View Full Version : New CGI movie
Zog The Magnificent
07-19-2020, 03:29 PM
I don't think Jennika will ever get cured. In all my years, I have never, ever read or seen a story where a person gets turned into something, wants to turn back, and actually succeeds. They either find out it's impossible and accept it, decide that they've gotten used to it and turn down the cure, or change back briefly, only to be forced into a contrived situation where they have to change back to save everyone's life. Or they change back and then die immediately. One of these things will happen eventually, and it probably won't be the dying one. As for mutant town, that's probably here to stay too. They've already showed us several glimpses of a future populated with just as many mutants as humans, and this is probably the first big step linking the present with that future.
Though on the actual subject of this thread, If the new movie ended up being a better finale for the 2012 series, I would be totally fine with that. I hated the Mutant Apocalypse as an ending. I don't care what JK Rowling nonsense Nickelodeon pulls after the fact, Mutant Apocalypse was the intended ending. "Wanted" also doesn't work as an ending, even if it was a good three parter.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 03:32 PM
Just because something is different does not mean it's good. Again, I pointed out why this direction is not going to work out in the long run. On the topic of disease, if you had a type of medicine to treat some condition you have and you don't experience a lot of problem with it, but then it's discontinued and you're forced to use something causing more side-effects, are you going to go "This is good because it's a new experience for me, I was tired of my old medication!"?
Some people may not want to deal with taking medicine all the time to treat the disease if the mutation complete cures them of it.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 03:36 PM
Some people may not want to deal with taking medicine all the time to treat the disease if the mutation complete cures them of it.
Your ideas about mutating into an animal seem awfully defensive. Just one question, is this something you think a lot about or have fantasized over?
You seem incredibly onboard with the idea of humans becoming animals.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 03:39 PM
Your ideas about mutating into an animal seem awfully defensive. Just one question, is this something you think a lot about or have fantasized over?
You seem incredibly onboard with the idea of humans becoming animals.
I'm no furry or anything. But I often find human characters boring to look at. Beings that look animalistic and so on look way more interesting and cooler to me then your average looking human.
80gmrp
07-19-2020, 03:47 PM
I'm no furry or anything. But I often find human characters boring to look at. Beings that look animalistic and so on look way more interesting and cooler to me then your average looking human.
Hmm, I personally see both sides to this particular debate. I'm with TigerClaw in that non-human designs can be more interesting, but, by the same token, having too many characters will easily be exhausting, and partially for that reason, I doubt such a scenario will come to the movies in the immediate future.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 03:58 PM
I'm no furry or anything. But I often find human characters boring to look at. Beings that look animalistic and so on look way more interesting and cooler to me then your average looking human.
You like othe funny animal books? Carl Barks' "Duck Comics" featuring Donald, Huey, Duey, and Louie and Uncle Scrooge are INCREDIBLE comics. They're nearly 80 years old and they remain wonderfully engaging.
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51xYnjxYJDL._SX363_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg
I'll give you another recommendation... BLACKSAD!
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51Ick4X-ZGL._SX383_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg
neatoman
07-19-2020, 04:05 PM
Some people may not want to deal with taking medicine all the time to treat the disease if the mutation complete cures them of it.
You're missing the point. I wasn't talking about the in-universe subject, I was refering to your attitude that the status quo change was good for the comic, I just picked disease as an analogy because it was topical.
Let's rephrase this with another analogy:
Just because there is a new status quo for the comic, that does not mean it is inherently good. Let's say you have a barber you are fine with, does exactly what you want. One day he quits and there's a new guy who gives you a hideous haircut you have never had before. Just because it's different from what you're used to, it doesn't mean it's good. It's of course not impossible for a new barber to be better than your old one, but your new barber still sucks in comparison to your old.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 04:12 PM
You're missing the point. I wasn't talking about the in-universe subject, I was refering to your attitude that the status quo change was good for the comic, I just picked disease as an analogy because it was topical.
Let's rephrase this with another analogy:
Just because there is a new status quo for the comic, that does not mean it is inherently good. Let's say you have a barber you are fine with, does exactly what you want. One day he quits and there's a new guy who gives you a hideous haircut you have never had before. Just because it's different from what you're used to, it doesn't mean it's good. It's of course not impossible for a new barber to be better than your old one, but your new barber still sucks in comparison to your old.
Maybe its not good to you. But its good for me. Because i get to see more fantastical looking characters appear in this comic.
80gmrp
07-19-2020, 04:27 PM
I mean, both of you are right in a general sense. Neatoman is right that change isn’t always a good thing, but then again, TigerClaw is also right that what’s good, in most cases, is subjective.
My personal view about the issue at hand: while I do like the idea of more mutants in moderation, I don’t want to be overwhelmed by so many characters that it’s hard to follow any favorites I do have, which I do feel is one of IDW’s flaws. Again, though, my opinion is subjective, meaning, while some people do share that concern with me, others either don’t feel it as strongly or outright disagree.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-19-2020, 06:07 PM
Everyone here thinking Jennika will ever go back to being human isn't considering the base politics of the issue and public reception.
C'mon, guys. This is 2020. C'mon.
neatoman
07-19-2020, 06:21 PM
Maybe its not good to you. But its good for me. Because i get to see more fantastical looking characters appear in this comic.
I mean, both of you are right in a general sense. Neatoman is right that change isn?t always a good thing, but then again, TigerClaw is also right that what?s good, in most cases, is subjective.
My personal view about the issue at hand: while I do like the idea of more mutants in moderation, I don?t want to be overwhelmed by so many characters that it?s hard to follow any favorites I do have, which I do feel is one of IDW?s flaws. Again, though, my opinion is subjective, meaning, while some people do share that concern with me, others either don?t feel it as strongly or outright disagree.
The thing is that you can still argue about excecution and potential, even if there is a level of subjectivity involved.
Now my argument is that Mutant Town will become stale if it sticks around longer than it needs to, which I'd say is longer than it takes to give a simple introduction to the mutants they want around. The reason it would go stale is the fact that it is a quarantine zone, a setting of inherently little action and areas to explore. Given that there are settings established that offer far more potential than character introduction, this also means Mutant Town is drawing attention away from potential stories that are... Actual stories, not just hanging out at a bar or something.
Now TigerClaw's arguments are that he likes the fantastical nature of Mutant Town and that he likes looking at non-human characters. Now the problem with these arguments are:
We are talking about a comic featuring heaven, hell, realms of gods, alien worlds, time travel and various other fantastical settings in the first place. Mutant Town effectively just takes what we've seen before (humanoid animals, the least creative non-human characters we have) and gives them a new package. That package being a slum quarantine zone, a setting that is by definition a small rundown and blocked off area. It's by far one of the settings in the series with the least amount of potential. If you want more fantastical settings, don't argue in favor of the quarantine zone, argue for a Dimension X spin-off or a Renet Spin-Off, something that offers you more than broken buildings.
Even if you do in fact enjoy looking at characters who are not human beings, they still have to be good characters or you'll get sick of them. And again, they're stuck in a quarantine zone so there isn't much wiggle room for actual stories here. If all you really want to read a comic about mostly anthro characters that does not shoot it's own setting in the foot, read something like Usagi, there's plenty of comics in that genre.
As we have established, this series also features aliens, robots and gods. Now if your argument is that non-human characters are just more interesting to look at, why would we honestly need more humanoid animals when the actual possibilities are far less limited? If you can have a scalie thing from outer space with six arms, four robotic eyes, a furry tail, leathery wings and three mouths, are you really going to argue a humanoid pig is that interesting to look at?
Saying that something is subjective (even when it's true )is not a defense and an opinion you can't defend is one that you ought to think more strongly about.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 06:50 PM
I like when TMNT gets into the more scifi territories. I'm bored with the grounded stuff. Its no longer interesting any more. I seen way too much of that that I want to move on to the other parts of TMNT that are more fantastical.
I would like to see IDW do there take on the Future Shark Trilogy from the Archie Comics. Would love to see the Turtles teaming up with there future adult selves for some adventure set in the future.
80gmrp
07-19-2020, 06:54 PM
Saying that something is subjective (even when it's true )is not a defense and an opinion you can't defend is one that you ought to think more strongly about.
All opinions are subjective, and I never said I disagreed with your opinion: on the contrary, I do agree with your just-expressed three counterarguments to various degrees, as well as it needing to have a real story (that much I'm 100% behind you on).
I like when TMNT gets into the more scifi territories. I'm bored with the grounded stuff. Its no longer interesting any more. I seen way too much of that that I want to move on to the other parts of TMNT that are more fantastical.
This I agree with as well, but then, I always had a small thing for science fiction in general.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 07:18 PM
Can we get back on topic here?
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 07:21 PM
Can we get back on topic here?
I have a Q:
What would anybody say to this idea...
The CGI movie gets the Turtle Prime Turtles Forever treatment?
A completely B&W movie with Eastman and Laird designed city and buildings and TMNT and characters designed like the first dozen issues?
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 07:33 PM
I would like for this movie to borrow from FW and from IDW.
What if they borrow the origin from the IDW comics in which the Turtles were reincarnated? That's different enough of an origin in some ways that they were once humans from another life. Including Splinter. They still mutated from the Ooze the same way. But there mutation resulted in memories that manifest itself from a previous life.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 08:00 PM
I would like for this movie to borrow from FW and from IDW.
What if they borrow the origin from the IDW comics in which the Turtles were reincarnated? That's different enough of an origin in some ways that they were once humans from another life. Including Splinter. They still mutated from the Ooze the same way. But there mutation resulted in memories that manifest itself from a previous life.
I would adore that BUT then the narrative would have to heavily involve their former lives in Feudal Japan to justify it, no?
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 08:05 PM
I would adore that BUT then the narrative would have to heavily involve their former lives in Feudal Japan to justify it, no?
That can be done with a series of flashbacks.
LeotheLateBloomer
07-19-2020, 08:26 PM
I would like for this movie to borrow from FW and from IDW.
What if they borrow the origin from the IDW comics in which the Turtles were reincarnated? That's different enough of an origin in some ways that they were once humans from another life. Including Splinter. They still mutated from the Ooze the same way. But there mutation resulted in memories that manifest itself from a previous life.
Yeah...that's not going to happen
Andrew NDB
07-20-2020, 12:44 AM
I would like for this movie to borrow from FW and from IDW.
What if they borrow the origin from the IDW comics in which the Turtles were reincarnated? That's different enough of an origin in some ways that they were once humans from another life. Including Splinter. They still mutated from the Ooze the same way. But there mutation resulted in memories that manifest itself from a previous life.
FW has been "borrowed from" more than enough, enough for a lifetime. For ten lifetimes.
Yes, a movie can borrow IDW's reincarnation angle as long as they promise that is the only thing they take from it.
Leo656
07-20-2020, 01:11 AM
IDW has just never figured out how to make the TMNT shine in their own book while also balancing a giant number of characters. Admittedly it's a damn near impossible feat. To balance that kind of writing... to write a decent story like that... takes a masterful skill that no comic book writer has ever had.
Kieth f*cking Giffen says "Howdy", brah. :lol: How'd you miss that one?
C'mon, man... it wasn't MY favorite run of "Justice League", but seriously... tell me a TMNT book written by Giffen wouldn't work better than Extenze. :trazz: That'd be awesome.
But yeah, it's tough. A few guys could do it, though. That's the first one that came to mind.
I see Neatoman is being his usual self.
He's generally pretty f*ckin' neato. :lol:
Everyone here thinking Jennika will ever go back to being human isn't considering the base politics of the issue and public reception.
C'mon, guys. This is 2020. C'mon.
When you're right, you're right. Just like April's gonna be black in at least the next three movies/TV shows/misc. Same thing.
I'm no furry or anything. But I often find human characters boring to look at. Beings that look animalistic and so on look way more interesting and cooler to me then your average looking human.
See, here's my problem: I 100% don't believe you. I've paid attention to your posts on various topics for years and years and years. If you're NOT a furry then you do a great impression of one. And I'll lead in by saying, furries absolutely don't bother me at all. So don't think I'm insulting you, because I'm not. Not even a little. Just observing the evidence.
BUT, just like the message board "shippers" who ruin perfectly good TV shows and other entertainment by projecting what THEY want to see over what would actually be good for the story, furries have a habit of doing the same thing. "Oh, great, more things I can wank to! That's awesome, that's ALL I want and care about!" And those things are usually bad for the characters and story at large. Then perfectly good shows or comics or whatever else get "hijacked", because the shippers/furries make themselves so overwhelmingly vocal that the pen-holders have no choice but to cater to them, and everyone else just gets annoyed because they KNOW that what's being done is NOT what's best for the story or the characters at large.
I personally would have a LOT more respect for you as a poster and a person if you'd just say, "Okay, I'm a furry, I want more furry bait in everything, because it tickles me." That would at least be honest. I respect honesty even if I don't agree with the position a person takes, if they're sincere I can respect it. Instead, you repeatedly advocate for objectively bad ideas, and when people explain why they're terrible, you just keep bleating, "Well, it's what *I* want." We hear you. At some point it might be time to accept that Most TMNT Fans don't agree with you and stop trying to Square Peg/Round Hole everything.
If I'm wrong, then I'm wrong, and again, I mean no insult in my observation. Just saying, some of my best friends are furries and I thus can generally spot 'em. If you're not, then you do a fantastic impression. And I know why you might not want to advertise it, because people can be jerks. But what tickles you individually isn't what's best for the TMNT brand at large, and it would be nice if you at least accepted that even if you continued to be defensive about it.
If need be, I can recommend some books that would cater more directly to your personal tastes, although I'm not aware of any that are currently in-print. But they'd probably speak more to you than TMNT does, based on what you seem to like best. And we can let TMNT be TMNT without mucking it up with things that are only going to be bad for the brand over the long haul. The things you want to see are bad for TMNT, but they've been done elsewhere plenty of times. So if it's really about what you say it is, "I'd just rather look at animal-people than People-People", then there's ways to scratch that itch without sending a perfectly good brand down the toilet. Just saying.
The things you wanna see are bad for THIS brand, though, and saying "Well it's what *I* want!" over and over again doesn't make anyone want to agree with you. It just makes you look entitled. And that's no way to make friends.
FW has been "borrowed from" more than enough, enough for a lifetime. For ten lifetimes.
Yes, a movie can borrow IDW's reincarnation angle as long as they promise that is the only thing they take from it.
I agree with you on Point 1.
Point 2 would get them banned in China, and possibly Japan as well. Can't do it, G.
Although frankly, devoting 20+ minutes of a sub-120 minute movie to explaining the whole reincarnation deal would be a lousy idea, anyway. It's not like in comics where they've got "unlimited" pages to tell the story. That'd be asking the audience to swallow a lot all at once, and we still have a lot more movie to get through. I don't know, I don't think it would work.
As I've said elsewhere, every TMNT version has its own One Thing that should never be carried over. Nick has Every Single Thing About April, 4Kids has Utrom Shredder, IDW has reincarnation. These ideas work well in their OWN TMNT universe but aren't good enough to be justified anywhere else. They're just not really good ideas, they're merely ideas that make their own version of TMNT "unique". And as others have pointed out in this thread, "Different" or "Unique" do not equate with "Good". In a vacuum, these ideas are all pretty cheesy and terrible, to put it bluntly.
Wildcat
07-20-2020, 02:04 AM
Ive always loved Utrom Shredder. Always thought it was a clever way to incorporate Shredder/Krang without just making them partners again. Plus it made for a unique backstory and more sinister villain.
I think people would be ok with that in a movie. Well mostly. Im sure some would complain they just turned-Krang-into-Shredder and call it lazy or something.
Leo656
07-20-2020, 02:19 AM
It was literally only done for two reasons:
- "We need a 'Krang' or people will ask why there's no Krang, especially since we're going heavy on Utroms and they all look exactly like Krang, but Peter won't sign off on Krang. So let's do this and it'll be Just Different Enough to make him agree to it."
- "We'll show Leo cut Shredder's head off, so everyone will think we're edgy! And then we'll immediately walk it back and dilute the entire thing by pretty much giving the entire plot away in the next scene, when he calmly picks up his head and walks away. But for five seconds, everyone will think we're edgy! And that'll be cool!"
It's an "acceptable" idea within That Specific TMNT Universe. It makes sense within the world they built for THAT story. In any other TMNT story at all, it would be a terrible, horrible, borderline insulting idea.
Shredder's "just" some Japanese guy with an ax to grind, not an alien overlord who's thousands of years old. The biggest problem with that whole entire show - and I DO love that show, just not everything about it - is that WAY too often as it went on it became Generic Super-Hero Fiction that you just as well could have plopped the JLA or Avengers into. And that super-hero type stuff overwhelmed the entire latter part of the series. Even Yoshi and Saki's feud couldn't "just" be about pride and revenge, it had to be part of an intergalactic conspiracy with Aliens and Guardians and other dimensions and it's all just way too much.
KISS Theory. It's the first thing they teach you in writing class, and yet when they get writing jobs, so many people are all like "Well *I* know better."
Again, Utrom Shredder is fine for 2K3 but I don't ever want to see it again, and I think the vast majority of people feel the same. It didn't really go over too well with many people when it happened, either. I remember much crying and ballyhoo about it. But stuff like that definitely keeps 2K3 from being anything close to "definitive" in people's minds. And it really deserves more respect, and it probably would have it, if only the entire story of the show wasn't such an over-stuffed, over-cooked mess. It's a very good TMNT show but it needed a lot of trimming.
Wildcat
07-20-2020, 03:03 AM
Oh. Well I never read up on that decision. I do not remember peoples reaction to it here either.
I see what you mean about them going more and more grand with things. I personally like when shows or movie series do that. As long as they start out simple enough and build up to it.
Although I never cared much for Fast Forward or Back to the Sewers. I know thats the common agreement already but should have been a separate show.
Although depending on what they did with it it might have been a perfectly fine direction for 4kids to do as 1 season. I dont know. I should rewatch it.
newfan
07-20-2020, 03:17 AM
If they do use Shredder here I hope he is Saki and written to be compelling and a threat without needing to be some giant monster or alien robot. I thought Ch'rell was a good character to introduce in 2k3 and this was something different, but I would not like to see this become a norm for Shredder.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-20-2020, 12:37 PM
It's time for a TMNT movie to just be about the five mutants fighting small time crime. Whether it's a street gang, the mob or the foot. None of this 'save the world/city from generically written villain #12723438'.
Go back to the scale and tone of the original 1990 movie. Establish characters, have them interact. Have some jokes and then throw some proper martial arts fight scenes in without any gimmicks.
It's really not that hard Hollywood.
Leo656
07-20-2020, 12:49 PM
I'd like to buy you a drink! What's yer poison, stranger? :tgrin:
Say... d'you like Huey Lewis and the- NO! NO! Not THIS guy, dammit... not this guy.
Alright, I'm okay. :lol:
PizzaPower1985
07-20-2020, 01:07 PM
It's time for a TMNT movie to just be about the five mutants fighting small time crime. Whether it's a street gang, the mob or the foot. None of this 'save the world/city from generically written villain #12723438'.
Go back to the scale and tone of the original 1990 movie. Establish characters, have them interact. Have some jokes and then throw some proper martial arts fight scenes in without any gimmicks.
It's really not that hard Hollywood.
https://d207ibygpg2z1x.cloudfront.net/image/upload/v1570152145/articles_upload/content/k2lvulvqowvha8dolo6r.jpg
Andrew NDB
07-20-2020, 02:51 PM
It's time for a TMNT movie to just be about the five mutants fighting small time crime. Whether it's a street gang, the mob or the foot. None of this 'save the world/city from generically written villain #12723438'.
Go back to the scale and tone of the original 1990 movie. Establish characters, have them interact. Have some jokes and then throw some proper martial arts fight scenes in without any gimmicks.
It's really not that hard Hollywood.
I agree with you except on one point, the fighting of the "small time crime." They aren't supposed to be crimefighters or vigilantes, really.
Leo656
07-20-2020, 02:55 PM
And yet.......
Look, man, people aren't supposed to kick out of Superkicks or DDTs, either. But they do. Like, all the time. 30 years ago? Fired. Now? Five in one match, f*ck it.
...Not in my match, obviously, I'll smack ya for that sh*t. But the point is... sometimes having a case of the "Sposed'tas" just gives ya heartburn.
The world has moved on from such simple and pure ideas. We can catch up, or get left behind.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-20-2020, 03:11 PM
I agree with you except on one point, the fighting of the "small time crime." They aren't supposed to be crimefighters or vigilantes, really.
I get that, and nor should be they be, but don't they usually get roped into dealing with gangs and the foot? Even if they don't fight the crime directly, the turtles taking out gangs or the foot usually indirectly helps in some aspect.
Definitely agreed on the superhero and vigilante point though.
AquaParade
07-20-2020, 03:22 PM
I agree with you except on one point, the fighting of the "small time crime." They aren't supposed to be crimefighters or vigilantes, really.
Yes. Please never send the turtles "on patrol".
Leo656
07-20-2020, 03:26 PM
But "Turtles On Patrol" makes me think of "Citizens On Patrol", which was one of the better "Police Academy" movies.
That can't be all bad.
d_osborn
07-20-2020, 03:28 PM
But "Turtles On Patrol" makes me think of "Citizens On Patrol", which was one of the better "Police Academy" movies.
That can't be all bad.
Now THAT is a crossover I can get behind. :o
Leo656
07-20-2020, 03:33 PM
When they get to the part where Callahan jumps in the pool and you can see her nipples through her white T-shirt... which Turtle jumps in to "save" her first? :lol::lol::lol:
That is such a good movie.
ssjup81
07-20-2020, 10:18 PM
So, we are getting another Turtles film in the theaters. I couldn't get into the Michael Bay produced ones much at all, so I've never seen those. My superficial reason were the designs of the turtles since I really didn't like the idea of Teenage Mutant Ninja Skyscraper Shreks running around the city, but was kind of willing to give it a chance...but the story and the fact that the Foot was walking around with guns just didn't sit well with me. One thing I expect in a Turtles film is fighting...but mostly hand-to-hand combat and martial arts. There were other things that kept me from watching it too, but my main reason was the whole reimagining of the Foot, lack of marital arts, and weak plot, imo.
As for this upcoming CGI film, I might give it a chance. I still haven't looked into what it's supposed to be about or even if it's taking place in the same universe as the current show...I just know that we're getting a movie.
Personally, I wish we would get a legitimate modern-day live-action film in the same vein as the first film from 30 years ago. I still feel that the 1990 film holds up now for practical effects and I have a lot more appreciation for the actors in those suits, given the hard work that went into maneuvering them, doing those moves than something just computer generated and over the top that's not even fully physically there for the live-cast to interact with. I know the 1990 film had some flaws and using CGI to fix those flaws would be cool, but I prefer this style and still would like to see this.
One thing that seems to be going for this upcoming film, though, is that it's going to be fully CGI, like how the 2007 film was, not a hybrid like the Bay produced films. One or the other works for me on that level at least, and hopefully, they (enemies too) will be using actual martial arts this time around.
Andrew NDB
07-21-2020, 12:57 AM
I get that, and nor should be they be, but don't they usually get roped into dealing with gangs and the foot? Even if they don't fight the crime directly, the turtles taking out gangs or the foot usually indirectly helps in some aspect.
Yeah, they get roped in all the time... and obviously if they see someone innocent getting attacked, probably they would step in. But they're not actively going around seeking criminals to bust like Batman or anything.
Zog The Magnificent
07-21-2020, 03:34 AM
I don't understand the idea that the turtles are "supposed" to be one thing or another. The franchise is incredibly diverse and can support any number of stories in a number of genres, and has for some time. And honestly, even if the originals weren't, if every subsequest version is, than isn't that just what they are now? I mean, and though he is much older, we don't judge what Batman is supposed to be based on his ininitial stories or really based on the first 30 or 40 years of his entire career. Most of the current Batman template can be traced back to the 70s. I don't see why we don't extend that same line of thought to the turtles.
AquaParade
07-21-2020, 10:08 AM
I don't understand the idea that the turtles are "supposed" to be one thing or another. The franchise is incredibly diverse and can support any number of stories in a number of genres, and has for some time. And honestly, even if the originals weren't, if every subsequest version is, than isn't that just what they are now? I mean, and though he is much older, we don't judge what Batman is supposed to be based on his ininitial stories or really based on the first 30 or 40 years of his entire career. Most of the current Batman template can be traced back to the 70s. I don't see why we don't extend that same line of thought to the turtles.
I essentially agree, but even hardcore Batman fans wanted a return to the roots of the franchise during the days of “Batman 66”. I don’t necessarily think TMNT should be any which way, personally, I just have a strong opinion of what way is best, arguably even for the health of the franchise.
I?d take your point even a step further though. The other day I was comparing the “Coming out of our Shells” tour to Kevin Eastman’s “Bodycount” when it hit me that this is probably the most diverse franchise ever.
Leo656
07-21-2020, 10:18 AM
The other day I was comparing the "Coming out of our Shells" tour to Kevin Eastman's "Bodycount" when it hit me that this is probably the most diverse franchise ever.
And equally full of crap up to its ears from polar opposite directions. :lol::lol::lol:
AquaParade
07-21-2020, 02:42 PM
Yeah, neither are riveting experiences to a fully-matured brain, but it still speaks to the strengths and accomplishments of the franchise. It's fascinating to me.
TigerClaw
08-02-2020, 06:26 PM
There was an interview with Seth Rogen for a Podcast hosted by Marc Marron. and the animated TMNT Movie was briefly mentioned on it. You can listen to it at the 49 minute mark.
http://www.wtfpod.com/podcast/episode-1143-seth-rogen
Apparently the head of Nickelodeon used to produce Superbad with Seth Rogen. I guess that's why they went with him to produce the animated movie.
IndigoErth
08-02-2020, 06:56 PM
Always worries me a little when the choice of who to get on a project is just pulled from the names someone is already acquainted with.
I mean that's how those last films ended up with lousy writing because they just went with the guys they already had associated with the company, and got Megan Fox to be April because who wants to bother with casting and auditions.
Not that there aren't talented people (at least appropriately for this) in some circles, but...is that one such circle.
Leo656
08-02-2020, 08:08 PM
It's been often said that Hollywood is rather incestuous insofar as its business relationships. Although it's not unheard of in any other field of entertainment, either.
In the wrestling business, we call those "Buddy Bookings"; you bring someone in for a spot that maybe they haven't legit earned or belong in, but they're good buddies with The Boss so they get booked ahead of other guys in line who maybe deserve it more. I can't say much about it because I get most of my bookings this way! :lol: But it's something everybody grumbles under their breath about. Everybody does it, but everybody swears they never would if it were them holding the pencil... but then they all end up doing it anyway. :lol:
I mean, I get it. Can't say I'd never do it, I probably would. In pretty much any business, you're gonna call a guy you know for a job before some guy you've *heard* might be good but aren't personally involved with, whether it's acting or plowing your driveway. Maybe the other guy is better... but this guy's your buddy! How ya gonna leave your buddy hangin'? Makes things awkward.
Then there's the fact that with movies and TV shows, there's contracts involved, and thus producers are usually limited to only working with talent who are under contract to their own studio. Like, could Robert Downey, Jr. appear in a DC movie if he really were inclined? Sure, technically, but Disney would make WB jump through 87 hoops first to secure him, and in the end it would be more hassle than it would be worth, when they could hire someone "in-house" who cost 1/10th as much and probably do just as good a job. You do see actors cross-over between studios all the time but it's always a headache for everyone involved. So "Do we already have _____ under contract?" is always a concern as well when scouting talent. You'll often hear stories about "________ auditioned for ________ and didn't get it," and there's not a reason given; sometimes they're not the preferred pick, but other times, they're already another studio's "property" and the people hiring just don't wanna be bothered with the red tape.
So yeah, it's a whole big thing. It's the same whether it's people who work in front of the camera or behind it. And it might be annoying but it also makes a lot of sense. It's why guys like Zack Snyder generally have their own "team" of guys they work with on every project; writers, cinematographers, all the way down the list including certain actors who show up in most of his movies. It's just easier, they already know each others' styles and they're already buddies. Cuts down on tons of pre-production if you go into a project already knowing who's getting what gig.
AquaParade
08-02-2020, 10:59 PM
Yeah, kinda painful hearing him say it?s something he was handed as opposed to one of the many things he has pined after, but that?s par for the course. On the other side, he definitely seems rather familiar with the property from childhood and described himself as being ?annoyingly hands on? with the writing process for this movie, so it?s nice to hear that he is invested in the project. With a little research and good taste, he might be able to push this on a positive direction.
And this is no surprise but he distinctly mentioned this as a kids property he is working on after being asked about his R-rated animation projects. Expected, because even if this does have enough edge for older fans, they?ll still probably call it?s a kids property.... but slightly painful nonetheless.
Leo656
08-02-2020, 11:16 PM
It would be great if it ever reached a point where TMNT was universally considered an "All-Ages" property, which is proper.
Instead, it's a "Kids Property", which implies that anyone over age 7 who pays attention to it has some kind of disorder. Even if it's not spoken, it's implied right there in those two little words: "Kids' Property".
Never mind that it wasn't created for kids. Never mind that kids generally wouldn't have even been "allowed" to read the earliest issues of Mirage (or even cared about it, since it was black and white). Never mind that the BEST stuff in the franchise, up to and including the 1990 film, contains content that the Soccer Mommy Brigade would clutch their pearls over their little parasitic spawn laying eyes on.
Nah, forget all that. It's funny talking animals, and every character's a moron. "Kids Property". :roll:
I really, really, really, REALLY hate that. Not only is it not technically accurate, it inherently, subliminally implies that you're an idiot if you still look at it after you get your pubes. It's insulting to the audience. MORE adults give a sh*t about TMNT than kids do. By like, several million people. Kids do NOT care about this franchise anymore, they just like it for 5 minutes when their parents who grew up on it force-feed it to 'em, then they move on to whatever else.
It could've reasonably been considered a "kids' property" up to 1995 or so, but not after. Once the primary audience went to high school, that was the end of that. Kids barely watched 2K3, it was all people my age. Same for the rest of the shows since. Kids don't like TMNT anymore.
They haven't for a LONG time. TMNT is for the people who were kids in the 80s/early90s, NOT those who are kids NOW. They don't care! Stop marketing it for them!!!
If 80% of your audience is 25-40years old, HOW can you call it a "Kids' Property"? Do they not do any market research? Is it as simple as "Well look at how loony this is, it HAS to be for kids" and there's nothing else taken into consideration? I mean, if they're working off of the assumption that most TMNT fans are mentally children, I might agree, but even still... kinda mean, no?
Like, there's NO way you can call TMNT a "kids' property" without meaning it as an insult. It's absolutely an insult, and also, technically, a lie.
AquaParade
08-02-2020, 11:29 PM
Well said, man. Summed it up.
Leo656
08-02-2020, 11:55 PM
It would be a bit less annoying if there was any evidence whatsoever that TMNT makes a strong connection with kids anymore, but I've seen almost nothing to suggest that. And I know many people who've tried it on their own kids.
I think kids today don't have the capacity to form strong and lasting bonds with the things they like. Attention spans are too short, they're too quick to discard one thing to move on to The New Thing. They don't seem to have the same kind of nostalgia that our generation does/did. They were raised on technology, which likewise pushes a constant need for "Newer and Better". Old isn't "cool", it's just Old. TMNT? That's something Mom and Dad liked. Gross! No kid wants to be caught dead liking something their parents were into. There's nothing less cool than that.
I'm kind of curious to see what sort of things, if any, this current generation of kids will be nostalgic for in 20+ years, or even if those sentiments will even exist. Because quite frankly, Pop Culture Nostalgia is something 80s kids invented; before the 80s, the idea of living in the past, watching old movies and TV shows, playing with old toys, and romanticizing the past, was considered something of... well, mental illness, basically. When things were done, they were Done. Nobody really made a big fuss about bringing them back, or even going out of their way to remember or pay tribute to them. And when 80s kids in the late-90s started putting He-Man stickers on their notebooks or watching Thundercats reruns, for the first few years it was considered a campy sort of trend that would soon pass. But it didn't, and now "Nostalgia Culture" is a huge industry, perhaps the biggest in all of entertainment.
...But will it stay that way? I'm not sure. Given how quick the youth of today is to abandon things - as well as how much of today's content is merely recycled from older things to begin with - will there even BE a "Nostalgia Culture" in three decades or so? And if so, what will it look like? Will kids Then be romanticizing Paw Patrol the way our generation does TMNT? I kinda doubt it. I don't know, obviously, but... I kinda think something's changed. I kinda think maybe "We" were just some weird glitch in the Matrix. We cared way too much for way too long about things we were supposed to grow out of... and people both older and younger than us think we're crazy for being that way. If you've ever been chastised by someone in their 60s for still playing video games, AND by a teenager for playing a game that's more than 4 months old, both in the same DAY, then you know exactly what I'm talking about.
So yeah, I'unno. I don't know how it all fits or what it all means, or what it will mean 30 years from now. I DO know, though, that little kids don't care about Ninja Turtles. And that therefore, it's ridiculous to call it a "Kids' Property" and make that a hard rule. "Well, we want them to care, so we'll force 'em to care." Doesn't work! Kids don't care about the brand... maybe aim for the people who grew up with it already and also have all the money, who've shown that they DO care.
"You're not supposed to care. Frankly, we're embarrassed by you. We'd honestly prefer it if you 30-somethings gave up on this. You're not who we want."
At least that would be honest. Ignorant, shortsighted, mean-spirited... but I'd respect the honesty.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-03-2020, 12:31 AM
My kids don't connect with TMNT. They're not ADD or anything, not moving on to the next thing. They just like other things, even though I've shown them a lot of TMNT (and purchased a lot of TMNT merch).
$hit, man. I guess it was an 80's thing after all.
Leo656
08-03-2020, 12:39 AM
My niece liked the 2003 show for a minute, and she's a little nostalgic for it now. Hates the newer stuff. She was like 3 or 4 when 2K3 came out and saw it when she was like seven or eight. She liked it a lot very briefly but then moved onto something else. I never heard her talk about it again until my wife asked her about it last week.
My wife's cousin tried getting her 4-year old son into it with the Nick show, but again, it only took for like five minutes. Ask him about it now, he's like "Eh."
I could go on. I don't know what it is, but it seems like regardless of the "Why", TMNT doesn't actually connect with kids. It only did the ONE time. ONE time, it made a lasting impression on a bunch of kids who carried it with them forever. Since then it just doesn't stick. The only people who care NOW, are people who Always Cared.
So since it's pretty much proven fact that the alleged audience doesn't actually give a sh*t... why does it get labeled as a "Kids Property" so pervasively and insistently? It makes. No. SENSE.
MLP didn't plan for 75% of its audience being adults when they put out FiM, but once they realized it was mostly adults watching the show, they leaned way, way into it. They didn't discourage it, rather the complete opposite. It was supposed to be a "kids show", then it became an "All-Ages" show. Smart business! One would think other companies would take note.
JonesyKitty
08-03-2020, 01:20 AM
My son is seven and he likes it a bit. He enjoys select episodes of the 2012 Nick show and the Half Shell Heroes animated film (but I think that's strictly because of the dinosaurs). He refused to watch the Rise show after we rented a dvd from the library. He watched about 2 mins and was done.
Recently he pulled out his Nick Turtle figures and played with them for a day or two but that was only because I had moved my Neca figures out of the bedroom and into the Ikea cabinet in our living room. I popped in one of the Old Toon dvds and he went right back in his room. Only had an interest in it because I was making stuff for a display diorama and he wanted me to make some things for his Jurassic Park toys (the turtles and April were filling in for the missing JP workers).
I think his turtle phase lasted maybe a year and he was pretty little. We bought tons of nick stuff and it all basically got tossed to the side and went to goodwill or ebay. The only remaining stuff is the Wave 1 characters and my old Party Wagon. They are only pulled out to use as substitutes for missing characters from other toy lines or when I mess around with my displays.
I think the brand is kind of dead to kids. The only other kids I know were only briefly into the toys because they were hand-me-downs. Never something they got into themselves.
Wildcat
08-03-2020, 01:26 AM
Nostalgia effects everyone. Theres people who grew up in the 50s/60s and collect stuff from that era and so on. It happens to all generations.
Im positive adults thought the exact same thing about us 80s/90s kids...we did not appreciate anything and were spoiled by tv and video games. That was like the theme of certain things too. We were supposedly the wild generation that showed no respect - kids today do not know how good they have it.
Its funny, now we are suddenly the generation that knew the importance of movies, toys and honoring what came before?
The 80s/90s are extremely glorified and romanticized as the golden age of all things. You can literally see it on forums and YouTube and it will keep going with kids from the 2000s, 10s, 20s etc. This has been proven by every decade in modern times.
Ooh you kids and your newfangled Internet Pads...back in my day if you wanted to play a portable game you needed a hundred AA batteries and a lamp. What if I told you Nintendo did not always light the screen? :lol:
Leo656
08-03-2020, 01:37 AM
It's so weird, isn't it?
Our generation cared SO much, and still do, clearly. Some of us lost touch with it, or weave in and out of it, but it's safe to say most of us Right Here Right Now obviously never let go of it.
Is it generational? Something in the water? Is the essential concept a lot dumber than we ever thought it was or want to admit? Some combination of all that, or something else entirely?
It's just so weird. I mean, I have my own theories - I tend to lean into it being Our Generation just in general, because there's plenty of other things from that era like He-Man and Ghostbusters that also have passionate fans of a certain age but don't translate well or at all to anyone who wasn't there. I also don't want to write off any or all of those brands as just being too silly or one-dimensional to properly exist outside of their era of origin, although many have made that case, but I don't agree with it.
So all I can figure is, there's something about our collective generation that allowed us to form a much deeper and meaningful personal connection to the things we entertained ourselves with, in ways that generations before and after simply don't. I think it kinda started with Star Wars, but I'm not sure where it ended. But that whole generation of people who are 35-45 now just seems to care a lot more about pop culture stuff as more than just "entertainment".
It's weird.
newfan
08-03-2020, 02:32 AM
Not sure about other people's children but it's not the case for my son, he has totally loved TMNT for about 4 years now, he has other interests and he doesn't watch the eps as much as when he found it but they have remained the favourite with Leo being his number one character. One day I will be stuck with a lot of merch/figs to rehome unless this turns out to be a life long thing but I can say it wasn't a waste of money.
So, unless the new movie looks terrible to both of us I will be going to see it.
Wildcat
08-03-2020, 02:42 AM
Leo656,
No my point was that every generation DOES care about the stuff they grew up on. Not just us. Most of the things Im into originated in the 80s/90s but I can honestly say I never fell into the mindset that that was the golden age of entertainment like a lot of people do.
You would think I would but Ive always viewed it as...this stuff happen to come out and become popular while I was a kid so naturally I gravitated towards it and some things are just appealing no matter when. Its not because I think they came out during a special time period.
I know Im in the minority with that point of view. At least within my age range.
It may seem kids move from thing to thing and forget previous interests but thats because theyre kids and sometimes its not til youre a bit older that you start to revisit stuff. Then theres certain things you never really put aside even if it seems that way to others.
AquaParade
08-03-2020, 09:11 AM
TMNT is like the only modern comic book property that isn't going for teens and adults in a big way. It's pretty messed up.
That said, in the grand scheme of things, Nickelodeon really hasn't owned the franchise that long. These are big, lumbering projects, and I don't mind cutting them a bit of slack as they find their feet with this multi-million dollar franchise. It doesn't mean I'm eating what they are serving, but the "wait and see" approach remains on the table. It helps that they are at least serving delicious appetizers like "TLR", or experimental ones like "Batman vs TMNT".
I think now that Nick has had a few ups & downs, between the success of 2k12 and the crash and burn of the PD films, and apparently "Rise...", they now have a better grasp of what works and what doesn't. And going by that evidence, you have to imagine they will be inclined to take things in a more traditional route, as trying to re-invent the franchise has not been successful for them.
Now, I imagine their idea of traditional to be a mix of the comics and classic cartoon. Something between 2k12 and the 1990 film, possibly. It has to come down to more than just "Fred Wolf" in their minds, because the second PD film's DNA was essentially a mix of Michael bay and the classic toon - an ingredient that couldn't save them.
Welmanshire
08-03-2020, 05:30 PM
That said, in the grand scheme of things, Nickelodeon really hasn't owned the franchise that long. These are big, lumbering projects, and I don't mind cutting them a bit of slack as they find their feet with this multi-million dollar franchise. It doesn't mean I'm eating what they are serving, but the "wait and see" approach remains on the table. It helps that they are at least serving delicious appetizers like "TLR", or experimental ones like "Batman vs TMNT".
I think now that Nick has had a few ups & downs, between the success of 2k12 and the crash and burn of the PD films, and apparently "Rise...", they now have a better grasp of what works and what doesn't. And going by that evidence, you have to imagine they will be inclined to take things in a more traditional route, as trying to re-invent the franchise has not been successful for them.
Nickelodeon have had the turtles for 11 years now, which is over 1/4 of the franchises lifespan. I think if Nick were going to try the traditional route they would have done it by now. I could be wrong though.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-03-2020, 05:43 PM
Nickelodeon have had the turtles for 11 years now, which is over 1/4 of the franchises lifespan. I think if Nick were going to try the traditional route they would have done it by now. I could be wrong though.
This. They've had the franchise for a long damn time. Two failed films, some direct to DVD stuff, one successful show that kinda meandered and drifted after a few seasons, and then... whatever the fvck Rise is.
Not to mention the IDW comics, the Mirage reprints, the Last Ronin, and the Image conclusion.
IndigoErth
08-03-2020, 06:11 PM
Is it generational? Something in the water? Is the essential concept a lot dumber than we ever thought it was or want to admit? Some combination of all that, or something else entirely?
It's just so weird. I mean, I have my own theories - I tend to lean into it being Our Generation just in general, because there's plenty of other things from that era like He-Man and Ghostbusters that also have passionate fans of a certain age but don't translate well or at all to anyone who wasn't there. I also don't want to write off any or all of those brands as just being too silly or one-dimensional to properly exist outside of their era of origin, although many have made that case, but I don't agree with it.
Imo, a lot of it has to do with kids just having WAAAY more aimed at them now and vying for their attention than we did. I remember when Nick was our only dedicated kids channel, and back then that still wasn't even full time. And now kids have how many channels, kid friendly (or sections of) streaming serivces, apps, websites, games, etc?? (If kids have a harder time learning to focus, well no wonder!)
Sad to say, but to an extent the era of longtime, or even lifelong, passionate fandom may be sort of over, replaced with passing interests and fads before the next flashy thing comes along for ten min. With fewer options it was probably just easier for us to actually become more attached to the things we loved and feel invested in them, rather than it just being the most interesting thing at present to entertain us. At least properties like the TMNT have an older fanbase in place to secure it has a longtime thing to take an interest in and continue being worthy of attention and more media.
AquaParade
08-03-2020, 09:16 PM
Nickelodeon have had the turtles for 11 years now, which is over 1/4 of the franchises lifespan. I think if Nick were going to try the traditional route they would have done it by now. I could be wrong though.
I thought 2k12 was “traditional” compared to something like Rise or the PD films.
Obviously the Mirage comics are where the roots lie, but in terms of franchise recognition, I think they will revert back to something more traditional with this next film.
One could argue the BvS interpretation was along these lines as well.
AquaParade
08-03-2020, 09:19 PM
This. They've had the franchise for a long damn time. Two failed films, some direct to DVD stuff, one successful show that kinda meandered and drifted after a few seasons, and then... whatever the fvck Rise is.
Not to mention the IDW comics, the Mirage reprints, the Last Ronin, and the Image conclusion.
The Mirage reprints wouldn?t fall under the ?traditional? category?
Or maybe I lost track of your point.
NinjaPug
08-04-2020, 09:27 AM
Little bit of info from Rogen:
?As a lifelong fan of Ninja Turtles, weirdly the ?Teenage? part of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was always the part that stuck out to me the most. And as someone who loves teenage movies, and who?s made a lot of teenage movies, and who literally got their start in their entire profession by writing a teenage movie, the idea of kind of honing in on that element was really exciting to us. I mean, not disregarding the rest, but really using that as kind of a jumping off point for the film.?
https://collider.com/seth-rogen-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-movie-reboot-details/
AquaParade
08-04-2020, 10:02 AM
Thanks for posting that.
The teenage aspect is important, but I'm also glad he made a note to clarify that the other elements matter too. He wasn't prompted to say that, he made a point of it. Interesting to me.
The positive thing about this is Seth Rogen does know how to write *real* teenagers, the like of which we actually haven't really seen in TMNT. I'm not sure that they will actually go that route with Nick being in charge, but I think it could bring a sense of realism, and therefore heightened drama. Just make sure to give the Foot Clan a sense of dread.
Really, the biggest red flag for me right now is the director, unless Seth is planning to be as hands on in that aspect as he seems to be in the writing. Nothing against "Jeff Rowe" other than the fact that he is relatively unproven. Seems like he comes from a television show called "Gravity Falls". He could be perfect for the job, just don't expect me to have faith in him based on that, relative to who other studios are hiring to direct their comic book properties.
Andrew NDB
08-04-2020, 12:09 PM
The positive thing about this is Seth Rogen does know how to write *real* teenagers, the like of which we actually haven't really seen in TMNT.
Which, again, if we're talking about the TMNT, they really shouldn't be anything remotely like (normal human teenagers). So that's less of a "positive" thing and just a thing.
80gmrp
08-04-2020, 12:18 PM
Really, the biggest red flag for me right now is the director, unless Seth is planning to be as hands on in that aspect as he seems to be in the writing. Nothing against "Jeff Rowe" other than the fact that he is relatively unproven. Seems like he comes from a television show called "Gravity Falls". He could be perfect for the job, just don't expect me to have faith in him based on that, relative to who other studios are hiring to direct their comic book properties.
Well, in all fairness, speaking as someone who has seen a bit of Gravity Falls, it wasn’t 100% kiddy. While not as edgy as Invader Zim, it did have some similar themes thanks to the paranormal context of the main story, even going as far as openly referencing the Illuminati. That in mind, we could’ve ended up with a much more iffy director choice.
IndigoErth
08-04-2020, 12:29 PM
We've had some attempts to make them act like "real teenagers," and generally it's come down to stupid stereotypes. That at this point end up out of character in some cases.
I'm ready for my normal-acting "teen in name only" Turtles back. Hell, I've long been ready for try to other direction and drop the "teen" part from the title for a bit.
But Rogen supposedly meant the TMNT when he mentioned "kids animation" in that podcast or whatever it was. *sigh*
AquaParade
08-04-2020, 01:12 PM
Which, again, if we're talking about the TMNT, they really shouldn't be anything remotely like (normal human teenagers). So that's less of a "positive" thing and just a thing.
They shouldn't be exactly like human teenagers, sure, but at the same time, they've always had humanistic and teenage traits. Raphael being a hothead in his first micro-issue, all the goofing around that you see in the Mirage short stories, etc. Those were all aspects of being a teenager, in the way they showed either a lack of maturity or highlighted their playfulness.
And they are clearly learning something or other from humans or they wouldn't speak english and have a home decorated full of human-like comforts and entertainment.
It can be easy to get caught up in semantics, but I don't mind seeing them as teenagers if it means they occasionally show a lack of judgement, or naivety, lack of control, or an eagerness to experiment and engage with the outside world. Or maybe it allows them to just screw up and use poor judgement.
I don't think them acting as teenagers means they need to be caricatures or just plain stupid. Although there is a good chance we get that.
Well, in all fairness, speaking as someone who has seen a bit of Gravity Falls, it wasn’t 100% kiddy. While not as edgy as Invader Zim, it did have some similar themes thanks to the paranormal context of the main story, even going as far as openly referencing the Illuminati. That in mind, we could’ve ended up with a much more iffy director choice.
I've never seen it so it's cool to get your perspective.
Galactus
08-04-2020, 01:49 PM
Way to say all the wrong things, Seth. Off to a great start.
ssjup81
08-04-2020, 02:02 PM
We've had some attempts to make them act like "real teenagers," and generally it's come down to stupid stereotypes. That at this point end up out of character in some cases.
I'm ready for my normal-acting "teen in name only" Turtles back. Hell, I've long been ready for try to other direction and drop the "teen" part from the title for a bit.
But Rogen supposedly meant the TMNT when he mentioned "kids animation" in that podcast or whatever it was. *sigh*You know, I like how they were portrayed in the 2012 series. They were pretty teen like there in some ways. They came across as naive at times since they had been hiding out underground for so long and a bit awkward. So in that regard I feel they were portrayed okay there.
80gmrp
08-04-2020, 03:43 PM
You know, I like how they were portrayed in the 2012 series. They were pretty teen like there in some ways. They came across as naive at times since they had been hiding out underground for so long and a bit awkward. So in that regard I feel they were portrayed okay there.
You raise a good point. As much as I needed time for all the family bickering to grow on me, I can't say that isn't inacurrate to what I've both been and experienced when it comes to teenagers. Still, the fact that the Collider article mentions looking forward to lack of grit is worrisome for me, speaking as someone who prefers both that and deep stories...
IndigoErth
08-04-2020, 05:32 PM
I do agree that 2012 did pretty well in an attempt to go "younger," though not without it's own failings (esp on Mikey being a bit too juvenile and never maturing a little), but still a decent, enjoyable show and for the most part and didn't go too overboard on that... though it seems to have opened a Pandora's box for Nick wanting to continue further in that direction.
If this movies goes too on nose to make them into stereotyped caricatures, I fear it may mostly end up being 'Rise' with a new look.
If they just made them like the 2003 who could get to playing around sometimes (though still often in ways that an adult can still relate to), that would be fine. But I doubt that's likely.
Sharman
08-04-2020, 06:49 PM
Which, again, if we're talking about the TMNT, they really shouldn't be anything remotely like (normal human teenagers). So that's less of a "positive" thing and just a thing.
Indeed. Why do I feel uneasy about Rogen's comments?
Andrew NDB
08-04-2020, 07:55 PM
I do agree that 2012 did pretty well in an attempt to go "younger," though not without it's own failings (esp on Mikey being a bit too juvenile and never maturing a little), but still a decent, enjoyable show and for the most part and didn't go too overboard on that... though it seems to have opened a Pandora's box for Nick wanting to continue further in that direction.
It would be super impressive if Rogen did not go for "Dude Mikey." I kind of feel like he will because he'll feel like everyone will want him to... but whatever.
Indeed. Why do I feel uneasy about Rogen's comments?
Eh... it doesn't make me uneasy that he brings that up about doing and digging movies about teenagers. It makes me uneasy that that's the big thing that attracts him to this. Like, everything is to serve and revolve around that one element.
For me? Ideally, in terms of focus?
35% teenage
65% ninja
(the "mutant" and "turtle" are obviously a given)
By virtue of them not really ever being able to be "teenagers" as we think of them. In fact, their age is sort of irrelevant, whether it's in the title or not. Whether they're 15 or 30, I don't imagine they'd behave wholly differently if they're just stuck in a sewer training day after day to kill a guy one day. Maybe a little more angsty in their teenage years, if that's even a thing biologically in mutant turtles? But then Splinter would just slap them around and it'd be back to doing katas and sh** and that'd be the end of it.
Galactus
08-04-2020, 08:16 PM
I don't know why people seem eager to give the people making this movie the benefit of the doubt given the franchises history of going in the worst possible directions more often than not.
Right here the red flags could not be more obvious. It's a fully animated cgi movie, it's confirmed to be kids movie with an emphasis on them being teenagers. It already sounds like the complete antithesis of what fans want and yet there's still people reaching to find ways why this wont be bad.
Okay so it's cgi but maybe it wont be for kids - okay so they say it's for kids but maybe it wont be dumb - okay so the emphasis is on them being teenagers which sounds dumb but maybe it'll still be good.:roll:
The teenage part of TMNT is always been the least relevant part of the whole thing. It only exists because Laird thought that Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles sounded cooler than simply Ninja Turtles. At least they came up with a story and mythology to justify them being mutants but really the only thing teenage about them is...I dunno they skateboard in some of the cartoons sometimes?
If you want to have a scene showing Mikey skateboarding in the sewers that'd be okay, if Leo enters the main room of the lair and Don and Raph are playing a video game sure that'd be okay but making this the emphasis is dumb. Nobody wants this.
AquaParade
08-04-2020, 08:28 PM
Bottom line at this point is we don’t really know what he means by “teenage”.
Seth associates himself with teenage stories, but when you think of them, they all are practically defined by taking place in high school like settings that come with all their own story avenues that we simply won’t have access to while dealing with four turtles.
So I have to assume by “teenage” he means “coming of age”, or based around family, which was really par for the course with the 1990 film. What else could it mean, really?
Andrew NDB
08-04-2020, 08:37 PM
Good point. Probably that is what he means by it. A coming of age story. But that could mean many things in terms of story.
Jeeze... my first worry is that this almost guarantees a love story. Hopefully that's just going to be, like, Casey and April, because the alternatives with the Turtles will probably kill my interest dead in it's tracks.
AquaParade
08-04-2020, 10:01 PM
My mind didn?t go there but I sure hope not.
The ?love story? in City at War was pretty well done. Not implying it would be anything like that. Man, if a live action series could only adapt City at War...
Andrew NDB
08-04-2020, 10:02 PM
My mind didn't go there but I sure hope not.
Think, like... "Superbad" but with absolutely no love story. There's no way.
ssjup81
08-04-2020, 11:08 PM
I do agree that 2012 did pretty well in an attempt to go "younger," though not without it's own failings (esp on Mikey being a bit too juvenile and never maturing a little), but still a decent, enjoyable show and for the most part and didn't go too overboard on that... though it seems to have opened a Pandora's box for Nick wanting to continue further in that direction.To me, Mikey did improve and mature a bit. I mean, season 1 Mikey is not as bothersome as say season 2 - 5 Mikey. Season 1 Mikey would get distracted by a wad of gum and had no problem with the others thinking of him as stupid or being called stupid. Later Mikey hated it and being underestimated. The problem the series had in regards to him was consistency and plot convenience.
Wildcat
08-05-2020, 02:49 AM
Honing in on the teenage element is not really a red flag. It could be their immaturity/growing pains plays into the story and they must learn to focus to overcome the threat.
That is kind of cliche and probably will not be portrayed super seriously but it could still make a decent movie. It probably wont be the TMNT movie of our dreams but I think it will turn out fine.
I really do not see it being THAT over the top or silly. Even the Nick show was balanced. At the moment I picture it being a typical action/adventure cartoon with some kids humor thrown in.
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 05:14 AM
The comments in that article are very telling. Put 2 and 2 together, people. Seth Rogen+"teenage." It means that Seth Rogen and everyone he ever gets involved with can only do one thing.
You wanna make a Western... take inspiration from Western films and John Ford. You wanna make a TMNT film... Take inspiration from Hong Kong/Kung Fu movies... Simple! Throwing stars, espionage, intrigue, ninjas in black ninja suits... It's not that hard.
Except it is... because people in Hollywood dont understand NINJA Turtles. This is not going to be what Mirage/IDW fans want. It's going to be a weed comedy and yeah, there may be zero drug references, but it's still going to make the audience feel like they toked a bunch of herb after they watched the movie or perhaps wish they had done so before seeing it.
There is no way in hell a focus on martial arts-ninja aspects or a deep, philosophical, experimental, engaging story comes out of this. They also wont be smart enough to set it in a pre-gentrified New York. No arcade machines, no pay phones mixed with modern sensibilities, not even a single hint that in 20 years this will be regarded as a timeless classic.
At best, we either get a crappy looking giant cartoon with little or no plot like the 2007 film, or a comedy based around Rogen tropes.
Face it, the only people who ever have a chance at cracking Ninja Turtles are the people who focus on the NINJA aspects of this property. Too damn bad that Peter Laird has left the building.
TEENAGE = COMEDY! And there are still some fans that believe that because its on the big screen, it's gonna be worthy of what Kevin and Peter did.
Bottom line... Ciro Nieli was supposedly a "Mirage fan" and he turned TMNT into a kids cartoon. If a fan like Andrew had been in charge in 2012, would that show have been far better? Oh yeah! Definitely. You know how I know? Because he made a fan work that respected TMNT. And if Andrew had done 2012, we'd be holding it up to the golden light the way we do the 1990 film. Rogen however, doesnt know what he's doing. He's somebody that professes to be a huge comics fan... And yet, he's not going to respect source material... unless of course he defines that as the FW cartoon. Memo to all in Hollywood: TMNT is not a baby's toy.
ssjup81
08-05-2020, 05:45 AM
Bottom line... Ciro Nieli was supposedly a "Mirage fan" and he turned TMNT into a kids cartoon. Likewise, Rogen doesnt know what he's doing. He's somebody that professes to be a huge comics fan... And yet, he's not going to respect source material... unless of course he defines that as the FW cartoon. Memo to all in Hollywood: TMNT is not a baby's toy.What was so wrong with the 2012 series? I like the fact that it incorporated Japanese references and training...they even referenced kujikiri. Given that they were limited in what they could do given that it was a kid's network, I felt they did a halfway decent job with those limitations. Personally, I wouldn't want something completely like Mirage. I like having a mix of elements tossed in. I liked that the 2012 series had elements and throwbacks to different mediums of the franchise, including Mirage, Archie, 2003, 1987, TNM, the original live action films,etc. Were there things about the 2012 series I disliked? Sure, no movie or show is without sin, but the likes outweighed that. Seriously, out of the animated mediums, the Nick version is the only one to actually kill the real Shredder by beheading...it wasn't shown, naturally, but the fact that they did it is still surprising. Same with Splinter being impaled and tossed off a building. It was mild, but it was done. And then that whole resurrection thing of Shredder's spirit and Bradford and them going back to hell or wherever.
That still surprises me because this was on a Nick show.
Bottom line, as long as they're aiming the series at a younger audience, there will be restrictions. If this was the 80s before the PG-13 rating, maybe it would have more in it, but that's not the case. They sell toys...you have to have the medium cater to the ones who would be the most interested in the toys that go along with it. It just can't be helped. I'm sure there are more children interested in Ninja Turtle toys than adults, unless they're collectors. I know for me personally, I have no interest in the toys, nor do I collect them.
As for the 2014 movies, I can't help but wonder what audience that was being aimed at.
Andrew NDB
08-05-2020, 06:06 AM
I think I will just hit up Rogen.
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 07:28 AM
What was so wrong with the 2012 series? I like the fact that it incorporated Japanese references and training...they even referenced kujikiri. Given that they were limited in what they could do given that it was a kid's network, I felt they did a halfway decent job with those limitations. Personally, I wouldn't want something completely like Mirage. I like having a mix of elements tossed in. I liked that the 2012 series had elements and throwbacks to different mediums of the franchise, including Mirage, Archie, 2003, 1987, TNM, the original live action films,etc. Were there things about the 2012 series I disliked? Sure, no movie or show is without sin, but the likes outweighed that. Seriously, out of the animated mediums, the Nick version is the only one to actually kill the real Shredder by beheading...it wasn't shown, naturally, but the fact that they did it is still surprising. Same with Splinter being impaled and tossed off a building. It was mild, but it was done. And then that whole resurrection thing of Shredder's spirit and Bradford and them going back to hell or wherever.
That still surprises me because this was on a Nick show.
Bottom line, as long as they're aiming the series at a younger audience, there will be restrictions. If this was the 80s before the PG-13 rating, maybe it would have more in it, but that's not the case. They sell toys...you have to have the medium cater to the ones who would be the most interested in the toys that go along with it. It just can't be helped. I'm sure there are more children interested in Ninja Turtle toys than adults, unless they're collectors. I know for me personally, I have no interest in the toys, nor do I collect them.
As for the 2014 movies, I can't help but wonder what audience that was being aimed at.
Age and maturity level has everything to do with my argument. Let the brand age with its audience... I'm hitting 35 in less than 2 weeks. Most of us are in our 30's and 40's by now. There are even a few people on the Drome in their 50's and maybe there are even older fans too? How old are you? The majority of us are not kids... There's no problem AT ALL with pulling from any and every incarnation of TMNT. Bring in as much or as little of the kid's cartoons as is needed, BUT... it cannot be directed solely at children just because the property sells toys because TMNT's primary audience are not kids born in 2011 who are now TMNT fans. The primary audience was born in during the Carter and Reagan administrations... A LONG TIME AGO.
As far as the 2012 show is concerned... you missed the point of my argument... my argument was that a professed Mirage fan made that show and it turned out to be a child's cartoon. Was Ciro beholden to the corporation? Of course. Did he have to answer to what they wanted? YES! But he could have easily shifted the tone and spirit of that show into a more mature direction and still marketed it to 12 year olds because it was done 10 years before. Aesthetically, there's no denying that the 2012 show was made for very young children, despite arguments that they delivered dark, less-kid friendly elements on occasion.
WHY is TMNT fandom willing to accept this $h*t? Why does TMNT fandom bend over and salivate when a new cartoon or big splashy movie that's aimed at their kids become reality? Are WE so perpetually child-like that we're just going to keep giving our dollars to a brand that feeds us nothing but baby food?
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 07:31 AM
I think I will just hit up Rogen.
YOU specifically would be the person I would want to see consult with the movie people because your sensibilities and background with this franchise would help. Will you contacting him/them/they do any good? One can only hope!
Galactus
08-05-2020, 07:40 AM
Remember in '07 when Imagi released the last cgi animated TMNT film and while okay it wasn't exactly a huge commercial hit?
Remember in '16 when Out of the Shadows was marketed very heavily to children and that was a huge commercial flop that nearly killed the franchise?
Why on earth does anyone think adding these two unsuccessful things together will add up to a hit???
Unless you're Pixar or a company that can ape their formula childrens cgi movies are never that big and every time TMNT goes kiddie in it's movies the series starts to fail. History shows what works and what doesn't for this franchise and they keep going for fails. Kinda like how Rise of the TMNT combined almost all the ill conceived ideas to modernise the franchise (roided up turtles, magic weapons, kewl new central enemy etc) and put all into one show.
This isn't the first time we've had a new turtle product that is said to put the emphasis on them being teenagers. It usually means we see them characterised as more childlike. I have little faith this will be different.
80gmrp
08-05-2020, 07:52 AM
As far as the 2012 show is concerned... you missed the point of my argument... my argument was that a professed Mirage fan made that show and it turned out to be a child's cartoon. Was Ciro beholden to the corporation? Of course. Did he have to answer to what they wanted? YES! But he could have easily shifted the tone and spirit of that show into a more mature direction and still marketed it to 12 year olds because it was done 10 years before. Aesthetically, there's no denying that the 2012 show was made for very young children, despite arguments that they delivered dark, less-kid friendly elements on occasion.
Yeah, honestly, between the two camps of whether 2012 was crap or not, I’m more inclined to agree with ssjup81, and don’t understand why it’s so hip to hate Ciro here. It certainly is a more mature atmosphere to me than Rise, which I think would be a much better example of concerns about whether this movie will be what we want, partially because it’s current.
Not to say I’m optimistic about this movie, either. As long as it doesn’t go as far into kiddy territory as Rise did, I’ll be content for now, but knowing Rise and it being current, we’ll see if that happens.
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 07:52 AM
remember in '07 when imagi released the last cgi animated tmnt film and while okay it wasn't exactly a huge commercial hit?
Remember in '16 when out of the shadows was marketed very heavily to children and that was a huge commercial flop that nearly killed the franchise?
Why on earth does anyone think adding these two unsuccessful things together will add up to a hit???
Unless you're pixar or a company that can ape their formula childrens cgi movies are never that big and every time tmnt goes kiddie in it's movies the series starts to fail. History shows what works and what doesn't for this franchise and they keep going for fails. Kinda like how rise of the tmnt combined almost all the ill conceived ideas to modernise the franchise (roided up turtles, magic weapons, kewl new central enemy etc) and put all into one show.
This isn't the first time we've had a new turtle product that is said to put the emphasis on them being teenagers. It usually means we see them characterised as more childlike. I have little faith this will be different.
egg-zackly! ! ! !
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 07:55 AM
Yeah, honestly, between the two camps of whether 2012 was crap or not, I?m more inclined to agree with ssjup81, and don?t understand why it?s so hip to hate Ciro here. It certainly is a more mature atmosphere to me than Rise, which I think would be a much better example of concerns about whether this movie will be what we want, partially because it?s current.
Not to say I?m optimistic about this movie, either. As long as it?s doesn?t go as far into kiddy territory as Rise did, I?ll be content for now.
So, a children's show aimed at 8 year olds is more mature than a baby's show aimed at pre-school kids and that's somehow a positive? Okay! How old are you people? Am I old enough to be your father?
80gmrp
08-05-2020, 07:57 AM
...I see you missed my disclaimer about whether I’m optimistic about the movie...
Also, I’ll answer your question that you intended to be rhetorical: I’m 28. I get that this is a heavy subject, but can we please refrain from personal attacks, especially since I (and likely others) do agree with you on some points?
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 08:12 AM
...I see you missed my disclaimer about whether I?m optimistic about the movie...
Also, I?ll answer your question that you intended to be rhetorical: I?m 28. I get that this is a heavy subject, but can we please refrain from personal attacks, especially since I (and likely others) do agree with you on some points?
I ATTACKED NO ONE! I simply was curious to ages here and am just asking questions... IF that makes me a jerk for trying to get a read on where this fandom's heads are at, I apologize. I will say this... as a 32 year old man I watched the first 2 seasons of 2012... Seriously forced myself to sit through it... AND IT WAS PAINFUL. If some people liked that show and are well passed the age of 20 then my hope for both this fandom and this franchise is wearing thin.
80gmrp
08-05-2020, 08:26 AM
I will say this... as a 32 year old man I watched the first 2 seasons of 2012... Seriously forced myself to sit through it... AND IT WAS PAINFUL.
Okay. Good to know you hated it that much. Only two things I’ll add:
1. I never outright said I liked it: on the contrary, I don’t remember whether it was this thread or not, but I have said that I wasn’t fond of all the bickering in it, which seems to have made up a good chunk of what I did watch. I’ll add onto this and say that 2003 is my favorite era insofar as the cartoons, not 2012.
2. Once again, I feel like Rise is a better example of whether this movie will be too kiddy or not. It’s current, and the only other thing we have that is current is the IDW comics. If we use that as a gauge, then I fear that you may be right about the movie.
Sharman
08-05-2020, 09:41 AM
It would be super impressive if Rogen did not go for "Dude Mikey." I kind of feel like he will because he'll feel like everyone will want him to... but whatever.
Eh... it doesn't make me uneasy that he brings that up about doing and digging movies about teenagers. It makes me uneasy that that's the big thing that attracts him to this. Like, everything is to serve and revolve around that one element.
For me? Ideally, in terms of focus?
35% teenage
65% ninja
(the "mutant" and "turtle" are obviously a given)
I think that's exactly what I was thinking. The worst kind of kids comedy movies came to mind as soon as I saw the emphasis on 'teenager'.
Of course, In the end I hope that it's one of the better variations of TMNT.
AquaParade
08-05-2020, 10:10 AM
I don’t think anyone here is bending over backwards to defend this movie. If you are someone who is freaking out about tmnt fans accepting any old thing, you might want to read the thread more carefully. There is merely speculation going on. I haven’t seen one person claim this will be a great or even good movie. Chill.
As far as the 2012 show is concerned... you missed the point of my argument... my argument was that a professed Mirage fan made that show and it turned out to be a child's cartoon. Was Ciro beholden to the corporation? Of course. Did he have to answer to what they wanted? YES! But he could have easily shifted the tone and spirit of that show into a more mature direction and still marketed it to 12 year olds because it was done 10 years before.
Wait. What was done ten years before? 2K3?
2K3 was no bastion of mature storytelling for big kids. It’s literally Mirage for 10 year olds.
I think I will just hit up Rogen.
This I like.
newfan
08-05-2020, 10:41 AM
Wait. What was done ten years before? 2K3?
2K3 was no bastion of mature storytelling for big kids. It?s literally Mirage for 10 year olds.
.
This. Nick seems to be getting all the blame for the kids stigma lately, it also isn't shocking that the first thing a company like this do with the franchise is make a show for their network. Going forward however I get people having concerns about getting anything older now that it is owned by a kids network (technically viacom) I too would like to have something older also.
Back to movies though, so far as getting movies into the adult spotlight,(EDIT: or all ages anyway) I think you might have mentioned this before AquaParade?, cinematic movies have the opportunity to do this as there is a wider range of exposure, so when they fail it's more of a let down.
I don't know what will come here, I hope it isn't going to be the case that after 7 movies there is still only really ONE that most people like. I know the others get love, I am thinking of the larger collective thought I've picked up on here. I might be wrong.
PizzaPower1985
08-05-2020, 10:57 AM
This. Nick seems to be getting all the blame for the kids stigma lately, it also isn't shocking that the first thing a company like this do with the franchise is make a show for their network. Going forward however I get people having concerns about getting anything older now that it is owned by a kids network (technically viacom) I too would like to have something older also.
Back to movies though, so far as getting movies into the adult spotlight, I think you might have mentioned this before AquaParade?, cinematic movies have the opportunity to do this as there is a wider range of exposure, so when they fail it's more of a let down.
I don't know what will come here, I hope it isn't going to be the case that after 7 movies there is still only really ONE that most people like. I know the others get love, I am thinking of the larger collective thought I've picked up on here. I might be wrong.
^^^ You're not wrong. We older fans drone on endlessly about our love and adoration for the 1990 movie and tend to hold that as either the only good one or the standard for others to build on/learn from. I myself have a soft spot for its 2 sequels but I dont watch them often. I see that 1990 movie at least every 3 months.
The problem with a lot of us older fans though is, we've seen what TMNT is capable of... We know how great it can be... and then, when it inevitably gets geared towards 3 year olds or 10 year olds, we just have to ignore it and go back to our comics and other favorite bits. It's the fact of knowing TMNT's true potential and seeing it constantly miss the mark that gets a lot of us old fogeys down.
LeotheLateBloomer
08-05-2020, 11:28 PM
2K3 was no bastion of mature storytelling for big kids. It?s literally Mirage for 10 year olds.
Mature compared to the other cartoons in this property.
AquaParade
08-06-2020, 03:43 AM
Mature compared to the other cartoons in this property.
I wouldn't agree. It's not even more mature than the original cartoon. It's just more "serious". It still has to be neutered at every corner for a young audience. The banned Baxter episode maybe being an exception, I can't recall.
I'd say 2k12 is the most "mature", but I wouldn't argue that title for any of them, frankly.
And in the context of the convo, I still don't see the reasoning in holding 2k3 up as being much more mature than anything Nick is doing.
Technogeek29
08-06-2020, 05:40 AM
I have to agree with Aqua 2k3 had some dark themes but one thing it was known for rather infamously is neutered Mirage stories or leaning heavily into the Mysticism part of the franchise. favorite episodes are Notes from the Underground, April's Artifact , Bishop's Gambit and Milk Run
PizzaPower1985
08-06-2020, 07:15 AM
You guys have gotta be kidding here. Of course 2K3 was neutered compared to the actual Mirage storylines. That should frankly be obvious. That said, 2K3 is on a whole other level than 2012. The first season of 2012 is incredibly juvenile, the character designs look like they are made for pre-schoolers and they can't go 30 seconds without some bombastic, manic behavior, one-liners etc. 2012 has a lot more in common with the 87 show and, in my opinion, is made for an even younger audience... Of course that's the thing about interpretation... Everyone's is different.
The 2003 show has a lot of jokes too by way of Michelangelo (their funny by the way) but it has a far more (not sure if "mature" is the right word) serious approach overall.
As far as 2003 being a "bastion of maturity" when you compare it to FW, 2012, even the live action PD movies, the stories are better and the show feels like something an adult can watch. The others not so much... But that's my opinion and you know what they say about opinions.
Regardless, IF the Rogen fronted TMNT film is any good, well there ya' go, I'm wrong... But in that snippet of an article, he never once mentioned Mirage or IDW and he never talked about character depth or how deep the story is going to be. The only thing he mentioned was "Teenagers" and instantly I was thinking about the poor turtles being subjected to a Kevin Smith type script with sex jokes, drug references etc. Granted, Nick wouldnt let that happen, but we'll see. My money is on the opposite of Kevin and Peter's Turtles and we probably wont even be lucky enough to get Waltz turtles either.
Sumac
08-06-2020, 09:03 AM
Mike in 2k3 was one of the worst aspects of the show.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
08-06-2020, 10:19 AM
2k3 Mikey started vaguely annoying, pulling out an occasional joke that did land, but as the show went on he became very mean spirited, completely unfunny and unbearable.
And that was just his personality. His voice started to become grating as well, to the point where by the time Back to the Sewer began, he seemed to almost scream practically every line he had, didn't seem to care about anyone else and pretty much gave up on jokes and just annoyed people.
ssjup81
08-06-2020, 10:42 AM
Mikey in 2012 is also played being mentally deranged, but at least it's actually in a quirky, somewhat funny way, done my a more competent voice actor. I'm not interested in pairing the shows up against one another, but just for example, because I do feel that even the humor is probably more "mature" in 2012. Like both characters are brain dead, but I find the jokes to actually be clever in 2012. Probably more subjective than anything. Hm, a mature joke, eh...
Mikey: We're not that kind of sub... :P
Anywho, imo, season 1 Mikey in 2012 acted kind of dumb. In season 1, he didn't care if the others thought of him as stupid (Monkey Brains ep...Splinter was pointing out how Mikey was a good fighter because he fought naturally and instinctively...but didn't think and why Donatello had trouble because he would overthink). Later on, though, you found out that it did bother him and he hated being underestimated by the others...like in that ep with the giant wasps. He hated that the others never took him seriously. The episode with the Shellacne also showed that. The other three treating him like the baby...but that was something I found completely realistic when it comes to families. The youngest being babied or overlooked because the older siblings always did stuff for them by default. It's like my mom and her sisters. My mother grew up the oldest of the four sisters she grew up with. My grandmother babied the youngest of them. She always did. She never did this with my mother or her other daughters, only the youngest one even in adulthood...almost like she underestimated her. Seeing the three treat Mikey that way didn't really surprise me...
Oh yeah, Mikey was also more easily distracted early on, like a child with ADD...not so much ADHD...so mentally deranged doesn't really work here, I feel (I've worked with kids that have ADD and ADHD). He even got distracted by a wad of gum at one point (season 1). They changed that about Mikey as the show went on. He was still quirky, but was able to focus when necessary. Look at his weapons of choice. The nunchucks and the kusarigama. Both weapons, you need a lot of focus and concentration to master compared to the other weapons, imo. It's ironic how the one who has the most trouble with focus, was given the weapon that required the most to master it.
Maybe I'm over thinking it...just don't feel that Mikey's character later in the series acts the same way he did in the beginning. They all changed in some ways...felt Leo's progression was the most interesting, though.
AquaParade
08-06-2020, 12:05 PM
Edit: accidentally deleted
You guys have gotta be kidding here. Of course 2K3 was neutered compared to the actual Mirage storylines. That should frankly be obvious. That said, 2K3 is on a whole other level than 2012. The first season of 2012 is incredibly juvenile, the character designs look like they are made for pre-schoolers and they can't go 30 seconds without some bombastic, manic behavior, one-liners etc. 2012 has a lot more in common with the 87 show and, in my opinion, is made for an even younger audience... Of course that's the thing about interpretation... Everyone's is different.
The 2003 show has a lot of jokes too by way of Michelangelo (their funny by the way) but it has a far more (not sure if "mature" is the right word) serious approach overall.
As far as 2003 being a "bastion of maturity" when you compare it to FW, 2012, even the live action PD movies, the stories are better and the show feels like something an adult can watch. The others not so much... But that's my opinion and you know what they say about opinions.
Regardless, IF the Rogen fronted TMNT film is any good, well there ya' go, I'm wrong... But in that snippet of an article, he never once mentioned Mirage or IDW and he never talked about character depth or how deep the story is going to be. The only thing he mentioned was "Teenagers" and instantly I was thinking about the poor turtles being subjected to a Kevin Smith type script with sex jokes, drug references etc. Granted, Nick wouldnt let that happen, but we'll see. My money is on the opposite of Kevin and Peter's Turtles and we probably wont even be lucky enough to get Waltz turtles either.
Actually Mikey's jokes are one of the worst aspects of 2k3, if you ask me. I find his jokes to be more juvenile than probably anything found elsewhere in TMNT cartoons. He is just plain stupid.
Mikey in 2012 is also played being mentally deranged, but at least it's actually in a quirky, somewhat funny way, done my a more competent voice actor. I'm not interested in pairing the shows up against one another, but just for example, because I do feel that even the humor is probably more "mature" in 2012. Like both characters are brain dead, but I find the jokes to actually be clever in 2012. Probably more subjective than anything.
I respect your opinion, but I'm still not hearing what exactly makes the 2k3 show more mature than 2012 or FW. I appreciate that it adapts the Mirage stories, but there is no sense of danger, drama, or adult themes in those 2k3 adaptions that aren't present in 2012. They're all for kiddo's of the same age, imo. I do find that the 2012 show at least has some wit, charm, clever writing thrown in though.
Yeah, the Seth Rogen movie might be bad, but again, no one here really said otherwise. Your posts indicated you are eager to understand why tmnt fans are willing to swallow buckets of crap because it came in a "TMNT" container, and that sort of thing does happen, but I also feel like it's a trend to come into these threads now and scream that question into the clouds, when no one in the thread is even participating in that behavior. Everyone is just speculating as far as I can see.
I guess I've gotten a bit tired of the seemingly "contrarian" behavior here that isn't really all that contrarian anymore. It's def become a thing around here to hop into threads for upcoming tmnt projects and get all aggressive towards anyone who is not immediately lambasting the project, while implying that anyone who chooses to speculate, rather than condemn, is just willing to bend over and take any product handed to them. It's simply not the case.
LeotheLateBloomer
08-06-2020, 12:39 PM
I wouldn't agree. It's not even more mature than the original cartoon. It's just more "serious". It still has to be neutered at every corner for a young audience. The banned Baxter episode maybe being an exception, I can't recall.
I'd say 2k12 is the most "mature", but I wouldn't argue that title for any of them, frankly.
And in the context of the convo, I still don't see the reasoning in holding 2k3 up as being much more mature than anything Nick is doing.
Batman TAS was also a toned down version for kids. The episode "The Demon's Quest" was loosely based on the 70s issues "Daughter of the Demon" and "The Demon Lives Again." There were some differences but it was still a good episode, at least imo. I've come to understand that whenever a comic book story gets adapted into another media, there will be elements that will be toned down for younger audiences (unless it gets a direct-to-video release, Viacom please get on that!) but for me personally, it helps they are still able to get away with what they can, though sometimes not with the best results. For me, 2k3 was more so a show that used Mirage as a template as opposed to actually being exactly like Mirage. Which you could also say the same for the 1990 film which was Mirage-influenced but still contained elements from the FW tv series and 2k12 which takes influences (dare I say too many, imo) from Mirage, FW, 2k3, the 90s films, etc.
And for my preference, I rather have a product that's closer to a brand's source material (Mirage) regardless if they alter it or not than changing it's identity completely (FW, PD, Rise). Again this is just my opinion.
AquaParade
08-06-2020, 01:16 PM
Batman TAS was also a toned down version for kids. The episode "The Demon's Quest" was loosely based on the 70s issues "Daughter of the Demon" and "The Demon Lives Again." There were some differences but it was still a good episode, at least imo. I've come to understand that whenever a comic book story gets adapted into another media, there will be elements that will be toned down for younger audiences (unless it gets a direct-to-video release, Viacom please get on that!) but for me personally, it helps they are still able to get away with what they can, though sometimes not with the best results. For me, 2k3 was more so a show that used Mirage as a template as opposed to actually being exactly like Mirage. Which you could also say the same for the 1990 film which was Mirage-influenced but still contained elements from the FW tv series and 2k12 which takes influences (dare I say too many, imo) from Mirage, FW, 2k3, the 90s films, etc.
And for my preference, I rather have a product that's closer to a brand's source material (Mirage) regardless if they alter it or not than changing it's identity completely (FW, PD, Rise). Again this is just my opinion.
Yeah, but Batman: TAS was of much higher quality than TMNT 2k3. Everything is subjective, but my opinion on that is pretty drastic, which is why I highlight it.
LeotheLateBloomer
08-06-2020, 01:22 PM
Debatable but to each his own. Just thought I'd have a say in this.
PizzaPower1985
08-06-2020, 01:29 PM
Yeah, but Batman: TAS was of much higher quality than TMNT 2k3. Everything is subjective, but my opinion on that is pretty drastic, which is why I highlight it.
I'll agree there. Absolutely. 2K3 is not BTAS but if BTAS is the purest version of Batman outside of Detective and Batman comic books, then perhaps 2K3 is the purest version of TMNT outside of Mirage? IDK... but I did argue that in my latest blog so....
The problem 2K3 had was that, as an established brand, the TMNT had to go into a new cartoon with 87 tropes as well as Mirage tropes. And out popped 2K3... a great show minus the theme song.
LeotheLateBloomer
08-06-2020, 02:02 PM
Little bit of info from Rogen:
?As a lifelong fan of Ninja Turtles, weirdly the ?Teenage? part of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was always the part that stuck out to me the most. And as someone who loves teenage movies, and who?s made a lot of teenage movies, and who literally got their start in their entire profession by writing a teenage movie, the idea of kind of honing in on that element was really exciting to us. I mean, not disregarding the rest, but really using that as kind of a jumping off point for the film.?
https://collider.com/seth-rogen-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-movie-reboot-details/
I'm not sure I like the sound of this.
Technogeek29
08-06-2020, 10:30 PM
Can't say nick is Darker because it suffers from tone whiplash....A lot. And 2k3 is so serious it becomes melodramatic. Can't say that people dying makes it dark because that happens in both series. Wanna say Baxter rotting away is dark but that's not the only time that specific thing happens in that version.
Want to say Nick is Dark because it killed a Turtle but then SAINW exist. So the next argument I hear is more people died more often in Nick, But a recent rewatch made me realise the 2k3 Turtles let a lot of people die. Mikey pulls the pin of a grenade clipped to a Triceratons belt and makes a joke about it as he watches him explodes.
Nick has the Turtles watch a guy gets mutated and are unsympathetic about it and kinda make fun of him. Even continue to make fun of him no matter when he appears, and then just abandon him to die by the end of the series.
Long story short just pick one. And on the subject of Mikey? Both are annoying for different reasons and I hate them both. But at least I have some episodes I like that are 2k3 Mikey centric. Nick Mikey centric episodes can be summed up as follows "Turtles think Mikey is an idiot, Mikey proves he is a valuable member of the team." Rinse and repeat until all the way in Season 3.
newfan
08-07-2020, 06:33 AM
What a derail.
2012 is supposed to be mixed comedy and darker elements, when I was trying to fill the void after the show ended I found 2k3 filled the gap for me a little more, they all however feel like different toons to me, people like more than one depending on what they can enjoy about them. 2012 will always remain my favourite (unless another ever comes along and I like that more) but I liked 2k3 also.
So far as the Mikey part of the derail, as pointed out already the issues people have with the two versions are different things but I did find myself thinking 'man what a jerk' at times with 2k3, the voice used probably didn't help when it came to whining or showing but I didn't totally dislike him.
Hopefully soon we'll get more movie info and then good or bad we will back on topic :)
neatoman
08-07-2020, 08:11 AM
Trying to defend the Nicktoon as more mature in any sense is a bit awkward considering it's the show with the Ice Cream Kitty, Muckman, Pizza Face, Sparrow Wizard, April Derp, Mutant Zits, Bigfoot crushing on Don, Dream Beavers, Skateboard Sewer Race, Wyrm, Mikey's wacky mind world, Batman 1966 homage and probably more that would this paragraph unreadable if I kept adding to it.
There is so much of that show that isn't just stupid but clearly meant to be stupid that it's hard to take anything about it seriously. When Splinter dies it doesn't hit hard, it just feels out place. What's worse is that the story of that show is not good and feels the need to repeat many of the same beats. Splinter "died" a few times before he really did and when they really did kill him off it seemed kind of hollow.
If the Nicktoon tried to be mature, it either failed to or it was mere lipservice to maturity.
Leo656
08-07-2020, 02:58 PM
Trying to defend the Nicktoon as more mature in any sense is a bit awkward considering it's the show with the Ice Cream Kitty, Muckman, Pizza Face, Sparrow Wizard, April Derp, Mutant Zits, Bigfoot crushing on Don, Dream Beavers, Skateboard Sewer Race, Wyrm, Mikey's wacky mind world, Batman 1966 homage and probably more that would this paragraph unreadable if I kept adding to it.
There is so much of that show that isn't just stupid but clearly meant to be stupid that it's hard to take anything about it seriously. When Splinter dies it doesn't hit hard, it just feels out place. What's worse is that the story of that show is not good and feels the need to repeat many of the same beats. Splinter "died" a few times before he really did and when they really did kill him off it seemed kind of hollow.
If the Nicktoon tried to be mature, it either failed to or it was mere lipservice to maturity.
Yeah man.
If anyone asked me "What makes 2K3 so much more 'sophisticated' or whatever than the Nick show?", my knee-jerk response would be, "Did you even watch them?" Because it's one of those things that should just be patently obvious on its face without requiring a ton of explanation. But yeah, one of these shows has a mutant cat made out of ice cream, or something. That says it all.
Granted, I can only speak to what I've seen most often, that being the first three Seasons of 2K3 and the first Season of Nick. They both had their strengths and weaknesses, but "neutered" as it may have been 2K3 still aimed much higher and hit the mark much more often than it's Nicktoon counterpart. The latter show was hellbent on being "silly" right from the jump and that's partly why they lost me very early on.
Anyways, Rogen says what we all subliminally knew. Y'think we'll get more than 20 minutes into the movie before Mikey asks someone to pull his finger? :roll:
AquaParade
08-07-2020, 03:05 PM
The reason 2k3 comes off as so silly to me is because it thinks it's mature when it so clearly isn't. It's sort of painful to watch. Like someone trying to be something they're not. Whereas, the other cartoons are comfortable within their own skin.
As for which is more mature between the cartoons? Neither. That was my original argument anyway. They are all intended for younger audiences and there is nothing "mature" about them.
Leo656
08-07-2020, 03:50 PM
I dunno, man. When I watched Season 1 of 2K3 recently there were almost a dozen incidents before the Season was half over where I said out loud, "Man, this is kind of heavy for a kids show. I bet they got phone calls."
This is just a general observation, but I find that people who lean heavily towards Mirage, often discount the 2K3 show for being "Mirage-Lite", therefore it's "juvenile". I, personally, don't give much of a sh*t about Mirage (comic book equivalent of Saltine crackers, in my own humble opinion) and therefore am not comparing 2K3 directly to that, other than giving them points for bothering to lean into it so much in the early goings (something more shows should do when adapting something).
I just see so many comments from people about how "mature" or "juvenile" 2K3 Is or Is Not come back to Mirage in some kind of roundabout way, or even a direct way. But if you take it as JUST a "kids show"... the early Seasons, at least, were very "dark and violent" for a kids show. Like, they got away with stuff even Batman: TAS wasn't allowed to go near. To imply otherwise isn't being fair. They got away with quite a lot with 2K3.
I mean, if a person were inclined I'm sure they could sit down and make a checklist as to whether 2K3 or the Nick show had more "serious" or "dark" moments. But if we flip it around and focus just on which show is more silly... well, c'mon, Nick. Nick is obviously a much, much sillier show; therefore 2K3 is "more mature" by default without even having to try to be. But it did try to be, and early on at least they did a good job at it.
AquaParade
08-07-2020, 04:54 PM
Good points. But being silly doesn't necessarily mean being less mature.
neatoman
08-07-2020, 05:39 PM
The issue with the Nicktoon is that it essentially tries to create a reverse of levity in drama, create what is essentially a comedy with serious moments of drama, which does not work. If your show is primarily comedic, you expect a comedic outcome. You can have steaks but they can't be undermined by the general tone.
Imagine this:
A clown steps out of his tiny car. He slips on a banana peel onto a trampoline. The force of the trampoline launches him to the top of a building being demolishhed. He falls onto a wrecking ball and as it swings he jumps into a swimming pool where belly flops. When he gets out of the pool... He slips on anther banana peel... And this time he falls head first onto a brick wall and breaks his neck with a loud crunch. His family then holds a serious funeral for him with no comedic overtones.
That is what the Nicktoon is like to me. It doesn't work because the payoff is off-tone.
Leo656
08-07-2020, 06:10 PM
Good points. But being silly doesn't necessarily mean being less mature.
Really? Huh. I mean... maybe. I guess.
I mean "Ernest Goes To Camp" is certainly more "mature", or at least heartfelt, than stuff like "Ernest Scared Stupid", sure, but at that point it's kinda splitting hairs, no?
I kinda feel like "silly" and "mature" are antithetic. Perhaps it's from upbringing; as a youngster, if I was acting below my age or otherwise being a pest, people would say, "Stop being silly. That's not very mature." The implication being that you can't be both of those things at once. Which makes sense to me.
But I mean, maybe? I don't know, I'd have to see the math.
The issue with the Nicktoon is that it essentially tries to create a reverse of levity in drama, create what is essentially a comedy with serious moments of drama, which does not work. If your show is primarily comedic, you expect a comedic outcome. You can have steaks but they can't be undermined by the general tone.
Imagine this:
A clown steps out of his tiny car. He slips on a banana peel onto a trampoline. The force of the trampoline launches him to the top of a building being demolishhed. He falls onto a wrecking ball and as it swings he jumps into a swimming pool where belly flops. When he gets out of the pool... He slips on anther banana peel... And this time he falls head first onto a brick wall and breaks his neck with a loud crunch. His family then holds a serious funeral for him with no comedic overtones.
That is what the Nicktoon is like to me. It doesn't work because the payoff is off-tone.
You're a good egg.
AquaParade
08-07-2020, 06:54 PM
Well, just think of a goofy but responsible older uncle vs your brooding 13 year old cousin.
Is your cousin really more mature because he has his arms crossed in the corner while your uncle plays tag with the 5 year olds?
No, but he probably thinks he is.
Leo656
08-07-2020, 07:22 PM
Interesting analogy, but I feel like sincerity of authorial intent should count for something as well, and that's something I don't feel like enough people consider when it comes to these things.
2K3 and Nick were clearly approaching the material from different directions. With 2K3, one strongly gets the sense that if they could have gotten away with it, then the show would have been entirely "played straight" with a minimum of gags or comedic elements or "toy-etic" bits. So, SO much of the first Season, especially, plays like a blatant "F*ck You" to everything that the FW cartoon was, and that may be off-putting for some but I felt that it was exactly what was necessary at that time. And you can tell that they were clearly pushing boundaries insofar as what they could "get away with" within the confines of what was ostensibly children's programming, to the point where when they did inject something "silly", it felt forced, like a begrudging concession to expectations rather than something they actually wanted to do. The comedic or toy-potential bits felt like they were executed through gritted teeth; "Well, we ARE a kids show, after all..." But it obviously wasn't what they wanted to be the focus. At least the early Seasons.
Conversely, the Nick show, as neatoman pointed out, generally operated on the assumption that if you spent ten minutes on someone getting hit by pies, but then suddenly cut someone's head off, then things somehow tonally balance out. Their attempts at being more serious came off as insincere and even pandering. "Well, we WANT to just be a straight comedy, but we know there's a few older TMNT fans who'll whine if we don't put SOME more serious content in there."
It really felt like the execution and intent from the two shows came from entire polar opposite perspectives. Like 2K3 would have been serious all the time if they were allowed, and Nick would have been a straight comedy if they were allowed. Consequently, the humor in 2K3 felt forced, and the "serious" bits in the Nick show felt forced. Because in either case those elements weren't in there by design, rather by the knowledge that to some degree one must cater to what's expected.
The "mature" bits of 2K3 felt sincere to me. The ones in the Nick show did not. They felt very, very forced and even out of place at times. So I don't feel like 2K3 is the "pouty teen" in the analogy; if anything, the Nick show was occasionally that. It occasionally put on a front that was anything but true to its real values.
Seeing how the films turned out, as well as "Rise", it is very obvious to me that Nick Corporate simply wants this franchise to be 100% Comedy, and that they only lean into anything more "mature" because they have to occasionally pretend to care about the older fans. But it's not what they WANT to do.
The Great Saiyaman
08-07-2020, 08:49 PM
Interesting analogy, but I feel like sincerity of authorial intent should count for something as well, and that's something I don't feel like enough people consider when it comes to these things.
2K3 and Nick were clearly approaching the material from different directions. With 2K3, one strongly gets the sense that if they could have gotten away with it, then the show would have been entirely "played straight" with a minimum of gags or comedic elements or "toy-etic" bits. So, SO much of the first Season, especially, plays like a blatant "F*ck You" to everything that the FW cartoon was, and that may be off-putting for some but I felt that it was exactly what was necessary at that time. And you can tell that they were clearly pushing boundaries insofar as what they could "get away with" within the confines of what was ostensibly children's programming, to the point where when they did inject something "silly", it felt forced, like a begrudging concession to expectations rather than something they actually wanted to do. The comedic or toy-potential bits felt like they were executed through gritted teeth; "Well, we ARE a kids show, after all..." But it obviously wasn't what they wanted to be the focus. At least the early Seasons.
Conversely, the Nick show, as neatoman pointed out, generally operated on the assumption that if you spent ten minutes on someone getting hit by pies, but then suddenly cut someone's head off, then things somehow tonally balance out. Their attempts at being more serious came off as insincere and even pandering. "Well, we WANT to just be a straight comedy, but we know there's a few older TMNT fans who'll whine if we don't put SOME more serious content in there."
It really felt like the execution and intent from the two shows came from entire polar opposite perspectives. Like 2K3 would have been serious all the time if they were allowed, and Nick would have been a straight comedy if they were allowed. Consequently, the humor in 2K3 felt forced, and the "serious" bits in the Nick show felt forced. Because in either case those elements weren't in there by design, rather by the knowledge that to some degree one must cater to what's expected.
The "mature" bits of 2K3 felt sincere to me. The ones in the Nick show did not. They felt very, very forced and even out of place at times. So I don't feel like 2K3 is the "pouty teen" in the analogy; if anything, the Nick show was occasionally that. It occasionally put on a front that was anything but true to its real values.
Seeing how the films turned out, as well as "Rise", it is very obvious to me that Nick Corporate simply wants this franchise to be 100% Comedy, and that they only lean into anything more "mature" because they have to occasionally pretend to care about the older fans. But it's not what they WANT to do.
I don't know, episodes such as "Vengeance is mine", "Invasion" and "Return to New York city" DO have comedic moments but certainly don't paint the 2012 series as being just a humor for the sake of humor series as you guys describe it.
Heck, take a look at the season two opener "The Mutation situation" there was very little to laugh about in that episode.
neatoman
08-07-2020, 09:07 PM
I don't know, episodes such as "Vengeance is mine", "Invasion" and "Return to New York city" DO have comedic moments but certainly don't paint the 2012 series as being just a humor for the sake of humor series as you guys describe it.
Heck, take a look at the season two opener "The Mutation situation" there was very little to laugh about in that episode.
I don't think you understand the argument.
The Great Saiyaman
08-07-2020, 09:21 PM
I don't think you understand the argument.
You're probably right, It's four in the morning here and I can't sleep with the heatwave going on.
I'll just slip back into the sewers...
AquaParade
08-09-2020, 06:26 PM
Okay, this is somewhat interesting:
Rogen and Goldberg are rebooting 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' and making a movie with the director of 'Call Me by Your Name'
Rogen and Goldberg are hard at work reviving the "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" franchise with a coming animated movie for Nickelodeon. It is set to be directed by Jeff Rowe ("Connected") and written by the "Neighbors" franchise scribe Brendan O'Brien. It marks the first time Point Grey has a legacy IP to play around with, and it's all the more special for Rogen and Goldberg, as they are big fans of the heroes in a half shell.
"When I look at 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles,' the teenage part was weirdly what stuck out to me the most," Rogen said. "I think one thing we've been pretty consistently good at over the years is creating material about teenagers, from 'Blockers,' 'Good Boys,' and 'Superbad.' That was really what became exciting for us is how do we make a great action-adventure movie that's also a great teenage movie."
Goldberg said the duo's personal interest became evident to everyone on the "Turtles" project in a recent call when he and Rogen found out some story notes were given to O'Brien that they didn't know about.
"We freaked out more than normal," Goldberg said. "They were just shocked by that, but we were like, 'Guys, we just really care about this.'"
https://www.insider.com/seth-rogen-evan-goldberg-an-american-pickle-point-grey-movies-2020-8
To me, it sounds something like Spider-Man Homecoming.
Leo656
08-09-2020, 06:57 PM
Being compared to "Superbad" and "Homecoming" is just more nickels in the "Nope" jar from me. :lol:
This is totally gonna be one of those movies where if you generally like the way the guy handling it makes movies, you'll like it, and if you don't, you won't. Happens all the time, but it's a bit disappointing all the same, on account of we just got done with that kinda thing with BayTurtles. If you like the Bay aesthetic, those movies are brilliant. If you've ever once in your life enjoyed a movie without something exploding, they're awful. No middle ground.
This won't likely be such an... extreme case, but it will ultimately come down to whether or not you like Rogen's sense of humor in general.
I haaaaaaate it. I absolutely abhor Rogen's entire gimmick. So yeah, this will probably be the third "major" TMNT movie in a row that I don't bother to ever see. And that's disappointing. :ohwell:
I'm sure it will totally hit the mark with people who like what he sells, though. And that's not altogether a bad thing, I guess. There's definitely a place for "juvenile" humor in this world; I mean I love Family Guy and Aqua Teen way more than most people.
I was just hoping the next TMNT project wouldn't be a "dick and fart joke" movie, but it undoubtedly will be. Not the end of the world, I guess. It just reinforces my belief that for the rest of my life, there will never, ever be a TMNT project that I truly enjoy. And that makes me sad.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
08-09-2020, 06:59 PM
To me, it sounds something like Spider-Man Homecoming.
And that sounds worrying to me
Leo656
08-09-2020, 07:14 PM
I know, right? "He's wearing the costume, but literally Every Other thing has no resemblance at all to the Spider-Man universe!" :lol: What a bad example if one wants to get someone excited for something. We just HAD a great big "In Name Only" TMNT adaptation in "Rise". Can we stick to coloring within the damn lines for once, please? Can we get back to some semblance of "TMNT As We Know Them", or is everything from now on gonna be a Brand New Take?
Unless one just means the overly-saccharine tone and "sassy teen" dialog of the "Homecoming" movie, in which case... I'm still not a fan. :lol: I personally found everything about that movie obnoxious, rather than endearing as most seem to. I still haven't seen all of it. It is so, so not my thing. When people compare other things to that, I generally know I'm not gonna have a good time.
IndigoErth
08-09-2020, 08:25 PM
I just wish the first look at the designs weren't probably many, many months away. Not fond of the intended "teen" focus angle, but hard to even guess with this thing without knowing if they're going with cartoony designs or something more realistic.
I'm hoping for Injustice 2... expecting 2012/87 crossover.
After what we've seen produced in the past several years, this is frightening. lol
AquaParade
08-09-2020, 08:30 PM
I just wish the first look at the designs weren't probably many, many months away. Not fond of the intended "teen" focus angle, but hard to even guess with this thing without knowing if they're going with cartoony designs or something more realistic.
I'm hoping for Injustice 2... expecting 2012/87 crossover.
Injustice tmnt were so dope.
TigerClaw
08-09-2020, 08:32 PM
I just wish the first look at the designs weren't probably many, many months away. Not fond of the intended "teen" focus angle, but hard to even guess with this thing without knowing if they're going with cartoony designs or something more realistic.
I'm hoping for Injustice 2... expecting 2012/87 crossover.
After what we've seen produced in the past several years, this is frightening. lol
If we get first look at the designs for Seth Rogen TMNT. It will probably be from places like Toy Fair with those leaks.
Leo656
08-09-2020, 08:41 PM
Injustice tmnt were so dope.
So, so, so, SO f*cking good.
I don't even know what I was expecting when I saw the teaser video but man... the execution was far beyond any expectations. The look! The swappable gear! The moves! It's just so... perfect.
I barely even like fighting games - although I kinda have gotten into them in recent years; I ain't good, but they're fun! :lol: But man, even if you don't like fighting games, ANY TMNT fan who hasn't played them in Injustice 2 is seriously missing out. It's not even a hard game so the "intimidation" factor should be nil.
Like, they're so awesome I legit feel a sadness for anyone who hasn't played them in that game for themselves. Yet another "gift I never knew I wanted until I got it." It's so satisfying.
...Except I wish they'd do an entire TMNT game like that and they're not ever going to. :tgrumble: They should, though!
Technogeek29
08-11-2020, 10:00 AM
If we went Fred Wolf and Nick crossover with he skin tones you get Batman vs the TMNT for appearance. with the 2k3 different skin tones.
NOTE: I'm well aware 2k3 isn't the first to do that, just the first animated version.
https://media.comicbook.com/2019/05/batman-tmnt-1170874-1280x0.jpeg
Slash-Dash
09-03-2020, 06:06 PM
hello everyone.
I am very excited about this movie. I wonder what the animation will be like. something like into the spider-verse perhaps?
also is there a release date? I'm thinking 2022.
have a great day.
S-D.
neatoman
09-03-2020, 06:37 PM
hello everyone.
I am very excited about this movie. I wonder what the animation will be like. something like into the spider-verse perhaps?
also is there a release date? I'm thinking 2022.
have a great day.
S-D.
It's a Point Grey / Paramount animation co-production. While looking at the previous movies by those studios might only give a vague idea about what it'll look like, it is probable that many of the same animators are working on it.
Here's Point Grey's one animated movie:
WVAcTZKTgmc
And Paramount Animation's latest scheduled movie with a trailer:
QbE5JpYWhGk
So my guess, probably not that ambitious but not bad either. Like still good but not trying to push the envelope.
Slash-Dash
09-03-2020, 07:21 PM
It's a Point Grey / Paramount animation co-production. While looking at the previous movies by those studios might only give a vague idea about what it'll look like, it is probable that many of the same animators are working on it.
Here's Point Grey's one animated movie:
WVAcTZKTgmc
And Paramount Animation's latest scheduled movie with a trailer:
QbE5JpYWhGk
So my guess, probably not that ambitious but not bad either. Like still good but not trying to push the envelope.
thanks. I never saw that rumble trailer before. I found it quite enjoyable.
is it safe to assume that the new tmnt movie will come out in 2022. theres no way this is a 2021 release....
IndigoErth
09-03-2020, 08:12 PM
Huh. I so wish it would lean toward a more realistic design (and highly doubting we'd get that), but Rumble looks decent. Glad to see something else to potentially give some kind of idea of what it might look like besides... bleh, Sausage Party. Thanks for sharing that. :thumbsup:
Leo656
09-03-2020, 08:17 PM
It's being put together by the guys who thought "Hey, ever notice how some food looks like sex parts?" was High Art. :roll:
Anybody with 1% enthusiasm for this thing is deluding themselves. It's gonna be unbearable.
F*ck Nickelodeon. Not a single good decision in ten goddamn years.
AquaParade
09-03-2020, 09:22 PM
It'll be good. No way it lives up to the franchise potential, but GreyPoint does some good work and they'll be forced to try harder after the PD failure.
Slash-Dash
09-04-2020, 02:33 AM
Huh. I so wish it would lean toward a more realistic design (and highly doubting we'd get that), but Rumble looks decent. Glad to see something else to potentially give some kind of idea of what it might look like besides... bleh, Sausage Party. Thanks for sharing that. :thumbsup:
agreed. after seeing the trailer I might check rumble out when it releases.
909 Turtle Fan
09-04-2020, 09:16 AM
I hope it exceeds any and all expectations. But unfortunately, I seriously effing doubt it LOL
No I think it?ll be decent to pretty good. If they?re smart it?ll have some good action and enjoyable comedy (but FFs no fart jokes)
One more thing, learn from the numbers, understand your target audience, and please don?t make it woke and no sjw stuff either.
frank_one
09-04-2020, 09:26 AM
Is the new movie confirmed to be all-cgi? No mixed live action/cgi?
Cyndaquilfan123
09-04-2020, 10:17 AM
Is the new movie confirmed to be all-cgi? No mixed live action/cgi?
Yup that was one of the first things revealed about it.
IndigoErth
09-04-2020, 10:56 AM
It's probably safe to assume it is all CGI (I guess? Doesn't really seem like a mocap kind of company), although really the first articles about it were collectively rather blurry on that detail.
AquaParade
09-04-2020, 12:16 PM
I hope it exceeds any and all expectations. But unfortunately, I seriously effing doubt it LOL
No I think it?ll be decent to pretty good. If they?re smart it?ll have some good action and enjoyable comedy (but FFs no fart jokes)
One more thing, learn from the numbers, understand your target audience, and please don?t make it woke and no sjw stuff either.
Seriously. One fart joke and I'm out. Barring very few exceptions. I'm not above laughing at a fart, but it's low hanging fruit.
Slash-Dash
09-04-2020, 06:08 PM
It's probably safe to assume it is all CGI (I guess? Doesn't really seem like a mocap kind of company), although really the first articles about it were collectively rather blurry on that detail.
yes, seems to be the case unfortunately.
TigerClaw
09-05-2020, 11:28 AM
It's probably safe to assume it is all CGI (I guess? Doesn't really seem like a mocap kind of company), although really the first articles about it were collectively rather blurry on that detail.
I could see mocap be used for all the fight scenes.
IndigoErth
09-05-2020, 12:45 PM
Yes, but what I was saying is if you look over the titles associated with that company, they don't seem to make those sort of films.
Granted, there's always a first, but personally, I'm not going to hope that this will be it or assume that Point Grey has much interest in that direction.
Most mocap I can find is Rogen providing it (and voice) for the alien in "Paul," so he has some experience with it at least as an actor, but that was also nine years ago with 2011 technology and not via Point Grey.
Though if this is a cartoon-looking all CGI film, with no realistic look, then prob not much point in the time and cost of mocap anyhow if it's just a cartoon. Plus, the virus and the reason animation is supposedly being pushed more right now anyhow...and mocap requires the traditional togetherness on a set that companies can avoid with regular animation.
Leo656
09-05-2020, 02:19 PM
I imagine it will stylistically be in a similar vein as the 2007 movie, but more cartoon-ish and stylized. It will look more "modern" due to advances in CGI technology but I doubt they're in any way going for "realism". I have a strong feeling that it will be very stylized.
Leolead
09-05-2020, 05:50 PM
I imagine it will stylistically be in a similar vein as the 2007 movie, but more cartoon-ish and stylized. It will look more "modern" due to advances in CGI technology but I doubt they're in any way going for "realism". I have a strong feeling that it will be very stylized.
Bummer. :(
TigerClaw
09-05-2020, 06:53 PM
I imagine it will stylistically be in a similar vein as the 2007 movie, but more cartoon-ish and stylized. It will look more "modern" due to advances in CGI technology but I doubt they're in any way going for "realism". I have a strong feeling that it will be very stylized.
I bet it will be a stylized version of FW. But with modern aesthetics.
frank_one
09-05-2020, 07:33 PM
I bet it will be a stylized version of FW. But with modern aesthetics.I'm afraid this is exactly what we will get.
neatoman
09-05-2020, 09:19 PM
I'm also afraid they'll try something like that.
Like, I get it, FW was the big toyseller back in the day so of course it makes sense for a producer to look in that direction. But it is also TMNT in it's most manufactured and creatively bankrupt form. Try to emulate it and you'll get a confusing mess (see Out of the Shadows and the weaker aspects of 2012).
IndigoErth
09-06-2020, 01:42 AM
*nod*
What keeps coming to mind for me is something like 2012's CGI rendering of the FW Turtles. DO NOT WANT.
While I'll always love that first show for what it is, please no. Just leave it what it is, where it is. One of the last things I want is dome durpy 3D depiction of them saturated with dumb humor. What it was back then was genuine and a product of its time. Do not try to emulate it because it is only going to seem forced and inauthentic.
Galactus
09-06-2020, 07:04 AM
I bet it will be a stylized version of FW. But with modern aesthetics.
I have a feeling you're right and given that's what the last PD movie was you can see what a dumb movie that would be.
LeotheLateBloomer
09-06-2020, 10:23 AM
I have a feeling you're right and given that's what the last PD movie was you can see what a dumb movie that would be.
Truthfully, he's saying this because it's what he wants.:lol:
IndigoErth
09-06-2020, 11:30 AM
And consider that the attempt at it with OotS was at least relatively limited on the Turtles themselves; mostly on Raph a couple times, and really it was more Looney Tunes than Turtles (also gross). A cartoon that tries to go full blown FW...? Universe have mercy on us all.
If they want to draw anything from it inspiration wise and maybe take Raph back to the witty sarcasm instead of angry Raph, and make Mikey more similarly the laid back, jokester type instead of the naive dumbass he's kind of become over the years, that's just fine (at least imo), but please, no more. Okay, film lurkers? Please.
Slash-Dash
09-11-2020, 12:45 AM
I hope this movie comes out in 2022.
Andrew NDB
09-11-2020, 01:29 AM
I hope this movie comes out in 2022.
Odds are pretty good. And the nature of making a CGI movie... no real need to hamstring anything with social distancing or anything.
Galactus
09-11-2020, 04:36 AM
I can potentially see a cgi animated movie boom in the wake of Covid-19. Could be good if like Kevin Munroe originally wanted for the Imagi movie it could show not all cgi movies have to be kiddie joints and you could do different things in the medium. Not that I think this movie will be the one trail blaze that though.
Leo656
09-11-2020, 06:07 AM
Didn't work out too well for "Beowulf". Although to be fair, that was a long time ago.
AquaParade
09-11-2020, 09:22 AM
Kevin said less than a year ago that he wouldn't mind seeing the next big feature film being animated due to the potential for them to go a little gritter in an animated setting. Possible he was dropping hints if this was already in production. Nothing to hold your breath over, but somewhat interesting.
Galactus
09-11-2020, 01:33 PM
Kevin says lots of things. He said both PD movies were "gritty like the comics" or words to that effect so I'm not holding my breath.
AquaParade
09-11-2020, 01:49 PM
Yeah, it's your prerogative how seriously you take Kevin's words.
That said, I think it's still interesting to hear his perspective and share it.
Generally, people have gone a bit overboard with the narrative that nothing Kevin says can be trusted. I understand where it comes from, because it's clear that he spoke too soon with PD and was burned (even though it does have gritty elements, and very well may have been a "gritty" movie at some point in production. It had no clear direction). He's a cheerleader for his creations and will always have a bias, but anyone with a discerning eye can still extrapolate some interesting bits of information from his interviews.
IndigoErth
09-11-2020, 02:08 PM
The guy hopes for it as much as we do, I guess, but with less control of it these days, esp any part that Nick has their hands on... good luck.
AquaParade
09-11-2020, 02:21 PM
I'll agree that Kevin saying that is probably not a hint for this movie, as I said in my original post.
But speaking of the movie, what on earth is Kevin saying here at the 19:40 mark? "I heard they are developing a --??"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gqUsN6CCdGQ
IndigoErth
09-11-2020, 03:00 PM
Gah, what a great time for the audio to break up. >.<
Given the comment from the one guy, I'm guessing it may have been that unproven rumor of a live action Netflix series (https://comicbook.com/movies/news/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-live-action-tv-series-mirage-kevin-eastman/) that was mentioned last year? Though if that is the case I'm surprised to hear it mentioned again more than a year later with still nothing else to back it up. (Unless this interview isn't new video.)
AquaParade
09-11-2020, 03:36 PM
That's what it sounds like according to the interviewer. It's definitely what a lot of us have been hoping for. Perhaps the movie is for the kids and the live action series is for older fans on a streaming service.
IndigoErth
09-11-2020, 04:00 PM
If we really did get an awesome live action on Netflix, can you imagine...? Might be a rather pricey venture, and even if something like that was actually in the works the virus would probably put off production anyhow :tsad:, but if such a thing happened -- and done well -- that would be amazing.
nylemon
09-14-2020, 09:00 PM
I really like "Batman VS TMNT". Hope there will be a similar dark style solo TMNT movie, I mean Shredder kill his own foot ninja, violent fight and all the blood, dark city and filth streets. That will be my taste. Just stop making Michelangelo that dumb, even in this show Michelangelo is stupid dumb. I like angry Rapheal so maybe make Michelangelo a bit like FW Raph, humor and wise, like the fellow said.
CGI has its limitations, even stain will look like clean, and you don't get rich colors. Animation looks good but you never get it on big screen, except for japanese movies(I am totally fine there will be no big screen movie because they always ruin it.). Hope one day Netflix will have the right to develop a series, they have decent attitude on the show, not for selling children's toys.
Slash-Dash
09-20-2020, 06:53 AM
Odds are pretty good. And the nature of making a CGI movie... no real need to hamstring anything with social distancing or anything.
great news, thank you.
IndigoErth
09-23-2020, 06:12 PM
If only we could get designs similar to the recent art by Raf Grassetti (minus the Rise parts), that would be a dream come true for an all CGI movie. :D
Most here have prob seen it by now, but for the few out there who didn't, I'm referring to this art:
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-D6SPaIXJlvc/X2qVKCeIJXI/AAAAAAABXIM/ZoMZl7wcm7wvfAwB28sznbKG8MNGdR0KwCNcBGAsYHQ/s2632/raf-grassetti-tmnt-final.jpg
Depresses me that I'm instead expecting and will probably get some version of what 2012 did with the 87 Turtles.
AquaParade
09-23-2020, 06:36 PM
I'm glad you like that but I'm not a fan. Just speaks to how varied the fan base for TMNT seems to be. There is no universal TMNT movie that would get everyone on this board on the same page, from what I can see.
Andrew NDB
09-23-2020, 08:23 PM
If only we could get designs similar to the recent art by Raf Grassetti (minus the Rise parts), that would be a dream come true for an all CGI movie. :D
Most here have prob seen it by now, but for the few out there who didn't, I'm referring to this art:
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-D6SPaIXJlvc/X2qVKCeIJXI/AAAAAAABXIM/ZoMZl7wcm7wvfAwB28sznbKG8MNGdR0KwCNcBGAsYHQ/s2632/raf-grassetti-tmnt-final.jpg
Hell no. That's just the Bay Turtles with less accessories.
IndigoErth
09-23-2020, 08:52 PM
Well you don't like most things, Andrew, so no surprise there.
But mark my words, when it comes out closer to this than that, I'm blaming you. :trazz:
https://oyster.ignimgs.com/wordpress/stg.ign.com/2016/03/tmnt-trans-dimensional-turtles-img-1-720x405.jpg
As much as I do love the '87 Turtles, too... CGI just does not suit them.
I like those Raf Grassetti designs but they're definitely HULK PD style turtles, but I'm one of the 12 people that wanted a third PD movie so I'm ok with the characters looking like that as a soft-reboot.
IndigoErth
09-23-2020, 09:40 PM
They're a bit bulky for sure, and Raph definitely takes after the PD design, at least by way of and thanks to Rise I guess (he's my least fave of this art), though really there is nothing to judge actual scale and I wish there was something to give that context.
I don't mind me some chunky Turtles so long as they are a more normal height for them, not 6'.
Leo656
09-23-2020, 10:00 PM
Eh, I could take them seriously around 6'. That's honestly not THAT tall. There's a reason it's called "average" male height.
I know I'm the opposite of most people but I kinda don't like the whole "they need to be about four feet tall" thing. Just seems silly. Whenever I see them in frame with regular characters I can no longer take them seriously. I really don't see why they can't be Average Height and still have every other thing about them remain exactly the same as it always is. I get that it's generally how things are but I don't see any reason it needs to be A Rule.
I mean, they were clearly pushing seven feet in the PD movies and that's definitely overkill, but I don't like them being short, either. Whenever I write or draw them they're around 6'. Too much shorter and I think it puts it right back into cartoon territory.
The simple fact is, absolutely nobody shorter than myself can ever be threatening or imposing no matter how much they know. That's just the way it is. :trazz: And I have double-lifts in my wrestling boots - a full inch outside and a half-inch "hidden" inside) because I KNOW how much these things matter. :tgrin:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2020, 10:41 PM
If only we could get designs similar to the recent art by Raf Grassetti (minus the Rise parts), that would be a dream come true for an all CGI movie. :D
Most here have prob seen it by now, but for the few out there who didn't, I'm referring to this art:
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-D6SPaIXJlvc/X2qVKCeIJXI/AAAAAAABXIM/ZoMZl7wcm7wvfAwB28sznbKG8MNGdR0KwCNcBGAsYHQ/s2632/raf-grassetti-tmnt-final.jpg
Depresses me that I'm instead expecting and will probably get some version of what 2012 did with the 87 Turtles.
Oh, he finally did Michelangelo! I like the art, but I wouldn't want to see it in a movie. Like Andrew said, it's Bayturtles with nose jobs and fewer accessories.
Now, if we took those designs, removed all the accessories and shorts, and threw in a human for comparison so I can see they're not 8-foot tall 'roid monsters? Then I'm onboard.
Eh, I could take them seriously around 6'. That's honestly not THAT tall. There's a reason it's called "average" male height.
I know I'm the opposite of most people but I kinda don't like the whole "they need to be about four feet tall" thing. Just seems silly. Whenever I see them in frame with regular characters I can no longer take them seriously. I really don't see why they can't be Average Height and still have every other thing about them remain exactly the same as it always is. I get that it's generally how things are but I don't see any reason it needs to be A Rule.
I don't think they need to be dwarf-height, although I'm okay with it. 5' is doable. But I'm over 6', and I'd rather see them shorter.
Plus, having the Turtles be shorter would make their skills more necessary, instead of just clobbering everybody. They have shells for armor, after all, so I feel like making them a little shorter than some humans would make for more interesting fight sequences.
IndigoErth
09-24-2020, 01:10 PM
I'm not opposed to them being around average human height, though unless someone is designing skinny, lanky Turtles (bleh, not a fan) they may still have the tissue of looking far too big in comparison. And if they are too big to fit through a manhole that's just gets kind of immersion breaking. Even when PD made it happen, you can't get past knowing manholes aren't that big.
(If the 2016 film wanted to up the humor, forget Raph surviving hitting an airplane windshield, he should have met the police and other first responders for the first time because he got stuck. Now that would have been believable. lol)
I could see around 5'6 or so being a decent adult height for them. Not huge, but not tiny either.
Though it people would actually take into consideration that they're originally Sliders, not tortoises, and stop overdoing the size and bulk of the shell, a flatter shell would be a start on not making them the size of small cars. (Plus, a flatter shell could make the whole disguised thing work, unlike PD that had to axe it.)
Leo656
09-24-2020, 01:31 PM
The shells would make it impossible for them to get through manholes already, I can't get hung up on that. :lol:
The closest guy in real life I could relate any of them to would be someone like Rob Van Dam. He's an expert martial artist with ungodly flexibility and a highly acrobatic style, who in his prime would be able to leap from the top rope into the third row of fans with a full flip somersault in between. He's older now, but in his prime he was very much how a Ninja Turtle would move and fight in real life. He's put on a few pounds in middle-age, but when he was at his peak he wasn't very big or bulky at all, and the stuff he could do was absolutely uncanny, as far as his acrobatics and whatnot.
Spoiler'ed for Big Picture.
https://w0.pngwave.com/png/370/696/rob-van-dam-royal-rumble-wwf-invasion-ecw-professional-wrestler-rob-van-dam-png-clip-art.png
6'1, 235. Very lean, not at all bulky, but MUCH bigger than you'd think he is if all you've seen is him in motion.
Speaking of, here's just a sample of just how amazing he is/was for being a "big guy" by normal standards. Some of this stuff still has to be seen to be believed. There's better highlight reels but that's the first one that came up and I think it sends the message well enough.
YMtIdSZ9Dkc
Just for fun, here's another one. It's my Birthday, and the world needs more RVD. Plus, this one has more spin kicks. His flexibility is really quite amazing for such a big guy.
kfx80mfzLik
See, this is why when people insist that the Turtles would have to be short and thin or else they couldn't do all the cool stuff they do, I say nonsense. They could very easily be around 6' and still flip around and throw high kicks just fine. Real-Life Precedent ruins the narrative that they MUST be short. :trazz:
Also, Rob Van Dam is a very nice guy. Unrelated, But Relevant. :tgrin:
IndigoErth
09-24-2020, 01:39 PM
Well, realistically, the Turtles should still have some degree of limitation, due to the whole shell fused with the spine part limiting flexibility and probably shouldn't be able to compensate quite to that degree and be that good. lol But still compensate well enough to be awesome.
Leo656
09-24-2020, 01:49 PM
To be fair, asking anyone to measure up to the standard of Rob Van Dam is a pretty impossible task. :lol: Regardless, we do see the Turtles behave very acrobatically even when it "should" be impossible for their anatomy. I feel like some stuff you just gotta let go. :trazz:
RVD would have been an awesome Ninja Turtle.
Andrew NDB
09-24-2020, 02:23 PM
The Turtles aren't 6'. Flat out. Though I'm OK with the heights in the 1990 movie.
AquaParade
09-24-2020, 04:08 PM
Make the turtles 2 ft tall. They'll be adorable. No one will care if they slaughter and kill. Would anyone complain if Baby Yoda caused someone to explode from the inside out?
IndigoErth
09-24-2020, 05:07 PM
:tlol: Awww... look at them slaughter those villains. Adorable!
Thanks, instead of Mutant Town, now I can't unthink Mutant Munchkinland. A village full of tiny murderous animal people will now fuel my nightmares.
Galactus
09-24-2020, 06:27 PM
I'm still mad they gave the part of Wolverine to that tall Australian pretty boy. MCU Logan better be stocky 5.3.
Leo656
09-24-2020, 06:47 PM
He might be, but allegedly with Xavier and Magneto at least one of them will be black and at least one of them will be gay, because that's allegedly what Disney wants to do. At least that was the rumor the last time anyone spoke of it. If all of that happens but Wolverine gets to stay short, will you be altogether Happy or Sad? :trazz:
garsh
09-24-2020, 07:20 PM
Maybe it's my imagination, but I feel like some of what I just read is losing sight of the fundamental gag.
Ninja turtles, as a concept, is silly and appealing -- because -- they're turtle ninjas. It's amusing because of course they shouldn't be able to do any of the things they do. That's the whole point, and I presume it's a large part of the reason they caught on in the first place.
Unrelated, short turtles are extremely important to me personally just because it's one of their main defining characteristics that I like about them. If that's taken away, as far as I'm concerned, they needn't be ninjas, or turtles, etc.; the whole concept unravels. That's just me.
LeotheLateBloomer
09-24-2020, 09:22 PM
Ninja turtles, as a concept, is silly and appealing -- because -- they're turtle ninjas.
So is a man dressed in a bat costume. Can we please stop using this tired excuse? No offense btw.
Andrew NDB
09-24-2020, 09:35 PM
Ninja turtles, as a concept, is silly and appealing -- because -- they're turtle ninjas.
You know what isn't silly? Crisler's Law (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s%20Law).
Leo656
09-24-2020, 09:45 PM
It is pretty uncanny how often that happens.
garsh
09-25-2020, 12:02 AM
It seems like both of you, LeotheLateBloomer and Andrew NDB, got the wrong impression about what I was trying to say.
Ninja turtles, as a concept, is silly and appealing -- because -- they're turtle ninjas.
So is a man dressed in a bat costume. Can we please stop using this tired excuse? No offense btw.
You know what isn't silly? Crisler's Law (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler%27s%20Law).
You really think that applies?. What exactly do you guys think I'm trying to "excuse" or "refute"? Specifically I was just remarking about the likes of this:
Well, realistically, the Turtles should still have some degree of limitation, due to the whole shell fused with the spine part limiting flexibility and probably shouldn't be able to compensate quite to that degree and be that good.
Though it people would actually take into consideration that they're originally Sliders, not tortoises, and stop overdoing the size and bulk of the shell...
The point is not that "the premise is silly and therefore anything goes." The point was meant to be that some of the fundamental the logical fallacies are what makes the premise interesting and drew people to it.
The original movie demonstrates what I mean. It doesn't try too hard to justify the underlying gags, but it takes itself seriously enough to be meaningful, and stands up to its own internal logic. It might be the perfect balance.
IndigoErth
09-25-2020, 10:26 AM
Have ya considered that maybe you yourself missed that some people also find it fun to throw the logic wrench in there and over overanalyze the details, and are now the one taking the conversation too seriously?
Interesting conversation, though the only thing it has proved, a usual, is that preferences vary, as well as what we're willing to let slide (or not), such as their height, which I find interesting to hear.
Really though, had the PD films took a note from 2012 in giving them flatter slider-like shells it would have helped the size issue at least a little. But they also made them bulletproof, so you'd still get your logical fallacies.
I do think the Turtles could lift a full-animation film, especially if they try to make it look like a comic book. Spidey and Lupin III have done this! Could they even try to push the envelope of demographics for CG movie design? Though I see why many would miss the live-action films of the series, but it’s understandable in the age of COVID to animate.
Galactus
09-25-2020, 03:48 PM
He might be, but allegedly with Xavier and Magneto at least one of them will be black and at least one of them will be gay, because that's allegedly what Disney wants to do. At least that was the rumor the last time anyone spoke of it. If all of that happens but Wolverine gets to stay short, will you be altogether Happy or Sad? :trazz:
My comment about Logan's height was in jest. Sure I'd like a comics accurate Wolverine and I like the idea that the turtles and Wolverine are short badasses but height isn't that important.
As for rumours that they want to turn Magneto and Professor X either black or gay I'd take that with a pinch of salt for now. It seems like a very obvious rumour deliberately designed to trigger people who complain about 'forced diversity' and whatnot.
If (and that's a big if) it happens I'd be very wary of it. Charles Xavier being black or gay I'd be okay with I suppose but Erik not being a Jewish holocaust survivor would be a serious knock to the character. I suppose he could be a gay Jewish holocaust survivor but since romance has never been a huge part of the character I don't think I see much of a point.
AquaParade
09-25-2020, 05:04 PM
I don't think those are legit rumors so much as fan speculation. Black, gay, doesn't really matter. What matters is that Eric has experienced prejudice and discrimination firsthand.
Although, yeah it'd be awful if they tried to equate modern lgbq struggles with that of Holocaust Survivors, or something, but I really don't see that happening
garsh
09-25-2020, 10:00 PM
Have ya considered that maybe you yourself missed that some people also find it fun to throw the logic wrench in there and over overanalyze the details, and are now the one taking the conversation too seriously?
No WAY! All I was trying to say is it sounded like you were wanting to sort of diminish the turtle part so that the ninja part would make more sense, when not making sense is a large part of the fun. Like I said, though, that may have just been my own mistaken take-away. By all means carry on over-analyzing, that's what it's all about!
I didn't mean to come off serious!
By the way, though, bullet-proof shells isn't so bad to me. I can accept the stretch of credulity, since turtle shells are rigid and durable armor anyway, plus the characters are biologically altered after all. And the payoff is a built-in solution for dealing with the inevitable narrative conflict of the imbalance between fantasy melee weapons versus ubiquitous modern firearms. But wasn't their skin also bulletproof? I didn't watch either of those movies, just failed to avoid clips here and there. If so, bulletproof skin is too much for me.
Andrew NDB
09-25-2020, 10:09 PM
By the way, though, bullet-proof shells isn't so bad to me.
Shells? Bullets were bouncing off their SKIN in the 2014 movie.
Leo656
09-25-2020, 11:28 PM
Yeah, that sh*t was straight trash. Four Hulks, that's all that was. Nothing to do with TMNT at all.
I honestly wouldn't mind at all if everyone on the creative end of those movies ended up never working again and had to resort to burning copies of their own stupid ideas at night to stay warm. It'd serve them right.
IndigoErth
09-26-2020, 02:42 AM
For most we don't see it even hitting them, but there is one shot of Raph taking bullets in both the thinner (and should be more vulnerable?) plastron AND his flesh I think, with, if I recall, a slow motion view of them coming back out of him. Pretty disturbing stuff right there. :teek:
edit: Here, I went looking for a gif, I'm not going to re-suffer this nightmare alone. (Okay I guess it wasn't slow motion, maybe a trailer was.)
https://64.media.tumblr.com/d66462583844ff1f90b863dd55a4e74a/tumblr_n8uoks2Hye1sysem0o4_500.gif
Also found images. Raph is... made of tire rubber?
https://images.fancaps.net/images/movies/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014_Screenshot_2057. jpg
https://images.fancaps.net/images/movies/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014_Screenshot_2058. jpg
Whose idea was that, because it's just all kinds of creepy wrongness. And looks like two or three in his arms. Pardon me while I throw up.
Leo656
09-26-2020, 03:48 AM
It's NERF. Raphael is made of NERF.
You're up very late these days, young lady. You're not running with a bad crowd, are you? :trazz: Dropping those marijuana pills down at the docks with those ne'er-do-well hoodlums who hang out down there? :lol:
IndigoErth
09-26-2020, 12:51 PM
lol Nerf. Bullets don't rip through Nerf material??
Those metal bullet "nipples" though... (More nightmare fuel.) Placement is bit high, but come on, someone did that on purpose.
Haha, no. Game night with a long distance friend. (Though was annoyed and up later than intended because their system gave me a "warning" notice for "inappropriate language" for some stupid reason -- not a clue what it thought it flagged! -- so I might have still been up causing trouble. Just not sure how.)
AquaParade
09-26-2020, 04:36 PM
They're more like cafeteria chicken nuggets in Elementary school.
Leo656
09-26-2020, 04:40 PM
My school had bangin' nuggets. Although nothing compared to the chicken patties at the high school. I used to eat three of those a day. Mmmm.
AquaParade
09-26-2020, 04:53 PM
Our high school sold "Domino's" pizza (tmnt related, I'm on topic) except it looked different than what you'd usually expect from Domino's and tasted good, not like ****.
You could see the Domino's guy drop the pizza off, so it wasn't a scam. If Domino's always tasted that good, I'd be eating it right now. Always wondered what was up with that.
Leo656
09-26-2020, 05:25 PM
It's probably a regional thing. The Domino's over here is slammin'.
But I've definitely been to ones where it tasted like cardboard with sauce on it.
IndigoErth
09-26-2020, 05:28 PM
You guys got delivery??
Only pizza schools here ever really had was the rectangular Ellio's type pizza.
And, also totally on topic, since Ellio's is a northeast brand and many might not be familiar, 2012 did a parody of it with a fictional brand named Hellio's.
Leo656
09-26-2020, 05:47 PM
Nah, when it came to pizza our school as well only got the Elio's-style. Which wasn't bad at all so long as they didn't over-cook it. Nobody wanted to be the kid to get that one blackened slice on the end of the tray, but we all had it happen at least once.
In high school they had "regular" pizza instead of the squares but I'm positive that was frozen as well. NJ school budgets aren't the greatest.
Could've been worse; at least I went to Monroe. I hear that in Newark and New Brunswick (aka "Brun'fus") kids just get a crack rock and a playing card with a frowny-face on it.
LeotheLateBloomer
09-27-2020, 04:12 PM
lol Nerf. Bullets don't rip through Nerf material??
Those metal bullet "nipples" though... (More nightmare fuel.) Placement is bit high, but come on, someone did that on purpose.
Haha, no. Game night with a long distance friend. (Though was annoyed and up later than intended because their system gave me a "warning" notice for "inappropriate language" for some stupid reason -- not a clue what it thought it flagged! -- so I might have still been up causing trouble. Just not sure how.)
Can you imagine if Marbled-Nerf guns were a thing? Nerf guns that shoot out marbles! They'd get sued.:lol:
Edit: Wasn't there an episode of FW where their shells reflected bullets? Still a stupid idea as that's a cartoon.
Voltron
10-11-2020, 02:27 AM
Nah, when it came to pizza our school as well only got the Elio's-style. Which wasn't bad at all so long as they didn't over-cook it. Nobody wanted to be the kid to get that one blackened slice on the end of the tray, but we all had it happen at least once.
In high school they had "regular" pizza instead of the squares but I'm positive that was frozen as well. NJ school budgets aren't the greatest.
Could've been worse; at least I went to Monroe. I hear that in Newark and New Brunswick (aka "Brun'fus") kids just get a crack rock and a playing card with a frowny-face on it.
School budgets in Jersey work like this:
Are you the football team? Here's a blank check.
Are you just about anything else? I think there's some change in between the cushions of the couch in the teacher's lounge.
Leo656
10-11-2020, 09:14 AM
School budgets in Jersey work like this:
Are you the football team? Here's a blank check.
Are you just about anything else? I think there's some change in between the cushions of the couch in the teacher's lounge.
:lol: Nailed it.
Although my school paid for me to spend part of one year getting bussed to a special art school a couple times a week, so that was pretty awesome. Some kind of deal for kids who were artistically talented but had no money, if you were recommended then you got to be part of this program. Only like two students from my school got to do it, I went for visual arts (drawing and painting) and this girl went for music, I think. I wish I could remember the name of the school, it was really cool, it was a big place where they did everything, from dance to drama and all that stuff. Really awesome.
I sincerely regret not doing more with my thimble full of talent given that they went out on a limb for me and enabled me to go there, and I did learn a lot. I'unno, my interests just shift a lot. Art was never gonna be my whole life, just a hobby. I'm grateful I got to go but sometimes I felt like they wasted it on me and not someone who actually would have done more with it, made it a career, I'unno.
I was raised Catholic, we're guilty as a natural state of being. :lol:
IndigoErth
10-11-2020, 11:47 AM
I dunno, acting is an art and wrestling itself usually includes some amount of a created character persona and showmanship, etc for many wrestlers, right?
Leo656
10-11-2020, 12:14 PM
Yeah, but that all came naturally and it's not what the school paid me to go and learn. And charisma can't be taught, anyhow. Nurtured, sure, but people are who they are. That's why some guys who can wrestle incredibly never go anywhere: All the physical tools, personality of a block of wood. There's seminars, but... everyone admits that there's a certain intangible quality that some human beings are just born with. Thankfully, for whatever else I'm lacking, even those who hate me will admit that I reek of charisma. That covers up whatever I don't have.
But yeah, that's all well and fine but the school paid for me to go get better at drawing and painting. And I did! But I never made that my field, nor was I ever going to. So on a tiny level I feel like I "stole" a spot from someone who maybe could have been a fashion designer or something, "if only".
That's not a very healthy way to think, though, I know that. Odds are good that like, maybe one out of ten kids who went there made their study into a career. And I held onto what I learned so it's not like it was a waste, I still apply it. Just one of those nagging little things is all. I was chosen to be part of this selective thing for people who were "really good" at art, and meanwhile I was merely average to begin with and also never really did much with it afterwards.
Then I try and remind myself that no experience is waste if you learn something. It's not like it always bothers me, I just often feel like as fortunate as I was, someone else probably deserved it more. But then, that could also apply to just about everything, so I try not to dwell on it.
These kids nowadays with their art tablets and stuff, though. Whoof. I couldn't do that. Pretty amazing what people can do nowadays.
ssjup81
10-14-2020, 09:08 AM
For most we don't see it even hitting them, but there is one shot of Raph taking bullets in both the thinner (and should be more vulnerable?) plastron AND his flesh I think, with, if I recall, a slow motion view of them coming back out of him. Pretty disturbing stuff right there. :teek:
edit: Here, I went looking for a gif, I'm not going to re-suffer this nightmare alone. (Okay I guess it wasn't slow motion, maybe a trailer was.)
https://64.media.tumblr.com/d66462583844ff1f90b863dd55a4e74a/tumblr_n8uoks2Hye1sysem0o4_500.gif
Also found images. Raph is... made of tire rubber?
https://images.fancaps.net/images/movies/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014_Screenshot_2057. jpg
https://images.fancaps.net/images/movies/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_2014_Screenshot_2058. jpg
Whose idea was that, because it's just all kinds of creepy wrongness. And looks like two or three in his arms. Pardon me while I throw up.What I find funny about this, is that they didn't know that they were bulletproof. Weren't they hovered together while their shells were being shot at? Raph stood up and faced the bullets assuming they were bulletproof. :lol: What if he would've been wrong? I think Phelous pointed that out at some point. "Oh no, shell shock!" lol
Shark_Blade
10-16-2020, 05:47 AM
I’m so confused. There’s a CGI movie coming and also a Rise of TMNT movie?
https://twitter.com/1023dve/status/1316733822952636418?s=21
newfan
10-16-2020, 06:02 AM
I’m so confused. There’s a CGI movie coming and also a Rise of TMNT movie?
https://twitter.com/1023dve/status/1316733822952636418?s=21
Yes, Rise is Netflix (there is a thread for that too but not many details), GCI movie is a separate thing planned for theatres. I guess instead of a 3rd PD movie, not officially been confirmed as that but pretty much looks that way.
I wonder how long it will be until there is news to put in this thread.
Shark_Blade
10-16-2020, 07:27 AM
Cheers! That’s cool we’re getting more movies.
AquaParade
10-16-2020, 10:59 AM
The Rise...movie seems like such a waste of resources. The show failed, relatively speaking, and there is a lot of potential for a Netflix TMNT movie that this could stifle.
Leo656
10-16-2020, 01:22 PM
I feel like more than anything, it's that they promised it so they feel like they have to deliver it.
newfan
10-16-2020, 01:26 PM
I think the announcement was a joint one, Rise and the Loud House would get a movie but then we heard nothing after that, until recent posts regarding Rise, but not a lot of info like how much progress had been made (less I got that wrong) More interested to get some idea of what they want to go for with this one.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-18-2020, 09:43 PM
I feel like more than anything, it's that they promised it so they feel like they have to deliver it.
Contractually obligated, yeah.
Leo656
10-18-2020, 09:49 PM
Partly that, partly saving face.
Contracts are traditionally printed on toilet paper, they can be broken any number of ways. But they talked a huge game about Rise and made a ton of Big Promises about it. And while Rise didn't catch on with very many people, those people had their hearts set on getting the movie that was promised, and are still counting on some level of - snerk - "story closure".
You can bet that once it's out, the book on Rise will be closed and they'll treat it like the BayTurtles movies, which are only 4 and 6 years old BUT Viacom pretends never happened at all. It'll be the same exact thing.
AquaParade
10-18-2020, 10:25 PM
Very curious to see what is next, given it will have to be more faithful if they plan on making money.
If they really are working on a live-action series, things will really get interesting.
Musashi
10-19-2020, 01:33 PM
Very curious to see what is next, given it will have to be more faithful if they plan on making money...
I really wish we could assume that's among the lessons learned, but will believe it when I see it. It's unfortunately just as likely they will double (triple? quadruple?) down on the No, it's for today's little kids even though they just shrug and walk away. Make it sillier. No, sillier than that. Sillier. Throw in some fart jokes.
Slash-Dash
10-22-2020, 08:41 AM
do we have any idea about the release date? I'm so curious to see the turtle designs...
NinjaPug
10-24-2020, 12:27 PM
do we have any idea about the release date? I'm so curious to see the turtle designs...
Depends on when they started developing it. Most animated projects typically take 4-5 years to complete a project.
Vicky82
10-24-2020, 02:15 PM
do we have any idea about the release date? I'm so curious to see the turtle designs...
Well no voice cast have been announced yet and with the Corona virus delaying movies, it probably won't be released until 2025/2026.
IndigoErth
10-24-2020, 03:12 PM
O.o Yeah, probably not nearly that long. Animation has the benefit of allowing a lot of it to be collaborated on long distance. (We can probably dub this the Covid work from home TMNT movie. lol) I assume recording the voice cast for it could probably wait for a bit if need be, and though I assume that probably still really needs a professional studio, they could easily limit the amount of people there at one time and keep it sanitized.
Population and animation... the two possible 'booms' thanks to lock downs. lol
PizzaPower1985
11-03-2020, 08:11 PM
Is there any news yet? Been gone for months... are we getting tv series ala Mirage/IDW again? or is that officially dead?
Is Rogen still producing a "teenage" TMNT film? has this prospect improved at all for adult fans or are we forever cursed to keep eating the kid's stuff?
Andrew NDB
11-03-2020, 08:21 PM
are we getting tv series ala Mirage/IDW again? or is that officially dead?
I don't think anything like that was ever alive to begin with to be made dead.
PizzaPower1985
11-03-2020, 08:25 PM
I don't think anything like that was ever alive to begin with to be made dead.
okay then. the Eastman interview where he teased the Netflix series was never confirmed? my bad then. I thought it had life at one point. Bummer! Thanks, Andrew.
Slash-Dash
11-06-2020, 11:20 AM
what kind of animation do you think they will go with here?
TigerClaw
11-06-2020, 05:20 PM
what kind of animation do you think they will go with here?
That's a good question. They could either go with a more cartoony art style or go with a more highly detailed style like the stuff you see from Disney or Dreamworks.
Or they could go with the style that is similar to the 2007 CGI movie.
retr0pia75
11-14-2020, 01:04 PM
with how it seems to be catching on i wouldn't be surprised if they go for a "stylized/low framerate" approach like in spider-verse, the new spongebob movie or connected
considering that jeff rowe is involved with connected maybe that could be what they're planning
TigerClaw
11-14-2020, 01:07 PM
with how it seems to be catching on i wouldn't be surprised if they go for a "stylized/low framerate" approach like in spider-verse, the new spongebob movie or connected
considering that jeff rowe is involved with connected maybe that could be what they're planning
Maybe. or they go the motion capture route so that they can be able to do some really cool martial arts with the CGI animation.
retr0pia75
11-14-2020, 01:19 PM
Maybe. or they go the motion capture route so that they can be able to do some really cool martial arts with the CGI animation.
i don't know about that, i'm fine with motion capture when it's applied to explicitly non-human characters or animated films with a cast of non-human characters but it just doesn't look good when it's applied to humans
i remember loving the polar express when i was a kid and while i still have a soft spot for it the designs of the characters aren't something i'd say holds up about it. the tintin movie was the best it was ever utilized but i still don't think it was the right approach. and the less said about mars needs moms the better
you can still convey good martial arts in animation as long as you simply do the necessary research and have a spot-on understanding of it, the kung fu panda movies were a testament to this
IndigoErth
11-14-2020, 01:38 PM
With this virus very possibly being one of the factors in movie attention turning to a new CGI instead of live action, since a lot of it can be done by people in separate locations, I won't hold my breath on there being any mocap. Esp if it's not realistic looking CGI, it would just be a waste anyhow imo if this is likely more cartoon looking.
Powder
11-14-2020, 04:28 PM
with how it seems to be catching on i wouldn't be surprised if they go for a "stylized/low framerate" approach like in spider-verse, the new spongebob movie or connected
considering that jeff rowe is involved with connected maybe that could be what they're planning
I really hope not. Spiderverse was a super dope movie but that animation style was so jarring, it really put me off.
Slash-Dash
12-01-2020, 06:40 AM
when do you guys think we will get an update on this movie?
Musashi
12-01-2020, 02:06 PM
I think dialogue recording is usually done very early into production, so maybe we'll get the voice cast announced reasonably soon.
Or... that might all happen in secret under non-disclosure agreements, with an announcement delayed till much nearer release.
IndigoErth
12-01-2020, 05:02 PM
After all the silence, is it still a thing? I hope we can at least see designs in the near future, that would be reasonable.
Cyndaquilfan123
12-02-2020, 01:27 PM
After all the silence, is it still a thing? I hope we can at least see designs in the near future, that would be reasonable.
I think it'll be awhile... I don't see this thing coming out until 2023/24. I'd be happy to be wrong though.
TigerClaw
12-02-2020, 03:32 PM
I think it'll be awhile... I don't see this thing coming out until 2023/24. I'd be happy to be wrong though.
Maybe we'll get some voice casting news next year. Who knows. Were all curious who will voice the Turtles. My money's on some big names doing some of the voices. Because you know they love casting some big stars which gives the movie a lot more attention.
With Seth Rogen producing. Don't be surprise if he voices a character in the movie. In fact he could voice one of the Turtles. But who?
Slash-Dash
12-10-2020, 08:05 AM
could this movie go straight to streaming like all of WB's movies for 2021?
I wouldn't put it past me...
NinjaPug
12-10-2020, 09:42 AM
could this movie go straight to streaming like all of WB's movies for 2021?
I wouldn't put it past me...
They just announced this movie a few months ago. It's not even close to being ready for movie theaters. The pandemic will be done by the time this is ready to be released.
Slash-Dash
01-07-2021, 12:38 PM
I think it'll be awhile... I don't see this thing coming out until 2023/24. I'd be happy to be wrong though.
late 2022 is my bet.
Cyndaquilfan123
03-19-2021, 10:36 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXU89lZVn4k
So, It seems I was right about this coming around 2023.
To me a movie does not exist until we see evidence that the movie is far along, announcements of a movie being made, actors getting roles and even teaser posters are meaningless if it's in development hell. So up until the first trailer almost.
IndigoErth
03-19-2021, 11:22 AM
Well it's not much, but after roughly a year of no info at all, glad to at least hear some confirmation as to whether or not it's even still on the table. Was starting to have my doubts.
Wish we'd hear something more. If it's still slated to happen, surely after a year there is a little progress on this? So much of a 3D animated film, esp the initial parts of it, doesn't even need to be done colletively in the same office/studio these day.
2023 feels sooo far away, esp right now. lol But on the bright side, my nephew will be 6 or 7 and possibly old enough not to ruin my own viewing experience so maybe we can actually see it together. edit: Unless it's not for the kiddies... haha wait, of course it is.
newfan
03-19-2021, 11:32 AM
I'm just thinking about when we heard they were going to start shooting the announced PD movie 'later in the year' which was... 2019? and then we heard nothing again. Not saying the same will happen here, just I'll wait until we see something more.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.