very, very well for a non-Marvel/DC book in it's third year.
It could be that we take some horrible turns and start shedding readers at a faster rate, but I don't think that's going to be the case. If we continue as is, we're very safe till #50, possibly well beyond. No one is more concerned about the status of the book than me, and I feel really good about the future of the book.
The only thing anyone can really do is, if you're enjoying the book, buy it (maybe pre-order!) tell your friends, post about it online. The rest will take care of itself.
BODYCOUNT
02-13-2014, 11:45 AM
After reading City Fall (a bday gift from my wife) i went out and bought all the issues for City Fall and #1-6 of the trades. Just finished Vol 5 Krang War. Just gotta pic up the micro trades and im set. This series has really rekindled my love for the Turtles. My children are just as in to it as well. But the writing in these books are great and i cant get enough of them. I have a feeling the movie will really push the comics sales as older folks who grew up in the early (been down since day 1) 80's as children will now have the loot to go out and buy these comics.
When Shredder gutted Casey in City Fall Thats when i knew that this was the real deal. If you can go that far as to mortally wound a main character like that. I knew that the writers were gonna deliver the goods. Thanks man!
Redeemer
02-14-2014, 12:47 AM
When Shredder gutted Casey in City Fall Thats when i knew that this was the real deal.
Damn straight!!!!! :thumbsup:
Joey Kamikaze
02-14-2014, 02:56 AM
When Shredder gutted Casey in City Fall Thats when i knew that this was the real deal. If you can go that far as to mortally wound a main character like that. I knew that the writers were gonna deliver the goods. Thanks man!
Amen. That panel left my mouth hanging open. This incarnation of Shredder has quickly risen to become my favorite. Out of all the other Shredders, how many of them have actually used those gauntlets on-screen like that? Dude means business.
BODYCOUNT
02-14-2014, 07:32 PM
Amen. That panel left my mouth hanging open. This incarnation of Shredder has quickly risen to become my favorite. Out of all the other Shredders, how many of them have actually used those gauntlets on-screen like that? Dude means business.
Shredder = My favorite character by far in this rendition of the turtles. :tcool:
MrTMNT2012
03-16-2014, 09:56 AM
I got into the IDW Series after City Fall and have been buying every Issue from the TMNT Comics App ever since! :)
One way you guys could help boost the sales is by adding Social Networking sites like a Twitter/Facebook Page, just to spread out the fan base. Hell, even the TMNTIDW Twitter name is free if you want to use it...
Redeemer
03-18-2014, 12:11 AM
Matches has it right. There are always anomalies, but the vast majority of titles decline over time, either by a little or by a lot. That's just they way it is with anything. With TMNT, it's a pretty gentle decline. Honestly, there's a lot of good hype around the book right now, and for a series this far along, that means more people are picking up the trades to see what the good word of mouth is about. Of course i'd like better numbers, but we're doing very, very well for a non-Marvel/DC book in it's third year.
It could be that we take some horrible turns and start shedding readers at a faster rate, but I don't think that's going to be the case. If we continue as is, we're very safe till #50, possibly well beyond. No one is more concerned about the status of the book than me, and I feel really good about the future of the book.
The only thing anyone can really do is, if you're enjoying the book, buy it (maybe pre-order!) tell your friends, post about it online. The rest will take care of itself.
Hey do you think that maybe if the movie does well enough it actually might boost comics sales and help improve the longevity of the book???
Kendamu
03-18-2014, 01:34 AM
Matches has it right. There are always anomalies, but the vast majority of titles decline over time, either by a little or by a lot. That's just they way it is with anything. With TMNT, it's a pretty gentle decline. Honestly, there's a lot of good hype around the book right now, and for a series this far along, that means more people are picking up the trades to see what the good word of mouth is about. Of course i'd like better numbers, but we're doing very, very well for a non-Marvel/DC book in it's third year.
It could be that we take some horrible turns and start shedding readers at a faster rate, but I don't think that's going to be the case. If we continue as is, we're very safe till #50, possibly well beyond. No one is more concerned about the status of the book than me, and I feel really good about the future of the book.
The only thing anyone can really do is, if you're enjoying the book, buy it (maybe pre-order!) tell your friends, post about it online. The rest will take care of itself.
Are digital copies taken into account for these numbers?
ToTheNines
03-20-2014, 07:51 PM
February numbers...
129. TMNT #31 - 14,684 copies
144. X-Files Conspiracy: TMNT - 13,104
185. TMNT: Utrom Empire - 9,542
249. TMNT: NAA #8 - 6,034
CyberCubed
03-20-2014, 07:57 PM
First time the main series has dipped as low as 14,000, huh? Last month was 15,000. Hopefully it boosts up again soon.
The Nick comic is holding steady at 6,000 each month. I'd love to see the Nick comic go on for the entire run of the cartoon, but I realize that might not be feasible. It's a fun little companion comic.
HeroTurtlesFan
03-21-2014, 08:31 AM
IDW has previously suggested that 5000 is their magic number - in other words, if a book goes under 5000 it could be cancelled... but then they have some books that are, and haven't been, so the Nick Turtles comic could still go for a while.
DrSpengler
03-21-2014, 09:10 AM
Those micro funpacks for New Animated Adventures are on the way. They aren't tallied along with direct market numbers, I don't think, but I'm betting if they sell well (and they likely will since they'll have wider distribution) they may warrant keeping New Animated Adventures alive, even if the direct market numbers dip below 5,000.
Are these numbers just USA? Or worldwide?
Physical, digital or combined?
Thanks :)
ToTheNines
04-07-2014, 08:44 PM
March numbers...
134. TMNT #32 - 15,040 copies
171. X-Files Conspiracy #2 - 10,859
200. TMNT: Utrom Empire #3 - 9,035
268. TMNT: NAA #9 - 6,009
Redeemer
04-07-2014, 08:48 PM
Are these numbers just USA? Or worldwide?
Physical, digital or combined?
Thanks :)
I am not sure if its just US or worldwide, but I do know that they are Physical copies only, not digital.
MikeandRaph87
04-07-2014, 08:59 PM
March numbers...
134. TMNT #32 - 15,040 copies
171. X-Files Conspiracy #2 - 10,859
200. TMNT: Utrom Empire #3 - 9,035
268. TMNT: NAA #9 - 6,009
Over 15,000 again. Lets try to push it up another 500 for the next issue. That means you all who read through trades.
CyberCubed
04-07-2014, 09:05 PM
Overall the Utrom Empire mini sold the least of all the Turtle-centric miniseries so far. I don't believe any of the micro's sold around 9,000 or Secret History of the Foot Clan.
I hope the Turtles in Time mini will sell a lot more, I wonder if the name will help it any.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
04-07-2014, 09:07 PM
Do we have other IDW comics to compare these numbers to?
(This may have already been discussed, so if so, sorry about that.)
Redeemer
04-07-2014, 09:11 PM
Overall the Utrom Empire mini sold the least of all the Turtle-centric miniseries so far. I don't believe any of the micro's sold around 9,000 or Secret History of the Foot Clan.
I hope the Turtles in Time mini will sell a lot more, I wonder if the name will help it any.
Utrom empire was only 3 issue right?? For some reason I feel like I skipped an issue and I was suppose to pick up a 4th issue :lol:
Cipher
04-07-2014, 09:55 PM
Do we have other IDW comics to compare these numbers to?
(This may have already been discussed, so if so, sorry about that.)
Haven't looked at the full Diamond numbers (where you could find other IDW series), but just seeing it hit #129 at all isn't bad when you consider that the top 100 spots are usually full of the Big 2's outputs.
15,000 is cancellation threshold for DC's superhero titles, but I imagine it's fairly successful for IDW, whose licensed titles are a lot more niche.
ToTheNines
04-08-2014, 06:31 AM
Do we have other IDW comics to compare these numbers to?
(This may have already been discussed, so if so, sorry about that.)
http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2014/2014-03.html
HeroTurtlesFan
04-08-2014, 07:06 AM
Over 15,000 again. Lets try to push it up another 500 for the next issue. That means you all who read through trades.
That would be me... I am seriously considering jumping on the singles, but my "collecting compulsion" would not be satisfied at just having a collection starting at #33. I'd feel compelled to try and track down the other 32, even if I have them in TPB... and the price on some of those early single issues is way too high. Hence, I falter. Silly reason, I know...
I hope the Turtles in Time mini will sell a lot more, I wonder if the name will help it any.
I am confident it will. Not just the name (am I the only one who has never heard of this video game?) but the concept, and the fact it will focus on the Turtles themselves, will help.
Do we have other IDW comics to compare these numbers to?
(This may have already been discussed, so if so, sorry about that.)
The two ongoing Transformers titles at the moment are called "More Than Meets The Eye" and "Robots In Disguise". They both receive enormous fan and sometimes-critical acclaim (esp. MTMTE) but both are averaging between 9500 - 10500 at the moment, and have been for the last year.
"Ghostbusters" is way lower, at circa 5-7k.
Coincidentally, both franchises, like TMNT, celebrate their 30th anniversaries this year.
Nobody should be worried - TMNT is a consistently good seller for IDW.
CyberCubed
04-08-2014, 08:28 AM
I think it might be people like me causing the decline in sales. I'm one of the many people who switched over to the trades and no longer buy the single issues anymore. I also sold all my previous single issues on ebay a while ago.
I've learned that IDW TMNT is best read in arcs. Reading a single issue every month is actually what caused me to lose interest in the comic after a while.
However once I got the trades I got back into the series and re-read it from start to finish and enjoyed it much more. I prefer sticking with the trades now and that's why I haven't read Utrom Empire or the Northampton arc yet...I gotta wait till June, etc. till those trades come out.
I figured TMNT was doing relatively well, sales-wise, but I didn't realize it's one of IDW's top sellers. Only outsold by the ridiculously popular My Little Pony stuff. Wow.
That's pretty awesome, and really speaks to the great work that whole team is doing.
Sewer Sirens Podcast
04-08-2014, 09:21 AM
Haven't looked at the full Diamond numbers (where you could find other IDW series), but just seeing it hit #129 at all isn't bad when you consider that the top 100 spots are usually full of the Big 2's outputs
http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2014/2014-03.html
The two ongoing Transformers titles at the moment are called "More Than Meets The Eye" and "Robots In Disguise". They both receive enormous fan and sometimes-critical acclaim (esp. MTMTE) but both are averaging between 9500 - 10500 at the moment, and have been for the last year.
"Ghostbusters" is way lower, at circa 5-7k.
Coincidentally, both franchises, like TMNT, celebrate their 30th anniversaries this year.
Nobody should be worried - TMNT is a consistently good seller for IDW.
This is all great news. I was getting a little worried that this series wasn't pulling off good numbers because of other peoples worry based statements, but now I'm a lot more faithful that this series won't be canceled anytime soon. It's great, and just getting better, and I can't wait to see where they plan to go in the future.
CyberCubed
04-08-2014, 10:08 AM
I expect IDW TMNT to last for 10 years.
It's the Nick animated comic I would be worried about given it only sells 6,000 copies .
Sewer Sirens Podcast
04-08-2014, 10:20 AM
I expect IDW TMNT to last for 10 years.
It's the Nick animated comic I would be worried about given it only sells 6,000 copies .
What are you basing the 10 years off of? What makes you think it'll be that particular number?
CyberCubed
04-09-2014, 08:47 PM
What are you basing the 10 years off of? What makes you think it'll be that particular number?
I mean at least 10 years. Why do I say it? Because if sales remain consistent at around 15,000 or higher, its likely to go on for a long time.
The Nick cartoon is probably going to go on for a long period of time as well, and the IDW comic had a almost 2 year head start over it since it started in 2011. We're already in year 3.
ToTheNines
05-13-2014, 04:43 PM
April numberz...
138. TMNT #33 - 16,736 copies
279. TMNT NAA #10 - 5,911
The ongoing got a decent boost, and was IDW's third best selling book last month behind My Little Pony and its Friends Forever companion book.
CyberCubed
05-13-2014, 05:05 PM
I wonder if it's because the art returned to its Cityfall look. The Nick comic is below 6,000 now which makes you wonder what direction they're going to go with it.
Sabacooza
05-13-2014, 05:53 PM
The Nick comic needs to up the quality over all or I don't see it lasting very long. Give me a reason to make me want to pick it up every month.
CyberCubed
05-13-2014, 06:07 PM
The Nick comic needs to up the quality over all or I don't see it lasting very long. Give me a reason to make me want to pick it up every month.
It's aimed at kids though. I don't think IDW expects older fans to be picking it up aside from the hardcore TMNT fans like us. But the rest of the IDW readers probably don't bother. And we know that because the 16,000 people buying IDW TMNT every month aren't buying the Nick comic or else the sales numbers would be identical.
Sabacooza
05-14-2014, 09:10 AM
It's aimed at kids though. I don't think IDW expects older fans to be picking it up aside from the hardcore TMNT fans like us. But the rest of the IDW readers probably don't bother. And we know that because the 16,000 people buying IDW TMNT every month aren't buying the Nick comic or else the sales numbers would be identical.True dat. It still wouldn't hurt to up the quality a bit. Just because it's for kids doesn't mean it can't look nice.
However, if the quality has to do with the tight schedule, I can understand that. Since I've done some work for IDW I have a new appreciation for it. Some are good under pressure, others, not so much.
CyberCubed
05-15-2014, 11:00 PM
What was the cancellation number for IDW's comics again? It was less than 5,000, I think?
Nick Animatied is at 5,900...but if it continues to dip I don't think they'll bother continuing it much longer. I wonder if it'll make it to issue 20 as we're at #11 now.
Sabacooza
05-18-2014, 09:49 PM
Honestly, if it gets canceled, it wouldn't bother me.
Heather Breckel
05-18-2014, 10:09 PM
Well it would definitely bother me as I work on it :P
CyberCubed
05-18-2014, 10:18 PM
I like the Nick animated comics, but as said if it does end it wouldn't be a big loss.
I think its more of a shame that little kids who watch the cartoon aren't picking up the comics, rather than for older fans like us. If this is the case this will be the second comic series based on a cartoon that failed, just like the Dreamwave series for the 4kids series bombed.
Sabacooza
05-18-2014, 11:01 PM
Well it would definitely bother me as I work on it :PSorry. I guess I have to watch what I say. Everyone's watching.;) If the artwork itself was better, maybe then I'd care. With all this TMNT stuff coming out though one has to prioritize as a consumer.
Redeemer
05-19-2014, 05:25 PM
Well it would definitely bother me as I work on it :P
Step up your game then :P
jk: I have not even read the series so I have no opinion on it.
ToTheNines
06-19-2014, 07:33 AM
Nombres de Mayo
156. TMNT 30th anniversary special - 13,391 copies sold
258. TMNT NAA #11 - 6,075
Even with the ongoing missing it's May release, TMNT still came in behind MLP as IDW's second best selling license thanks to the Anniversary special. Cool!
Zulithe
06-19-2014, 07:41 AM
sad to see how few copies BOTH books sell, tbh. But that's just how comics are these days. In the 90s when I was really into reading comics the numbers were pretty big even for smaller books. I know this isn't news, but it still gets me sometimes to think about.
I wonder how these IDW books sell in trade format?
CyberCubed
06-19-2014, 08:22 AM
sad to see how few copies BOTH books sell, tbh. But that's just how comics are these days. In the 90s when I was really into reading comics the numbers were pretty big even for smaller books. I know this isn't news, but it still gets me sometimes to think about.
I wonder how these IDW books sell in trade format?
The ongoing usually averages 16,000 sales per month. The specials always sell less.
And Nick animated has always sold poorly, barely hovering around 6,000 sales.
ToTheNines
06-19-2014, 08:29 AM
I see that book getting cancelled soon. It's selling the same as Ghostbusters, which is going bye-bye after September. Sadly :(
CyberCubed
06-19-2014, 01:15 PM
I wonder if Nick themselves are paying IDW to keep the animated book going. I mean they probably want kids to get into the comics.
It's like how Peter Laird was making a loss on Volume 4 and Tales for years, but he kept them going from the money out of his own pocket.
ToTheNines
06-19-2014, 01:21 PM
I dunno, possible I guess. I think it might be more likely that the digital sales are doing well.
MikeandRaph87
06-19-2014, 01:40 PM
I assume its Diamond Distribution Co. that you are getting the numbers from? I would like to see what the total sales are, in that I mean the combined digital and physical sales together to get the real total. TMNT may very well be over the 20,000 mark instead of an average around 16 and a quarter.
Redeemer
06-19-2014, 02:48 PM
I dunno, possible I guess. I think it might be more likely that the digital sales are doing well.
I can definitely see that, everything is moving to digital media now.
CyberCubed
06-19-2014, 07:11 PM
Well judging by solicitations Nick animated will probably make it to the end of this year at least so it'll hit 20 issues.
Still if it does get canceled than that's the second comic based on a cartoon that got canceled early. I guess something like Archie will never happen again.
The Purple Dragon
06-28-2014, 04:16 PM
sad to see how few copies BOTH books sell, tbh. But that's just how comics are these days. In the 90s when I was really into reading comics the numbers were pretty big even for smaller books. I know this isn't news, but it still gets me sometimes to think about.
I wonder how these IDW books sell in trade format?
me as well i wish someone coued post the salenr on tpb and hc
i coued be wrong but i think they sell well because most people/comic store in europe just buy/sell the tpb/hc because nobody wanth them or because they are to pricey and i does not help with all the variant covers.
that i guess is the main reason people in europe dont buy ploppys/singel issues eny more.
my guess if the publisher want to keep going with paper they have to just go digital with the singel issues and just print tbp or hc
Redeemer
06-28-2014, 04:29 PM
me as well i wish someone coued post the salenr on tpb and hc
i coued be wrong but i think they sell well because most people/comic store in europe just buy/sell the tpb/hc because nobody wanth them or because they are to pricey and i does not help with all the variant covers.
that i guess is the main reason people in europe dont buy ploppys/singel issues eny more.
my guess if the publisher want to keep going with paper they have to just go digital with the singel issues and just print tbp or hc
That is interesting, so in Europe people buy more trade-paperbacks or Hardcover trades than single issues????? I guess it would make sense from a price point. It is cheaper to ship and import trades than single issues.
The Purple Dragon
06-28-2014, 05:03 PM
i cant say all contrys in europe does it but most of them do,perhaps in some of the biggest citys they take in a small nr of singel issues atleast of the marvel best sellers but the rest goes in trades and harcover,
last time i did buy a singel issue in 02 it was 10$ fore a issue. my guess to day is closer to 15$ and that are fore regulare so you can guess how mutch a variant cover woued go fore.i cant rember to see singel issues in my comic store the couple of years.
i think most people in europe buy singels digital to support and keep track and buy trades or hard covers on paper.
but rember its not just the price on singel issues but variant covers and if you want to store singels propley the supplyes also cost mutch and take a lot of space.
instead of trades and hc you can just store in your bookshelvs,coast less and you get a better flow in the reading
Mayhem
06-29-2014, 06:34 AM
Probably depends on the country. I know Norway has some pretty extreme import duties at times, having shipped to folks there in the past, and marking down the valuation quite severely heh.
Here in the UK via my comic store (and many others having compared over the years), your bog standard issue tends to be £2.99 or £3.29 (US$5), the 5:1 will be £4.99 (US$8.50), the 10:1 will be £7.99 (US$13.50) and the 25:1 will be £14.99 (US$25.50). Many places will also do free shipping within the UK as well, all bagged and boarded on top.
So it isn't that expensive for me to get single issues, and the variants on top in general. Certainly I've been able to get almost all the Diamond distributed covers from the IDW TMNT run via my comic place, I just needed to go to other places for a couple of the 25:1 (Utrom and X-Files).
Outside, UK most of Europe doesn't have comic shops with imported comics at all, and you wouldn't be able to be up to date with an ongoing titles, only with a a big delay, unless you can buy it on Comixology. But for example TMNT is region locked and there are a countless places you can't buy it.
Importing single issues are just way too ****ing expensive, in my country there's a comic shop, which one can import single issues, but they almost as expensive as buying directly from Amazon. Besides, they don't have everything, you would possibly like to buy.
So, the only option left is buying from shops like bookdepository.com, which ships without postal fee, but only have TPBs/HCs, so no single issues, and no TMNT 30th Anniversary issue for you. :(
Rat A Tat
07-15-2014, 10:30 AM
June numbers:
Comics
127 TMNT Ongoing #34 17,442
136 TMNT Ongoing #35 15,174
145 TMNT Turtles In Time #1 13,840
218 TMNT New Animated Adventures 7,577
Collections
53 TMNT Ongoing Vol. 8 Northampton 1,621
CyberCubed
07-15-2014, 10:48 AM
Wow, New Animated Adventures got a pretty good boost this month.
liugeaux
07-17-2014, 08:24 PM
That's a really good number for turtles in time. Obviously, name recognition works.
CyberCubed
07-18-2014, 09:07 AM
That's a really good number for turtles in time. Obviously, name recognition works.
Really? The sales are about the same as the worst selling micro's. I think Fugitoid only did around 13,000.
Redeemer
08-12-2014, 01:33 PM
36# 15,415
slight boost......
Hopefully the next issue will bounce back.
ToTheNines
08-23-2014, 03:20 PM
Full July numbers:
175. TMNT #36 - 15,415
203. Turtles in Time #2 - 11,334
278. New Animated Adventures #13 - 7,158
CyberCubed
08-23-2014, 03:38 PM
Shame that the main ongoing is only in the 15,000 now, I wish it would go back to 18-19k.
Surprised the Nick comic has gotten a boost. Perhaps that series has legs yet.
But at least it looks like fixed 15k, and far away from IDW's cancellation value (5000>).
Joey Kamikaze
08-23-2014, 04:58 PM
AFAIK it's still one of IDW's best-selling books, and it's been getting lots of hype from people just starting to read it the last few months round the web. It's good to see articles like this (http://comicsalliance.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-idw-publishing-review-synopsis/) popping up more and more as people realize there's a badass TMNT comic for teens/adults going now. I wonder what effect the movie is going to have on readership in the next couple months.
CyberCubed
08-23-2014, 07:12 PM
But at least it looks like fixed 15k, and far away from IDW's cancellation value (5000>).
Nick TMNT was around 6,000 a few months back, but its received a boost lately. Unless it continues to climb, I think a lot of people are wondering how much longer IDW is willing to put up with low sales of a kid spinoff book.
Its not like Nick Animated is like Archie where we're getting new exciting adventures with new villains...its essentially a filler book with simple and short stories that are otherwise forgettable. I like it for what it is, but I wouldn't miss it if it got canceled.
What is strange they had Ghostbusters around 7,500 at the last months, I think, and they still canceled it. I guess they pay more money for the Ghostbusters license then TMNT or something like?
I think IDW's Rouge Trooper (a 2000AD created comic originally, like Judge Dredd) was around 5000, it got canceled, but yet they said, they might continue if the TPB will sell well.
Interesting.
Besides TMNT one of the better selling IDW books, but yet it's still far from the best. (just check the statistics) They no more selling 25k, like at the beginning.
ToTheNines
08-23-2014, 08:05 PM
What is strange they had Ghostbusters around 7,500 at the last months, I think, and they still canceled it. I guess they pay more money for the Ghostbusters license then TMNT or something like?
GB only moved 6,400 in June, can't find July numbers for it though...
Cipher
08-23-2014, 08:11 PM
36# 15,415
slight boost......
Hopefully the next issue will bounce back.
It's pretty crazy for any ongoing series to get a boost on a random month without any sort of gimmick. That's a really good sign for the health of the series' sales.
They no more selling 25k, like at the beginning
Long-running serials pretty much universally lose numbers over time. I's just way more likely that some people drop off along the way than that a large number of people will jump into the middle of an ongoing story. Nothing sells as well as it does at the beginning, when people are jumping on to try it. Par for the course. There are occasional sleeper hits that gain numbers as they go along, but that's rare.
That's also why it's crazy to see upswings on random months.
I got it wrong then, but that's still over their cancelation limit for TMNT. (under 5000)
CyberCubed
08-23-2014, 08:34 PM
I got it wrong then, but that's still over their cancelation limit for TMNT. (under 5000)
They're still producing 3 TMNT books at a time, (the ongoing, the mini-series/specials, and Nick animated), that if something has to give, it'll obviously be the Nick comic.
I guess kids these days just don't read comics. The Nick comic isn't aimed at us, its aimed at 8 year olds watching the Nick cartoon. They must not be asking their parents to buy the comic.
snake
08-24-2014, 12:23 AM
They're still producing 3 TMNT books at a time, (the ongoing, the mini-series/specials, and Nick animated), that if something has to give, it'll obviously be the Nick comic.
I guess kids these days just don't read comics. The Nick comic isn't aimed at us, its aimed at 8 year olds watching the Nick cartoon. They must not be asking their parents to buy the comic.
That's a shame. I love reading comics and I think kids would love them if they gave them a shot.
Joey Kamikaze
08-24-2014, 03:02 AM
If I had grade school kids in my life I would totally be buying them New Animated Adventures right now. I get my own turtle kicks off the main title.
CyberCubed
08-24-2014, 11:22 PM
I can see the Nick comic making it to about issue 25, then maybe IDW might want to pull the plug if sales simmer down to the 6,000 range again.
Redeemer
08-28-2014, 03:45 PM
I guess kids these days just don't read comics. The Nick comic isn't aimed at us, its aimed at 8 year olds watching the Nick cartoon. They must not be asking their parents to buy the comic.
Unfortunately comics are not as stimulating as other media today.
If I had grade school kids in my life I would totally be buying them New Animated Adventures right now. I get my own turtle kicks off the main title.
I know right :lol: I would brain wash my kids with TMNT!!!!!:D
"Dad I want to read Spider-man!"" SMACK!!!!!!! "You will read TMNT and you will like it!!"
I can see the Nick comic making it to about issue 25, then maybe IDW might want to pull the plug if sales simmer down to the 6,000 range again.
Thats good, I am very interested to see August and September numbers, I am hoping to see a boost from the movie release.
neatoman
09-04-2014, 09:50 AM
I've read a little of the Nick comic, I think a problem is that it seems to play it a little too safe, like how each story feels like it could be adapted into an episode and nothing would feel out of place. Maybe giving it a story of it's own (like the Archie series back in the day) would have saved it or at least given it a large enough following to make it stay around for a little longer but now it's a little too late.
ToTheNines
09-09-2014, 05:50 AM
Full August numbers:
144. TMNT #37 - 15,470
169. Turtles in Time #3 - 11,803
261. New Animated Adventures #14 - 6,420
zodach
09-09-2014, 02:21 PM
I have to wonder if these little boosts the last couple months is due to the publicity and marketing for the movie. It's good to see the numbers are pretty consistent for IDW.
CyberCubed
09-09-2014, 02:28 PM
Hm, Nick comic is back down to the 6,000 range when last month it was in the 7,000's. Guess that was a fluke. I'm still wondering if IDW is planning to give that title the axe sometime next year.
I also wish the main series would go back to the 17,000-18,000 range like it used to be. 15,000 is too low for a comic that's gotten really good the last couple of months.
Redeemer
09-10-2014, 07:57 PM
Hm, Nick comic is back down to the 6,000 range when last month it was in the 7,000's. Guess that was a fluke. I'm still wondering if IDW is planning to give that title the axe sometime next year.
I also wish the main series would go back to the 17,000-18,000 range like it used to be. 15,000 is too low for a comic that's gotten really good the last couple of months.
I am betting all the hype and trailers led to the spike. I just wish they main title would have brought on more new readers. Its been getting a lot of positive reviews and buzz.
AquaParade
09-10-2014, 09:02 PM
I am betting all the hype and trailers led to the spike. I just wish they main title would have brought on more new readers. Its been getting a lot of positive reviews and buzz.
Not to mention it's never been more captivating than now.
I had pretty much decided to stop following monthly, due to a lack of fulfillment with the storytelling. As of these last few months, the book has shot back to the top of my pile along with Saga, Daredevil, and Deadly Class ( Which features teenage assassin's in the coolest way since Mirage TMNT). This book deserves to be read right now.
snake
09-10-2014, 09:07 PM
Full August numbers:
144. TMNT #37 - 15,470
169. Turtles in Time #3 - 11,803
261. New Animated Adventures #14 - 6,420
Not bad numbers, is this also digital?
Redeemer
09-10-2014, 09:37 PM
Not bad numbers, is this also digital?
No that one thing we all keep forgetting these are not the digital numbers. I am betting the Nick adventures is selling better than we think, this new generation prefers e-books over the physical copies.
CyberCubed
09-10-2014, 10:26 PM
No that one thing we all keep forgetting these are not the digital numbers. I am betting the Nick adventures is selling better than we think, this new generation prefers e-books over the physical copies.
But their parents still have to buy them for their kids.
Redeemer
09-10-2014, 10:35 PM
But their parents still have to buy them for their kids.
???? what the hell are you talking about??? All I said is these numbers do not reflect digital sales of the book. These sales numbers are from physical copies.
Coola Yagami
09-10-2014, 10:49 PM
They should just kinda break free from the cartoon's limitations and pave their own way. I still follow the series, but my girlfriend got sick of it after issue 10 or so, especially since most of the plots seem to follow the 'omg dumbass mikey did something dumb, hilarity ensues' kinda thing. It would help if they did multi-parters. Something to actually make you want to buy the next issue.
Redrumh2o
09-11-2014, 05:43 AM
I bet the series is doing very well with floppies/digital/tpb/hardcover/limited/shop and con variants all added up. With at least 1 more movie ahead I doubt anything would be in Jeopardy until the movies are done.
ToTheNines
10-06-2014, 08:30 PM
Full September numbers:
181. Turtles in Time #4 - 11,526
245. New Animated Adventures #14 - 7,589
#38 just missed September.
snake
10-06-2014, 08:39 PM
Full September numbers:
181. Turtles in Time #4 - 11,526
245. New Animated Adventures #14 - 7,589
#38 just missed September.
Thats some good numbers for a miniseries.
Redeemer
10-06-2014, 09:19 PM
Thats some good numbers for a miniseries.
Better than what some of them have been. Hopefully #38 remains steady or even a boost
snake
10-06-2014, 09:21 PM
Better than what some of them have been. Hopefully #38 remains steady or even a boost
Yeah. 37 was a great jumping-on point for new readers.
Joey Kamikaze
10-06-2014, 10:08 PM
Between the arcade game and the third movie, Turtles In Time had great name recognition for new readers. Not to mention it's a fun concept. It's no surprise it did so well.
ToTheNines
11-13-2014, 04:57 PM
Full October numbers:
134. TMNT/Ghostbusters #1 - 21,223
174. TMNT #38 - 15,498
176. TMNT #39 - 15,235
???. New Animated Adventures #15 - not reported
MikeandRaph87
11-13-2014, 05:20 PM
Full October numbers:
134. TMNT/Ghostbusters #1 - 21,223
174. TMNT #38 - 15,498
176. TMNT #39 - 15,235
???. New Animated Adventures #15 - not reported
I like the TMNT/Ghostbusters numbers but I am concerned about the 15.3. I want it to have numbers like the crossover. Keep spreading positive reviews of the main series to boost its sales.
CyberCubed
11-13-2014, 05:48 PM
The reason the crossover sold more is because it isn't just TMNT fans buying it, there are Ghostbuster fans who bought it who never read a TMNT issue otherwise.
Joey Kamikaze
11-13-2014, 07:37 PM
Yeah, I wouldn't worry too much. (http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2014/2014-10.html)
TMNT/Ghostbusters was IDW's best-selling comic this month, and the TMNT ongoing issues were their #4 and #5 best-selling comics (behind My Little Pony at #2 and #3, of course, because little girls and bronies). TMNT is consistently one of IDW's top sellers. Don't worry if they're not pulling crazy X-Men numbers, it's still doing damn well.
ToTheNines
12-19-2014, 04:44 PM
Full November numbers:
132. TMNT/Ghostbusters #2 - 16,624
146. TMNT #40 - 14,734
258. New Animated Adventures #17 - 6,228
CyberCubed
12-19-2014, 06:07 PM
Only in the 14,000's for the main ongoing? I'm pretty sure that's the lowest the main series has ever been. Hopefully things pick up with the hype leading to the Shredder/Krang conclusion.
ToTheNines
12-19-2014, 07:23 PM
It was kind of a slow month for comics overall I guess. The ranking is still good (actually shot up a good bit), and TMNT still only ranks behind My Little Pony for idws top spot.
ToTheNines
01-21-2015, 06:12 PM
December numbers:
158. TMNT/Ghostbusters #3 - 15,264
160. TMNT #41 - 14,970
270. New Animated Adventures #18 - 6,084
CyberCubed
01-21-2015, 08:38 PM
Seems the main ongoing sold about 200 more issues than last month, although still not great. I miss the days when the series sold 16,000-17,000 regularly each month, although I guess that's over now.
I just hope the series doesn't continue to dip, I'd love to see the IDW comic reach issue 100 in the main ongoing if possible. It'll take us at least 5 more years for that though.
Redeemer
01-21-2015, 09:02 PM
Seems the main ongoing sold about 200 more issues than last month, although still not great. I miss the days when the series sold 16,000-17,000 regularly each month, although I guess that's over now.
I just hope the series doesn't continue to dip, I'd love to see the IDW comic reach issue 100 in the main ongoing if possible. It'll take us at least 5 more years for that though.
Yeah we all do.
Honestly its great to see it rise even a little which is shocking consider this was during the Christmas rush.
snake
01-21-2015, 11:45 PM
Christmas passed and I'm sure some people out there got TPBs, just wait for them to get caught up.
ToTheNines
03-03-2015, 09:00 PM
January numbers:
132. TMNT/Ghostbusters #4 - 16,420
148. TMNT #42 - 14,286
270. New Animated Adventures #19 - 5,227
CyberCubed
03-03-2015, 10:14 PM
Low numbers for the main ongoing, slipped almost 600 copies from the previous month. Its a shame that we seem to be dipping below 14,000 in sales soon.
I'll be really surprised if Nick Animated Adventures doesn't get canceled by the end of the year. Sales only in the 5,000's now...I honestly wonder if Nick is paying IDW to keep it afloat.
Mormegil
03-04-2015, 05:34 AM
Do they make the TP sales public? Can good sales in that area save a comic even if the monthly issues start to drop?
HeroTurtlesFan
03-05-2015, 06:43 AM
IDW have unofficially said before that 5000 is their "red line" - whether or not that's across the board or only certain titles.
CyberCubed
03-05-2015, 02:16 PM
IDW have unofficially said before that 5000 is their "red line" - whether or not that's across the board or only certain titles.
Which makes me believe Nick animated will end around December of this year. They'll probably give it some leeway as issues have likely been scripted and drawn for a few months ahead of time but I don't see it continuing past 2015.
neatoman
03-05-2015, 02:24 PM
Which makes me believe Nick animated will end around December of this year. They'll probably give it some leeway as issues have likely been scripted and drawn for a few months ahead of time but I don't see it continuing past 2015.
Do you think IDW will replace it with something else?
CyberCubed
03-05-2015, 08:10 PM
Do you think IDW will replace it with something else?
The Nick animated comic was aimed at kids watching the cartoon and a "gateway" to bring them into comics. Obviously the kids of today are not reading TMNT comics, and the 5,000 sales a month prove that. I'm willing to bet those 5,000 sales are coming from older fans like us who follow the IDW series and buy the Nick comic too.
If the Nick animated comic isn't reaching its intended target audience, (the kids 5-12 years old watching the cartoon), then there's no reason to keep it around.
ToTheNines
03-05-2015, 09:14 PM
We have this discussion almost monthly, but I'll say it again: For all we know it could sell like crazy digitally.
ToTheNines
03-21-2015, 11:16 PM
FEB numbers:
149. TMNT #43 - 14,551
189. Mutanimals #1 - 10,274
262. New Animated Adventures #20 - 6,049
Joey Kamikaze
03-21-2015, 11:21 PM
NAA jumped like 800? Dang.
It'll be interesting to see the numbers for #44. Of course we won't get those for another couple months, I'm guessing, but it sounds like it's selling out in places.
ToTheNines
03-21-2015, 11:25 PM
It's sold out in like 6 of my surrounding shops. Numbers won't be crazy though, since I doubt they printed a ton of them.
CyberCubed
03-21-2015, 11:32 PM
Mutanimals didn't do too well, makes me wonder if the upcoming April/Casey mini will sell any better.
spookycookies
03-22-2015, 08:50 AM
Mutanimals didn't do too well, makes me wonder if the upcoming April/Casey mini will sell any better.
I really don't think A&C will sell that great. Maybe as a trade it'll pick up some steam with the indie crowd?
On the other hand, my shop sold through #44 like hotcakes. I know it wasn't marketed as a stunt issue but it seems to have gotten the effects of one.
DrSpengler
03-22-2015, 08:57 AM
NAA jumped like 800? Dang.
That's what happens when you put Pizza Face on your cover.
You get RESULTS.
spookycookies
03-22-2015, 09:12 AM
That's what happens when you put Pizza Face on your cover.
You get RESULTS.
New Animated Adventures #21 Death of Pizza Face SOLD OUT $900 Buy Now eBay
CyberCubed
03-22-2015, 09:51 AM
I really don't think A&C will sell that great. Maybe as a trade it'll pick up some steam with the indie crowd?
.
Yeah. I'm pretty sure Mutanimals is the lowest selling debut for a mini though at only 10,000 sales. Most of the others debuted much higher especially for their first issue.
ToTheNines
03-22-2015, 10:24 AM
Worth mentioning that Mutanimals was asterisked and noted as such on the comicchron list
"Items marked with asterisks had their reported orders slightly reduced due to returnability."
Joey Kamikaze
03-26-2015, 02:58 PM
So yeah, based on reorder numbers, #44 is going to do pretty damn well (http://www.bleedingcool.com/2015/03/26/turtles-and-descender-top-this-weeks-advance-reorders/). #45 probably will as well.
Mutant Ninja Anole
03-26-2015, 03:07 PM
Worth mentioning that Mutanimals was asterisked and noted as such on the comicchron list
"Items marked with asterisks had their reported orders slightly reduced due to returnability."
Speaking as a total ignoramus of the comic industry, what does that mean?
ToTheNines
04-14-2015, 03:30 PM
March numbers:
146. TMNT #44 - 14,604
208. Mutanimals #2 - 8,980
274. New Animated Adventures #21 - 5,949
CyberCubed
04-14-2015, 03:32 PM
Seems like the Mutanimals mini is on track to be IDW's worst-selling TMNT comic. Even with digital sales its probably not too much higher. The almost 1000 reader drop to 8,900 from the already low 10,000 sales is rather bizarre.
You would think the casuals would like to read a comic with a whole bunch of cool TMNT mutants who were already established in the main series.
Jephael
04-14-2015, 03:35 PM
Seems like the Mutanimals mini is on track to be IDW's worst-selling TMNT comic. Even with digital sales its probably not too much higher. The almost 1000 reader drop to 8,900 from the already low 10,000 sales is rather bizarre.
You would think the casuals would like to read a comic with a whole bunch of cool TMNT mutants who were already established in the main series.
Nope, all they give a damn about is Don, Mike, Raph and Leo.
spookycookies
04-14-2015, 08:12 PM
Nope, all they give a damn about is Don, Mike, Raph and Leo.
The next Mutanimal adventure should guest star Mikey, his popularity could carry the book.
AquaParade
04-14-2015, 08:45 PM
as a reader of the main title and most of the micro series, I have absolutely no interest in a Mutanimals series.
CyberCubed
04-14-2015, 09:48 PM
as a reader of the main title and most of the micro series, I have absolutely no interest in a Mutanimals series.
Why not? Its part of the main continuity, Old Hob/Slash, etc. are all established likeable characters, and wouldn't you try to read everything in IDW continuity regardless?
I would never skip a mini-series. I even read that ridiculous X-files crossover just because it had the IDW TMNT in it.
Jephael
04-14-2015, 09:51 PM
I would never skip a mini-series. I even read that ridiculous X-files crossover just because it had the IDW TMNT in it.
I was actually considering picking up that story. Is it any good?
Mormegil
04-14-2015, 10:19 PM
The mutanimals is just like all the other micro series, a side story that adds to the main line. These first two issues have been really good. Best micro series stories since the villans imo.
The only thing I can think of is the name mutanimals is putting some people off. Which is a shame because no one should miss out on Slash kicking some ass, especially if you read the ongoing series.
I can't wait for mutagen man to lose it and start whooping up on people.
Mike Lowrey
04-14-2015, 10:28 PM
Did I miss the numbers for #43? Couldn't find them. Also, why are the numbers for #44 so low when it was such a popular issue?
PangolinFeets
04-14-2015, 10:46 PM
Did I miss the numbers for #43? Couldn't find them. Also, why are the numbers for #44 so low when it was such a popular issue?
I feel like that can't be accurate. It sold out everywhere. People drove hours to get them from other stores.
Joey Kamikaze
04-14-2015, 10:55 PM
I was actually considering picking up that story. Is it any good?
It's entertaining so far.
And to expound on what's been said, every miniseries is part of canon, so they might as well be issues of the main series if you care about staying on top of the story and character development. Even if the minis don't feature the turtles, they're often major sources of foreshadowing and explaining what's going on behind the scenes. You'd miss a lot reading just the main book.
Did I miss the numbers for #43? Couldn't find them. Also, why are the numbers for #44 so low when it was such a popular issue?
I'm guessing the post at the top of the last page with the February numbers should say #43 instead of #42.
Also, I'm guessing the numbers quoted for #44 are from the first print only, which sold out. There's since been a second (and third?) print that probably isn't included in last month's sales data.
AquaParade
04-14-2015, 11:20 PM
Why not? Its part of the main continuity, Old Hob/Slash, etc. are all established likeable characters, and wouldn't you try to read everything in IDW continuity regardless?
I would never skip a mini-series. I even read that ridiculous X-files crossover just because it had the IDW TMNT in it.
I suppose the concept just didn't grab me. I can appreciate the fact that with the right team, this could be a great book.
Redeemer
04-15-2015, 12:30 AM
The mutanimals is just like all the other micro series, a side story that adds to the main line. These first two issues have been really good. Best micro series stories since the villans imo.
The only thing I can think of is the name mutanimals is putting some people off. Which is a shame because no one should miss out on Slash kicking some ass, especially if you read the ongoing series.
I can't wait for mutagen man to lose it and start whooping up on people.
Really???? I thought Secret History of the Foot Clan was hands down the best Micro series of all of TMNT.
ToTheNines
04-15-2015, 05:49 AM
Did I miss the numbers for #43? Couldn't find them. Also, why are the numbers for #44 so low when it was such a popular issue?
Sorry, I screwed up my February post. It's been edited.
Mormegil
04-15-2015, 07:03 AM
Really???? I thought Secret History of the Foot Clan was hands down the best Micro series of all of TMNT.
Wel secret history came out before the two villans micro series, but Its been awhile since I've read Secret History of the foot. I remember liking it but I don't think I was blown away by it. Just from reading people opinions here at the forums I've found that I like the micro series issues more than some people here. I think they've all been just as good as the ongoing series.
I need to reread the whole series, but I've caught up reading the Mirage stuff for the first time.
ToTheNines
05-18-2015, 06:04 PM
April numbers:
147. TMNT #45 - 20,158
182. TMNT #44 - 15,895
Mutanimals missed April and animated adventures wasn't reported for some reason.
CyberCubed
05-18-2015, 07:11 PM
Seems like all the news outlets breaking the news that Donatello "died" really helped boost sales. Funny how whenever a comic kills off a major character there's always a sales spike, even though everyone knows the character won't stay dead permanently.
Redeemer
05-18-2015, 07:34 PM
Seems like all the news outlets breaking the news that Donatello "died" really helped boost sales. Funny how whenever a comic kills off a major character there's always a sales spike, even though everyone knows the character won't stay dead permanently.
Yeah I agree, but why would they buy #45???? just to gauge the story to see if it actually happened???
ToTheNines
05-19-2015, 10:08 AM
Between March and April, #44 sold an estimated 30,499 copies.
Redrumh2o
05-19-2015, 10:10 AM
Do those numbers include just first printings?
Mike Lowrey
05-19-2015, 12:33 PM
Between March and April, #44 sold an estimated 30,499 copies.
Does this number include the Canadian Comicon retailer exclusive which technically came out in May? If not, then we may see #44 increase even more.
Redeemer
05-19-2015, 01:33 PM
Do those numbers include just first printings?
No it includes 1st,2nd, and 3rd printings of physical copies only.
Does this number include the Canadian Comicon retailer exclusive which technically came out in May? If not, then we may see #44 increase even more.
Probably not, because theses numbers are only number of physical copies sold to LCS, does not include digital comic sales
ToTheNines
06-16-2015, 08:49 PM
Mayo numbers:
127. TMNT #46 - 18,187
194. Mutanimals #3 - 8,723
Strangely, no numbers were reported for tmnt/Ghostbusters directors cut, the second printing of #45 or NAA.
CyberCubed
06-16-2015, 09:47 PM
I wish we knew why Mutanimals is selling so poorly. It doesn't really make much sense since all those characters were well established in the main series.
Makes me wonder if the April/Casey mini will do any better, or if these mini's are on a decline in general.
PangolinFeets
06-16-2015, 10:52 PM
I wish we knew why Mutanimals is selling so poorly. It doesn't really make much sense since all those characters were well established in the main series.
Makes me wonder if the April/Casey mini will do any better, or if these mini's are on a decline in general.
I think the creative team on the Casey/April story will bring in some new readers. Mariko Tamaki has a pretty loyal fanbase.
Wentos
06-17-2015, 01:45 AM
I wish we knew why Mutanimals is selling so poorly. It doesn't really make much sense since all those characters were well established in the main series.
Name recognition is probably a factor. It's a lot easier to sell people on a miniseries called "Turtles in Time" than a book about bit players like the Mutanimals.
(To be perfectly honest I wouldn't be surprised if the art was a contributing factor, but everyone here seems to love Andy Kuhn's art so I might be in the minority there.)
Mormegil
06-17-2015, 06:12 AM
I don't get how someone can read the main series and not read the micros. You are missing out on some very key plot lines.
Not to mention how good they are. Maybe it's just because it's been awhile since I've read the other micros but Mutanimals might be my favorite yet.
ToTheNines
06-17-2015, 06:39 AM
I agree. Especially like City Fall, i could never imagine reading that without the villain micros.
PangolinFeets
06-17-2015, 10:16 AM
These number don't include digital or trades, which is how most of my friends acquire their comics now, especially spin-offs. I'd be interested in seeing how digital/trade numbers stack up against single issues for the TMNT micros.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-17-2015, 10:26 AM
Name recognition is probably a factor. It's a lot easier to sell people on a miniseries called "Turtles in Time" than a book about bit players like the Mutanimals.
(To be perfectly honest I wouldn't be surprised if the art was a contributing factor, but everyone here seems to love Andy Kuhn's art so I might be in the minority there.)
No, my wife read Mutanimals last night and was shocked at the rough quality of the art. She also pointed out that when Jillian gets punched by Lindsey, she looks EXACTLY like a Weeping Angel. :tlol:
CyberCubed
06-17-2015, 12:05 PM
Isn't Mutanimals brand recognition though?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-17-2015, 12:26 PM
Isn't Mutanimals brand recognition though?
No. Mutanimals is still an obscure brand. It's gaining a little more recognition thanks to IDW and the Nick cartoon, but other than that, Mutanimals was only limited to a lesser known branch of TMNT comics (themselves not as well known to the general populace).
But this must change. Lead us to fame and mutant freedom, Old Hob!!!
neatoman
06-17-2015, 03:28 PM
Isn't Mutanimals brand recognition though?
Hahahaha, what? Seriously? Why would the Mutanimals, a revival of a comic that was canceled in the 90's before it even reached ten issues, have any brand recognisability?
funatic
06-17-2015, 03:43 PM
Hahahaha, what? Seriously? Why would the Mutanimals, a revival of a comic that was canceled in the 90's before it even reached ten issues, have any brand recognisability?
An iteration of self-declared 'Mighty Mutanimals' have recently appeared in the Nick series, so there might be *a little* more recognition from that. But I think the major factor this mini didn't sell as well is plain and simple - no turtles. There's probably scores of pseudo-turtlefans out there who'll only buy a book if they see that iconic image of a bandana-clad mutant turtle on the cover.
ToTheNines
07-11-2015, 07:05 AM
June numbers:
155. TMNT Casey & April #1 - 12,301
202. Mutanimals #4 - 8,492
250. New Animated Adventures #24 - 6,101
253. New Animated Adventures #23 - 6,026
ToTheNines
08-11-2015, 10:01 PM
July sales:
121. TMNT #48 - 21,106
134. TMNT #47 - 19,393
209. TMNT Casey & April #2 - 9,714
Casey April had an asterisk with this note:
Items marked with asterisks had their reported orders slightly reduced due to returnability
And just a non professional observation... Green Lantern/Star Trek #1 sold 64,000 copies. So since TMNT sells better than Star Trek and Batman sells better than Green Lantern, I could see that crossover being a top 15, maybe even top 10 book when it comes out.
CyberCubed
08-11-2015, 10:10 PM
Yeah the Batman crossover is sure to sell well especially since DC is publishing it themselves and will likely market the hell out of it.
It looks like April/Casey isn't selling much better than Mutanimals though, I wonder if the secondary mini's just aren't selling well anymore. I know Bobby says they have another mini planned after the Batman crossover, but I'm going to assume we're going to see a lot less of them in the future if sales aren't good enough to support them anymore.
If not I guess the main ongoing won't have a companion book anymore come late 2016.
PangolinFeets
08-11-2015, 10:12 PM
July sales:
121. TMNT #48 - 21,106
134. TMNT #47 - 19,393
209. TMNT Casey & April #2 - 9,714
Casey April had an asterisk with this note
And just a non professional observation... Green Lantern/Star Trek sold 64,000 copies. So since TMNT sells better than Star Trek and Batman sells better than Green Lantern, I could see that crossover being a top 15, maybe even top 10 book when it comes out.
People were returning the comic? :(
Also, its nice to see TMNT going up by a significant amount with each issues. This is a great arc and its pulling people in!
I agree with the Batman crossover. Not only are Batman, TMNT, and general comic readers going to pick it up, but lots of non-readers are sure to grab to for the sheer hype.
Wentos
08-11-2015, 10:29 PM
It looks like April/Casey isn't selling much better than Mutanimals though, I wonder if the secondary mini's just aren't selling well anymore. I know Bobby says they have another mini planned after the Batman crossover, but I'm going to assume we're going to see a lot less of them in the future if sales aren't good enough to support them anymore.
If not I guess the main ongoing won't have a companion book anymore come late 2016.
TBH I've lost interest in them myself. The micros were cool when they gave us miniature origin stories and filled in story gaps during City Fall, but the miniseries that don't feature the turtles drag on a bit too long.
What I'd really love to see are miniseries that spotlight each individual turtle.
CyberCubed
08-11-2015, 11:30 PM
I loved the Mutanimals mini actually, and it was nice to see those characters get some more screentime. I don't think TMNT-less mini's are the reason they aren't selling, because there's still important story elements in them that affect the main story.
Redeemer
08-11-2015, 11:31 PM
TBH I've lost interest in them myself. The micros were cool when they gave us miniature origin stories and filled in story gaps during City Fall, but the miniseries that don't feature the turtles drag on a bit too long.
What I'd really love to see are miniseries that spotlight each individual turtle.
I agree the micros become irrelavent when the don't contribute to the on going. Even though the April and Casey Micro have not directly contributed to the story so far, i bet they it will at the end.
Also nice to see the on going with strong numbers!!!!!
Joey Kamikaze
08-12-2015, 05:40 AM
We're seeing the results of the whole "death of Donatello" hype. I wonder what the drop-off is going to be in the months ahead. Though of course I'd love to see the numbers keep increasing instead.
As far as the mini-series go... Casey & April hasn't been great, frankly. I wouldn't be buying it if it wasn't canon, and I'm just reading it in hopes of info on the Pantheon. The comic shop I go to isn't even snagging any copies of that mini-series except the one I requested in my box. Mutanimals was a lot of fun, but I don't expect those without a background in the Archie books to have cared as much. The Batman crossover will probably move plenty of units... which meh, I'm not looking forward to it because it feels like a bad fit to me and it sounds like the DC writers are in charge of it (and DC, blech), but whatever. I wouldn't be surprised to see the numbers go up again if they do another turtle-focused mini-series.
Mormegil
08-12-2015, 06:26 AM
I think people judged the mutanimals micro without even looking to see what it was about or trying the first issue. It was good because it added a lot of support information for the main series.
I've never read any of the archie stuff and don't know anything about it, other than what i've read around here, and it might be my favorite micro series yet. It helps that i really like Slash in this series.
CyberCubed
08-12-2015, 12:50 PM
All the micros have continuity that tie into the main series which makes skipping them rather ridiculous especially if you enjoy IDW's universe. You really miss out on a lot if you don't read them.
I imagine though a lot of casuals who aren't big TMNT fans don't care about micros though because its another comic on their pull list. So that might be the reason for their decline in sales.
Hopefully after the Batman crossover the next micro is a big 4-part event similar to "Secret History of the Foot Clan" which was the best mini hands down.
AquaParade
08-12-2015, 04:10 PM
All the micros have continuity that tie into the main series which makes skipping them rather ridiculous especially if you enjoy IDW's universe. You really miss out on a lot if you don't read them.
I imagine though a lot of casuals who aren't big TMNT fans don't care about micros though because its another comic on their pull list. So that might be the reason for their decline in sales.
Hopefully after the Batman crossover the next micro is a big 4-part event similar to "Secret History of the Foot Clan" which was the best mini hands down.
Wish I shared the love that everyone has of Secret History of the Foot, especially so I could pick up the gorgeous slipcase edition. Unfortunately I found the story dull and lacking in character development. The art is nice but that can't save it for me.
What attracts you to this story?
ToTheNines
08-12-2015, 05:18 PM
#1 is one of my favorite TMNT comics ever, but it ended up being kind of anti climactic, I thought.
I think they nailed everything in Japan, but the present day stuff came to an abrupt end. I thought it was pretty lame that Splinter just burned the book.
MikeandRaph87
08-12-2015, 05:27 PM
There have been a couple of IDW's TMNT releases I did not care for rhe Lovecraft creature 2 parter and I could not get interested in SHotFC . The bloody Fuedal Japan and reincarnation stuff was not for me. Aside from that only half a dozen issues would I grade a "C" to and as of issue 15? Its been atworse a base hit if not a homerun.
Redeemer
08-12-2015, 05:56 PM
#1 is one of my favorite TMNT comics ever, but it ended up being kind of anti climactic, I thought.
I think they nailed everything in Japan, but the present day stuff came to an abrupt end. I thought it was pretty lame that Splinter just burned the book.
I agree. The arc overal was great. Secret history of the foot clan is actually my favorite TMNT book/arc from this series. Definitely top 5 for me in all of TMNT comics.
CyberCubed
08-12-2015, 06:24 PM
The bloody Fuedal Japan and reincarnation stuff was not for me. .
The Feudal Japan backstory was the whole point and why it was good. The car chase on the highway with Shredder fighting Splinter again (and I believe that was only the second Shredder fight in the series after #11-13 at the time), was also a highlight.
MikeandRaph87
08-12-2015, 06:29 PM
The Feudal Japan backstory was the whole point and why it was good. The car chase on the highway with Shredder fighting Splinter again (and I believe that was only the second Shredder fight in the series after #11-13 at the time), was also a highlight.
http://cdn.meme.am/instances/400x/57290983.jpg
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-12-2015, 07:07 PM
http://cdn.meme.am/instances/400x/57290983.jpg
Given your POV, I can see why SHotFC isn't a favorite of yours.
But I definitely love it. Freaking love it.
I'd say my favorite arcs have been anything where mutants (Old Hob, Slash, or the Psychopathic Wrecking Duo of Bebop and Rocksteady) have prominently featured.
MikeandRaph87
08-12-2015, 07:24 PM
Given your POV, I can see why SHotFC isn't a favorite of yours.
But I definitely love it. Freaking love it.
I'd say my favorite arcs have been anything where mutants (Old Hob, Slash, or the Psychopathic Wrecking Duo of Bebop and Rocksteady) have prominently featured.
You are right I am not one for that kind of thing which makes me only care for the one fight sequence real time vs the Foot Clan and that is it. You got to give IDW credit. Something Andrew and I can both love that is a TMNT comic? Its a testament to IDW in how just how good it is!
15-16 Slash
17-19 Krang War
41-44 Attack On The Technodrome
I hope to put Batman/TMNT on the top of that list. If Dick Grayson or Riddler appear...:teek::D
It was a slow start as I am not a fan of the first five issue or #13-14. Not my thing, but everything else has excelled my expectations. Granted April & Casey is soso I like it because of The Rat King!
HeroTurtlesFan
08-13-2015, 05:47 AM
I loved the Mutanimals mini actually, and it was nice to see those characters get some more screentime. I don't think TMNT-less mini's are the reason they aren't selling, because there's still important story elements in them that affect the main story.
I disagree. The fact they don't feature the Turtles is absolutely the reason they're not doing as well.
Yes, they might feature story elements that play into the main book, but that's not going to be enough to entice casual collectors or fans to play.
You know, a book titled "CASEY AND APRIL" will never do as well as a mini-series called, I don't know, "Ninja Turtles: DARK EVIL FALLING" or something that sounds like a contained, exciting adventure people can test the water with.
Powder
08-13-2015, 06:34 AM
Maybe so, but it's not as if core fans are thrilled with the stuff, either. A non-turtle turtle book can be good, but this latest one is a miss.
spookycookies
08-13-2015, 11:41 AM
Maybe so, but it's not as if core fans are thrilled with the stuff, either. A non-turtle turtle book can be good, but this latest one is a miss.
There are plenty of non turtle concepts I would read and enjoy from IDW's run. Casey & April is not one of them.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-13-2015, 11:54 AM
There are plenty of non turtle concepts I would read and enjoy from IDW's run. Casey & April is not one of them.
The problem is Casey & April could have been done in a much more appealing fashion. But this slow-burn teen drama thing is just... ugh. We've gotten, what, 2 pages of Rat King talking to himself? One page an issue?
I get that IDW is trying to reach a different audience (Bobby has said this himself at least twice), and I get that comics read better in trade... but this mini-series is not at all going well to my mind.
Still buying the trade, though. :tlol:
CyberCubed
08-13-2015, 03:25 PM
I disagree. The fact they don't feature the Turtles is absolutely the reason they're not doing as well.
Yes, they might feature story elements that play into the main book, but that's not going to be enough to entice casual collectors or fans to play.
.
Then why did the micros of the heroes and villains sell well? They made micros for April, Casey, Fugitoid...and then 8 more micros about the villains. As far as I can remember none of those featured the Turtles in them beyond maybe a few panels.
spookycookies
08-13-2015, 08:14 PM
The problem is Casey & April could have been done in a much more appealing fashion. But this slow-burn teen drama thing is just... ugh. We've gotten, what, 2 pages of Rat King talking to himself? One page an issue?
I get that IDW is trying to reach a different audience (Bobby has said this himself at least twice), and I get that comics read better in trade... but this mini-series is not at all going well to my mind.
Still buying the trade, though. :tlol:
Totally agree with you on quality of the book despite whoever the audience is supposed to be. Even if they want to use that as an excuse for how the book is being handled I don't understand why they would want to alienate their installed base of readers like this book has been verging on.
Sadly I want a complete run of IDW TMNT singles so I buy them bag them, read once and then they are staying on the shelf.
ToTheNines
09-14-2015, 01:00 PM
August sales:
117. TMNT #49 - 19,627
176. Amazing Adventures #1 - 10,614
198. TMNT Casey & April #3 - 9,085
So sales dipped a tad, but the ongoing is IDW's best selling book after Star Trek/GL, and that's always good.
CyberCubed
09-14-2015, 02:54 PM
Wow the new #1 for the Nick comic really boosted sales. Went from barely hovering around 5,000 to up to 10,000. Makes me wonder if it'll continue to do well with this new continuing stories.
ToTheNines
09-14-2015, 03:03 PM
Wow the new #1 for the Nick comic really boosted sales. Went from barely hovering around 5,000 to up to 10,000. Makes me wonder if it'll continue to do well with this new continuing stories.
NAA did 14,000 for #1, then 10,000 for #2 and then 8,500 for #3 and pretty much just down from there. So we'll see.
I feel like the ongoing story line format should help keep readers on board though.
Joey Kamikaze
09-14-2015, 04:19 PM
August sales:
117. TMNT #49 - 19,627
176. Amazing Adventures #1 - 10,614
198. TMNT Casey & April #3 - 9,085
So sales dipped a tad, but the ongoing is IDW's best selling book after Star Trek/GL, and that's always good.
My Little Pony is about 5000 copies ahead of TMNT at #105 for the month. But yeah, TMNT's still consistently IDW's second best-selling ongoing series.
As to NAA... All the people who jump on #1s of series they have no intention of following kinda make me giggle, but hey, whatever floats their boats. We'll see how sales are in a couple months once the collectors drop off.
ToTheNines
09-14-2015, 04:31 PM
Nah bro, MLP came in at 127 this month. About 2,000 behind Turtles.
Joey Kamikaze
09-14-2015, 06:11 PM
Weird, yeah, now that I look at a different site.
...Is TMNT really out-selling Squirrel Girl? Goddamn.
ToTheNines
09-14-2015, 06:44 PM
It is weird that MLP would drop by 5,000 copies though. I wonder if that's an error.
AquaParade
09-14-2015, 08:51 PM
I wonder what goes through IDW's head when they see the sales boost the new #1 of the cartoon based comic.
Surprised to see them continuing on to issue #51 as opposed to restarting the main comic at #1. I have to give them props for this move if they indeed feel that it is appropriate for their story. It would be hard to blame them for starting fresh at this opportune moment.
spookycookies
09-14-2015, 09:06 PM
I wonder what goes through IDW's head when they see the sales boost the new #1 of the cartoon based comic.
Surprised to see them continuing on to issue #51 as opposed to restarting the main comic at #1. I have to give them props for this move if they indeed feel that it is appropriate for their story. It would be hard to blame them for starting fresh at this opportune moment.
I would blame them very easily if they decided to start over again after #50. How many different versions of TMNT have their been so far? Each time we have to go through the checklists of firsts and repeat the same stories over and over and so on and so forth it's difficult to reach a point in the series that isn't retelling the first encounter with so and so for the millionth time.
If they just split it into a new volume #1 but kept the story and universe intact I would be okay with it even though it's purely a marketing thing. But if they did a total reboot, I'd be so pissed. I love IDW TMNT and all I want is for this universe to continue.
CyberCubed
09-14-2015, 10:44 PM
I would blame them very easily if they decided to start over again after #50. How many different versions of TMNT have their been so far? Each time we have to go through the checklists of firsts and repeat the same stories over and over and so on and so forth it's difficult to reach a point in the series that isn't retelling the first encounter with so and so for the millionth time.
If they just split it into a new volume #1 but kept the story and universe intact I would be okay with it even though it's purely a marketing thing. But if they did a total reboot, I'd be so pissed. I love IDW TMNT and all I want is for this universe to continue.
You do realize that an IDW #1 wouldn't have been a reboot, but just a new #1 to boost sales right? IDW has no intention of ending their own continuity they spent 4 years building up, they were just debating going with either #51 or #1 for a possible sales boost.
Besides the Nick comic isn't really a reboot either as it continues from what comes before it even if it goes into its own thing now with new characters. The fact that Karai is still a snake in Nick Amazing Adventures #1 proves its continuing on from the previous Nick comic and cartoon...although its going in its unique direction going forward.
PangolinFeets
09-14-2015, 10:47 PM
Weird, yeah, now that I look at a different site.
...Is TMNT really out-selling Squirrel Girl? Goddamn.
A lot of readers didnt even give SG a chance, even though its absolutely hilarious. XD
Good to seen strong numbers though. Even April&Casey is doing better than I expected (which I'm haply for because I like it ).
Joey Kamikaze
09-14-2015, 11:14 PM
I don't do Marvel, but I thought Squirrel Girl was the new hotness in that universe. I hear about it all the time on the internet. Kinda expected it to be way at the top of the list, not down below the independent books.
(For the record, my pull-list at the moment is basically TMNT/tie-ins, Star Wars/Darth Vader/tie-ins, Saga, Sex Criminals and The Wicked + The Divine, so I could be off on whatever's happening with the capes-and-underwear-over-the-pants books.)
PangolinFeets
09-14-2015, 11:40 PM
I don't do Marvel, but I thought Squirrel Girl was the new hotness in that universe. I hear about it all the time on the internet. Kinda expected it to be way at the top of the list, not down below the independent books.
(For the record, my pull-list at the moment is basically TMNT/tie-ins, Star Wars/Darth Vader/tie-ins, Saga, Sex Criminals and The Wicked + The Divine, so I could be off on whatever's happening with the capes-and-underwear-over-the-pants books.)
The only Marvel I read is SG, A-Force, and new Infinity Gauntlet. My pull list looks like yours: Saga, WicDiv, Kanan, Sex Crims, Jem, Shutter, and Nailbiter.
I think that's why she's not that popular. Her comic definitely doesn't appeal to the typical Marvel crowd.
spookycookies
09-15-2015, 08:01 AM
It would be hard to blame them for starting fresh at this opportune moment.
You do realize that an IDW #1 wouldn't have been a reboot, but just a new #1 to boost sales right? IDW has no intention of ending their own continuity they spent 4 years building up, they were just debating going with either #51 or #1 for a possible sales boost.
Besides the Nick comic isn't really a reboot either as it continues from what comes before it even if it goes into its own thing now with new characters. The fact that Karai is still a snake in Nick Amazing Adventures #1 proves its continuing on from the previous Nick comic and cartoon...although its going in its unique direction going forward.
No I understand the difference, I just don't see a re-numbering as "starting fresh" so to say. Semantics.
CyberCubed
09-20-2015, 07:41 PM
#50 is most likely going to have a huge surge in sales if only because of all the alternate covers it has that will drive up people buying double or triple issues.
ToTheNines
10-13-2015, 05:51 AM
]September sales:
226. TMNT Casey & April #4 - 8,000
238. TMNT AA #2 - 7,353
CyberCubed
10-13-2015, 12:51 PM
Seems like Nick Amazing Adventures is settling back into similar sales numbers as the original Nick comic. Oh well, I guess kids of today just don't read comics much anymore.
Hopefully it gets at least 15 issues before they decide to pull the plug entirely. There probably won't be any comic based on the Nick cartoon after this, in the U.S. anyway since that UK Nick comic is still going.
ToTheNines
11-09-2015, 09:40 AM
October sales:
67. TMNT #50 - 33,552
95. TMNT #51 - 23,247
241. TMNT AA #3 - 6,646
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-09-2015, 10:04 AM
October sales:
67. TMNT #50 - 33,552
95. TMNT #51 - 23,247
241. TMNT AA #3 - 6,646
Kinda surprised a whole 10k dropped after Issue #51. :tcry:
Redeemer
11-09-2015, 12:46 PM
Kinda surprised a whole 10k dropped after Issue #51. :tcry:
That number is still solid and I am happy to see how well 50 did
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-09-2015, 12:52 PM
That number is still solid and I am happy to see how well 50 did
Yeah, it's solid but such a huge drop-off? :tconfuse:
Are there a lot of stupid people out there who still think the series ends at #50 or what?
Duke Nukem
11-09-2015, 01:19 PM
The numbers could be skewed by the amount of variant covers for #50 and people buying multiple copies.
Redeemer
11-09-2015, 02:04 PM
The numbers could be skewed by the amount of variant covers for #50 and people buying multiple copies.
Thats a good point. I am sure people do realize the series is still ongoing.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-09-2015, 02:06 PM
The numbers could be skewed by the amount of variant covers for #50 and people buying multiple copies.
Very good point... that would definitely explain it and relieve my fears.
Joey Kamikaze
11-09-2015, 02:12 PM
Yeah, that's the collector market for you. 23k is back around normal.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-09-2015, 02:20 PM
Yeah, that's the collector market for you. 23k is back around normal.
Collectors be like Ash Ketchum... gotta catch 'em all.
WTF is wrong with me, I just made a Pokemon joke. I'm so sorry.
Redeemer
11-09-2015, 03:22 PM
Collectors be like Ash Ketchum... gotta catch 'em all.
WTF is wrong with me, I just made a Pokemon joke. I'm so sorry.
This time you will get just a warning, but next time you will get banned :lol:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
11-09-2015, 03:34 PM
This time you will get just a warning, but next time you will get banned :lol:
Thank you for your lenience... I swear, it won't happen again! :teek:
CyberCubed
11-10-2015, 08:06 PM
Yeah, that's the collector market for you. 23k is back around normal.
23,000 is actually better than normal, its above average. The book usually sells around 17,000-19,000 most of the time. So it did indeed get quite a boost after #50 even without all the alternate covers driving up sales.
AquaParade
11-10-2015, 08:58 PM
Great to see the strong sales. It goes without saying that the IDW team deserves it.
mrmaczaps
11-10-2015, 09:11 PM
How much of those sales on #51 was for the blank variant that could be ordered?
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.